Highly specific enrichment of phosphopeptides by zirconium dioxide nanoparticles for phosphoproteome analysis

Large-scale characterization of phosphoproteins requires highly specific methods for the purification of phosphopeptides because of the low abundance of phosphoproteins and substoichiometry of phosphorylation. A phosphopeptide enrichment method using ZrO2 nanoparticles is presented. The high specificity of this approach was demonstrated by the isolation of phosphopeptides from the digests of model phosphoproteins. The strong affinity of ZrO2 nanoparticles to phosphopeptides enables the specific enrichment of phosphopeptides from a complex peptide mixture in which the abundance of phosphopeptides is two orders of magnitude lower than that of nonphosphopeptides. Superior selectivity of ZrO2 nanoparticles for the enrichment of phosphorylated peptides than that of conventional immobilized metal affinity chromatography was observed. Femtomole phosphopeptides from digestion products could be enriched by ZrO2 nanoparticles and can be well detected by MALDI mass spectrometric analysis. ZrO2 nanoparticles were further applied to selectively isolate phosphopeptides from the tryptic digestion of mouse liver lysate for phosphoproteome analysis by nanoliter LC MS/MS (nano-LC-MS/MS) and MS/MS/MS. A total of 248 defining phosphorylation sites and 140 phosphorylated peptides were identified by manual validation using a series of rigid criteria.     

Nanoparticle-modified monolithic pipette tips for phosphopeptide enrichment

We have developed nanoparticle-modified monoliths in pipette tips for selective and efficient enrichment of phosphopeptides. The 5 μL monolithic beds were prepared by UV-initiated polymerization in 200 μL polypropylene pipette tips and either iron oxide or hydroxyapatite nanoparticles were used for monolith modification. Iron oxide nanoparticles were prepared by a co-precipitation method and stabilized by citrate ions. A stable coating of iron oxide nanoparticles on the pore surface of the monolith was obtained via multivalent electrostatic interactions of citrate ions on the surface of nanoparticles with a quaternary amine functionalized poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate-co-ethylene dimethacrylate) monolith. Hydroxyapatite nanoparticles were incorporated into the poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate-co-ethylene dimethacrylate) monolith by simply admixing them in the polymerization mixture followed by in situ polymerization. The nanoparticle-modified monoliths were compared with commercially available titanium dioxide pipette tips. Performance of the developed and commercially available sorbents was demonstrated with the efficient and selective enrichment of phosphopeptides from peptide mixtures of α-casein and β-casein digests followed by off-line MALDI/MS analysis.     

Evaluation of the impact of some experimental procedures on different phosphopeptide enrichment techniques

The complete characterization of phosphorylated proteins requires an efficient procedure for the enrichment of phosphopeptides from amongst a complicated peptide mixture. The sensitivity of the traditional immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) approach is severely affected by various buffers, detergents and other reagents normally utilized in biochemical and cell biological procedures, and thus pre-purification steps such as reversed-phase chromatography is required prior to phosphopeptide enrichment. Here we evaluate the use of different 'non-phosphopeptide-excluding compounds' in the loading buffer for titanium dioxide (TiO(2)) chromatography and show that TiO(2) is more robust and tolerant towards many reagents, including salts, detergents and other low molecular mass molecules, than conventional IMAC. In addition, we show that the inclusion of various detergents can enhance the efficiency of this enrichment method, as phosphopeptides that otherwise adhere to plastic surfaces can be efficiently solubilized and subsequently purified. The TiO(2) chromatography technique is also compared to zirconium dioxide chromatography for phosphopeptide enrichment.     

A novel titanium dioxide-polydimethylsiloxane plate for phosphopeptide enrichment and mass spectrometry analysis

The phosphorylation of proteins is a major post-translational modification that is required for the regulation of many cellular processes and activities. Mass spectrometry signals of low-abundance phosphorylated peptides are commonly suppressed by the presence of abundant non-phosphorylated peptides. Therefore, one of the major challenges in the detection of low-abundance phosphopeptides is their enrichment from complex peptide mixtures. Titanium dioxide (TiO₂) has been proven to be a highly efficient approach for phosphopeptide enrichment and is widely applied. In this study, a novel TiO₂ plate was developed by coating TiO₂ particles onto polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS)-coated MALDI plates, glass, or plastic substrates. The TiO₂-PDMS plate (TP plate) could be used for on-target MALDI-TOF analysis, or as a purification plate on which phosphopeptides were eluted out and subjected to MALDI-TOF or nanoLC-MS/MS analysis. The detection limit of the TP plate was ∼10-folds lower than that of a TiO₂-packed tip approach. The capacity of the ∼2.5 mm diameter TiO₂ spots was estimated to be ∼10 μg of β-casein. Following TiO₂ plate enrichment of SCC4 cell lysate digests and nanoLC-MS/MS analysis, ∼82% of the detected proteins were phosphorylated, illustrating the sensitivity and effectiveness of the TP plate for phosphoproteomic study.     

pI-based phosphopeptide enrichment combined with nanoESI-MS

IEF is introduced as a new principle for enrichment and separation of phosphopeptides as obtained after digestion of phosphoproteins by trypsin. Tryptic peptides and phosphopeptides exhibit pI values, which overlap in the range of about 4-6. However, after methyl esterification of all carboxyl functions, the pI values of tryptic peptides and phosphopeptides regroup in discrete clusters. In addition, mono- and diphosphorylated peptides show different but very homogeneous pI values, with variations when internal Arg, Lys, or His residues are present. Experimentally, this new concept was applied for separation of model peptides on IPG strips pH 3-10 as used in the first dimension of 2-DE. After IEF of methyl-esterified peptides, the IPG strip was cut into pieces followed by peptide extraction, desalting and MS analysis by nanoESI-MS. Phosphopeptides were found to focus in good agreement with their calculated pI values. This analytical strategy showed a resolution of about 0.2 pI units, and thus turned out to be capable of detecting minor differences in pI values, such as those occurring between pSer, pThr and pTyr residues. Using IPG strips with a pI range of 3-10, methyl esterified nonphosphorylated tryptic peptides are concentrated in the basic part of the IPG strip or even leave the strip. Thus, efficient enrichment of phosphopeptides and their subfractionation according to pI is obtained in one step. Minor hydrolytic side reactions including deamidation of Asn and partial hydrolysis of methyl esters are observed. The results show that IEF opens attractive avenues for the further advancement of analytical phosphoproteomics.     

Optimizing the performance of tin dioxide microspheres for phosphopeptide enrichment

Phosphopeptide enrichment based on metal oxide affinity chromatography is one of the most powerful tools for studying protein phosphorylation on a large scale. To complement existing metal oxide sorbents, we have recently introduced tin dioxide as a promising alternative. The preparation of SnO₂ microspheres by the nanocasting technique, using silica of different morphology as a template, offers a strategy to prepare materials that vary in their particle size and their porosity. Here, we demonstrate how such stannia materials can be successfully generated and their properties fine-tuned in order to obtain an optimized phosphopeptide enrichment material. We combined data from liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry experiments and physicochemical characterization, including nitrogen physisorption and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX), to explain the influence of the various experimental parameters.     

A novel strategy for phosphopeptide enrichment using lanthanide phosphate co-precipitation

Reversible phosphorylation of proteins is a common theme in the regulation of important cellular functions such as growth, metabolism, and differentiation. The comprehensive understanding of biological processes requires the characterization of protein phosphorylation at the molecular level. Although, the number of cellular phosphoproteins is relatively high, the phosphorylated residues themselves are generally of low abundance due to the sub-stoichiometric nature. However, low abundance of phosphopeptides and low degree of phosphorylation typically necessitates isolation and concentration of phosphopeptides prior to mass spectrometric analysis. In this study, we used trivalent lanthanide ions (LaCl(3), CeCl(3), EuCl(3), TbCl(3), HoCl(3), ErCl(3), and TmCl(3)) for phosphopeptide enrichment and cleaning-up. Due to their low solubility product, lanthanide ions form stable complexes with the phosphate groups of phosphopeptides and precipitate out of solution. In a further step, non-phosphorylated compounds can easily be removed by simple centrifugation and washing before mass spectrometric analysis using Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation-time of flight. The precipitation method was applied for the isolation of phosphopeptides from standard proteins such as ovalbumin, α-casein, and β-casein. High enrichment of phosphopeptides could also be achieved for real samples such as fresh milk and egg white. The technology presented here represents an excellent and highly selective tool for phosphopeptide recovery; it is easily applicable and shows several advantages as compared with standard approaches such as TiO(2) or IMAC.     

Highly efficient enrichment of phosphopeptides by magnetic nanoparticles coated with zirconium phosphonate for phosphoproteome analysis

The location of phosphorylation plays a vital role for the elucidation of biological processes. The challenge of low stoichiometry of phosphoproteins and signal suppression of phosphopeptides by nonphosphopeptides in mass spectrometry (MS) analysis makes the selective enrichment of phosphopeptides prior to MS analysis necessary. Besides the immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) method, some affinity methods based on nanoparticles displayed a higher enrichment efficiency for phosphopeptides such as Fe(3)O(4)/TiO2 and Fe(3)O(4)/ZrO(2) nanoparticles. To further improve the selectivity and compatibility of the affinity methods, a novel strategy based on magnetic nanoparticles coated with zirconium phosphonate for the enrichment of phosphopeptides has been developed in this study. Under optimized experimental conditions, 1 x 10(-9) M phosphopeptides in 50 microL tryptic digest of beta-casein could be enriched and identified successfully. Reliable results were also obtained for 1 x 10(-8) M phosphopeptides in 50 microL tryptic digest of beta-casein in the presence of nonphosphopeptides from a tryptic digest of bovine serum albumin (BSA) over 20 times in concentration. The performance of nanoparticles for use in a real sample was further demonstrated by employing the strong cation-exchange chromatography (SCX) fraction of a tryptic digest of a protein extract from Chang liver cells as a model sample. Experimental results show that the nanoparticles can be easily and effectively used for enrichment of phosphopeptides in low concentration. Most importantly, our approach is more compatible with commonly used SCX strategies than Fe(3+)-IMAC. The proposed method thus has great potential for future studies of large-scale phosphoproteomes.     

功能化磁性纳米材料在磷酸化肽富集中的应用

蛋白质磷酸化是最重要和最普遍的翻译后修饰之一。基于质谱的技术已成为分析蛋白质磷酸化的重要手段。然而,磷酸化肽固有的低丰度和电离效率以及由非磷酸化肽共存引起的严重抑制使得直接质谱分析仍然是一个挑战。为解决此问题,需在质谱分析前对磷酸化蛋白质进行选择性富集。磁性纳米材料具有良好的磁响应性,可以在外界磁铁的帮助下实现与溶液的迅速分离。功能化磁性纳米材料作为一种新型的分析技术已在蛋白质组学研究中得到广泛的应用。该文就近年来对磁性纳米粒子进行各种功能化修饰以提高其特异性吸附能力的吸附材料在磷酸化肽的富集方面的应用予以综述,并展望了功能化磁性纳米材料在磷酸化肽富集领域的应用前景。     

二氧化钛富集磷酸肽方法优化及在腾冲嗜热厌氧菌磷酸化蛋白质组分析中的应用

为了提高二氧化钛富集磷酸肽法对磷酸肽的富集效率,以6种标准蛋白酶切肽段混合物为研究对象,对二氧化钛富集磷酸肽过程中的乙腈比例、三氟乙酸比例、二氧化钛用量等条件分别进行了优化。结果表明在乙腈含量为80%(v/v),三氟乙酸含量为1%(v/v),二氧化钛用量与需要富集肽段的质量比为40:1的条件下,可以取得较好的富集效果。将优化后的富集方法应用于腾冲嗜热厌氧菌磷酸化蛋白质的分析,初步鉴定到25个磷酸化蛋白质,为进一步研究这种极端环境下生存的低等生物的生命活动提供了参考信息。     

智能响应材料在磷酸化肽和糖肽富集中的应用

蛋白质的磷酸化和糖基化作为研究最广泛的两种翻译后修饰(PTMs),在疾病的早期无创诊断、预后和治疗评估中表现出越来越大的潜力。蛋白质的异常磷酸化和糖基化经常被用于临床蛋白质组学研究和疾病相关生物标志物的发现。目前已有多种材料被开发用于磷酸化肽和糖肽的富集研究,其中,智能响应材料由于具有独特的响应特性,已被陆续报道用于磷酸化肽和糖肽的富集。智能响应材料可对外界刺激做出响应,发生结构和性质上的变化,将光、电、热、机械等信号转化为生物化学信号。响应分子是决定智能响应材料响应特性的先决条件,它们在不同刺激条件下(如温度、pH、光、机械应力、电磁场等)的可逆异构化将导致材料的宏观物理和化学性质的动态变化。与传统材料相比,智能响应材料可以可逆地“打开”和“关闭”,具有更好的可调控性。由于引起智能材料响应的刺激信号对其性能具有重要的影响,综述根据施加的刺激种类对智能响应材料进行分类,具体分为外源性响应材料和内源性响应材料,且分别总结了外源性响应材料、内源性响应材料以及内外源共同响应材料在磷酸化肽和糖肽富集方面的工作。此外,综述对智能响应材料在磷酸化肽和糖肽富集方面的发展前景进行了展望,并且提出了智能响应材料在其他蛋白质翻译后修饰方面的应用中存在的挑战。     

Zirconia layer coated mesoporous silica microspheres used for highly specific phosphopeptide enrichment

Zirconia layer coated mesoporous silica microspheres with mesostructured cellular foams (MCFs) were prepared by NH₃/water vapor-induced internal hydrolysis method. Zirconia layer coated MCF microspheres were characterized by SEM, XRD, N₂ sorption, UV, and chromatographic analysis, and explored for enrichment of phosphopeptides. ZrO₂/MCF microspheres in solid-phase extraction (SPE) mode demonstrated much higher selectivity and higher efficiency towards phosphopeptide enrichment than bulk ZrO₂ particles. In particular, the selectivities of ZrO₂/MCF microspheres towards multi-phosphopeptides are even higher than that of the widely used commercial TiO₂ microparticles. The ZrO₂/MCF microspheres were also applied to enrich endogenous phosphopeptides from human serum, and twelve endogenous phosphorylated peptides could be specifically enriched.     

Protein digestion and phosphopeptide enrichment on a glass microchip

This work describes an integrated glass microdevice for proteomics, which directly couples proteolysis with affinity selection. Initial results with standard phosphopeptide fragments from β-casein in peptide mixtures showed selective capture of the phosphorylated fragments using immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) beads packed into a microchannel. Complete selectivity was seen with angiotensin, with capture of only the phosphorylated form. On-chip proteolysis, using immobilized trypsin beads packed into a separate channel, was directly coupled to the phosphopeptide capture and the integrated devices evaluated using β-casein. Captured and eluted fragments were analyzed using both capillary electrophoresis (CE) and capillary liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (cLC/MS). The results show selective capture of only phosphopeptide fragments, but incomplete digestion of the protein was apparent from multiple peaks in the CE separations. The MS analysis indicated a capture bias on the IMAC column for the tetraphosphorylated peptide fragment over the monophosphorylated fragment. Application to digestion and capture of a serum fraction showed capture of material; however, non-specific binding was evident. Additional work will be required to fully optimize this system, but this work represents a novel sample preparation method, incorporating protein digestion on-line with affinity capture for proteomic applications.     

Membrane-based techniques for sample enrichment

Sample preparation techniques based on non-porous membrane extraction generally offer a high degree of selectivity and enrichment power, together with convenient possibilities for direct and automated connections to chromatographic and other analytical instruments. In this review principles and applications for techniques as supported liquid membrane extraction, microporous membrane liquid-liquid extraction, polymeric membrane extraction and membrane extraction with a sorbent interface are described and compared.     

Recent advances in enrichment techniques for trace analysis in capillary electrophoresis

CE is gaining great popularity as a well‐established separation technique for many fields such as pharmaceutical research, clinical application, environmental monitoring, and food analysis, owing to its high resolving power, rapidity, and small amount of samples and reagents required. However, the sensitivity in CE analysis is still considered as being inferior to that in HPLC analysis. Diverse enrichment methods and techniques have been increasingly developed for overcoming this issue. In this review, we summarize the recent advances in enrichment techniques containing off‐line preconcentration (sample preparation) and on‐line concentration (sample stacking) to enhancing sensitivity in CE for trace analysis over the last 5 years. Some relatively new cleanup and preconcentration methods involving the use of dispersive liquid–liquid microextraction, supercritical fluid extraction, matrix solid‐phase dispersion, etc., and the continued use and improvement of conventional SPE, have been comprehensively reviewed and proved effective preconcentration alternatives for liquid, semisolid, and solid samples. As for CE on‐line stacking, we give an overview of field amplication, sweeping, pH regulation, and transient isotachophoresis, and the coupling of multiple modes. Moreover, some limitations and comparisons related to such methods/techniques are also discussed. Finally, the combined use of various enrichment techniques and some significant attempts are proposed to further promote analytical merits in CE.     

TiO2-ZrO2 affinity chromatography polymeric microchip for phosphopeptide enrichment and separation

We fabricated a TiO(2)-ZrO(2) affinity chromatography micro-column on 2 mm PMMA plates, and demonstrated the enrichment and separation of (a) a standard mono- and tetra-phosphopeptide, and (b) phosphopeptides contained in a tryptic digest of β-Casein. The chromatography column consisted of 32 parallel microchannels with common input and output ports and was fabricated by lithography directly on the polymeric substrate followed by plasma etching (i.e. standard MEMS processing) and sealed with lamination. The liquid deposited TiO(2)-ZrO(2) stationary phase was characterized by X-ray diffraction and was found to be mostly TiO(2) and ZrO(2) in crystalline phases. Off-chip UV detection and MALDI MS identification of the separated effluents were used. The chip had a capacity of >1.4 μg (0.7 nmol) of a prototype mono-phosphopeptide and a recovery of 94 ± 3%, and can be used with small samples (less than 0.1 μL depending on the syringe pump used). The chip design allows an expansion of its capacity by means of increasing the number of parallel microchannels at a constant sample volume. Our approach provided an alternative to off-line extraction tips (with typical capacities of 1-2 μg and sample volumes of 1-10 μL), and to on-chip efforts based on packed bed and frit formats.     

Sequential Fe3O4/TiO2 enrichment for phosphopeptide analysis by liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry

Protein phosphorylation regulates a wide range of cellular functions and is associated with signaling pathways in cells. Various strategies for enrichment of phosphoproteins or phosphopeptides have been developed. Here, we developed a novel sequential phosphopeptide enrichment method, using magnetic iron oxide (Fe₃O₄) and titanium dioxide (TiO₂) particles, to detect mono‐ and multi‐phosphorylated peptides. In the first step, phosphopeptides were captured on Fe₃O₄ particles. In a subsequent step, any residual phosphopeptides were captured on TiO₂ particles. The particles were eluted and rinsed to yield phosphopeptide‐enriched fractions that were combined and analyzed using liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS). The validity of this sequential Fe₃O₄/TiO₂ enrichment strategy was demonstrated by the successful enrichment of bovine α‐casein phosphopeptides. We then applied the sequential Fe₃O₄/TiO₂ enrichment method to the analysis of phosphopeptides in L6 muscle cell lysates and successfully identified mono‐ and multi‐phosphorylated peptides. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Iminodiacetic acid-modified magnetic poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate)-based microspheres for phosphopeptide enrichment

Magnetic non-porous hydrophilic poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate-co-glycidyl methacrylate) microspheres prepared by the dispersion polymerization and modified with iminodiacetic acid (IDA) were employed for the IMAC separation of phosphopeptides. Fe³⁺ and Ga³⁺ ions immobilized on IDA-modified magnetic microspheres were used for the enrichment of phosphopeptides from the proteolytic digests of two model proteins differing in their physico-chemical properties and phosphate group content: porcine pepsin A and bovine α-casein. The optimum conditions for phosphopeptide adsorption and desorption in both cases were investigated and compared. The phosphopeptides separated from the proteolytic digests were analyzed by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry. The ability of the prepared Fe³⁺- and Ga³⁺-IDA-modified magnetic microspheres to capture phosphopeptides from complex mixtures was shown on an example of bovine milk proteolytic digest.     

Comparison of metal and metal oxide media for phosphopeptide enrichment prior to mass spectrometric analyses

Several affinity resins consisting of ionic metals or metal oxides were investigated for their phosphopeptide enrichment capabilities with subsequent mass spectrometric analyses. Commercially-available enrichment metal oxide affinity chromatography (MOAC) resins using manufacturer’s and/or published protocols were compared and evaluated for the most efficient and selective method that could be implemented as a standard enrichment procedure. From these comparative analyses, using a tryptic digest of casein proteins, it was determined that in our hands, two of the resins out-performed the others based on a variety of criteria, including the number of phosphorylation sites identified during MS analyses, the lower numbers of nonspecifically bound peptides observed, and the limits of detection. Applicability of these enrichment resins to a complex biological mixture was investigated. For this work, a mixture of avian histones was digested, subjected to titanium dioxide phosphopeptide enrichment, and analyzed by mass spectrometry. Eight phosphorylated tryptic peptides were observed following enrichment and subsequent LC/MS/MS analyses. Of note, seven of the eight phosphopeptides were not observed without titanium dioxide enrichment. From these analyses, four sites of phosphorylation were unequivocally determined, two of which have not been reported previously. Four additional phosphopeptides were observed; however, the site of phosphorylation could not be distinguished but was localized to one of two possible amino acids. These methods should aid in the investigation of proteins post-translationally modified with phosphate, especially those present at low concentrations as was demonstrated by successful enrichment at the femtomole level.     

Lanthanum silicate coated magnetic microspheres as a promising affinity material for phosphopeptide enrichment and identification

Novel Fe(3)O(4)@La(x)Si(y)O(5) affinity microspheres consisting of a superparamagnetic Fe(3)O(4) core and an amorphous lanthanum silicate shell have been synthesized. The core-shell-structured Fe(3)O(4)@La(x)Si(y)O(5) microspheres, with a mean size of ca. 480 nm, had rough lanthanum silicate surfaces and displayed relatively strong magnetism (47.2 emu g(-1)). This novel affinity material can be used for selective capture, rapid magnetic separation, and part dephosphorylation (which plays an important role in identifying phosphopeptides in MS) of the phosphopeptides in a peptide mixture. Its ability to selectively trap and magnetically isolate as well as label the phosphopeptides was evaluated using a standard phosphorylated protein (β-casein) and a real sample (human serum). Phosphopeptides and their corresponding label ions were detected for concentrations of β-casein as low as 1 × 10(-9) M and in mixtures of β-casein and BSA with molar ratios as low as 1:50. In addition, this affinity material, with its labeling properties, is superior to commercial TiO(2) beads in terms of interference from non-phosphopeptide molecules. These results reveal that the lanthanum silicate coated magnetic microspheres represent a promising affinity material for the rapid purification and recognition of phosphopeptides.