A theoretical approach to substituent effects. Structural consequences of electrostatic and orbital interactions in model mono- and disubstituted methanes

Ab initio molecular orbital theory is used to examine the effect of substituents on bond lengths in mono- and disubstituted methanes. The relative importance of electrostatic and orbital interaction terms are assessed. The results suggest that for substituents (X) which show powerful σ effects and weak π interactions (e.g., F), the changes in bond length are due primarily to the electrostatic component except in some disubstituted methanes in which case the change in the hyperconjugative ability of the C—X bond is also important. On the other hand, substituents X which show weak σ effects but powerful π interactions (e.g., NH₂) affect bond lengths primarily through hyperconjugative interaction of a filled or vacant π-type orbital on X with the adjacent bonds.     

Experimental and theoretical study of substituent effects of iodonitrobenzenes

The electronic structures and substituent effects of o-, m-, and p-iodonitrobenzene have been studied by ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS). The observed bands were interpreted on the basis of empirical arguments and theoretical calculations. The analysis of electronic effects of the donor/acceptor substituent groups is essential for the reliable assignment of the observed photoelectron spectra. The investigation of pi- and n-orbital ionization potentials enabled us to describe the correlation between substituent effects and the relative reactivities of the iodonitrobenzenes. It was found that the energy order of the pi(2) and n(II) parallel orbitals is reversed as a result of the combined influence of the electron-withdrawing nitro group and the electron-donating iodine atom. Distinct changes of the pi and n bands occur in o-iodonitrobenzene. This characteristic depends on the conjugation between the pi orbitals of the benzene ring and the nitro group and the interaction of in-plane lone pairs of iodine and one of the oxygen atoms of the nitro group in the adjacent position. This might contribute to the high reactivity of o-iodonitrobenzene in a number of reactions.     

A theoretical study of substituent effects on the structure of isolated and condensed three-membered rings. A comparison between radicals and parent hydrocarbons

Substituent effects on the structure of radicals and parent hydrocarbons formed by isolated or condensed three-membered rings have been investigated by Hartree-Fock, post-Hartree-Fock and density functional methods. The trends of structural parameters computed for the hydrocarbon systems are in agreement with available experimental data. Substituent effects can be rationalized in terms of interactions between localized orbitals obtained by natural bond analysis. The effects are even larger in free radicals and can be analyzed using the same model. Received: 13 March 1998 / Accepted: 13 July 1998 / Published online: 9 October 1998     

A theoretical study of substituent effects on allylic ion and ion pair SN2 reactions

An ab initio study of ionic and ion pair displacement reactions involving allylic systems has been carried out at the RHF/6-31+G* level. The geometries and natural charges show the absence of conjugative stabilization in the ionic transition states, thus differing from traditional explanations. The high reactivity of allyl halides is explained by electrostatic polarization of the double bond. Substituent effects were also studied; in general, electron-withdrawing groups lower the barriers of the ionic S(N)2 reactions but increase the barriers of the ion pair reactions. The allylic reactions are compared with related benzylic systems. Hammett correlations give rho of opposite sign for the ionic and ion pair displacement reactions, in agreement with some experimental results.     

Ab initio and density functional study of substituent effects in halogenated cations of alkenes

A theoretical study of the halogenated cations of mono-, di-, tri- and tetramethyl-substituted ethylenes, C₃H₆X⁺, C₄H₈X⁺, C₅H₁₀X⁺ and C₆H₁₂X⁺, X=F, Cl, Br, have been studied at the ab initio MP2 and density functional B3LYP levels of theory implementing 6-311++G(d,p) basis set. The potential energy surfaces of all molecules under investigation have been scanned and the ¹³C and ¹H NMR chemical shifts for all the bridged halonium ions studied have been calculated using the GIAO method at the B3LYP level. The calculated halogen binding energies in the halonium ions have been correlated with the experimental rates of chlorination and bromination of the corresponding alkenes. The computed hydride affinities and the NICS values for the bridged cations show that the bromo cations are more stable than the analogous chloro and fluoro cations.     

A substituent effects study reveals the kinetic pathway for an interfacial reaction

This paper describes the use of a substituent effects study to understand the mechanistic basis for an interfacial Diels-Alder reaction that does not proceed with standard second-order kinetics. Cyclopentadiene (Cp) undergoes a Diels-Alder reaction with a chemisorbed mercaptobenzoquinone to yield an immobilized Diels-Alder adduct. The pseudo-first-order rate constants are not linearly related to the concentration of diene, but they reach a limiting value with increasing concentrations of diene. The results of a substituent effects study support a mechanism wherein the electrochemical oxidation of hydroquinone produces two states of quinone. The first form, Q*, either reacts with Cp or isomerizes to Q, a form that is significantly less reactive with the diene. The interfacial reaction reaches a maximum rate when the concentration of diene is sufficiently high so that Q* undergoes complete Diels-Alder reaction and does not isomerize to Q. This work provides an example of the use of physical organic chemistry to understand an interfacial reaction.     

A theoretical investigation on the cycloaddition reaction between azocarbenium ions and nitriles

The 1,3‐dipolar cycloaddition reactions of the cationic 1,3‐dipolarophiles of azocarbenium ion 1 with HCN in the gas phase were examined using the density functional theory, QCISD method (Quadratic configuration interaction using single and double substitutions) and CCSD(T) (Coupled cluster calculations with single and double excitations and a perturbative estimate of triple contributions calculations) calculations. The theoretical results revealed that the reaction takes place via an initial formation of a 1:1 complex of the two reactants, mainly driven by charge interaction, followed by an asynchronous concerted cyclization forming the 3H‐[1,2,4]‐triazolium ion 3, which undergo [1,2]‐H shift to provide the 1H‐[1,2,4]‐triazolium ion 4. The effect of the solvent has been modeled by using the isodensity‐surface polarizable continuum (IPCM) model and the calculation showed that the reaction in CH₂Cl₂ solution proceeds in a similar manner as in gas phase with only a slight derivation of activation barrier. The substituent effects have also been investigated. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2008     

A theoretical analysis of the reaction between propargyl and molecular oxygen

The temperature- and pressure-dependent kinetics of the reaction between propargyl and molecular oxygen have been studied with a combination of electronic structure theory, transition state theory, and the time-dependent master equation. The stationary points on the potential energy surface were located with B3LYP density functional theory. Approximate QCISD(T,Full)/6-311++G(3df,2pd) energies were obtained at these stationary points. At low temperatures the reaction is dominated by addition to the CH2 side of the propargyl radical followed by stabilization. However, addition to the CH side, which is followed by one of various possible internal rearrangements, becomes the dominant process at higher temperatures. These internal rearrangements involve a splitting of the O2 bond via the formation of 3-, 4- or 5-membered rings, with the apparent products being CH2CO + HCO. Rearrangement via the 3-membered ring is found to dominate the kinetics. Rearrangement from the CH2 addition product, via a 4-membered ring, would yield H2CO + HCCO, but the barrier to this rearrangement is too high to be kinetically significant. Other possible products require H transfers and, as a result, appear to be kinetically irrelevant. Modest variations in the energetics of a few key stationary points (most notably the entrance barrier heights) yield kinetic results that are in good agreement with the experimental results of Slagle and Gutman (I. R. Slagle and D. Gutman, Proc. Combust. Inst., 1986, 21, 875) and of Atkinson and Hudgens (D. B. Atkinson and J. W. Hudgens, J. Phys. Chem. A, 1999, 103, 4242).     

Effect of the heteroatomic substituent on the pi-facial diastereoselectivity in Lewis acid catalyzed carbonyl ene reaction: A theoretical study

Quantum chemical investigation on the optimized transition structures of intermolecular ene reaction containing various heteroatomic substituents at the -carbon atom reveal that, the electrostatic effect produced by the ene moiety plays a crucial role in controlling the conformation of the transition structure. The stereoselectivity calculated from the proposed model agreed nicely with the reported experimental results.     

A theoretical study on the mechanism of the addition reaction between carbene and epoxyethane

The mechanism of addition reaction between carbene and epoxyethane has been investigated employing the MP2 and B3LYP/6-311+G* levels of theory. Geometry optimization, vibrational analysis, and energy property for the involved stationary points on the potential energy surface have been calculated. Based on the calculated results at the MP2/6-311+G* level of theory, it can be predicted that there are two reaction mechanisms (1) and (2). In the first reaction carbene attacks the atom O of epoxyethane to form an intermediate 1a (IM1a), which is a barrier-free exothermic reaction. Then, IM1a can isomerize to IM1b via a transition state 1a (TS1a), where the potential barrier is 48.6 kJ/mol. Subsequently, IM1b isomerizes to a product epoxypropane (Pro1) via TS1b with a potential barrier of 14.2 kJ/mol. In the second carbene attacks the atom C of epoxyethane firstly to form IM2 via TS2a. Then IM2 isomerizes to a product allyl alcohol (Pro2) via TS2b with a potential barrier of 101.6 kJ/mol. Correspondingly, the reaction energies for the reactions (1) and (2) are −448.4 and −501.6 kJ/mol, respectively. Additionally, the orbital interactions are also discussed for the leading intermediate. The results based on the B3LYP/6-311+G* level of theory are paralleled to those on the MP2/6-311+G* level of theory. Furthermore, the halogen and methyl substituent effects of H₂C: on the two reaction mechanisms have been investigated. The calculated results indicate that the introductions of halogen or methyl make the addition reaction difficult to proceed.     

Theoretical investigation into the potential of halogenated methanes to undergo reductive metabolism

The density-functional theory (DFT)-based computational chemistry software package DMol was used to provide insight into the reductive potentials of a series of halomethanes. It is known that certain members of this series are readily reduced in vivo via catalysis by cytochrome P450. DMol was used to calculate the electron affinities of these molecules to be used as measures of their reduction potentials. Our results are consistent with experimental electrochemical reduction potentials and indicate that electron affinity is dependent upon the number and type of halogens present in the molecule. Calculated bond lengths and angles also compared favorably with experimental results and estimates derived from other ab initio methods of calculation. Concurrent with this study was the observation of a linear empirical relationship between electron affinity and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital energy. It is possible that these values could be used as indicators of reductive potentials and ultimately of metabolic rates for use in PB–PK models designed to predict the dose associated with the toxicity of molecules of this and other classes. © John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

A theoretical analysis of the reaction between hydrogen atoms and isocyanic acid

Using BAC-MP4 potential-surface parameters, supplemented by an MP2 normal-mode analysis at one transition state, and statistical theoretical methods, we have computed thermal rate coefficients for the reactions, and Over the entire temperature range considered, 300 K < T < 3300 K, reaction (2) is the dominant product channel. The theoretical predictions are in excellent agreement with the experimental results available for k₂ and k_?1, the rate coefficient for the reverse of reaction (1). Modified Arrhenius expressions are given for k₁, k_?1, and k₂. In addition, we identify and discuss a weakness in utilizing a Hartree-Fock normal-mode analysis in the prediction of k₂. The present result for k₂ is much smaller than that used in the initial modeling of the RAPRENO_x process. The implications of this are discussed.     

The ultraviolet absorption of some halogenated methanes and ethanes of atmospheric interest

The absorption spectra of some chlorine-containing methanes (CCl₄, CCl₃F, CClF₃, CHCl₃, CH₂Cl₂ and CH₂ClF) and ethanes (CCl₂FCClF₂, CClF₂CClF₂, CF₃CClF₂, CF₃CH₂Cl, CH₃CCl₃, CH₃CClF₂ and CH₃CH₂Cl) and also of N₂O were determined at wavelengths near 220 nm. Some of these spectra were obtained at both 298 and 208 K. Additionally, a chemical method was used to determine the absorption cross section of CCl₃F at λ = 253.7 nm and the absorption properties at wavelengths above 280 nm. It is concluded from these experiments that the tropospheric decay rate of CCl₃F is less than 10⁻¹⁰ s⁻¹ for the homogeneous gas phase photolysis.     

Catalyst and substituent effects on the rhodium(II)-catalysed intramolecular Buchner reaction

Intramolecular rhodium(II)-catalysed aromatic addition (Buchner) reactions of a range of α- and β-substituted α-diazoketones are reported. Both steric and electronic effects are evident for the aromatic additions investigated. In general, highly efficient aromatic addition is achieved through use of rhodium carboxylates bearing electronegative ligands, such as rhodium trifluoroacetate, while aromatic addition employing rhodium catalysts with more electron-donating ligands, such as rhodium caprolactam, is less efficient. Excellent levels of diastereoselectivity are possible for this process in the presence of rhodium acetate and rhodium caprolactam, however, a reduction in diastereocontrol is generally associated with use of the more reactive, electronegative catalysts. Interestingly, these catalyst effects can be overcome through the steric effects of the substituents on the α-diazoketone substrates, with the presence of sterically bulky substituents at the 2- or 3-position rendering the aromatic addition essentially catalyst independent in terms of efficiency and diastereocontrol.     

Remote substituent effects on the oxymercuration of 2-substituted norbornenes: an experimental and theoretical study.

The effect of a remote substituent on regioselectivity in the oxymercuration of 2-substituted norbornenes has been investigated experimentally and theoretically using density functional theory (DFT). Regioselectivities of 1:1 to 14:1 were observed with various 2-substituted norbornenes. Exo-2-substituted norbornenes always gave greater regioselectivities compared to the corresponding endo-2-substituted norbornenes. The effects of solvents on the regioselectivity have also been examined, and ethereal solvents were found to be the best choice giving the optimal yield and regioselectivity. The relative rate of oxymercuration was estimated by competition experiments. The least reactive substrate (X = OAc) gave the highest regioselectivity. According to DFT predictions, the increased difference between the reaction barriers that results in the greater regioselectivity is correlated directly with the larger polarity of the C=C double bond, which is attacked by the mercury and oxygen. A number of stable exo and endo conformers were predicted. All exo conformers show the same polarity of the double bond, while some endo conformers have a reversal of this polarity. All the conformers except those with the OAc substituent are very close in energy and thus should react. The existence of a mixture of endo conformers with the C=C double bond of opposite polarity clearly explains a decrease in regioselectivity for the endo species. The origin of the greatest regioselectivity for the OAc-2-norbornenes lies in the fact that the conformer with the largest polarity is notably lower in energy than others due to an internal C-H-O hydrogen bond.     

Solvent,substituent, and dimerization effects on the ring-opening mechanisms of monosilacyclopropylidenoids: a theoretical study

Density functional theory and ab initio computations elucidated the ring-opening of substituted (R = –CF₃, –CN, –CH₃, –H, –NH₂, –OCH₃, –OH, –SiH₃) 1-bromo–1-lithiosilirane 1 and 2-bromo–2-lithiosilirane 2 to LiBr complexes of 2-silaallene and 1-silaallene, respectively. Formally, two competitive pathways can be considered. The ring-opening reaction can take place through a concerted manner via TS3. Alternatively, the reaction may proceed in a stepwise fashion with the intermediacy of a free silacyclopropylidene–LiBr complex 7. In both cases, the position of the substituents determines the kinetic of the reactions. The structures with an electron-donating group are generally unstable, whereas the silacyclopropylidenoids bearing electron-withdrawing substituents are particularly stable species. Here, we propose the ring-opening of 5a–h to corresponding LiBr complexes of 2-silaallenes can proceed in both concerted and stepwise mechanism except for –H, –CH₃, and –SiH₃. The obtained activation energies for the ring-openings of 5a–h to related 2-silaallenes are too high for a reaction at room temperature with up to 61.4 kcal/mol. In contrast, the activation energy barriers for the isomerization of 6a–h to the LiBr complexes of 1-silaallenes was determined to be relatively low at the B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p), M06/6-31+G(d,p), and MP2/6-31+G(d,p) levels. Moreover, we have also investigated the solvent effect on the unsubstituted models using both implicit and explicit solvation models. The energy barriers of the solvated models are found to be slightly higher than the results of gas phase calculations. Additionally, the ring-opening of dimer 6 (6–Dim) is also calculated for the ring-opening mechanism with the energy barrier of 3.7 kcal/mol at B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p) level of theory.     

A theoretical approach to substituent effects: Stabilities and conformational preferences in β-substituted ethyl radicals

Ab initio molecular orbital theory is used to study substituent effects in a series of β-substituted Et radicals XCH₂CH₂. For X = BH₂ (plan.), CH₃, NH₂, OH and F, only slight conformational preferences and weak stabilizations are indicated. Such behaviour may be rationalized, using a PMO model, in terms of opposing changes, accompanying variation in X, in positive and negative hyperconjugation between the XCH₂ group and the CH₂ centre. On the other hand, for groups containing an appropriately oriented, low-lying vacant orbital, viz. X = Li, BeH and BH₂ (perp.), there is a pronounced preference for the perpendicular conformation of the radical. This is attributed to 1,3-interaction between the singly-occupied 2p(C) orbital and the vacant 2p(X) orbital.     

A theoretical study of the anomalous substituent effect of the hydroxyl group

A theoretical study by MINDO/3 and STO-3G SCF calculations has been used to examine the effect of a H-bonded water molecule on the ability of the hydroxyl group to stabilise a carbocation centre. Alkoxy groups are better stabilising groups in the gas phase, hydroxyl is more effective in protic solvents.