Force measurements of bacterial adhesion on metals using a cell probe atomic force microscope

The adhesion of microbial cells to metal surfaces in aqueous media is an important phenomenon in both the natural environment and engineering systems. The adhesion of two anaerobic sulfate-reducing bacteria (Desulfovibrio desulfuricans and a local marine isolate) and an aerobe (Pseudomonas sp.) to four polished metal surfaces (i.e., stainless steel 316, mild steel, aluminum, and copper) was examined using a force spectroscopy technique with an atomic force microscope (AFM). Using a modified bacterial tip, the attraction and repulsion forces (in the nano-Newton range) between the bacterial cell and the metal surface in aqueous media were quantified. Results show that the bacterial adhesion force to aluminum is the highest among the metals investigated, whereas the one to copper is the lowest. The bacterial adhesion forces to metals are influenced by both the electrostatic force and metal surface hydrophobicity. It is also found that the physiological properties of the bacterium, namely the bacterial surface charges and hydrophobicity, also have influence on the bacteria-metal interaction. The adhesion to the metals by Pseudomonas sp. and D. desulfuricans was greater than by the marine SRB isolate. The cell-cell interactions show that there are strong electrostatic repulsion forces between bacterial cells. Cell probe atomic force microscopy has provided some useful insight into the interactions of bacterial cells with the metal surfaces.     

Streptococcus mutans and Streptococcus intermedius adhesion to fibronectin films are oppositely influenced by ionic strength

Bacterial adhesion to protein-coated surfaces is mediated by an interplay of specific and nonspecific interactions. Although nonspecific interactions are ubiquitously present, little is known about the physicochemical mechanisms of specific interactions. The aim of this paper is to determine the influence of ionic strength on the adhesion of two streptococcal strains to fibronectin films. Streptococcus mutans LT11 and Streptococcus intermedius NCTC11324 both possess antigen I/II with the ability to bind fibronectin from solution, but S. intermedius binds approximately 20x less fibronectin than does the S. mutans strain under identical conditions. Both strains as well as fibronectin films are negatively charged in low ionic strength phosphate buffered saline (PBS, 10x diluted), but bacteria appear uncharged in high ionic strength PBS. Physicochemical modeling on the basis of overall cell surface properties (cell surface hydrophobicity and zeta potentials) demonstrates that both strains should favor adhesion to fibronectin films in a high ionic strength environment as compared to in a low ionic strength environment, where electrostatic repulsion between equally charged surfaces is dominant. Adhesion of S. intermedius to fibronectin films in a parallel plate flow chamber was completely in line with this modeling, while in addition atomic force microscopy (AFM) indicated stronger adhesion forces upon retraction between fibronectin-coated tips and the cell surfaces in high ionic strength PBS than in low ionic strength PBS. Thus, the dependence of the interaction on ionic strength is dominated by the overall negative charge on the interacting surfaces. Adhesion of S. mutans to fibronectin films, however, was completely at odds with theoretical modeling, and the strain adhered best in low ionic strength PBS. Moreover, AFM indicated weaker repulsive forces upon approach between fibronectin-coated tips and the cell surfaces in low ionic strength PBS than in high ionic strength PBS. This indicated that the dependence of the interaction on ionic strength is dominated by electrostatic attraction between oppositely charged, localized domains on the interacting surfaces, despite their overall negative charge. In summary, this study shows that physicochemical modeling of bacterial adhesion to protein-coated surfaces is only valid provided the number of specific interaction sites on the cell surfaces is low, such as on S. intermedius NCTC11324. Nonspecific interactions are dominated by specific interactions if the number of specific interaction sites is large, such as on S. mutans LT11. Its ionic strength dependence indicates that the specific interaction is electrostatic in nature and operative between oppositely charged domains on the interacting surfaces, despite the generally overall negatively charged character of the surfaces.     

Adhesion properties of uric acid crystal surfaces

Two key steps in kidney stone formation--crystal aggregation and attachment to renal tissues--depend on the surface adhesion properties of the crystalline components. Anhydrous uric acid (UA) is the most common organic crystalline phase found in human kidney stones. Using chemical force microscopy, the adhesion force between various functional groups and the largest (100) surface of UA single crystals was measured in both aqueous solution and model urine. Adhesion trends in the two solutions were identical, but were consistently lower in the latter. Changes in the solution ionic strength and pH were also found to affect the magnitude of the adhesion. UA surfaces showed the strongest adhesion to cationic functionalities, which is consistent with ionization of some surface uric acid molecules to urate. Although hydrogen-bonding and van der Waals interactions are usually considered to be dominant forces in the association between neutral organic compounds, this work demonstrates that electrostatic interactions can be important, particularly when dealing with weak acids under certain solution conditions.     

A modeling approach to describe the adhesion of rough, asymmetric particles to surfaces

A combined theoretical and experimental study of the adhesion of alumina particles and polystyrene latex spheres to silicon dioxide surfaces was performed. A boundary element technique was used to model electrostatic interactions between micron-scale particles and planar surfaces when the particles and surfaces were in contact. This method allows quantitative evaluation of the effects of particle geometry and surface roughness on the electrostatic interaction. The electrostatic interactions are combined with a previously developed model for van der Waals forces in particle adhesion. The combined model accounts for the effects of particle and substrate geometry, surface roughness and asperity deformation on the adhesion force. Predictions from the combined model are compared with experimental measurements made with an atomic force microscope. Measurements are made in aqueous solutions of varying ionic strength and solution pH. While van der Waals forces are generally dominant when particles are in contact with surfaces, results obtained here indicate that electrostatic interactions contribute to the overall adhesion force in certain cases. Specifically, alumina particles with complex geometries were found to adhere to surfaces due to both electrostatic and van der Waals interactions, while polystyrene latex spheres were not affected by electrostatic forces when in contact with various surfaces.     

Detachment of Particles from Surfaces: An AFM Study

We have measured interactions between hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces in an aqueous medium at various pH and ionic strengths as well as in some organic solvents using atomic force microscopy and analyzed them in terms of particle adhesion and detachment from surfaces. In hydrophilic systems the forces observed were found to be well described by DLVO theory at large separation distances. Very long range hydrophobic forces were not observed in hydrophilic-hydrophobic systems. Nevertheless, the jump into contact was found to occur at distances greater that those predicted by just van der Waals attraction. The interaction between two hydrophobic surfaces was dominated by the long-range attraction due to hydrophobic forces. This interaction was found to be sensitive to the type of substrate as well as to the pH and electrolyte concentration. Measured pull-off forces showed poor reproducibility. However, average values showed clear trends and were used to estimate interfacial energies or work of adhesion for all systems studied by means of the Derjaguin approximation. These values were compared to those calculated by the surface tension component theory using the acid-base approach. Good qualitative agreement was obtained, giving support for the usefulness of this approach in estimating interfacial energies between surfaces in liquid media. A comparison of the measured adhesion force with hydrodynamic detachment experiments showed good qualitative agreement. Copyright 2001 Academic Press.     

Residence time, loading force, pH, and ionic strength affect adhesion forces between colloids and biopolymer-coated surfaces

Exopolymers are thought to influence bacterial adhesion to surfaces, but the time-dependent nature of molecular-scale interactions of biopolymers with a surface are poorly understood. In this study, the adhesion forces between two proteins and a polysaccharide [Bovine serum albumin (BSA), lysozyme, or dextran] and colloids (uncoated or BSA-coated carboxylated latex microspheres) were analyzed using colloid probe atomic force microscopy (AFM). Increasing the residence time of an uncoated or BSA-coated microsphere on a surface consistently increased the adhesion force measured during retraction of the colloid from the surface, demonstrating the important contribution of polymer rearrangement to increased adhesion force. Increasing the force applied on the colloid (loading force) also increased the adhesion force. For example, at a lower loading force of approximately 0.6 nN there was little adhesion (less than -0.47 nN) measured between a microsphere and the BSA surface for an exposure time up to 10 s. Increasing the loading force to 5.4 nN increased the adhesion force to -4.1 nN for an uncoated microsphere to a BSA surface and to as much as -7.5 nN for a BSA-coated microsphere to a BSA-coated glass surface for a residence time of 10 s. Adhesion forces between colloids and biopolymer surfaces decreased inversely with pH over a pH range of 4.5-10.6, suggesting that hydrogen bonding and a reduction of electrostatic repulsion were dominant mechanisms of adhesion in lower pH solutions. Larger adhesion forces were observed at low (1 mM) versus high ionic strength (100 mM), consistent with previous AFM findings. These results show the importance of polymers for colloid adhesion to surfaces by demonstrating that adhesion forces increase with applied force and detention time, and that changes in the adhesion forces reflect changes in solution chemistry.     

Direct surface force measurements of polyelectrolyte multilayer films containing nanocrystalline cellulose

Polyelectrolyte multilayer films containing nanocrystalline cellulose (NCC) and poly(allylamine hydrochloride) (PAH) make up a new class of nanostructured composite with applications ranging from coatings to biomedical devices. Moreover, these materials are amenable to surface force studies using colloid-probe atomic force microscopy (CP-AFM). For electrostatically assembled films with either NCC or PAH as the outermost layer, surface morphology was investigated by AFM and wettability was examined by contact angle measurements. By varying the surrounding ionic strength and pH, the relative contributions from electrostatic, van der Waals, steric, and polymer bridging interactions were evaluated. The ionic cross-linking in these films rendered them stable under all solution conditions studied although swelling at low pH and high ionic strength was inferred. The underlying polymer layer in the multilayered film was found to dictate the dominant surface forces when polymer migration and chain extension were facilitated. The precontact normal forces between a silica probe and an NCC-capped multilayer film were monotonically repulsive at pH values where the material surfaces were similarly and fully charged. In contrast, at pH 3.5, the anionic surfaces were weakly charged but the underlying layer of cationic PAH was fully charged and attractive forces dominated due to polymer bridging from extended PAH chains. The interaction with an anionic carboxylic acid probe showed similar behavior to the silica probe; however, for a cationic amine probe with an anionic NCC-capped film, electrostatic double-layer attraction at low pH, and electrostatic double-layer repulsion at high pH, were observed. Finally, the effect of the capping layer was studied with an anionic probe, which indicated that NCC-capped films exhibited purely repulsive forces which were larger in magnitude than the combination of electrostatic double-layer attraction and steric repulsion, measured for PAH-capped films. Wherever possible, DLVO theory was used to fit the measured surface forces and apparent surface potentials and surface charge densities were calculated.     

Interaction and structure of surfaces coated by poly(vinyl amines) of different line charge densities

Interactions between preadsorbed films of poly(vinyl amine) (PVA) of two different line charge densities on silica substrates were studied with the colloidal probe technique based on the atomic force microscope (AFM). The preadsorbed films were prepared by adsorption of PVA from a pH 4 solution without any added salt. The highly charged PVA adsorbs in a flat configuration and in laterally heterogeneous layers, while the more weakly charged PVA analog adsorbs in thicker and more homogeneous films. As revealed by reflectivity measurements, such preadsorbed PVA films are stable in polyelectrolyte-free solutions. However, force measurements with the colloidal probe reveal that their interactions depend strongly on the ionic strength. Upon approach, interactions are dominated by electrostatic diffuse layer overlap forces. Both PVA films have very similar diffuse layer charge densities of about 1.5 mC/m2. Since these values are substantially lower than what would be expected from the total charge of the adsorbed polyelectrolytes measured by reflectivity, we infer that coadsorption of anions represents the principal mechanism in charge neutralization. Upon retraction, the adhesion between the films is dominated by bridging forces due to single polymer chains. Such bridging adhesion becomes progressively important with increasing ionic strength, whereby their range and frequency increase. The work of adhesion due to bridging is about 0.3 mN/m. At low ionic strengths, the films behave differently. While the highly charged PVA shows unspecific adhesion at small distances, the more weakly charged PVA analog shows few adhesion events occurring at long distances.     

Modification of Surface Forces by Metal Ion Adsorption

Abstract

Sorption of ions may lead to variations in interparticle forces and, thus, changes in the stability of colloidal particles. Chemical interactions between metal ions and colloidal particles modify the molecular structure of the surface, the surface charge, and the electrical potential between colloidal particles. These modifications to the surface and to the electrical double layer due to metal ion sorption are reflected in the interaction force between a particle and another surface, which is measured in this study by atomic force microscopy (AFM). Specifically, AFM is used to investigate the sorption of copper ions from aqueous solutions by silica particles. The influence of metal ion concentration and solution ionic strength on surface forces is studied under transient conditions. Results show that as the metal ion concentration is decreased, charge reversal occurs and a longer period of time is required for the system to reach equilibrium. The ionic strength has no significant effect on sorption kinetics. Furthermore, neither metal concentration nor ionic strength exhibits any effect on sorption equilibria, indicating that for the experimental conditions used in this study, the surface sites of the silica particle are fully occupied by copper ions.     

Nanoscale experimental investigation of particle interactions at the origin of the cohesion of cement

Atomic force microscopy has been used to investigate the force at the origin of the cohesion of cement. The cohesion of cement grains is caused by surface forces acting between calcium silicate hydrate nanoparticles in interstitial electrolytic solution. Direct measurement of the interaction between two calcium silicate hydrate surfaces is performed in air and different aqueous solutions. In dry air, starting with the van der Waals forces, the interaction area between calcium silicate hydrate nanoparticles can be estimated. In electrolytic solution, the evolution of these forces is extensively dependent on both surface and solution chemistry. The roles of the calcium hydroxide concentration, pH, and ionic strength are investigated. The force measurements allow us to confirm the pre-eminence of ionic correlation forces in the cohesion of cement.     

Phase behavior of aqueous solutions containing dipolar proteins from second-order perturbation theory

Due to the interplay of Coulombic repulsion and attractive dipolar and van der Waals interactions, solutions of globular proteins display a rich variety of phase behavior featuring fluid-fluid and fluid-solid transitions that strongly depend on solution pH and salt concentration. Using a simple model for charge, dispersion and dipole-related contributions to the interprotein potential, we calculate phase diagrams for protein solutions within the framework of second-order perturbation theory. For each phase, we determine the Helmholtz energy as the sum of a hard-sphere reference term and a perturbation term that reflects both the electrostatic and dispersion interactions. Dipolar effects can induce fluid-fluid phase separation or crystallization even in the absence of any significant dispersion attraction. Because dissolved electrolytes screen the charge-charge repulsion more strongly than the dipolar attraction, the ionic strength dependence of the potential of mean force can feature a minimum at intermediate ionic strengths offering an explanation for the observed nonmonotonic dependence of the phase behavior on salt concentration. Inclusion of correlations between charge-dipole and dipole-dipole interactions is essential for a reliable calculation of phase diagrams for systems containing charged dipolar proteins and colloids.     

Effect of introduced charge in cellulose gels on surface interactions and the adsorption of highly charged cationic polyelectrolytes

The interaction between cellulose surfaces in aqueous solution has been measured using colloidal probe microscopy. Cellulose thin films with varying charge through carboxyl group substitution were used in this study with the surface forces fit to DLVO theory. It was found that the surface potential increased, as expected, with increasing carboxyl substitution. Furthermore, for a given degree of substitution, the surface potential increased as a function of increasing pH. At low pH, the surface forces interaction were attractive and could be fit to the non-retarded Hamaker equation using a constant of 3 x 10(-21) J. At pH greater than 5, the force interactions were monotonically repulsive, regardless of the ionic strength of the solution for all charge densities of the cellulose thin films. The adsorption of polyDADMAC to these charged cellulose films was also investigated using the quartz crystal microbalance. It was found that for the low charge film, a low surface excess of PDADMAC was sensed and that the adsorbed conformation was essentially flat. However for the higher charged cellulose film, a spontaneous de-swelling was observed resulting in no possibility of quantitatively determining the sensed mass using QCM.     

Interaction forces between silica surfaces in aqueous solutions of cationic polymeric flocculants: effect of polymer charge

Three cationic polymers with molecular weights and charge density of 3.0 x 10(5) g/mol and 10% (D 6010), 1.1 x 10(5) g/mol and 40% (D6040), and 1.2 x 10(5) g/mol and 100% (D6099) were investigated in aqueous NaCl solutions in the presence of silica. The atomic force microscope (AFM) colloidal probe technique was used to determine silica interparticle interaction forces, which were compared to macroscopic information on the strength of interactions such as compressive yield stress measurements. It was found that in 30 mM NaCl solution the 10% charged polymer produced steric repulsion upon approach and long-range adhesion with multiple pull off events upon retraction at the optimum flocculation concentration. This suggests that the polymer was adsorbed in a conformation where segments extend from the surface, resulting in bridging flocculation. The 40 and 100% charged polymers produced attraction upon approach and strong adhesion with snap out from contact upon separation at optimum polymer dosages. This suggests that these polymers are adsorbed with flat conformations and is typical of charge neutralization or patch attraction. The attractions for 40 and 100% charged polymers measured with the AFM are significantly larger than for the 10% charged polymer. The polymer dose that produced the optimum flocculation and the maximum compressive yield stress typically corresponded to the polymer concentration that produced the maximum adhesion for each polymer. It was found that the magnitude of the adhesive force was more significant in determining the compressive yield stresses of the silica particle sediments than the aggregate size and structure.     

Multiscale dynamics of the cell envelope of Shewanella putrefaciens as a response to pH change

The bacterial surface properties of gram-negative Shewanella putrefaciens were characterized by microbial adhesion to hydrocarbons (MATH), adhesion to polystyrene dishes, and electrophoresis at different values of pH and ionic strength. The bacterial adhesion to these two apolar substrates shows significant variations according to pH and ionic strength. Such behavior could be partly explained by electrostatic repulsions between bacteria and the solid or liquid interface. However, a similar trend was also observed at rather high ionic strength where electrostatic interactions are supposed to be screened. The nanomechanical properties at pH 4 and 10 and at high ionic strength were investigated by using atomic force microscopy (AFM). The indentation curves revealed the presence of a polymeric external layer that swells and softens up with increasing pH. This suggests a concomitant increase of the water permeability and so did of the hydrophilicity of the bacterial surface. Such evolution of the bacterial envelope in response to changes in pH brings new insight to the pH dependence in the bacterial adhesion tests. It especially demonstrates the necessity to consider the hydrophobic/hydrophilic surface properties of bacteria as not univocal for the various experimental conditions investigated.     

Multiscale dynamics of the cell envelope of Shewanella putrefaciens as a response to pH change

The bacterial surface properties of gram-negative Shewanella putrefaciens were characterized by microbial adhesion to hydrocarbons (MATH), adhesion to polystyrene dishes, and electrophoresis at different values of pH and ionic strength. The bacterial adhesion to these two apolar substrates shows significant variations according to pH and ionic strength. Such behavior could be partly explained by electrostatic repulsions between bacteria and the solid or liquid interface. However, a similar trend was also observed at rather high ionic strength where electrostatic interactions are supposed to be screened. The nanomechanical properties at pH 4 and 10 and at high ionic strength were investigated by using atomic force microscopy (AFM). The indentation curves revealed the presence of a polymeric external layer that swells and softens up with increasing pH. This suggests a concomitant increase of the water permeability and so did of the hydrophilicity of the bacterial surface. Such evolution of the bacterial envelope in response to changes in pH brings new insight to the pH dependence in the bacterial adhesion tests. It especially demonstrates the necessity to consider the hydrophobic/hydrophilic surface properties of bacteria as not univocal for the various experimental conditions investigated.     

Interactions between charged surfaces with ionizable sites

A key factor controlling the interactions between surfaces in aqueous solutions is the surface charge density. Surfaces typically become charged though a titration process where surface groups can become ionized based on their dissociation constant and the pH of the solution. In this work, we use a Monte Carlo method to treat this process in a system with two planar surfaces with explicitly described ionizable sites in a salt solution. We focus on a system with a surface density of ionizable sites set to 4.8 nm(-2), corresponding to silica. We find that the surface charge density changes as the surfaces come close to contact due to interactions between the ionizable groups on each surface. In addition, we observe an attraction between the surfaces above a threshold surface charge, in good agreement with previous theoretical predictions based on uniformly charged surfaces. However, close to contact we find the force is significantly different than for the uniformly charged case.     

Direct measurement of recognition forces between proteins and membrane receptors

The interactions between the protein, cholera toxin B subunit attached to an atomic force microscope, AFM, cantilever, CTB and its receptor the ganglioside, GM1 have been measured in a dilute electrolyte solution, pH 5.5. Although there is variation in the force separation data obtained, particularly on approach of the AFM tip to the GM1 surface where usually, but not always an attraction is noted, an adhesion is always noted on separation of the surfaces. The strength of this adhesion varies from experiment to experiment, but appears to be quantised at a value of around 90 pN. Addition of cholera toxin to the aqueous electrolyte solution completely removes the attractive interaction and adhesion. This gives us confidence that in the earlier experiments, a specific interaction between the CTB and GM1 was measured.     

DLVO and steric contributions to bacterial deposition in media of different ionic strengths

The deposition of eight bacterial strains on Teflon and glass in aqueous media with ionic strengths varying between 0.0001 and 1 M was measured and interpreted. Two types of interactions were considered: (1) those described by the DLVO theory, which comprise van der Waals attraction and electrostatic repulsion (bacteria and surfaces are both negatively charged); and (2) steric interactions between the outer cell surface macromolecules and the substrata. As a trend, at low ionic strength (<0.001 M), deposition is inhibited by DLVO-type electrostatic repulsion, but at high ionic strength (≥0.1 M) it is dominated by steric interactions. The ionic strength at which the transition from the DLVO-controlled to the sterically controlled deposition occurs, is determined by the extension of the macromolecules into the surrounding medium, which varied between 5 and 100 nm among the bacterial strains studied. The steric interactions either promote deposition by bridging or inhibit it by steric repulsion. Between Teflon and hydrophobic bacteria, bridging is generally observed. The surface of one bacterial strain contains amphiphilic macromolecules that form bridges with Teflon but induce steric repulsion on glass. The presence of highly polar anionic polysaccharide coatings on the cell impedes attachment on both glass and Teflon. For practice, the general conclusion is that the deposition of most bacteria is: (1) strongly inhibited by DLVO-type electrostatic repulsion in aqueous environments of low ionic strength such as rain water, streams and lakes; (2) controlled by DLVO and/or steric interactions in systems as domestic waste waters and saliva; and (3) determined by steric interactions only in more saline environments as milk, urine, blood and sea water.     

Breakdown of hydration repulsion between charged surfaces in aqueous Cs+ solutions

Using a surface force balance, we have measured the normal and shear forces between mica surfaces across aqueous caesium salt solutions (CsNO(3) and CsCl) up to 100 mM concentrations. In contrast to all other alkali metal ions at these concentrations, we find no evidence of hydration repulsion between the mica surfaces on close approach: the surfaces appear to be largely neutralized by condensation of the Cs ions onto the charged lattice sites, and are attracted on approach into adhesive contact. The contact separation at adhesion indicates that the condensed Cs ions protrude by 0.3 +/- 0.2 nm from each surface, an observation supported both by the relatively weak adhesion energies between the surfaces, and the relatively weak frictional yield stress when they are made to slide past each other. These observations show directly that the hydration shells about the Cs(+) ions are removed as the ions condense into the charged surface lattice. This effect is attributed to the low energies-resulting from their large ionic radius-required for dehydration of these ions.