How the biomimetic assembly of membrane receptors into multivalent domains is regulated by a small ligand

In living cells, communication requires the action of membrane receptors that are activated following very small environmental changes. A binary all-or-nothing behavior follows, making the organism extremely efficient at responding to specific stimuli. Using a minimal system composed of lipid vesicles, chemical models of a membrane receptor and their ligands, we show that bio-mimetic ON/OFF assembly of high avidity, multivalent domains is triggered by small temperature changes. Moreover, the intensity of the ON signal at the onset of the switch is modulated by the presence of small, weakly binding divalent ligands, reminiscent of the action of primary messengers in biological systems. Based on the analysis of spectroscopic data, we develop a mathematical model that rigorously describes the temperature-dependent switching of the membrane receptor assembly and ligand binding. From this we derive an equation that predicts the intensity of the modulation of the ON signal by the ligand-messenger as a function of the pairwise binding parameters, the number of binding sites that it features and the concentration. The behavior of our system, and the model derived, highlight the usefulness of weakly binding ligands in the regulation of membrane receptors and the pitfalls inherent to their binding promiscuity, such as non-specific binding to the membrane. Our model, and the equations derived from it, offer a valuable tool for the study of membrane receptors in both biological and biomimetic settings. The latter can be exploited to program membrane receptor avidity on sensing vesicles, create hierarchical protocell tissues or develop highly specific drug delivery vehicles.

In lipid vesicles near their membrane phase-transition temperature, the presence of a small, weakly binding ligand tips the balance for the assembly of multivalent receptor domains. We recapitulate this behaviour using a global binding-clustering model.     

Measuring raft size as a function of membrane composition in PC-based systems: Part II--ternary systems

The heterogeneity of cell membranes, specifically the presence of lipid rafts, has been hypothesized to play a role in a large number of cellular processes. Although extensive work has been carried out to show the function of lipid rafts in these processes, the characterization of lipid rafts has proven to be extremely difficult. It is known that raft size is relevant to the function of cellular processes and that raft coalescence may be a driving factor for these processes; however, it remains unclear what factors influence raft size and coalescence in natural cell membranes. In this work, we study two ternary model phospholipid and cholesterol systems using two steady-state fluorescent techniques to detect and characterize membrane domains. Domain size is determined through the use of a model to relate experimental F?rster resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements to domain size. Domains in the range of 3-15 nm were detected in a dioleoylphosphatidylcholine-dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine-cholesterol (DOPC-DPPC-Chol) system, while only a very small region containing domains was detected in a 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine-dipamitoylphosphatidylcholine-cholesterol (POPC-DPPC-Chol) system. In addition, the polarity-dependent emission maximum shift of the acceptor 1-myristoyl-2-[12-[(5-dimethylamino-1-naphthalenesulfonyl)amino]dodecanoyl]-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DAN-PC) was used to detect the type of liquid phase(s) present in the membrane. It was found that, even in the case in which no two-phase coexistence was observed (POPC-DPPC-Chol), two liquid phases are present, although not necessarily in coexistence. These steady-state fluorescent techniques provide a method for detecting the presence of very small domains in model membranes and provide previously inaccessible detail about the phase behavior of these two systems.     

Incorporation of blood clotting factor X into phospholipid model membranes: fluorescence microscopy imaging and subphase effects surrounding the lipid phase transition region

Factor X is a blood clotting protein that associates at membrane surfaces to become activated during the coagulation cascade. A molecular level understanding of the protein-membrane phospholipid interactions has not been reached, although it is thought that the protein binds to phospholipids in the presence of calcium through a bridge with the Gla (gamma-carboxyglutamic acid) domain on the protein. In this work, phospholipid Langmuir monolayers have been utilized as model membranes to study factor X association with phospholipid membrane components. Surface pressure measurements indicate that subphase addition of sodium, magnesium, and calcium ions enhances protein penetration of the lipid monolayer, with the largest association found with calcium ions in the subphase. Fluorescence microscopy images collected after protein penetration of lipid monolayers indicate monolayer condensation in the presence of sodium and magnesium ions. Aggregation of lipid domains is induced when calcium is in the subphase, indicating binding-induced flocculation of surface lipid aggregates. Calcium binding to factor X likely causes a conformational change which allows protein-membrane interaction via hydrophobic association with lipid molecules.     

Lateral reorganization of myelin lipid domains by myelin basic protein studied at the air-water interface

It has been speculated that adsorption of myelin basic protein (MBP) to the myelin lipid membrane leads to lateral reorganization of the lipid molecules within the myelin membrane. This hypothesis was tested in this study by surface pressure measurement and fluorescent imaging of a monolayer composed of a myelin lipid mixture. The properties of the lipid monolayer before and after addition of MBP into the subphase were monitored. Upon addition of MBP to the monolayer subphase, the surface pressure rose and significant rearrangement of the lipid domains was observed. These results suggest that binding and partial insertion of MBP into the lipid monolayer led to dramatic rearrangement and morphological changes of the lipid domains. A model of adsorption of MBP to the lipid domains and subsequent domain fusion promoted by minimization of electrostatic repulsion between the domains was proposed to account for the experimental observations. The significance of these results in light of the role of MBP in maintaining the myelin structural integrity is discussed.     

Membrane domain-disrupting effects of 4-substitued cholesterol derivatives

A wide range of cellular functions are thought to be regulated not only by the activity of membrane proteins, but also by the local membrane organization, including domains of specific lipid composition. Thus, molecules and drugs targeting and disrupting this lipid pattern, particularly of the plasma membrane, will not only help to investigate the role of membrane domains in cell biology, but might also be interesting candidates for therapy. We have identified three 4-substituted cholesterol derivatives that are able to induce a domain-disrupting effect in model membranes. When applied to giant unilamellar vesicles displaying liquid-ordered-liquid-disordered phase coexistence, extensive reorganization of the membrane can be observed, such as the budding of membrane tubules or changes in the geometry of the domains, to the point of complete abolition of phase separation. In this case, the resulting membranes display a fluidity intermediate between those of liquid-disordered and liquid-ordered phases.     

Hydrodynamic effects on spinodal decomposition kinetics in planar lipid bilayer membranes

The formation and dynamics of spatially extended compositional domains in multicomponent lipid membranes lie at the heart of many important biological and biophysical phenomena. While the thermodynamic basis for domain formation has been explored extensively in the past, domain growth in the presence of hydrodynamic interactions both within the (effectively) two-dimensional membrane and in the three-dimensional solvent in which the membrane is immersed has received little attention. In this work, we explore the role of hydrodynamic effects on spinodal decomposition kinetics via continuum simulations of a convective Cahn-Hilliard equation for membrane composition coupled to the Stokes equation. Our approach explicitly includes hydrodynamics both within the planar membrane and in the three-dimensional solvent in the viscously dominated flow regime. Numerical simulations reveal that dynamical scaling breaks down for critical lipid mixtures due to distinct coarsening mechanisms for elongated versus more isotropic compositional lipid domains. The breakdown in scaling should be readily observable in experiments on model membrane systems.     

Enantiospecific interactions between cholesterol and phospholipids

The effects of cholesterol on various membrane proteins have received considerable attention. An important question regarding each of these effects is whether the cholesterol exerts its influence by binding directly to membrane proteins or by changing the properties of lipid bilayers. Recently it was suggested that a difference in the effects of natural cholesterol and its enantiomer, ent-cholesterol, would originate from direct binding of cholesterol to a target protein. This strategy rests on the fact that ent-cholesterol has appeared to have effects on lipid films similar to those of cholesterol, yet fluorescence microscopy studies of phospholipid monolayers have provided striking demonstrations of the enantiomer effects, showing opposite chirality of domain shapes for phospholipid enantiomer pairs. We observed the shapes of ordered domains in phospholipid monolayers containing either cholesterol or ent-cholesterol and found that the phospholipid chirality had a great effect on the domain chirality, whereas a minor (quantitative) effect of cholesterol chirality could be observed only in monolayers with racemic dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine. The latter is likely to derive from cholesterol-cholesterol interactions. Accordingly, cholesterol chirality has only a modest effect that is highly likely to require the presence of solidlike domains and, accordingly, is unlikely to play a role in biological membranes.     

Crystalline protein domains and lipid bilayer vesicle shape transformations

Cellular membranes can take on a variety of shapes to assist biological processes including endocytosis. Membrane-associated protein domains provide a possible mechanism for determining membrane curvature. We study the effect of tethered streptavidin protein crystals on the curvature of giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) using confocal, fluorescence, and differential interference contrast microscopy. Above a critical protein concentration, streptavidin domains align and percolate as they form, deforming GUVs into prolate spheroidal shapes in a size-dependent fashion. We propose a mechanism for this shape transformation based on domain growth and jamming. Osmotic deflation of streptavidin-coated GUVs reveals that the relatively rigid streptavidin protein domains resist membrane bending. Moreover, in contrast to highly curved protein domains that facilitate membrane budding, the relatively flat streptavidin domains prevent membrane budding under high osmotic stress. Thus, crystalline streptavidin domains are shown to have a stabilizing effect on lipid membranes. Our study gives insight into the mechanism for protein-mediated stabilization of cellular membranes.     

Design and application of stimulus-responsive droplets and bubbles stabilized by phospholipid monolayers

Biomimetic colloidal particles are promising agents for biosensing, but current technologies fall far short of Nature's capabilities for sensing, assessing, and responding to stimuli. Phospholipid-containing cell membranes are capable of binding and responding to an enormous variety of biomolecules by virtue of membrane organization and the presence of receptor proteins. By tuning the composition and functionalization of simulated membranes, soft colloids such as droplets and bubbles can be designed to respond to various stimuli. Moreover, because lipid monolayers can surround almost any hydrophobic phase, the interior of the colloid can be selected to provide a sensitive readout, for example in the form of optical microscopy or acoustic detection. In this work, we review some advances made by our group and others in the formulation of lipid-coated particles with different internal phases such as fluorocarbons, hydrocarbons, or liquid crystals. In some cases, binding or displacement of stabilizing lipids gives rise to conformational changes or disruptions in local membrane geometry, which can be amplified by the interior phase. In other cases, multivalent analytes can promote aggregation or even membrane fusion, which can be utilized for an optical or acoustic readout. By highlighting a few recent examples, we hope to show that lipid monolayers represent a versatile biosensing platform that can react to and detect biomolecules by leveraging the unique capabilities of phospholipid membranes.     

Lipid mobility and molecular binding in fluid lipid membranes

The lateral mobility of dilute concentrations of fluorescently labeled lipids doped into supported membranes is found to change upon receptor ligand binding at the membrane surface, even when the lipid is not directly involved in the binding event. Experiments using membrane microarrays are performed that illustrate the use of lipid mobility measurements as an effectively label-free strategy of detecting binding on membrane surfaces.     

Evaluation of the membrane-binding properties of the proximal region of the angiotensin II receptor (AT1A) carboxyl terminus by surface plasmon resonance.

The proximal region of the angiotensin II receptor (AT1A) carboxyl-terminus (known as helix VIII) is important for receptor function. In this study, we used surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to examine the interaction of helix VIII-derived peptides with three model lipid membranes. The membrane-binding properties of these synthetic peptides, as well as a series of peptide analogues with modified amino acid sequences, could be explained by both amino acid sequence and kinetic binding data by SPR. The helix VIII peptides showed a higher affinity for lipid membranes that contained negatively charged phospholipid, rather than zwitterionic phospholipid. The findings of an SPR study may be useful for estimating the cooperative binding of intracellular receptor domains with G proteins and the components of the lipid bilayer.     

Effect ofcholinergic ligands on the lipids of acetylcholine receptor-rich membrane preparations from Torpedo californica.

Ion permeation, triggered by ligand-receptor interaction, is associated with the primary events of membrane depolarization at the neuromuscular junction and synaptic connections. To explore the possible sites of ion permeation, the long-lived fluorescent probe pyrene (fluorescence lifetime approximately 400 nsec) has been inserted into the lipid phase of acetylcholine receptor-rich membrane (AcChR-M) preparations from Torpedo californica. The pyrene probe is susceptible to both fluidity and permeability changes in the lipid bilayer. These changes are detected by variations in the rate of decay of the excited singlet state of pyrene after pulsation with a 10-nsec ruby laser flash. Variations of these lifetimes in the membrane preparations alone or in the presence of quenchers show that binding of cholinergic agonists and antagonists, neurotoxins, and local anesthetics to AcChR-M produces varying effects on the properties of the pyrene probe in the lipid phase. It is concluded that binding of cholinergic ligands to the receptor does not significantly alter the fluidity of permeability of the lipids in the bilayer contact with pyrene. On the other hand, local anesthetics do affect these properties.     

Single particle tracking reveals corralling of a transmembrane protein in a double-cushioned lipid bilayer assembly

A predominate question associated with supported bilayer assemblies containing proteins is whether or not the proteins remain active after incorporation. The major cause for concern is that strong interactions with solid supports can render the protein inactive. To address this question, a large transmembrane protein, the serotonin receptor, 5HT(3A), has been incorporated into several supported membrane bilayer assemblies of increasing complexity. The 5HT(3A) receptor has large extracellular domains on both sides of the membrane, which could cause strong interactions. The bilayer assemblies include a simple POPC (1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) supported planar bilayer, a “single-cushion” POPC bilayer with a PEG (poly(ethylene glycol)) layer between membrane and support, and a “double-cushion” POPC bilayer with both a PEG layer and a layer of BSA (bovine serum albumin). Single-cushion systems are designed to lift the bilayer from the surface, and double-cushion systems are designed to both lift the membrane and passivate the solid support. As in previously reported work, protein mobilities measured by ensemble fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) are quite low, especially in the double-cushion system. But single-particle tracking of fluorescent 5HT(3A) molecules shows that individual proteins in the double-cushion system have quite high local mobilities but are spatially confined within small corralling domains ( 450 nm). Comparisons with the simple POPC membrane and the single-cushion POPC?PEG membrane reveal that BSA both serves to minimize interactions with the solid support and creates the corrals that reduce the long-range (ensemble averaged) mobility of large transmembrane proteins. These results suggest that in double-cushion assemblies proteins with large extra-membrane domains may remain active and unperturbed despite low bulk diffusion constants.     

Nanoscale imaging of domains in supported lipid membranes

The formation of domains in supported lipid membranes has been studied extensively as a model for the 2D organization of cell membranes. The compartmentalization of biological membranes to give domains such as cholesterol-rich rafts plays an important role in many biological processes. This article summarizes experiments from the author's laboratory in which a combination of atomic force microscopy and near-field scanning optical microscopy is used to probe phase separation in supported monolayers and bilayers as models for membrane rafts. These techniques are used to study binary and ternary lipid mixtures that have gel-phase or liquid-ordered domains that vary in size from tens of nanometers to tens of micrometers, surrounded by a fluid-disordered membrane. Examples are presented in which these models are used to investigate the distribution of glycolipid membrane raft markers and the preference for peptide and protein localization in ordered versus fluid membrane phases. Finally, the enzyme-mediated restructuring of membranes containing liquid-ordered domains provides an in vitro model for the coalescence of membrane rafts to give signaling platforms. Overall, the results demonstrate the importance of using techniques that can probe the nanoscale organization of membranes and of combining techniques that yield complementary information. Furthermore, the ability of supported lipid bilayers to model some aspects of membrane compartmentalization provides an important approach to understanding natural membranes.     

Regulating the size and stabilization of lipid raft-like domains and using calcium ions as their probe

We apply a means to probe, stabilize, and control the size of lipid raft-like domains in vitro. In biomembranes the size of lipid rafts is ca. 10-30 nm. In vitro, mixing saturated and unsaturated lipids results in microdomains, which are unstable and coalesce. This inconsistency is puzzling. It has been hypothesized that biological line-active surfactants reduce the line tension between saturated and unsaturated lipids and stabilize small domains in vivo. Using solution X-ray scattering, we studied the structure of binary and ternary lipid mixtures in the presence of calcium ions. Three lipids were used: saturated, unsaturated, and a hybrid (1-saturated-2-unsaturated) lipid that is predominant in the phospholipids of cellular membranes. Only membranes composed of the saturated lipid can adsorb calcium ions, become charged, and therefore considerably swell. The selective calcium affinity was used to show that binary mixtures, containing the saturated lipid, phase separated into large-scale domains. Our data suggests that by introducing the hybrid lipid to a mixture of the saturated and unsaturated lipids, the size of the domains decreased with the concentration of the hybrid lipid, until the three lipids could completely mix. We attribute this behavior to the tendency of the hybrid lipid to act as a line-active cosurfactant that can easily reside at the interface between the saturated and the unsaturated lipids and reduce the line tension between them. These findings are consistent with a recent theory and provide insight into the self-organization of lipid rafts, their stabilization, and size regulation in biomembranes.     

Specific interaction of desthiobiotin lipids and water-soluble biotin compounds with streptavidin

As shown for biotin lipids (Ref. 1), the formation of perfect 2-D crystalline streptavidin domains can also be observed in the plane of desthiobiotin lipid monolayers. The binding constant of streptavidin with desthiobiotin (K_a = 5·10¹³ mol⁻¹) is lower than that with biotin (K_a = 10¹⁵ mol⁻¹) (Ref. 2). By adding free biotin into the subphase a competitive replacement and a detaching of the streptavidin domains from the desthiobiotin lipid monolayer takes place. Streptavidin domains built at receptor lipid monolayers are still functional. As could be shown, there are two biotin binding sites at each protein molecule that are fully accessible to biotin (Ref. 1). This can be proven by the interaction with biotinylated ferritin and fluoresceinated biotin. Further coupling of an anti-FITC-antibody can proceed and a second protein layer can be formed. Using a bifunctional biotin linker a second crystalline streptavidin layer underneath the first one can be obtained.     

Cytochrome‐P450‐Induced Ordering of Microsomal Membranes Modulates Affinity for Drugs

Although membrane environment is known to boost drug metabolism by mammalian cytochrome P450s, the factors that stabilize the structural folding and enhance protein function are unclear. In this study, we use peptide‐based lipid nanodiscs to “trap” the lipid boundaries of microsomal cytochrome P450 2B4. We report the first evidence that CYP2B4 is able to induce the formation of raft domains in a biomimetic compound of the endoplasmic reticulum. NMR experiments were used to identify and quantitatively determine the lipids present in nanodiscs. A combination of biophysical experiments and molecular dynamics simulations revealed a sphingomyelin binding region in CYP2B4. The protein‐induced lipid raft formation increased the thermal stability of P450 and dramatically altered ligand binding kinetics of the hydrophilic ligand BHT. These results unveil membrane/protein dynamics that contribute to the delicate mechanism of redox catalysis in lipid membrane.     

Membrane receptor calorimetry: cardiac glycoside interaction with Na,K-ATPase

The receptor–ligand interaction between the cardiac glycoside Ouabain and purified, membrane-bound as well as micellar Na,K-ATPase is investigated. Calorimetric titrations are carried out with micromolar concentrations of the phosphorylated protein in the presence of Mg²⁺. The measured heat changes provide evidence for an exothermic, high affinity and specific receptor binding process as well as for a low affinity, nonspecific binding to the lipid part of the nanoparticulate membrane fragments. The degree of lipid binding markedly depends on the lipid composition of the tissue. The measured time course of the heat change resulting from specific binding to the receptor site is unusually slow and is limited by the binding kinetics of the ligand. A course estimation of the Ouabain binding kinetics leads to a rate constant around 10⁴ mol⁻¹ l s⁻¹. Receptor binding is characterized by affinities ranging between 10⁷ and 10⁸ mol⁻¹ l, ΔH values around −95 kJ mol⁻¹ and ΔS values of about −130 J K⁻¹ mol⁻¹ at 25°C. The enthalpic contribution is assumed to be mainly due to hydrogen bond formations between the ligand and the receptor site whereas the large, negative entropy change may be attributed to an increased interaction between water and the protein as a consequence of a conformational transition. The evaluation of the titrations provides stoichiometric coefficients around 0.55, which implies that only about 50–60% of the Na,K-ATPase protomers are capable to bind the cardiotonic steroid. This result is consistent with radioactive phosphorylation studies and appears to be a typical feature of kidney-type Na,K-ATPase preparations. Possible implications of this finding are discussed. As a general result, this study demonstrates how simple and suitable calorimetric titrations with micromolar protein concentrations can be for the purpose of a quantitative characterization of a receptor in nanoparticulate membrane systems.     

Hormone receptor mobility and catecholamine binding in membranes. A theoretical model.

[3H]-Catecholamine binding to intact cells, isolated cell membranes, and to several isolated macromolecules has been shown by several laboratories to be neither stereospecific nor inhibited by known beta-antagonists. Since additional evidence indicates that this binding is not an artifact (i.e. due neither to the binding of a catecholamine oxidation product nor hormone binding to a catabolic enzyme such as COMT), the question remains as to whether this represents binding to a bona fide membrane receptor. Because all ligands which bind strongly or compete for this binding possess a catechol group, one possible explanation is that the binding affinity is primarily determined by the catechol moiety, whereas the correct stereoisomer of the side chain is necessary to activate the receptor. Thus, although binding is a necessary condition for hormone action, the necessary and sufficient condition for activation of adenyl cyclase is both the catechol group and the correct stereoisomer of the side chain. A theoretical model is developed here to provide a quantitative basis for this hypothesis. This model extends the current concept of distinct subunits in the adenyl cyclase system by separating the receptors from the catalytic sites and placing them at separate locations within the membrane. Utilizing the spare receptor model of Furchgott, and the mobility of macromolecules within a "lipid sea," the appropriate equations to predict both hormone binding and enzyme activation are derived. Using the observed affinity constants from catecholamine binding studies, it is then shown that this model can predict the experimental observation and hence explain the apparent dichotomy arising from binding enzyme activation studies.     

Targeting proteins to liquid-ordered domains in lipid membranes

We demonstrate the construction of novel protein-lipid assemblies through the design of a lipid-like molecule, DPIDA, endowed with tail-driven affinity for specific lipid membrane phases and head-driven affinity for specific proteins. In studies performed on giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) with varying mole fractions of dipalymitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC), cholesterol, and diphytanoylphosphatidyl choline (DPhPC), DPIDA selectively partitioned into the more ordered phases, either solid or liquid-ordered (L(o)) depending on membrane composition. Fluorescence imaging established the phase behavior of the resulting quaternary lipid system. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy confirmed the fluidity of the L(o) phase containing DPIDA. In the presence of CuCl(2), the iminodiacetic acid (IDA) headgroup of DPIDA forms the Cu(II)-IDA complex that exhibits a high affinity for histidine residues. His-tagged proteins were bound specifically to domains enriched in DPIDA, demonstrating the capacity to target protein binding selectively to both solid and L(o) phases. Steric pressure from the crowding of surface-bound proteins transformed the domains into tubules with persistence lengths that depended on the phase state of the lipid domains.