Selection of two reliable parameters to evaluate the impact of the mobile-phase composition on capillary electrochromatography performance with monolithic and particle-packed capillary columns

Different models have been described in the literature to evaluate the total porosity of CEC columns: gravimetric, flow as well as conductivity-based methods. In this study, these models have been compared for two kinds of CEC columns: two mixed-mode silica particle stationary phases and different monolithic columns (acrylate or polystyrene divinylbenzene-based). The total porosities measured from the conductivity-based methods were lower than the total column porosities obtained by gravimetric or flow methods for all the investigated columns while the wide distribution of observed values shows that conductivity-based methods discriminate columns more efficiently with very different properties. We propose a conductivity-based method taking into account the actual length proposed by Horvath, to evaluate what we call an "actual electrokinetic" porosity (AEP). This parameter, based on electrokinetic theory only, affords the most consistent evaluation of porosity under experimental CEC conditions for the packed- and acrylate-based monolithic columns. To illustrate the potential of AEP and actual EOF for the estimation of the performances of a CEC system (stationary and mobile phases) we studied the influence of the mobile-phase composition on these parameters for CEC separations with an ammonium embedded packed stationary phase. The AEP and the actual electroosmotic mobility should allow a better understanding of the perfusive EOF and stationary-phase wettability. For neutral compounds (substituted phenols), AEP evaluation allowed us to predict the mobile-phase conditions able to enhance the efficiency while both AEP and actual EOF had to be considered in the case of peptide analysis.     

How to utilize the true performance of monolithic silica columns

Ways of utilizing the true separation efficiency of monolithic silica (MS) columns were studied. The true performance of MS columns, both regular-sized (rod-type clad with PEEK resin, 4.6 mm ID, 10 cm) and capillary sized (in 100 or 200 microm ID fused silica capillary, 25-140 cm) was evaluated by calculating the contribution of extra-column effects. HETP values of 7-9 microm were observed for solutes having retention factors (kvalues) of up to 4 for rod columns and up to 15 for a capillary column. The high permeability of MS columns allowed the use of long columns, with several connected together in the case of rod columns. Narrow-bore connectors gave good results. Peak variance caused by a column connector ranges from 50 to 70% of that caused by one rod-type column for up to three connectors or four columns in 80% methanol, but the addition of a 4th or 5th connector to add a 5th and 6th column, respectively, caused a much greater increase in peak variance, especially for long-retained solutes, which is greater than the variance caused by one rod column. Rod columns seem to show slightly lower efficiency at a pressure higher than 10 MPa or so. The use of acetonitrile-water as a mobile phase better preserved the ability of individual rod columns to generate up to 100,000 theoretical plates with 14 columns connected. Methods for eliminating extra-column effects in micro-HPLC were also studied. Split injection and on-column detection resulted in optimum performance. A long MS capillary measuring 140 cm produced 160,000 theoretical plates. The column efficiency of a capillary column was not affected by the pressure, showing advantages over the rod columns that exhibited peak broadening caused by connectors and pressure.     

Structure and performance of silica-based monolithic HPLC columns

Silica-based monolithic columns were prepared for HPLC with systematic variations of the tetramethoxysilane (TMOS) and polyethylene oxide (PEO) content as reactants in a sol-gel process accompanied by phase separation. The resulting monoliths showed differences in the macropore and silica skeleton diameter as well as in the corresponding domain sizes (the sum of macropore and skeleton diameter). All monoliths were synthesized with a diameter of 4.6 mm and cladded with a suitable polyaryletheretherketone (PEEK) polymer in a standardized and optimized manner for the subsequent chromatographic evaluation of the resulting monolithic HPLC columns. The columns were tested under normal phase conditions using n-heptane/dioxane (95:5 v/v) as a mobile phase and 2-nitroanisole as a test compound for the determination of separation efficiency and permeability. Two different sets of columns were prepared: the first one in which the amount of PEO was stepwise decreased to yield monoliths with identical macropore volumes and variations in the domain sizes. The second group of materials was synthesized adjusting both TMOS and PEO quantities to yield monolithic columns with identical macropore diameters of about 1.80 microm but different skeleton diameters and macropore volumes. The chromatographic results suggest that an increase in the column performance cannot be achieved by just arbitrarily decreasing the domain size of a given column. From a certain point of "downsizing" the monolithic structure a loss of structural homogeneity can be observed, which is apparently responsible for a lower chromatographic performance.     

Combining monolithic and hollow capillary columns under conditions of two-dimensional gas chromatography

A monolithic column with the optimum structure of its monolithic layer is considered as a second dimension column under the conditions of two-dimensional gas chromatography. It is shown that despite the considerable difference between the working pressures of different columns, sample transfer from a hollow capillary column to a monolithic column is possible when a looped switching valve is used. It is found that the additional broadening of the chromatographic zone observed during sample transfer can be effectively suppressed by using an additional flow splitter. At the same time, reducing the volume of the switching valve loop is inefficient and does not allow effective separation by the monolithic column.     

Preparation and application of hydrophilic monolithic columns

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) has experienced increasing attention in recent years. Much research has been carried out in the area of HILIC separation mechanisms, column techniques and applications. Because of their good permeability, low resistance to mass transfer and easy preparation within capillaries, hydrophilic monolithic columns represent a trend among novel HILIC column techniques. This review attempts to present an overview of the preparation and applications of HILIC monolithic columns carried out in the past decade. The separation mechanism of various hydrophilic monolithic stationary phases is also reviewed.     

Surfactant-bound monolithic columns for separation of proteins in capillary high performance liquid chromatography

A surfactant-bound monolithic stationary phase based on the co-polymerization of 11-acrylamino-undecanoic acid (AAUA) is designed for capillary high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Using D-optimal design, the effect of the polymerization mixture (concentrations of monomer, crosslinker and porogens) on the chromatographic performance (resolution and analysis time) of the AAUA–EDMA monolithic column was evaluated. The polymerization mixture was optimized using three proteins as model test solutes. The D-optimal design indicates a strong dependence of chromatographic parameters on the concentration of porogens (1,4-butanediol and water) in the polymerization mixture. Optimized solutions for fast separation and high resolution separation, respectively, were obtained using the proposed multivariate optimization. Differences less than 6.8% between the predicted and the experimental values in terms of resolution and retention time indeed confirmed that the proposed approach is practical. Using the optimized column, fast separation of proteins could be obtained in 2.5 min, and a tryptic digest of myoglobin was successfully separated on the high resolution column. The physical properties (i.e., morphology, porosity and permeability) of the optimized monolithic column were thoroughly investigated. It appears that this surfactant-bound monolith may have a great potential as a new generation of capillary HPLC stationary phase.     

The effect of hydrothermal treatment on column performance for monolithic silica capillary columns

Monolithic silica capillary columns with i.d. 100 μm and monolithic silica rods were prepared with tetramethoxysilane (TMOS) or a mixture of TMOS and metyltrimethoxysilane (MTMS) using different hydrothermal treatments at T=80 °C or 120 °C. Nitrogen physisorption was applied for the pore characterization of the rods and inverse size exclusion chromatography (ISEC) for that of the capillary columns. Using nitrogen physisorption, it was shown change of pore size and surface area corresponds to that of hydrothermal treatment and silica precursor. The results from ISEC agreed well with those from nitrogen physisorption regarding the pore size distribution (PSD). In addition, the retention factors for hexylbenzene with the ODS-modified capillary columns in methanol/water=80/20 at T=30 °C could also support the results from nitrogen physisorption. Furthermore, column efficiency for the columns was evaluated with alkylbenzenes and three kinds of peptides, leucine-enkephalin, angiotensin II, and insulin. Column efficiency for alkylbenzenes was similar independently of the hydrothermal treatment at T=120 °C. Even for TMOS columns, there was no significant difference in column efficiency for the peptides despite the difference in hydrothermal treatment. In contrast, for hybrid columns, it was possible to confirm the effect on hydrothermal treatment at T=120 °C resulting in a different column efficiency, especially for insulin. This difference supports the results from both nitrogen physisorption and ISEC, showing the presence of more small pores of ca. 3-6 nm for a hybrid silica without hydrothermal treatment at T=120 °C. Consequently, the results suggest that hydrothermal treatment for a hybrid column with higher temperature or longer time is necessary, compared to that for a TMOS column, to provide higher column efficiency with increase in molecular size of solute.     

Advances in capillary electrochromatography and micro-high performance liquid chromatography monolithic columns for separation science

Over the last decade, monoliths or continuous beds have emerged as an alternative to traditional packed-bed columns for use in capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and micro-high performance liquid chromatography (micro-HPLC). Monolithic columns can be divided into two categories: silica-based monolithic columns and rigid organic polymer-based monolithic columns resulting from the polymerization of acrylamide, styrene, acrylate or methacrylate monomers. In this paper, the chemistry and most recent applications of these various types of monoliths in both CEC and micro-HPLC are presented.     

Comparison of the efficiency of microparticulate and monolithic capillary columns

A comparison is made between the efficiency of microparticulate capillary columns and silica and polymer-based monolithic capillary columns in the pressure-driven (high-performance liquid chromatography) and electro-driven (capillary electrochromatography) modes. With packed capillary columns similar plate heights are possible as with conventional packed columns. However, a large variation is observed in the plate heights for individual columns. This can only be explained by differences in the quality of the packed bed. The minimum plate height obtained with silica monolithic capillary columns in the HPLC mode is approximately 10 microm, which is comparable to that of columns packed with 5-microm particles. The permeability of wide-pore silica monoliths was found to be much higher than that of comparable microparticulate columns, which leads to much lower pressure drops for the same eluent at the same linear mobile phase velocity. For polymer-based monolithic columns (acrylamide, styrene/divinyl benzene, methacrylate, acrylate) high efficiencies have been found in the CEC mode with minimum plate heights between 2 and 10 microm. However, in the HPLC mode minimum plate heights in the range of 10 to 25 microm have been reported.     

Chemical and chromatographic stability of methacrylate-based monolithic columns

Chemical and chromatographic stability of methacrylate-based monolithic columns bearing 3-N,N-diethylamino-2-hydroxypropyl (DEAE) and quarternary amine (QA) groups was studied. The leakage products from both monolithic columns were determined and the leakage of amines has been quantified in alkali solutions. Monolithic columns bearing QA functional groups being exposed to 1M sodium hydroxide solution for up to 3 months caused reduction of ion-exchange groups for approximately 12%, while for DEAE monolithic columns was only around 3% in 1 year. In 0.1M NaOH and 20% ethanol degradation was significantly lower. The main leaking compound from DEAE monolith was found to be 3-(diethylamino)-1,2-propanediol and 2,3-dihydroxypropyltrimethylammonium salt for QA monolith. During repeated 50 cleaning-in-place (CIP) cycles, no changes in chromatographic properties were detected.     

Guidelines for tuning the macropore structure of monolithic columns for high‐performance liquid chromatography

The ability to control the external porosity and to tune the dimensions of the macropore size on multiple length scales provides the possibility of tailoring the monolithic support structure towards separation performance. This paper discusses the properties of conventional polymer–monolithic stationary phases and its limitations regarding the effects of morphology on kinetic performance. Furthermore, guidelines to improve the macropore structure are discussed. The optimal monolithic macropore structure is characterized by high external porosity (while maintaining ultra‐high‐pressure stability), high structure homogeneity, polymer globule clusters in the submicron range, and macropores with a diameter tuned toward speed (small diameter in the 100–500 nm range using short beds) or efficiency (larger macropores in the range of 500 nm–1 μm allowing the use of longer column formats). Finally, promising approaches to control the morphology are discussed.     

Enzymes immobilized on montmorillonite: comparison of performance in batch and packed-bed reactors

Summary The enzymes a-amylase, invertase and glucoamylase were immobilized on acid activated montmorillonite using two techniques, viz. adsorption and covalent binding, and their activities were tested in a batch and packed-bed reactor and were compared. The packed-bed reactor showed an improved performance for all immobilized enzymes, which was attributed to lowering of diffusional restrictions to mass transfer. Lower activity in case of batch reactor for immobilized invertase was due to a combined effect of loss of native conformation of enzyme on account of immobilization and mass transfer resistances due to improper diffusion of substrate to the active site of enzyme. For immobilized glucoamylase, the packed-bed reactor demonstrated exceptionally high activity that was very close to the free enzyme. Covalently bound glucoamylase showed higher activity than the free enzyme.     

Standardization of test conditions for high performance liquid chromatography columns

Summary Comparisons of columns, column packings and column packing methods are made difficult and sometimes invalidated by differences and inadequacies in the test procedures used and the experimental data recorded. This paper reviews test procedures and recommends standards for a) the experimental and test parameters which must be recorded in order to enable comparisons to be made from laboratory to laboratory, b) the group of chromatographic parameters which best represent column performance for comparative purposes, with methods for their calculation, c) test solutes and eluents for some different types of packing materials. A computer program in BASIC is given which converts the experimental parameters into relevant chromatographic parameters.     

Preparation and application of organic-silica hybrid monolithic capillary columns

Organic-silica hybrid monolithic columns have drawn more and more attention due to the ease of preparation and good mechanical stability in recent years. Many synthetic approaches have been developed and a variety of hybrid monolithic capillary columns have been prepared. The sol-gel process is well recognized in the fabrication of hybrid monolithic columns, which can be mainly classified as one-step, acid/base two-step procedures. The new approaches such as the "one-pot" and nano-scaled inorganic-organic hybrid reagent of polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxane used as a cross-linker have also emerged for the preparation of hybrid monolithic columns. The applications of the organic-silica hybrid monolithic capillary columns for capillary electrochromatography, micro high-performance liquid chromatography, solid-phase micro-extraction and enzymatic reactor etc. are included in this review.     

Comparison of the performance of conventional microparticulates and monolithic reversed-phase columns for liquid chromatography separation of eleven pollutant phenols

The performance of isocratic separations of 11 pollutant phenols (PP) using monolithic (Chromolith RP-18e) and conventional reversed-phase 5 microm (Luna and Purospher C18) and 4 microm (Synergi C12) particulate size columns, selected from high purity silica materials, has been compared. The separations have been optimized based on a previously optimized separation in which a reversed-phase C18 Luna column and acetonitrile as organic modifier were used, allowing the separation of all phenols tested in 23 min. The optimization process was carried out for each column by studying the effect of the mobile phase (acetonitrile as organic modifier, pH, flow-rate) on phenols separation. Under the optimized separation conditions, all phenols were separated in less than 23 min for all columns tested. Asymmetry factors were further evaluated and used to estimate column efficiency using the Dorsey-Foley equation. The efficiency and asymmetry factors were lower for Chromolith than for Purospher and Luna columns respectively. The Chromolith column was finally selected, due to its lower flow resistance, analysis time and good efficiency and asymmetry factors. The PPs separation was achieved in 3 min. The asymmetry factors were in the range 0.9-1.5 using 50mM acetate buffer (pH = 5.25)-ACN (64:36, v/v) as mobile phase, T=45 degrees C and 4.0 ml min(-1) flow-rate.     

The performance of hybrid monolithic silica capillary columns prepared by changing feed ratios of tetramethoxysilane and methyltrimethoxysilane

The effect of a feed ratio of methyltrimethoxysilane (MTMS) to tetramethoxysilane (TMOS) was studied to improve the performance of a hybrid monolithic silica capillary column with 100-μm i.d. in HPLC in a range MTMS/TMOS (v/v) = 10/90–25/75. The domain size was also varied by adjusting the amount of PEG to control permeability (K = 2.8 × 10⁻¹⁴–6.9 × 10⁻¹⁴ m²). Evaluation of the performance for those capillary columns following octadecylsilylation proved an increase in retention factor (k) and a decrease in steric selectivity α(triphenylene/ortho-terphenyl) with the increase in MTMS content in the feed. The effect of the feed ratio was also observed in porosity and hydrophobic property of the C18 stationary phase from the results of size exclusion chromatography (SEC) and reversed phase characterization. The monolithic silica capillary columns prepared under new preparation conditions were able to produce a plate height of 4.6–6.0 μm for hexylbenzene in a mobile phase acetonitrile/water = 80/20 at a linear velocity of 2 mm/s. Consequently, it was possible to prepare hybrid monolithic silica capillary columns with higher performance than those reported previously while maintaining the retention factors in a similar range by reducing the MTMS/TMOS ratio and increasing the total silane concentration in feed.     

Porous structure of the monolithic sorbent and separation properties of monolithic capillary columns in gas and liquid chromatography

Macroporous polymer based on polydivinylbenzene was used for the preparation of monolithic capillary columns with the diameter from 0.01 to 0.53 mm for separations by gas and liquid chromatography. The separation properties of the columns were studied by analysis of model systems of aromatic (in liquid chromatography) and light (in gas chromatography) hydrocarbons. The permeability was determined and the C parameter of the Van-Deemter equation was found for each column. The permeability of the majority of columns determined by gas chromatography is independent of the column diameter. The permeability of the same columns in liquid chromatography is also almost constant for the columns 0.53–0.1 mm in diameter; however, the permeability decreases sharply on going to columns of smaller diameter. In gas chromatography the value of the C parameter reflecting the effect of the mass transfer of the sorbate between the mobile and stationary phases on the smearing of a chromatographic peak in the column approximately the same for all columns. In liquid chromatography the value of the C coefficient in the Van-Deemter equation for the same capillary columns changes with a change in the column diameter and reaches a minimum for the columns 0.1 mm in diameter. The differences observed for the characteristics of the columns in gas and liquid chromatography are due to different structures of the macroporous monolith formed in columns of different diameter and to the effect of solvation of the monolith by the mobile phase under the conditions of liquid chromatography.     

Silica monolithic columns: synthesis, characterisation and applications to the analysis of biological molecules

In recent years, proteomics has been a subject of intense research. The complexity of proteomics samples has fostered technological developments. One of these addresses the need for more efficient and faster separations. Monolithic columns prepared from organic and silica monomers offer very efficient separations at low back-pressure. Silica-based monoliths have small-sized skeletons and a bimodal pore size distribution with microm-sized throughpores and nm-sized mesopores. This gives silica-based monoliths favourable properties for high-efficiency, fast separations, like a low-pressure drop across the column, fast mass transfer kinetics and a high binding capacity.