Chemical bonding in view of electron charge density and kinetic energy density descriptors

Stalke's dilemma, stating that different chemical interpretations are obtained when one and the same density is interpreted either by means of natural bond orbital (NBO) and subsequent natural resonance theory (NRT) application or by the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM), is reinvestigated. It is shown that within the framework of QTAIM, the question as to whether for a given molecule two atoms are bonded or not is only meaningful in the context of a well‐defined reference geometry. The localized‐orbital‐locator (LOL) is applied to map out patterns in covalent bonding interaction, and produces results that are consistent for a variety of reference geometries. Furthermore, LOL interpretations are in accord with NBO/NRT, and assist in an interpretation in terms of covalent bonding. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.J Comput Chem, 2009.     

Experimental and Theoretical Evidence for an Agostic Interaction in a Gold(III) Complex

The first agostic interaction in a gold complex is described. The presence of a bonding C?H???Au interaction in a cationic “tricoordinate” gold(III) complex was suggested by DFT calculations and was subsequently confirmed by NMR spectroscopy at low temperature. The agostic interaction was analyzed computationally using NBO and QTAIM analyses (NBO=natural bond orbital; QTAIM=quantum theory of atoms in molecules).     

Bond paths as privileged exchange channels

Evidence that the bond paths of the quantum theory of atoms-in-molecules (QTAIM) signal preferred quantum-mechanical exchange channels is presented. We show how bond paths between an atom A and the atoms B in its environment appear to be determined by competition among the A-B exchange-correlation energies that always contribute to stabilize the A-B interactions. These pairwise additive stabilizations depend neither on the attractive or repulsive nature of the classical electrostatic interaction between the atoms' charge densities, nor on the change in the self energies of the atoms involved. These other terms may well cause an overall molecular-energy increase in spite of a possibly large A-B exchange-correlation stabilization. After our proposal, bond paths, both at and out of equilibrium geometries, are endowed with a specific energetic meaning that should contribute to reconcile the orthodox QTAIM interpretation with other widely accepted views, and to settle recent controversies questioning the meaning of hydrogen-hydrogen bonding and the nature of the so-called "steric interactions", the role of bond paths in endohedral complexes, and the generality of the results provided by the QTAIM. Implications for the nature of more general closed-shell interactions are also briefly discussed.     

Forced Bonding and QTAIM Deficiencies: A Case Study of the Nature of Interactions in He@Adamantane and the Origin of the High Metastability

Calculations within the framework of the interacting quantum atoms (IQA) approach have shown that the interactions of the helium atom with both tertiary, tC, and secondary, sC, carbon atoms in the metastable He@adamantane (He@adam) endohedral complex are bonding in nature, whereas the earlier study performed within the framework of Bader’s quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) revealed that only He???tC interactions are bonding. The He???tC and He???sC bonding interactions are shown to be forced by the high pressure that the helium and carbon atoms exert upon each other in He@adam. The occurrence of a bonding interaction between the helium and sC atoms, which are not linked by a bond path, clearly shows that the lack of a bond path between two atoms does not necessarily indicate the lack of a bonding interaction, as is asserted by QTAIM. IQA calculations showed that not only the destabilization of the adamantane cage, but also a huge internal destabilization of the helium atom, contribute to the metastability of He@adam, these contributions being roughly equal. This result disproves previous opinions based on QTAIM analysis that only the destabilization of the adamantane cage accounts for the endothermicity of He@adam. Also, it was found that there is no homeomorphism of the ρ( r ) and ‐v( r ) fields of He@adam. Comparison of the IQA and QTAIM results on the interactions in He@adam exposes other deficiencies of the QTAIM approach. The reasons for the deficiencies in the QTAIM approach are analyzed.     

Nature of a hydride-halogen bond. A SAPT-, QTAIM-, and NBO-based study

The nature of a hydride-halogen bond is investigated by means of high-level quantum mechanical calculations expended with symmetry-adapted perturbation theory (SAPT), quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM), and natural bond orbital (NBO) methods. As model hydride-halogen bonded systems complexes between either LiH or HBeH and either XCF(3) or XCCH (X = F, Cl, Br, I) are used. It is shown that the formation of a hydride-halogen bond leads to the elongation of the R(δ+)-H(δ-) hydride bond, which is accompanied by the blue shift of the ν(R-H) stretching vibration frequency and the increase of the IR intensity of this mode. All these effects, although untypical in the case of, e.g., hydrogen bonds, can be considered as rather typical for hydride-halogen bonded systems. The decomposition of the interaction energy based on the SAPT method clearly indicates the dominant role of the induction term, thus the inductive nature of a hydride-halogen bond in opposition to previous findings. NBO-based analysis indicates the charge transfer from the hydride molecule to the more remote parts of the halogen donor and that the elongation of the R-H bond is caused by the charge outflow from the σ(RH) bonding orbital.     

Actinium coordination chemistry: A density functional theory study with monodentate and bidentate ligands

In the current study, the coordination chemistry of nine-coordinate Ac(III) complexes with 35 monodentate and bidentate ligands was investigated using density functional theory (DFT) in terms of their geometries, charges, reaction energies, and bonding interactions. The energy decomposition analysis with naturals orbitals for chemical valence (EDA-NOCV) and the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) were employed as analysis methods. Trivalent Ac exhibits the highest affinities toward hard acids (such as charged oxophilic donors, fluoride), so its classification as a hard acid is justified. Natural population analysis quantified the involvement of 5f orbitals on Ac to be about 30% of total valence electron natural configuration indicating that Ac is a member of the actinide series. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to study the pairwise correlations among the bond lengths, ΔG reaction energies, charges on Ac and donor atoms, and data from EDA-NOCV and QTAIM. Strong correlations and anticorrelations were found between Voronoi charges on donor atoms with ΔG, EDA-NOCV interaction energies and QTAIM bond critical point densities.     

Nonconventional C–H···Cu Interaction Between Copper Cun Clusters (n = 3–20) and Aromatic Compounds

The present study examines bonding patterns between copper Cu_n clusters (n?=?3–20) and aromatic compounds (benzene, phenol, and benzaldehyde) using a density-functional theory (DFT) approach. Hirshfeld population, natural bond orbital (NBO), molecular orbitals, and quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) analyses suggested the formation of two types of interactions Cu–arene and C–H···Cu, in the complexation of copper clusters by an aromatic compound.

     

Chemical bonds without "chemical bonding"? A combined experimental and theoretical charge density study on an iron trimethylenemethane complex

High-resolution X-ray diffraction data, in conjunction with DFT(B3LYP) quantum calculations, have been used in a QTAIM analysis of the charge density in the trimethylenemethane (TMM) complex Fe(eta(4)-C[CH(2)](3))(CO)(3). The agreement between the theoretical and experimental topological properties is excellent. Only one bond path is observed between the TMM ligand and the Fe atom, from the central C(alpha) atom. However, much evidence, including from the delocalization indices and the source function, suggests that there is a strong chemical interaction between the Fe and C(beta) atoms, despite the formal lack of chemical bonding according to QTAIM.     

Biphenyl: A stress tensor and vector‐based perspective explored within the quantum theory of atoms in molecules

We use quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) and the stress tensor topological approaches to explain the effects of the torsion φ of the C‐C bond linking the two phenyl rings of the biphenyl molecule on a bond‐by‐bond basis using both a scalar and vector‐based analysis. Using the total local energy density H( r _b), we show the favorable conditions for the formation of the controversial H–H bonding interactions for a planar biphenyl geometry. This bond‐by‐bond QTAIM analysis is found to be agreement with an earlier alternative QTAIM atom‐by‐atom approach that indicated that the H–H bonding interaction provided a locally stabilizing effect that is overwhelmed by the destabilizing role of the C‐C bond. This leads to a global destabilization of the planar biphenyl conformation compared with the twisted global minimum. In addition, the H( r _b) analysis showed that only the central torsional C‐C bond indicated a minimum for a torsion φ value coinciding with that of the conventional global energy minimum. The H–H bonding interactions are found to be topologically unstable for any torsion of the central C‐C bond away from the planar biphenyl geometry. Conversely, we demonstrate that for 0.0° < φ < 39.95° there is a resultant increase in the topological stability of the C nuclei comprising the central torsional C‐C bond. Evidence is found of the effect of the H–H bonding interactions on the torsion φ of the central C‐C bond of the biphenyl molecule in the form of the QTAIM response β of the total electronic charge density ρ( r _b). Using a vector‐based treatment of QTAIM we confirm the presence of the sharing of chemical character between adjacent bonds. In addition, we present a QTAIM interpretation of hyperconjugation and conjugation effects, the former was quantified as larger in agreement with molecular orbital (MO) theory. The stress tensor and the QTAIM H atomic basin path set areas are independently found to be new tools relevant for the incommensurate gas to solid phase transition occurring in biphenyl for a value of the torsion reaction coordinate φ ≈ 5°. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Ab initio investigation of the complexes between bromobenzene and several electron donors: some insights into the magnitude and nature of halogen bonding interactions

Halogen bonding, a specific intermolecular noncovalent interaction, plays crucial roles in fields as diverse as molecular recognition, crystal engineering, and biological systems. This paper presents an ab initio investigation of a series of dimeric complexes formed between bromobenzene and several electron donors. Such small model systems are selected to mimic halogen bonding interactions found within crystal structures as well as within biological molecules. In all cases, the intermolecular distances are shown to be equal to or below sums of van der Waals radii of the atoms involved. Halogen bonding energies, calculated at the MP2/aug-cc-pVDZ level, span over a wide range, from -1.52 to -15.53 kcal/mol. The interactions become comparable to, or even prevail over, classical hydrogen bonding. For charge-assisted halogen bonds, calculations have shown that the strength decreases in the order OH- > F- > HCO2- > Cl- > Br-, while for neutral systems, their relative strengths attenuate in the order H2CS > H2CO > NH3 > H2S > H2O. These results agree with those of the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) since bond critical points (BCPs) are identified for these halogen bonds. The QTAIM analysis also suggests that strong halogen bonds are more covalent in nature, while weak ones are mostly electrostatic interactions. The electron densities at the BCPs are recommended as a good measure of the halogen bond strength. Finally, natural bond orbital (NBO) analysis has been applied to gain more insights into the origin of halogen bonding interactions.     

How big are atoms in crystals?

Atoms and bonds are central concepts in structural chemistry, but neither are concepts that arise naturally from the physics of condensed phases. It is ironic that the internuclear distances in crystals that are readily measured depend on the sizes of atoms, but since atoms in crystals can be defined in many different ways, all of them arbitrary and often incompatible, there is no natural way to express atomic size. I propose a simple coherent picture of Atoms-in-Crystals which combines properties selected from three different physically sound definitions of atoms and bonds. The charge density of the free atom that is used to construct the procrystal is represented by a sphere of constant charge density having the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) bonded radius. The sum of these radii is equal to the bond length that correlates with the bond flux (bond valence) in the flux theory of the bond. The use of this model is illustrated by answering the question: How big are atoms in crystals? The QTAIM bonded radii are shown to be simple functions of two properties, the number of quantum shells in the atomic core and the flux of the bond that links neighbouring atoms. Various radii can be defined. The univalent bonded radius measures the intrinsic size of the atom and is the same for all cations in a given row of the periodic table, but the observed bonded radius depends also on the bond flux that reflects the chemical environment.     

Performance of the density matrix functional theory in the quantum theory of atoms in molecules

The generalization to arbitrary molecular geometries of the energetic partitioning provided by the atomic virial theorem of the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) leads to an exact and chemically intuitive energy partitioning scheme, the interacting quantum atoms (IQA) approach, that depends on the availability of second-order reduced density matrices (2-RDMs). This work explores the performance of this approach in particular and of the QTAIM in general with approximate 2-RDMs obtained from the density matrix functional theory (DMFT), which rests on the natural expansion (natural orbitals and their corresponding occupation numbers) of the first-order reduced density matrix (1-RDM). A number of these functionals have been implemented in the promolden code and used to perform QTAIM and IQA analyses on several representative molecules and model chemical reactions. Total energies, covalent intra- and interbasin exchange-correlation interactions, as well as localization and delocalization indices have been determined with these functionals from 1-RDMs obtained at different levels of theory. Results are compared to the values computed from the exact 2-RDMs, whenever possible.     

Can QTAIM topological parameters be a measure of hydrogen bonding strength?

The block-localized wave function (BLW) method, which is the simplest variant of ab initio valence bond (VB) theory, together with the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) approach, have been used to probe the intramolecular hydrogen bonding interactions in a series of representative systems of resonance-assisted hydrogen bonds (RAHBs). RAHB is characteristic of the cooperativity between the π-electron delocalization and hydrogen bonding interactions and is identified in many biological systems. While the deactivation of the π resonance in these RAHB systems by the use of the BLW method is expected to considerably weaken the hydrogen bonding strength, little change on the topological properties of electron densities at hydrogen bond critical points (HBCPs) is observed. This raises a question of whether the QTAIM topological parameters can be an effective measure of hydrogen bond strength.     

A bond path and an attractive Ehrenfest force do not necessarily indicate bonding interactions: case study on M2X2 (M = Li, Na, K; X = H, OH, F, Cl)

Interactions in dimers of model alkali metal derivatives M(2)X(2) (M = Li or Na or K; X = H or F, Cl, OH) are studied in the frame of the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) using the interacting quantum atoms approach (IQA). Contrary to opinion prevalent in QTAIM studies, the interaction between two anions linked by a bond path is demonstrated to be strongly repulsive. One may therefore say that a bond path does not necessarily indicate bonding interactions. The interactions between two anions or two cations that are not linked by a bond path are also strongly repulsive. The repulsive anion-anion and cation-cation interactions are outweighed by much stronger attractive anion-cation interactions, and the model molecules are therefore in a stable state. The attractive Ehrenfest forces (calculated in the frame of the QTAIM) acting across interatomic surfaces shared by anions in the dimers do not reflect the repulsive interactions between anions. Probable reasons of this disagreement are discussed. The force exerted on the nucleus and the electrons of a particular atom by the nucleus and the electrons of any another atom in question is proposed. It is assumed that this force unambiguously exposes whether basins of two atoms are attracted or repelled by each other in a polyatomic molecule.     

Toward a Consistent Interpretation of the QTAIM: Tortuous Link between Chemical Bonds,Interactions, and Bond/Line Paths

Currently, bonding analysis of molecules based on the Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules (QTAIM) is popular; however, “misinterpretations” of the QTAIM analysis are also very frequent. In this contribution the chemical relevance of the bond path as one of the key topological entities emerging from the QTAIM’s topological analysis of the one‐electron density is reconsidered. The role of nuclear vibrations on the topological analysis is investigated demonstrating that the bond paths are not indicators of chemical bonds. Also, it is argued that the detection of the bond paths is not necessary for the “interaction” to be present between two atoms in a molecule. The conceptual disentanglement of chemical bonds/interactions from the bonds paths, which are alternatively termed “line paths” in this contribution, dismisses many superficial inconsistencies. Such inconsistencies emerge from the presence/absence of the line paths in places of a molecule in which chemical intuition or alternative bonding analysis does not support the presence/absence of a chemical bond. Moreover, computational QTAIM studies have been performed on some “problematic” molecules, which were considered previously by other authors, and the role of nuclear vibrations on presence/absence of the line paths is studied demonstrating that a bonding pattern consistent with other theoretical schemes appears after a careful QTAIM analysis and a new “interpretation” of data is performed.     

Stress tensor eigenvector following with next-generation quantum theory of atoms in molecules

The eigenvectors of the electronic stress tensor have been identified as useful for the prediction of chemical reactivity because they determine the most preferred directions to move the bonds. A new 3–D vector based interpretation of the chemical bond that we refer to as the bond-path framework set B provides a version of the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) beyond the minimum definition for bonding that is particularly suitable for understanding changes in molecular electronic structure that occur during reactions. We demonstrate that the most preferred direction for bond motion using the stress tensor corresponds to the most compressible direction and not to the least compressible direction as previously reported. We show the necessity for a directional approach constructed using the eigenvectors along the entire bond-length and demonstrate the insufficiency of scalar measures for capturing the nature of the stress tensor within the QTAIM partitioning.     

Theoretical investigation on charge‐assisted halogen bonding interactions in the complexes of bromocarbons with some anions

A series of dimeric complexes formed between bromocarbon molecules and two anions (Br^? and CN^?) have been investigated by using MP2 method. The quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) and the second‐order perturbation natural bond orbital (NBO) approaches were applied to analyze the electron density distributions of these complexes and to explore the nature of charge‐assisted halogen bonding interactions. As anticipated, these interactions are significantly stronger relative to the corresponding neutral ones. The results derived from ab initio calculations described herein reveal a major contribution from the electrostatic interaction on the stability of the systems considered. Beside the electrostatic interaction, the charge‐transfer force and the second‐order orbital interaction also play an important role in the formation of the complexes, as a NBO analysis suggested. The presence of halogen bonds in the complexes has been identified in terms of the QTAIM methodology, and several linear relationships have been established to provide more insight into charge‐assisted halogen bonding interactions. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2008     

QTAIM characteristics of halogen bond and related interactions

Different types of noncovalent interactions such as, for example, halogen bond, hydrogen bond, and dihalogen bond are analyzed. The analysis is based on ab initio calculations which were performed on complexes of the F(3)CCl molecule. This choice is connected with the features of the Cl atom which may act as the Lewis acid and also as the Lewis base center. Such a dual role is a consequence of the existence of negative and positive regions of the electrostatic potential of the Cl center. Hence, the F(3)CCl molecule forms complexes linked by various interactions. The formation of the complexes leads to the electron charge redistribution which is reflected in the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) characteristics. Numerous correlations and tendencies were found here between QTAIM, geometrical and energetic parameters. It was found that the mechanism of the formation of complexes linked through various interactions is generally the same as that known for the hydrogen bond formation. The dependencies and QTAIM characteristics considered here are in agreement with Bent's rule.