Towards a native environment: structure and function of membrane proteins in lipid bilayers by NMR

Solid-state NMR (ssNMR) is a versatile technique that can be used for the characterization of various materials, ranging from small molecules to biological samples, including membrane proteins. ssNMR can probe both the structure and dynamics of membrane proteins, revealing protein function in a near-native lipid bilayer environment. The main limitation of the method is spectral resolution and sensitivity, however recent developments in ssNMR hardware, including the commercialization of 28 T magnets (1.2 GHz proton frequency) and ultrafast MAS spinning (<100 kHz) promise to accelerate acquisition, while reducing sample requirement, both of which are critical to membrane protein studies. Here, we review recent advances in ssNMR methodology used for structure determination of membrane proteins in native and mimetic environments, as well as the study of protein functions such as protein dynamics, and interactions with ligands, lipids and cholesterol.

Solid-state NMR (ssNMR) is a versatile technique that can be used for the characterization of various materials, ranging from small molecules to biological samples, including membrane proteins, as reviewed here.     

Novel zwitterionic reverse micelles for encapsulation of proteins in low-viscosity media

Large proteins remain inaccessible to structural NMR studies because of their unfavorable relaxation properties. Their solubilization in the aqueous core of reverse micelles, in a low-viscosity medium, represents a promising approach, provided that their native tertiary structure is maintained. However, the use of classical ionic surfactants may lead to protein unfolding, due to strong electrostatic interactions between the polar head groups and the protein charges. To design reverse micelles in which these interactions are weakened, a new zwitterionic surfactant molecule was synthesized and studied by high-resolution NMR spectroscopy, for which cytochrome C and 15N-labeled ubiquitin were used as guest candidates. At different ionization states, both proteins are encapsulated in the absence of salts or other additives, in a folded conformation similar to the native one.     

Protein-surfactant interaction: differences between fluorinated and hydrogenated surfactants

The interactions of proteins with fluorinated/hydrogenated surfactants were investigated by circular dichroism and turbidity measurement. Pairs of fluorinated and hydrogenated surfactants with similar critical micelle concentrations (cmc), including sodium perfluorooctanoate/sodium decylsulfate and lithium perfluorononanoate/sodium dodecylsulfate were compared in view of their interactions with proteins including BSA, lysozyme, β-lactoglobulin and ubiquitin. It was found that fluorinated surfactants exhibited stronger interactions with proteins than hydrogenated ones, which, however, depended on the structures of both proteins and surfactant molecules. If the proteins are very stable, or the surfactant–protein interactions are very strong, such differences between the two kinds of surfactants might be indistinguishable.     

Direct observation of ligand binding to membrane proteins in living cells by a saturation transfer double difference (STDD) NMR spectroscopy method shows a significantly higher affinity of integrin alpha(IIb)beta3 in native platelets than in liposomes

About 30% of the proteins in mammalian systems are membrane bound or integrated (e.g., GPCRs). It is inherently difficult to investigate receptor-ligand interactions on a molecular level in their natural membrane environment. Here, we present a new method based on saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR to characterize at an atomic level binding interactions of cell surface proteins in living cells. Implemented as a double difference technique, STD NMR allows the direct observation of binding events and the definition of the binding epitopes of ligands. The binding of the pentapeptide cyclo(RGDfV) to the surface glycoprotein integrin alpha(IIb)beta3 of intact human blood platelets can be detected by saturation transfer double difference (STDD) NMR in less than an hour. A 5-fold higher STD response reflects a significantly higher affinity of integrin alpha(IIb)beta3 in native platelets than in liposomes, which demonstrates the importance of studying membrane proteins in their natural environment. Also, the binding mode of cyclo(RGDfV) in the arginine glycine region is slightly different when interacting with native integrin in platelets compared to integrin reintegrated into liposomes.     

Conformational Flexibility in the Transmembrane Protein TSPO

The translocator protein (TSPO) is an integral membrane protein that interacts with a wide variety of endogenous ligands, such as cholesterol and porphyrins, and is also the target for several small molecules with substantial in vivo efficacy. When complexed with the TSPO‐specific radioligand (R)‐PK11195, TSPO folds into a rigid five‐helix bundle. However, little is known about the structure and dynamics of TSPO in the absence of high‐affinity ligands. By means of NMR spectroscopy, we show that TSPO exchanges between multiple conformations in the absence of (R)‐PK11195. Extensive motions on time scales from pico‐ to microseconds occur all along the primary sequence of the protein, leading to a loss of stable tertiary interactions and local unfolding of the helical structure in the vicinity of the ligand‐binding site. The flexible nature of TSPO highlights the importance of conformational plasticity in integral membrane proteins.     

NMR and Molecular Genetics as Tools for Investigating Protein Interactions in Membrane Systems

In our laboratory, we have applied the tools of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and molecular genetics to investigate the structural and dynamic properties of membrane-associated proteins and their interactions with membrane components. There are two general classes of membrane proteins, i.e., intrinsic and peripheral ones. For the intrinsic membrane proteins, we have chosen the membranebound D-lactate dehydrogenase (D-LDH) of Escherichia coli as a model to study protein-lipid interactions in membranes. D-LDH is a respiratory enzyme of molecularweight 65, 000 containing flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) as a cofactor. The activity of purified D-LDH is enhanced up to 100-fold by lipids and detergents. The gene for D-LDH has been sequenced, and production of the enzyme amplified up to 300-times normal levels. We have biosynthetically incorporated 5-fluorotryptophan (5F-Trp) into D-LDH and studied the five Trp residues by ¹⁹F-NMR spectroscopy. In order to gain additional information using ¹⁹F-NMR, site-specific, oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis has been used to insert a sixth Trp into D-LDH at various positions throughout the 571-amino acid chain. These mutant D-LDHs are being characterized biochemically and through NMR. For peripheral membrane proteins, we have chosen two periplasmic binding proteins, histidine-binding protein J (J protein) of Salmonella Typhimurium and glutamine-binding protein (GlnBP) of E. coli as models to investigate the structure-function relationship in periplasmic binding protein-mediated active transport systems. These two proteins both have molecular weights of approximately 25, 000. By using mutant J proteins and GlnBPs and site-specific, oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis techniques, we have assigned several resonances to specific amino acid residues. We are investigating the relationship between ligand-induced conformational changes in these two proteins and their roles in the active transport of ligand across the cell membrane. We have found that a combination of isotopic labeling, biochemistry, molecular biology, and NMR is a very useful approach to investigate various interactions of membrane-associated protein systems.     

Solid-state NMR spectroscopy detects interactions between tryptophan residues of the E. coli sugar transporter GalP and the alpha-anomer of the D-glucose substrate

An experimental approach is described in which high resolution 13C solid-state NMR (SSNMR) spectroscopy has been used to detect interactions between specific residues of membrane-embedded transport proteins and weakly binding noncovalent ligands. This procedure has provided insight into the binding site for the substrate D-glucose in the Escherichia coli sugar transport protein GalP. Cross-polarization magic-angle spinning (CP-MAS) SSNMR spectra of GalP in its natural membrane at 4 degrees C indicated that the alpha- and beta-anomers of D-[1-(13)C]glucose were bound by GalP with equal affinity and underwent fast exchange between the free and bound environments. Further experiments confirmed that by lowering the measurement temperature to -10 degrees C, peaks could be detected selectively from the substrate when restrained within the binding site. Dipolar-assisted rotational resonance (DARR) SSNMR experiments at -10 degrees C showed a selective interaction between the alpha-anomer of D-[1-(13)C]glucose and 13C-labels within [13C]tryptophan-labeled GalP, which places the carbon atom at C-1 in the alpha-anomer of D-glucose to within 6 A of the carbonyl carbon of one or more tryptophan residues in the protein. No interaction was detected for the beta-isomer. The role of tryptophan residues in substrate binding was investigated further in CP-MAS experiments to detect D-[1-(13)C]glucose binding to the GalP mutants W371F and W395F before and after the addition of the inhibitor forskolin. The results suggest that both mutants bind D-glucose with similar affinities, but have different affinities for forskolin. This work highlights a useful general experimental strategy for probing the binding sites of membrane proteins, using methodology which overcomes the problems associated with the unfavorable dynamics of weak ligands.     

Structure, topology, and dynamics of membrane peptides and proteins from solid-state NMR spectroscopy

The high-resolution structure of membrane proteins is notoriously difficult to determine due to the hydrophobic nature of the protein-membrane complexes. Solid-state NMR spectroscopy is a unique and powerful atomic-resolution probe of the structure and dynamics of these important biological molecules. A number of new solid-state NMR methods for determining the depth of insertion, orientation, oligomeric structure, and long-range (10-15 A) distances of membrane proteins are summarized. Membrane protein depths can now be determined using several complementary techniques with varying site-specificity, distance precision, and mobility requirement on the protein. Membrane protein orientation can now be determined with or without macroscopic alignment, the latter providing a novel alternative for orientation determination of intrinsically curvature-inducing proteins. The novel analyses of beta-sheet membrane protein orientation are described. The quaternary structure of membrane peptide assemblies can now be elucidated using a 19F spin diffusion technique that simultaneously yields the oligomeric number and intermolecular distances up to 15 A. Finally, long-range distances up to approximately 10 A can now be measured using 1H spins with an accuracy of better than 1 A. These methods are demonstrated on several beta-sheet membrane peptides with antimicrobial activities and on two alpha-helical ion-channel proteins. Finally, we show that the nearly ubiquitous dynamics of membrane proteins can be readily examined using 2D correlation experiments. An intimate appreciation of molecular motion in these systems not only leads to important insights into the specific function of these membrane proteins but also may be exploited for other purposes such as orientation determination.     

NMR of membrane-associated peptides and proteins

In living cells, membrane proteins are essential to signal transduction, nutrient use, and energy exchange between the cell and environment. Due to challenges in protein expression, purification and crystallization, deposition of membrane protein structures in the Protein Data Bank lags far behind existing structures for soluble proteins. This review describes recent advances in solution NMR allowing the study of a select set of peripheral and integral membrane proteins. Surface-binding proteins discussed include amphitropic proteins, antimicrobial and anticancer peptides, the HIV-1 gp41 peptides, human alpha-synuclein and apolipoproteins. Also discussed are transmembrane proteins including bacterial outer membrane beta-barrel proteins and oligomeric alpha-helical proteins. These structural studies are possible due to solubilization of the proteins in membrane-mimetic constructs such as detergent micelles and bicelles. In addition to protein dynamics, protein-lipid interactions such as those between arginines and phosphatidylglycerols have been detected directly by NMR. These examples illustrate the unique role solution NMR spectroscopy plays in structural biology of membrane proteins.     

Characterization of heparin–protein interaction by saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR

The binding affinity and specificity of heparin to proteins is widely recognized to be sulfation-pattern dependent. However, for the majority of heparin-binding proteins (HBPs), it still remains unclear what moieties are involved in the specific binding interaction. Here, we report our study using saturation transfer difference (STD) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to map out the interactions of synthetic heparin oligosaccharides with HBPs, such as basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF2) and fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF10), to provide insight into the critical epitopes of heparin ligands involved. The irradiation frequency of STD NMR was carefully chosen to excite the methylene protons so that enhanced sensitivity was obtained for the heparin–protein complex. We believe this approach opens up additional application avenues to further investigate heparin–protein interactions.     

Surfactants – Compounds for inactivation of SARS-CoV-2 and other enveloped viruses

We provide here a general view on the interactions of surfactants with viruses, with a particular emphasis on how such interactions can be controlled and employed for inhibiting the infectivity of enveloped viruses, including coronaviruses. The aim is to provide to interested scientists from different fields, including chemistry, physics, biochemistry, and medicine, an overview of the basic properties of surfactants and (corona)viruses, which are relevant to understanding the interactions between the two. Various types of interactions between surfactant and virus are important, and they act on different components of a virus such as the lipid envelope, membrane (envelope) proteins and nucleocapsid proteins. Accordingly, this cannot be a detailed account of all relevant aspects but instead a summary that bridges between the different disciplines. We describe concepts and cover a selection of the relevant literature as an incentive for diving deeper into the relevant material. Our focus is on more recent developments around the COVID-19 pandemic caused by SARS-CoV-2, applications of surfactants against the virus, and on the potential future use of surfactants for pandemic relief. We also cover the most important aspects of the historical development of using surfactants in combatting virus infections. We conclude that surfactants are already playing very important roles in various directions of defence against viruses, either directly, as in disinfection, or as carrier components of drug delivery systems for prophylaxis or treatment. By designing tailor-made surfactants, and consequently, advanced formulations, one can expect more and more effective use of surfactants, either directly as antiviral compounds or as part of more complex formulations.     

Membrane protein–surfactant complexes

Transmembrane proteins expose to the surrounding membrane a belt of mainly hydrophobic amino acid residues, which makes them insoluble in water. Solubilizing them and handling them in vitro generally relies on the use of dissociating surfactants (detergents). Exposing membrane proteins to detergents, however, adversely affects their stability, which is a major hindrance in their study. After briefly recalling relevant aspects of membrane protein structure, the modus operandi of detergents and the problems they raise, we describe alternative approaches such as insertion into bicelles or lipid cubic phases, or association with non-detergent amphiphiles such as peptitergents, hemifluorinated surfactants and amphipols. These novel supramolecular assemblies offer a fascinating playground for collaborative studies between organic chemists, physical chemists and biologists, and they have spurred imaginative works in each of these fields.     

Nanodisc-solubilized membrane protein library reflects the membrane proteome

The isolation and identification of unknown membrane proteins offers the prospect of discovering new pharmaceutical targets and identifying key biochemical receptors. However, interactions between membrane protein targets and soluble ligands are difficult to study in vitro due to the insolubility of membrane proteins in non-detergent systems. Nanodiscs, nanoscale discoidal lipid bilayers encircled by a membrane scaffold protein belt, have proven to be an effective platform to solubilize membrane proteins and have been used to study a wide variety of purified membrane proteins. This report details the incorporation of an unbiased population of membrane proteins from Escherichia coli membranes into Nanodiscs. This solubilized membrane protein library (SMPL) forms a soluble in vitro model of the membrane proteome. Since Nanodiscs contain isolated proteins or small complexes, the SMPL is an ideal platform for interactomics studies and pull-down assays of membrane proteins. Sodium dodecyl sulfate–polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis of the protein population before and after formation of the Nanodisc library indicates that a large percentage of the proteins are incorporated into the library. Proteomic identification of several prominent bands demonstrates the successful incorporation of outer and inner membrane proteins into the Nanodisc library.

New reverse micelle surfactant systems optimized for high-resolution NMR spectroscopy of encapsulated proteins

Sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl)sulfosuccinate (AOT) is a surfactant commonly used to encapsulate water soluble proteins within the aqueous core of a reverse micelle. In the context of high-resolution NMR studies of encapsulated proteins the size of the resulting reverse micelle is critically important. We have designed and synthesized a short AOT analogue, 3,3-dimethyl-1-butylsulfosuccinate sodium salt and determined that it is able to form reverse micelles and to encapsulate the protein ubiquitin with high structural fidelity. AOT is often found to significantly destabilize encapsulated proteins, largely through charge-charge interactions between the anionic headgroup and the surface of the protein. Here we demonstrate, for the first time, that proportional mixtures of anionic and cationic surfactants can form reverse micelles that are also capable of protein encapsulation with high fidelity.     

Copper-metallomesogen structures obtained by ionic self-assembly (ISA): molecular electromechanical switching driven by cooperativity

In a stepwise noncovalent multiple-interaction strategy, copper(II) salts were complexed with the sodium salts of bathophenanthrolinedisulfonic acid (BPS) and bathocuproinedisulfonic acid (BCS), and organized into nanostructured materials by the addition of ammonium surfactants by means of the ionic self-assembly (ISA) route. In the case of the methyl-substituted BCS complexes, a slow color change from green to brick red was observed. UV and EPR investigations showed that the color change was due to a change in oxidation state, the resulting brick red color is typical for Cu(I) species. It is concluded that steric interactions and mechanical packing into a supramolecular structure drive this electronic transition at the metal center. When complexation is performed with double-tail ammonium surfactants, these metallomesogenic materials exhibit thermotropic liquid-crystalline phase behavior, as investigated by polarized light microscopy, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and temperature-dependent wide-angle and small-angle X-ray analyses. The complexity of the observed phases increased with increasing tail length of the surfactants. Complexation with double-tail C(18) surfactants yielded highly organized materials for both the BPS and BCS ligands.     

NMR Characterization of Surface Receptor Protein Interactions in Live Cells Using Methylcellulose Hydrogels

Interactions of transmembrane receptors with their extracellular ligands are essential for cellular communication and signaling and are therefore a major focus in drug discovery programs. The transition from in vitro to live cell interaction studies, however, is typically a bottleneck in many drug discovery projects due to the challenge of obtaining atomic‐resolution information under near‐physiological conditions. Although NMR spectroscopy is ideally suited to overcome this limitation, several experimental impairments are still present. Herein, we propose the use of methylcellulose hydrogels to study extracellular proteins and their interactions with plasma membrane receptors. This approach reduces cell sedimentation, prevents the internalization of membrane receptors, and increases cell survival, while retaining the free tumbling of extracellular proteins.     

Probing the Lipid Annular Belt by Gas‐Phase Dissociation of Membrane Proteins in Nanodiscs

Interactions between membrane proteins and lipids are often crucial for structure and function yet difficult to define because of their dynamic and heterogeneous nature. Here, we use mass spectrometry to demonstrate that membrane protein oligomers ejected from nanodiscs in the gas phase retain large numbers of lipid interactions. The complex mass spectra that result from gas‐phase dissociation were assigned using a Bayesian deconvolution algorithm together with mass defect analysis, allowing us to count individual lipid molecules bound to membrane proteins. Comparison of the lipid distributions measured by mass spectrometry with molecular dynamics simulations reveals that the distributions correspond to distinct lipid shells that vary according to the type of protein–lipid interactions. Our results demonstrate that nanodiscs offer the potential for native mass spectrometry to probe interactions between membrane proteins and the wider lipid environment.     

Monitoring the effects of antagonists on protein-protein interactions with NMR spectroscopy

We describe an NMR method that directly monitors the influence of ligands on protein-protein interactions. For a two-protein interaction complex, the size of one component should be small enough (less than ca. 15 kDa) to provide a good quality (15)N((13)C) HSQC spectrum after (15)N((13)C) labeling. The size of the second unlabeled component should be large enough so that the molecular weight of the preformed complex is larger than ca. 40 kDa. When the smaller protein binds to a larger one, broadening of NMR resonances results in the disappearance of most of its cross-peaks in the HSQC spectrum. Addition of an antagonist that can dissociate the complex would restore the HSQC spectrum of the smaller component. The method directly shows whether an antagonist releases proteins in their wild-type folded states or whether it induces their denaturation, partial unfolding, or precipitation. We illustrate the method by studying lead compounds that have recently been reported to block the MDM2-p53 interaction. Activation of p53 in tumor cells by inhibiting its interaction with MDM2 offers new strategy for cancer therapy.     

Mass Spectrometry Quantifies Protein Interactions—From Molecular Chaperones to Membrane Porins

Proteins possess an intimate relationship between their structure and function, with folded protein structures generating recognition motifs for the binding of ligands and other proteins. Mass spectrometry (MS) can provide information on a number of levels of protein structure, from the primary amino acid sequence to its three‐dimensional fold and quaternary interactions. Given that MS is a gas‐phase technique, with its foundations in analytical chemistry, it is perhaps counter‐intuitive to use it to study the structure and non‐covalent interactions of proteins that form in solution. Herein we show, however, that MS can go beyond simply preserving protein interactions in the gas phase by providing new insight into dynamic interaction networks, dissociation mechanisms, and the cooperativity of ligand binding. We consider potential pitfalls in data interpretation and place particular emphasis on recent studies that revealed quantitative information about dynamic protein interactions, in both soluble and membrane‐embedded assemblies.     

G Protein-coupled Receptor (GPCR) Reconstitution and Labeling for Solution Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Studies of the Structural Basis of Transmembrane Signaling

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are a large membrane protein family found in higher organisms, including the human body. GPCRs mediate cellular responses to diverse extracellular stimuli and thus control key physiological functions, which makes them important targets for drug design. Signaling by GPCRs is related to the structure and dynamics of these proteins, which are modulated by extrinsic ligands as well as by intracellular binding partners such as G proteins and arrestins. Here, we review some basics of using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy in solution for the characterization of GPCR conformations and intermolecular interactions that relate to transmembrane signaling.