Effect of temperature on the chromatographic retention of ionizable compounds. I. Methanol-water mobile phases

The retention mechanism of acids and bases in reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) has been experimentally studied by examining the temperature dependence of retention, with emphasis on the role of the buffer ionization equilibria in the retention and selectivity. Retention factors of several ionizable compounds in a typical octadecylsilica column and using buffers dissolved in 50% (w/w) methanol as eluents at three temperatures in the range of 25-50 degrees C were measured. Two pairs of buffer solutions were prepared by a close adjusting of their pH at 25 degrees C; differences in their ionization enthalpies determined a different degree of ionization when temperature was raised and, as a consequence, a different shift in the eluent pH. Predictive equations of retention that take into account the temperature effect on both the transfer and the ionization processes are proposed. This study demonstrates the significant role that the selected buffer would have in retention and selectivity in RPLC at temperatures higher than 25 degrees C, particularly for co-eluted solutes.     

Chromatographic properties of the ion-exclusion column IonPac ICE-AS6 and application in environmental analysis. Part I: Chromatographic properties

The chromatographic performance of the Dionex IonPac ICE-AS6 ion exclusion column is investigated. Therefore, capacity factors, efficiency, peak symmetry, resolution, and selectivity are determined for various mono- and polyfunctional aliphatic carboxylic acids under selected chromatographic conditions. Except for the stronger acids (pKa1 < 3.75), the highest chromatographic efficiency is achieved at a column temperature of 40 or 50 degrees C, and peak shape is found to be optimal at approximately 60 degrees C. The separation of the stronger acids is favored by an eluent pH below 3.0 and column temperatures below 40 degrees C. The maximal effective plate numbers range between 126 (tartronic acid) and 6380 (4-oxovaleric acid). Hydroxy-substituted acids are less retained and less influenced by temperature changes than the unsubstituted compounds. It is estimated that size exclusion effects take part in the separation of aldonic acids. The addition of 1% isopropanol to the acidic eluent increases the chromatographic efficiency generally, whereas higher concentrations reduce the retention of several acids drastically.     

Rationalisation of unusual changes in efficiency and retention with temperature shown for bases in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography at intermediate pH

Despite the possibility of poorer peak shapes, analysis of pharmaceuticals and other bases using reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) at intermediate pH gives useful increases in retention, selectivity and column loading capacity compared with low pH. Retention times of some bases showed anomalous increases with column temperature. Peak shapes for bases improved significantly at elevated temperature (up to 70 degrees C), with the weakest bases studied (pKa approximately 8) giving greater improvement than the strongest bases (pKa approximately 10). In contrast, quaternary ammonium compounds showed reduced retention with increasing column temperature (normal behaviour) and only modest improvements in peak shape. Considering these results, and pKa measurements of the bases made using capillary electrophoresis, it appears that increases in retention and improvement in efficiency may be influenced significantly by reduction in the pKa of bases with temperature, leading to reduction in protonation. It is less likely that efficiency improvements are due to the speeding up of the kinetics of silanol ion exchange, at least in the temperature range studied here.     

Effect of temperature on pH measurements and acid-base equilibria in methanol-water mixtures

The knowledge of the acid-base equilibria in water-solvent mixtures of both common buffers and analytes is necessary in order to predict their retention as function of pH, solvent composition and temperature. This paper describes the effect of temperature on acid-base equilibria in methanol-water solvent mixtures commonly used as HPLC mobile phases. We measured the delta-correction parameter (delta = sw pH - ss pH = Ej - log sw(gamma)oh) between two pH scales: pH measured in the solvent concerned and referred to the same standard state, ss pH, and the pH measured in that solvent mixture but referred to water as standard state, sw pH, for several methanol compositions in the temperature range of 20-50 degrees C. These determinations suggest that the delta-term depends only on composition of the mixture and on temperature. In water-rich mixtures, for which methanol is below 40% (w/w), delta-term seems to be independent of temperature, within the experimental uncertainties, whereas for methanol content larger than 50% (w/w) the delta-correction decreases as temperature increases. We have attributed this decrease to a large increase in the medium effect when mixtures have more than 50% methanol. The pKa of five weak electrolytes of different chemical nature in 50% methanol-water at 20-50 degrees C are presented: the effect of temperature on pKa was large for amines, pyridine and phenol, but almost no dependence was found for benzoic acid. This indicates that buffers can play a critical role in affecting retention and selectivity in HPLC at temperatures far from 25 degrees C, particularlyfor co-eluted solutes.     

Characterization of a microparticulate strong anion-exchanger in the HPLC of acidic drugs

The use of Waters Spherisorb S5SAX for the HPLC of acidic compounds, including a number of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), has been investigated. Adequate retention, separation, and peak efficiency and symmetry were obtained for most analytes on a 250 x 4.6 mm i.d. column using methanol containing ammonium perchlorate (10 mmol L(-1), pH 6.7 or pH 8.3) as eluent. The results of changes in (i) eluent pH (constant ionic strength); (ii) eluent ionic strength (constant pH); and (iii) adding water to the eluent (constant pH) were consistent with a retention mechanism dominated by ion-exchange with the bonded strong anion-exchange (SAX) moieties. However, there were some unexpected observations, including (i) a general decrease in retention at eluent pH values above 7.7; (ii) a marked increase in retention on adding 1% (v/v) water to the eluent; (iii) a subsequent marked decrease in retention on adding 5% (v/v) or more water; and (iv) decreased column activity with time. These observations may be due to (i) interaction between the charged SAX moieties and ionised surface silanols (with ionization increasing at higher eluent pH values) and (ii) influence of the solvation of silanols, analytes, SAX moiety, and counter-ion varying with both pH and water content. Nevertheless, the factors influencing separation of individual NSAIDs remain unclear especially as no relation between log k and pKa exists for these compounds. Hydrophobic interactions are unlikely to be important since basic and neutral compounds were hardly retained. Ease of accessibility of the counter-ion to the SAX moiety for analyte displacement may be a factor.     

High speed gradient elution reversed phase liquid chromatography of bases in buffered eluents. Part II. Full equilibrium

In this work we determined when the state of thermodynamic (full) equilibrium, i.e. time-invariate solute retention, was achieved in gradient elution reversed-phase chromatography. We investigated the effects of flow rate, temperature, organic modifier, buffer type/concentration, stationary phase type, n-butanol as eluent additive, and pore size. We also measured how selectivity varied with reequilibration time. Stationary phase wetting and the ability of the stationary phase to resist changes in pH strongly affect the time needed to reach full equilibrium. For example, full equilibrium is realized with many endcapped stationary phases after flushing with only two column volumes of acetonitrile-water containing 1% (v/v) n-butanol and 0.1% (v/v) trifluoroacetic acid. Trends in retention time (<0.010min) and selectivity become quite small after only five column volumes of reequilibration. We give practical guidelines that provide fast full equilibrium for basic compounds when chromatographed in buffered eluents.     

Effects of elevated temperature and mobile phase composition on a novel C18 silica column

A novel polydentate C18 silica column was evaluated at an elevated temperature under acidic, basic, and neutral mobile phase conditions using ACN and methanol as the mobile phase organic modifier. The temperature range was 40-200 degrees C. The mobile phase compositions were from 0 to 80% organic-aqueous v/v and the mobile phase pH levels were between 2 and 12. The maximum operating temperature of the column was affected by the amount and type of organic modifier used in the mobile phase. Under neutral conditions, the column showed good column thermal stability at temperatures ranging between 120 and 200 degrees C in methanol-water and ACN-water solvent systems. At pH 2 and 3, the column performed well up to about 160 degrees C at two fixed ACN-buffer compositions. Under basic conditions at elevated temperatures, the column material deteriorated more quickly, but still remained stable up to 100 degrees C at pH 9 and 60 degrees C at pH 10. The results of this study indicate that this novel C18 silica-based column represents a significant advancement in RPLC column technology with enhanced thermal and pH stability when compared to traditional bonded phase silica columns.     

Is hydrophilic interaction chromatography with silica columns a viable alternative to reversed-phase liquid chromatography for the analysis of ionisable compounds?

The separation of acidic, neutral and particularly basic solutes was investigated using a bare silica column, mostly under hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) conditions with water concentrations >2.5% and with >70% acetonitrile (ACN). Profound changes in selectivity could be obtained by judicious selection of the buffer and its pH. Acidic solutes had low retention or showed exclusion in ammonium formate buffers, but were strongly retained when using trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) buffers, possibly due to suppression of repulsion of the solute anions from ionised silanol groups at the low (s)(s)pH of TFA solutions of aqueous ACN. At high buffer pH, the ionisation of weak bases was suppressed, reducing ionic (and possibly hydrophilic retention) leading to further opportunities for manipulation of selectivity. Peak shapes of basic solutes were excellent in ammonium formate buffers, and overloading effects, which are a major problem for charged bases in RPLC, were relatively insignificant in analytical separations using this buffer. HILIC separations were ideal for fast analysis of ionised bases, due to the low viscosity of mobile phases with high ACN content, and the favourable Van Deemter curves which resulted from higher solute diffusivities.     

Comparison of zirconia- and silica-based reversed stationary phases for separation of enkephalins

In this study, the separation of biologically active peptides on two zirconia-based phases, polybutadiene (PBD)-ZrO2 and polystyrene (PS)-ZrO2, and a silica-based phase C18 was compared. Basic differences in interactions on both types of phases led to quite different selectivity. The retention characteristics were investigated in detail using a variety of organic modifiers, buffers, and temperatures. These parameters affected retention, separation efficiency, resolution and symmetry of peaks. Separation systems consisting of Discovery PBD-Zr column and mobile phase composed of a mixture of acetonitrile and phosphate buffer, pH 2.0 (45:55, v/v) at 70 degrees C and Discovery PS-Zr with acetonitrile and phosphate buffer, pH 3.5 in the same (v/v) ratio at 40 degrees C were suitable for a good resolution of enkephalin related peptides. Mobile phase composed of acetonitrile and phosphate buffer, pH 5.0 (22:78, v/v) was appropriate for separation of enkephalins on Supelcosil C18 stationary phase.     

Contributions to reversed-phase column selectivity. II. Cation exchange

The contribution of cation exchange to solute retention for type-B alkylsilica columns (made from high-purity silica) has been examined in terms of the hydrophobic-subtraction (H-S) model of reversed-phase column selectivity. The relative importance of cation exchange in the separation of ionized bases by reversed-phase chromatography (RPC) varies with (a) column acidity (values of the column cation-exchange capacity C), (b) mobile-phase pH and buffer concentration, and (c) the nature of the buffer cation. The effects of each of these separation variables on cation retention were examined. The contribution of cation exchange (and other ionic interactions) to solute retention is represented in the H-S model by properties of the solute (κ') and column (C), respectively. Values of κ' for 87 solutes have been examined as a function of solute molecular structure, and values of C for 167 type-B alkylsilica columns have been related to various column properties: ligand length (e.g., C(8) vs. C(18)) and concentration (μmol/m(2)), pore diameter (nm), and end-capping. These results contribute to a more detailed picture of the retention of cationic solutes in RPC as a function of separation conditions. While previous work suggests that the ionization of type-B alkylsilica columns is generally negligible with mobile-phase pH<7 (as a result of which cation exchange then becomes insignificant), the present study provides evidence for cation exchange (and presumably silanol ionization) at a pH as low as 3 for most columns.     

Separation of acidic compounds by strong anion-exchange capillary electrochromatography

Separation of the acidic compounds in the ion-exchange capillary electrochromatography (IE-CEC) with strong anion-exchange packing as the stationary phase was studied. It was observed that the electroosmotic flow (EOF) in strong anion-exchange CEC moderately changed with increase of the eluent ionic strength and decrease of the eluent pH, but the acetonitrile concentration in the eluent had almost no effect on the EOF. The EOF in strong anion-exchange CEC with eluent of low pH value was much larger than that in RP-CEC with Spherisorb-ODS as the stationary phase. The retention of acidic compounds on the strong anion-exchange packing was relatively weak due to only partial ionization of them, and both chromatographic and electrophoretic processes contributed to separation. It was observed that the retention values of acidic compounds decreased with the increase of phosphate buffer and acetonitrile concentration in the eluent as well as the decrease of the applied voltage, and even the acidic compounds could elute before the void time. These factors also made an important contribution to the separation selectivity for tested acidic compounds, which could be separated rapidly with high column efficiency of more than 220000 plates/m under the optimized separation conditions.     

Combined effect of solvent content, temperature and pH on the chromatographic behaviour of ionisable compounds

The organic solvent content and the pH in the mobile phase are the usual main factors in reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separations, owing to their strong effects on retention and/or selectivity. Temperature is often neglected. However, even in cases where the impact of this factor on selectivity is minor, the reduction in analysis time is still an interesting reason to consider it. In addition, ionisable compounds may exhibit selectivity changes, owing to the interaction of organic solvent and/or temperature with pH. The separation of ionisable compounds (nine diuretics: bendroflumethiazide, benzthiazide, bumetanide, chlorthalidone, furosemide, piretanide, probenecid, trichloromethiazide and xipamide, and two beta-blockers: oxprenolol and propranolol) exhibiting different acid-base behaviour was studied. The compounds were tested in a Zorbax SB C18 column under a wide range of conditions: 25-45% (v/v) acetonitrile, pH 3-7 and 20-50 degrees C. Models considering two factors (organic solvent/pH and temperature/pH), and three factors (organic solvent/temperature/pH) were developed from a previously reported equation, which considers the polarity contributions of solute, stationary and mobile phases. This allowed a comprehensive method to predict the retention of the 11 compounds, the modification of their acid-base behaviour (i.e. determination of protonation constants and shifts of the retention versus pH curves), and the selectivity changes within the studied factor ranges.     

High-performance liquid chromatographic analysis of basic drugs on silica columns using non-aqueous ionic eluents. I. Factors influencing retention, peak shape and detector response

The use of silica columns together with non-aqueous ionic eluents provides a stable yet flexible system for the high-performance liquid chromatographic analysis of basic drugs. At constant ionic strength, eluent pH influences retention via ionisation of surface silanols and protonation of basic analytes, pKa values indicating the pH of maximum retention. At constant pH, retention is proportional to the reciprocal of the eluent ionic strength for fully protonated analytes and quaternary ammonium compounds. The addition of water up to 10% (v/v) has little effect on retention if the protonation of the analytes is unaffected. Thus, it is likely that retention is mediated primarily via cation exchange with surface silanols. However, additional factors must play a part with compounds such as morphine which give tailing peaks at acidic or neutral eluent pHs.     

Superheated water as eluent in high-temperature high-performance liquid chromatographic separations of steroids on a polymer-coated zirconia column

High-temperature liquid chromatography (HTLC), with a superheated water mobile phase, has been shown to be a feasible replacement for medium-polarity acetonitrile-water mixtures as an eluent in reversed-phase HPLC. Instrumental parameters of flow-rate, injection volume and mobile phase preheating were shown to have significant effects on the quality of the chromatographic peaks. The selectivity and retention patterns of testosterone and several related compounds were investigated on a porous zirconia, polybutadiene-coated column at temperatures up to 200 degrees C and compared with that of a porous silica, octadecylsilane-coated column and the zirconia column under traditional reversed-phase conditions of an acetonitrile-water mobile phase at 40 degrees C. The selectivity differences observed for testosterone and related compounds show that the separation mechanisms are complementary and unique selectivity is obtained with the zirconia column under HTLC conditions.     

Analysis of selected withanolides in plant extract by capillary electrochromatography and microemulsion electrokinetic chromatography

Microemulsion electrokinetic chromatography (MEEKC) coupled with a diode-array detector was developed for the simultaneous analysis of natural steroidal compounds, withanolides including withaferin A, withacnistin and iochromolide. Optimal resolution was obtained with a microemulsion consisting of 70 mM octane, 800 mM 1-butanol, 100 mM sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), and 10 mM phosphate-borate buffer (pH 7) using a fused-silica capillary at 25 kV and 40 degrees C. Since this technique is not compatible with mass spectrometry detection, a capillary electrochromatographic method was developed to separate the investigated withanolides. The effects of mobile phase composition and pH were systematically investigated. Complete separation was obtained with a capillary electrochromatography (CEC) Hypersil C18 bonded silica column (packed length, 25 cmx100 microm ID and 375 microm OD), packed with 3 microm particles. The mobile phase consisted of formic acid-ammonia, pH 8 / acetonitrile (40/60 v/v); the voltage was set at 25 kV and the temperature at 20 degrees C. Under these conditions, resolution of these closely related compounds, including the critical pair withacnistin and iochromolide, was achieved in less than 5 min. The separations by MEEKC and CEC were compared with that obtained by reversed-phase liquid chromatography and showed similar retention order, indicating the analogy of the retention mechanism of these techniques. To further improve specificity and sensitivity, the developed CEC method was interfaced with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry using a Teflon connection between the CEC column and a void fused-silica capillary. Finally, the described methods were applied to the qualitative analysis of withanolides in Iochroma gesnerioides plant extract.     

Comparison of void volume, mobile phase volume and accessible volume determined from retention data for oligomers in reversed-phase liquid chromatographic systems

The experimental technique of mass spectrometric tracer pulse chromatography was used to determine the void volume, i.e., the total volume of eluent in the column, and the volume of eluent moving freely through the column, i.e., mobile phase volume, for a series of eluents with a C(18)-bonded RPLC column. The interstitial volume of the column was determined by size exclusion chromatography. In order to evaluate the utility of the accessible volumes determined from the retention volumes of homologous solutes, the accessible volume of the column was determined as a function of eluent composition and temperature with polystyrene and polyethylene glycol samples using Martin's Rule. Comparison of these four measured volumes indicated that the experimentally measured accessible volumes did not correspond to either the void volumes, mobile phase volumes or interstitial volumes.     

Effect of temperature on the chromatographic retention of ionizable compounds. III. Modeling retention of pharmaceuticals as a function of eluent pH and column temperature in RPLC

We propose a general simple equation for accurately predicting the retention factors of ionizable compounds upon simultaneous changes in mobile phase pH and column temperature at a given hydroorganic solvent composition. Only four independent experiments provide the input data: retention factors measured in two pH buffered mobile phases at extreme acidic and basic pH values (e. g., at least +/- 2 pH units far from the analyte pK(a)) and at two column temperatures. The equations, derived from the basic thermodynamics of the acid-base equilibria, additionally require the knowledge of the solute pK(a )and enthalpies of acid-base dissociation of both the solute and the buffer components in the hydroorganic solvent mixture. The performance of the predictive model is corroborated with the comparison between theoretical and experimental retention factors of several weak acids and bases of important pharmacological activity, in mobile phases containing different buffer solutions prepared in 25% w/w ACN in water and at several temperatures.     

Column selectivity in reversed-phase liquid chromatography II. Effect of a change in conditions

The isocratic retention of 67 widely-different solutes in reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RP-LC) has been investigated as a function of temperature and mobile phase composition (% B) for three different C18 columns. Similar studies were also carried out in a gradient mode, where temperature, gradient time and solvent type were varied. These results show that changes in retention with these conditions are similar for each of these three columns. This suggests that relative column selectivity as defined by experiments for one set of experimental conditions will be approximately applicable for other conditions, with the exception of changes in mobile phase pH-which can affect values of the column parameter C (a measure of silanol ionization). Column selectivity as a function of pH was explored for several columns.     

Separation of rutin nona(H-) and deca(H-) sulfonate sodium by ion-pairing reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Ion-pairing reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) was used to separate two polysulfonates, rutin nona(H-) sulfonate sodium and rutin deca(H-) sulfonate sodium, which have very similar chemical structures. The final product always contained both of them when one of the compounds was synthesized. Baseline separation was achieved on a C8-bonded silica column at ambient temperature. The eluent was acetonitrile-15 mM phosphate buffer solution containing 20 mM TBA (pH 6.0) (46:54, v/v). The calibration plot was linear in the concentration range 0.5-200 microg ml(-1) for both analytes. The limits of detection (LODs; 254 nm) were 0.03 microg ml(1-) for rutin nona(H-) sulfonate sodium and 0.04 microg ml(-1) for rutin deca(H-) sulfonate sodium. Three batches of rutin deca(H-) sulfonate sodium were analyzed using the assay; the results showed that the analytical performance is really satisfactory.     

Retention,enantioselectivity and enantiomeric elution order of propranolol and its ester derivatives on an alpha1-acid glycoprotein-bonded column

Summary The retention, enantionselectivity and enantiomeric elution order of racemic propranolol (PP) and its ester derivatives (O-acetyl,-propionyl,-butyrul and-valeryl PP) on an ₁-acid glycoprotein (AGP)-bonded column have been investigated by changing eluent composition (eluent pH, buffer concentration, type and content of organic modifier). The retention of these cationic solutes, PP and its ester derivatives, was influenced by eluent pH, ionic strength and organic modifier content. The enantioselectivity was dependent on eluent pH and type of organic modifier. Reversal of the enantiomeric elution order of ester derivatives of PP (O-propionyl-butyryl) and-valeryl PP) occurred around eluent pH 6–7. These results suggst that chiral recognition or binding properties may be altered by the change in eluent composition, espeically eluent pH and type of organic modifier.