Analysis of RF heating and sample stability in aligned static solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Sample instability during solid-state NMR experiments frequently arises due to RF heating in aligned samples of hydrated lipid bilayers. A new, simple approach for estimating sample temperature is used to show that, at 9.4 T, sample heating depends mostly on (1)H decoupling power rather than on (15)N irradiation in PISEMA experiments. Such heating for different sample preparations, including lipid composition, salt concentration and hydration level was assessed and the hydration level was found to be the primary parameter correlated with sample heating. The contribution to RF heating from the dielectric loss appears to be dominant under our experimental conditions. The heat generated by a single scan was approximately calculated from the Q values of the probe, to be a 1.7 degrees C elevation per single pulse sequence iteration under typical sample conditions. The steady-state sample temperature during PISEMA experiments can be estimated based on the method presented here, which correlates the loss factor with the temperature rise induced by the RF heating of the sample.     

Using low-E resonators to reduce RF heating in biological samples for static solid-state NMR up to 900 MHz

RF heating of solid-state biological samples is known to be a destabilizing factor in high-field NMR experiments that shortens the sample lifetime by continuous dehydration during the high-power cross-polarization and decoupling pulses. In this work, we describe specially designed, large volume, low-E 15N-1H solid-state NMR probes developed for 600 and 900 MHz PISEMA studies of dilute membrane proteins oriented in hydrated and dielectrically lossy lipid bilayers. The probes use an orthogonal coil design in which separate resonators pursue their own aims at the respective frequencies, resulting in a simplified and more efficient matching network. Sample heating at the 1H frequency is minimized by a loop-gap resonator which produces a homogeneous magnetic field B1 with low electric field E. Within the loop-gap resonator, a multi-turn solenoid closely matching the shape of the sample serves as an efficient observe coil. We compare power dissipation in a typical lossy bilayer sample in the new low-E probe and in a previously reported 15N-1H probe which uses a double-tuned 4-turn solenoid. RF loss in the sample is measured in each probe by observing changes in the 1H 360 degrees pulse lengths. For the same values of 1H B1 field, sample heating in the new probe was found to be smaller by an order of magnitude. Applications of the low-E design to the PISEMA study of membrane proteins in their native hydrated bilayer environment are demonstrated at 600 and 900 MHz.     

Sensitivity and resolution enhancement in solid-state NMR spectroscopy of bicelles

Magnetically aligned bicelles are becoming attractive model membranes to investigate the structure, dynamics, geometry, and interaction of membrane-associated peptides and proteins using solution- and solid-state NMR experiments. Recent studies have shown that bicelles are more suitable than mechanically aligned bilayers for multidimensional solid-state NMR experiments. In this work, we describe experimental aspects of the natural abundance (13)C and (14)N NMR spectroscopy of DMPC/DHPC bicelles. In particular, approaches to enhance the sensitivity and resolution and to quantify radio-frequency heating effects are presented. Sensitivity of (13)C detection using single pulse excitation, conventional cross-polarization (CP), ramp-CP, and NOE techniques are compared. Our results suggest that the proton decoupling efficiency of the FLOPSY pulse sequence is better than that of continuous wave decoupling, TPPM, SPINAL, and WALTZ sequences. A simple method of monitoring the water proton chemical shift is demonstrated for the measurement of sample temperature and calibration of the radio-frequency-induced heating in the sample. The possibility of using (14)N experiments on bicelles is also discussed.     

Reduction of RF-induced sample heating with a scroll coil resonator structure for solid-state NMR probes

Heating due to high power 1H decoupling limits the experimental lifetime of protein samples for solid-state NMR (SSNMR). Sample deterioration can be minimized by lowering the experimental salt concentration, temperature or decoupling fields; however, these approaches may compromise biological relevance and/or spectroscopic resolution and sensitivity. The desire to apply sophisticated multiple pulse experiments to proteins therefore motivates the development of probes that utilize the RF power more efficiently to generate a high ratio of magnetic to electric field in the sample. Here a novel scroll coil resonator structure is presented and compared to a traditional solenoid. The scroll coil is demonstrated to be more tolerant of high sample salt concentrations and cause less RF-induced sample heating. With it, the viable experimental lifetime of a microcrystalline ubiquitin sample has been extended by more than an order of magnitude. The higher B1 homogeneity and permissible decoupling fields enhance polarization transfer efficiency in 15N-13C correlation experiments employed for protein chemical shift assignments and structure determination.     

15N and 31P solid-state NMR study of transmembrane domain alignment of M2 protein of influenza A virus in hydrated cylindrical lipid bilayers confined to anodic aluminum oxide nanopores

This communication reports the first example of a high resolution solid-state 15N 2D PISEMA NMR spectrum of a transmembrane peptide aligned using hydrated cylindrical lipid bilayers formed inside nanoporous anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) substrates. The transmembrane domain SSDPLVVA(A-15N)SIIGILHLILWILDRL of M2 protein from influenza A virus was reconstituted in hydrated 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine bilayers that were macroscopically aligned by a conventional micro slide glass support or by the AAO nanoporous substrate. 15N and 31P NMR spectra demonstrate that both the phospholipids and the protein transmembrane domain are uniformly aligned in the nanopores. Importantly, nanoporous AAO substrates may offer several advantages for membrane protein alignment in solid-state NMR studies compared to conventional methods. Specifically, higher thermal conductivity of aluminum oxide is expected to suppress thermal gradients associated with inhomogeneous radio frequency heating. Another important advantage of the nanoporous AAO substrate is its excellent accessibility to the bilayer surface for exposure to solute molecules. Such high accessibility achieved through the substrate nanochannel network could facilitate a wide range of structure-function studies of membrane proteins by solid-state NMR.     

Melting temperature and enthalpy variations of phase change materials (PCMs): a differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) analysis

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) analysis is a standard thermal analysis technique used to determine the phase transition temperature, enthalpy, heat of fusion, specific heat and activation energy of phase change materials (PCMs). To determine the appropriate heating rate and sample mass, various DSC measurements were carried out using two kinds of PCMs, namely N-octadecane paraffin and calcium chloride hexahydrate. The variations in phase transition temperature, enthalpy, heat of fusion, specific heat and activation energy were observed within applicable heating rates and sample masses. It was found that the phase transition temperature range increased with increasing heating rate and sample mass; while the heat of fusion varied without any established pattern. The specific heat decreased with the increase of heating rate and sample mass. For accuracy purpose, it is recommended that for PCMs with high thermal conductivity (e.g. hydrated salt) the focus will be on heating rate rather than sample mass.     

Interference of homonuclear decoupling and exchange in the solid-state NMR of perfluorocyclohexane

We observe an interference between RF irradiation used for homonuclear decoupling of 19F and conformational exchange in the 13C spectrum of perfluorocyclohexane. We show that these effects can be readily reproduced in simulation, and characterise their dependence on the various NMR and experimental parameters. Their application to observing exchange rates on the kHz timescale is evaluated with respect to T(1rho) measurements and the connections between the two approaches established. The implications for experiments that use homonuclear decoupling of 1H to resolve 1J(CH)couplings in the solid-state are also evaluated in detail.     

Supercycled SW(f)-TPPM sequence for heteronuclear dipolar decoupling in solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance

The performance of a supercycled SW(f)-TPPM sequence for heteronuclear dipolar decoupling in solid-state NMR is analyzed here. The decoupling performance of this sequence with respect to experimental parameters, such as, the phase angle, proton offset and MAS frequency is studied. A comparison is made with two other commonly used decoupling schemes in solid-state NMR namely, SPINAL-64 and SW(f)-TPPM, on a sample of U-13C-labeled tyrosine. Our results show that supercycled SW(f)-TPPM performs better than the former sequences. Also, numerical spin dynamics studies are presented which support the experimentally observed efficiency in the decoupling.     

Complete Dipolar Decoupling ofC and Its Use in Two-Dimensional Double-Quantum Solid-State NMR for Determining Polymer Conformations

A multiple-pulse technique for complete dipolar decoupling of directly bonded¹³C-labeled sites is described. It achieves significant spectral simplifications in a recently introduced two-dimensional double-quantum solid-state NMR experiment for determining torsion angles. Both homonuclear and heteronuclear dipolar couplings are removed by combining a¹³C multiple-pulse sequence with continuous-wave irradiation on the protons. The¹³C sequence has a fundamental 10-pulse cycle which is a significantly modified magic-sandwich-echo sequence. The crucial heteronuclear decoupling is achieved by breaking the 360° “inner” pulses in the magic sandwich into 90° pulses and spacing them by¹H 360° pulse lengths. Spectral artifacts typical of multiple-pulse sequences are eliminated by phase shifts between cycles. In contrast to many other multiple-pulse decoupling sequences, the long window in the cycle is the dwell time and can be longer than the inverse dipolar coupling, which makes the sequence practical for direct detection even with long pulse ring-down times. A modification of the sequence to scale the chemical shift and increase the effective spectral width is also presented. The 1D and double-quantum 2D experiments are demonstrated on polyethylene with 4%¹³C–¹³C spin pairs. The potential of this approach for distinguishing segmental conformations is illustrated by spectral simulations of the two-dimensional ridge patterns that correlate double-quantum and single-quantum chemical-shift anisotropies.     

Real-time imaging of the spatial distribution of rf-heating in NMR samples during broadband decoupling

Continuous radio-frequency (rf) irradiation during decoupling and spin-lock periods in NMR pulse sequences may lead to undesired sample heating. Heat-sensitive samples can suffer damage from the sudden temperature rise which cannot be adequately compensated by the temperature control system. Moreover, as the heating is spatially inhomogeneous, higher temperature increases can arise locally than are indicated by the average increase detected by the temperature controller. In this work we present a technique that allows measurement of a real-time 2D-image of the temperature distribution inside an NMR sample during an experiment involving rf-heating. NMR imaging methods have previously been used to project the temperature distribution inside an NMR sample onto a single spatial axis or to acquire steady-state 2D- temperature distributions. The real-time 2D-temperature profiles obtained with our procedure provide much more detailed data. Our results show, that not only inhomogeneous heating but also inhomogeneous sample cooling contribute to the build-up of temperature gradients across the sample. The technique can be used to visualize rf-heating in order to protect sensitive samples and to experimentally test new coil geometries or to guide probehead design.     

Progress in correlation spectroscopy at ultra-fast magic-angle spinning: basic building blocks and complex experiments for the study of protein structure and dynamics

Recent progress in multi-dimensional solid-state NMR correlation spectroscopy at high static magnetic fields and ultra-fast magic-angle spinning is discussed. A focus of the review is on applications to protein resonance assignment and structure determination as well as on the characterization of protein dynamics in the solid state. First, the consequences of ultra-fast spinning on sensitivity and sample heating are considered. Recoupling and decoupling techniques at ultra-fast MAS are then presented, as well as more complex experiments assembled from these basic building blocks. Furthermore, we discuss new avenues in biomolecular solid-state NMR spectroscopy that become feasible in the ultra-fast spinning regime, such as sensitivity enhancement based on paramagnetic doping, and the prospect of direct proton detection.     

Sensitivity enhancement using paramagnetic relaxation in MAS solid-state NMR of perdeuterated proteins

Previously, Ishii et al., could show that chelated paramagnetic ions can be employed to significantly decrease the recycle delay of a MAS solid-state NMR experiment [N.P. Wickramasinghe, M. Kotecha, A. Samoson, J. Past, Y. Ishii, Sensitivity enhancement in C-13 solid-state NMR of protein microcrystals by use of paramagnetic metal ions for optimizing H-1 T-1 relaxation, J. Magn. Reson. 184 (2007) 350-356]. Application of the method is limited to very robust samples, for which sample stability is not compromised by RF induced heating. In addition, probe integrity might be perturbed in standard MAS PRE experiments due to the use of very short duty cycles. We show that these deleterious effects can be avoided if perdeuterated proteins are employed that have been re-crystallized from D(2)O:H(2)O=9:1 containing buffer solutions. The experiments are demonstrated using the SH3 domain of chicken alpha-spectrin as a model system. The labeling scheme allows to record proton detected (1)H, (15)N correlation spectra with very high resolution in the absence of heteronuclear dipolar decoupling. Cu-edta as a doping reagent yields a reduction of the recycle delay by up to a factor of 15. In particular, we find that the (1)H T(1) for the bulk H(N) magnetization is reduced from 4.4s to 0.3s if the Cu-edta concentration is increased from 0mM to 250 mM. Possible perturbations like chemical shift changes or line broadening due to the paramagnetic chelate complex are minimal. No degradation of our samples was observed in the course of the experiments.     

Applications of the Bloch–Siegert Shift in Solid-State Proton-Dipolar-Decoupled19F MAS NMR

In solid-state proton-dipolar-decoupled¹⁹F MAS NMR spectroscopy,¹⁹F chemical-shift data need to be corrected for the Bloch–Siegert shift. Assigning the single sharp¹⁹F resonance of 2-fluoroadamantane to its proton-coupled¹⁹F shift of −174.4 ppm results in chemical-shift referencing that is independent of the amplitude of the proton-decoupling field. The Bloch–Siegert shift is also a useful tool to characterize the amplitude and homogeneity of the proton-decoupling field,H_1H, and to monitor probe performance. Considerable inhomogeneity inH_1Halong the long axis of the right-cylinder sample rotor was detected. In our commercial 7 mm H– F MAS probe, the proton field strength,[formula], decreases to 25% of the maximum value across the usable sample volume. Measurement of the Bloch–Siegert shift revealed that the proton-decoupling field strength decreases during the first few scans of an acquisition. Reductions in the proton field strengths can exceed 10%, and they are explained by the heating of the RF coil circuitry which is caused by high-power proton decoupling. The extent of reduction in field amplitude is a function of the decoupling duty cycle. Losses in[formula]can be avoided by tuning the probe proton RF circuitry at the operating temperature of the probe, using the Bloch–Siegert shift as an optimization parameter.     

Heteronuclear decoupling interference during symmetry-based homonuclear recoupling in solid-state NMR

We examine the influence of continuous-wave heteronuclear decoupling on symmetry-based double-quantum homonuclear dipolar recoupling, using experimental measurements, numerical simulations, and average Hamiltonian theory. There are two distinct regimes in which the heteronuclear interference effects are minimized. The first regime utilizes a moderate homonuclear recoupling field and a strong heteronuclear decoupling field; the second regime utilizes a strong homonuclear recoupling field and a weak or absent heteronuclear decoupling field. The second regime is experimentally accessible at moderate or high magic-angle-spinning frequencies and is particularly relevant for many realistic applications of solid-state NMR recoupling experiments to organic or biological materials.     

In situ solid-state 1H NMR studies of hydration of the solid acid catalyst ZSM-5 in its ammonium form

Hydration of the ammonium form of the solid acid catalyst ZSM-5 is investigated by applying a technique that has been developed recently for carrying out in situ solid-state NMR studies of adsorption processes. From ¹H MAS NMR spectra recorded as a function of time and temperature during the hydration process, insights are established on the nature of the interaction between the adsorbed water molecules and the ammonium cations in the ZSM-5 material. The change in isotropic chemical shift for the ammonium cations is consistent with the formation of N–H?O hydrogen bonding with the water molecules. Studies of the adsorption of deuterated water, and dehydration of the hydrated material, are also reported.     

Heteronuclear spin decoupling in solid-state NMR under magic-angle sample spinning

Achieving high spectral resolution is an important prerequisite for the application of solid-state NMR to biological molecules. Higher spectral resolution allows to resolve a larger number of resonances and leads to higher sensitivity. Among other things, heteronuclear spin decoupling is one of the important factors which determine the resolution of a spectrum. The process of heteronuclear spin decoupling under magic-angle sample spinning is analyzed in detail. Continuous-wave RF irradiation leads only in a zeroth-order approximation to a full decoupling of heteronuclear spin systems in solids under magic-angle spinning (MAS). In a higher-order approximation, a cross-term between the dipolar-coupling tensor and the chemical-shielding tensor is reintroduced, providing a scaled coupling term between the heteronuclear spins. In strongly coupled spin systems this second-order recoupling term is partially averaged out by the proton spin-diffusion process, which leads to exchange-type narrowing of the line by proton spin flips. This process can be described by a spin-diffusion type superoperator, allowing the efficient simulation of strongly coupled spin systems under heteronuclear spin decoupling. Low-power continuous-wave decoupling at fast MAS frequencies offers an alternative to high-power irradiation by reversing the order of the averaging processes. At fast MAS frequencies low-power continuous-wave decoupling leads to significantly narrower lines than high-power continuous-wave decoupling while at the same time reducing the power dissipated in the sample by several orders of magnitude. The best decoupling is achieved by multiple-pulse sequences at high RF fields and under fast MAS. Two such sequences, two-pulse phase-modulated decoupling (TPPM) and X-inverse-X decoupling (XiX), are discussed and their properties analyzed and compared.     

The utility of phase alternated pulses for the measurement of dipolar couplings in 2D-SLF experiments

The measurement of hetero-nuclear dipolar coupling using two-dimensional separated local field (SLF-2D) NMR experiments is a powerful technique for the determination of the structure and dynamics of molecules in the solid state and in liquid crystals. However, the experiment is sensitive to a number of factors such as the Hartmann–Hahn match condition, proton frequency off-set and rf heating. It is shown here that by the use of phase alternated pulses during spin-exchange the effect of rf mismatch on the dipolar coupling measurement can be compensated over a wide range of off-sets. Phase alternation together with time and amplitude modulation has also been considered and incorporated into a pulse scheme that combines spin exchange with homonuclear spin decoupling based on magic sandwich sequence and named as SAMPI4. Such time and amplitude averaged nutation experiments use relatively low rf power and generate less sample heating. One of these schemes has been applied on liquid crystal samples and is observed to perform well and yield spectra with high resolution.     

Cross polarization, radio frequency field homogeneity, and circuit balancing in high field solid state NMR probes

Homogeneous radio frequency (RF) fields are important for sensitivity and efficiency of magnetization transfer in solid state NMR experiments. If the fields are inhomogeneous the cross polarization (CP) experiment transfers magnetization in only a thin slice of sample rather than throughout the entire volume. Asymmetric patterns have been observed in plots of the CP signal versus RF field mismatch for an 800 MHz solid-state NMR probe where each channel is resonated in a single-ended mode. A simple model of CP shows these patterns can be reproduced if the RF fields for the two nuclei are centered at different places in the coil. Experimental measurements using B1 field imaging, nutation arrays on extremely short NMR samples, and de-tuning experiments involving disks of copper incrementally moved through the coil support this model of spatially offset RF fields. We have found that resonating the high frequency channel in a double-ended or "balanced" mode can alleviate this field offset problem, and have implemented this in a three-channel solid state NMR probe of our own design.