Comparative analysis of prostate‐specific antigen by two‐dimensional gel electrophoresis and capillary electrophoresis

Serum levels of Prostate‐Specific Antigen (PSA) are not fully specific for prostate cancer (PCa) diagnosis and several efforts are focused on searching to improve PCa markers through the study of PSA subforms that could be cancer associated. We have previously reported by 2DE a decrease in the sialic acid content of PSA from PCa compared to benign prostatic hyperplasia patients based on the different proportion of the PSA spots. However, faster and more quantitative techniques, easier to automate than 2DE, are desirable. In this study, we examined the potential of CE for resolving PSA subforms in different samples and compared the results with those obtained by 2DE. We first fractionated by OFFGEL the subforms of PSA from seminal plasma according to their pI s and analyzed each separated fraction by 2DE and CE. We also analyzed PSA and high pI PSA, both from seminal plasma, and PSA from urine of a PCa patient. These samples with different PSA spots proportions by 2DE, due to different posttranslational modifications, also presented different CE profiles. This study shows that CE is a useful and complementary technique to 2DE for analyzing samples with different PSA subforms, which is of high clinical interest.     

Separation of DNA‐containing organelles from Toxoplasma gondii by CZE

Toxoplasma gondii and other members of the family Apicomplexa have two organelles, in addition to the nucleus, that contain DNA. Herein is reported the separation of the DNA‐carrying organelles from T. gondii tachyzoites, i.e. the mitochondrion and the apicoplast, by CZE. The cells were stained with SYTO9, a dye that exhibit fluorescence when interacting with double stranded nucleic acids (e.g. DNA) and disrupted by nitrogen cavitation. Following careful removal of the heavier cellular material, the remaining lysate was injected on a CE instrument and the DNA‐containing organelles were detected by LIF. The mitochondrion had longer migration time than the apicoplast, and the migration times were comparable in the replicates. This method should potentially also work for other members of the Apicomplexa including Plasmodium falciparum.     

Horizontal comparative fluorescence two‐dimensional gel electrophoresis for improved spot coordinate detection

Vertical comparative 2D fluorescence gel electrophoresis (CoFGE) has recently been shown to increase the reproducibility of coordinate assignment for protein spots, in particular in singular experiments, which cannot be investigated using DIGE. The method applies a standardized marker grid formed by a set of purified proteins to the sample proteome in a conglomerate of 1DE, 2DE, and DIGE. Here, improvements are demonstrated by transferring CoFGE to horizontal 2DE. These include the elimination of the protein modification by residual acrylamide monomer unavoidable in vertical CoFGE, reduced buffer volumes, and highly efficient laboratory procedures. Spot patterns are well defined and can be easily analyzed using commercially available warping algorithms. With horizontal CoFGE also a correction for changes in pI was introduced using a third fluorescent dye. Horizontal CoFGE holds high promises in comparative proteomics.     

The development of the DIGE system: 2D fluorescence difference gel analysis technology

Two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis is a powerful technique enabling simultaneous visualization of relatively large portions of the proteome. However, the well documented issues of variation and lack of sensitivity and quantitative capabilities of existing labeling reagents, has limited the use of this technique as a quantitative tool. Two-dimensional difference gel electrophoresis (2D DIGE) builds on this technique by adding a highly accurate quantitative dimension. 2D DIGE enables multiple protein extracts to be separated on the same 2D gel. This is made possible by labeling of each extract using spectrally resolvable, size and charge-matched fluorescent dyes known as CyDye DIGE fluors. 2D DIGE involves use of a reference sample, known as an internal standard, which comprises equal amounts of all biological samples in the experiment. Including the internal standard on each gel in the experiment with the individual biological samples means that the abundance of each protein spot on a gel can be measured relative (i.e. as a ratio) to its corresponding spot in the internal standard present on the same gel. Ettan DIGE is the system of technologies that has been optimized to fully benefit from the advantages provided by 2D DIGE.Cy, CyDye, DeCyder, Ettan, ImageMaster and Typhoon are trademarks of Amersham Biosciences Limited. Amersham and Amersham Biosciences are trademarks of Amersham plc.     

Characterization of bacterial lipid profiles by using rapid sample preparation and fast comprehensive two‐dimensional gas chromatography in combination with mass spectrometry

The bacteria fatty acid profile has been extensively studied for taxonomic classification purposes, since bacteria, in general, contain particular and rare fatty acids, compared with animal and plant tissues. As for any real‐world sample type, the development of rapid and reliable methods for (i) sample identification (in this case, bacterium type), and (ii) constituent identification (in this instance, the fatty acid profile) is desirable. In this research, a half‐an‐hour procedure, to analyze bacteria, was developed: a 2‐min one‐step sample preparation step was followed by a relatively fast comprehensive 2D GC‐MS separation (25 min). Furthermore, dedicated MS libraries were constructed for the identification of bacteria and fatty acids. Finally, data processing, only qualitative at this stage, was carried out with the support of a novel comprehensive 2D GC software.     

Comparative two‐dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D‐PAGE) of human milk to identify dysregulated proteins in breast cancer

Breast cancer (BC) remains a major cause of mortality, and early detection is considered important for reducing BC‐associated deaths. Early detection of BC is challenging in young women, due to the limitations of mammography on the dense breast tissue of young women. We recently reported results of a pilot proteomics study, using one‐dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (1D‐PAGE) and mass spectrometry (MS) to investigate differences in milk proteins from women with and without BC. Here, we applied two‐dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D‐PAGE) and MS to compare the protein pattern in milk from the breasts of a single woman who was diagnosed with BC in one breast 24 months after donating her milk. Statistically different gel spots were picked for protein digestion followed by nanoliquid chromatography tandem MS (nanoLC‐MS/MS) analysis. The upregulated proteins in BC versus control are alpha‐amylase, gelsolin isoform a precursor, alpha‐2‐glycoprotein 1 zinc isoform CRA_b partial, apoptosis‐inducing factor 2 and vitronectin. Several proteins were downregulated in the milk of the breast later diagnosed with cancer as compared to the milk from the healthy breast, including different isoforms of albumin, cholesterol esterase, different isoforms of lactoferrin, different proteins from the casein family and different isoforms of lysozyme. Results warrant further studies to determine the usefulness of these milk proteins for assessing risk and detecting occult disease. MS data is available via ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD009860.     

Influence of image‐analysis software on quantitation of two‐dimensional gel electrophoresis data

Image analysis of two‐dimensional gels is a crucial step in a proteomic workflow and has a direct impact on obtained qualitative and quantitative data. Since the analysis is a complex process and creates large data amounts, the use of a respective software is inevitable. There are only a few papers published addressing the issue of analysis‐based variance; therefore, our aim was to highlight the discrepancy of received results when different commercially available image‐tools are used for gel analysis especially in terms of comparability of the obtained outcome when the same digital image set is used. A set of six gels (three replicates per group) of real‐life samples was created and examined with two different versions of PD‐Quest (Bio‐Rad) (version 6.1 and its update version 8.0) and with an external image‐tool Delta 2D (Decodon) (version 3.6). Replicate groups were analyzed and compared with each other with regard to volume ratios of a group of significantly changed spots. The study points out significant variations among results depending on the software package used, underlining the importance of a careful investigation of post‐experimental processes to receive comparable and reliable results.     

Efficient extraction of proteins from recalcitrant plant tissue for subsequent analysis by two‐dimensional gel electrophoresis

Protein extraction for two‐dimensional electrophoresis from tissues of recalcitrant species is quite problematic and challenging due to the low protein content and high abundance of contaminants. Proteomics in Shorea robusta is scarcely conducted due to the lack of a suitable protein preparation procedure. To establish an effective protein extraction protocol suitable for two‐dimensional electrophoresis in Shorea robusta, four procedures (borate buffer/trichloroacetic acid extraction, organic solvent/trichloroacetic acid precipitation, sucrose/Tris/phenol, and organic solvent/phenol/sodium dodecyl sulfate) were evaluated. Following these, proteins were isolated from mature leaves and were analyzed for proteomics, and also for potential contaminants, widely reported to hinder proteomics. The borate buffer/trichloroacetic acid extraction had the lowest protein yield and did not result in any banding even in one‐dimensional electrophoresis. In contrast, organic solvent/phenol/sodium dodecyl sulfate extraction allowed the highest protein yield. Moreover, during proteomics, organic solvent/phenol/sodium dodecyl sulfate extracted protein resolved the maximum number (144) of spots. Further, when proteins were evaluated for contaminants, significant (77–95%) reductions in the nucleic acids, phenol, and sugars were discernible with refinement in extraction procedure. Accumulated data suggested that the organic solvent/phenol/sodium dodecyl sulfate extraction was the most effective protocol for protein isolation for proteomics of Shorea robusta and can be used for plants that have a similar set of contaminants.     

Evaluation of different two‐dimensional chromatographic techniques for proteomic analysis of mouse cardiac tissue

In proteomics experiments the first critical step after sampling is certainly sample preparation. Multidimensional chromatography techniques have emerged as a powerful tool for the large‐scale analysis of such complex samples as biological samples. In order to evaluate these separation techniques, microgram quantities of protein extracted from mouse heart tissue were fractionated by four different chromatographic methods. Regarding peptide‐level fractionation, the first dimension of separation was performed with high‐pH reversed‐phase chromatography (pH‐RP) and strong cation exchange chromatography (SCX). Regarding protein‐level fractionation, C₈ protein reversed‐phase (C₈‐RP Prot) and high‐recovery protein reversed‐phase (hr‐RP Prot) were used instead. The second dimension consisted of a reversed‐phase nano‐HPLC on‐Chip coupled to an electrospray ionization quadrupole time‐of‐flight mass spectrometer for tandem mass spectrometric analysis. The performance and relative fractionation efficiencies of each technique were assessed by comparing the total number of proteins identified by each method. The peptide‐level pH‐RP and the hr‐RP Prot protein‐level separations were the best methods, identifying 1338 and 1303 proteins, respectively. The peptide‐level SCX, with 509 proteins identified, was the worst method. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

An optimized method to extract poplar leaf proteins for two‐dimensional gel electrophoresis guided by analysis of polysaccharides and phenolic compounds

Commonly used methods for protein extraction from plant leaves, such as extraction with phenol or a combination of trichloroacetic acid and acetone, were ineffective for four tested cultivars of poplar. Moreover, multiple protocols for 2DE of the extracted proteins gave different results when protein profiles of relatively closely related plants were compared. Given that polycyclic compounds strongly hinder 2DE, we analyzed the impact of polyphenols and polysaccharides present in the plant tissues used for protein extraction, on the quality of 2DE protein profiles. Analysis of content of polyphenols and polysaccharides in leaves of poplar cultivars showed that even small differences in concentrations of analyzed metabolites accompany large differences between poplar cultivars when considering the susceptibility of samples to protein extraction for 2DE. High‐quality 2DE results were correlated with decreased amounts of polyphenols. Additional analysis using MS/MS suggested that only levels of total phenolics affected the results of 2DE. Soluble total nonstructural carbohydrates also had a negative effect, but the level of starch was not important. Finally, we present an optimized method for extraction of proteins from poplar leaves, which enables reliable comparative analysis of four different poplar cultivars, that is, “Eridano,” “Villafranca,” “NE‐42,” and “Luisa Avanzo,” which have not yet been used for the proteomic studies.     

Comparative proteomic analysis of B. cenocepacia using two-dimensional liquid separations coupled with mass spectrometry

Burkholderia cenocepacia is an important respiratory pathogen in persons with cystic fibrosis. We compared the proteomes of clinical and environmental isolates of B. cenocepacia by using a 2D liquid separation method coupled with mass spectrometry. Proteome maps of four B. cenocepacia isolates were generated. In the first dimension, 5 mg of protein from each isolate was fractionated by chromatofocusing (CF) in the range of pH 4.0-7.0. In the second dimension, each CF fraction was separated by NPS-RP-HPLC. Results of the 2D liquid separation were visualized as 2D UV maps, which allowed direct comparison of proteomes with high resolution and reproducibility. From the proteomic comparison of the four isolates, 38 of 96 differentially abundant proteins were identified by peptide mass fingerprinting and MS/MS sequence analysis using a partially annotated B. cenocepacia protein database. Many of the identified proteins in the clinical isolates are involved in gene translation and bacterial virulence such as transmissibility, resistance, and quorum sensing.     

Metabolic profiling for the identification of Huntington biomarkers by on‐line solid‐phase extraction capillary electrophoresis mass spectrometry combined with advanced data analysis tools

In this work, an untargeted metabolomic approach based on sensitive analysis by on‐line solid‐phase extraction capillary electrophoresis mass spectrometry (SPE‐CE‐MS) in combination with multivariate data analysis is proposed as an efficient method for the identification of biomarkers of Huntington's disease (HD) progression in plasma. For this purpose, plasma samples from wild‐type (wt) and HD (R6/1) mice of different ages (8, 12, and 30 weeks), were analyzed by C₁₈‐SPE‐CE‐MS in order to obtain the characteristic electrophoretic profiles of low molecular mass compounds. Then, multivariate curve resolution alternating least squares (MCR‐ALS) was applied to the multiple full scan MS datasets. This strategy permitted the resolution of a large number of metabolites being characterized by their electrophoretic peaks and their corresponding mass spectra. A total number of 29 compounds were relevant to discriminate between wt and HD plasma samples, as well as to follow‐up the HD progression. The intracellular signaling was found to be the most affected metabolic pathway in HD mice after 12 weeks of birth, when mice already showed motor coordination deficiencies and cognitive decline. This fact agreed with the atrophy and dysfunction of specific neurons, loss of several types of receptors, and changed expression of neurotransmitters.     

Effect of sialic acid content on glycoprotein pI analyzed by two‐dimensional electrophoresis

2‐DE is broadly used for quantitative analysis of differential protein expression in complex mixtures such as serum samples or cell lysates. PTMs directly influence the 2‐DE pattern, and knowledge of the rules of protein separation is required in order to understand the protein distribution in a 2‐DE gel. Glycosylation is the most common PTM and can modify both the molecular weight and the pI of a protein. In particular, the effect of charged monosaccharides (mainly sialic acids, SAs) on the 2‐DE pattern of a protein is of major interest since changes in sialylation are regularly observed in comparative studies. Little is known about the pI shift of a glycoprotein induced by the presence of SAs, or whether this shift is the same for all glycoproteins. To address this issue, this study examined the influence of SA on the 2‐DE pattern of three serum glycoproteins (haptoglobin, α1‐antitrypsin and ribonuclease 1), which N‐glycan chains had been previously characterised, and reviewed existing bibliographic data. The SA content of the different glycoforms of a glycoprotein showed a negative linear correlation with the pI, although the slope varied among the studied glycoproteins. We also described a positive correlation between the protein pI and the pI decrease per SA molecule.     

Improvements in protein identification confidence and proteome coverage for human liver proteome study by coupling a parallel mass spectrometry/mass spectrometry analysis with multi-dimensional chromatography separation

Recently, matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) technique has been shown to be complementary to electrospray ionization (ESI) with respect to the population of peptides and proteins that can be detected. In this study, we tried to hyphenate MALDI-TOF-TOF-MS and ESI-QUADRUPOLE-TOF-MS with a single 2D liquid chromatography for complicated protein sample analysis. The effluents of RPLC were split into two parts for the parallel MS/MS detection. After optimizing the operation conditions in LC separation and MS identification, a total of 1149 proteins were identified from the global lysate of normal human liver (NHL) tissue. Compared to the single MS/MS detection, the combined analysis increased the number of proteins identified (more than 25%) and enhanced the protein identification confidence. Proteins identified were categorized and analyzed based upon their cellular location, biological process and molecular function. The identification results demonstrated the application potential of a parallel MS/MS analysis coupled with multi-dimensional LC separation for complicated protein sample identification, especially for proteome analysis, such as human tissues or cells extracts.     

Development of a rapid and improved two‐dimensional electrophoresis method for the separation of protein lysate

Researchers frequently use two‐dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D‐PAGE) prior to mass spectrometric analysis in a proteomics approach. The i2D‐PAGE method, which ‘inverts’ the dimension of protein separation of the conventional 2D‐PAGE, is presented in this publication. Protein lysate of Channa striata, a freshwater snakehead fish, was separated based on its molecular weight in the first dimension and its isoelectric point in the second dimension. The first‐dimension separation was conducted on a gel‐free separation device, and the protein mixture was fractionated into 12 fractions in chronological order of increasing molecular weight. The second‐dimension separation featured isoelectric focusing, which further separated the proteins within the same fraction according to their respective isoelectric point. Advantages of i2D‐PAGE include better visualisation of the isolated protein, easy identification on protein isoforms, shorter running time, customisability and reproducibility. Erythropoietin standard was applied to i2D‐PAGE to show its effectiveness for separating protein isoforms. Various staining methods such as Coomassie blue staining and silver staining are also applicable to i2D‐PAGE. Overall, the i2D‐PAGE separation method effectively separates protein lysate and is suitable for application in proteomics research.     

Extended characterization of a vacuum gas oil by offline LC‐high‐temperature comprehensive two‐dimensional gas chromatography

In a context of environmental preservation, purification and conversion of heavy petroleum cuts into high‐quality fuel becomes essential. The interest for the characterization of those very complex matrices becomes a trendy analytical challenge, when it comes to get molecular information for the optimization of industrial processes. Among new analytical techniques, high‐temperature 2‐D GC has recently proved its applicability to heavy petroleum matrices, but lacks in selectivity to separate all chemical groups. To gain resolution, heart cutting is demonstrated for LC separation of saturated, aromatic and polar compounds prior to high‐temperature 2‐D GC. Therefore, an extended global resolution was obtained, especially by a better distinction of saturated compounds. This includes iso‐paraffins and biomarker polynaphthenic structures, which are impossible to quantify with MS methods. This new way to analyze heavy petroleum fractions gives innovative opportunities for the construction of global weight distributions by carbon atoms number and by chemical families. This can right now be employed for quantitative analysis of heavy petroleum fractions and for studying conversion processes.     

Comparison of hydrodynamically closed two‐dimensional capillary electrophoresis coupled with ultraviolet detection and hydrodynamically open capillary electrophoresis hyphenated with mass spectrometry in the bioanalysis of varenicline

Two capillary electrophoresis methods for monitoring renally excreted varenicline, a highly effective drug prescribed for smoking cessation, in human urine were developed and compared. A method combining capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry was proposed for the fast analysis of varenicline (analysis time up to 7 min). Here, mass spectrometry was a prerequisite for achieving high sensitivity and selectivity of the analysis suitable for the quantification of a 15 ng/mL level of varenicline in un‐pretreated urine matrices. An alternative approach, two‐dimensional (column‐coupled) capillary electrophoresis with enhanced sample load capacity and ultraviolet detection, was proposed as a low‐cost alternative to capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry. The isotachophoresis on‐line sample treatment included simple elimination of the major matrix constituents and stacking of the sample in a large volume so that threefold lower quantitation limits could be easily achieved in comparison to the capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry. On the other hand, longer analysis time (ca. 4.5‐fold) and more complex electrolyte system in the coupled zone electrophoresis step (including two additives enhancing separation selectivity, i.e. isopropanol and cyclodextrin) were prerequisites for the complete separation of varenicline from the sample matrix. Anyway, both the developed methods were validated according to the Food and Drug Administration guidelines showing favorable performance parameters, suitable for their routine biomedical use.     

Comprehensive two‐dimensional GC for the analysis of low‐molecular‐weight oxygenates in three different matrices from a petrochemical pilot plant using a single calibration

A method using comprehensive ²DGC with flame ionisation detection was developed to quantify 17 low‐molecular‐weight oxygenates in three different matrices, namely water, oil and gas, using a single calibration. The method was required for the pilot‐plant experiments of a chemical process unit. From an analytical perspective, the first task was to find a suitable analytical method with sufficient selectivity and sensitivity to analyse the selected oxygenates at low levels in the presence of high levels of hydrocarbons. The second was the accurate quantitation of oxygenates in the water, oil and gas fractions, using the same instrument and calibration. Both these requirements were met by using comprehensive ²DGC in the inverse configuration and calibrating the detector with the number of moles injected versus response. The method was successfully applied for the characterisation of the reactor product stream of the chemical process unit and made it possible to determine the fate of the selected oxygenates after passing through the reactor. The development of the method and some of the results are described in this paper.