Synthesis and stereochemical assignment of DNA spore photoproduct analogues

Investigation of the DNA repair process performed by the spore photoproduct (SP) lyase repair enzyme is strongly hampered by the lack of defined substrates needed for detailed enzymatic studies. The problem is particularly severe because the repair enzyme belongs to the class of strongly oxygen-sensitive radical (S)-adenosylmethionine (SAM) enzymes, which are notoriously difficult to handle. We report the synthesis of the spore photoproduct analogues 1 a and 1 b, which have open backbones and are diastereoisomers. In order to solve the problem of stereochemical assignment, two further derivatives 2 a and 2 b with closed backbones were prepared. The key step of the synthesis of 2 a/b is a metathesis-based macrocyclization that strongly increases the conformational rigidity of the synthetic spore photoproduct derivatives. NOESY experiments of the cyclic isomers furnished a clear cross-peak pattern that allowed the unequivocal assignment of the stereochemistry. The results were transferred to the data for isomers 1 a and 1 b, which were subsequently used for enzymatic-repair studies. These studies were performed with the novel spore photoproduct lyase repair enzyme from Geobacillus stearothermophilus. The studies showed an accordance with a recent investigation performed by us with the spore photoproduct lyase from Bacillus subtilis, in that only the S isomer 1 a is recognized and repaired. The ability to prepare a defined functioning substrate now paves the way for detailed enzymatic studies of the SP-lyase lesion recognition and repair process.     

DNA Repair by the Radical SAM Enzyme Spore Photoproduct Lyase: From Biochemistry to Structural Investigations

Radical S‐adenosyl‐L‐methionine (SAM) enzymes have emerged as one of the last superfamilies of enzymes discovered to date. Arguably, it is the most versatile group of enzymes involved in at least 85 biochemical transformations. One of the founding members of this enzyme superfamily is the spore photoproduct (SP) lyase, a DNA repair enzyme catalyzing the direct reversal repair of a unique DNA lesion, the so‐called spore photoproduct, back into two thymidine residues. Discovered more than 20 years ago in the bacterium Bacillus subtilis, SP lyase has been shown to be widespread in the endospore‐forming Firmicutes from the Bacilli and Clostridia classes and to use radical‐based chemistry to perform C‐C bond breakage, a chemically challenging reaction. This review describes how the work on SP lyase has illuminated a unique strategy for DNA repair and provided major advances in our understanding of the emerging radical SAM superfamily of enzymes, from a biochemical and structural perspective.     

Probing the reaction mechanism of spore photoproduct lyase (SPL) via diastereoselectively labeled dinucleotide SP TpT substrates

5-Thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine (commonly called spore photoproduct or SP) is the exclusive DNA photodamage product in bacterial endospores. It is generated in the bacterial sporulation phase and repaired by a radical SAM enzyme, spore photoproduct lyase (SPL), at the early germination phase. SPL utilizes a special [4Fe-4S] cluster to reductively cleave S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) to generate a reactive 5'-dA radical. The 5'-dA radical is proposed to abstract one of the two H-atoms at the C6 carbon of SP to initiate the repair process. Via organic synthesis and DNA photochemistry, we selectively labeled the 6-H(proS) or 6-H(proR) position with a deuterium in a dinucleotide SP TpT substrate. Monitoring the deuterium migration in enzyme catalysis (employing Bacillus subtilis SPL) revealed that it is the 6-H(proR) atom of SP that is abstracted by the 5'-dA radical. Surprisingly, the abstracted deuterium was not returned to the resulting TpT after enzymatic catalysis; an H-atom from the aqueous buffer was incorporated into TpT instead. This result questions the currently hypothesized SPL mechanism which excludes the involvement of protein residue(s) in SPL reaction, suggesting that some protein residue(s), which is capable of exchanging a proton with the aqueous buffer, is involved in the enzyme catalysis. Moreover, evidence has been obtained for a possible SAM regeneration after each catalytic cycle; however, such a regeneration process is more complex than currently thought, with one or even more protein residues involved as well. These observations have enabled us to propose a modified reaction mechanism for this intriguing DNA repair enzyme.     

Mechanistic studies on the repair of a novel DNA photolesion: the spore photoproduct

[formula: see text] UV irradiation of spores results in the formation of the spore photoproduct. This novel DNA photolesion is repaired in the germinating spore in a reaction catalyzed by the spore photoproduct lyase. Model studies, using a simple bispyrimidine, suggest that this repair reaction proceeds by hydrogen abstraction from C6 of the spore photoproduct followed by beta-scission of the bond linking the two pyrimidines and back hydrogen atom transfer.     

The spore photoproduct lyase repairs the 5S- and not the 5R-configured spore photoproduct DNA lesion

The spore photoproduct lyase is a Fe-S/AdoMet DNA repair enzyme, which directly repairs spore lesions, induced by UV irradiation of spores, using an unknown radical mechanism. The air sensitive radical SAM enzyme was for the first time challenged with synthetically pure substrates. It was found that the enzyme recognizes a synthetic 5S-configured spore lesion without the central phosphodiester bond. The 5R-configured lesion is in contrast to current belief not a substrate.     

Characterization of the DNA repair spore photoproduct lyase enzyme from Clostridium acetobutylicum: A radical-SAM enzyme

Spore photoproduct lyase (SPL) is a “Radical-SAM” repair enzyme which catalyzes the cleavage of spore photoproduct (SP, 5-thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine), a specific lesion found in bacterial spore DNA, to thymine monomers by a free-radical mechanism. The enzyme requires S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) and a [4Fe–4S] cluster for activity. SPL from Bacillus subtilis has been difficult to isolate and characterize due to problems with the solubility and stability of the overexpressed protein in Escherichia coli and the lability of the [Fe–S] cluster, even if the protein was purified under strictly anaerobic conditions. In order to overcome these problems we searched for another SPL enzyme and we found that the recombinant SPL enzyme from Clostridium acetobutylicum, isolated either aerobically or anaerobically from overexpressing E. coli, behaves more stably than the B. subtilis one. We report here a complete spectroscopic and biochemical characterization of this enzyme. In particular we show for the first time that, using HYSCORE spectroscopy, SAM binds to the cluster as observed in the case of other members of the “Radical-SAM” enzyme family such as the activases of pyruvate formate lyase and ribonucleotide reductase.     

Chemical synthesis, crystal structure and enzymatic evaluation of a dinucleotide spore photoproduct analogue containing a formacetal linker

Spore photoproduct (SP) is the exclusive DNA photodamage product found in bacterial endospores. Its photoformation and repair by a metalloenzyme spore photoproduct lyase (SPL) composes the unique SP biochemistry. Despite the fact that the SP was discovered almost 50 years ago, its crystal structure is still unknown and the lack of structural information greatly hinders the study of SP biochemistry. Employing a formacetal linker and organic synthesis, we successfully prepared a dinucleotide SP isostere 5R-CH(2) SP, which contains a neutral CH(2) moiety between the two thymine residues instead of a phosphate. The neutral linker dramatically facilitates the crystallization process, allowing us to obtain the crystal structure for this intriguing thymine dimer half a century after its discovery. Further ROESY spectroscopic, DFT computational, and enzymatic studies of this 5R-CH(2) SP compound prove that it possesses similar properties with the 5R-SP species, suggesting that the revealed structure truly reflects that of SP generated in Nature.     

Direct H atom abstraction from spore photoproduct C-6 initiates DNA repair in the reaction catalyzed by spore photoproduct lyase: evidence for a reversibly generated adenosyl radical intermediate

Spore photoproduct (SP) lyase, which catalyzes the direct reversal of SP (5-thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine) to thymine monomers, is the only identified nonphotoactivatable pyrimidine dimer lyase. Unlike DNA photolyase, SP lyase does not contain a flavin cofactor and does not require light for activation. Instead, preliminary studies point to the presence of an iron-sulfur cluster in SP lyase and the requirement for S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet) for catalytic activity, suggesting that SP lyase belongs to the growing group of iron-sulfur cluster and AdoMet-dependent radical enzymes. Here we provide evidence for the role of AdoMet as a reversible deoxyadenosyl radical generator, which initiates repair by hydrogen atom abstraction from C-6 of SP. Reaction of 6-(3)H-SP, but not methyl-(3)H-SP, with SP lyase and AdoMet results in transfer of (3)H to AdoMet, while no tritiated 5'-deoxyadenosine is observed. When 5'-tritiated AdoMet is used in the reaction with unlabeled SP, transfer of (3)H into the repaired thymine monomers is observed. These results point to the reversible generation of a 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical intermediate, which reacts directly with the DNA lesion to initiate a radical-mediated beta-scission. We also demonstrate that AdoMet is a catalytic cofactor that is not consumed during turnover. Together, these results support a novel radical-based mechanism for the repair of UV-induced DNA damage.     

Effects of the binding of alpha/beta-type small, acid-soluble spore proteins on the photochemistry of DNA in spores of Bacillus subtilis and in vitro

The main lesion produced in DNA by UV-C irradiation of spores of Bacillus subtilis is 5-thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine (spore photoproduct [SP]). In contrast, cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) and pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone photoproducts (6-4PP) are the main photolesions in other cell types. The novel photochemistry of spore DNA is accounted for in part by its reduced hydration, but largely by the saturation of spore DNA with alpha/beta-type small, acid-soluble spore proteins (SASP). Using high-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis of the photoproducts, we showed that in wild-type B. subtilis spores (1) UV-C irradiation generates almost exclusively SP with little if any CPD and 6-4PP; (2) the SP generated is approximately 99% of the intrastrand derivative, but approximately 1% is in the interstrand form; and (3) there is no detectable formation of the SP analog between adjacent C and T residues. UV-C irradiation of spores lacking the majority of their alpha/beta-type SASP gave less SP than with wild-type spores and significant levels of CPD and 6-4PP. The binding of an alpha/beta-type SASP to isolated DNA either in dry films or in aqueous solution led to a large decrease in the yield of CPD and 6-4PP, and a concomitant increase in the yield of SP, although levels of interstrand photoproducts were extremely low.     

Photochemistry and Photobiology of the Spore Photoproduct: A 50‐Year Journey

Fifty years ago, a new thymine dimer was discovered as the dominant DNA photolesion in UV‐irradiated bacterial spores [Donnellan, J. E. & Setlow R. B. (1965) Science, 149, 308–310], which was later named the spore photoproduct (SP). Formation of SP is due to the unique environment in the spore core that features low hydration levels favoring an A‐DNA conformation, high levels of calcium dipicolinate that acts as a photosensitizer, and DNA saturation with small, acid‐soluble proteins that alters DNA structure and reduces side reactions. In vitro studies reveal that any of these factors alone can promote SP formation; however, SP formation is usually accompanied by the production of other DNA photolesions. Therefore, the nearly exclusive SP formation in spores is due to the combined effects of these three factors. Spore photoproduct photoreaction is proved to occur via a unique H‐atom transfer mechanism between the two involved thymine residues. Successful incorporation of SP into an oligonucleotide has been achieved via organic synthesis, which enables structural studies that reveal minor conformational changes in the SP‐containing DNA. Here, we review the progress on SP photochemistry and photobiology in the past 50 years, which indicates a very rich SP photobiology that may exist beyond endospores.     

Synthesis and properties of DNA containing a spore photoproduct analog

The spore photoproduct is a unique photolesion, formed in spores upon irradiation with UV light; to investigate the properties of spore photoproduct containing DNA we have synthesized 5S and 5R lesion analogs and incorporated them into DNA.     

THE BIOLOGY OF THE (6–4) PHOTOPRODUCT

The (6-4) photoproduct is an important determinant of the lethal and mutagenic effects of UV irradiation of biological systems. The removal of this lesion appears to correlate closely with the early DNA repair responses of mammalian cells, including DNA incision events, repair synthesis and removal of replication blocks. The processing of (6-4) photoproducts and cyclobutane dimers appears to be enzymatically coupled in bacteria and most mammalian cell lines examined (i.e. a mutation affecting the repair of one lesion also often affects the other), although exceptions exist in which repair capacity may be evident for one photoproduct and not the other (e.g. UV61 and the XP revertant cell line). These differences in the processing of the two photoproducts in some cell lines of human and rodent origin suggest that in mammalian cells, different pathways for the repair of (6-4) photoproducts and cyclobutane dimers may be used. This observation is further supported by pleiotropic repair phenotypes such as those observed in CHO complementation class 2 mutants (e.g., UV5, UVL-1, UVL-13, and V-H1). Indirect data, from HCR of UV irradiated reported genes and the cytotoxic responses of UV61, suggest that the (6-4) photoproduct is cytotoxic in mammalian cells and may account for 20 to 30% of the cell killing after UV irradiation of rodent cells. Cytotoxicity of the (6-4) photoproduct may be important in the etiology of sunlight-induced carcinogenesis, affecting mutagenesis as well as tumorigenesis. The intricate photochemistry of the (6-4) photoproduct, its formation and photoisomerization, is in itself extremely interesting and may also be relevant to sunlight carcinogenesis. The data reviewed in this article support the notion that the (6-4) photoproduct and its Dewar photoisomer are important cytotoxic determinants of UV light. The idea that the (6-4) photoproduct is an important component in the spectrum of UV-induced cytotoxic damage may help clarify our understanding of why rodent cells survive the effects of UV irradiation as well as human cells, without apparent cyclobutane dimer repair in the bulk of their DNA. The preferential repair of cyclobutane dimers in essential genes has been proposed to account for this observation (Bohr et al., 1985, 1986; Mellon et al., 1986). The data reviewed here suggest that understanding the repair of a prominent type of noncyclobutane dimer damage, the (6-4) photoproduct, may also be important in resolving this paradox.     

Neutral histidine and photoinduced electron transfer in DNA photolyases

The two major UV-induced DNA lesions, the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) and (6-4) pyrimidine-pyrimidone photoproducts, can be repaired by the light-activated enzymes CPD and (6-4) photolyases, respectively. It is a long-standing question how the two classes of photolyases with alike molecular structure are capable of reversing the two chemically different DNA photoproducts. In both photolyases the repair reaction is initiated by photoinduced electron transfer from the hydroquinone-anion part of the flavin adenine dinucleotide (FADH(-)) cofactor to the photoproduct. Here, the state-of-the-art XMCQDPT2-CASSCF approach was employed to compute the excitation spectra of the respective active site models. It is found that protonation of His365 in the presence of the hydroquinone-anion electron donor causes spontaneous, as opposed to photoinduced, coupled proton and electron transfer to the (6-4) photoproduct. The resulting neutralized biradical, containing the neutral semiquinone and the N3'-protonated (6-4) photoproduct neutral radical, corresponds to the lowest energy electronic ground-state minimum. The high electron affinity of the N3'-protonated (6-4) photoproduct underlines this finding. Thus, it is anticipated that the (6-4) photoproduct repair is assisted by His365 in its neutral form, which is in contrast to the repair mechanisms proposed in the literature. The repair via hydroxyl group transfer assisted by neutral His365 is considered. The repair involves the 5'base radical anion of the (6-4) photoproduct which in terms of electronic structure is similar to the CPD radical anion. A unified model of the CPD and (6-4) photoproduct repair is proposed.     

RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SURVIVAL, PHOTOPRODUCT PRODUCTION AND REPAIR CAPACITY IN A VARIANT OF BACILLUS CEREUS

Abstract —As sporulation progresses, there is an increased resistance to UV irradiation of the cells of Bacillus cereus var. alesti. This progressive increase is independent of post-irradiation treatment and appears to be a property of the stage of sporulation. In addition, the proportion of photoproducts formed is different for each stage of sporulation. Cells irradiated at Stage I (axial filament) of sporulation display relatively large amounts of spore photoproduct 'c' and less of photoproduct 'b'. As sporulation proceeds, UV irradiation results in the production of more spore photoproduct 'b' and less 'c', suggesting a progressive change in configuration of the DNA within the sporulating cell. If irradiated early in the process (Stage II), large amounts of cyclobutane-type dimers are also produced which, with the 'spore-specific' photoproducts, may be retained in the resultant spore. Although no excision-repair was detectable during germination of these spores, both vegetative and 'spore-specific' damage is reduced during this period. The 'spore-specific' repair mechanism may be able to remove vegetative damage from germinating spores.     

Crystal Structure of the T(6‐4)C Lesion in Complex with a (6‐4) DNA Photolyase and Repair of UV‐Induced (6‐4) and Dewar Photolesions

UV‐light irradiation induces the formation of highly mutagenic lesions in DNA, such as cis‐syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD photoproducts), pyrimidine(6‐4)pyrimidone photoproducts ((6‐4) photoproducts) and their Dewar valence isomers ((Dew) photoproducts). Here we describe the synthesis of defined DNA strands containing these lesions by direct irradiation. We show that all lesions are efficiently repaired except for the T(Dew)T lesion, which cannot be cleaved by the repair enzyme under our conditions. A crystal structure of a T(6‐4)C lesion containing DNA duplex in complex with the (6‐4) photolyase from Drosophila melanogaster provides insight into the molecular recognition event of a cytosine derived photolesion for the first time. In light of the previously postulated repair mechanism, which involves rearrangement of the (6‐4) lesions into strained four‐membered ring repair intermediates, it is surprising that the not rearranged T(6‐4)C lesion is observed in the active site. The structure, therefore, provides additional support for the newly postulated repair mechanism that avoids this rearrangement step and argues for a direct electron injection into the lesion as the first step of the repair reaction performed by (6‐4) DNA photolyases.     

VARIATION IN THE PHOTOCHEMICAL REACTIVITY OF THYMINE IN THE DNA OF B. SUBTILIS SPORES, VEGETATIVE CELLS AND SPORES GERMINATED IN CHLORAMPHENICOL*,†

Abstract— The chief photoproduct of thymine produced in u.v. irradiated (2537Å) vegetative cells of B. subtilis is the cyclobutane-type dimer while in spores very little of this dimer is produced (maximum yield 2·6 per cent of thymine) but a new photoproduct is produced in high yield (maximum of 28·4 per cent of thymine). This difference in photochemical response appears to be due, at least in part, to a difference in uydration of the DNA. The photochemistry of thymine in isolated DNA irradiated in solution is similar to that of DNA in irradiated vegetative cells, but differs markedly from that of isolated DNA irradiated dry. The yield of cyclobutane-type thymine dimer is much reduced in isolated DNA irradiated dry but a new photoproduct of thymine. is produced which is chromatographically similar to the spore photoproduct. The yield of this photoproduct, however, is never as great as that obtained in irradiated spores. The photochemistry of the DNA thymine of spores germinated in the presence of chloramphenicol is very similar to that of normal vegetative cells. Except for hydration, the physical state of the DNA is probably not otherwise altered by germination in the presence of chloramphenicol since DNA replication is prevented by the presence of chloramphenicol. These results are also consistent with the hypothesis that the unique photochemistry of spores is due, at least in part, to the hydration state of the DNA. The acid stability of the spore photoproduct is indicated by the fact that it is isolated from irradiated spores after hydrolysis in trifluoroacetic acid at 155°C for 60 min. It still contains the methyl group of thymine as judged by the fact that for a given dose of u.v. the same yield of photoproduct was obtained whether the spores were labeled with thymine-2–C-14 or -methyl-C-14. This photoproduct is stable to reirradiation (2537Å) in solution under condiditions where thymine dimers of the cyclobutane-type are completely converted back to monomeric thymine. On a column of molecular sieve material (Sephadex-G10), the spore photoproduct elutes in a region intermediate between the cyclobutanetype thymine dimers and monomeric thymine. Of the numerous compounds tested by paper chromatography, the spore photoproduct is most similar (but not identical) in several solvents to 5–hydroxyuracil and 5–hydroxymethyluracil. Our data do not allow us to decide if the product is a monomer or a dimer. Although the photochemistry of thymine in the DNA of spores differs markedly from that for vegetative cells, several lines of evidence make it seem doubtful that the enhanced resistance of spores to u.v. relative to that of vegetative cells can be explained solely on the basis of this difference in the photochemistry of DNA thymine.     

ESTIMATION OF PHOTOPRODUCT FORMATION IN GERMINATING SPORES OF BACILLUS SUBTILIS

Abstract— Changes in UV sensitivity during spore germination of Bacillus subtilis mutants possessing various defects in DNA repair capacities were analysed in order to estimate the yield of the DNA photoproducts at the transient, UV resistant stage which occurs in the process of germination. It was concluded that the yield of the spore-specific photoproduct (5-thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine, TDHT) at the transient stage was only about 3% of that in dormant spores and the yield of the cyclobutane-type pyrimidine dimers at this stage was about 10% (or less) of that in germinated spores.     

Electrospray-mass spectrometry characterization and measurement of far-UV-induced thymine photoproducts

Far-UV-induced formation of dimeric pyrimidine photoproducts within DNA is a major cause of the carcinogenic effects of solar light. The chemical structure of this class of lesion has been mostly determined by studies on model compounds. The present work is aimed at providing mass spectrometry data on the thymine-thymine photoproducts, including the diastereoisomers of the cyclobutane dimer, the (6-4) adduct, the related Dewar valence isomer and the spore photoproduct. Fragmentation mass spectra of the modified bases, nucleosides, dinucleoside monophosphates and dinucleotides were recorded following electrospray ionization with either triple-quadrupolar or ion-trap detection. The results showed differences in fragmentation pattern between the different types of photoproducts. In addition, a drastic effect of the diastereoisometry was observed for the cyclobutane dimers. A sensitive detection technique has been developed for the analysis of dinucleoside monophosphate photoproducts by high-performance liquid chromatography associated with mass spectrometry in the negative mode with multiple reaction-monitoring detection.     

Interspecific variation in UV defense mechanisms among temperate freshwater fishes

An important step in predicting the effects of future increases in UV radiation (UVR) is to evaluate the mechanisms that organisms use to prevent and repair DNA damage and determine how those mechanisms influence UVR sensitivity. Damage is prevented to varying degrees through photoprotection and repaired via two main pathways: nucleotide excision repair and photoenzymatic repair. At present, little is known about the generality or similarity of these defenses among temperate freshwater fishes. We used laboratory experiments to compare UVR defense mechanisms among five freshwater fish species representing four families and three orders. Purified DNA, freeze-killed larvae and live larvae were exposed to UVB radiation for 12 h in the presence or absence of photorepair radiation. After exposure, we quantified frequencies of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in each exposure treatment. All five species used photoprotection and proportional decreases in dimer frequency were similar for all species. Evidence of excision repair was also found for all species but proportional decreases in photoproduct frequencies varied among species. Finally, evidence of photoenzymatic repair was found for only two of the five species.     

A comparative repair study of thymine- and uracil-photodimers with model compounds and a photolyase repair enzyme

Cyclobutane uridine and thymidine dimers with cis-syn-structure are DNA lesions, which are efficiently repaired in many species by DNA photolyases. The essential step of the repair reaction is a light driven electron transfer from a reduced FAD cofactor (FADH ) to the dimer lesion, which splits spontaneously into the monomers. Repair studies with UV-light damaged DNA revealed significant rate differences for the various dimer lesions. In particular the effect of the almost eclipsed positioned methyl groups at the thymidine cyclobutane dimer moiety on the splitting rates is unknown. In order to investigate the cleavage vulnerability of thymine and uracil cyclobutane photodimers outside the protein environment, two model compounds, containing a thymine or a uracil dimer and a covalently connected flavin, were prepared and comparatively investigated. Cleavage investigations under internal competition conditions revealed, in contrast to all previous findings, faster repair of the sterically less encumbered uracil dimer. Stereoelectronic effects are offered as a possible explanation. Ab initio calculations and X-ray crystal structure data reveal a different cyclobutane ring pucker of the uracil dimer, which leads to a better overlap of the pi*-C(4)-O(4)-orbital with the sigma*-C(5)-C(5')-orbital. Enzymatic studies with a DNA photolyase (A. nidulans) and oligonucleotides, which contain either a uridine or a thymidine dimer analogue, showed comparable repair efficiencies for both dimer lesions. Under internal competition conditions significantly faster repair of uridine dimers is observed.