Estimation of the uncertainty of mass measurements from in-house calibrated analytical balances

The uncertainty evaluation of mass measurements when using “in-house” calibrated analytical balances is revisited according to the Guide to the expression of Uncertainty Measurement (GUM). The calibration of analytical balances is discussed according to the guidelines of several bodies such as ASTM, UKAS and DKD/PTB. The remainder components of uncertainty can be estimated from the balance data sheet specifications.     

The traceability of analytical measurements

 Traceability to the System International (SI) is an important prerequisite for international comparability and uniformity of chemical measurements to ensure mutual recognition of the results. In theory, all measurements can be traced back to the seven base units of the SI. Although the traceability system works well for most physical measurements, in many analytical and in some spectrophotometric measurements this system is not satisfactory. This paper describes the particular and practical problems and the contribution of the Romanian National Institute of Metrology in this field. The paper discusses the following concepts: clearly defined targets in the form of requirement specification, knowledge of trueness and/or measurement uncertainty, and traceability through an unbroken chain of calibration to primary standards. Traceability and uncertainty being two concepts inherently coupled, two examples of assessment of the uncertainty of measurement results are given for two spectrophotometric methods currently used in chemical laboratories. Received: 17 July 1996 Accepted: 2 September 1996     

The effects of mass accuracy,data acquisition speed,and search algorithm choice on peptide identification rates in phosphoproteomics

Proteomic analyses via tandem mass spectrometry have been greatly enhanced by the recent development of fast, highly accurate instrumentation. However, successful application of these developments to high-throughput experiments requires careful optimization of many variables which adversely affect each other, such as mass accuracy and data collection speed. We examined the performance of three shotgun-style acquisition methods ranging in their data collection speed and use of mass accuracy in identifying proteins from yeast-derived complex peptide and phosphopeptide-enriched mixtures. We find that the combination of highly accurate precursor masses generated from one survey scan in the FT-ICR cell, coupled with ten data-dependent tandem MS scans in a lower-resolution linear ion trap, provides more identifications in both mixtures than the other examined methods. For phosphopeptide identifications in particular, this method identified over twice as many unique phosphopeptides as the second-ranked, lower-resolution method from triplicate 90-min analyses (744 ± 50 vs. 308 ± 50, respectively). We also examined the performance of four popular peptide assignment algorithms (Mascot, Sequest, OMSSA, and Tandem) in analyzing the results from both high-and low-resolution data. When compared in the context of a false positive rate of approximately 1%, the performance differences between algorithms were much larger for phosphopeptide analyses than for an unenriched, complex mixture. Based upon these findings, acquisition speed, mass accuracy, and the choice of assignment algorithm all largely affect the number of peptides and proteins identified in high-throughput studies. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Some aspects of quality assessment of the k0-based method of NAA

Neutron activation analysis is one of the analytical techniques often used for certification of reference materials. The k₀-based method of instrumental neutron activation analysis can also be applied in intercomparison runs in the certification process and therefore it is desirable to know its accuracy in advance. Possible systematic errors related to the application of nuclear data at given neutron flux rate parameters, that can affect the uncertainties of the results obtained by this specific method, are elucidated and error propagation factors calculated for a typical irradiation position in the TRIGA Mark II reactor of the Jozef Stefan Institute. It was found that these uncertainties are at the level of 1–2% on the average.     

Validation and qualification: the fitness for purpose of mass spectrometry-based analytical methods and analytical systems

The context of validation for mass spectrometry (MS)-based methods is critically analysed. The focus is on the fitness for purpose depending on the task of the method. Information is given on commonly accepted procedures for the implementation and acceptance of analytical methods as ‘confirmatory methods’ according to EU criteria, and strategies for measurement. Attention is paid to the problem of matrix effects in the case of liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry-based procedures, since according to recent guidelines for bioanalytical method validations, there is a need to evaluate matrix effects during development and validation of LC-MS methods “to ensure that precision, selectivity and sensitivity will not be compromised”. Beneficial aspects of the qualification process to ensure the suitability of the MS analytical system are also evaluated and discussed.     

Evaluating uncertainty in analytical measurements: the pursuit of correctness

 Simple in principle, the evaluation of uncertainty, especially in chemical analysis, is not a routine task and needs great care to be correct. This can be seen, particularly, from an examination of the EURACHEM Guide, Quantifying Uncertainty in Analytical Measurement (1995), which is the most important document on the subject. The examination reveals, in the author's opinion, a shortage of correctness in some principal details of the uncertainty estimation process as presented in worked examples in the Guide, and the author has therefore formulated some "in pursuit of correctness" rules for estimating uncertainty. The rules and respective comments are concerned with the following items: (1) choosing an appropriate distribution function in type B evaluation of uncertainty, (2) the necessity for consideration of separate contributions to the combined uncertainty, and (3) taking account of actual influence factors in the uncertainty estimation process. Furthermore, the problem of estimation of conditional versus overall uncertainty is touched upon in connection with comparative trials where only internal consistency of results is required. Received: 29 January 1998 · Accepted: 10 February 1998     

Design and model of calibration for chemical measurements

The international standard ISO 11843 specifies basic methods to design experiments for estimation of critical values referring to the capability of detection. The detection capability depends on the experimental design, the calibration model used, and the errors of the measurement process. This study reports how the specification of the calibration points within the calibration range can be used as a-priori information for evaluation of calibration uncertainty without any consideration of the response variables of the calibration. As result of investigation of the experimental designs, calibration points within the calibration range can be omitted without significant changes of calibration uncertainty. The approach is demonstrated at a practical example, the determination of arsenic in surface water samples taken from a river in Germany.     

Evaluation of measurement uncertainty for analytical procedures using a linear calibration function

In the EURACHEM/CITAC draft ”Quantifying uncertainty in analytical measurement” estimations of measurement uncertainty in analytical results for linear calibration are given. In this work these estimations are compared, i.e. the uncertainty deduced from repeated observations of the sample vs. the uncertainty deduced from the standard residual deviation of the regression. As a result of this study it is shown that an uncertainty estimation based on repeated observations can give more realistic values if the condition of variance homogeneity is not correctly fulfilled in the calibration range. The complete calculation of measurement uncertainty including assessment of trueness is represented by an example concerning the determination of zinc in sediment samples using ICP-atomic emission spectrometry. Received: 9 February 2002 Accepted: 17 April 2002     

Investigation of the performance of the instrument by nonlinear calibration

In the search for high reliability in chemical analysis, a straightforward method of nonlinear calibration is presented. The corresponding standard deviation (SD) was calculated by the law-of-propagation of errors that allowed the determination of uncertainties as a function of concentration within the range of concentrations defined by the lower limit of analysis (LLA) and the upper limit of analysis (ULA). The advantage of using nonlinear calibrations was demonstrated by the correspondence of average values to the peak position of the normal distribution. The concentration of cobalt in two certified reference materials (CRMs) was determined by flame absorption spectrometry (FAAS) that is recognised as an experiment of very high precision. In order to ensure the determination of a reliable value for the SD, a high number of repetitions were required for the analysis. It was thus demonstrated that results that apparently deviated significantly from the certified values, actually belonged to the overall normal distribution of results. The data of experiments were grouped according to Scott’s method, and the distribution of experiments showed a particularly high frequency of results at the peak position that exceeded the expected value predicted by the normal distribution. It also deviated from the distribution peak of experiments, which demonstrates the importance of a full investigation of the distribution of results using more than 100 repetitions. The skewness of the distribution of results was eliminated by the nonlinear calibration. Correspondence: Jens E. T. Andersen, Department of Chemistry, Technical University of Denmark, Kemitorvet building 207, DK-2800 Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark     

The teaching of analytical chemistry in the laboratory

Summary The operation of a combined inorganic analytical course designed to be as flexible as possible, and to use the student's time most economically is described. It has been found that students can be interested by carrying out experiments on their own preparations, but that considerable caution is needed in the interpretation of the results because their preparations may vary considerably and in a manner which is not predictable. The advantages and disadvantages of such a course are discussed.

---

Analytisch-chemischer Unterricht im Laboratorium

Zusammenfassung Ein kombinierter anorganisch-analytischer Lehrgang wird beschrieben, der möglichst flexibel ist und die aufgewendete Zeit nutzbringend einzusetzen erlaubt. Durch Versuche mit eigenen Präparaten wird das Interesse des Studenten geweckt; jedoch ist bei der Auswertung der Ergebnisse Vorsicht geboten, da die Präparate unterschiedliche Zusammensetzung aufweisen können. Vor- und Nachteile eines solchen Lehrganges werden diskutiert.

Lecture presented at Euroanalysis I Conference, 28. 8.–1. 9. 1972 in Heidelberg, Germany.     

Polynomial mass bias functions for the internal standardization of isotope ratio measurements by multi-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

The development and application of a calibration strategy for routine isotope ratio analysis by multi-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) is described and assessed. Internal standardization was used to account for the mass dependant determinate error (mass bias). The general solution for polynomial isotope ratio mass bias functions for use with internal standardization and isotope ratio measurements by multi-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry was derived. The resulting linear isotope ratio mass bias function was demonstrated to be mathematically consistent and experimentally realistic for the analysis of acidified aqueous solutions of analyte and internal standard elements (clean solutions) by multi-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry.     

Performance testing activities for analytical assessment of supercritical fluid extractors

Systematic performance testing activities for supercritical fluid extractors consistent with the implementation of quality systems in analytical laboratories are proposed. In this context, supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) is used for the automatic processing of complex samples. Ensuring reproducible operation of SFE equipment is crucial with a view to obtaining traceable results. To this end, an assessment protocol including recommended preventive and corrective actions, and complementary internal quality control activities, was developed with a view to facilitating the use of SFE equipment by routine analytical laboratories.     

Reference materials and analytical standards to stimulate improved laboratory performance: Experience from the external quality assessment scheme for trace elements in biological samples

The performance of a large number of laboratories measuring trace elements in biological fluids has been monitored over many years by examination of their results in the Guildford external quality assessment scheme. Specific experiences of the UK trace elements reference laboratories have been used to stimulate improvements in performance of other participants in the scheme. The key features of these initiatives were: specially prepared reference materials, used as internal quality control specimens within a common procedure, contributed to accuracy control; proposed standards of satisfactory and unacceptable analytical performance associated with a new system for scoring; regular non-threatening open discussion of performance with interested colleagues. The impact of these features is illustrated with reference to measurements of Al and Zn in serum and Pb in whole blood.     

The role of reference materials in the analytical laboratory

Summary Importance, definition, preparation, characterization, selection and use of reference materials in the analytical laboratory are discussed in general.

---

Die Rolle der Referenzmaterialien im analytischen Laboratorium

Zusammenfassung Bedeutung, Definition, Herstellung, Charakterisierung, Auswahl und Verwendung von Referenzmaterialien im analytischen Laboratorium werden allgemein diskutiert.

     

External calibration in gas chromatography-combustion-isotope ratio mass spectrometry measurements of endogenous androgenic anabolic steroids in sports doping control

An alternative calibration procedure for the Gas Chromatography–Combustion–Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry (GC–C–IRMS) measurements of the World Antidoping Agency (WADA) Accredited Laboratories is presented. To alleviate the need for externally calibrated CO₂ gas for GC–C–IRMS analysis of urinary steroid metabolites, calibration using an external standard mixture solution of steroids with certified isotopic composition was investigated. The reference steroids of the calibration mixture and routine samples underwent identical instrumental processes. The calibration standards bracketed the entire range of the relevant δ¹³C values for the endogenous and exogenous steroids as well as their chromatographic retention times. The certified δ¹³C values of the reference calibrators were plotted in relation to measured m/z¹³CO₂/¹²CO₂ (i.e. R(45/44)) mass spectrometric signals of each calibrator. δ¹³C values of the sample steroids were calculated from the least squares fit through the calibration curve. The effect of the external calibration on δ¹³C values, using the same calibration standards and set of urine samples but different brands of GC–C–IRMS instruments, was assessed by an interlaboratory study in the WADA Accredited Laboratories of Sydney, Australia and Athens, Greece. Relative correspondence between the laboratories for determination of androsterone, etiocholanolone, 5β-androstane-3α,17β-diacetate, and pregnanediacetate means were SD(δ¹³C) = 0.12‰, 0.58‰, −0.34‰, and −0.40‰, respectively. These data demonstrate that accurate intralaboratory external calibration with certified steroids provided by United States Antidoping Agency (USADA) and without external CO₂ calibration is feasible and directly applicable to the WADA Accredited Laboratories for the harmonization of the GC–C–IRMS measurements.     

Independent assessment of matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) sample preparation quality: A novel statistical approach for quality scoring

Preparation of samples according to an optimized method is crucial for accurate determination of polymer sample characteristics by Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption Ionization (MALDI) analysis. Sample preparation conditions such as matrix choice, cationization agent, deposition technique or even the deposition volume should be chosen to suit the sample of interest. Many sample preparation protocols have been developed and employed, yet finding the optimal sample preparation protocol remains a challenge. Because an objective comparison between the results of diverse protocols is not possible, “gut-feeling” or “good enough” is often decisive in the search for an optimum. This implies that sub-optimal protocols are used, leading to a loss of mass spectral information quality. To address this problem a novel analytical strategy based on MALDI imaging and statistical data processing was developed in which eight parameters were formulated to objectively quantify the quality of sample deposition and optimal MALDI matrix composition and finally sum up to an overall quality score of the sample deposition. These parameters can be established in a fully automated way using commercially available mass spectrometry imaging instruments without any hardware adjustments. With the newly developed analytical strategy the highest quality MALDI spots were selected, resulting in more reproducible and more valuable spectra for PEG in a variety of matrices. Moreover, our method enables an objective comparison of sample preparation protocols for any analyte and opens up new fields of investigation by presenting MALDI performance data in a clear and concise way.     

Influence of internal standard charge state on the accuracy of mass measurements in orthogonal acceleration time-of-flight mass spectrometers

Accuracy of mass measurements performed in orthogonal acceleration time-of-flight (oa-TOF) mass spectrometers highly depends on the quality of the signal and the internal calibration. The use of two reference compounds which bracket the targeted unknown, give rise to ions with sufficient signal-to-noise ratio while avoiding detector saturation and produce signals of similar intensity as compared to the target is a common requirement which allow a 5 ppm accuracy on a routine basis. Ion charge state is demonstrated here to be an additional and particularly critical parameter. Using internal references of lower charge state than the target ion systematically yielded overestimated data. Errors measured for quadruply charged molecules were in the range 16-18 ppm when mass calibrants were singly charged ions while accuracy was below 5 ppm when references and target ions were in the same charge state. Magnitude of errors was found to increase with the difference in charge state. This phenomenon arises from the orthogonal acceleration of ions in the TOF analyzer, an interface implemented in all TOF mass spectrometers to accommodate continuous beam ionization sources. Copyright (c) 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Evaluation and single laboratory validation of an on-line turbulent flow extraction tandem mass spectrometry method for melamine in infant formula

This report presents the single-laboratory validation of a method for the determination of melamine in dairy-based products using on-line turbulent flow extraction-tandem mass spectrometry. Liquid or powder test portions were dissolved in water, enriched with (13)C(3)(15)N(3)-Melamine internal standard, followed by protein precipitation and withdrawal of an aliquot for analysis. The turbulent flow method was validated by analyses of liquid and powdered proficiency test portions containing up to 10mg/kg melamine. Accuracy of results ranged from 96 to 106% of the assigned values for the 6 proficiency test portions tested with relative standard deviations of 4-8%. Apparent recoveries based on addition of amino-(15)N(3)-Melamine to prepared test portions were between 98 and 114%. Based on the repeat analysis of a known blank sample the limit of detection and limit of quantification were determined to be 27 and 87 μg/kg, respectively. Additionally, this report demonstrates that turbulent flow chromatography is significantly faster than traditional LC-MS, with sample analysis times of less than 2 min.     

光照度探测器设计与精度校正

助航灯光系统为夜间或能见度较低环境下飞机的安全起降提供安全保障。快速准确地测量和判断其光强等级、光照射角等是否符合国际民用航空组织(ICAO)的标准,是保障机场安全运行的重要工作。本文设计了基于硅光电池的照度探测器,通过余弦校正器和不同滤光片的组合完成视见函数校正和照度探测的精度标定,实现了灯光的高速动态检测;完成了光照度探测器的线性标定和动态精度测量实验,照度测量误差率和动态测量误差均满足ICAO规定的要求;实现了助航灯光平行截面内光强的高速动态检测。