Towards an authentic teaching of mathematics: Hans-Georg Steiner’s contribution to the reform of mathematics teaching

Hans-Georg Steiner was the “motor of the reform” of mathematics education in Germany. His main concern was to promote authentic teaching. His suggestions for teaching mathematical structures stimulated the process of reform, but were criticised as well. Two controversies are studied in this paper. The controversy with Detlef Laugwitz in 1965 was about the dichotomy “axiomatics vs. constructiveness”. Another controversy with Alexander Wittenberg in 1964 was about the problem of “elementary”. The following considerations can show the need for fundamental didactical analyses in mathematics education, as they were initiated by Hans-Georg Steiner.     

The role of mathematics in educational systems

In this paper, I will explain my views on education, particularly mathematics education, stressing my critique on the socio-cultural dimensions involved in mathematics education. The state of the world and ethical behavior play an important role in my critique. In exposing my views, the importance of my relationship with Hans-Georg Steiner will be clearly stated. In my memory, our discussions on these issues were very influential to my thinking. The importance of the support given by Hans-Georg to the development of mathematics education worldwide will be underlined. Both in the position of the chairman of the International Program Committee of ICME 3 and in the early years of the IDM in Bielefeld, Hans-Georg provided the material and intellectual space for the strengthening of Didactics of Mathematics as a research field. Following these preliminary remarks, I will briefly present the Program Ethnomathematics and explain how the program fits into what I call the modern trivium of literacy, matheracy and technoracy, which is a curriculum alternative for contemporary education.     

Hans-Georg Steiner: a life dedicated to the development of didactics of mathematics as a scientific discipline

In our introductory paper to this special issue we follow two goals. First of all, we take on the challenge to give an account of more than 40 years of academic work by one of the leading members of our discipline by looking at Hans Georg Steiner’s contributions to the development of didactics of mathematics as a scientific discipline in Germany as well as internationally. Therefore, we try to highlight major research interests, publications and conferences during his early years in Münster, Karlsruhe and Bayreuth as well as during the 20 years at the IDM in Bielefeld. Closely linked to these periods of this life and work are specific research interests, professional contacts and friendships. Hence, the second goal of our paper is to emphasise Hans-Georg Steiner’s relationships with national and international colleagues (many of whom became friends) and their shared interests and collaborations in the development of mathematics education through a selection of invited papers that address different stages and professional foci in the life of Hans-Georg Steiner. These papers are organised in four sections: (1) Revisiting the New Math reform, (2) Developing specific research domains in didactics of mathematics, (3) Discussing theories of mathematics education (TME), and (4) Reflecting on goals and results of mathematics education.     

Conception of expert mathematics teacher: a comparative study between Hong Kong and Chongqing

This paper reports the similarities and differences in how “expert mathematics teacher” is conceptualized by mathematics educators in Hong Kong and Chongqing, two cities in China which share similar but different cultural and social backgrounds. Thirty-seven mathematics education researchers, school principals with mathematics education background, and mathematics teachers were interviewed on their perceptions of expert mathematics teacher. It is found that in both cities an expert mathematics teacher should have a profound knowledge base in mathematics, teaching, and students; strong ability in teaching; and a noble personality and a spirit of life-long learning. As for differences, an expert mathematics teacher should have the ability to conduct research, mentor other teachers, and have profound knowledge of examination and educational theories in Chongqing. These attributes were not found in Hong Kong. These similarities and differences are discussed, and relevant social and cultural factors in the two contexts are examined.     

Didactics of mathematics as a scientific discipline: A sketch of its development from a personal (autobiographic) point of view

At the 8th International Congress on Mathematical Education (ICME-8) held in Sevilla, Spain, July 1996, Working Group 25 was devoted to the theme “Didactics of Mathematics as a Scientific Discipline”. The proceedings of this activity have been published by Nicolina A. Malara (s. footnote 1). The plenary talk given by the author on “Basic Characteristics and Recent Trends in the Development of Didactics of Mathematics as a Scientific Discipline” as well as the round-table discussion under his chairmanship are documented in the proceedings. Furthermore the author has contributed to the proceedings an autobiographicly oriented paper which goes back to his own time as a schoolboy and refers to his professional development in connections with various national and international institutions and movements. The present slightly extended reproduction of that contribution is mediating aspects of developmental dynamics which can hardly be grasped by highly objectified presentations. As for a similar paper see H. G. Steiner: “Some notable anniversaries and some personal German-Italian memories in didactis of mathematics ZDM 26 (1994), 211–214; also in Italian: L’insegnamento della matematica e delle scienze integrate (Numero Speziale), vol. 5 N.17A-17B, Sept.–Oct. 1994, 425–437.     

Theories of Mathematics Education: A global survey of theoretical frameworks/trends in mathematics education research

In this article we survey the history of research on theories in mathematics education. We also briefly examine the origins of this line of inquiry, the contribution of Hans-Georg Steiner, the activities of various international topics groups and current discussions of theories in mathematics education research. We conclude by outlining current positions and questions addressed by mathematics education researchers in the research forum on theories at the 2005 PME meeting in Melbourne, Australia.     

A Sino-German semi-virtual seminar in mathematics education

In summer 2006 the University of Education in Weingarten, Germany, and East China Normal University, Shanghai, performed a semi-virtual seminar with mathematics students on “Mathematics and Architecture”. The goal was the joint development of teaching materials for German or Chinese school, based on different buildings such as “Nanpu Bridge”, or the “Eiffel Tower”. The purpose of the seminar was to provide a learning environment for students supported by using information and communication technology (ICT) to understand how the hidden mathematics in buildings should be related to school mathematics; to experience the multicultural potential of the international language “Mathematics”; to develop “media competence” while communicating with others and using technologies in mathematics education; and to recognize the differences in teaching mathematics between the two cultures. In this paper we will present our ideas, experiences and results from the seminar.     

Making mathematics and science integration happen: key aspects of practice

The integration of mathematics and science teaching and learning facilitates student learning, engagement, motivation, problem-solving, criticality and real-life application. However, the actual implementation of an integrative approach to the teaching and learning of both subjects at classroom level, with in-service teachers working collaboratively, at second-level education, is under-researched due to the complexities of school-based research. This study reports on a year-long case study on the implementation of an integrated unit of learning on distance, speed and time, within three second-level schools in Ireland. This study employed a qualitative approach and examined the key aspects of practice that impact on the integration of mathematics and science teaching and learning. We argue that teacher perspective, teacher knowledge of the ‘other subject’ and of technological pedagogical content knowledge (TPACK), and teacher collaboration and support all impact on the implementation of an integrative approach to mathematics and science education.     

Hong Kong teachers’ views of effective mathematics teaching and learning

Twelve experienced mathematics teachers in Hong Kong were invited to face-to-face semi-structured interviews to express their views about mathematics, about mathematics learning and about the teacher and teaching. Mathematics was generally regarded as a subject that is practical, logical, useful and involves thinking. In view of the abstract nature of the subject, the teachers took abstract thinking as the goal of mathematics learning. They reflected that it is not just a matter of “how” and “when”, but one should build a path so that students can proceed from the concrete to the abstract. Their conceptions of mathematics understanding were tapped. Furthermore, the roles of memorisation, practices and concrete experiences were discussed, in relation with understanding. Teaching for understanding is unanimously supported and along this line, the characteristics of an effective mathematics lesson and of an effective mathematics teacher were discussed. Though many of the participants realize that there is no fixed rule for good practices, some of the indicators were put forth. To arrive at an effective mathematics lesson, good preparation, basic teaching skills and good relationship with the students are prerequisite.     

Beliefs and beyond: affect and the teaching and learning of mathematics

The importance of beliefs for the teaching and learning of mathematics is widely recognized among mathematics educators. In this special issue, we explicitly address what we call “beliefs and beyond” to indicate the larger field surrounding beliefs in mathematics education. This is done to broaden the discussion to related concepts (which may not originate in mathematics education) and to consider the interconnectedness of concepts. In particular, we present some new developments at the conceptual level, address different approaches to investigate beliefs, highlight the role of student beliefs in problem-solving activities, and discuss teacher beliefs and their significance for professional development. One specific intention is to consider expertise from colleagues in the fields of educational research and psychology, side by side with perspectives provided by researchers from mathematics education.     

Australian teachers’ views of effective mathematics teaching and learning

Thirteen Australian teachers who had been nominated by their professional mathematics teachers’ associations as excellent teachers of elementary school mathematics were interviewed on their beliefs about mathematics, mathematics learning and mathematics teaching. In particular, they were asked to discuss the characteristics of effective teachers of mathematics and excellent mathematics lessons. In spite of their differences in location, experience and teacher education, the teachers displayed a lot of consistency in their responses and in their lists of characteristics. While this group of teachers cannot be claimed to be representative of Australian teachers, they have provided a snapshot of what is regarded as effectiveness in mathematics education in Australian elementary schools.     

Learning from similarities and differences: a reflection on the potentials and constraints of cross-national studies in mathematics

Research in mathematics education that crosses national boundaries provides new insights into the development and improvement of the teaching and learning of mathematics. In particular, cross-national comparisons lead researchers to more explicit understanding of their own implicit theories about how teachers teach and how children learn mathematics in their local contexts as well as what is going on in school mathematics in other countries. Further, when researchers from multiple countries and regions study collaboratively aspects of teaching and learning of mathematics, the taken-for-granted familiar practices in the classroom can be questioned. Such cross-national comparisons provide opportunities for researchers and educators to probe typical dichotomies such as “high-performing” versus “low performing”, “teacher-centred versus student-centred”, or even “East versus West”, in searching for similarities and differences in educational policies and practices in different cultural contexts.     

From numbers to narratives: Preservice teachers experiences’ with mathematics anxiety and mathematics teaching anxiety

This paper presents qualitative and quantitative approaches to exploring teachers’ experiences of mathematics anxiety (for learning and doing mathematics) and mathematics teaching anxiety (for instructing others in mathematics), the relationship between these types of anxiety and test/evaluation anxiety, and the impacts of anxiety on experiences in teacher education. Findings indicate that mathematics anxiety and mathematics teaching anxiety may be similar (i.e., that preservice teachers perceive a logical continuity and cumulative effect of their experiences of mathematics anxiety as learners in K–12 classrooms that impacts their work as teachers in future K–12 classrooms). Further, anxiety is not limited to occurring in evaluative settings, but when anxiety is triggered by thoughts of evaluation, preservice teachers may be affected by worrying about their own as well as their students' performances. The implications for preservice experiences within a teacher education program and for impacting future students are discussed.     

Representing context in video records of practice for urban mathematics teacher education

Mathematics education research has not sufficiently theorized about mathematics teacher knowledge and practice, teacher learning, and teacher education in ways that are reflective of the specificities of the sociopolitical contexts of schooling. In the USA, this is particularly important for urban mathematics education. This paper examines the affordances and challenges of representing context in video records of practice, particularly in the urban context, for use in the preparation of mathematics teachers for urban settings. The discussion, grounded in current research and theory relevant to representations of teaching, urban education, and mathematics teacher education, takes up three key issues: how is a focus on the urban context relevant to the design of video records of practice for mathematics teacher education? How can video records support prospective teachers’ understandings of the sociopolitical contexts of mathematics teaching? How does a focus on the urban context impact the meaning teachers make of video records?     

ICT integration in mathematics initial teacher training and its impact on visualization: the case of GeoGebra

This case study investigates the impact of the integration of information and communications technology (ICT) in mathematics visualization skills and initial teacher education programmes. It reports on the influence GeoGebra dynamic software use has on promoting mathematical learning at secondary school and on its impact on teachers’ conceptions about teaching and learning mathematics. This paper describes how GeoGebra-based dynamic applets – designed and used in an exploratory manner – promote mathematical processes such as conjectures. It also refers to the changes prospective teachers experience regarding the relevance visual dynamic representations acquire in teaching mathematics. This study observes a shift in school routines when incorporating technology into the mathematics classroom. Visualization appears as a basic competence associated to key mathematical processes. Implications of an early integration of ICT in mathematics initial teacher training and its impact on developing technological pedagogical content knowledge (TPCK) are drawn.     

The mathematics of war

During the Desert Storm, the Gulf war, it was possible to read in the newspapers words such as: “Inmathematical terms, was is becoming more and more electronically controlled and, as a result, it is moving away from the battlefield. Then, when war comes down to earth, it becomes bloody, it loses its mathematical asceticism” Reading the newspapers in those days, one had the impression that modern warfare is based on mathematics, as if it were not men but computers that decided where to carry out “surgical operations”. By contrast, the volume published a few years before the Gulf war conceived as a didactic unit to be used in schools with a guide for the teacher with the titleLa matematica della guerra (The Mathematics of War) published by Gruppo Abele in Turin begins with the words “Mathematics, like any other discipline, lends itself to building several paths towards education for peace”. The volume, written by a group of teachers belonging to an anti-violence organisation forming part of the “education for peace” project, highlights the power or ambiguitiy of mathematical models used to simulate war or conflict situations and demonstrates that in some cases the use of mathematics leads to a better understanding of the situation, but in other cases, the mathematical model itself can lead to conclusions which are either wrong or morally unacceptable.     

Teaching and learning of mathematics: what really matters to teachers and students?

The learner’s perspective study, motivated by a strong belief that the characterization of the practices of mathematics classrooms must attend to learner practice with at least the same priority as that accorded to teacher practice, is a comprehensive study that adopts a complementary accounts methodology to negotiate meanings in classrooms. In Singapore, three mathematics teachers recognized for their locally defined ‘teaching competence’ participated in the study. The comprehensive sets of data from the three classrooms have been used to explore several premises related to the teaching and learning of mathematics. In this paper the student interview data and the teacher interview data were examined to ascertain what do students attach importance to and what do teachers attach importance to in a mathematics lesson? The findings of the student interview data showed that they attached importance to several sub-aspects of the three main aspects, i.e., exposition, seatwork and review and feedback of their teachers’ pedagogical practices. The findings of the teacher interview data showed that they attached importance to student’s self assessment, teacher’s demonstration of procedures, review of prior knowledge and close monitoring of their student’s progress in learning and detailed feedback of their work. It was also found that teachers and students did attach importance to some common lesson events.     

Research into teacher knowledge: a stimulus for development in mathematics teacher education practice

In this paper, we document some developments in teacher education practice at one university, brought about by reflection on research into mathematics teacher knowledge. The authors are three members of the Cambridge-based research team who developed the Knowledge Quartet (KQ), a theory of mathematics teacher knowledge, with a focus on classroom situations in which this knowledge is applied. At the same time as being researchers, the authors were elementary mathematics teacher education instructors. They found that the KQ research brought about new awareness of the importance of some components of mathematics didactics, as well as providing new tools for undertaking some aspects of their teacher educator role. The paper explores some of these awarenesses and tools in detail.     

Connecting social perspectives on mathematics teacher education in online environments

This article explores theoretical issues underpinning the design and use of online learning environments in mathematics teacher education. It considers the contribution of social theories of learning to conceptualising technology-mediated interaction, focusing specifically on community of practice models and the notion of digital mathematics performance. The article begins by introducing social perspectives on collaboration. Because of the diversity of theories within this broad research paradigm, the next section outlines networking strategies that have been proposed for connecting theoretical approaches. There follows a discussion of studies that illustrate the community of practice and performance-based approaches to research into online mathematics teacher education. The main purpose of the article is to show how these approaches could be connected by examining the same teaching and learning scenarios through different theoretical lenses. The final section identifies implications of this exploration for the design of online learning environments in mathematics teacher education to capitalise on the affordances of Web-based technologies.     

Rural teacher leadership in science and mathematics

This study adds to our understanding of science and mathematics teacher leadership in rural schools. Through In Vivo and Concept coding of teacher interviews, we investigated 20 secondary science and mathematics teachers' perceptions of rural teacher leadership during their participation in a three-year professional development program. As the teachers developed as teacher leaders, they broadened their focus from improving their own students' learning to sharing new knowledge learned through the program with other teachers both informally and formally. We compared our program components to the Teacher Leader Model Standards and added an emphasis on the importance of disciplinary content knowledge. We also identified patterns in science and mathematics teacher leadership that are contextually connected to teachers' instruction in rural high poverty schools. Rural teacher leadership included the importance of building strong teacher–student relationships, providing new academic opportunities for students, encouraging students' success, and building community connections.