Can semi-empirical models describe HCl dissociation in water?

We discuss the failure of commonly used AM1 and PM3 semiempirical methods to correctly describe acid dissociation. We focus our analysis on HCl because of its physicochemical importance and its relevance in atmospheric chemistry. The structure of non-dissociated and dissociated HCl – (H₂O) _n clusters is accounted for. The very bad results obtained with PM3 (and also with AM1) are related to large errors in gas-phase proton affinity of water and gas-phase acidity of HCl. Indeed, estimation of pKa values shows that neither AM1 nor PM3 are able to predict HCl dissociation in liquid water since HCl is found to be a weaker acid than H₃O⁺. We have proposed in previous works a modified PM3 approach (PM3-MAIS) adapted to intermolecular calculations. It is derived from PM3 by reparameterization of the core–core functions using ab initio data. Since parameters for H–Cl and O–Cl core–core interactions were not yet available, we have carried out the corresponding optimization. Application of the PM3-MAIS method to HCl dissociation in HCl–(H₂O) _n clusters leads to a huge improvement over PM3 results. Though the method predicts a slightly overestimated HCl acidity in water environment, the overall agreement with ab initio calculations is very satisfying and justifies efforts to develop new semiempirical methods.     

NDDO semiempirical approximations coupled with Green's function technique—a reliable approach for calculating ionization potentials

The ionization potentials of different molecules have been calculated with the outer valence Green's function (OVGF) technique, coupled with semiempirical MNDO, AM1 and PM3 methods. It is found that the OVGF method gives significantly better agreement with the experimental data than do results obtained with semiempirical calculations using Koopman's theorem including a new SAM1 and MNDO/d methods. Of the three semiempirical methods tested (MNDO, AM1, PM3) the OVGF (AM1) method gives the best agreement with experiment.     

PDDG/PM3 and PDDG/MNDO: improved semiempirical methods

Two new semiempirical methods employing a Pairwise Distance Directed Gaussian modification have been developed: PDDG/PM3 and PDDG/MNDO; they are easily implemented in existing software, and yield heats of formation for compounds containing C, H, N, and O atoms with significantly improved accuracy over the standard NDDO schemes, PM5, PM3, AM1, and MNDO. The PDDG/PM3 results for heats of formation also show substantial improvement over density functional theory with large basis sets. The PDDG modifications consist of a single function, which is added to the existing pairwise core repulsion functions within PM3 and MNDO, a reparameterized semiempirical parameter set, and modified computation of the energy of formation of a gaseous atom. The PDDG addition introduces functional group information via pairwise atomic interactions using only atom-based parameters. For 622 diverse molecules containing C, H, N, and O atoms, mean absolute errors in calculated heats of formation are reduced from 4.4 to 3.2 kcal/mol and from 8.4 to 5.2 kcal/mol using the PDDG modified versions of PM3 and MNDO over the standard versions, respectively. Several specific problems are overcome, including the relative stability of hydrocarbon isomers, and energetics of small rings and molecules containing multiple heteroatoms. The internal consistency of PDDG energies is also significantly improved, enabling more reliable analysis of isomerization energies and trends across series of molecules; PDDG isomerization energies show significant improvement over B3LYP/6-31G* results. Comparison of heats of formation, ionization potentials, dipole moments, isomer, and conformer energetics, intermolecular interaction energies, activation energies, and molecular geometries from the PDDG techniques is made to experimental data and values from other semiempirical and ab initio methods.     

A comparison of conformational energies calculated by molecular mechanics (MM2(85), Sybyl 5.1, Sybyl 5.21, and ChemX) and semiempirical (AM1 and PM3) methods

Conformational energies of different conformers have been calculated for a series of molecules using various molecular mechanics and semiempirical methods. The quality of the force fields has also been tested by calculating barriers to rotation about carbon-carbon bonds. The molecular mechanics force fields used are MM2(85), Sybyl 5.1, Sybyl 5.21, and ChemX, ver. Jan 89. The semiempirical methods used are AM1 and PM3. Molecules with different functional groups, for which good experimental data exist, have been selected. The semiempirical methods generally calculate barriers to rotation which are lower than the experimentally determined. The conformational energies for hydrocarbons are reasonably well reproduced by all tested methods although MM2(85) gives the quantitatively best agreement with experiments. For compounds containing oxygen, nitrogen and halogens MM2(85) gives results which are in best agreement with the experimentally determined values.     

Path-integral molecular dynamics simulations of hydrated hydrogen chloride cluster HCl(H2O)4 on a semiempirical potential energy surface

Path-integral molecular dynamics simulations for the HCl(H₂O)₄ cluster have been performed on the ground-state potential energy surface directly obtained on-the-fly from semiempirical PM3-MAIS molecular orbital calculations. It is found that the HCl(H₂O)₄ cluster has structural rearrangement above the temperature of 300 K showing a liquid-like behavior. Quantum mechanical fluctuation of hydrogen nuclei plays a significant role in structural arrangement processes in this cluster.     

Semiempirical study of the conformation of tetroxane and its halogenated derivatives

We have made a conformational study of tetroxane and its bi- and tetra-halogenated derivatives by means of the semiempirical AM1 and PM3 molecular orbital methods. The results are compared with previous semiempirical and ab initio studies as well as with available experimental data. We have found that in every case the AM1 method underestimates the peroxidic O-O bond length by approximately 12%, while the PM3 procedure describes such a bond in a better way. The degree of accuracy of these two semiempirical methods is discussed in relation with the tetroxane structure.     

Comparison of semiempirical MO methods applied to large molecules

The heats of formation for 19 molecules have been calculated with PM3 and AM1 semiempirical methods. The values obtained have been compared with experimental heats of formation. With PM3 and AM1 the average differences between calculated and experimental heats of formation are 8.45 and 12.34 kcal mol^?1 respectively. There are significant differences when large molecules are considered: this suggests that the parameterization should be done including larger molecules.     

Extension of the PDDG/PM3 and PDDG/MNDO semiempirical molecular orbital methods to the halogens

The new semiempirical methods, PDDG/PM3 and PDDG/MNDO, have been parameterized for halogens. For comparison, the original MNDO and PM3 were also reoptimized for the halogens using the same training set; these modified methods are referred to as MNDO' and PM3'. For 442 halogen-containing molecules, the smallest mean absolute error (MAE) in heats of formation is obtained with PDDG/PM3 (5.6 kcal/mol), followed by PM3' (6.1 kcal/mol), PDDG/MNDO (6.6 kcal/mol), PM3 (8.1 kcal/mol), MNDO' (8.5 kcal/mol), AM1 (11.1 kcal/mol), and MNDO (14.0 kcal/mol). For normal-valent halogen-containing molecules, the PDDG methods also provide improved heats of formation over MNDO/d. Hypervalent compounds were not included in the training set and improvements over the standard NDDO methods with sp basis sets were not obtained. For small haloalkanes, the PDDG methods yield more accurate heats of formation than are obtained from density functional theory (DFT) with the B3LYP and B3PW91 functionals using large basis sets. PDDG/PM3 and PM3' also give improved binding energies over the standard NDDO methods for complexes involving halide anions, and they are competitive with B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) results including thermal corrections. Among the semiempirical methods studied, PDDG/PM3 also generates the best agreement with high-level ab initio G2 and CCSD(T) intrinsic activation energies for S(N)2 reactions involving methyl halides and halide anions. Finally, the MAEs in ionization potentials, dipole moments, and molecular geometries show that the parameter sets for the PDDG and reoptimized NDDO methods reduce the MAEs in heats of formation without compromising the other important QM observables.     

Improved semiempirical heats of formation through the use of bond and group equivalents

Deficiencies in energetics obtained using the common semiempirical methods, AM1, PM3, and MNDO, may partly be traced to the use of pseudoatomic equivalents for conversion of molecular energies to heats of formation at 298 K. We present an alternative scheme based on the use of bond and group equivalents. Values for the 61 bond and group equivalents necessary for treatment of molecules containing the common organic elements, hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen have been derived. For a set of 583 neutral, closed-shell molecules mean absolute errors in AM1, PM3, and MNDO heats of formation are reduced from 6.6, 4.2, and 8.2 kcal/mol to 2.3, 2.2, and 3.0 kcal/mol, respectively. Several systematic problems are overcome in the present scheme including relative stabilities of branched hydrocarbons, energetics of conjugated systems, heats of formation of long chain hydrocarbons, and enthalpies of molecules containing multiple heteroatoms. Although the approach is restricted to molecules with well-defined functional groups, the equivalents are easy to incorporate and are chemically relevant. This revised procedure allows semiempirical methods to be used for far more reliable evaluations of heats of reactions. Estimates are made of the errors inherent in these semiempirical formalisms, arising from integral approximations and the neglect of explicit treatment of electron correlation effects, while excluding those from inadequate parameterization.     

Theoretical studies on heats of formation for cubylnitrates using density functional theory B3LYP method and semiempirical MO methods

The heats of formation (HOF) have been calculated for all the 21 cubylnitrate compounds using the semiemprical molecular orbital (MO) methods (MINDO/3, MNDO, AM1, and PM3) and for 8 of 21 cubylnitrates containing 1–4 ? ONO₂ groups using the density functional theory (DFT) method at the B3LYP/6‐31G* level by means of designed isodesmic reactions. The cubane cage skeletons in cubylnitrate molecules have been kept in setting up isodesmic reactions to produce more accurate and reliable results. It is found that there are good linear relationships between the HOFs of the 8 cubylnitrates calculated using B3LYP/6‐31G* and two semiempirical MO (PM3 and AM1) methods, and the linear correlation coefficients of PM3 and AM1 methods are 0.9901 and 0.9826, respectively. Subsequently, the accurate HOFs at B3LYP/6‐31G* level of other 13 cubylnitrates containing 4–8 ? ONO₂ groups are obtained by systematically correcting their PM3‐calculated HOFs. Compared with noncaged nitrates, all the 21 cubylnitrates have high heats of formation implying that they may be very powerful energetic materials and have highly exploitable value. The relationship between the HOFs and the molecular structures of cubylnitrates has been discussed. © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2001     

Computational structural determination and energy landscape analysis of the hepatic carcinogen 2-(acetylamino)fluorene

 2-(Acetylamino)fluorene (AAF), a potent mutagen and a prototypical example of the mutagenic aromatic amines, forms covalent adducts to DNA after metabolic activation in the liver. A benchmark study of AAF is presented using a number of the most widely used molecular mechanics and semiempirical computational methods and models. The results are compared to higher-level quantum calculations and to experimentally obtained crystal structures. Hydrogen bonding between AAF molecules in the crystal phase complicates the direct comparison of gas-phase theoretical calculations with experiment, so Hartree–Fock (HF) and Becke–Perdew (BP) density functional theory (DFT) calculations are used as benchmarks for the semiempirical and molecular mechanics results. Systematic conformer searches and dihedral energy landscapes were carried out for AAF using the SYBYL and MMFF94 molecular mechanics force fields; the AM1, PM3 and MNDO semiempirical quantum mechanics methods; HF using the 3-21G*and 6-31G* basis sets; and DFT using the nonlocal BP functional and double numerical polarization basis sets. MMFF94, AM1, HF and DFT calculations all predict the same planar structures, whereas SYBYL, MNDO and PM3 all predict various nonplanar geometries. The AM1 energy landscape is in substantial agreement with HF and DFT predictions; MMFF94 is qualitatively similar to HF and DFT; and the MNDO, PM3 and SYBYL results are qualitatively different from the HF and DFT results and from each other. These results are attributed to deficiencies in MNDO, PM3 and SYBYL. The MNDO, PM3 and SYBYL models may be unreliable for compounds in which an amide group is immediately adjacent to an aromatic ring. Received: 26 May 2002 / Accepted: 12 December 2002 / Published online: 14 February 2003     

Are AM1 ligand‐protein binding enthalpies good enough for use in the rational design of new drugs?

We have examined the performance of semiempirical quantum mechanical methods in solving the problem of accurately predicting protein-ligand binding energies and geometries. Firstly, AM1 and PM3 geometries and binding enthalpies between small molecules that simulate typical ligand-protein interactions were compared with high level quantum mechanical techniques that include electronic correlation (e.g., MP2 or B3LYP). Species studied include alkanes, aromatic systems, molecules including groups with hypervalent sulfur or with donor or acceptor hydrogen bonding capability, as well as ammonium or carboxylate ions. B3LYP/6-311+G(2d,p) binding energies correlated very well with the BSSE corrected MP2/6-31G(d) values. AM1 binding enthalpies also showed good correlation with MP2 values, and their systematic deviation is acceptable when enthalpies are used for the comparison of interaction energies between ligands and a target. PM3 otherwise gave erratic energy differences in comparison to the B3LYP or MP2 approaches. As one would expect, the geometries of the binding complexes showed the known limitations of the semiempirical and DFT methods. AM1 calculations were subsequently applied to a test set consisting of "real" protein active site-ligand complexes. Preliminary results indicate that AM1 could be a valuable tool for the design of new drugs using proteins as templates. This approach also has a reasonable computational cost. The ligand-protein X-ray structures were reasonably reproduced by AM1 calculations and the corresponding AM1 binding enthalpies are in agreement with the results from the "small molecules" test set.     

Coupled semiempirical quantum mechanics and molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations on the aqueous solvation free energies of ionized molecules

The aqueous solvation free energies of ionized molecules were computed using a coupled quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) model based on the AM1, MNDO, and PM3 semiempirical molecular orbital methods for the solute molecule and the TIP3P molecular mechanics model for liquid water. The present work is an extension of our model for neutral solutes where we assumed that the total free energy is the sum of components derived from the electrostatic/polarization terms in the Hamiltonian plus an empirical “nonpolar” term. The electrostatic/polarization contributions to the solvation free energies were computed using molecular dynamics (MD) simulation and thermodynamic integration techniques, while the nonpolar contributions were taken from the literature. The contribution to the electrostatic/polarization component of the free energy due to nonbonded interactions outside the cutoff radii used in the MD simulations was approximated by a Born solvation term. The experimental free energies were reproduced satisfactorily using variational parameters from the vdW terms as in the original model, in addition to a parameter from the one-electron integral terms. The new one-electron parameter was required to account for the short-range effects of overlapping atomic charge densities. The radial distribution functions obtained from the MD simulations showed the expected H-bonded structures between the ionized solute molecule and solvent molecules. We also obtained satisfactory results by neglecting both the empirical nonpolar term and the electronic polarization of the solute, i.e., by implementing a nonpolarization model. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Comput Chem 20: 1028–1038, 1999     

Hydrogen bonds: a comparison of semiempirical and ab initio treatments

H-bonding interactions calculated using the AM1, PM3 and SAM1 semiempirical molecular orbital methods are compared with the best available ab initio calculations for several intermolecular interactions of interest: acetic acid dimers, water/ acetylene, water/HCN, formaldehyde/acetylene, formaldehyde/HCN, ozone/acetylene, ozone/HCN, acetylacetone, melamine/ cyanuric acid, and nitromethane/ammonia. Experimental values are also presented where available. The energetic comparisons are based upon enthalpies of interaction from the ab initio calculations after counterpoise and vibrational corrections have been applied. Overall, AM1 seems to do best, except for O---H…O interactions, where none of the three methods excel.     

Performance assessment of semiempirical molecular orbital methods in describing halogen bonding: quantum mechanical and quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical-molecular dynamics study

The performance of semiempirical molecular-orbital methods--MNDO, MNDO-d, AM1, RM1, PM3 and PM6--in describing halogen bonding was evaluated, and the results were compared with molecular mechanical (MM) and quantum mechanical (QM) data. Three types of performance were assessed: (1) geometrical optimizations and binding energy calculations for 27 halogen-containing molecules complexed with various Lewis bases (Two of the tested methods, AM1 and RM1, gave results that agree with the QM data.); (2) charge distribution calculations for halobenzene molecules, determined by calculating the solvation free energies of the molecules relative to benzene in explicit and implicit generalized Born (GB) solvents (None of the methods gave results that agree with the experimental data.); and (3) appropriateness of the semiempirical methods in the hybrid quantum-mechanical/molecular-mechanical (QM/MM) scheme, investigated by studying the molecular inhibition of CK2 protein by eight halobenzimidazole and -benzotriazole derivatives using hybrid QM/MM molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations with the inhibitor described at the QM level by the AM1 method and the rest of the system described at the MM level. The pure MM approach with inclusion of an extra point of positive charge on the halogen atom approach gave better results than the hybrid QM/MM approach involving the AM1 method. Also, in comparison with the pure MM-GBSA (generalized Born surface area) binding energies and experimental data, the calculated QM/MM-GBSA binding energies of the inhibitors were improved by replacing the G(GB,QM/MM) solvation term with the corresponding G(GB,MM) term.     

A comparison of semiempirical and ab initio transition states for HF elimination in unimolecular decompositions

The transition states for unimolecular HF elimination from a series of methylene halides and vinyl halides have been located and properly characterized at the AM 1, MNDO , PM 3, RHF /6-311G (d, p), and MP 2/6-311G (d, p) levels. Whereas the semiempirical MO methods deal well with the structures of the stable molecules, the structural differences between the ab initio and semiempirical transition states are considerably larger. The AM 1 and PM 3 activation energies appear to be relatively more accurate. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Testing electronic structure methods for describing intermolecular H...H interactions in supramolecular chemistry

In this article a wide variety of computational approaches (molecular mechanics force fields, semiempirical formalisms, and hybrid methods, namely ONIOM calculations) have been used to calculate the energy and geometry of the supramolecular system 2-(2'-hydroxyphenyl)-4-methyloxazole (HPMO) encapsulated in beta-cyclodextrin (beta-CD). The main objective of the present study has been to examine the performance of these computational methods when describing the short range H. H intermolecular interactions between guest (HPMO) and host (beta-CD) molecules. The analyzed molecular mechanics methods do not provide unphysical short H...H contacts, but it is obvious that their applicability to the study of supramolecular systems is rather limited. For the semiempirical methods, MNDO is found to generate more reliable geometries than AM1, PM3 and the two recently developed schemes PDDG/MNDO and PDDG/PM3. MNDO results only give one slightly short H...H distance, whereas the NDDO formalisms with modifications of the Core Repulsion Function (CRF) via Gaussians exhibit a large number of short to very short and unphysical H...H intermolecular distances. In contrast, the PM5 method, which is the successor to PM3, gives very promising results. Our ONIOM calculations indicate that the unphysical optimized geometries from PM3 are retained when this semiempirical method is used as the low level layer in a QM:QM formulation. On the other hand, ab initio methods involving good enough basis sets, at least for the high level layer in a hybrid ONIOM calculation, behave well, but they may be too expensive in practice for most supramolecular chemistry applications. Finally, the performance of the evaluated computational methods has also been tested by evaluating the energetic difference between the two most stable conformations of the host(beta-CD)-guest(HPMO) system.     

Theoretical Study of the trans-3,6-Dimethoxy-1,2,4-trioxane Molecule

The molecule of trans-3,6-dimethoxy-1,2,4-trioxane has been studied by the semiempirical molecular orbital AM1 and PM3 methods. The numerical results of the structural study have been analyzed in terms of several stereoelectronic effects and compared with available experimental data. Theoretical predictions derived from both methods are in a good agreement with each other.     

Structural studies of aromatic amines and the dna intercalating compounds m-amsa and o-amsa: Comparison of mndo,am1, and pm3 to experimental and ab initio results

The ability of the MNDO, AM1, and PM3 semiempirical methods to reproduce pyramidalization at the nitrogen in 15 aromatic amines has been examined and compared to experimental and other theoretical results. AM1 consistently gives the best agreement. We have therefore reexamined the DNA intercalating compounds m-AMSA and o-AMSA using AM1.