Ceramide-enriched microdomains in planar membranes

Ceramide has a large effect on the properties of biological membranes, increasing lipid order and promoting lateral phase separation, and plays an important role in cell signaling. This review provides an overview of recent studies of the effects of direct ceramide incorporation and enzymatic ceramide generation on planar supported membranes, including lipid monolayers and supported lipid bilayers. Recent studies have focused on understanding the nucleation, growth and morphology of ceramide gel domains, characterizing the properties of ceramide-rich membrane phases and investigating the effects of ceramide on phase-separated membranes with co-existing liquid-ordered and fluid phases, as models for cellular membranes.     

Raft domain reorganization driven by short- and long-chain ceramide: a combined AFM and FCS study

Naturally occurring long-chain ceramides (Cer) are known to alter the lateral organization of biological membranes. In particular, they produce alterations of microdomains that are involved in several cellular processes, ranging from apoptosis to immune response. In order to induce similar biological effects, short-chain Cer are extensively used in in vivo experiments to replace their long-chain analogues. In this work, we used the combined approach of atomic force microscopy (AFM) and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to investigate the effect of Cer chain length in lipid bilayers composed of sphingomyelin, dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine, and cholesterol. Our results show that only long-chain Cer, like C18 and C16, are able to segregate from the liquid-ordered phase, forming separate Cer-enriched domains. Conversely, short-chain Cer do not form a separate phase but alter the physical properties of the liquid-ordered domains, decreasing their stability and viscosity and perturbing the lipid packing. These differences may contribute to the explanation of the different physiological effects that are often observed for the long- and short-chain Cer.     

Effects of isoflurane, halothane, and chloroform on the interactions and lateral organization of lipids in the liquid-ordered phase

The first quantitative insight has been obtained into the effects that volatile anesthetics have on the interactions and lateral organization of lipids in model membranes that mimic "lipid rafts". Specifically, nearest-neighbor recogntion measurements, in combination with Monte Carlo simulations, have been used to investigate the action of isoflurane, halothane, and chloroform on the compactness and lateral organization of cholesterol-rich bilayers of 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) in the liquid-ordered (l(o)) phase. All three anesthetics induce a similar weakening of sterol-phospholipid association, corresponding to ca. 30 cal/mol of lipid at clinically relevant concentrations. Monte Carlo lattice simulations show that the lateral organization of the l(o) phase, under such conditions, remains virtually unchanged. In sharp contrast to their action on the l(o) phase, these anesthetics have been found to have a similar strengthening effect on sterol-phospholipid association in the liquid-disordered (l(d)) phase. The possibility of discrete complexes being formed between DPPC and these anesthetics and the biological relevance of these findings are discussed.     

Interaction of 3β-amino-5-cholestene with phospholipids in binary and ternary bilayer membranes

3β-Amino-5-cholestene (aminocholesterol) is a synthetic sterol whose properties in bilayer membranes have been examined. In fluid palmitoyl sphingomyelin (PSM) bilayers, aminocholesterol and cholesterol were equally effective in increasing acyl chain order, based on changes in diphenylhexatriene (DPH) anisotropy. In fluid 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) bilayers, aminocholesterol ordered acyl chains, but slightly less efficiently than cholesterol. Aminocholesterol eliminated the PSM and DPPC gel-to-liquid crystalline phase transition enthalpy linearly with concentration, and the enthalpy approached zero at 30 mol % sterol. Whereas cholesterol was able to increase the thermostability of ordered PSM domains in a fluid bilayer, aminocholesterol under equal conditions failed to do this, suggesting that its interaction with PSM was not as favorable as cholesterols. In ternary mixed bilayers, containing 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC), PSM or DPPC, and cholesterol at proportions to contain a liquid-ordered phase (60:40 by mol of POPC and PSM or DPPC, and 30 mol % cholesterol), the average lifetime of trans-parinaric acid (tPA) was close to 20 ns. When cholesterol was replaced with aminocholesterol in such mixed bilayers, the average lifetime of tPA was only marginally shorter (about 18 ns). This observation, together with acyl chain ordering data, clearly shows that aminocholesterol was able to form a liquid-ordered phase with saturated PSM or DPPC. We conclude that aminocholesterol should be a good sterol replacement in model membrane systems for which a partial positive charge is deemed beneficial.     

Nonuniform lipid distribution in membranes

The noniform lateral and transbilayer lipid arrangement existing in two-component lipid bilayers are reviewed.

The lateral lipid organization is considered on the basis of the temperature-composition phase diagrams of the lipid binaries. A comparative analysis of the phase diagrams of synthetic phospholipid mixtures is carried out. The various types of the phase diagrams observed are set in a continuous row determined by the increase of the lipid lateral immiscibility. A special emphasis is laid on the appearance of peculiar points in the phase diagrams--triple, critical, and isoconcentration points. Two basic statistical-mechanical methods for simulation of phase diagrams--Bragg-Williams (regular solutions, mean field) and quasichemical--are compared. Stability criteria indicating the regions of lateral phase separation are also given. The main advantage of the quasichemical method is that it also allows the short-range order in the lipid arrangement to be determined.

The physical interactions contributing to an equilibrium lipid asymmetry in mixed lipid bilayers are pointed out. The most important among them are: (i) electrostatic forces induced by differences in the membrane electric double layers; (ii) nonideal lateral mixing of the lipids; (iii) packing restrictions important in curved bilayers.

A unified electrostatic model is presented to calculate the surface charge asymmetry created by any factors affecting the electric double layers of the bilayer (external electric potential, overlapping electric double layers in parallel membranes or in vescicles, etc.).

The transmembrane asymmetry strongly depends on the degree of c corrections may increase up two-three times the asymmetry induced by factors of the order of 1–3 kT. A typical nonideality effect, which may be used in an experimental verification, is the appearance of an extremum in the dependence of the asymmetry on the mole fraction of the components.

As previously shown in other reviews on membrane organization, the packing restrictions are of importance in highly curved bilayers, e.g., in small unilamellar vesicles.

The experimental data on the asymmetry of two-component small unilamellar vesicles are summarized and some general conclusions are formulated.

With a view toward the native membranes, some inferences are drawn about (i) the state of thermodynamic equilibrium and (ii) the lipid organization in multicomponent membranes.     

Nanoscale imaging of domains in supported lipid membranes

The formation of domains in supported lipid membranes has been studied extensively as a model for the 2D organization of cell membranes. The compartmentalization of biological membranes to give domains such as cholesterol-rich rafts plays an important role in many biological processes. This article summarizes experiments from the author's laboratory in which a combination of atomic force microscopy and near-field scanning optical microscopy is used to probe phase separation in supported monolayers and bilayers as models for membrane rafts. These techniques are used to study binary and ternary lipid mixtures that have gel-phase or liquid-ordered domains that vary in size from tens of nanometers to tens of micrometers, surrounded by a fluid-disordered membrane. Examples are presented in which these models are used to investigate the distribution of glycolipid membrane raft markers and the preference for peptide and protein localization in ordered versus fluid membrane phases. Finally, the enzyme-mediated restructuring of membranes containing liquid-ordered domains provides an in vitro model for the coalescence of membrane rafts to give signaling platforms. Overall, the results demonstrate the importance of using techniques that can probe the nanoscale organization of membranes and of combining techniques that yield complementary information. Furthermore, the ability of supported lipid bilayers to model some aspects of membrane compartmentalization provides an important approach to understanding natural membranes.     

Partitioning of dual-lipidated peptides into membrane microdomains: lipid sorting vs peptide aggregation

The lateral membrane organization and phase behavior of the lipid mixture DMPC(di-C(14))/DSPC(di-C(18))/cholesterol (0-33 mol %) with and without an incorporated fluorescence-labeled palmitoyl/farnesyl dual-lipidated peptide, BODIPY-Gly-Cys(Pal)-Met-Gly-Leu-Pro-Cys(Far)-OMe, which represents a membrane recognition model system for Ras proteins, was studied by two-photon excitation fluorescence microscopy. Measurements were performed on giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) over a large temperature range, ranging from 30 to 80 degrees C to cover different lipid phase states (all-gel, fluid/gel, liquid-ordered, all-fluid). At temperatures where the fluid-gel coexistence region of the pure binary phospholipid system occurs, large-scale concentration fluctuations appear. Incorporation of cholesterol levels up to 33 mol % leads to a significant increase of conformational order in the membrane system and a reduction of large domain structures. Adding the peptide leads to dramatic changes in the lateral organization of the membrane. With cholesterol present, a phase separation is induced by a lipid sorting mechanism owing to the high affinity of the lipidated peptide to a fluid, DMPC-rich environment. This phase separation leads to the formation of peptide-containing domains with high fluorescence intensity that become progressively smaller with decreasing temperature. As a result, the local concentration of the peptide increases steadily within the confines of the shrinking domains. At the lowest temperatures, where the acyl-chain order parameter of the membrane has already drastically increased and the membrane achieves a liquid-ordered character, an efficient lipid sorting mechanism is no longer supported and aggregation of the peptide into small clusters prevails. We can conclude that palmitoyl/farnesyl dual-lipidated peptides do not associate with liquid-ordered or gel-like domains in phase-separated bilayer membranes. In particular, the study shows the interesting ability of the peptide to induce formation of fluid microdomains at physiologically relevant cholesterol concentrations, and this effect very much depends on the concentration of fluid vs ordered lipid molecules.     

Dynamics imaging of lipid phases and lipid-marker interactions in model biomembranes

Biomembranes are complex systems that regulate numerous biological processes. Lipid phases that constitute these membranes influence their properties and transport characteristics. Here, we demonstrate the potential of short-range dynamics imaging (excited-state lifetime, rotational diffusion, and order parameter) as a sensitive probe of lipid phases in giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs). Liquid-disordered and gel phases were labeled with Bodipy-PC at room temperature. Two-photon fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy of single-phase GUVs reveals more heterogeneity in fluorescence lifetimes of Bodipy in the gel phase (DPPC: 3.8+/-0.6 ns) as compared with the fluid phase (DOPC: 5.2+/-0.2 ns). The phase-specificity of excited-state lifetime of Bodipy-PC is attributed to the stacking of ordered lipid molecules that possibly enhances homo-FRET. Fluorescence polarization anisotropy imaging also reveals distinctive molecular order that is phase specific. The results are compared with DiI-C12-labeled fluid GUVs to investigate the sensitivity of our fluorescence dynamics assay to different lipid-marker interactions. Our results provide a molecular perspective of lipid phase dynamics and the nature of their microenvironments that will ultimately help our understanding of the structure-function relationship of biomembranes in vivo. Furthermore, these ultrafast excited-state dynamics will be used for molecular dynamics simulation of lipid-lipid, lipid-marker and lipid-protein interactions.     

Effect of cholesterol on diffusion in surfactant bilayers

Biological membranes consist of lipid bilayers with liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered phases. It is believed that cholesterol controls the size of the microdomains in the liquid-ordered phase and thereby affects the mobility as well as the permeability of the membrane. We study this process in a model system consisting of the nonionic surfactant C(12)E(5) and water in the lamellar phase. We measure the diffusion of fluorescent probe molecules (rhodamine B) by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. For different surfactant to water ratios, we measure how the molecular mobility varies with the amount of cholesterol added. We find that a reduction of the diffusion coefficient is already detectable at a molar ratio of 8 mol % cholesterol.     

Using ionic strength to control liquid-ordered/liquid-disordered separation

In this Letter, we will show that liquid-ordered/liquid-disordered separation can be controlled with ionic strength. Using this observation, a robust method was developed for creating visible, by fluorescence microscopy, liquid-ordered domains in supported lipid bilayers. The details of the method will be discussed.     

Combined AFM and two-focus SFCS study of raft-exhibiting model membranes.

Dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/sphingomyelin/cholesterol (DOPC/SM/cholesterol) model membranes exhibit liquid-liquid phase separation and therefore provide a physical model for the putative liquid-ordered domains present in cells. Here we present a combination of atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging, force measurements, confocal fluorescence imaging and two-focus scanning fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (two-focus SFCS) to obtain structural and dynamical information about this model membrane system. Partition coefficients and diffusion coefficients in the different phases were measured with two-focus SFCS for numerous fluorescent lipid analogues and proteins, while being directly related to the lateral organization of the membrane and its mechanical properties probed by AFM. Moreover we show how the combination of these different approaches is effective in reducing artifacts resulting from the use of a single technique.     

Ethanol-induced reorganization of the liquid-ordered phase: enhancement of cholesterol-phospholipid association

This paper records what is believed to be the first evidence for the reorganization of the liquid-ordered phase by ethanol. Specifically, ethanol has been found to significantly enhance sterol-phospholipid association in liquid-ordered bilayers derived from 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) plus cholesterol and also 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DSPC) plus cholesterol. The evidence for such reorganization comes from a series of nearest-neighbor recognition (NNR) experiments that have been carried out, where low concentrations of equilibrating lipid dimers (i.e., "reporter molecules") have been used to detect changes in the phase composition of host membranes made from varying mixtures of DPPC/cholesterol, and also DSPC/cholesterol, in the presence and in the absence of ethanol. These findings have important biological implications, which are briefly discussed.     

Measuring lipid asymmetry in planar supported bilayers by fluorescence interference contrast microscopy

There is substantial scientific and practical interest in engineering supported lipid bilayers with asymmetric lipid distributions as models for biological cell membranes. In principle, it should be possible to make asymmetric supported lipid bilayers by either the Langmuir-Blodgett/Schafer (LB/LS) or Langmuir-Blodgett/vesicle fusion (LB/VF) techniques (Kalb et al. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1992, 1103, 307-316). However, the retention of asymmetry in biologically relevant lipid bilayers has never been experimentally examined in any of these systems. In the present work, we developed a technique that is based on fluorescence interference contrast (FLIC) microscopy to measure lipid asymmetry in supported bilayers. We compared the final degree of lipid asymmetry in LB/LS and LB/VF bilayers with and without cholesterol in liquid-ordered (l(o)) and liquid-disordered (l(d)) phases. Of five different fluorescent lipid probes that were examined, 1,2-dipalmitoyl-phosphatidylethanolamine-N-[lissamine rhodamine B] was the best for studying supported bilayers of complex composition and phase by FLIC microscopy. An asymmetrically labeled bilayer made by the LB/LS method was found to be at best 70-80% asymmetric once completed. In LB/LS bilayers of either l(o) or l(d) phase, cholesterol increased the degree of lipid mixing between the opposing monolayers. The use of a tethered polymer support for the initial monolayer did not improve lipid asymmetry in the resulting bilayer. However, asymmetric LB/VF bilayers retained nearly 100% asymmetric label, with or without the use of a tethered polymer support. Finally, lipid mixing across the center of LB/LS bilayers was found to have drastic effects on the appearance of l(d)-l(o) phase coexistence as shown by epifluorescence microscopy.     

Small-scale structure in fluid cholesterol–lipid bilayers

Cholesterol is the single most abundant molecule in animal plasma membranes, in the range of 20–30 mol%, where it is known to modulate the lipid-bilayer component of the membrane and lead to increased mechanical stability, lower permeability, larger thickness, and a distinct lateral organization. The phase equilibria of membranes with cholesterol and the associated large- and small-scale structure have turned out to be a particularly elusive problem. With the proposal that lipid domains and so-called ‘rafts’, characterized by high local levels of cholesterol in a liquid-ordered phase, are important for a wide range of cellular functions, an understanding and a quantitative assessment of the nature of these cholesterol-induced structures and their types of ordering have become urgent. Recent progress in neutron diffraction studies of lipid–cholesterol model membranes has now revealed details of the lateral ordering, and combined with earlier molecular model studies a picture emerges of the membrane as a locally structured liquid with small ordered ‘domains’ of a highly dynamic nature.     

Filipin orientation revealed by linear dichroism. Implication for a model of action

The organization of the polyene antibiotic filipin in membranes containing cholesterol is a controversial matter of debate. Two contradictory models exist, one suggesting a parallel and the other perpendicular organization of filipin with respect to the plane of the membrane. UV-vis linear dichroism, ATR-FTIR, and fluorescence anisotropy decay techniques were combined to study the orientation of filipin in model systems of membranes composed of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) or 1,2-palmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) with and without cholesterol. Filipin's orientation is determined by the presence/absence of cholesterol when it is inserted in gel crystalline phase model membranes. When cholesterol (33%) is present in DPPC bilayers, filipin stands perpendicular to the membrane surface as expected in "pore-forming" models. At variance, absence of cholesterol leaves filipin in an essentially random organization in the lipidic matrix. In liquid crystalline phase bilayers (POPC) filipin's orientation is perpendicular to the membrane surface even in absence of cholesterol. Thus filipin's activity/organization depends not only on cholesterol presence but also in the lipid phase domain it is inserted in. These findings were combined with spectroscopy and microscopy data in the literature, solving controversial matters of debate.     

Interleaflet interaction and asymmetry in phase separated lipid bilayers: molecular dynamics simulations

In order to investigate experimentally inaccessible, molecular-level detail regarding interleaflet interaction in membranes, we have run an extensive series of coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations of phase separated lipid bilayers. The simulations are motivated by differences in lipid and cholesterol composition in the inner and outer leaflets of biological membranes. Over the past several years, this phenomenon has inspired a series of experiments in model membrane systems which have explored the effects of lipid compositional asymmetry in the two leaflets. The simulations are directed at understanding one potential consequence of compositional asymmetry, that being regions of bilayers where liquid-ordered (L(o)) domains in one leaflet are opposite liquid-disordered (L(d)) domains in the other leaflet (phase asymmetry). The simulated bilayers are of two sorts: 1) Compositionally symmetric leaflets where each of the two leaflets contains an identical, phase separated (L(o)/L(d)) mixture of cholesterol, saturated and unsaturated phospholipid; and 2) Compositionally asymmetric leaflets, where one leaflet contains a phase separated (L(o)/L(d)) mixture while the other contains only unsaturated lipid, which on its own would be in the L(d) phase. In addition, we have run simulations where the lengths of the saturated lipid chains as well as the mole ratios of the three lipid components are varied. Collectively, we report on three types of interleaflet coupling within a bilayer. First, we show the effects of compositional asymmetry on acyl chain tilt and order, lipid rotational dynamics, and lateral diffusion in regions of leaflets that are opposite L(o) domains. Second, we show substantial effects of compositional asymmetry on local bilayer curvature, with the conclusion that phase separated leaflets resist curvature, while inducing large degrees of curvature in an opposing L(d) leaflet. Finally, in compositionally symmetric, phase separated bilayers, we find phase asymmetry (domain antiregistration) between the two leaflets occurs as a consequence of mismatched acyl chain-lengths in the saturated and unsaturated lipids.     

Phase and mixing behavior in two-component lipid bilayers: a molecular dynamics study in DLPC/DSPC mixtures

Phase and mixing behavior of dilauroylphosphatidylcholine (DLPC)/distearoylphosphatidylcholine (DSPC) lipid mixtures are studied by molecular dynamics simulations with use of a coarse-grained model over a wide range of concentrations. The results reveal that phase transformations from the fluid to the gel state can be followed over a microsecond time scale. The changes in structure suggest regions of phase coexistence allowing us to outline the entire phase diagram for this lipid mixture using a molecular based model. We show that simulations yield good agreement with the experimental phase diagram. We also address the effect of macroscopic phase separation on the determination of the transition temperature, different leaflet composition, and finite size effects. This study may have implications on lateral membrane organization and the associated processes dependent on these membrane regions on different time and length scales.     

Visualizing association of N-ras in lipid microdomains: influence of domain structure and interfacial adsorption

In this study, two-photon fluorescence microscopy on giant unilamellar vesicles and tapping-mode atomic force microscopy (AFM) are applied to follow the insertion of a fluorescently (4,4-difluoro-4-bora-3a,4a-diaza-s-indacene, BODIPY) labeled and completely lipidated (hexadecylated and farnesylated) N-Ras protein into heterogeneous lipid bilayer systems. The bilayers consist of the canonical raft mixture 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC), sphingomyelin, and cholesterol, which-depending on the concentration of the constituents-separates into liquid-disordered (l(d)), liquid-ordered (l(o)), and solid-ordered (s(o)) phases. The results provide direct evidence that partitioning of N-Ras occurs preferentially into liquid-disordered lipid domains, which is also reflected in a faster kinetics of incorporation into the fluid lipid bilayers. The phase sequence of preferential binding of N-Ras to mixed-domain lipid vesicles is l(d) > l(o) > s(o). Intriguingly, we detect, using the better spatial resolution of AFM, also a large proportion of the lipidated protein located at the l(d)/l(o) phase boundary, thus leading to a favorable decrease in line tension that is associated with the rim of the demixed phases. Such an interfacial adsorption effect may serve as an alternative vehicle for association processes of signaling proteins in membranes.     

Unusual fluorescence spectral response of 1-(4-N,N-dimethylaminophenylethynyl)pyrene towards the thermotropic phase change in lipid bilayer membranes

The applicability of 1-(4-N,N-dimethylaminophenylethynyl)pyrene (DMAPEPy), a pyrene derivative showing intramolecular charge transfer, as a prospective probe for lipid bilayer membranes has been evaluated. High sensitivity of DMAPEPy to solvent polarity and viscosity makes it to act both as a polarity-sensitive probe and as a fluorescence anisotropy probe. The molecule shows high partition efficiency towards bilayer membranes in both solid gel as well as in the liquid crystalline phases. The emission spectrum, quenching experiment and lifetime data suggest bimodal distribution of DMAPEPy in the bilayer. Using the solvent polarity scales the polarity parameters of the two locations in lipid bilayer have been estimated. In the bilayer environment it exhibits remarkable spectral changes with temperature. The thermotropic phase change of the bilayer is sensitively monitored by fluorescence intensity as well as fluorescence anisotropy parameters. DMAPEPy is also capable of sensing the changes induced by membrane modifiers like cholesterol.