Narrow-band fractionation of proteins from whole cell lysates using isoelectric membrane focusing and nonporous reversed-phase separations

Preparative isoelectric focusing (PIEF) is used to achieve narrow-band fractionation of proteins from whole cell lysates of Escherichia coli (E. coli). Isoelectric membranes create well-defined pH ranges that fractionate proteins by isoelectric point (pI) upon application of an electric potential. A commercial IsoPrime device (Amersham-Pharmacia BioTech) is modified for the PIEF separation to lessen run volumes significantly. Two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2-D PAGE) analysis of chamber contents indicates that excellent pH fractionation is achieved with little overlap between chambers. PIEF pH fractions are further separated using nonporous reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (NPS-RP-HPLC) and HPLC eluent is analyzed on-line by electrospray ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry (ESI-TOF-MS) for intact protein molecular weight (MW) analysis. The result is a pI versus MW map of bacterial protein content. IEF fractionation down to 0.1 pH units combined with intact protein MW values result in a highly reproducible map that can be used for comparative analysis of different E. coli strains.     

Integration of capillary isoelectric focusing with capillary reversed-phase liquid chromatography for two-dimensional proteomics separation

On-line combination of capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) with capillary reversed-phase liquid chromatography (CRPLC) is developed using a microinjector as the interface for performing two-dimensional (2-D) protein/peptide separations of complex protein mixtures. The focusing effect of CIEF not only contributes to a high-resolution protein/peptide separation, but also may permit the analysis of low-abundance proteins with a typical concentration factor of 50-100 times. The preparative capabilities of CIEF are much larger than most of capillary-based electrokinetic separation techniques since the entire capillary is initially filled with a solution containing proteins/peptides and carrier ampholytes for the creation of a pH gradient inside the capillary. The focused peptides which have a similar pI are coinjected into the second separation dimension and further resolved by their differences in hydrophobicity. The resolving power of combined CIEF-CRPLC system is demonstrated using the soluble fraction of Drosophila salivary glands taken from a period beginning before steroid-triggered programmed cell death and extending to its completion. The separation mechanisms of CIEF and CRPLC are completely orthogonal and the overall peak capacity is estimated to be around approximately 1800 over a run time of less than 8 h. Significant enhancement in the separation peak capacity can be realized by further increasing the number of CIEF fractions and/or slowing the solvent gradient in CRPLC, however, at the expense of overall analysis time. The results of our preliminary studies display significant differences in the separation profiles of peptide samples obtained from salivary glands of animals staged at the 6 and 12 h following puparium formation.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional separation in coupling of reversed-phase chromatography with capillary isoelectric focusing followed by MALDI-MS identification using on-target digestion for intact protein analysis

A coupling of capillary RP LC as the first dimension with CIEF as the second dimension followed by MALDI-MS identification was demonstrated. Based on 2-D separation system developed by our group (Electrophoresis 2003, 24, 3289-3295), this paper focused on incorporating tryptic digestion into the top-down proteomics methodology, retaining the benefits of the top-down method. Hydrophobic layer of packing-material C18 coated with SE-30 on the MALDI-target surface was used to permit the CIEF fractions to be easily concentrated and free of ampholytes using on-target washing. Following the removal of ampholytes, on-target tryptic digestion was performed to generate PMF for protein identification. Using the proteome analytical strategy, we could obtain not only intact protein pI value but also PMF for accurate protein identification. The feasibility of the strategy was first tested with a mixture of model proteins with different pIs and molecular masses. Proteome of rat liver tissue extracts was further analyzed using the system for verification. The results have shown that the system is effective for complex proteomic analysis.     

Miniaturization of capillary isoelectric focusing.

Miniaturization of whole-column imaging capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) is discussed. A 1.2 cm capillary was used as a separation column for CIEF. The experimental results for the analysis of two pI markers and the protein myoglobin showed that good CIEF separation results could be obtained. Secondly, a light-emitting diode (LED) was used as the light source for the whole-column absorbance imaging detection. The focusing of both the pI markers and myoglobin were observed with the LED light source. The whole-column imaging CIEF instrument was simplified and miniaturized by the use of the LED. Further developments are also discussed.     

Separation and quantitation of milk whey proteins of close isoelectric points by on-line capillary isoelectric focusing--electrospray ionization mass spectrometry in glycerol-water media

On-line coupling between CIEF and ESI/MS based on the use of bare fused-silica capillaries and glycerol-water media, recently developed in our laboratory, has been investigated for the separation of milk whey proteins that present close pI values. First, a new rinsing procedure, compatible with MS detection, has been developed to desorb these rather hydrophobic proteins (α-casein (α-CN), bovine serum albumin (BSA), lactoferrin (LF)) from the inner capillary wall and to avoid capillary blockages. Common hydrochloric acid washing solution was replaced by a multi-step sequence based on the use of TFA, ammonia and ethanol. To achieve the separation of major whey proteins (β-lactoglobulin A (β-LG A), β-lactoglobulin B (β-LG B), α-lactalbumin (α-LA) and BSA, which possess close pI values (4.5-5.35), CIEF parameters i.e. carrier ampholyte nature, capillary partial filling length with ampholyte/protein mixture and focusing time, have been optimized with respect to total analysis time, sensitivity and precision on pI determination. After optimization of sheath liquid composition (80:20 (v/v) methanol-water+1% HCOOH), quantitation of β-LG A, β-LG B, α-LA and BSA was performed. The limits of detection obtained from extracted ion current (EIC) and single ion monitoring (SIM) modes were in the 57-136 nM and 11-68 nM range, respectively. Finally, first results obtained from biological samples demonstrated the suitability of CIEF-MS as a potential alternative methodology to 2D-PAGE to diagnose milk protein allergies.     

Profiling recombinant major birch pollen allergen Bet v 1a and carbamylated variants with CZE and CIEF

A preparation of recombinant birch pollen allergen of Betula verrucosa isoform 1a (Bet v 1a) containing chemically modified (carbamylated) variants has been analyzed by CZE and CIEF. In CZE, employing a 100 mmol/L MES buffer at pH 6.50, with 0.4 mmol/L tetraethylenepentamine (TEPA) added, allowed for the resolution of 17 protein fractions. The CIEF profiling of the allergen preparation required a combination of a wide-pH-range carrier ampholyte (CA) of pH 3-10 with two narrow-range CAs of pH 5-6 and 5-7. For CIEF, 91 mmol/L of glycine at pH 2.12 and 20 mmol/L of CHES at pH 10.00 were applied as anolyte and catholyte, respectively. The generated pH gradient was nonlinear with a flat slope for pH 4-6, thus providing an improved resolution. In CIEF, up to 18 protein fractions were distinguished as well. The pI of the target allergen Bet v 1a was 4.9 as determined by means of two pI marker compounds flanking the allergen. Relative purity of the target allergen within the preparation containing carbamylated variants was in accordance for both separation systems and varied between 40.7 and 42.8%.     

Isoelectric focusing nonporous silica reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography/electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry: a three-dimensional liquid-phase protein separation method as applied to the human erythroleukemia cell-line

A liquid-phase three-dimensional protein separation method has been developed that is used to separate the cytosolic fraction of a HEL cell lysate via isoelectric focusing (IEF), nonporous silica (NPS) reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) and electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (ESI-TOFMS), respectively. Several hundred unique protein molecular weights were observed in a pI range from 4.8 to 8.5 and a mass range from 5 to 85 kDa. Proteins were positively identified by analysis of the pI (+/-0.5 pI units), an intact protein molecular weight (+/-150 ppm), and peptide mass mapping results. Using the molecular weight (MW) and peptide mapping results of identified proteins it was possible to characterize their posttranslational (PTMs) and/or sequence modifications. PTMs were detected on both forms of cytosolic actin, heat shock 90 beta, HINT and alpha-enolase. Sequence modifications or conflicts were observed for beta-and gamma-actin, ATP beta-synthase and heat shock 90 beta. IEF-NPS-RP-HPLC/ESI-TOFMS was used to determine experimental pI, MW and relative hydrophobicity values for each protein detected. This data was used to generate a 2-D pI-MS protein map, where proteins are displayed according to their pI and molecular weight. Protein molecular weight peaks are represented as bands in the 2-D pI-MS image where the gray scale of each band is proportional to the intensity of the protein molecular weight peak. In addition, a third hydrophobicity dimension (%B) was added as the % acetonitrile elution to generate a 3-D pI-MS-%B plot where each protein can be tagged according to three parameters.     

Estimation of isoelectric points of human plasma proteins employing capillary isoelectric focusing and peptide isoelectric point markers

Synthetic UV-detectable peptide pI markers were used to estimate isoelectric point (pI) values of proteins separated by capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) followed by cathodic mobilization in the absence of denaturing agents. The pI calculation and quantitative analysis of purified proteins showed the feasibility of these peptides as pI markers and internal standards in CIEF separation of proteins. Estimation of pI values of major proteins in human plasma was performed using the peptide pI markers, and the values were compared with those previously obtained by gel isoelectric focusing (IEF). Sera of immunoglobulin G (IgG) myeloma patients, which showed characteristic peaks of myeloma IgG in their CIEF patterns, were also subjected to the analysis and the pI values of the myeloma proteins have been estimated.     

Fluorescein-based pI markers for capillary isoelectric focusing with laser-induced fluorescence detection

We prepared a series of low-molecular-mass fluorescent ampholytes with narrow pI range. These fluorescein-based ampholytes are detection compatible with argon laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) detection. The selected properties, important for their routine use as fluorescent pI markers, were examined. The pI values of new fluorescein-based pI markers were determined by capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) using currently available low-molecular-mass pI markers for CIEF with photometric detection. The examples of CIEF with fluorometric detection of new compounds together with fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) derivatized proteins are presented.     

Evaluation of capillary isoelectric focusing in glycerol-water media with a view to hydrophobic protein applications

Capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) separations are usually performed with neutral coated fused-silica capillaries in aqueous anticonvective media. Glycerol, a very viscous solvent (eta = 945 mPa x s at 25 degrees C), known to help stabilize any kind of proteins and solubilize hydrophobic ones, was tested as an alternative to using commercial gels. Viscosity and electroosmotic mobility were measured as a function of gel or glycerol content in water, and a 30:70 v/v glycerol-water medium appeared as a good compromise for performing CIEF in a bare fused-silica capillary without imposing too high a viscosity. To demonstrate the feasibility of this new CIEF system, a standard mixture of nine model proteins was separated according to their pI with a good agreement between experimental and literature aqueous pIs. Moreover, better resolution was achieved with this system than with the conventional aqueous CIEF system, as two of the model proteins could not be separated in the latter system. Glycerol-water CIEF in bare silica capillary was next applied to the separation of horse radish peroxidase, a complex mixture of protein isoforms. The good concordance with the separation obtained by the conventional CIEF system indicated the adequacy of this new system. Finally, as anticipated from the results obtained for the separation of bacteriorhodopsin, a membrane protein, glycerol-water CIEF performed in bare silica capillary appears to be a promising alternative to conventional aqueous CIEF for hydrophobic protein characterization, under their native form.     

Miniaturized capillary isoelectric focusing in plastic microfluidic devices

We report the demonstration of miniaturized capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) in plastic microfluidic devices. Conventional CIEF technique was adapted to the microfluidic devices to separate proteins and to detect protein-protein interactions. Both acidic and basic proteins with isoelectric points (pI) ranging from 5.4 to 11.0 were rapidly focused, mobilized, and detected in a 1.2 cm long channel (50 microm deep x 120 microm wide) with a total analysis time of 150 s. In a device with a focusing distance of 4.7 cm, the separation efficiency for a basic protein, lysozyme, was achieved as high as 1.5 x 10(5) plates, corresponding to 3.2 million plates per meter. We also experimentally confirmed that IEF resolution is essentially independent of focusing length when the applied voltage is kept the same and within a range that it does not cause Joule heating. Further, we demonstrated the use of miniaturized CIEF to study the interactions between two pairs of proteins, immunoglobulin G (IgG) with protein G and anti-six histidine (anti-6xHis) with 6xHis-tagged green fluorescent protein (GFP). Using this approach, protein-protein interactions can be detected for as little as 50 fmol of protein. We believe miniaturized CIEF is useful for studying protein-protein interactions when there is a difference in pI between a protein-protein complex and its constitutent proteins.     

Capillary isoelectric focusing--reproducibility and protein adsorption

Capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) is an important tool for the quality assurance of biotechnologically maintained drugs and for proteome analysis. The critical performance parameters of this technique are the precisions of isoelectric point (pI) values and peak areas. Compared to capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE), where precise results can be obtained (e.g., 0.5% relative standard deviation (RSD) for peak areas, n = 60), only few data are available for CIEF experiments. So far, reproducible data of pI values (RSD = 0.5%) have been acquired, but peak areas show inferior results (about 3-15% RSD). Nonstable capillary coatings and protein adsorption have been discussed as possible reasons. Recent work of Righetti et al. [25, 27] has proven that the use of coated capillaries can reduce the adsorption of proteins by 50% but cannot prevent it. In our CIEF experiments irregular and poorly reproducible peak patterns have been observed. In a long-time experiment of 106 repeated runs, an overall RSD of 10% was obtained for peak areas, RSD of 2% only in series of about 10 consecutive replicates. Especially at higher concentrations the reproducibility deteriorates. This seems to be the result of a self-amplifying process, induced by adsorbed protein molecules, leading to further agglomerations. CZE control experiments in linear polyacrylamide (LPA)-coated capillaries proved a strong pH dependency of these effects within a small range. Compared to bare fused-silica surfaces, adsorption effects are reduced but not inhibited. An enhancement of reproducibility in CIEF experiments can be achieved only by controlling the interactions of proteins and capillary walls.     

Application of capillary isoelectric focusing and peptide mass fingerprinting in carbohydrate-deficient transferrin detection

Carbohydrate-deficient transferrin (CDT) is a specific biomarker of alcohol abuse and is widely used in clinical diagnosis to detect and follow up excessive alcohol consumption. However, false %CDT results still exist in CDT detection, because of interference from genetic variants and the lack of standardization in CDT analysis. Therefore, it is still very important to find a method with high sensitivity and high accuracy for CDT detection. Here, we compared the detection sensitivity and accuracy of pI values based methods [isoelectric focusing on polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (IEF-PAGE) and capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF)] with hydrophobic characteristic based methods [reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC)] on CDT detection. Moreover, we investigated the potential of peptide mass fingerprinting (PMF), a method based on the mass spectrometry to identify human transferrin (HTf) variants including CDT isoforms and genetic variants, based on their specific peptide masses. Results indicated that PMF can identify HTf variants including CDT isoforms and genetic variants based on their specific peptides, and CIEF showed higher sensitivity detection of HTf variants than RP-HPLC and IEF-PAGE did. Accordingly, we suggest that PMF is suitable for identifying CDT with high accuracy, and CIEF has potential for detection of CDT and genetic variants with high sensitivity; moreover, they are both worth further investigation in clinical diagnosis.     

Characterization of antithrombin III from human plasma by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and capillary electrophoretic methods

The isoforms distribution of the glycoprotein antithrombin III (ATIII) derived from human plasma was investigated by means of isoelectric focusing (IEF) in polyacrylamide gels with immobilized pH gradients (IPG) and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) as well as capillary electrophoretic methods. It turned out that the presence of high concentrations of chaotropics (urea, thiourea) and zwitterionic detergents (3-[(3-cholamidepropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate (CHAPS)) was decisive for attaining good resolution of the protein isoforms. Resolution by IPG-IEF was obtained with excellent reproducibility and pI differences down to 0.01 pH units could be distinguished. ATIII-alpha and ATIII-beta-fractions preseparated by heparin affinity chromatography showed an analogous but shifted spot pattern consisting each of one major and three minor isoforms. The main isoforms of ATIII-alpha and ATIII-beta exhibit pI values of 5.18 and 5.32, respectively, both values determined in the presence of high concentrations of urea. The pI difference of 0.14 pH units correspond to the effect of two sialic acids absent in ATIII-beta. The formation and occurrence of ATIII dimers and trimers turned out to be dependent on the sample preparation. The results obtained by 2-DE were compared with those of capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) and capillary IEF (CIEF). Quantitative analysis regarding the CZE separated isoforms of plasma derived ATIII yielded a content of about 70% ATIII-alpha main isoform and about 6.6% of ATIII-beta. The pI values of ATIII determined by CIEF with internal calibration were in fair agreement with the pI values of the main isoforms achieved with 2-DE.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional separation system by coupling capillary reverse-phase liquid chromatography to capillary isoelectric focusing for peptide and protein mapping with laser-induced fluorescence detection

A comprehensive two-dimensional (2-D) separation system, coupling capillary reverse-phase liquid chromatography (cRPLC) to capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), is described for protein and peptide mapping. cRPLC, the first dimension, provided high-resolution separations for salt-free proteins. CIEF, the second dimension with an orthogonal mechanism to cRPLC afforded excellent resolution capability for proteins with efficient protein enrichment. Since all sample fractions in cRPLC effluents could be transferred to the CIEF dimensions, the combination of the two high-efficiency separations resulted in maximal separation capabilities of each dimension. Separation effectiveness of this approach was demonstrated using complex protein/peptide samples, such as yeast cytosol and a BSA tryptic digest. A peak capacity of more than 10 000 had been achieved. A laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) detector, developed for this system, allowed for high-sensitive detection, with a fmol level of peptide detection for the BSA digest. FITC and BODIPY maleimide were used to tag the proteins, and the latter was found better both for separation and detection in our 2-D system.     

Separation of hemoglobin variants with similar charge by capillary isoelectric focusing: value of isoelectric point for identification of common and uncommon hemoglobin variants

Clinical assays for the primary evaluation of congenital hemoglobin (Hb) disorders must detect and identify a variety of Hb variants. We analyzed hemolysates containing Hb variants with similar charge to evaluate the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of automated capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF). Peak separation was observed for each variant in samples containing Hb S, D, and G. The calculated isoelectric points (pI) of these variants were significantly different such that each could be identified in a single run with pI as the sole criterion of identification. The pI of Hb C was significantly different from that of Hb E, C-Harlem, and O-Arab. Hb E, C-Harlem, and O-Arab had similar pI and were not readily differentiated. Hb Koln, M-Saskatoon, Aida, and S/Aida hybrid were readily separated from common Hb variants and detected by CIEF. We conclude that CIEF exhibits both diagnostic sensitivity and specificity, and that pI is an objective and specific criterion of Hb variant identification.     

Synthetic oligopeptides as isoelectric point markers for capillary isoelectric focusing with ultraviolet absorption detection

Sixteen peptides (trimers to hexamers) were designed for use as a set of pI markers for capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF). Each peptide contains one tryptophan residue for detection by UV absorption and other amino acid residues having ionic side chains, which are responsible for focusing to its pI. The pIs of these peptides were determined by slab-gel IEF using commercial carrier ampholytes. The focused peptides in the gel were detected by absorption measurement at 280 nm using a scanning densitometer and the pH gradient was determined by measuring the pH of the gel using an oxidized metal membrane electrode. The pI values of the peptides ranged from 3.38 to 10.17. The obtained values agreed well with the predicted ones, which were calculated based on amino acid compositions, with root mean square differences of 0.15 pH unit. The peptides were detected at 280 nm as very sharp peaks when separated by CIEF. The pI values of some standard proteins were redetermined by CIEF by using this set of peptide pI markers and the values agreed closely with those reported previously. The sharp focusing, stability, high purity and high solubility of these synthetic pI markers should facilitate the profiling of a pH gradient in a capillary and the determination of the pI values of proteins.     

Integration of capillary isoelectric focusing with monolithic immobilized pH gradient,immobilized trypsin microreactor and capillary zone electrophoresis for on‐line protein analysis

An integrated platform consisting of protein separation by CIEF with monolithic immobilized pH gradient (M‐IPG), on‐line digestion by trypsin‐based immobilized enzyme microreactor (trypsin‐IMER), and peptide separation by CZE was established. In such a platform, a tee unit was used not only to connect M‐IPG CIEF column and trypsin‐IMER, but also to supply adjustment buffer to improve the compatibility of protein separation and digestion. Another interface was made by a Teflon tube with a nick to couple IMER and CZE via a short capillary, which was immerged in a centrifuge tube filled with 20 mmol/L glutamic acid, to exchange protein digests buffer and keep electric contact for peptide separation. By such a platform, under the optimal conditions, a mixture of ribonuclease A, myoglobin and BSA was separated into 12 fractions by M‐IPG CIEF, followed by on‐line digestion by trypsin‐IMER and peptide separation by CZE. Many peaks of tryptic peptides, corresponding to different proteins, were observed with high UV signals, indicating the excellent performance of such an integrated system. We hope that the CE‐based on‐line platform developed herein would provide another powerful alternative for an integrated analysis of proteins.     

Element of a validation method for MU-B3 monoclonal antibody using an imaging capillary isoelectric focusing system

This paper presents an imaging capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) assay for the determination of the identity, stability, and isoform distribution of a murine monoclonal antibody (MU-B3). The experiments were conducted using a Convergent Bioscience iCE280 instrument. The optimum carrier ampholyte composition that gave the best peak separation was found to be 25% Pharmalyte pH 3-10 and 75% Pharmalyte pH 5-8. The antibody gave a highly reproducible CIEF profile with three major peaks having average isoelectric point (pI) values of 6.83, 6.99, and 7.11. Intraday and interday reproducibility of pI values was found to be within RSD of 0.5%. The CIEF profile was also the same, with an alternate column cartridge and alternate batches of methyl cellulose. A plot of peak areas versus MU-B3 concentration was linear (R2 = 0.995) up to a concentration of 0.5 mg/mL in the sample solution. Peak area measurements were reproducible to within 7% RSD. The CIEF profiles of two other antibodies were distinctly different from the profile of MU-B3, showing that the assay is specific. After a sample of MU-B3 was subjected to heat stress by exposure to heat at 55 degrees C for 4 h, its CIEF profile was altered with extra peaks appearing at lower pI values, indicating that the assay could be used to monitor stability. The result of the heat stress experiment was also confirmed with a parallel slab-gel IEF analysis of the antibody sample before and after application of the heat stress. The results of this work suggest that imaging CIEF can be used for product testing under a quality control environment. The assay can be used for pI profiling of proteins and for monitoring structural changes (deamidation, glycosylation, etc.) during the manufacturing process and upon storage.     

Interference‐free mass spectrometric detection of capillary isoelectric focused proteins,including charge variants of a model monoclonal antibody

CIEF represents an elegant technique especially for the separation of structural similar analytes, whereas MS is a state‐of‐the‐art instrumentation for the identification and characterization of biomolecules. The combination of both techniques can be realized by hyphenating CIEF with CZE‐ESI‐MS applying a mechanical valve. During the CZE step, the remaining ESI‐interfering components of the CIEF electrolyte are separated from the analytes prior to MS detection. In this work, a multiple heart‐cut approach is presented expanding our previous single heart‐cut concept resulting in a dramatical reduction of analysis time. Moreover, different sample transfer loop volumes are systematically compared and discussed in regard to peak width and transfer efficiency. With this major enhancement, model proteins (1.63–9.75 mg/L), covering a wide pI range (5–10), and charge variants from a deglycosylated model antibody were analyzed on intact level. The promising CIEF‐CZE‐MS setup is expected to be applicable in different bioanalytical fields, e.g. for the fast and information rich characterization of therapeutic antibodies.