Reducing abstraction: The case of constructing an operation table for a group

This paper describes students' mental processes while constructing an operation table for a group. More specifically, undergraduate students' approaches are analyzed as the students fill in an operation table for four elements—a, b, c, and d—in such a way that it represents a group of order four. The data are analyzed from the perspective of reducing abstraction, which aims to explain students' conceptions of abstract algebra concepts. From this perspective, most students' responses and conceptions can be attributed to their tendency to work on a lower level of abstraction than the level on which concepts are introduced in class.     

Three women's understandings of algebra in a precalculus course integrated with the graphing calculator

This study investigated the role of function in a precalculus classroom which incorporated the graphing calculator in the instructional process. Perspectives were taken from students, teachers, and textbooks. Emphasis was placed on choice of functional symbol system when thinking and problem solving, connections across symbol systems, the role of the instructor and the textbook in learning, affective components, and the effect of the graphing calculator.The study starts with a defination of the concept of structure as it relates to function. The account of a semester-long qualitative study on students' concept images of function and its role in problem solving follows. It was found that the students involved in the study entered the graph-intensive course with predominantly symbolic notions of algebra, in part due to prior instruction. The students also possessed highly procedural views of algebraic content. These preconceptions and expectations resulted in the students' inability to effectively coordinate graphic and symbolic notions of algebra, both in procedural and conceptual realms. Implications and curricular suggestions are provided.     

Effects of variation theory approach in teaching and learning of algebra on urban and rural students’ algebraic achievement and motivation

This study investigates the effect of utilizing variation theory approach (VTA) on students' algebraic achievement and their motivation in learning algebra. The study used quasi-experimental non-equivalent control group research design. It involved 114 Form Two students in four intact classes (two classes were from an urban school, another two classes from a rural school). The first group of students from each school learnt algebra in class which used the VTA, while the second group of students in each school learnt algebra through conventional teaching approach. Two-way analysis of covariance and two-way multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) were used to analyse the data collected. The result of this study indicated that the use of VTA has significant effect on both urban and rural students' algebraic achievement. There were evidences that VTA has significant effect on rural VTA students' overall motivation in its five subscales: attention, relevance, confidence, satisfaction and interest but it was not so for urban VTA students' motivation. This study provides further empirical evidence that utilization of variation theory as pedagogical guide can promote the teaching and learning of Form Two Algebra topics in urban and rural secondary school classrooms.     

Gestures,Speech, and the Sprouting of Signs: A Semiotic-Cultural Approach to Students' Types of Generalization

To improve our understanding of novice students' production of symbolic algebraic expressions, this article contrasts students' presymbolic and symbolic procedures in generalizing activities. Although a significant amount of previous research on the learning of algebra has dealt with students' errors in the mastering of the algebraic syntax, the semiotic cultural theoretical approach presented here focuses on the role that body, discourse, and signs play when students' refer to mathematical objects. Three types of generalizations are identified: factual, contextual, and symbolic. The results suggest that the passage from presymbolic to symbolic generalizations requires a specific kind of rupture with the ostensive gestures and contextually based key linguistic terms underpinning presymbolic generalizations. This rupture means a disembodiment of the students' previous spatial temporal embodied mathematical experience.     

Learning the Algebraic Method of Solving Problems

This study of students' attempts to formulate and solve algebra word problems shows that the logic underlying algebraic problem solving methods is little understood. Students' prior experiences with solving problems in arithmetic gives them a compulsion to calculate which is manifested in the meaning they give to “the unknown” and how they use letters, their interpretation of what an equation is, and the methods they choose to solve equations. At every stage of the process of solving problems by algebra, students were deflected from the algebraic path by reverting to thinking grounded in arithmetic problem solving methods.     

Is There Something to be Gained from Guessing? Middle School Students' Use of Systematic Guess and Check

This article will share results from research that investigated how sixth‐, seventh‐, and eighth‐grade students who had not been exposed to formal algebraic methods approached word problems of an algebraic nature. Student use of systematic guess and check, the predominate approach taken by these students, is the focus. The goal is to consider the students' use of systematic guess and check reasoning in terms of the broadening perspective of algebra and algebraic thinking by highlighting ways in which this reasoning can provide a basis for developing some of the thinking patterns and discourse of formal algebra. Two perspectives will be highlighted: relationships among quantities and function‐based reasoning.     

Examining the Conceptual Organization of Students in an Integrated Algebra and Physical Science Class

The cross-disciplinary context of density and slope was used to compare the conceptual organization of students in an integrated algebra and physical science class (SAM9) with that of students in a discipline-specific physical science class (PSO). Analyses of students' concept maps indicated that the SAM9 students used a greater number of procedural linkages to connect mathematics and science concepts on the SAM9 students' maps than did the PSO students. The maps produced by SAM9 students also tended to show a more compartmentalized approach to thinking about the content of the two disciplines, a finding contrary to the researcher's original assertion. Traditional teaching territories and conceptual complexity were examined as possible explanations for the discrepancy between the predicted and actual outcomes.     

Components of Place Value Understanding: Targeting Mathematical Difficulties When Providing Interventions

Place value understanding requires the same activity that students use when developing fractional and algebraic reasoning, making this understanding foundational to mathematics learning. However, many students engage successfully in mathematics classrooms without having a conceptual understanding of place value, preventing them from accessing mathematics that is more sophisticated later. The purpose of this exploratory study is to investigate how upper elementary students' unit coordination related to difficulties they experience when engaging in place value tasks. Understanding place value requires that students coordinate units recursively to construct multi‐digit numbers from their single‐digit number understandings through forms of unit development and strategic counting. Findings suggest that students identified as low‐achieving were capable of only one or two levels of unit coordination. Furthermore, these students relied on inaccurate procedures to solve problems with millennial numbers. These findings indicate that upper elementary students identified as low‐achieving are not to yet able to (de)compose numbers effectively, regroup tens and hundreds when operating on numbers, and transition between millennial numbers. Implications of this study suggest that curricula designers and statewide standards should adopt nuances in unit coordination when developing tasks that promote or assess students' place value understanding.     

Flexible thinking and met-befores: Impact on learning mathematics

In this paper we study the difficulties resulting from changes in meaning of the minus sign, from an operation on numbers, to a sign designating a negative number, to the additive inverse of an algebraic symbol on students in two-year colleges and universities. Analysis of the development of algebra reveals that these successive meanings that the student has met before often become problematic, leading to a fragile knowledge structure that lacks flexibility and leads to confusion and long-term disaffection. The problematic aspects that arise from changes in meaning of the minus sign are identified and the iconic function machine is utilized as a supportive strategy, along with formative assessment to encourage teachers and learners to seek more flexible and effective ways of making sense of increasingly sophisticated mathematics.     

Middle Grades Students' Algebraic Understanding in a Reform Curriculum

The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics' Curriculum and Evaluation Standards in 1989 was pivotal in mathematics reform. The National Science Foundation funded several curriculum projects to address the vision described in the Standards. This study investigates students' learning in one of these Standards‐based curricula, the Connected Mathematics Project (CMP). The authors of CMP believe that the teaching and learning of algebra is an ongoing activity woven through the entire curriculum, rather than being parceled into a single grade level. The content of the study investigates students' ability to symbolically generalize functions. The data regards the solutions of four performance tasks dealing with three different types of relationships—linear, quadratic, and exponential situations—completed by five pairs of eighth‐grade students. The major finding claims that middle to high achieving students who had 3 years in the CMP curriculum demonstrated achievement in five strands of mathematical proficiency of a significant piece of algebra.     

Teaching of real numbers by using the Archimedes–Cantor approach and computer algebra systems

Computer technologies and especially computer algebra systems (CAS) allow students to overcome some of the difficulties they encounter in the study of real numbers. The teaching of calculus can be considerably more effective with the use of CAS provided the didactics of the discipline makes it possible to reveal the full computational potential of CAS. In the case of real numbers, the Archimedes–Cantor approach satisfies this requirement. The name of Archimedes brings back the exhaustion method. Cantor's name reminds us of the use of Cauchy rational sequences to represent real numbers. The usage of CAS with the Archimedes–Cantor approach enables the discussion of various representations of real numbers such as graphical, decimal, approximate decimal with precision estimates, and representation as points on a straight line. Exercises with numbers such as e, π, the golden ratio ?, and algebraic irrational numbers can help students better understand the real numbers. The Archimedes–Cantor approach also reveals a deep and close relationship between real numbers and continuity, in particular the continuity of functions.     

Instructional Supports for Representational Fluency in Solving Linear Equations with Computer Algebra Systems and Paper‐and‐Pencil

This research addresses the issue of how to support students' representational fluency—the ability to create, move within, translate across, and derive meaning from external representations of mathematical ideas. The context of solving linear equations in a combined computer algebra system (CAS) and paper‐and‐pencil classroom environment is targeted as a rich and pressing context to study this issue. We report results of a collaborative teaching experiment in which we designed for and tested a functions approach to solving equations with ninth‐grade algebra students, and link to results of semi‐structured interviews with students before and after the experiment. Results of analyzing the five‐week experiment include instructional supports for students' representational fluency in solving linear equations: (a) sequencing the use of graphs, tables, and CAS feedback prior to formal symbolic transpositions, (b) connecting solutions to equations across representations, and (c) encouraging understanding of equations as equivalence relations that are sometimes, always, or never true. While some students' change in sophistication of representational fluency helps substantiate the productive nature of these supports, other students' persistent struggles raise questions of how to address the diverse needs of learners in complex learning environments involving multiple tool‐based representations.     

The fractional knowledge and algebraic reasoning of students with the first multiplicative concept

To understand relationships between students’ quantitative reasoning with fractions and their algebraic reasoning, a clinical interview study was conducted with 18 middle and high school students. Six students with each of three different multiplicative concepts participated. This paper reports on the fractional knowledge and algebraic reasoning of six students with the most basic multiplicative concept. The fractional knowledge of these students was found to be consistent with prior research, in that the students had constructed partitioning and iteration operations but not disembedding operations, and that the students conceived of fractions as parts within wholes. The students’ iterating operations facilitated their work on algebra problems, but the lack of disembedding operations was a significant constraint in writing algebraic equations and expressions, as well as in generalizing relationships. Implications for teaching these students are discussed.     

Reviewers for Volume 10

This article compares first-year university students' development of the concept of limits to mathematicians' historical development of the concept. The aim was to find out if students perceive the notion as mathematicians of the past did, as understandings of the concept evolved. The results imply that there are some similarities—for example, the struggle with rigor and attainability. Knowledge of such critical areas can be used to improve students' opportunities of learning limits of functions. Some teaching aspects related to the study are also discussed.     

Improving Algebra Preparation: Implications From Research on Student Misconceptions and Difficulties

Through historical and contemporary research, educators have identified widespread misconceptions and difficulties faced by students in learning algebra. Many of these universal issues stem from content addressed long before students take their first algebra course. Yet elementary and middle school teachers may not understand how the subtleties of the arithmetic content they teach can dramatically, and sometimes negatively, impact their students' ability to transition to algebra. The purpose of this article is to bring awareness of some common algebra misconceptions, and suggestions on how they can be averted, to those who are teaching students the early mathematical concepts they will build upon when learning formal algebra. Published literature discussing misconceptions will be presented for four prerequisite concepts, related to symbolic representation: bracket usage, equality, operational symbols, and letter usage. Each section will conclude with research‐based practical applications and suggestions for preventing such misconceptions. The literature discussed in this article makes a case for elementary and middle school teachers to have a deeper and more flexible understanding of the mathematics they teach, so they can recognize how the structure of algebra can and should be exposed while teaching arithmetic.     

Mixing Microworld and Cas Features in Building Computer Systems that Help Students Learn Algebra

We present the design principles for a new kind of computer system that helps students learn algebra. The fundamental idea is to have a system based on the microworld paradigm that allows students to make their own calculations, as they do with paper and pencil, without being obliged to use commands, and to verify the correctness of these calculations. This requires an advanced editor for algebraic expressions, an editor for algebraic reasoning and an algorithm that calculates the equivalence of two algebraic expressions. A second feature typical of microworlds is the ability to provide students information about the state of the problem in order to help them move toward a solution. A third feature comes from the CAS (Computer Algebra System) paradigm, consisting of providing commands for executing certain algebraic actions; these commands have to be adapted to the current level of understanding of the students in order to only present calculations they can do without difficulty. With this feature, such a computer system can provide an introduction to the proper use of a Computer Algebra System. We have implemented most of these features in a computer system called aplusix for a sub-domain of algebra, and we have done several experiments with students (mainly grades 9 and 10). We had good results, with positive feedback from students and teachers. aplusix is currently a prototype that can be downloaded from http://aplusix.imag.fr. It will become a commercial product during 2004. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

A Brief History of Algebraic Notation

This paper traces three major stages in the development of algebraic notation: rhetorical or prose, syncopated, and symbolic. The. development of algebra began in Babylonia and Egypt around 1700 BC. Examples of rhetorical algebra by al‐Khowârizmî are used to illustrate potential difficulties that arise when algebraic problems are worked using words without symbols. Greek mathematician Diophantus was one of the pioneers of syncopated algebra. In this stage of notation, some shorthand was used along with prose. Indian mathematicians developed a syncopated algebraic notation independently of Diophantus. Around 1500 BC, symbolic algebra began to develop. The process of the development of a standardized, efficient symbol system is illustrated by tracing the evolution of some common symbols, including the symbols for equals, addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division.     

Teaching Algebraic Expressions to Young Students: The Three‐day Journey of “a+ 2”

This classroom scholarship report is based on the teaching experience using Davydov's mathematics curriculum, which was developed in the former Soviet Union. While “from arithmetic to algebra” is the normally accepted instructional sequence in school mathematics, Davydov's curriculum is laid out “from algebra to arithmetic,” focusing on algebraic thinking from the very beginning of the elementary grades. The purpose of this report is not to provide a definitive conclusion about which curriculum or sequence is better nor to address which instructional strategy is right in all circumstances. Rather, it is to explore how primary grade students develop their own conceptual understanding while confronting difficulties met within a specific context. This report provides actual classroom episodes from working with a group of first graders and describes dynamic interactions between the teacher and children while they discuss the use of algebraic expressions and understand the meaning behind them.     

Understanding and representing the arithmetic averaging algorithm: an analysis and comparison of US and Chinese students' responses

Analysing the responses of 311 sixth-grade Chinese students and 232 sixth-grade US students to two problems involving arithmetic average, this study explored students' understanding and representation of the averaging algorithm from a cross-national perspective. Results of the study show that Chinese students were more successful than US students in obtaining correct numerical answers to each of the problems, but US and Chinese students had similar cognitive difficulties in solving the second task. The difficulties were not due to their lack of procedural knowledge of the averaging algorithm, rather due to their lack of conceptual understanding of the algorithm. There were significant differences between the US and Chinese students in their solution representations of the two average problems. Chinese students were more likely to use algebraic representations than US students; while US students were more likely to use pictorial or verbal representations. US and Chinese students' use of representations are related to their mathematical problem-solving performance. Students who used more advanced representations were better problem solvers. The findings of the study suggest that Chinese students' superior performance on the averaging problems is partly due to their use of advanced representations (e.g. algebraic).