Improving the quality of 3D-QSAR by using flexible-ligand receptor models

To address the problems associated with molecular conformations and alignments in the 3D-QSAR studies, we have developed the Flexible Ligand - Atomic Receptor Model (FLARM) 2.0 method. The FLARM 2.0 method has three unique features as compared to other pseudoreceptor model methods: (1) the training ligands are flexibly optimized inside the receptors to achieve minimal docking energies; (2) the receptor atoms are spatially moveable in the process of genetic evolving in order to avoid improper initial receptor shapes; and (3) void receptor sites are specially favored in order to obtain open receptor models that allow large gaps. Advantages of an open model include less noise information, a smaller risk of overfitting, and ease of locating the key interaction sites. The latter two features, inherited from the previous FLARM 1.0 method, can improve the predictive ability of the 3D-QSAR models, while the first feature is newly implemented to relieve the uncertainty caused by improper conformation and alignment. Three FLARM 2.0 case studies were performed, and the results show that FLARM 2.0 models are highly predictive and robust. FLARM 2.0 pseudoreceptor models can correspond well with the pharmacophore models and/or the binding sites of the real protein receptors.     

Structure–activity relationships of cannabinoids: A joint CoMFA and pseudoreceptor modelling study

A cannabinoid pseudoreceptor model for the CB1-receptor has been constructed for 31 cannabinoids using the molecular modelling software YAK. Additionally, two CoMFA studies were performed on these ligands, the first of which was conducted prior to the building of the pseudoreceptor. Its pharmacophore is identical with the initial superposition of ligands used for pseudoreceptor construction. In contrast, the ligand alignment for the second CoMFA study was taken directly from the final cannabinoid pseudoreceptor model. This altered alignment gives markedly improved cross-validated r² values as compared to those obtained from the original alignment with values of 0.79 and 0.63, respectively, for five components. However, the pharmacophore alignment has the better predictive ability. Both the CoMFA and pseudoreceptor methods predict the free energy of binding of test ligands well.     

3D-QSAR and receptor modeling of tyrosine kinase inhibitors with flexible atom receptor model (FLARM)

A set of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) tyrosine kinase inhibitors was investigated with the aim of developing 3D-QSAR models using the Flexible Atom Receptor Model (FLARM) method. Some 3D-QSAR models were built with high correlation coefficients, and the FLARM method predicted the biological activities of compounds in test set well. The FLARM method also gave the pseudoreceptor model, which indicates the possible interactions between the receptor and the ligand. The possible interactions include two hydrogen bonds, one hydrophobic interaction, and one sulfur-aromatic interaction, which are in accord with those in the pharmacophore model given by the scientists at Novartis. This shows that the FLARM method can bridge 3D-QSAR and receptor modeling in computer-aided drug design. Pharmacophore can be obtained according to these results, and 3D searching can then be done with databases to find the lead compound of EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors.     

3D QSAR (COMFA) of a series of potent and highly selective VLA-4 antagonists

The integrin VLA-4 (41) is involved in the migration of white blood cells to sites of inflammation, and is implicated in the pathology of a variety of diseases including asthma and multiple sclerosis. We report the structure-activity relationships of a series of VLA-4 antagonists that were based upon the integrin-binding sequence of the connecting segment peptide of fibronectin (Leu-Asp-Val), and of VCAM-1 (Ile-Asp-Ser), both natural ligands of VLA-4. We explore variation in the ligand derived peptide portion of these antagonists and also in the novel N-terminal cap, which have discovered through chemical optimization, and which confers high affinity and selectivity. Using the X-ray derived conformation of the Ile-Asp-Ser region of VCAM-1, we rationalize the structure-activity relationships of these antagonists using 3D QSAR (COMFA). The COMFA model was found to be highly predictive with a cross-validated R² _CVof 0.7 and a PRESS of 0.49. The robustness of the model was confirmed by testing the influence of various parameters, including grid size, column filtering, as well as the role of orientation of the aligned molecules. Our results suggest that the VCAM-1 structure is useful in generating highly predictive models of our VLA-4 antagonists. The COMFA model coupled with the knowledge that the peptide amides are tolerant to methylation should prove useful in future peptidomimetic design studies.     

6-氮杂吲唑类Pim-1激酶抑制剂的3D-QSAR、药效团模型研究和分子设计

Pim-1激酶通过作用于多种信号通路或靶点影响肿瘤的发生发展,近年来被认为是肿瘤治疗的良好靶标。本文采用SYBYL-X2.1.1软件中的Topomer CoMFA、GALAHAD模块建立计算机模型,研究39个基于6-氮杂吲唑环的Pim-1激酶抑制剂的三维定量构效关系及药效团特征元素。结果显示,Topomer CoMFA建模所得交叉验证系数(q²)和相关系数(r²)分别为0.756和0.951,结合外部验证表明此3D-QSAR模型具有较高预测能力及较好的统计学稳定性,同时,用等势图描述了R1、R2基团处立体场、静电场对活性的具体影响。药效团研究结果表明,含氢键受体的芳香杂环母核结构,以及侧链取代基中含有芳香杂环结构对化合物的活性贡献较大。最后根据上述模型信息新设计了15个Pim-1激酶抑制剂分子并完成活性预测及分子对接模式研究,其中4个分子的预测pIC₅₀高于建模分子中活性最好的化合物17,Surflex-Dock分析显示新设计分子均与Pim-1激酶形成较强氢键相互作用。基于6-氮杂吲唑环的Pim-1激酶抑制剂的3D-QS...     

3D QSAR analyses of novel tyrosine kinase inhibitors based on pharmacophore alignment

In an effort to develop a quantitative ligand-binding model for the receptor tyrosine kinases, a pharmacophore search was first used to identify structural features that are common in two novel sets of 12 molecules of the 3-substituted indolin-2-ones and 19 compounds of the benzylidene malononitriles with low-to-high affinity for HER2, a kind of receptor tyrosine kinase. The common pharmacophore model based on these 31 compounds was used as a template to obtain the aligned molecular aggregate, which provided a good starting point for 3D-QSAR analysis of only the 19 benzylidene malononitriles. Two molecular field analysis (MFA) techniques, including CoMFA and CoMSIA, were used to derive the quantitative structure-activity relationships of the studied molecules. From the studied results, it was obvious that the 3D-QSAR models based on the pharmacophore alignment were superior to those based on the simple atom-by-atom fits. Considering the flexibility of the studied molecules and the difference between the active conformers and the energy-lowest conformers, the pharmacophore model can usually provide the common features for the flexible regions. Moreover, the best CoMSIA model based on the pharmacophore hypothesis gave good statistical measure from partial least-squares analysis (PLS) (q(2) = 0.71), which was slightly better than the CoMFA one. Our study demonstrated that pharmacophore modeling and CoMSIA research could be effectively combined. Results obtained from both methods helped with understanding the specific activity of some compounds and designing new specific HER2 inhibitors.     

Integration of Ligand-Based and Structure-Based Methods for the Design of Small-Molecule TLR7 Antagonists

Toll-like receptor 7 (TLR7) is activated in response to the binding of single-stranded RNA. Its over-activation has been implicated in several autoimmune disorders, and thus, it is an established therapeutic target in such circumstances. TLR7 small-molecule antagonists are not yet available for therapeutic use. We conducted a ligand-based drug design of new TLR7 antagonists through a concerted effort encompassing 2D-QSAR, 3D-QSAR, and pharmacophore modelling of 54 reported TLR7 antagonists. The developed 2D-QSAR model depicted an excellent correlation coefficient (R²_training: 0.86 and R²_test: 0.78) between the experimental and estimated activities. The ligand-based drug design approach utilizing the 3D-QSAR model (R²_training: 0.95 and R²_test: 0.84) demonstrated a significant contribution of electrostatic potential and steric fields towards the TLR7 antagonism. This consolidated approach, along with a pharmacophore model with high correlation (R_training: 0.94 and R_test: 0.92), was used to design quinazoline-core-based hTLR7 antagonists. Subsequently, the newly designed molecules were subjected to molecular docking onto the previously proposed binding model and a molecular dynamics study for a better understanding of their binding pattern. The toxicity profiles and drug-likeness characteristics of the designed compounds were evaluated with in silico ADMET predictions. This ligand-based study contributes towards a better understanding of lead optimization and the future development of potent TLR7 antagonists.     

A three-dimensional chemical phase pharmacophore mapping,QSAR modelling and electronic feature analysis of benzofuran salicylic acid derivatives as LYP inhibitors

Lymphoid tyrosine phosphatase (LYP), encoded by the PTPN22 gene, has a critical negative regulatory role in T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) and emerged as a promising drug target for human autoimmune diseases. A five-point pharmacophore with two hydrogen bond acceptors, one hydrogen bond donor and two aromatic ring features was generated for a series of benzofuran salicylic acid derivatives as LYP inhibitors in order to elucidate their anti-autoimmune activity. The generated pharmacophore yielded a significant 3D-QSAR model with r² of 0.9146 for a training set of 27 compounds. The model also showed excellent predictive power with Q² of 0.7068 for a test set of eight compounds. The investigation of the 3D-QSAR model has revealed the structural insights which could lead to more potent analogues. The most active and inactive compounds were further subjected to electronic structure analysis using density functional theory (DFT) at B3LYP/3?21^?G level to support the 3D-QSAR predictions. The results obtained from this study are expected to be useful in the proficient design and development of benzofuran salicylic acid derivatives as inhibitors of LYP.     

Identification of potential Gly/NMDA receptor antagonists by cheminformatics approach: a combination of pharmacophore modelling,virtual screening and molecular docking studies

The Gly/NMDA receptor has become known as potential target for the management of neurodegenerative diseases. Discovery of Gly/NMDA antagonists has thus attracted much attention in recent years. In the present research, a cheminformatics approach has been used to determine structural requirements for Gly/NMDA antagonism and to identify potential antagonists. Here, 37 quinoxaline derivatives were selected to develop a significant pharmacophore model with good certainty. The selected model was validated by leave-one-out cross-validation, an external test set, decoy set and Y-randomization test. Applicability domain was verified by the standardization approach. The validated 3D-QSAR model was used to screen virtual hits from the ZINC database by pharmacophore mapping. Molecular docking was used for assessment of receptor–ligand binding modes and binding affinities. The GlideScore and molecular interactions with critical amino acids were considered as crucial features to identify final hits. Furthermore, hits were analysed for in silico pharmacokinetic parameters and Lipinski’s rule of five, demonstrating their potential as drug-like candidates. The PubChem and SciFinder search tools were used to authenticate the novelty of leads retrieved. Finally, five different leads have been suggested as putative novel candidates for the exploration of potent Gly/NMDA receptor antagonists.     

Molecular docking and 3D-QSAR study of pyranmycin derivatives against 16S rRNA A site

To understand pharmacophore properties of pyranmycin derivatives and to design novel inhibitors of 16S rRNA A site, comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) approach was applied to analyze three-dimensional quantitative structure–activity relationship (3D-QSAR) of 17 compounds. AutoDock 3.0.5 program was employed to locate the orientations and conformations of the inhibitors interacting with 16S rRNA A site. The interaction mode was demonstrated in the aspects of inhibitor conformation, hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interaction. Similar binding conformations of these inhibitors and good correlations between the calculated binding free energies and experimental biological activities suggest that the binding conformations of these inhibitors derived from docking procedure were reasonable. Robust and predictive 3D-QSAR model was obtained by CoMFA with q² values of 0.723 and 0.993 for cross-validated and non-cross-validated, respectively. The 3D-QSAR model built here will provide clear guidelines for novel inhibitors design based on the Pyranmycin derivatives against 16S rRNA A site.     

Improved 3D-QSAR prediction by multiple-conformational alignment: A case study on PTP1B inhibitors

Three-dimension quantitative structure activity relationship (3D-QSAR) was one of the major statistical techniques to investigate the correlation of biological activity with structural properties of candidate molecules, and the accuracy of statistic greatly depended on molecular alignment methodology. Exhaustive conformational search and successful conformational superposition could extremely improve the predictive accuracy of QSAR modeling. In this work, we proposed a solution to optimize QSAR prediction by multiple-conformational alignment methods, with a set of 40 flexible PTP1B inhibitors as case study. Three different molecular alignment methods were used for the development of 3D-QSAR models listed as following: (1) docking-based alignment (DBA); (2) pharmacophore-based alignment (PBA) and (3) co-crystallized conformer-based alignment (CCBA). Among these three alignments, it was indicated that the CCBA was the best and the fastest strategy in 3D-QSAR development, with the square correlation coefficient (r²) and cross-validated squared correlation coefficient (q²) of comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) were 0.992 and 0.694; the r² and q² of comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA) were 0.972 and 0.603, respectively. The alignment methodologies used here not only generated a robust QSAR model with useful molecular field contour maps for designing novel PTP1B inhibitors, but also provided a solution for constructing accurate 3D-QSAR model for various disease targets. Undoubtedly, such attempt in QSAR analysis would greatly help us to understand essential structural features of inhibitors required by its target, and so as to discover more promising chemical derivatives.     

Development of predictive pharmacophore model for in silico screening,and 3D QSAR CoMFA and CoMSIA studies for lead optimization,for designing of potent tumor necrosis factor alpha converting enzyme inhibitors

A chemical feature-based pharmacophore model was developed for Tumor Necrosis Factor-α converting enzyme (TACE) inhibitors. A five point pharmacophore model having two hydrogen bond acceptors (A), one hydrogen bond donor (D) and two aromatic rings (R) with discrete geometries as pharmacophoric features was developed. The pharmacophore model so generated was then utilized for in silico screening of a database. The pharmacophore model so developed was validated by using four compounds having proven TACE inhibitory activity which were grafted into the database. These compounds mapped well onto the five listed pharmacophoric features. This validated pharmacophore model was also used for alignment of molecules in CoMFA and CoMSIA analysis. The contour maps of the CoMFA/CoMSIA models were utilized to provide structural insight for activity improvement of potential novel TACE inhibitors. The pharmacophore model so developed could be used for in silico screening of any commercial/in house database for identification of TACE inhibiting lead compounds, and the leads so identified could be optimized using the developed CoMSIA model. The present work highlights the tremendous potential of the two mutually complementary ligand-based drug designing techniques (i.e. pharmacophore mapping and 3D-QSAR analysis) using TACE inhibitors as prototype biologically active molecules.     

4D-QSAR analysis of a series of antifungal p450 inhibitors and 3D-pharmacophore comparisons as a function of alignment

A training set of 55 antifungal p450 analogue inhibitors was used to construct receptor-independent four-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship (RI 4D-QSAR) models. Ten different alignments were used to build the models, and one alignment yields a significantly better model than the other alignments. Two different methodologies were used to measure the similarity of the best 4D-QSAR models of each alignment. One method compares the residual of fit between pairs of models using the cross-correlation coefficient of their residuals of fit as a similarity measure. The other method compares the spatial distributions of the IPE types (3D-pharmacophores) of pairs of 4D-QSAR models from different alignments. Optimum models from several different alignments have nearly the same correlation coefficients, r(2), and cross-validation correlation coefficients, xv-r(2), yet the 3D-pharmacophores of these models are very different from one another. The highest 3D-pharmacophore similarity correlation coefficient between any pair of 4D-QSAR models from the 10 alignments considered is only 0.216. However, the best 4D-QSAR models of each alignment do contain some proximate common pharmacorphore sites. A test set of 10 compounds was used to validate the predictivity of the best 4D-QSAR models of each alignment. The "best" model from the 10 alignments has the highest predictivity. The inferred active sites mapped out by the 4D-QSAR models suggest that hydrogen bond interactions are not prevalent when this class of P450 analogue inhibitors binds to the receptor active site. This feature of the 4D-QSAR models is in agreement with the crystal structure results that indicate no ligand-receptor hydrogen bonds are formed.     

Pharmacophore Modeling and 3D-QSAR Study of Indole and Isatin Derivatives as Antiamyloidogenic Agents Targeting Alzheimer’s Disease

Thirty-six novel indole-containing compounds, mainly 3-(2-phenylhydrazono) isatins and structurally related 1H-indole-3-carbaldehyde derivatives, were synthesized and assayed as inhibitors of beta amyloid (Aβ) aggregation, a hallmark of pathophysiology of Alzheimer’s disease. The newly synthesized molecules spanned their IC₅₀ values from sub- to two-digit micromolar range, bearing further information into structure-activity relationships. Some of the new compounds showed interesting multitarget activity, by inhibiting monoamine oxidases A and B. A cell-based assay in tau overexpressing bacterial cells disclosed a promising additional activity of some derivatives against tau aggregation. The accumulated data of either about ninety published and thirty-six newly synthesized molecules were used to generate a pharmacophore hypothesis of antiamyloidogenic activity exerted in a wide range of potencies, satisfactorily discriminating the ‘active’ compounds from the ‘inactive’ (poorly active) ones. An atom-based 3D-QSAR model was also derived for about 80% of ‘active’ compounds, i.e., those achieving finite IC₅₀ values lower than 100 μM. The 3D-QSAR model (encompassing 4 PLS factors), featuring acceptable predictive statistics either in the training set (n = 45, q² = 0.596) and in the external test set (n = 14, r²_ext = 0.695), usefully complemented the pharmacophore model by identifying the physicochemical features mainly correlated with the Aβ anti-aggregating potency of the indole and isatin derivatives studied herein.     

4D-QSAR analysis of a set of ecdysteroids and a comparison to CoMFA modeling.

The ecdysteroid-responsive Drosophila melanogaster B(II) cell line is a prototypical homologous inducible gene expression system. A training set of 71 ecdysteroids, for which the -log(EC(50)) potencies in the ecdysteroid-responsive B(II) cell line were measured, was used to construct 4D-QSAR models. Four nearly equivalent optimum 4D-QSAR models, for two modestly different alignments, were identified (Q(2) = 0.76-0.80). These four models, together with two CoMFA models, were used in consensus modeling to arrive at a three-dimensional pharmacophore. The C-2 and C-22 hydroxyls are identified as hydrogen-bond acceptor sites which enhance activity. A hydrophobic site near C-12 is consistent with increasing activity. The side-chain substituents at C-17 are predicted to adopt semiextended "active" conformations which could fit into a cylinder-shaped binding pocket lined largely with nonpolar residues for enhanced activity. A test set of 20 ecdysteroids was used to evaluate the QSAR models. Two 4D-QSAR models for one alignment were identified to be superior to the others based on having the smallest average residuals of prediction for the prediction set (0.69 and 1.13 -log[EC(50)] units). The correlation coefficients of the optimum 4D-QSAR models (R(2) = 0.87 and 0.88) are nearly the same as those of the best CoMFA model (R(2) = 0.92) determined for the same training set. However, the cross-validation correlation coefficient of the CoMFA model is less significant (Q(2) = 0.59) than those of the 4D-QSAR models (Q(2) = 0.80 and 0.80).     

Computer-aided molecular design of (E)-N-Aryl-2-ethene-sulfonamide analogues as microtubule targeted agents in prostate cancer

Microtubules are tube-shaped, filamentous and cytoskeletal proteins that are essential in all eukaryotic cells. Microtubule is an attractive and promising target for anticancer agents. In this study, three-dimensional quantitative structure activity relationships (3D-QSAR) including comparative molecular field analysis, CoMFA, and comparative molecular similarity indices analysis, CoMSIA, were performed on a set of 45 (E)-N-Aryl-2-ethene-sulfonamide analogues as microtubule-targeted anti-prostate cancer agents. Automated grid potential analysis, AutoGPA module in Molecular Operating Environment 2009.10 (MOE) as a new 3D-QSAR approach with the pharmacophore-based alignment was carried out on the same dataset. AutoGPA-based 3D-QSAR model yielded better prediction parameters than CoMFA and CoMSIA. Based on the contour maps generated from the models, some key features were identified in (E)-N-Aryl-2-arylethene-sulfonamide analogues that were responsible for the anti-cancer activity. Virtual screening was performed based on pharmacophore modeling and molecular docking to identify the new inhibitors from ZINC database. Seven top ranked compounds were found based on Gold score fitness function. In silico ADMET studies were performed on compounds retrieved from virtual screening in compliance with the standard ranges.     

Linear and nonlinear 3D-QSAR approaches in tandem with ligand-based homology modeling as a computational strategy to depict the pyrazolo-triazolo-pyrimidine antagonists binding site of the human adenosine A2A receptor

The integration of ligand- and structure-based strategies might sensitively increase the success of drug discovery process. We have recently described the application of Molecular Electrostatic Potential autocorrelated vectors (autoMEPs) in generating both linear (Partial Least-Square, PLS) and nonlinear (Response Surface Analysis, RSA) 3D-QSAR models to quantitatively predict the binding affinity of human adenosine A3 receptor antagonists. Moreover, we have also reported a novel GPCR modeling approach, called Ligand-Based Homology Modeling (LBHM), as a tool to simulate the conformational changes of the receptor induced by ligand binding. In the present study, the application of both linear and nonlinear 3D-QSAR methods and LBHM computational techniques has been used to depict the hypothetical antagonist binding site of the human adenosine A2A receptor. In particular, a collection of 127 known human A2A antagonists has been utilized to derive two 3D-QSAR models (autoMEPs/PLS&RSA). In parallel, using a rhodopsin-driven homology modeling approach, we have built a model of the human adenosine A2A receptor. Finally, 3D-QSAR and LBHM strategies have been utilized to predict the binding affinity of five new human A2A pyrazolo-triazolo-pyrimidine antagonists finding a good agreement between the theoretical and the experimental predictions.     

Molecular Modification of Benzophenone Derivatives for Lower Bioenrichment and Toxicity Through the Pharmacophore Model

In this study, we used the improved extreme-difference normalization method to calculate the comprehensive evaluation values of bioenrichment and toxicity of benzophenone UV light absor-bers(BPs). Based on this parameter, a 3D-QSAR(QSAR=quantitative structure activity relationship) pharmacophore model was constructed using Discovery Studio software and applied to the mole-cular modification of BPs. With three commonly used ingredients in sunscreen 2-hydroxy-4-methoxybenzophenone(BP-3), 2,2'-dihydroxy-4,4'-dimethoxybenzophenone(BP-6) and 2,2'-dihydroxy-4-methoxybenzophenone(BP-8) as target molecules, we performed BPs substitution reaction based on the binding positions of characteristic elements of the pharmacophore model and designed BP derivatives with reduced bioenrichment and toxicity. Stability and function evaluation showed that while the stability of 6 BP derivatives was enhanced, the light absorption capacity was also significantly enhanced(from 9.16% to 43.16%). Molecular dynamics simulation results showed that the binding ability of BP-609 molecule with serum albumin was reduced by 16.37% compared with BP-6, and the binding with collagen could not occur spontaneously, which could be used as an explanation for the simultaneous reduction of its bioenrichment and toxicity. Besides, through the simulation of human metabolism, it was found that the liver metabolites of BP-609 were less toxic, which reduced the potential risk of human metabolism. It proved that the molecular modification scheme of BPs was environment-friendly.