Ewald summation versus direct summation of shifted-force potentials for the calculation of electrostatic interactions in solids: A quantitative study

The calculated Madelung energies and Madelung forces of the electrostatic interaction for nine crystal structures are reported. The method of direct summation with two different shifted-force potentials is compared to the Ewald summation. There is a considerable difference in the convergence of the energy and the force for the two shifted-force potentials regarding the cutoff radius. The convergence depends not only on the potential itself, but also on the crystal structure. One of the shifted-force potentials used is implemented in the CHARMM force field. The energy calculated with this potential shows a good convergence for small cutoff radii. With the other shifted-force potential, the force shows a better convergence for small cutoff radii. The number of pair interactions for obtaining the Madelung limit using the Ewald summation and the direct summation of a shifted-force potential is also reported. For complex structures like zeolites, the number of relevant pair interactions is smaller using the direct summation of a shifted-force potential. For simple structures such as cesium chloride, the number of significant pair interactions is smaller using the Ewald summation. © 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Methodological problems in pressure profile calculations for lipid bilayers

From molecular dynamics simulations of a dipalmitoyl-phosphatidyl-choline (DPPC) lipid bilayer in the liquid crystalline phase, pressure profiles through the bilayer are calculated by different methods. These profiles allow us to address two central and unresolved problems in pressure profile calculations: The first problem is that the pressure profile is not uniquely defined since the expression for the local pressure involves an arbitrary choice of an integration contour. We have investigated two different choices leading to the Irving-Kirkwood (IK) and Harasima (H) expressions for the local pressure tensor. For these choices we find that the pressure profile is almost independent of the contour used, which indicates that the local pressure is well defined for a DPPC bilayer in the liquid crystalline phase. This may not be the case for other systems and we therefore suggest that both the IK and H profiles are calculated in order to test the uniqueness of the profile. The second problem is how to include electrostatic interactions in pressure profile calculations when the simulations are conducted without truncating the electrostatic potential, i.e., using the Ewald summation technique. Based on the H expression for the local pressure, we present a method for calculating the contribution to the lateral components of the local pressure tensor from electrostatic interactions evaluated by the Ewald summation technique. Pressure profiles calculated with an electrostatic potential truncation (cutoff) from simulations conducted with Ewald summation are shown to depend on the cutoff in a subtle manner which is attributed to the existence of long-ranged charge ordering in the system. However, the pressure profiles calculated with relatively long cutoffs are qualitatively similar to the Ewald profile for the DPPC bilayer studied here.     

Simple and accurate scheme to compute electrostatic interaction: Zero-dipole summation technique for molecular system and application to bulk water

The zero-dipole summation method was extended to general molecular systems, and then applied to molecular dynamics simulations of an isotropic water system. In our previous paper [I. Fukuda, Y. Yonezawa, and H. Nakamura, J. Chem. Phys. 134, 164107 (2011)], for evaluating the electrostatic energy of a classical particle system, we proposed the zero-dipole summation method, which conceptually prevents the nonzero-charge and nonzero-dipole states artificially generated by a simple cutoff truncation. Here, we consider the application of this scheme to molecular systems, as well as some fundamental aspects of general cutoff truncation protocols. Introducing an idea to harmonize the bonding interactions and the electrostatic interactions in the scheme, we develop a specific algorithm. As in the previous study, the resulting energy formula is represented by a simple pairwise function sum, enabling facile applications to high-performance computation. The accuracy of the electrostatic energies calculated by the zero-dipole summation method with the atom-based cutoff was numerically investigated, by comparison with those generated by the Ewald method. We obtained an electrostatic energy error of less than 0.01% at a cutoff length longer than 13 A for a TIP3P isotropic water system, and the errors were quite small, as compared to those obtained by conventional truncation methods. The static property and the stability in an MD simulation were also satisfactory. In addition, the dielectric constants and the distance-dependent Kirkwood factors were measured, and their coincidences with those calculated by the particle mesh Ewald method were confirmed, although such coincidences are not easily attained by truncation methods. We found that the zero damping-factor gave the best results in a practical cutoff distance region. In fact, in contrast to the zero-charge scheme, the damping effect was insensitive in the zero-charge and zero-dipole scheme, in the molecular system we treated. We discussed the origin of this difference between the two schemes and the dependence of this fact on the physical system. The use of the zero damping-factor will enhance the efficiency of practical computations, since the complementary error function is not employed. In addition, utilizing the zero damping-factor provides freedom from the parameter choice, which is not trivial in the zero-charge scheme, and eliminates the error function term, which corresponds to the time-consuming Fourier part under the periodic boundary conditions.     

A long-range electrostatic potential based on the Wolf method charge-neutral condition

Molecular simulations rely heavily on a long range electrostatic Coulomb interaction. The Coulomb potential decays inversely with distance, indicating infinite effective range. In practice, molecular simulations do not directly take into account such an infinite interaction. Therefore, the Ewald, fast multipole, and cutoff methods are frequently used. Although cutoff methods are implemented easily and the calculations are fast, it has been pointed out that they produce serious artifacts. Wolf and coworkers recently discovered one source of the artifacts. They found that when the total charge in a cutoff sphere disappeared, the cutoff error is dramatically suppressed. The Wolf method uses the charge-neutral principle combined with a potential damping that is realized using a complementary error function. To date, many molecular simulation studies have demonstrated the accuracy and reliability of the Wolf method. We propose a novel long-range potential that is constructed only from the charge-neutral condition of the Wolf method without potential damping. We also show that three simulation systems, in which involve liquid sodium-chloride, TIP3P water, and a charged protein in explicit waters with neutralized ions using the new potential, provide accurate statistical and dielectric properties when compared with the particle mesh Ewald method.     

The ENUF method—Ewald summation based on nonuniform fast Fourier transform: Implementation,parallelization, and application

Computer simulations of model systems are widely used to explore striking phenomena in promising applications spanning from physics, chemistry, biology, to materials science and engineering. The long range electrostatic interactions between charged particles constitute a prominent factor in determining structures and states of model systems. How to efficiently calculate electrostatic interactions in simulation systems subjected to partial or full periodic boundary conditions has been a grand challenging task. In the past decades, a large variety of computational schemes has been proposed, among which the Ewald summation method is the most reliable route to accurately deal with electrostatic interactions between charged particles in simulation systems. In addition, extensive efforts have been done to improve computational efficiencies of the Ewald summation based methods. Representative examples are approaches based on cutoffs, reaction fields, multi-poles, multi-grids, and particle-mesh schemes. We sketched an ENUF method, an abbreviation for the Ewald summation method based on the nonuniform fast Fourier transform technique, and have implemented this method in particle-based simulation packages to calculate electrostatic energies and forces at micro- and mesoscopic levels. Extensive computational studies of conformational properties of polyelectrolytes, dendrimer-membrane complexes, and ionic fluids demonstrated that the ENUF method and its derivatives conserve both energy and momentum to floating point accuracy, and exhibit a computational complexity of with optimal physical parameters. These ENUF based methods are attractive alternatives in molecular simulations where high accuracy and efficiency of simulation methods are needed to accelerate calculations of electrostatic interactions at extended spatiotemporal scales.     

电解质水溶液传递性质的布朗动力学模拟研究

在传统布朗动力学的基础上, 考虑流体力学的影响, 并且引入Smart Monte Carlo方法的接受概率, 对电解质溶液进行布朗动力学模拟, 得到不同浓度和温度下KCl溶液中离子间的径向分布函数, 并且与超网链积分方程理论计算结果进行了比较, 同时, 模拟了KCl和NaCl溶液的摩尔电导率. 模拟过程基于电解质溶液的原始模型, 溶剂被看作连续介质, 溶质分子之间的相互作用采用软核加静电的势能函数模型, 长程静电力的处理采用Ewald加和方法. 结果显示, 流体力学的作用对于电解质溶液的结构性质没有明显的影响, 但是对于传递性质的影响显著; 考虑流体力学作用的布朗动力学模拟结果与实验数据吻合良好.     

Assessing group-based cutoffs and the Ewald method for electrostatic interactions in clusters and in saturated,superheated, and supersaturated vapor phases of dipolar molecules

Monte Carlo simulations in the canonical, isobaric-isothermal, grand canonical, and Gibbs ensembles were used to assess whether the computationally expensive Ewald summation method for the computation of the first-order electrostatic energy can be replaced with a simpler truncation approach for accurate simulations of the saturated, superheated, and supersaturated vapor phases of dipolar and hydrogen-bonding molecules. Rotationally averaged hydrogen fluoride dimer and trimer energies, thermophysical properties and aggregation in the superheated vapor phase of hydrogen fluoride, nucleation free energy barriers for water, and the vapor–liquid coexistence properties of hydrogen fluoride and water were investigated over a wide range of state points. We find that for densities not too close to the critical density, results obtained from simulations using a spherical potential truncation based on neutral groups (molecules or fragments) for the Coulomb interactions are statistically identical to those obtained using the Ewald summation method. Use of the simpler spherical truncation results in a significant reduction of the computational effort for simulations employing molecular mechanics force fields and also allows for straightforward implementation of many-body expansion methods to compute the potential energy from electronic structure calculations of subsystems of the entire vapor-phase system.     

Ewald summation and multiple time step methods for molecular dynamics simulation of biological molecules

Methods by which to determine conditions for a molecular dynamics (MD) simulation of biological molecules were investigated. Derivation of the optimal parameters of the Ewald summation was described so as to give same precision to the real space, the reciprocal space summations and the van der Waals interaction. Later, the procedure by which to determine the condition of the multiple time step method by RESPA (REference System Propagator Algorithm; Tuckerman et al., 1992, J. Chem. Phys., 97, 1990) was described as exemplified by MD simulations of a solvated β-sheet peptide. The conservation of the total energy in a microcanonical ensemble was measured to investigate the stability of the simulation conditions. The most feasible respective combinations of the time steps were: 0.25 fs for bond, angle and torsion interactions; 2 fs for van der Waals interaction and Ewald real-space summation; and 4 fs for Ewald reciprocal-space summation. Though it retained an acceptable accuracy, this condition accelerated the simulation ten-fold compared to that in which a simple velocity-Verlet method with a time step of 0.25 fs was used. The update of the correction term due to excluded neighbors was then investigated. Better results were obtained when the correction was updated with the real-space than when it was updated with the reciprocal-space summation. Finally, an MD simulation as long as 50 ps performed under the optimal Ewald and RESPA parameters was thus determined. The trajectory showed a good stability, indicating the feasibility of the parameters.     

On the proper calculation of electrostatic interactions in solid-supported bilayer systems

Modeling systems that are not inherently isotropic, e.g., extended bilayers, using molecular simulation techniques poses a potential problem. Since these methods rely on a finite number of atoms and molecules to describe the system, periodic boundary conditions are implemented to avoid edge effects and capture long-range electrostatic interactions. Systems consisting of a solvated bilayer adsorbed on a solid surface and exposed to an air/vacuum interface occur in many experimental settings and present some unique challenges in this respect. Here, we investigated the effects of implementing different electrostatic boundary conditions on the structural and electrostatic properties of a quartz/water/vacuum interface and a similar quartz-supported hydrated lipid bilayer exposed to vacuum. Since these interfacial systems have a net polarization, implementing the standard Ewald summation with the conducting boundary condition for the electrostatic long-range interactions introduced an artificial periodicity in the out-of-plane dimension. In particular, abnormal orientational polarizations of water were observed with the conducting boundary condition. Implementing the Ewald summation technique with the planar vacuum boundary condition and calculating electrostatic properties compatible with the implemented electrostatic boundary condition removed these inconsistencies. This formulation is generally applicable to similar interfacial systems in bulk solution.     

A comparison of Coulombic interaction methods in non-equilibrium studies of heat transfer in water

We investigate the impact of the treatment of electrostatic interactions on the heat conduction of liquid water. With this purpose, we report a series of non-equilibrium molecular dynamics computer simulations of the Modified Central Force Model of water. We consider both the Ewald summation approach, which includes the full range of the electrostatic interactions, and the Wolf method, which uses a cutoff to truncate the long range contributions. It is shown that the relaxation of the temperature profiles towards the stationary state solution and the equation of state of the liquid are not affected by the treatment of the electrostatic interactions. However, the truncation of the interactions results in lower internal energy fluxes as well as lower thermal conductivities. We also find that the anomalous increase of the thermal conductivity of water with temperature is reproduced by the different methods considered in this work, showing that this physical behavior is independent of the treatment of the long range electrostatic interactions.     

Cutoff radius effect of the isotropic periodic sum and Wolf method in liquid-vapor interfaces of water

As a more economical but similarly accurate computation method than the Ewald sum, the isotropic periodic sum (IPS) method for nonpolar molecules (IPSn) and polar molecules (IPSp), along with the Wolf method are of interest, but the cutoff radius dependence is an important issue. To evaluate the cutoff radius effect of the three methods, a water-vapor interfacial system has been studied by molecular dynamics. The Wolf method can produce adequate results for surface tension compared to that of the Ewald sum (within 2.9%) at a long enough cutoff radius, r(c). However, the estimation of the electrostatic potential profile and dipole orientational function is poor. The Wolf method cannot estimate electrostatic configuration at r(c) ≤ L(z)∕2 (L(z) is the longest lattice of the system). We have found that the convergence of the surface tension and the electrostatic configuration of the IPSn method is faster than that of the IPSp method. Moreover, the IPSn method is most accurate among the three methods for the same cutoff radius. Furthermore, the behavior of the surface tension against the cutoff radius shows a greater difference for the IPSn and IPSp method. The surface tension of the IPSp method fluctuates and presents a similar result to that of the Ewald sum, but the surface tension for the IPSn method greatly deviates near r(c) = L(z)∕3. The cause of this deviation is the difference between the interfacial configuration of the water surface and the cutoff treatment of the IPS method. The deviation becomes insignificant far from r(c) = L(z)∕3. In spite of this shortcoming, the IPSn method gives the most accurate result in estimating the surface tension at r(c) = L(z)∕2. From all the results in this work, the IPSn and IPSp method have been found to be more accurate than the Wolf method. In conclusion, the surface tension and structure of water-vapor interface can be calculated by the IPSn method when r(c) is greater than or equal to the longest lattice of the system. The IPSp method and the Wolf method require a longer cutoff radius than the longest lattice of the system to estimate interfacial properties.     

Effect of different treatments of long-range interactions and sampling conditions in molecular dynamic simulations of rhodopsin embedded in a dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine bilayer

The present study analyzes the effect of the simulation conditions on the results of molecular dynamics simulations of G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) performed with an explicit lipid bilayer. Accordingly, the present work reports the analysis of different simulations of bovine rhodopsin embedded in a dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) lipid bilayer using two different sampling conditions and two different approaches for the treatment of long-range electrostatic interactions. Specifically, sampling was carried out either by using the statistical ensembles NVT or NPT (constant number of atoms, a pressure of 1 atm in all directions and fixed temperature), and the electrostatic interactions were treated either by using a twin-cutoff, or the particle mesh Ewald summation method (PME). The results of the present study suggest that the use of the NPT ensemble in combination with the PME method provide more realistic simulations. The use of NPT during the equilibration avoids the need of an a priori estimation of the box dimensions, giving the correct area per lipid. However, once the system is equilibrated, the simulations are irrespective of the sampling conditions used. The use of an electrostatic cutoff induces artifacts on both lipid thickness and the ion distribution, but has no direct effect on the protein and water molecules.     

Amorphous silica modeled with truncated and screened Coulomb interactions: a molecular dynamics simulation study

We show that finite-range alternatives to the standard long-range pair potential for silica by van Beest et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 1955 (1990)] might be used in molecular dynamics simulations. We study two such models that can be efficiently simulated since no Ewald summation is required. We first consider the Wolf method, where the Coulomb interactions are truncated at a cutoff distance rc such that the requirement of charge neutrality holds. Various static and dynamic quantities are computed and compared to results from simulations using Ewald summations. We find very good agreement for rc approximately 10 A. For lower values of rc, the long-range structure is affected which is accompanied by a slight acceleration of dynamic properties. In a second approach, the Coulomb interaction is replaced by an effective Yukawa interaction with two new parameters determined by a force fitting procedure. The same trend as for the Wolf method is seen. However, slightly larger cutoffs have to be used in order to obtain the same accuracy with respect to static and dynamic quantities as for the Wolf method.     

Computer simulation of charged hard spherocylinders

In this work we present a computer simulation study of charged hard spherocylinders of aspect ratio L/sigma=5, using NVT and NPT Monte Carlo methods. Coulombic interactions are handled using the Wolf method [D. Wolf, P. Keblinski, S. R. Phillpot, and J. Eggebrecht, J. Chem. Phys. 110, 8254 (1999)]. Thermodynamic and structural properties are in excellent agreement with the results obtained with the standard Ewald summation method. A partial prediction of the corresponding phase diagram is obtained by studying two isotherms of this system. The stability of the liquid crystalline phases is examined and compared with the phase diagrams of neutral hard spherocylinders and dipolar hard spherocylinders.     

Comparison of the accuracy of periodic reaction field methods in molecular dynamics simulations of a model liquid crystal system

A periodic reaction field (PRF) method is a technique to estimate long‐range interactions. The method has the potential to effectively reduce the computational cost while maintaining adequate accuracy. We performed molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of a model liquid‐crystal system to assess the accuracy of some variations of the PRF method in low‐charge‐density systems. All the methods had adequate accuracy compared with the results of the particle mesh Ewald (PME) method, except for a few simulation conditions. Furthermore, in all of the simulation conditions, one of the PRF methods had the same accuracy as the PME method. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Accelerating electrostatic interaction calculations with graphical processing units based on new developments of ewald method using non‐uniform fast fourier transform

We present new algorithms to improve the performance of ENUF method (F. Hedman, A. Laaksonen, Chem. Phys. Lett. 425, 2006, 142) which is essentially Ewald summation using Non‐Uniform FFT (NFFT) technique. A NearDistance algorithm is developed to extensively reduce the neighbor list size in real‐space computation. In reciprocal‐space computation, a new algorithm is developed for NFFT for the evaluations of electrostatic interaction energies and forces. Both real‐space and reciprocal‐space computations are further accelerated by using graphical processing units (GPU) with CUDA technology. Especially, the use of CUNFFT (NFFT based on CUDA) very much reduces the reciprocal‐space computation. In order to reach the best performance of this method, we propose a procedure for the selection of optimal parameters with controlled accuracies. With the choice of suitable parameters, we show that our method is a good alternative to the standard Ewald method with the same computational precision but a dramatically higher computational efficiency. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Dynamical motions of lipids and a finite size effect in simulations of bilayers

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers composed of 72 and 288 lipids are used to examine system size dependence on dynamical properties associated with the particle mesh Ewald (PME) treatment of electrostatic interactions. The lateral diffusion constant Dl is 2.92 x 10(-7) and 0.95 x 10(-7) cm2/s for 72 and 288 lipids, respectively. This dramatic finite size effect originates from the correlation length of lipid diffusion, which extends to next-nearest neighbors in the 288 lipid system. Consequently, diffusional events in smaller systems can propagate across the boundaries of the periodic box. The internal dynamics of lipids calculated from the PME simulations are independent of the system size. Specifically, reorientational correlation functions for the slowly relaxing phosphorus-glycerol hydrogen, phosphorus-nitrogen vectors, and more rapidly relaxing CH vectors in the aliphatic chains are equivalent for the 72 and 288 lipid simulations. A third MD simulation of a bilayer with 72 lipids using spherical force-shift electrostatic cutoffs resulted in interdigitated chains, thereby rendering this cutoff method inappropriate.     

Molecular dynamics simulation of trp-repressor/operator complex: analysis of hydrogen bond patterns of protein–DNA interaction

Molecular dynamics simulation of Escherichia coli trp-repressor/operator complex was performed to elucidate protein–DNA interactions in solution for 800 ps on special-purpose computer MD-GRAPE. The Ewald summation method was employed to treat the electrostatic interaction without cutoff. DNA kept stable conformation in comparison with the result of the conventional cutoff method. Thus, the trajectories obtained were used to analyze the protein–DNA interaction and to understand the role of dynamics of water molecules forming sequence specific recognition interface. The dynamical cross-correlation map showed a significant positive correlation between the helix-turn-helix DNA-binding motifs and the major grooves of operator DNA. The extensive contact surface was stable during the simulation. Most of the contacts consisted of direct interactions between phosphates of DNA and the protein, but several water-mediated polar contacts were also observed. These water-mediated interactions, which were also seen in the crystal structure (Z. Otwinowski, et al., Nature, 335 (1998) 321) emerged spontaneously from the randomized initial configuration of the solvent. This result suggests the importance of the water-mediated interaction in specific recognition of DNA by the trp-repressor, consistent with X-ray structural information.     

Errors in the Ewald summation method with electrostatic layer correction for Coulomb interactions in slab geometry

New theoretical expressions for cut-off errors in 2D reciprocal-space summation of the electrostatic layer correction (ELC) term in energy and forces are derived, and a procedure to determine optimal parameters of the method is proposed. The procedure is tested in numerical calculations for charges distributed uniformly in a cubic box and charges located in two layers near the box basis. The summation errors for conventional Ewald method can be used to find out optimal values of the convergence parameter, and real- and reciprocal-space cut-off radii, whereas the ELC errors give possibility to choose an optimal value of an empty space gap in the simulation box.     

Integral equation theory for correcting truncation errors in molecular simulations

Various strategies for correcting structural and energetic artefacts of molecular simulations with truncated potentials based on integral equation theory are described and applied to liquid water. The performance of the methods is examined for a range of cutoff distances and different shifted-force potentials. With the recently enhanced damped Coulomb potential (D. Zahn, B. Schilling, S.M. Kast, J. Phys. Chem. B, 106 (2002) 10725), parameterised and corrected by integral equation theory, radial distribution functions and excess internal energy very close to the Ewald simulation limit are obtained from a simulation with a cutoff distance of only 6 Å.