A comparative study of solvent extraction of total petroleum hydrocarbons in soil

Three non-specific methods for the extraction of total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) from soil into organic solvent were compared. The techniques used for sample preparation were Soxhlet extraction, closed-vessel microwave-assisted extraction, and CEN shake extraction. The total concentrations of extracted compounds in the boiling point range of C10–C40 were determined by gas chromatography with flame ionization detection. The best recovery (99%) and repeatability (±3%) from standard oil mixtures were obtained with microwave-assisted extraction. However, the different extraction methods exhibited different behaviour when spiked soil samples were extracted. The best repeatability was obtained with CEN shake extraction (±6%) but the repeatability values for Soxhlet and microwave-assisted methods were quite high (>20%). However, the larger uncertainties of the latter extraction methods does not necessarily limit the applicability of these methods to the determination of petroleum hydrocarbons in soil, as in the assessment of soil contamination the expanded uncertainty of the result is usually not limited by analytical uncertainty, but rather by the uncertainty of the primary sampling stage. However, distinctive variation found in the chromatographic profiles illustrates that discretion should be obeyed when chromatograms obtained after application of different extraction methods on petroleum contaminated samples are to be used in the fingerprinting or age dating studies. Otherwise, misleading conclusions concerning the age of spillage could be drawn.     

Evaluating the impact of GC operating settings on GC-FID performance for total petroleum hydrocarbon (TPH) determination

Interlaboratory comparisons for the analysis of mineral oil have indicated that many laboratories have problems in producing data of acceptable quality, mainly because of variations in the gas chromatographic settings used in the determination. A D-optimal design was therefore utilized to study the effects of six different GC operating settings on the GC performance criterion proposed by ISO and CEN draft standards ISO/FDIS 16703:2004 and CEN prEN 14039:2004:E for total petroleum hydrocarbon (TPH) determination. Both qualitative and quantitative factors were investigated. The results indicate that the performance criterion can only be achieved if the splitless injection settings are carefully optimized. Otherwise mass discrimination readily affects the validity of the results. The most critical factors affecting GC performance were the inlet liner design, inlet temperature and injection volume. The methods, however, were robust with respect to small changes in split vent time, GC column flow and FID temperature. The results show that non-discriminating splitless injection can only be obtained by optimizing the injector settings with respect to the significant factors. The main conclusion that can be drawn is that, if no further standardization is to be given for TPH determination by GC-FID, then a proper estimate of the expanded uncertainty should be appended to the TPH results. Only then can the reliability of the TPH results be guaranteed and further justification thus gained to support the end-use of the data.     

Effect of sample matrix on the determination of total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) in soil by gas chromatography–flame ionization detection

Research papers in different fields of analytics indicate that the effect of matrix-induced chromatographic response enhancement (matrix effect) is a commonly encountered problem in gas chromatography applications. In this paper, an example of the effect of sample matrix on the quantitative determination of total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) by GC–FID in soil is presented. Two types of soil were selected for the evaluation. Extraction and analysis of the soil samples was in accordance with CEN prEN 14039. The relative systematic error resulting from the matrix effect was obtained for three different TPH concentrations by statistical comparison of the slopes of the matrix-matched calibration lines and a pure solvent calibration line. Too high TPH concentrations were obtained when conventional solvent calibration was used for quantitation. This demonstrates that matrix-matched calibration should be exploited in the determination of petroleum hydrocarbons in soil samples. However, there was also significant enhancement of the response due to an interfering matrix with decreasing analyte concentration. Enhancement seems to be especially evident in the quantification of TPH over the concentration range encountered in polluted environments. As a result, even when matrix-matched calibration is used for quantitation, it is still necessary to establish the range over which a linear response can be expected. Otherwise too high results for sample TPH concentrations will be obtained.     

高效液相色谱-气相色谱在线联用同时测定土壤中饱和烃和芳香烃

为加强对土壤中石油烃类污染物的风险管控,生态环境部已将石油烃类列为土壤中的重点监测项目。石油烃源于石油与合成油,是涵盖一定碳数范围的碳氢化合物,主要分为饱和烃和芳香烃两大类。芳香烃通常是高度烷基化的单环、双环与多环芳烃,其对人和动物的毒性较饱和烃大很多,因此,仅仅测定土壤中总石油烃含量难以准确评估其环境毒性。目前环境领域的标准方法尚未区分土壤中饱和烃和芳香烃。该研究针对土壤样品的基质干扰特点,对样品的提取和净化环节进行了优化,并且应用高效液相色谱-气相色谱在线联用(HPLC-GC)技术,建立了同时测定土壤中饱和烃和芳香烃的方法。其中,提取方法选择正己烷-乙醇(1∶1, v/v)以固液比1∶4常温振荡提取1 h,然后水洗去除乙醇,取正己烷层提取液净化;净化方法选择自制硅胶柱,以正己烷-二氯甲烷(8∶2, v/v)洗脱;洗脱液经浓缩注入HPLC-GC分析,以内标法同时测定试液中的饱和烃和芳香烃,方法的定量限为0.4 mg/kg。该方法经过土壤石油烃标准物(SQC-116)验证,测定值在证书提供的可信区间内,相对误差(RE)为10.6%,相对标准偏差(RSD)为1.4%,说明方法准确可靠且精密度达到分析要求。最后,该文采用建立的方法检测了北京地区的5个土壤样品,结果表明:5个样品均含有饱和烃(C₁₀~C₄₀),其含量范围为3.3~32.1 mg/kg;其中4个样品中检出芳香烃(C₁₀~C₄₀),其含量范围为0.8~4.3 mg/kg;此外,通过谱图分析还可以初步判别烃类物质的污染来源。     

Recovery of diesel fuel from soil by supercritical fluid extraction–gas chromatography

An analytical method based on CO₂ supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) followed by gas chromatography (GC) was evaluated, compared to Soxhlet extraction, and found to determine accurately and precisely diesel fuel contamination of standard soil samples at a total petroleum hydrocarbon level of 100 μg/g in soil. While both extraction methods have the same 3% relative repeatability standard deviation for determination of total hydrocarbon contamination at this level, SFE requires much less time, uses less organic solvent and provides better recovery of the more volatile n-C₁₀ to n-C₁₂ hydrocarbons.     

The determination of petroleum hydrocarbons in soil using a miniaturized extraction method and gas chromatography

A gas chromatographic (GC) method for the determination of petroleum hydrocarbons (PH) in the boiling range from 175°C to 525°C (C₁₀?C₄₀ alkane) in soil was evaluated. The extraction was carried out using minimal amounts of acetone and heptane, prior to a clean up with silica gel. The extraction procedure was tested by means of standard solutions of petroleum products and soil samples. The clean up procedure did not have any significant effect on the amounts of petroleum hydrocarbons present and hydrocarbons of natural origin were removed effectively. The recovery of the extraction and clean up procedure for petroleum products in soil was greater than 90%. The standard deviation for the repeatability was estimated to be less than 10% based on multiple analyses of homogenized soil samples. The detection limit for soil was determined to be 10 mg/kg dry matter. Comparing the GC method with the widely used infrared spectrometry (IR) method in combination with a Soxhlet-extraction using Freon-113, the results obtained are equivalent.     

Estimation of the efficiencies and uncertainties of the extraction and cleanup steps of pesticide residue determination in cucumber using <Superscript>14</Superscript>C-carbaryl

The estimation of the uncertainty of measurement has, nowadays, become an integral part of analytical results. The uncertainty and efficiency of extraction and cleanup are very important components of a pesticide residue analytical method. In this work, for a quick review of extraction and cleanup efficiency and to evaluate the individual analysis steps during method adaptation, ¹⁴C-carbaryl was applied at all fortification levels. Then, further analyses, such as ethylacetate extraction, filtration, evaporation and cleanup, were performed. The calibration of gel chromatograph column, performed with both ¹⁴C-carbaryl and fortification mixture (dichlorvos, malathion and chlorpyrifos), showed that pesticide fractions came through the column between the 8- and 23-mL fractions. The overall recovery of ¹⁴C-carbaryl after the extraction and cleanup step was 0.91, with the relative uncertainty of 0.084. Using the “bottom-up” approach, the uncertainty of extraction u _cEX and cleanup u _cGPC were 0.033 and 0.107, respectively. The combined standard uncertainty u _c associated with the described analytical method was 0.112. Similar values were obtained using the alternative “top-down” approach: uncertainty of extraction u _ct1 was 0.039, uncertainty of cleanup u _ct2 was 0.108 and the combined standard uncertainty u _cAV was 0.081. Both approaches showed that the uncertainty of cleanup was the main source of combined standard uncertainty.     

An internal surface reversed phase column for the effective removal of humic acid interferences in the trace analysis of mecoprop in soils with coupled-column RPLC-UV

In the development of a screening method for the determination of residues of mecoprop in soils involving coupled-column RPLC-UV (228 nm) the cleanup performance of a 5 μm GFF-II internal surface reversed phase (ISRP, Pinkerton) analytical column (50 × 4.6 mm I.D.) as a first column was investigated. In comparison to an analytical C18 column the ISRP column substantially improved the separation between acidic analyte and co-extracted humic substances. Under the selected coupled-column conditions soil extracts obtained after hydrolysis with an aqueous alkaline solution, acidifying and centrifugation could be analyzed directly allowing the determination of mecoprop in soils to a level of about 0.02 mg/kg. A rapid concentration step on a 100 mg C18 solid phase extraction (SPE) cartridge was adopted into the procedure providing a limit of detection (S/N = 3) of 0.01 mg/kg of mecoprop in soil. The method was validated by analyzing freshly spiked soil samples and samples with aged residues. In case of freshly spiked samples the overall recovery was 87% (n = 18, spiked level 0.02–8.0 mg/kg) with a repeatability of 6.8% and a reproducibility of 8.3%. No significant decrease of the recovery was observed for samples with aged residues (n = 15, spiked level 0.1 and 8.0 mg/kg) during a storage of 29 days in the refrigerator at about 4 °C; a storage of 67 days provided a mean recovery of 76% (n = 14, spiked level 8.0 mg/kg). Received: 4 May 1998 / Revised: 11 July 1998 / Accepted: 18 July 1998     

Comparison of various extraction techniques for the determination of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in worms

Two less laborious extraction methods, viz. (i) a simplified liquid extraction using light petroleum or (ii) microwave-assisted solvent extraction (MASE), for the analysis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in samples of the compost worm Eisenia andrei, were compared with a reference method. After extraction and concentration, analytical methodology consisted of a cleanup of (part) of the extract with high-performance gel permeation chromatography (HPGPC) and instrumental analysis of 15 PAHs with reversed-phase liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection (RPLC-FLD). Comparison of the methods was done by analysing samples with incurred residues (n=15, each method) originating from an experiment in which worms were exposed to a soil contaminated with PAHs. Simultaneously, the performance of the total lipid determination of each method was established. Evaluation of the data by means of principal component analysis (PCA) and analysis of variance (ANOVA) revealed that the performance of the light petroleum method for both the extraction of PAHs (concentration range 1-30 ng/g) and lipid content corresponds very well with the reference method. Compared to the reference method, the MASE method yielded somewhat lower concentrations for the less volatile PAHs, e.g., dibenzo[ah]anthracene and benzo[ghi]perylene and provided a significant higher amount of co-extracted material.     

Assisted solvent extraction and ion-trap tandem mass spectrometry for the determination of polychlorinated biphenyls in mussels. Comparison with other extraction techniques

A selective and sensitive analytical method for determination of ten congeners of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs 31, 28, 52, 101, 118, 153, 105, 138, 156, and 180) in mussel samples (Mytilus galloprovincialis) based on accelerated solvent extraction (ASE) and gas chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (GC–MS–MS) is presented in this work. Extraction conditions were optimised using a Plackett–Burman factorial design. The final extracts were analysed after cleanup on alumina columns. The optimised extraction parameters were solvent percentage, sample amount, extraction temperature, pressure, static extraction time, flush percentage, and purge time. The results suggest that PCBs 118, 105, and 180 extractions appeared affected by only one statistically significant factor, pressure, solvent percentage and static extraction time, respectively. Extraction of PCBs 138 and 156 was affected by amount of sample. PCB 138 extraction was also statistically affected by static extraction time and purge time. Quantitative recoveries (64.8–120.3%) were achieved for all PCBs and method precision (RSD < 19%) was satisfactory.     

Determination of ropivacaine in human plasma using highly selective molecular imprint-based solid phase extraction and fast LC–MS analysis

A method for determining ropivacaine in human plasma using highly selective molecular imprint-based solid phase extraction and LC–MS analysis was developed. The imprinted extraction material was prepared using a structural analogue of ropivacaine as the template. The efficient sample cleanup achieved allowed single MS mode operation and analytical separation under isocratic conditions with a total separation time of less than two minutes. The absence of ion suppression was confirmed for both the m/z of ropivacaine and the m/z of the internal standard. The solid phase extraction protocol was optimised for elution of ropivacaine in a small volume of aqueous-rich solvent suitable for injection into a reversed phase LC–MS system. The final method measured trace levels of ropivacaine in human plasma with a limit of quantification of 2.5 nmol/L and interassay accuracy and precision of 101.7–104.4% and 2.1–7.2%, respectively.     

Trace analysis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in suspended particulate matter by accelerated solvent extraction followed by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry

An analytical procedure based on extraction by accelerated solvent extraction (ASE) followed by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC/MS) analysis has been developed for the determination of particulate polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) from large-volume water samples (20 L). The effect of temperature and number of cycles on the efficiency of ASE was investigated: the best results were obtained by using a temperature of 100°C and one static cycle. A mixture of hexane/acetone 1:1 (v/v) was used as extraction solvent. Mean total method recovery under optimized conditions was 85%. The developed methodology was applied to the analysis of suspended particulate matter from Lake Maggiore waters (north of Italy). Mean PAH concentrations in suspended particulate matter from Lake Maggiore ranged from 0.2 ng L⁻¹ for anthracene to 18.7 ng L⁻¹ for naphthalene.     

Determination of wear metals in lubricating oils by flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry

A simple, rapid and reliable method was developed for the determination of copper, nickel, iron and lead in fresh and used lubricating oil samples by flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry (FAAS). In the present study, a mixture of organic solvents containing propionic acid and iso-butylmethyl ketone (1: 1) was used to extract the metals from lubricating oil samples followed by FAAS analysis. Aqueous standard solutions can be easily employed with the proposed mixed solvent system instead of organometallic standards. The analytical results obtained by employing the proposed solvent extraction system were found to be in good agreement with the results for aqueous media obtained after the destruction of oil samples matrix. Percentage recovery studies showed 88–98% for Cu, 92–95% for Fe, 96–106% for Ni and 84–100% for Pb with relative standard deviation of 2–6%. The developed method was effectively applied to routine determination of Cu, Ni, Fe, and Pb in lubricating oil samples.     

Analysis of alcohol ethoxylates and alkylamine ethoxylates in agricultural soils using pressurised liquid extraction and liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry

Nonionic surfactants e.g. alcohol ethoxylates (AEOs) and alkylamine ethoxylates (ANEOs) are commonly utilised as adjuvants in pesticide formulations to enhance their effectiveness. In this study, analytical methods for AEO and ANEO determination in soil samples using pressurised liquid extraction (PLE) were developed and used in connection with LC–MS. The recovery of the method, which was highly dependent on the soil properties, varied in the range 47–106% for AEO and 27–109% for ANEO. Detection limits (LOD) were 7–13 µg kg^–1 for AEO and 24–43 µg kg^–1 for ANEO. The developed method has been applied to determine AEOs and ANEOs in surface soil samples from fields sprayed with glyphosate herbicides. Tallowalkylamine ethoxylates (an ANEO) were detected in the soil before and after pesticide application, with increasing concentrations after treatment. The highest concentration in the soil samples was observed for the ANEO homologues with the longest ethoxy chains; in the clay soil the concentration decreased with the length of the ethoxy chain. ANEOs added to pesticide formulations as a technical mixture will, as demonstrated in this study, behave as individual homologues, which is reflected in their behaviour in the environment.Abbreviations AEO Alcohol ethoxylates - ANEO Alkylamine ethoxylates - APEO Alkylphenol ethoxylates - APCI Atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation - ASE Accelerated solvent extraction - CEC Cationic exchange capacity - LC–MS Liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry - LOD Limit of detection - MAE Microwave-assisted extraction - PLE Pressurised liquid extraction - SD Standard deviation - SIM Selected-ion monitoring - SPE Solid-phase extraction - TEA Triethylamine     

Determination of total petroleum hydrocarbons in soil from different locations using infrared spectrophotometry and gas chromatography

Total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) are important environmental contaminants which are toxic to human and environmental receptors. Several analytical methods have been used to quantify TPH levels in contaminated soils, specifically through infrared spectrometry (IR) and gas chromatography (GC). Despite being two of the most used techniques, some issues remain that have been inadequately studied: a) applicability of both techniques to soils contaminated with two distinct types of fuel (petrol and diesel), b) influence of the soil natural organic matter content on the results achieved by various analytical methods, and c) evaluation of the performance of both techniques in analyses of soils with different levels of contamination (presumably non-contaminated and potentially contaminated). The main objectives of this work were to answer these questions and to provide more complete information about the potentials and limitations of GC and IR techniques. The results led us to the following conclusions: a) IR analysis of soils contaminated with petrol is not suitable due to volatilisation losses, b) there is a significant influence of organic matter in IR analysis, and c) both techniques demonstrated the capacity to accurately quantify TPH in soils, irrespective of their contamination levels.     

Evaluation of clean-up agents for total petroleum hydrocarbon analysis in biota and sediments

Petroleum hydrocarbons (oil) are common environmental contaminants. For risk assessment purposes, their concentrations in environmental matrixes, such as biota and soils/sediments are frequently determined by solvent extraction and subsequent analysis with gas chromatography (GC) equipped with flame ionization detection (FID) or mass spectrometry (MS). Because the total GC detector response is labeled as total petroleum hydrocarbon (TPH) concentration and matrix compounds (lipids, organic matter) will contribute to this response, proper extract clean-up is crucial. Still, the choice for a specific clean-up material during open column chromatography often seems arbitrary, since no comparative study on clean-up agents for TPH analysis is available. Here, such a study is described and it is demonstrated that none of the commonly used agents fulfills the requirements of complete matrix compound removal and TPH recovery. A novel column filled with (top-down) 1 g of 33% (w/w) 1 M NaOH-impregnated and 2.2 g of 7% (w/w) H₂SO₄-impregnated silica gel is recommended for cleaning-up biota extracts, as it fully removes extracted lipids and yields acceptable TPH recoveries of around 90%, based on a certified oil reference standard. For sediment extracts, most columns tested resulted in a negligibly low contribution of matrix compounds to the overall detector response, but 5% deactivated Florisil or 10% deactivated aluminum oxide are preferable, because these materials yield the highest (∼95%) TPH recoveries.     

Microbial dynamics in oil-impacted prairie soil

A remote site in the Tallgrass Prairie Preserve (Osage County, OK) was contaminated with crude oil by a pipeline break in 1992. In 1996, the contaminated soil was bioremediated by blending with uncontaminated soil, prairie hay, buffalo manure, and commercial fertilizers, and spreading in a shallow layer over uncontaminated soil to create a landfarm. The landfarm was monitored for two years for aerobic and anaerobic bacteria, soil gases indicative of microbial activity, and for changes in the concentration of total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH). Levels of hydrocarbon degraders and soil gas indicators of aerobic degradation were stimulated in the landfarm during the first warm season relative to uncontaminated prairie soil. However, these same indicators were less conclusive during the second warm season, indicating depletion of the more easily degradable hydrocarbons, although the landfarm still contained 6,800 mg/kg TPH on the average at the beginning of the second warm season. Methane formation and methanogen counts were clearly stimulated in the first warm season relative to uncontaminated prairie soil, in dicating that methanogenesis plays an important role in the mineralization of hydrocarbons even in these shallow soils.     

Aqueous solubility calculation for petroleum mixtures in soil using comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography analysis data

An assessment of aqueous solubility (leaching potential) of soil contaminations with petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) is important in the context of the evaluation of (migration) risks and soil/groundwater remediation. Field measurements using monitoring wells often overestimate real TPH concentrations in case of presence of pure oil in the screened interval of the well. This paper presents a method to calculate TPH equilibrium concentrations in groundwater using soil analysis by high-performance liquid chromatography followed by comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (HPLC-GCXGC). The oil in the soil sample is divided into 79 defined hydrocarbon fractions on two GCXGC color plots. To each of these fractions a representative water solubility is assigned. Overall equilibrium water solubility of the non-aqueous phase liquid (NAPL) present in the sample and the water phase's chemical composition (in terms of the 79 fractions defined) are then calculated using Raoult's law. The calculation method was validated using soil spiked with 13 different TPH mixtures and 1 field-contaminated soil. Measured water solubilities using a column recirculation equilibration experiment agreed well to calculated equilibrium concentrations and water phase TPH composition.     

Determination of chlorobenzenes in environmental samples using solid phase microextraction, thermal desorption and analysis by gas chromatography coupled to FID, ECD, MSD, IRD detectors

Summary A complex method was developed for the determination of chlorobenzenes in soil and groundwater samples. Samples were taken at two sites in Baranya county, where a mixture of chlorobenzene waste was deposited, causing severe contamination in the environment. Clean-up of these sites demands modern and reliable analytical methods. Several sample preparation techniques were used, such as solid phase microextraction (SPME), supercritical fluid extraction (SFE), and a recently developed thermal desorption method. The applicability of various sample preparation methods was compared by measuring recovery percentages, relative standard deviations and by investigating the matrix dependency of these values. Gas chromatography was used for quantitative determination of chlorobenzenes, using MS, IR, FID and ECD detection techniques. Detection levels were as low as 1 ppt in water, and 10 ppt in soil samples. Chlorobenzene concentration was in the range 1 ppt-1 ppm in water and 100 ppb-100 ppm in soil samples. Identification and calibration of these compounds were performed by quantitative standards. This complex analytical method can be used for rapid and precise quantitative and qualitative determination of chlorobenzenes. Presented at: Balaton Symposium on High-Performance Separation Methods, Siófok, Hungary, September 3–5, 1997