Wall shear stress and void fraction in Poiseuille bubbly flows: Part II: experiments and validity of analytical predictions

In a companion paper, a simple analytical formulation has been established which provides the wall shear stress in laminar bubbly flows for idealised transverse void fraction distributions. In the present paper, this approach is applied to Poiseuille bubbly flows in circular ducts. New measurements of the void fraction profiles and wall friction angular distribution in a pipe are presented for a wide range of flow parameters. Approximating the void profiles by step-functions allows us to evaluate the wall friction with the above mentioned model. Results are shown to agree satisfactorily with measurements. Notably, negative wall shear stress and wall shear stress much higher than their single-phase flow counterpart at the same liquid flow rate are recovered. Therefore, the principal mechanisms responsible for friction modification are captured with this simple model.     

Bubble and liquid turbulence characteristics of bubbly flow in a large diameter vertical pipe

The bubble and liquid turbulence characteristics of air–water bubbly flow in a 200 mm diameter vertical pipe was experimentally investigated. The bubble characteristics were measured using a dual optical probe, while the liquid-phase turbulence was measured using hot-film anemometry. Measurements were performed at six liquid superficial velocities in the range of 0.2–0.68 m/s and gas superficial velocity from 0.005 to 0.18 m/s, corresponding to an area average void fraction from 1.2% to 15.4%. At low void fraction flow, the radial void fraction distribution showed a wall peak which changed to a core peak profile as the void fraction was increased. The liquid average velocity and the turbulence intensities were less uniform in the core region of the pipe as the void fraction profile changed from a wall to a core peak. In general, there is an increase in the turbulence intensities when the bubbles are introduced into the flow. However, a turbulence suppression was observed close to the wall at high liquid superficial velocities for low void fractions up to about 1.6%. The net radial interfacial force on the bubbles was estimated from the momentum equations using the measured profiles. The radial migration of the bubbles in the core region of the pipe, which determines the shape of the void profile, was related to the balance between the turbulent dispersion and the lift forces. The ratio between these forces was characterized by a dimensionless group that includes the area averaged Eötvös number, slip ratio, and the ratio between the apparent added kinetic energy to the actual kinetic energy of the liquid. A non-dimensional map based on this dimensionless group and the force ratio is proposed to distinguish the conditions under which a wall or core peak void profile occurs in bubbly flows.     

Numerical simulation of circulation in gas-liquid column reactors: isothermal, bubbly, laminar flow

The gas-liquid flow inside a circular, isothermal column reactor with a vertical axis has been studied using numerical simulations. The flow is assumed to be in the laminar, bubbly flow regime which is characterized by a suspension of discrete air bubbles in a continuous liquid phase such as glycerol water. The mathematical formulation is based on the conservation of mass and momentum principle for the liquid phase. The gas velocity distribution is calculated via an empirically prescribed relative velocity as a function of void fraction. The interface viscous drag forces are prescribed empirically. For some cases a profile shape is assumed for the void ratio distribution. The influence of various profile shapes is investigated. The results are compared with those where the void ratio distribution is calculated from the conservation of mass equation. The mathematical model has been implemented by modifying a readily available computer code for single-phase newtonian fluid flows. The numerical discretization is based on a finite volume approach. The predictions show a good agreement with measurements. The circulation pattern seems not to be so sensitive to the actual shape of the void fraction profiles, but the inlet distribution of it is important. A significantly different flow pattern results when the void fraction distribution is calculated from the transport equation, as compared to those with a priori prescribed profiles. When the void fraction is uniformly distributed over the whole distributor plate, no circulation is observed. Calculations also show that even the two-phase systems with a few discrete bubbles can be simulated successfully by a continuum model.     

Studies on two-phase cross flow. Part I: Flow characteristics around a cylinder

A two-phase flow around a body has scarcely been studied until now, though the flow is used in many industrial components. The cross flows around a spacer in a fuel assembly of light water reactors (LWR) and tube supports in a steam generator are closely related to the long-term reliability and the safety. The present study has been planned to clarify the two-phase flow and heat transfer characteristics around a body including the unknown complicated flow behavior. In the first report, the flow characteristics near and behind a cylinder which was located in a vertical upward air-water bubbly flow were investigated. From the observation of the flow patterns and the measurements of the distributions of void fraction, liquid velocity and static pressure, it is revealed that the vortex flow and the change of the static pressure and liquid velocity distribution around the cylinder resulted in the large distortion of the void fraction distribution around the cylinder. The most noticeable phenomena in the wake were that the peaks of the local void fraction appeared in the vicinity of the cylinder surface near the separation point and in the wake behind the cylinder.     

EULERIAN–LAGRANGIAN COMPUTATIONS ON PHASE DISTRIBUTION OF TWO-PHASE BUBBLY FLOWS

A comprehensively theoretical model is developed and numerically solved to investigate the phase distribution phenomena in a two-dimensional, axisymmetric, developing, two-phase bubbly flow. The Eulerian approach treats the fluid phase as a continuum and solved Eulerian conservation equations for the liquid phase. The Lagrangian bubbles are tracked by solving the equation of motion for the gas phase. The interphase momentum changes are included in the equations. The numerical model successfully predicts detailed flow velocity profiles for both liquid and gas phases. The development of the wall-peaking phenomenon of the void fraction and velocity profiles is also characterized for the developing flow. For 42 experiments in which the mean void fraction is less than 20 per cent, numerical calculations demonstrate that the predictions agree well with Liu's experimental data. © 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

The structure of bubbly flow through venturis

The phase structure of vertical air-water mixture flows through venturis were investigated using area contraction ratios of 3.16 and 7.11 and with variations in angles of convergence and divergence. The flow conditions were predominantly of the bubbly type and covered a range of gas volume fraction at the throat between 0.2 and 0.6 for average mixture velocities of up 32 m/s. Resistivity probe signals indicating void fluctuations were analyzed to yield local void fraction, bubble velocity, bubble detection rate and probability density function of bubble sizes in the flow. Velocity ratios were also obtained to provide information on the overall behaviour of the two concurrent phases. The resistivity probe was shown to give reliable results for bubble flows in a wide range of speeds indicating velocity ratios up to 1.7 in the venturi throat. All flows tended toward a stable and well-mixed bubbly pattern downstream of the venturi exit following a sufficient length. The void and velocity profiles here always appeared to be characterized by a local maximum in the pipe centre, the local maximum close to the wall of some of the inlet flows being eliminated. Bubble coalescence was noted in the convergent passage whilst significant bubble fragmentation in the divergent passage was observed from the results.     

Experimental study of “laminar” bubbly flows in a vertical pipe

Measurement of bubbly two-phase flow parameters in a vertical pipe were performed. To keep the pipe Reynolds number below that for single-phase turbulent transition, a water-glycerin solution was used as the test liquid. Local void fraction and liquid velocity profiles along with the wall shear stress were measured by an electrochemical method. Experiments were made with bubbles of two different sizes. As the gas flow rate was increased, a gradual development of the liquid velocity profile from the parabolic Poiseuille flow to a flattened two-phase profile was observed. The evolution of the wall shear stress and of the velocity fluctuations were also quantified.Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique. Université Joseph Fourier, Institut National Polytechnique de Grenoble.     

Turbulence structure of air-water bubbly flow—II. local properties

Microstructure was studied experimentally in air-water two-phase bubbly flow flowing upward in a vertical pipe of 60 mm diameter under atmospheric pressure. The results indicate that over a large portion of fully-developed bubbly flow the phases, the velocities of bubbles and water, and the ratio between the velocities of the phases have fairly flat radial profiles. In the wall region a maximum void fraction was observed. Spectra of the velocities of bubbles and water showed a Poisson distribution and a normal distribution function, respectively. The experimental evidence indicated a trend for the turbulent intensity to decrease first with increasing gas flow rate for constant water velocity and to increase again with a further increase in the gas flow rate. This phenomenon was more significant for a higher water velocity.     

Characteristics of developing vertical bubbly flow under normal and microgravity conditions

The axial development of the void fraction profile, interfacial area concentration and Sauter mean bubble diameter of adiabatic nitrogen-water bubbly flows in a 9 mm-diameter pipe were measured using stereo image processing under normal and microgravity conditions. The flow measurements were performed at four axial locations (axial distance from the inlet, z normalized by the pipe diameter, D, z/D = 5, 20, 40 and 60) and with various flows: superficial gas velocity of 0.00840-0.0298 m/s, and superficial liquid velocity of 0.138-0.914 m/s. The effect of gravity on radial distribution of bubbles and the axial development of two-phase flow parameters is discussed in detail based on the obtained database and visual observation. Following Serizawa-Kataoka’s phase distribution pattern criteria under normal gravity conditions, the phase distribution pattern map was developed. Similar to normal gravity two-phase flows, wall, core and intermediate void peak patterns are observed under microgravity conditions but a transition void distribution pattern is not observed in the current experimental conditions. The data obtained in the current experiment are expected to contribute to the benchmarking of CFD simulation of phase distribution pattern and interfacial area concentration in forced convective pipe flow under microgravity conditions.     

Study of local hydrodynamic characteristics of upward slug flow

Results of an experimental study of local velocity, fluctuation and void fraction profiles in liquid plugs of an upward vertical gas-liquid flow as well as of wall shear stress distribution both under gas slugs and in liquid plugs, are presented. The conditional sampling technique allowed to obtain instantaneous profiles of the above hydrodynamical quantities, which illuminated the real physical picture of the flow in a liquid plug. The toroidal vortex adjacent to the bottom of a gas slug is shown to determine significantly the development of the flow in a liquid plug. The intensity of this vortex is determined only by the relative velocity of the gas bubble with respect to the liquid.     

Scaling of damping induced by bubbly flow across tubes

The damping of tubes subjected to two-phase air–water bubbly cross-flow is investigated with the use of an experimental database from several authors. A new definition of damping in stagnant flow is proposed using an extrapolation of the measured values at low dimensionless flow velocities. This approach yields values of damping substantially lower than those currently defined in the literature. They are found to vary continuously with void fraction, within the bubbly flow regime. These data are used to compare several models of the equivalent viscosity of a two-phase mixture. The effect of the flow velocity is then analysed up to fluidelastic instability. It is observed that, using scaling factors based on the characteristics of the liquid phase, fluidelastic effects of bubbly flows are closely related to those known in single-phase flows.     

Void fraction,bubble velocity and bubble size in two-phase flow

Experiments were performed in atmosphereic vertical air-water flows, for void fractions between 0.25 and 0.75 (cross-sectional averages) and superficial liquid velocities of 1.3, 1.7 and 2.1 m/s. Local values of void fraction and bubble velocity as well as the bubble diameter were measured by means of a resistivity probe technique. Reliable values were obtained for the local void fraction over the entire range $\text{0 ≤ α ≤ 1}$. The void fraction profiles appeared to have a local maximum at the pipe center, local maxima close to the wall were obviously absent. The resistivity probes are shown to measure the velocity of the interface between the conducting and nonconducting phases, which equals the gas velocity only for low void fractions. The measured data for void fraction and bubble velocity were correlated by means of power law distribution functions, with exponents given by a function of the cross-sectionally averaged void fraction. The Sauter mean diameters for the bubble size spectra found, agree reasonably well with diameters predicted by a theoretical model based on the energy dissipation in the flow.     

On the liquid turbulence energy spectra in two-phase bubbly flow in a large diameter vertical pipe

The liquid turbulence structure of air–water bubbly flow in a 200 mm diameter vertical pipe was experimentally investigated. A dual optical probe was used to measure the bubble characteristics, while the liquid turbulence was measured using hot-film anemometry. Experiments were performed at two liquid superficial velocities of 0.2 and 0.68 m/s for gas superficial velocities in the range of 0–0.18 m/s, corresponding to an area averaged void fraction up to 13.6%. In general, there is an increase in the liquid turbulence energy when the bubbles are introduced into the liquid flow. The increase in the energy mainly occurs over a range of length scales that are on the order of the bubble diameter. A suppression of the turbulence was observed close to the wall at very low void fraction flows. Initially, the suppression occurs in the low wave number range and then extends to higher wave numbers as the suppression is increased.     

Bubbly-to-cap bubbly flow transition in a long-26 m vertical large diameter pipe at low liquid flow rate

The concurrent upward two-phase flow of air and water in a long vertical large diameter pipe with an inner diameter (D) of 200 mm and a height (z) of 26 m (z/D = 130) was investigated experimentally at low superficial liquid velocities from 0.05009 to 0.3121 m/s and the superficial gas velocities from 0.01779 to 0.5069 m/s. The resultant void fractions range from 0.03579 to 0.4059. According to the observations using a high speed video camera, the flow regimes of bubbly, developing cap bubbly and fully-developed cap bubbly flows prevailed in the flows. The developing cap bubbly flow appeared as a flow regime transition from bubbly to fully-developed cap bubble flow in the vertical large diameter pipe. The developing cap bubbly flow changes gradually and lasts for a long time period and a wide axial region in the flow direction, in contrast to a sudden transition from bubbly to slug flows in a small diameter pipe. The analysis in this study showed that the flow regime transition depends not only on the void fraction but also on the axial distance in the flow and the pipe diameter. The axial flow development brings about the transition to happen in a lower void fraction flow and the increase of pipe diameter causes the transition to happen in a higher void fraction flow. The measured void fraction showed an N-shaped axial changing manner that the void fraction increases monotonously with axial position in the bubbly flow, decreases non-monotonously with axial position in the developing cap bubbly flow, and increases monotonously again with axial position in the fully-developed cap bubbly flow. The temporary void fraction decrease phenomenon in the transition region from bubbly to cap bubbly flow can be attributed to the formation of medium to large cap bubbles and their gradual growth into the maximum size of cap bubble and/or cluster of large cap bubbles in the developing cap bubbly flow. In order to predict the N-shaped axial void fraction changing behaviors in the flow regime transition from bubbly to cap bubbly flow, the existing 12 drift flux correlation sets for large diameter pipes are reviewed and their predictabilities are studied against the present experimental data. Although some drift flux correlation sets, such as those of Clark and Flemmer (1986) and Hibiki and Ishii (2003), can predict the present experimental data with reasonable average relative deviations, no drift flux correlation set for distribution parameter and drift velocity can give a reliable prediction for the observed N-shaped axial void fraction changing behaviors in the region from bubbly to cap bubbly flow in a vertical large diameter pipe.     

A New Approach in Modeling Phase Distribution in Fully Developed Bubbly Pipe Flow

Turbulent two-phase flow equations are derived and solved for fully developed pipe flow using a composite eddy-viscosity model and a new void-fraction equation. The void fraction profile is first specified from experiments and the velocity field is calculated to validate the eddy-viscosity model. Consequently, a new equation is presented for calculation of the void fraction. This void-fraction equation incorporates the gradient of turbulent normal stresses in the radial direction, the conventional lift force, and a contribution from the unsteady drag force. The implications of this new equation, for the bubbly flow regime, are investigated by calculating the void-fraction distribution for a given velocity field. Inclusion of the normal turbulent stresses in the radial direction is shown to simulate correctly the experimentally observed trends of the phase distribution, both for upward and downward bubbly flow, without the need for a fictitious term such as the so called ``lubrication force'. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Flow pattern and flow characteristics for counter-current two-phase flow in a vertical round tube with wire-coil inserts

Flow pattern, void fraction and slug rise velocity on counter-current two-phase flow in a vertical round tube with wire-coil inserts are experimentally studied. Flow pattern and slug rise velocity are measured visually with a video camera. The void fraction is measured by the quick-closing valve method. Four kinds of coils with different coil pitches and coil diameters are used as inserts. The presence of wire-coil inserts induces disturbance into gas and liquid flows so that the shape and motion of gas slug or bubbles in a wire-coil inserted tube are quite different from those observed in a smooth tube without insert. The bubbly flow occurs in the low gas superficial velocity region in the wire-coil inserted tube, while the slug or churn/annular flow only appears in the smooth tube without insert over the all test range. The measured slug rise velocity in the wire-coil inserted tube is higher than that in the smooth tube. With modified mean flow velocity calculated with core area, the slug rise velocity in wire-coil tube inserted is in good agreement with Nicklin's correlation. The void fraction in a wire-coil inserted tube is lower than that in a smooth tube in the range of high gas superficial velocities. By introducing a simple assumption on considering the effective flowing area, the measured void fractions in a wire-coil inserted tube are in relatively good agreement with the predicted result based on the drift flux model proposed by others with the correlation for slug rise velocity given by others when the coil pitch is dense.     

Local liquid velocity measurements in air-water bubbly flow

Local measurements of axial liquid velocity were performed for vertical upward air-water bubbly flow in a 101.6-mm inner-diameter round pipe by using a laser Doppler anemometer (LDA) and a hot-film anemometer (HFA). The data reduction approaches for both the LDA and HFA are discussed in detail. A threshold scheme with the information of local void fraction and velocity distribution in single-phase flow was applied to the LDA to approximately discriminate liquid velocity signals from those of the bubble interface velocity. Furthermore, a formulation was given to account for the effect of the bubble relative velocity on the liquid in the front and wake regions of the bubbles. For the HFA, an amplitude threshold scheme and a slope criterion were used to extract liquid velocity information. To reduce the measurement uncertainty, the experiments were performed in flow conditions where the area-averaged void fraction was less than 20%. The experimental results showed satisfactory agreement between the liquid volumetric flow rates calculated by area integration of the local liquid velocity and void fraction measurements, and the measured value by a magnetic flow meter. Also, the area-averaged relative velocity between the gas and liquid phases obtained from the current measurements agreed well with previous research.     

Comparison of results from DNS of bubbly flows with a two-fluid model for two-dimensional laminar flows

Results from direct numerical simulations of laminar bubbly flow in a vertical channel are compared with predictions of a two-fluid model for steady-state flow. The simulations are done assuming a two-dimensional system and the model coefficients are adjusted slightly to match the data for upflow. The model is then tested by comparisons with different values of flow rate and gravity, as well as downflow. In all cases the results agree reasonably well, even though the simulated void fraction is considerably higher than what is assumed in the derivation of the model. The results do, however, suggest a need to understand the lift and the wall repulsion force on bubbles better, particularly in dense flows.     

Development of co-current air–water flow in a vertical pipe

Measurements of the cross-sectional distribution of the gas fraction and bubble size distributions were conducted in a vertical pipe with an inner diameter of 51.2 mm and a length of about 3 m for air/water bubbly and slug flow regimes. The use of a wire-mesh sensor obtained a high resolution of the gas fraction data in space as well as in time. From this data, time averaged values for the two-dimensional gas fraction profiles were decomposed into a large number of bubble size classes. This allowed the extraction of the radial gas fraction profiles for a given range of bubble sizes as well as data for local bubble size distributions. The structure of the flow can be characterized by such data. The measurements were performed for up to 10 different inlet lengths and for about 100 combinations of gas and liquid volume flow rates. The data is very useful for the development and validation of meso-scale models to account for the forces acting on a bubble in a shear liquid flow and models for bubble coalescence and break-up. Such models are necessary for the validation of CFD codes for the simulation of bubbly flows.