Comparative analysis of methods for heat losses in turbulent premixed flames using physically-derived reduced-order manifolds

Heat losses have the potential to substantially modify turbulent combustion processes, especially the formation of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides. The chemistry governing these species is strongly temperature sensitive, making heat losses critical for an accurate prediction. To account for the effects of heat loss in large eddy simulation (LES) using a precomputed reduced-order manifold approach, thermochemical states must be precomputed not only for adiabatic conditions but also over a range of reduced enthalpy states. However, there are a number of methods for producing reduced enthalpy states, which invoke different implicit assumptions. In this work, a set of a priori and a posteriori LES studies have been performed for turbulent premixed flames considering heat losses within a precomputed reduced-order manifold approach to determine the sensitivity to the method by which reduced enthalpy states are generated. Two general approaches are explored for generating these reduced enthalpy states and are compared in detail to assess any effects on turbulent flame structure and emissions. In the first approach, the enthalpy is reduced at the boundary of the one-dimensional (1D) premixed flame solution, resulting in a single enthalpy deficit for a single premixed flame solution. In the second approach, a variable heat loss source term is introduced into the 1D flame solutions by mimicking a real heat loss to reduce the post-flame enthalpy. The two approaches are compared in methane–air piloted turbulent premixed planar jet flames with different diluents that maintain a constant adiabatic flame temperature but experience different radiation heat losses. Both a priori and a posteriori results, as well as a chemical pathway analysis, indicate that the manner by which the heat loss is accounted for in the manifold is of secondary importance compared to other model uncertainties such as the chemical mechanism, except in situations where heat loss is unphysically fast compared to the flame time scale. A new theoretical framework to explain this insensitivity is also proposed, and its validity is briefly assessed.     

Flame balls dynamics in divergent channel

A three-dimensional reaction-diffusion model for lean low-Lewis-number premixed flames with radiative heat losses propagating in divergent channel is studied numerically. Effects of inlet gas velocity and heat-loss intensity on flame structure at low Lewis numbers are investigated. It is found that continuous flame front exists at small heat losses and the separate flame balls settled within restricted domain inside the divergent channel at large heat losses. It is shown that the time averaged flame balls coordinate may be considered as important characteristic analogous to coordinate of continuous flame stabilized in divergent channel.     

Polydisperse effects in jet spray flames

A laminar jet polydisperse spray diffusion flame is analysed mathematically for the first time using an extension of classical similarity solutions for gaseous jet flames. The analysis enables a comparison to be drawn between conditions for flame stability or flame blow-out for purely gaseous flames and for spray flames. It is found that, in contrast to the Schmidt number criteria relevant to gas flames, droplet size and initial spray polydispersity play a critical role in determining potential flame scenarios. Some qualitative agreement for lift-off height is found when comparing predictions of the theory and sparse independent experimental evidence from the literature.     

Stationary combustion regimes and extinction limits of one-dimensional stretched premixed flames in a gap between two heat conducting plates

Stationary combustion regimes, their linear stability and extinction limits of stretched premixed flames in a narrow gap between two heat conducting plates are studied by means of numerical simulations in the framework of one-dimensional thermal-diffusion model with overall one-step reaction. Various stationary combustion modes including normal flame (NF), near-stagnation plane flame (NSF), weak flame (WF) and distant flame (DF) are detected and found to be analogous to the same-named regimes of conventional counterflow flames. For the flames stabilized in the vicinity of stagnation plane at moderate and large stretch rates (which are NF, NSF and WF) the effect of channel walls is basically reduced to additional heat loss. For distant flame characterized by large flame separation distance and small stretch rates intensive interphase heat transfer and heat recirculation are typical. It is shown that in mixture content / stretch rate plane the extinction limit curve has ε-shape, while for conventional counterflow flames it is known to be C-shaped. This result is quite in line with recent experimental findings and is explained by extension of extinction limits at small stretch rates at the expense of heat recirculation. Analysis of the numerical results makes possible to reveal prime mechanisms of flame quenching on different branches of ε-shaped extinction limit curve. Namely, two upper limits are caused by stretch and heat loss. These limits are direct analogs of the upper and lower limits on conventional C-shaped curve. Two other limits are related with weakening of heat recirculation and heat dissipation to the burner. Thus, the present study provides a satisfactory explanation for the recent experimental observations of stretched flames in narrow channel.     

Ultra-lean hydrogen-enriched oscillating flames behind a heat conducting bluff-body: Anomalous and normal blow–off

This paper presents a numerical study of ultra-lean hydrogen-methane flames stabilized behind a rectangular, highly conducting metallic bluff body acting as a flame holder. Using high fidelity numerical simulations, we show that lean inverted steady flames exist below normal flammability limits. They have distinct stabilization mechanism from pure methane flames. These flames are blown-off for sufficiently small velocities, a phenomenon called anomalous blow-off. At even leaner conditions oscillating ultra–lean hydrogen-methane flames can be established. These oscillating flames exist within a rather small range of equivalence ratios and inflow velocities, and move to mean locations closer to the flame holder as the reactant flow is increased. We show that the oscillations are associated with the shedding of flame balls from the downstream end of a “residual flame” that remains attached. Unlike their steady counterparts, the oscillating flames exhibit blow-off at both low velocities (anomalous blow-off) and at sufficiently high inflow velocities (normal blow-off). We show that normal blow-off is linked to heat losses to the flame holder.     

Experimental measurements of geometric properties of turbulent stratified flames

Combustion under stratified conditions is common in many systems. However, relatively little is known about the structure and dynamics of turbulent stratified flames. Two-dimensional imaging diagnostics are applied to premixed and stratified V-flames at a mean equivalence ratio of 0.77, and low turbulent intensity, within the corrugated flame range. The present results show that stratification affects the mean turbulent flame speed, structure and geometric properties. Stratification increases the flame surface density above the premixed flame levels in all cases, with a maximum reached at intermediate levels of stratification. The flame surface density (FSD) of stratified flames is higher than that of premixed flames at the same mean equivalence ratio. Under the present conditions, the FSD peaks at a stratification ratio around 3.0. The FSD curves for stratified flames are further skewed towards the product side. The distribution of flame curvature in stratified flames is broader and more symmetric relative to premixed flames, indicating an additional mechanism of curvature generation, which is not necessarily due to cusping. These experiments indicate that flame stratification affects the intrinsic behaviour of turbulent flames and suggest that models may need to be revised in the light of the current evidence.     

重力对扩散射流火焰动态特性的影响

本文探讨重力对扩散射流火焰动态特性的影响规律。结果表明,火焰闪烁现象是一种浮力诱导不稳定性,在浮力消失或反向重力场中,不存在这种不稳定性现象,闪烁频率与燃料射流速度无直接关系,但涡的大小随燃料射流速度的增大而增大。存在触发火焰闪烁的临界高度,闪烁频率与重力成平方根关系式。反向重力情况下,也存在浮力稳定型平面火焰,它反映了浮力与火焰的耦合作用。     

An apparatus-independent extinction strain rate in counterflow flames

Resistance to extinction by stretch is a key property of any flame, and recent work has shown that this property controls the overall structure of several important types of turbulent flames. Multiple definitions of the critical strain rate at extinction (ESR) have been presented in the literature. However, even if the same definition is used, different experiments report different extinction strain rates for flames burning the same fuel-air mixture at very similar temperatures using similarly constructed opposed-flow instruments. Here we show that at extinction, all these flames are essentially identical, so one would expect that each would be assigned the same value of a parameter representing its intrinsic resistance-to-stretch-induced-extinction, regardless of the specifics of the experimental apparatus. A similar situation arises in laminar flame speed measurements since different apparatuses could result in different strain rate distributions. In that instance, the community has agreed to report the unstretched laminar flame speed, and methods have been developed to translate the experimental (stretched) flame speed into a universal unstretched laminar flame speed. We propose an analogous method for translating experimental measurements for stretch-induced extinction into an unambiguous and apparatus-independent quantity (ESR_∞) by extrapolating to infinite opposing burner separation distance. The uniqueness of the flame at extinction is shown numerically and supported experimentally for twin premixed, single premixed, and diffusion flames at Lewis numbers greater than and less than one. A method for deriving ESR_∞ from finite-boundary experimental studies is proposed and demonstrated for methane and propane experimental diffusion and premixed single flame data. The two values agree within the range of ESR differences typically observed between experimental measurements and simulation results for the traditional ESR definition.     

Turbulent propagation of premixed flames in the presence of Darrieus–Landau instability

We investigate the role played by hydrodynamic instability in the wrinkled flamelet regime of turbulent combustion, where the intensity of turbulence is small compared to the laminar flame speed and the scale large compared to the flame thickness. To this end the Michelson–Sivashinsky (MS) equation for flame front propagation in one and two spatial dimensions is studied in the presence of uncorrelated and correlated noise representing a turbulent flow field. The combined effect of turbulence intensity, integral scale, and an instability parameter related to the Markstein length are examined and turbulent propagation speed monitored for both stable planar flames and corrugated flames for which the planar conformation is unstable. For planar flames a particularly simple scaling law emerges, involving quadratic dependence on intensity and a linear dependence on the degree of instability. For corrugated flames we find the dependence on intensity to be substantially weaker than quadratic, revealing that corrugated flames are more resilient to turbulence than planar flames. The existence of a threshold turbulence intensity is also observed, below which the corrugated flame in the presence of turbulence behaves like a laminar flame. We also analyze the conformation of the flame surface in the presence of turbulence, revealing primary, large-scale wrinkles of a size comparable to the main corrugation. When the integral scale is much smaller than the characteristic corrugation length we observe, in addition to primary wrinkles, secondary small-scale wrinkles contaminating the surface. The flame then acquires a multi-scale, self-similar conformation, with a fractal dimension, for one-dimensional flames, plateauing at 1.23 for large intensities. The existence of an intermediate integral scale is also found at which the turbulent speed is maximized. When two-dimensional flames are subject to turbulence, the primary wrinkling patterns give rise to polyhedral-cellular structures which bear a very close resemblance to those observed in experiments on hydrodynamically unstable expanding spherical flames.     

The two-dimensional structure of low strain rate counterflow nonpremixed-methane flames in normal and microgravity

The structure and extinction of low strain rate nonpremixed methane–air flames was studied numerically and experimentally. A time-dependent axisymmetric two-dimensional (2D) model considering buoyancy effects and radiative heat transfer was developed to capture the structure and extinction limits of normal gravity (1-g) and zero gravity (0-g) flames. For comparison with the 2D modelling results, a one-dimensional (1D) flamelet computation using a previously developed numerical code was exercised to provide information on the 0-g flames. A 3-step global reaction mechanism was used in both the 1D and 2D computations to predict the measured extinction limit and flame temperature. Photographic images of flames undergoing the process of extinction were compared with model calculations. The axisymmetric numerical model was validated by comparing flame shapes, temperature profiles, and extinction limits with experiments and with the 1D computational results. The 2D computations yielded insight into the extinction mode and flame structure. A specific maximum heat release rate was introduced to quantify the local flame strength and to elucidate the extinction mechanism. The contribution by each term in the energy equation to the heat release rate was evaluated to investigate the multi-dimensional structure and radiative extinction of the 1-g flames. Two combustion regimes depending on the extinction mode were identified. Lateral heat loss effects and multi-dimensional flame and flow structure were also found. At low strain rates in 1-g flames (‘regime A’), the flame is extinguished from the weak outer edge of the flame, which is attributed to a multi-dimensional flame structure and flow field. At high strain rates, (‘regime B’), the flame extinction initiates near the flame centreline owing to an increased diluent concentration in the reaction zone, similar to the extinction mode of 1D flames. These two extinction modes can be clearly explained by consideration of the specific maximum heat release rate.     

Analytical predictions of shapes of laminar diffusion flames in microgravity and earth gravity

Flame shape is an important observed characteristic of flames that can be used to scale flame properties such as heat release rates and radiation. Flame shape is affected by fuel type, oxygen levels in the oxidiser, inverse burning and gravity. The objective of this study is to understand the effect of high oxygen concentrations, inverse burning, and gravity on the predictions of flame shapes. Flame shapes are obtained from recent analytical models and compared with experimental data for a number of inverse and normal ethane flame configurations with varying oxygen concentrations in the oxidiser and under earth gravity and microgravity conditions. The Roper flame shape model was extended to predict the complete flame shapes of laminar gas jet normal and inverse diffusion flames on round burners. The Spalding model was extended to inverse diffusion flames. The results show that the extended Roper model results in reasonable predictions for all microgravity and earth gravity flames except for enhanced oxygen normal diffusion flames under earth gravity conditions. The results also show trends towards cooler flames in microgravity that are in line with past experimental observations. Some key characteristics of the predicted flame shapes and parameters needed to describe the flame shape using the extended Roper model are discussed.     

Dynamics and burning limits of near-limit hot,warm, and cool diffusion flames of dimethyl ether at elevated pressures

The near-limit diffusion flame regimes and extinction limits of dimethyl ether at elevated pressures and temperatures are examined numerically in the counterflow geometry with and without radiation at different oxygen concentrations. It is found that there are three different flame regimes—hot flame, warm flame, and cool flame—which exist, respectively, at high, intermediate, and low temperatures. Furthermore, they are governed by three distinct chain-branching reaction pathways. The results demonstrate that the warm flame has a double reaction zone structure and plays a critical role in the transition between cool and hot flames. It is also shown that the cool flame can be formed in several different ways: by either radiative extinction or stretch extinction of a hot flame or by stretch extinction of a warm flame. A warm flame can also be formed by radiative extinction of a hot flame or ignition of a cool flame. A general €-shaped flammability diagram showing the burning limits of all three flame regimes at different oxygen mole fractions is obtained. The results show that thermal radiation, reactant concentration, temperature, and pressure all have significant impacts on the flammable regions of the three flame regimes. Increases in oxidizer temperature, oxygen concentration, and pressure shift the cool flame regime to higher stretch rates and cause the warm flame to have two extinction limits. At elevated temperatures, it is found that there is a direct transition between the hot flame and warm flame at low stretch rates. The results also show that, unlike the hot flame, the cool flame structure cannot be scaled by using pressure-weighted stretch rates due to the its significant reactant leakage and strong dependence of reactivity on pressure. The present results advance the understanding of near-limit flame dynamics and provide guidance for experimental observation of different flame regimes.     

Structural response of different Lewis number premixed flames interacting with a toroidal vortex

Simultaneous measurements of temperature, CH* and OH* chemiluminescent species are carried out to explore the impact of stretch rate and curvature on the structure of premixed flames. The configuration of an initially flat premixed flame interacting with a toroidal vortex is selected for the present study and reasons for this choice are discussed. Lewis number effects are assessed by comparing methane and propane flames. It is emphasized that the flame structure experiences very strong variations. In particular, the flame is shrunk (broadened) in the initial (final) period of the interaction with the vortex where strain rate (curvature) contribution of the stretch rate is predominant. By further analysing independently the thickness of the preheat and reaction zones, it is shown that for propane flames, not only the former but also the latter is significantly altered in zones where the flame curvature is negative. Changes in the reaction zone properties are further emphasized using CH* and OH* radicals. It is demonstrated that higher thermal diffusivity plays a significant role around curved regions, in which the enhanced diffusion of heat leads to a strong increase of CH* compared to OH* intensity. As an overall conclusion, this study suggests that it would be interesting to reassess the internal flame structure at lower and moderate Karlovitz numbers since changes might appear for a moderate vortex intensity with typical size much larger than the flame thickness.     

Experimental measurements of two-dimensional planar propagating edge flames

The study of edge flames has received increased attention in recent years. This work reports the results of a recent study into two-dimensional, planar, propagating edge flames that are remote from solid surfaces (called here, “free-layer” flames, as opposed to layered flames along floors or ceilings). They represent an ideal case of a flame propagating down a flammable plume, or through a flammable layer in microgravity. The results were generated using a new apparatus in which a thin stream of gaseous fuel is injected into a low-speed laminar wind tunnel thereby forming a flammable layer along the centerline. An airfoil-shaped fuel dispenser downstream of the duct inlet issues ethane from a slot in the trailing edge. The air and ethane mix due to mass diffusion while flowing up towards the duct exit, forming a flammable layer with a steep lateral fuel concentration gradient and smaller axial fuel concentration gradient. We characterized the flow and fuel concentration fields in the duct using hot wire anemometer scans, flow visualization using smoke traces, and non-reacting, numerical modeling using COSMOSFloWorks. In the experiment, a hot wire near the exit ignites the ethane-air layer, with the flame propagating downwards towards the fuel source. Reported here are tests with the air inlet velocity of 25 cm/s and ethane flows of 967-1299 sccm, which gave conditions ranging from lean to rich along the centerline. In these conditions the flame spreads at a constant rate faster than the laminar burning rate for a premixed ethane-air mixture. The flame spread rate increases with increasing transverse fuel gradient (obtained by increasing the fuel flow rate), but appears to reach a maximum. The flow field shows little effect due to the flame approach near the igniter, but shows significant effect, including flow reversal, well ahead of the flame as it approaches the airfoil fuel source.     

圆柱火焰的可燃极限及稳定性分析

本文从理论上分析了有辐射热损失和曲率的圆柱火焰,推导出了关于火焰位置、火焰温度同热损失和来流速度之间的关系式。并在此基础上对圆柱火焰的可燃极限进行了研究,结果表明热损失对可燃极限产生很大的影响。另外,作者运用线性稳定分析法对有辐射热损失的圆柱火焰作了稳定性分析,得出了判断圆柱火焰稳定与否的通用表达式。     

Characteristics of microjet methane diffusion flames

Characteristics of microjet methane diffusion flames stabilized on top of the vertically oriented, stainless-steel tubes with an inner diameter ranging from 186 to 778 μ m are investigated experimentally, theoretically and numerically. Of particular interest are the flame shape, flame length and quenching limit, as they may be related to the minimum size and power of the devices in which such flames would be used for future micro-power generation. Experimental measurements of the flame shape, flame length and quenching velocity are compared with theoretical predictions as well as detailed numerical simulations. Comparisons of the theoretical predictions with measured results show that only Roper's model can satisfactorily predict the flame height and quenching velocity of microjet methane flames. Detailed numerical simulations, using skeletal chemical kinetic mechanism, of the flames stabilized at the tip of d = 186, 324 and 529 μ m tubes are performed to investigate the flame structures and the effects of burner materials on the standoff distance near extinction limit. The computed flame shape and flame length for the d = 186 μm flame are in excellent agreement with experimental results. Numerical predictions of the flame structures strongly suggest that the flame burns in a diffusion mode near the extinction limit. The calculated OH mass fraction isopleths indicate that different tube materials have a minor effect on the standoff distance, but influence the quenching gap between the flame and the tube.     

Interaction of a premixed flame with a liquid fuel film on a wall

In piston engines and in gas turbines, the injection of liquid fuel often leads to the formation of a liquid film on the combustor wall. If a flame reaches this zone, undesired phenomena such as coking may occur and diminish the lifetime of the engine. Moreover, the effect of such an interaction on maximum wall heat fluxes, flame quenching, and pollutant formation is largely unknown. This paper presents a numerical study of the interaction of a premixed flame with a cold wall covered with a film of liquid fuel. Simulations show that the presence of the film leads to a very rich zone at the wall in which the flame cannot propagate. As a result, the flame wall distance remains larger with liquid fuel than it is for a dry wall, and maximum heat fluxes are smaller. The nature of the interaction of flame wall interaction with a liquid fuel is also different from the classical flame/dry wall interaction: it is controlled mainly by chemical mechanisms and not by the thermal quenching effect observed for flames interacting with dry walls: the existence of a very rich zone created above the liquid film is the main mechanism controlling quenching.     

Heat release rate as represented by [OH] × [CH2O] and its role in autoignition

Data from a recent instantaneous, simultaneous, high-resolution imaging experiment of Rayleigh temperature and laser induced fluorescence (LIF) of OH and CH₂O at the base of a turbulent lifted methane flame issuing into a hot vitiated coflow are analysed and contrasted to reference flames to further investigate the stabilization mechanisms involved. The use of the product of the quantified OH and semi-quantified CH₂O images as a marker for heat release rate is validated for transient autoigniting laminar flames. This is combined with temperature gradient information to investigate the flame structure. Super-equilibrium OH, the nature of the profiles of heat release rate with respect to OH mole fraction, and comparatively high peak heat release rates at low temperature gradients is found in the kernel structures at the flame base, and found to be indicative of autoignition stabilization.     

Influences of stoichiometry on steadily propagating triple flames in counterflows

Most studies of triple flames in counterflowing streams of fuel and oxidizer have been focused on the symmetric problem in which the stoichiometric mixture fraction is 1/2. There then exist lean and rich premixed flames of roughly equal strengths, with a diffusion flame trailing behind from the stoichiometric point at which they meet. In the majority of realistic situations, however, the stoichiometric mixture fraction departs appreciably from unity, typically being quite small. With the objective of clarifying the influences of stoichiometry, attention is focused on one of the simplest possible models, addressed here mainly by numerical integration. When the stoichiometric mixture fraction departs appreciably from 1/2, one of the premixed wings is found to be dominant to such an extent that the diffusion flame and the other premixed flame are very weak by comparison. These curved, partially premixed flames are expected to be relevant in realistic configurations. In addition, a simple kinematic balance is shown to predict the shape of the front and the propagation velocity reasonably well in the limit of low stretch and low curvature.     

A numerical study of auto-ignition in turbulent lifted flames issuing into a vitiated co-flow

This paper presents a numerical study of auto-ignition in simple jets of a hydrogen–nitrogen mixture issuing into a vitiated co-flowing stream. The stabilization region of these flames is complex and, depending on the flow conditions, may undergo a transition from auto-ignition to premixed flame propagation. The objective of this paper is to develop numerical indicators for identifying such behavior, first in well-known simple test cases and then in the lifted turbulent flames. The calculations employ a composition probability density function (PDF) approach coupled to the commercial CFD code, FLUENT. The in-situ-adaptive tabulation (ISAT) method is used to implement detailed chemical kinetics. A simple k–ε turbulence model is used for turbulence along with a low Reynolds number model close to the solid walls of the fuel pipe.

The first indicator is based on an analysis of the species transport with respect to the budget of convection, diffusion and chemical reaction terms. This is a powerful tool for investigating aspects of turbulent combustion that would otherwise be prohibitive or impossible to examine experimentally. Reaction balanced by convection with minimal axial diffusion is taken as an indicator of auto-ignition while a diffusive–reactive balance, preceded by a convective–diffusive balanced pre-heat zone, is representative of a premixed flame. The second indicator is the relative location of the onset of creation of certain radical species such as HO₂ ahead of the flame zone. The buildup of HO₂ prior to the creation of H, O and OH is taken as another indicator of autoignition.

The paper first confirms the relevance of these indicators with respect to two simple test cases representing clear auto-ignition and premixed flame propagation. Three turbulent lifted flames are then investigated and the presence of auto-ignition is identified. These numerical tools are essential in providing valuable insights into the stabilization behaviour of these flames, and the demarcation between processes of auto-ignition and premixed flame propagation.