Micelles,Bicelles, and Nanodiscs: Comparing the Impact of Membrane Mimetics on Membrane Protein Backbone Dynamics

Detergents are often used to investigate the structure and dynamics of membrane proteins. Whereas the structural integrity seems to be preserved in detergents for many membrane proteins, their functional activity is frequently compromised, but can be restored in a lipid environment. Herein we show with per‐residue resolution that while OmpX forms a stable β‐barrel in DPC detergent micelles, DHPC/DMPC bicelles, and DMPC nanodiscs, the pico‐ to nanosecond and micro‐ to millisecond motions differ substantially between the detergent and lipid environment. In particular for the β‐strands, there is pronounced dynamic variability in the lipid environment, which appears to be suppressed in micelles. This unexpected complex and membrane‐mimetic‐dependent dynamic behavior indicates that the frequent loss of membrane protein activity in detergents might be related to reduced internal dynamics and that membrane protein activity correlates with lipid flexibility.     

MD simulations of spontaneous membrane protein/detergent micelle formation

The in vitro study of membrane proteins for the purpose of physicochemical analysis or structure determination often relies upon successful reconstitution into detergent micelles. Moreover, a number of biological processes such as membrane protein folding and transport rely on lipid interactions which may resemble the micellar environment. Little is known about the structures of these micelles or the processes which lead to their formation. We therefore present two 50 ns all-atom molecular dynamics simulations of spontaneous dodecylphosphocholine micelle formation around representatives of the two major families of membrane proteins, a small beta-barrel protein, OmpA, and a model alpha-helical protein, glycophorin A. Despite differences in protein architecture, we highlight common mechanistic pathways in micelle formation, which are consistent with experimental studies. We characterize the exponential kinetics of detergent-protein adsorption and suggest a simple model which may explain the aggregation process. We also compare the results with 25 and 50 ns simulations of preformed micelles containing the same proteins. We confirm that the end structures of the self-assembled micelles are similar to those from their preformed counterparts, with each micelle presenting a bilayerlike environment to the enclosed protein.     

Insertion and assembly of membrane proteins via simulation

Interactions of lipids are central to the folding and stability of membrane proteins. Coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations have been used to reveal the mechanisms of self-assembly of protein/membrane and protein/detergent complexes for representatives of two classes of membrane protein, namely, glycophorin (a simple alpha-helical bundle) and OmpA (a beta-barrel). The accuracy of the coarse-grained simulations is established via comparison with the equivalent atomistic simulations of self-assembly of protein/detergent micelles. The simulation of OmpA/bilayer self-assembly reveals how a folded outer membrane protein can be inserted in a bilayer. The glycophorin/bilayer simulation supports the two-state model of membrane folding, in which transmembrane helix insertion precedes dimer self-assembly within a bilayer. The simulations also suggest that a dynamic equilibrium exists between the glycophorin helix monomer and dimer within a bilayer. The simulated glycophorin helix dimer is remarkably close in structure to that revealed by NMR. Thus, coarse-grained methods may help to define mechanisms of membrane protein (re)folding and will prove suitable for simulation of larger scale dynamic rearrangements of biological membranes.     

Formation and dissociation processes of gas-phase detergent micelles

Growing interest in micelles to protect membrane complexes during the transition from solution to gas phase prompts a better understanding of their properties. We have used ion mobility mass spectrometry to separate and assign detergent clusters formed from the n-trimethylammonium bromide series of detergents. We show that cluster size is independent of detergent concentration in solution, increases with charge state, but surprisingly decreases with alkyl chain length. This relationship contradicts the thermodynamics of micelle formation in solution. However, the liquid drop model, which considers both the surface energy and charge, correlates extremely well with the experimental cluster size. To explore further the properties of gas-phase micelles, we have performed collision-induced dissociation on them during tandem mass spectrometry. We observed both sequential asymmetric charge separation and neutral evaporation from the precursor ion cluster. Interestingly, however, we also found markedly different dissociation pathways for the longer alkyl chain detergents, with significantly fewer intermediate ions formed than for those with a shorter alkyl chain. These experiments provide an essential foundation for understanding the process of the gas-phase analysis of membrane protein complexes. Moreover they imply valuable mechanistic details of the protection afforded to protein complexes by detergent clusters during gas-phase activation processes.     

Technological Advancements in Mass Spectrometry and Its Impact on Proteomics

Amalgamation of mass spectrometry (MS) and proteomics has led to the most awaited technological inventions such as discovery of clinically potential biomarkers and generation of effective drugs. This review focuses on the synergistic growth in MS instrumentation, proteomics and its impact on biomedical sciences. Novel ionization methods: surface enhanced laser desorption ionization, electrospray assisted laser desorption ionization, desorption electrospray ionization, laser diode thermal desorption are discussed. Different mass analyzers: ion trap, time-of-flight, Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance and their applications are outlined. New ion fragmentation techniques: electron capture dissociation, electron transfer dissociation, infrared multiphoton dissociation and their attributes are described.     

Monitoring Backbone Hydrogen‐Bond Formation in β‐Barrel Membrane Protein Folding

β‐barrel membrane proteins are key components of the outer membrane of bacteria, mitochondria and chloroplasts. Their three‐dimensional structure is defined by a network of backbone hydrogen bonds between adjacent β‐strands. Here, we employ hydrogen–deuterium (H/D) exchange in combination with NMR spectroscopy and mass spectrometry to monitor backbone hydrogen bond formation during folding of the outer membrane protein X (OmpX) from E. coli in detergent micelles. Residue‐specific kinetics of interstrand hydrogen‐bond formation were found to be uniform in the entire β‐barrel and synchronized to formation of the tertiary structure. OmpX folding thus propagates via a long‐lived conformational ensemble state in which all backbone amide protons exchange with the solvent and engage in hydrogen bonds only transiently. Stable formation of the entire OmpX hydrogen bond network occurs downhill of the rate‐limiting transition state and thus appears cooperative on the overall folding time scale.     

Solubilization of Membrane Proteins into Functional Lipid‐Bilayer Nanodiscs Using a Diisobutylene/Maleic Acid Copolymer

Once removed from their natural environment, membrane proteins depend on membrane‐mimetic systems to retain their native structures and functions. To this end, lipid‐bilayer nanodiscs that are bounded by scaffold proteins or amphiphilic polymers such as styrene/maleic acid (SMA) copolymers have been introduced as alternatives to detergent micelles and liposomes for in vitro membrane‐protein research. Herein, we show that an alternating diisobutylene/maleic acid (DIBMA) copolymer shows equal performance to SMA in solubilizing phospholipids, stabilizes an integral membrane enzyme in functional bilayer nanodiscs, and extracts proteins of various sizes directly from cellular membranes. Unlike aromatic SMA, aliphatic DIBMA has only a mild effect on lipid acyl‐chain order, does not interfere with optical spectroscopy in the far‐UV range, and does not precipitate in the presence of low millimolar concentrations of divalent cations.     

Paramagnetic-based NMR restraints lift residual dipolar coupling degeneracy in multidomain detergent-solubilized membrane proteins

Residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) are widely used as orientation-dependent NMR restraints to improve the resolution of the NMR conformational ensemble of biomacromolecules and define the relative orientation of multidomain proteins and protein complexes. However, the interpretation of RDCs is complicated by the intrinsic degeneracy of analytical solutions and protein dynamics that lead to ill-defined orientations of the structural domains (ghost orientations). Here, we illustrate how restraints from paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) experiments lift the orientational ambiguity of multidomain membrane proteins solubilized in detergent micelles. We tested this approach on monomeric phospholamban (PLN), a 52-residue membrane protein, which is composed of two helical domains connected by a flexible loop. We show that the combination of classical solution NMR restraints (NOEs and dihedral angles) with RDC and PRE constraints resolves topological ambiguities, improving the convergence of the PLN structural ensemble and giving the depth of insertion of the protein within the micelle. The combination of RDCs with PREs will be necessary for improving the accuracy and precision of membrane protein conformational ensembles, where three-dimensional structures are dictated by interactions with the membrane-mimicking environment rather than compact tertiary folds common in globular proteins.     

Simplification of complex peptide mixtures for proteomic analysis: reversible biotinylation of cysteinyl peptides

A rapid means of identifying many components in an enriched mixture of proteins is enzymatic digestion of the entire protein fraction. This complex peptide mixture is then subjected to reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) coupled on-line with a mass spectrometer capable of data-dependent ion selection for fragmentation (LC-tandem mass spectrometry; MS/MS). Thus, as many peptides as possible in the sample are fragmented to produce MS/MS spectra, which can then be searched against sequence databases. Ideally, one peptide from each protein in the mixture would be fragmented and identified. To this end, we employed an affinity selection method to capture cysteinyl peptides and thereby simplify the mixture. Both the captured cysteinyl and the noncysteinyl peptides are analyzed by LC-MS/MS, to increase the number of proteins identified. The method was tested on a limited set of standard proteins and applied to the analysis of a protein fraction obtained from isolated mitochondria treated with atractyloside. To further increase the number of different precursor ions selected for fragmentation, dynamic exclusion and ion selection from multiple narrow mass ranges of consecutive runs were employed.     

Affinity capture using chimeric membrane proteins bound to magnetic beads for rapid ligand screening by matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry

The rapid and specific detection of therapeutically important ligands in complex mixtures, that may bind to membrane proteins, remains challenging for many research laboratories and pharmaceutical industries. Through its use in the development of screening assays, mass spectrometry (MS) is currently experiencing a period of tremendous expansion. In the study presented here, we took advantage of the remarkable stability properties of a bacterial membrane protein, the KcsA K⁺ channel, produced in E. coli and purified as a tetrameric protein in the presence of a detergent. This membrane protein can subserve as a molecular template to display the pore‐forming region of human K⁺ channels, which are considered as targets in the search for inhibitory ligands. The engineered chimeric proteins were linked to metal‐bound magnetic beads, for the screening of complex peptide mixtures, such as that of scorpion venoms. The affinity‐captured scorpion toxins were eluted prior to matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry (MALDI‐TOFMS), and to nano‐electrospray ionization tandem mass QqTOF mass spectrometry (MS/MS) analysis. The de novo sequence of the toxins was deduced by combining the MS/MS fragmentation of the reduced form (up to the 33 first residues) and the trypsin digest peptides of the native toxins. This affinity‐capture screening assay led to the isolation and characterization of potent and specific ligands of the human K⁺ channel, Kv1.3. The affinity‐capture procedure is fast and reproducible. When linked to magnetic beads, the chimeric membrane protein can be re‐used several times without losing any of its selectivity or specificity. This assay also benefits from the fact that it requires minimal amounts of animal venoms or complex mixtures, which can be expensive or difficult to procure. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

High-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry with a new quadrupole/linear ion trap instrument

The use of a new hybrid quadrupole/linear ion trap known as the Q TRAP offers unique benefits as a LC-MS-MS detector for both small and large molecule analyses. The instrument combines the capabilities of a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer and ion trap technology on a single platform. Product ion scans are conducted in a hybrid fashion with the fragmentation step accomplished via acceleration into the collision cell followed by trapping and mass analysis in the Q3 linear ion trap. This results in triple quadrupole fragmentation patterns with no inherent low molecular mass cutoff. In-trap fragmentation is also possible in order to provide triple MS (MS3) capabilities. There are also several scan modes that are not possible on conventional instruments that enable identification of analytes within complex biological matrixes for subsequent high sensitivity product ion scans. This report will describe the new hybrid instrument and the principles of operation, and also provide examples of the unique scan modes and capabilities of the Q TRAP for LC-MS-MS detection in metabolism identification.     

Charged gels as orienting media for measurement of residual dipolar couplings in soluble and integral membrane proteins

Measurement of residual dipolar couplings for membrane proteins will dramatically improve the quality of the structures obtainable by solution NMR spectroscopy. While there has been some success in achieving alignment of membrane-bound peptides, there has been very limited success in achieving alignment for functional membrane proteins. Herein, we demonstrate that charged polyacrylamide-based copolymers are suitable for obtaining weak alignment of membrane proteins reconstituted in detergent micelles. Varying the copolymer compositions, we prepared positively, zwitterionic, and negatively charged gels that are very stable at low concentration and can be used for obtaining weak alignment by compression in an NMR tube. Application of this method is demonstrated for the integral membrane protein OmpA in DPC micelles.     

Affinity and chemical enrichment strategies for mapping low‐abundance protein modifications and protein‐interaction networks

Protein post‐translational modifications and protein interactions are the central research areas in mass‐spectrometry‐based proteomics. Protein post‐translational modifications affect protein structures, stabilities, activities, and all cellular processes are achieved by interactions among proteins and protein complexes. With the continuing advancements of mass spectrometry instrumentations of better sensitivity, speed, and performance, selective enrichment of modifications/interactions of interest from complex cellular matrices during the sample preparation has become the overwhelming bottleneck in the proteomics workflow. Therefore, many strategies have been developed to address this issue by targeting specific modifications/interactions based on their physical properties or chemical reactivities, but only a few have been successfully applied for systematic proteome‐wide study. In this review, we summarized the highlights of recent developments in the affinity enrichment methods focusing mainly on low stoichiometric protein lipidations. Besides, to identify potential glyoxal modified arginines, a small part was added for profiling reactive arginine sites using an enrichment reagent. A detailed section was provided for the enrichment of protein interactions by affinity purification and chemical cross‐linking, to shed light on the potentials of different enrichment strategies, along with the unique challenges in investigating individual protein post‐translational modification or protein interaction network.     

Two-dimensional Blue Native/sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis for analysis of multimeric proteins in platelets

Two-dimensional (2-D) Blue Native/SDS gel electrophoresis combines a first-dimensional separation of monomeric and multimeric proteins in their native state with a second denaturing dimension. These high-resolution 2-D gels aim at identifying multiprotein complexes with respect to their subunit composition. We applied this method for the first time to analyze two human platelet subproteomes: the cytosolic and the microsomal membrane protein fraction. Solubilization of platelet membrane proteins was achieved with the nondenaturing detergent n-dodecyl-beta-D-maltoside. To validate native solubilization conditions, we demonstrated the correct assembly of the Na,K-ATPase, a functional multimeric transmembrane protein, when expressed in Xenopus oocytes. We identified 63 platelet proteins after in-gel tryptic digestion of 58 selected protein spots and liquid chromatography-coupled tandem mass spectrometry. Nine proteins were detected for the first time in platelets by a proteomic approach. We also show that this technology efficiently resolves several known membrane and cytosolic multiprotein complexes. Blue Native/SDS gel electrophoresis is thus a valuable procedure to analyze specific platelet subproteomes, like the membrane(-bound) protein fraction, by mass spectrometry and immunoblotting and could be relevant for the study of protein-protein interactions generated following platelet activation.     

Fourier-transform mass spectrometry for automated fragmentation and identification of 5-20 kDa proteins in mixtures

When presented with a mixture of intact proteins, electrospray ionization with Fourier-transform mass spectrometry (ESI-FTMS) has the capability to obtain direct fragmentation information from isolated ions. However, the automation of this capability has not been achieved to date. We have developed software for unattended acquisition of protein tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) data and batch processing of the resulting files for identification of whole proteins. Mixtures of both protein standards (8-29 kDa) and Methanococcus jannaschii cytosolic proteins (up to six components + 20 kDa) were infused via an autosampler, and MS/MS data were acquired without human intervention. The acquisition software recognizes ESI charge state patterns, generates protein-specific isolation waveforms on-the-fly, and fragments ions using two different infrared laser times. In addition to protein standards, five wild-type proteins (7-14 kDa) were identified automatically with 100% sequence coverage from the M. jannaschii database. The software underpins a measurement platform for sample-dependent acquisition of MS/MS data for whole proteins, a critical step to realize proteomics with 100% sequence coverage in a higher throughput setting.     

Mobility-Modulated Sequential Dissociation Analysis Enables Structural Lipidomics in Mass Spectrometry Imaging

Spatial lipidomics based on mass spectrometry imaging (MSI) is a powerful tool for fundamental biology studies and biomarker discovery. But the structure-resolving capability of MSI is limited because of the lack of multiplexed tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) method, primarily due to the small sample amount available from each pixel and the poor ion usage in MS/MS analysis. Here, we report a mobility-modulated sequential dissociation (MMSD) strategy for multiplex MS/MS imaging of distinct lipids from biological tissues. With ion mobility-enabled data-independent acquisition and automated spectrum deconvolution, MS/MS spectra of a large number of lipid species from each tissue pixel are acquired, at no expense of imaging speed. MMSD imaging is highlighted by MS/MS imaging of 24 structurally distinct lipids in the mouse brain and the revealing of the correlation of a structurally distinct phosphatidylethanolamine isomer (PE 18 : 1_18 : 1) from a human hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) tissue. Mapping of structurally distinct lipid isomers is now enabled and spatial lipidomics becomes feasible for MSI.     

FPOP-LC-MS/MS Suggests Differences in Interaction Sites of Amphipols and Detergents with Outer Membrane Proteins

Amphipols are a class of novel surfactants that are capable of stabilizing the native state of membrane proteins. They have been shown to be highly effective, in some cases more so than detergent micelles, at maintaining the structural integrity of membrane proteins in solution, and have shown promise as vehicles for delivering native membrane proteins into the gas phase for structural interrogation. Here, we use fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP), which irreversibly labels the side chains of solvent-accessible residues with hydroxyl radicals generated by laser photolysis of hydrogen peroxide, to compare the solvent accessibility of the outer membrane protein OmpT when solubilized with the amphipol A8-35 or with n-dodecyl-β-maltoside (DDM) detergent micelles. Using quantitative mass spectrometry analyses, we show that fast photochemical oxidation reveals differences in the extent of solvent accessibility of residues between the A8-35 and DDM solubilized states, providing a rationale for the increased stability of membrane proteins solubilized with amphipol compared with detergent micelles, as a result of additional intermolecular contacts.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?

     

Membrane Proteins Have Distinct Fast Internal Motion and Residual Conformational Entropy

The internal motions of integral membrane proteins have largely eluded comprehensive experimental characterization. Here the fast side‐chain dynamics of the α‐helical sensory rhodopsin II and the β‐barrel outer membrane protein W have been investigated in lipid bilayers and detergent micelles by solution NMR relaxation techniques. Despite their differing topologies, both proteins have a similar distribution of methyl‐bearing side‐chain motion that is largely independent of membrane mimetic. The methyl‐bearing side chains of both proteins are, on average, more dynamic in the ps–ns timescale than any soluble protein characterized to date. Accordingly, both proteins retain an extraordinary residual conformational entropy in the folded state, which provides a counterbalance to the absence of the hydrophobic effect. Furthermore, the high conformational entropy could greatly influence the thermodynamics underlying membrane‐protein functions, including ligand binding, allostery, and signaling.     

Top-down analysis of 30–80 kDa proteins by electron transfer dissociation time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Electron transfer dissociation (ETD)-based top-down mass spectrometry (MS) is the method of choice for in-depth structure characterization of large peptides, small- and medium-sized proteins, and non-covalent protein complexes. Here, we describe the performance of this approach for structural analysis of intact proteins as large as the 80 kDa serotransferrin. Current time-of-flight (TOF) MS technologies ensure adequate resolution and mass accuracy to simultaneously analyze intact 30–80 kDa protein ions and the complex mixture of their ETD product ions. Here, we show that ETD TOF MS is efficient and may provide extensive sequence information for unfolded and highly charged (around 1 charge/kDa) proteins of ～30 kDa and structural motifs embedded in larger proteins. Sequence regions protected by disulfide bonds within intact non-reduced proteins oftentimes remain uncharacterized due to the low efficiency of their fragmentation by ETD. For serotransferrin, reduction of S–S bonds leads to significantly varied ETD fragmentation pattern with higher sequence coverage of N- and C-terminal regions, providing a complementary structural information to top-down analysis of its oxidized form.