Between Counting and Multiplication: Low-Attaining Students’ Spatial Structuring,Enumeration and Errors in Concretely-Presented 3D Array Tasks

The move from additive to multiplicative thinking requires significant change in children’s comprehension and manipulation of numerical relationships, involves various conceptual components, and can be a slow, multistage process for some. Unit arrays are a key visuospatial representation for supporting learning, but most research focuses on 2D (rectangular) arrays, and when focusing on 3D (cuboid) arrays still frequently uses 2D representations. This article documents low-attaining children’s partially developed multiplicative thinking as they work on concretely presented 3D array tasks; it also presents a framework for microanalysis of learners’ early multiplicative thinking in array tasks. Data derives from a small but cognitively diverse set of participants, all arithmetically low-attaining and relying heavily on counting: this enabled detailed analysis of small but significant differences in their arithmetical engagement with arrays. The analytical framework combines and builds on previous structural and enumerative categorizations, and may be used with a variety of array representations.     

A Case Study of Three Childrens' Original Interpretations of the Moon's Changing Appearance

A case study of three children was conducted to shed light on the process that children undergo in developing their understanding of physical phenomena. Using the notion of spontaneous construction and its relationship with school learning of scientific concepts, children's early thoughts of the moon's appearance were explored. Research questions were primarily concerned with how children view the moon's appearance, explain how and/or why its appearance changes, quantify the moon's size and its distance to Earth, and explain the moon's illumination. A Piagetian interview was conducted with each child and then each was asked to tell a story about the moon. The external interest of this research study involves when and why do children develop the commonly held Earth's shadow alternative conception as the cause of the moon's phases. The findings show that children have stories and experiences that give meaning to the existence of such things as the moon, stars, sun, and clouds. Similarities were found in the children's interpretations with regard to their natural tendencies to animate celestial objects. Clues were discovered of cultural influence such as family, personal observations and experiences, books, pictures, car travel, and even a strategically placed Palladian window.     

Young children's recognition of quantitative relations in mathematically unspecified settings

Children have been found to be able to reason about quantitative relations, such as non-symbolic proportions, already by the age of 5 years. However, these studies utilize settings in which children were explicitly guided to notice the mathematical nature of the tasks. This study investigates children's spontaneous recognition of quantitative relations on mathematically unspecified settings. Participants were 86 Finnish-speaking children, ages 5–8. Two video-recorded tasks, in which participants were not guided to notice the mathematical aspects, were used. The tasks could be completed in a number of ways, including by matching quantitative relations, numerosity, or other aspects. Participants’ matching strategies were analyzed with regard to the most mathematically advanced level utilized. There were substantial differences in participants’ use of quantitative relations, numerosity and other aspects in their matching strategies. The results of this novel experimental setting show that investigating children's spontaneous recognition of quantitative relations provides novel insight into children's mathematical thinking and furthers the understanding of how children recognize and utilize mathematical aspects when not explicitly guided to do so.     

Teaching children to add and subtract

At a 1980 conference, leading mathematics educators synthesized previous knowledge on children's early understanding of addition and subtraction and proposed central parameters for future research in these areas form a cognitive science perspective. We have, since 1980, increased our knowledge about how children learn to add and subtract, but we need to know more about the best ways for teachers to guide children as they construct knowledge of addition and subtraction.In this article, we review several studies that focus on an enhanced role for teachers in enabling children to learn addition and subtraction. These studies describe efforts that have been made to teach children to use diagrams and mediational representations, number sentences, or algorithms and procedures. The studies report improvement in children's problem-solving performance, but the impact of the efforts described on children's conceptual understanding is less clear. Thus, we analyze this research, pose questions on the relationship of instruction to children's knowledge construction, and propose a research agenda that we believe will enable us to understand how teaching can best help children learn to add and subtract.     

Evaluation of three interventions teaching area measurement as spatial structuring to young children

We evaluated the effects of three instructional interventions designed to support young children’s understanding of area measurement as a structuring process. Replicating microgenetic procedures we used in previous research with older children to ascertain whether we can build these competencies earlier, we also extended the previous focus on correctness to include analyses of children’s use of procedural and conceptual knowledge and examined individual differences in strategy shifts before and after transitions, enabling a more detailed examination of the hypothesized necessity of development through each level of a learning trajectory. The two experimental interventions focused on a dynamic conception of area measurement while also emphasizing unit concepts, such as unit identification, iteration, and composition. The findings confirm and extend earlier results that seeing a complete record of the structure of the 2D array—in the form of a drawing of organized rows and columns—supported children’s spatial structuring and performance.     

Concept Development of Decimals in Chinese Elementary Students: A Conceptual Change Approach

The aim of this study was to examine the concept development of decimal numbers in 244 Chinese elementary students in grades 4–6. Three grades of students differed in their intuitive sense of decimals and conceptual understanding of decimals, with more strategic approaches used by older students. Misconceptions regarding the density nature of decimals indicated the progress in an ascending spiral trend (i.e., fourth graders performed the worst; fifth graders performed the best; and sixth graders regressed slightly), not in a linear trend. Misconceptions regarding decimal computation (i.e., multiplication makes bigger) generally decreased across grades. However, children's misconceptions regarding the density and infinity features of decimals appeared to be more persistent than misconceptions regarding decimal computation. Some students in higher grades continued to use the discreteness feature of whole numbers to explain the distance between two decimal numbers, indicating an intermediate level of understanding decimals. The findings revealed the effect of symbolic representation of interval end points and students' responses were contingent on the actual representations of interval end points. Students in all three grades demonstrated narrowed application of decimal values (e.g., merchandise), and their application of decimals was largely limited by their learning experiences.     

The missing link in teachers’ knowledge about common fractions division

The current study explored the difficulties teachers encounter when teaching common fractions division, focusing on teachers’ knowledge concerning this issue. Nine teachers who study towards a M.Ed. degree in mathematics education demonstrated the algorithms they apply in order to solve fractions division problems, described how they teach the subject, and attempted to explain a student's mistake, in understanding a word problem involving dividing by fraction. The findings indicate there is a missing link in the teachers’ pedagogical capability, stemming from insufficient content knowledge. They presented different solution algorithms and reported using constructivist teaching methods, yet the methods they described couldn't lead a student to understand the logic behind the algorithm they teach (invert-and-multiply – multiplication by an inverse number, in accordance with the requirements of the curriculum). Furthermore, the participating teachers did not possess specialized mathematics content knowledge (SCK) and knowledge of content and students (KCS), enabling them to identify the source of a student's misconception.     

Mathematical tasks,study approaches,and course grades in undergraduate mathematics: a year-by-year analysis

Students approach learning in different ways, depending on the experienced learning situation. A deep approach is geared toward long-term retention and conceptual change while a surface approach focuses on quickly acquiring knowledge for immediate use. These approaches ultimately affect the students’ academic outcomes. This study takes a cross-sectional look at the approaches to learning used by students from courses across all four years of undergraduate mathematics and analyses how these relate to the students’ grades. We find that deep learning correlates with grade in the first year and not in the upper years. Surficial learning has no correlation with grades in the first year and a strong negative correlation with grades in the upper years. Using Bloom's taxonomy, we argue that the nature of the tasks given to students is fundamentally different in lower and upper year courses. We find that first-year courses emphasize tasks that require only low-level cognitive processes. Upper year courses require higher level processes but, surprisingly, have a simultaneous greater emphasis on recall and understanding. These observations explain the differences in correlations between approaches to learning and course grades. We conclude with some concerns about the disconnect between first year and upper year mathematics courses and the effect this may have on students.     

A preliminary genetic decomposition for conceptual understanding of the indefinite integral

This paper reports on the use of APOS theory to investigate conceptual understanding of the indefinite integral amongst undergraduate students at the University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. We present a Preliminary Genetic Decomposition (PGD) for the indefinite integral, which predicts the mental constructions and mechanisms that may facilitate conceptual understanding. In this pilot study, the analysis of students’ written responses to the research instrument suggested that more than half of the participants lacked the prerequisite knowledge of the concepts of function, derivative of functions and the chain rule. The findings confirmed that students experience greater difficulty dealing with transcendental functions than with algebraic functions. The analysis indicated that the cognitive mechanism of reversal, to recognise the inverse nature of differentiation and integration, was inconsistent or absent in many students. Interview data from a subset of participants was employed for triangulation with the document analysis. The empirical data suggested refinement of the PGD and modification of the research instrument, and further fine-grained interviews with study participants to investigate their conceptual understanding more deeply, and for the purposes of data triangulation.     

Components of Place Value Understanding: Targeting Mathematical Difficulties When Providing Interventions

Place value understanding requires the same activity that students use when developing fractional and algebraic reasoning, making this understanding foundational to mathematics learning. However, many students engage successfully in mathematics classrooms without having a conceptual understanding of place value, preventing them from accessing mathematics that is more sophisticated later. The purpose of this exploratory study is to investigate how upper elementary students' unit coordination related to difficulties they experience when engaging in place value tasks. Understanding place value requires that students coordinate units recursively to construct multi‐digit numbers from their single‐digit number understandings through forms of unit development and strategic counting. Findings suggest that students identified as low‐achieving were capable of only one or two levels of unit coordination. Furthermore, these students relied on inaccurate procedures to solve problems with millennial numbers. These findings indicate that upper elementary students identified as low‐achieving are not to yet able to (de)compose numbers effectively, regroup tens and hundreds when operating on numbers, and transition between millennial numbers. Implications of this study suggest that curricula designers and statewide standards should adopt nuances in unit coordination when developing tasks that promote or assess students' place value understanding.     

Additive relations and function tables

We present work with a second grade classroom where we carried out a teaching experiment that attempted to bring out the algebraic character of arithmetic. In this paper, we specifically illustrate our work with the second graders on additive relations, through the children’s work with function tables. We explore the different ways in which the children represented the information of a problem in the form of a self-designed function table. We argue that the choices children make about the kind of information to represent or not, as well as the way in which they constructed their tables, highlight some of the issues that children may find relevant in their construction of function tables. This open-ended format pointed to how they were understanding and appropriating tables into their thinking about additive relations.     

Understanding of Earth and Space Science Concepts: Strategies for Concept‐Building in Elementary Teacher Preparation

This research is concerned with preservice teacher understanding of six earth and space science concepts that are often taught in elementary school: the reason for seasons, phases of the moon, why the wind blows, the rock cycle, soil formation, and earthquakes. Specifically, this study examines the effect of readings, hands‐on learning stations, and concept mapping in improving conceptual understanding. Undergraduates in two sections of a science methods course (N= 52) completed an open‐ended survey, giving explanations about the above concepts three times: as a pretest and twice as posttests after various instructional interventions. The answers, scored with a three point rubric, indicated that the preservice teachers initially had many misconceptions (alternative conceptions). A two way ANOVA with repeated measures analysis (pretest/posttest) demonstrated that readings and learning stations are both successful in building preservice teacher's understanding and that benefits from the hands‐on learning stations approached statistical significance. Concept mapping had an additive effect in building understanding, as evident on the second posttest. The findings suggest useful strategies for university science instructors to use in clarifying science concepts while modeling activities teachers can use in their own classrooms.     

Understanding and representing the arithmetic averaging algorithm: an analysis and comparison of US and Chinese students' responses

Analysing the responses of 311 sixth-grade Chinese students and 232 sixth-grade US students to two problems involving arithmetic average, this study explored students' understanding and representation of the averaging algorithm from a cross-national perspective. Results of the study show that Chinese students were more successful than US students in obtaining correct numerical answers to each of the problems, but US and Chinese students had similar cognitive difficulties in solving the second task. The difficulties were not due to their lack of procedural knowledge of the averaging algorithm, rather due to their lack of conceptual understanding of the algorithm. There were significant differences between the US and Chinese students in their solution representations of the two average problems. Chinese students were more likely to use algebraic representations than US students; while US students were more likely to use pictorial or verbal representations. US and Chinese students' use of representations are related to their mathematical problem-solving performance. Students who used more advanced representations were better problem solvers. The findings of the study suggest that Chinese students' superior performance on the averaging problems is partly due to their use of advanced representations (e.g. algebraic).     

Teachers' Considerations of Students' Thinking During Mathematics Lesson Design

Teachers' abilities to design mathematics lessons are related to their capability to mobilize resources to meeting intended learning goals based on their noticing. In this process, knowing how teachers consider Students' thinking is important for understanding how they are making decisions to promote student learning. While teaching, what teachers notice influences their decision‐making process. This article explores the mathematics lesson planning practices of four 4th‐grade teachers at the same school to understand how their consideration of Students' learning influences planning decisions. Case study methodology was used to gain an in‐depth perspective of the mathematics planning practices of the teachers. Results indicate the teachers took varying approaches in how they considered students. One teacher adapted instruction based on Students' conceptual understanding, two teachers aimed at producing skill‐efficient students, and the final teacher regulated learning with a strict adherence to daily lessons in curriculum materials, with little emphasis on student understanding. These findings highlight the importance of providing professional development support to teachers focused on their noticing and considerations of Students' mathematical understandings as related to learning outcomes. These findings are distinguished from other studies because of the focus on how teachers consider Students' thinking during lesson planning. This article features a Research to Practice Companion Article . Please click on the supporting information link below to access.     

Students' Retention of Mathematical Knowledge and Skills in Differential Equations

This study investigates students' retention of mathematical knowledge and skills in two differential equations classes. Posttests and delayed posttests after 1 year were administered to students in inquiry‐oriented and traditional classes. The results show that students in the inquiry‐oriented class retained conceptual knowledge, as seen by their performance on modeling problems, and retained equal proficiency in procedural problems, when compared with students in the traditionally taught classes. The results of this study add additional support to the claim that teaching for conceptual understanding can lead to longer retention of mathematical knowledge.     

Fractions as Subtraction: An Activity‐Oriented Perspective from Elementary Children

A sample of third‐, fourth‐, and fifth‐grade student responses to the question “What is a fraction?” were examined to gain an understanding of how children in upper elementary grades make sense of fractions. Rather than measure children's understanding of fractions relative to mathematically conventional part–whole constructions of fractions, we attempted to understand children's actions and processes. A small but nontrivial group of children used subtraction (takeaway and removal) as a framework for understanding how fractions were created and written. An analysis of the content of their responses as well as a comparison of the performance of these children with that of children who used other ways of describing fractions suggests that the use of subtraction may be a reasonable (or at least not harmful) way for children to begin to access concepts related to fractions. Also, this study suggests that attention to children's understanding through the lens of children's activity might reveal ways of thinking and insights that are masked when we compare children's thinking in more structured research settings.     

Changing Children's Conceptions of Burning

Relatively few studies have examined the effects of instruction on children's understanding of burning. This study focused on three questions: (a) What are children's views of burning prior to and after instruction? (b) Do children's views become more scientific, that is, more in accord with scientists' views, with instruction, and if so, how? (c) Are the changes in children's understanding of burning correlated to their ages? Data were collected before and after five hours of instruction in a Saturday Science Program, using both a short multiple choice test based on common misconceptions from the literature and "interviews about events." Children were divided into two classes according to their grade in school. A significant difference was found in children's understanding before and after instruction on the multiple‐choice test that was corroborated with interview data. Younger children (ages 8 to 11) made more significant gains than did the older children (ages 11 to 13), with both groups reaching similar levels of understanding after instruction. Although notable gains were made in recognizing the need for oxygen in burning and in distinguishing between decomposition and burning, interviews revealed that few children at any age could explain specifically what was happening on the phenomena level.     

Spatial fuzzy consumer's decision making: A multicriteria analysis

This paper is devoted to a multicriteria analysis of the consumer's behavior when the decision maker is acting in a fuzzy space and manifesting an imprecise attitude. At first, the process of decision making is described with the help of three relationships between the set of goods which are supplied in several locations, the set of their characteristics and the set of the consumer's a priori possible behaviors. All these relations are fuzzy. The model applies the theory of fuzzy relations equations. Then, the stages of the decision process are analyzed. Often fuzzy behavior relations are like ‘black boxes’. The mathematical solution of the model indicates in which conditions their valuations are possible. The main interest of this method is not to use additive operations on subjective items and to use operators which are coherent with the fuzzy nature of the variables.     

Modelling in Science Lessons: Are There Better Ways to Learn With Models?

Modelling is the essence of scientific thinking, and models are both the methods and products of science. However, secondary students usually view science models as toys or miniatures of real-life objects, and few students actually understand why scientists use multiple models to explain concepts. A conceptual typology of models is presented and explained to help teachers select models appropriate to the cognitive ability of their students. An example explains how the systematic presentation of analogical models enhanced an 11th-grade chemistry student's understanding of atoms and molecules. The article recommends that teachers encourage their students to use and explore multiple models in science lessons at all levels.