Lipophilic Multi‐walled Carbon Nanotube‐based Solid Contact Potassium Ion‐selective Electrodes with Reproducible Standard Potentials. A Comparative Study

The two most promising approaches for preparing solid contacts (SCs) for polymeric membrane based ion‐selective electrodes (ISEs) are based on the use of large surface areas conducting materials with high capacitance (e. g., various carbon nanotubes) and redox active materials (e. g. conducting polymers). While many of the essential requirements for the potential stability of SCISEs were addressed, the E⁰ reproducibility and its predictability, that would enable single use of such electrodes without calibration is still a challenge, i. e., the fabrication of electrodes with sufficiently close E⁰ and slope values to enable the characterization of large fabrication batches through the calibration of only a small number of electrodes. The most generic solution seems to be the adjustment of the E⁰ potential by polarization prior to the application of the ion‐selective membrane. This approach proved to be successful in case of conducting polymer‐based solid contacts, but has to be still explored for capacitive solid contact based ISEs, which is the purpose of this paper. We have chosen a well‐established highly lipophilic multi‐walled carbon nanotube (MWCNT), i. e. octadecane modified MWCNT (OD‐MWCNT), that is investigated in the comparative context of a similarly lipophilic conducting polymer solid contact (a perfluorinated alkanoate side chain functionalized poly(3,4‐ethylenedioxythiophene)). While, the OD‐MWCNT based SCISEs had inherently small standard deviation of their E⁰ values (less than 5 mV) this could be further improved by external polarization and short circuiting the SCISEs.     

Conducting Polymer‐Based Solid‐State Ion‐Selective Electrodes

Conducting polymers, i.e., electroactive conjugated polymers, are useful both as ion‐to‐electron transducers and as sensing membranes in solid‐state ion‐selective electrodes. Recent achievements over the last few years have resulted in significant improvements of the analytical performance of solid‐contact ion‐selective electrodes (solid‐contact ISEs) based on conducting polymers as ion‐to‐electron transducer combined with polymeric ion‐selective membranes. A significant amount of research has also been devoted to solid‐state ISEs based on conducting polymers as the sensing membrane. This review gives a brief summary of the progress in the area in recent years.     

Tailoring Solution Cast Poly(3,4‐dioctyloxythiophene) Transducers for Potentiometric All‐Solid‐State Ion‐Selective Electrodes

A novel concept of tailoring potentiometric responses of all‐solid‐state ion‐selective electrodes was introduced. The effect of composition and resulting properties of the conjugated polymer transducer, placed between the electrode support and ion‐selective membrane, on analytical characteristic of obtained sensors was studied.     

The Influence of the Conditioning Procedure on Potentiometric Characteristics of Solid Contact Calcium‐Selective Electrodes in Nanomolar Concentration Solutions

A solid contact calcium‐selective electrode with a poly(pyrrole) intermediate layer doped with the calcium ion‐complexing ligand Tiron was successfully constructed and examined towards the possibility of lowering the detection limit. Two calcium ionophores, ETH 1001 and ETH 129, were compared. A variety of different shapes of potentiometric responses can be obtained in a controlled manner by applying an appropriate conditioning procedure. The lifetime of the investigated electrodes was longer than 1 year. The modified poly(pyrrole) solid contact electrode was compared with the coated wire type. An inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry with laser ablation analysis (LA ICP MS) was used to confirm the transmembrane ion fluxes.     

Advantages of Amperometric Readout Mode of Ion‐selective Electrodes under Potentiostatic Conditions

Amperometric responses of all‐solid‐state ion‐selective electrodes, recorded under potentiostatic conditions, were studied on example of potassium‐selective sensors with polypyrrole solid contact, at potential corresponding to reduction of the solid contact material and accompanying transfer of potassium ions across the membrane. Selective and stable in time linear dependences of current vs. logarithm of analyte concentration were recorded, resulting from high membrane resistance and changing membrane potential. The influence of experimental parameters as applied potential or thickness of the membrane was discussed. Advantages of the amperometric mode compared to potentiometric one relate to possibility of tailoring analytical parameters (sensitivity, magnitude of the signal) as well as over one order of magnitude decrease of the detection limit. The latter effect is achieved due to externally forced incorporation of potassium ions from the solution to the membrane, compensating their spontaneous release to the sample solution. A method of experimental setup simplification was proposed, with application of two‐electrode system, which can be used in the absence of external polarization source. The required driving force for the current flow was assured by spontaneous oxidation process occurring at the second electrode, coupled with reduction of the solid contact material of the ion‐selective electrode. In this case also stable in time calibration plots can be recorded.     

Comparison of Multi‐walled Carbon Nanotubes and Poly(3‐octylthiophene) as Ion‐to‐Electron Transducers in All‐Solid‐State Potassium Ion‐Selective Electrodes

Multi‐walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) were compared with poly(3‐octylthiophene) (POT) as ion‐to‐electron transducer in all‐solid‐state potassium ion‐selective electrodes with valinomycin‐based ion‐selective membranes. MWCNTs and POT were mixed with the other components of the potassium ion‐selective membrane cocktail (valinomycin, KTpClPB, o‐NPOE, PVC, THF) which was then applied on a glassy carbon (GC) substrate to prepare single‐piece ion‐selective electrodes (SPISEs). Results from potentiometric and impedance measurements showed that the MWCNT‐based electrodes have a more reproducuible standard potential and a lower overall impedance than the electrodes based on POT. Both types of electrodes showed similar sensitivity to potassium ions and no redox sensitivity.     

Single‐Piece Solid‐Contact Pb2+‐Selective Electrodes Based on Thiophene Oligomer

A single‐piece solid‐contact Pb²⁺‐selective electrode was prepared by adding a thiophene oligomer into the ion‐selective cocktail directly. The one‐step fabrication yielded an electrode with Nernstian response spanning a wide concentration range of 10^?3–10^?8 mol L^?1, and detection limit as low as 5.6×10^?9 mol L^?1. The electrode had a quick response time of approximately 10–15 s and showed excellent selectivity over the most common univalent and divalent cations. The practical application of the proposed electrode has been tested by determining Pb²⁺ in real water samples.     

Intercalation Compounds as Inner Reference Electrodes for Reproducible and Robust Solid‐Contact Ion‐Selective Electrodes

With billions of assays performed every year, ion‐selective electrodes (ISEs) provide a simple and fast technique for clinical analysis of blood electrolytes. The development of cheap, miniaturized solid‐contact (SC‐)ISEs for integrated systems, however, remains a difficult balancing act between size, robustness, and reproducibility, because the defined interface potentials between the ion‐selective membrane and the inner reference electrode (iRE) are often compromised. We demonstrate that target cation‐sensitive intercalation compounds, such as partially charged lithium iron phosphate (LFP), can be applied as iREs of the quasi‐first kind for ISEs. The symmetrical response of the interface potentials towards target cations ultimately results in ISEs with high robustness towards the inner filling (ca. 5 mV dec^?1 conc.) as well as robust and miniaturized SC‐ISEs. They have a predictable and stable potential derived from the LiFePO₄/FePO₄ redox couple (97.0±1.5 mV after 42 days).     

Optimizing Carbon Nanotubes Dispersing Agents from the Point of View of Ion‐selective Membrane Based Sensors Performance – Introducing Carboxymethylcellulose as Dispersing Agent for Carbon Nanotubes Based Solid Contacts

The influence of dispersing agent used to prepare carbon nanotubes solid‐contact on the performance of all‐solid state ion‐selective electrodes has been evaluated. It is shown that excess of surfactant dispersing agent is leading to deterioration of sensor performance, however, removal of dispersing agent – a typically applied approach – is resulting in substantial change of transducer layer physical properties, which can influence sensor performance. As remedy we propose application of a polymeric dispersing agent – carboxymethylcellulose. Thus obtained ion‐selective electrodes are characterized by high potential readings stability both within day and between days.     

Investigation of Protein Binding With All Solid‐State Ion‐Selective Electrodes

A potentiometric sensor for studying charge based adsorption of proteins was created using a single‐piece polyaniline‐PVC ion‐selective electrode (ISE). Three different ISEs, two for Na⁺ and one for Cl^? ion determination, were studied. The Na⁺‐ISEs consisted of a neutral calixarene‐based ionophore and one with a charged carrier dinonylnapthalenesulfonic acid (DNNSA) whereas for the Cl^? ISE, an anion exchanger tridodecylmethylammonium chloride (TDDMA⁺Cl^?), was used. The Na⁺ ISE with DNNSA as the charged carrier was successfully able to discriminate the binding of two different proteins (bovine serum albumin and lysozyme) based on their intrinsic charge.     

Crown Ethers Bearing 18C6 Unit; Sensory Molecules for Fabricating PVC Membrane Lead Ion‐selective Electrodes

Crown ethers bearing 18C6 unit 18‐crown‐6 (18C6), dicyclohexyl18‐crown‐6 (DC18C6) and dibenzo18‐crown‐6 (DB18C6) have been examined as ion sensing materials for fabricating lead ion‐selective potentiometric sensors. Best performance of the electrode based upon 18C6 ionophore was achieved by using a membrane including 9% ionophore, 30% polyvinyl chloride (PVC), 2% oleic acid and 59% dibutylphthalate (DBP). The optimum composition for the sensors based on DC18C6 and DB18C6 was provided by the compositions: 9% DC18C6, 30% PVC, 1.5% sodium tetraphenyl borate (NaTBP), 59.5% DBP; and 5.9% DB18C6, 29.7% PVC, 2.5% NaTBP and 61.9% DBP, respectively. The linear response range of the electrode based on 18C6 (1 × 10^‐6‐1 × 10^‐3 M) differs from that presented by the DC18C6‐ and DB18C6‐based electrodes (1 × 10^‐5‐1 × 10^‐2 M). All the sensors were shown rapid response time (<12 s). The detection limit of the electrodes varies as 5.6 × 10^‐7, 6.3 × 10^‐6 and 7.1 × 10^‐6 M, for 18C6‐, DC18C6‐ and DB18C6‐based electrodes, respectively. The selectivity of the electrodes towards lead ions over some mono‐, di‐ and trivalent metal ions was evaluated. The lifetime of the electrode based on DC18C6 or DB18C6 ionophores was found to be more than three months, while it was shorter for 18C6‐based electrode. The application of the electrodes in aqueous samples was assessed.     

Voltammetric Properties of All‐solid State Ion‐selective Electrodes with Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes‐poly(3‐octylthiophene‐2,5‐diyl) Nanocomposite Transducer

Voltammetric response of an all‐solid‐state ion‐selective electrode was studied on example of potassium‐selective sensor with poly(vinyl chloride) based membrane and nanocomposite transducer containing poly(3‐octylthiophene‐2,5‐diyl) and multiwalled carbon nanotubes. Factors limiting the rate of the electrochemical process and the response were discussed. The challenge in voltammetric applications of ion‐selective electrodes is thickness of the plastic membrane. It was found that although a relatively thick ion‐selective membrane was applied, as typically used in potentiometric studies, the position of the reduction peak, corresponding to potassium ions incorporation, was dependent on ions concentration in a Nernstian manner. This opens possibility of deviation from the paradigm of ultrathin membranes in voltammetric applications, thus potentially extending the sensors lifetime. The high resistance of the membrane did not affect the voltammetric characteristics, because the resistance was independent of ions concentration in solution. On the other hand, high resistance results in charge trapping effect in the solid contact material, leading to advantageous retention of the oxidized‐conducting state of the solid contact, independently of the applied electrode potential.     

Stability and Lifetime of Potassium Solid‐Contact Ion Selective Electrodes for Continuous and Autonomous Measurements

The current generation of solid‐contact ion‐selective electrodes (SC‐ISE) suffer from lack of stability and lifetime. When using such sensors for remote, continuous, or autonomous measurements, these analytical characteristics are especially critical. In this work we compare several different configurations of ISEs to be deployed for monitoring in extreme environments, and present a novel configuration to improve performance. In particular we compare a polymeric hydrogel‐based ISE, used previously in the Wet Chemistry Lab on the Phoenix Mars Lander, with three variations of solid supported nanoporous carbon‐based ISEs. The symmetric membrane (SM) solid contact ISE (SM‐SC‐ISE) shows promise in overcoming many of the analytical problems encountered with hydrogel and solid‐state devices. The results indicate that sensors based on the SM configuration provide improvements in both stability, and most importantly reproducibility, over other existing SC‐ISEs. Future work will continue testing the SM configuration for use in a variety of extreme environments, including continuous monitoring and in‐situ analyses in extraterrestrial environments.     

Highly Conductive PEDOT:PSS Films with 1,3‐Dimethyl‐2‐Imidazolidinone as Transparent Electrodes for Organic Light‐Emitting Diodes

Highly conductive poly(3,4‐ethylenedioxythiophene):poly(styrenesulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS) films as transparent electrodes for organic light‐emitting diodes (OLEDs) are doped with a new solvent 1,3‐dimethyl‐2‐imidazolidinone (DMI) and are optimized using solvent post‐treatment. The DMI doped PEDOT:PSS films show significantly enhanced conductivities up to 812.1 S cm⁻¹. The sheet resistance of the PEDOT:PSS films doped with DMI is further reduced by various solvent post‐treatment. The effect of solvent post‐treatment on DMI doped PEDOT:PSS films is investigated and is shown to reduce insulating PSS in the conductive films. The solvent posttreated PEDOT:PSS films are successfully employed as transparent electrodes in white OLEDs. It is shown that the efficiency of OLEDs with the optimized DMI doped PEDOT:PSS films is higher than that of reference OLEDs doped with a conventional solvent (ethylene glycol). The results present that the optimized PEDOT:PSS films with the new solvent of DMI can be a promising transparent electrode for low‐cost, efficient ITO‐free white OLEDs.

     

Simple Modification of Sheet Resistivity of Conducting Polymeric Anodes via Combinatorial Ink‐Jet Printing Techniques

Summary: Due to its capability of dispensing very small volumes of different liquids in a controlled manner, ink‐jet printing is well suited for combinatorial experiments. The multi‐nozzle ink‐jet delivery system is especially advantageous for parallel chemical synthesis of different materials. We have used ink‐jet printing of an oxidizing agent to pattern a pre‐coated conducting polymer, poly(3,4‐ethylenedioxy)‐thiophene‐poly(styrene sulfonate) (PEDOT‐PSS), yielding electrodes with predefined shapes and a controlled degree of sheet resistivity for use in gray‐scale organic light‐emitting devices (OLEDs). The electrical and optical properties of the PEDOT‐PSS layer are modified via chemical interaction using the oxidizing agent. These experiments were performed using a desktop ink‐jet printer in conjunction with common graphic software which employed color functions such as CMY (cyan, magenta and yellow), HSL (hue, saturation and luminosity) and RGB (red, green and blue).

Photographs of gray‐scale OLEDs patterned on PEDOT‐PSS surfaces by an ink‐jet printer on plastic substrates.     

Solid Contact Nitrate Ion‐Selective Electrode Based on Ionic Liquid with Stable and Reproducible Potential

A simple, fast and cheap method of preparation of solid contact nitrate ion‐selective electrode is proposed. The electrode membrane phase consist of only three components: PVC, plasticizer and ionic liquid (IL).The ionic liquid trihexyltetradecylphosphonium chloride is used in triple function as ionophore, as lipophilic ionic component in order to reduce membrane resistance, and as transducer media in order to stabilize the potential of internal Ag/AgCl electrode. The electrical properties of the membrane were studied by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and the influence of the interfacial water film was evaluated by potentiometric water layer test.     

PVC‐Based Ion‐Selective Electrodes with Enhanced Biocompatibility by Surface Modification with “Click” Chemistry

We report here on plasticized ion‐selective poly(vinyl chloride) membranes with increased biocompatibility by means of a copper(I)‐catalyzed azide‐alkyne cycloaddition (‘click chemistry’) on the surface of finished membranes. We aimed for increasing the hydrophilicity of the surface and the application of NO releasing molecules. Employing the first principle, sodium selective membranes based on azide‐substituted PVC were modified with different length poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) chains. For the second, cysteine groups were used as a nitrous oxide releasing substance. Surface modification was confirmed by Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS). Potentiometric measurements in undiluted whole blood showed an increased sensor stability in comparison to unmodified PVC. Membrane surfaces after 18 h contact with blood were analyzed with Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and revealed a reduced level of blood cell adsorption on membranes modified with tetraethylene glycol (TEG) and PEGs. In contrast, cysteine modified membranes did not exhibit improved fouling resistance, suggesting that nitric oxide release by itself is not a sufficiently efficient mechanism.     

Response Behavior of Poly(vinyl chloride)‐ and Polyurethane‐Based Ca2+‐Selective Membrane Electrodes with Polypyrrole‐ and Poly(3‐octylthiophene)‐Mediated Internal Solid Contact

The potentiometric response behavior of Ca²⁺‐selective poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC) and polyurethane (PU) membranes with different inner contacts has been compared. Evidence for the formation of a water film between membrane and internal contact and, hence, a less than optimal lower detection limit have been found for membranes directly in contact with bare Au or with polypyrrole generated by electropolymerization in the presence of KCl. A significantly better behavior is shown by membranes with polypyrrole prepared in the presence of potassium hexacyanoferrate. Best performances have been obtained with solvent‐cast poly(3‐octylthiophene) as the internal contacting layer. As compared with the PVC membranes, those with PU had a significantly worse performance throughout.     

Evaluation,Pitfalls and Recommendations for the “Water Layer Test” for Solid Contact Ion‐selective Electrodes

The “water layer test” is a crucial validation step of solid‐contact ion‐selective electrodes. It can confirm or contest the claim that the tested electrode is indeed a genuine solid contact electrode without an aqueous film between the ion‐selective membrane and its solid contact. Information about the presence of a water layer is essential for the interpretation of drifts in the electrode potentials commonly experienced with solid contact electrodes. Since its publication, the water layer test has been ubiquitously used, but without a standardized protocol the interpretation (or misinterpretation) of the test results led to uncertainties in the conclusions. Through both experiments and simulations based on theoretical models we have investigated the experimental parameters that can influence the results of the water layer test. We propose guidelines to minimize the possibility of misinterpretation of the results of the water layer test by considering the key factors that affect the shape of transients recorded during the water layer test. Most importantly, we emphasize the importance of allowing sufficient time for conditioning the tested electrode before the water layer test and providing adequate time for equilibration during the experiment. Using a thin ion‐selective membrane and thin solid‐contact layer for the tests is also recommended.     

Development of Miniature Solid Contact Ion Selective Electrodes for in situ Instrumentation

Using a standardized miniature format ion selective electrode, five different carbon based solid contact materials, including a novel commercially available graphene oxide assisted carbon nanotube dispersion (Flexiphene^TM), were compared. The electromotive force (EMF) response, stability, and behavior following storage was evaluated. Bulk resistance for the novel graphene oxide/carbon nanotube (GO‐CNT) based ISE was observed to be 0.09±0.03 MΩ, which is two orders of magnitude lower than reported for either component in isolation. The results for previously described solid contact materials are in general agreement with the literature, and the tradeoffs between solid contact layer material choices are discussed. Performance of GO‐CNT solid contact ion selective electrodes were then evaluated in a 3D‐printed fluidic array to determine their suitability for future in situ instruments.