Positive and negative design leads to compositional control in AAB collagen heterotrimers

Although collagen is the most abundant protein in the human body and has at least 28 types, research involving collagen mimetic systems only recently began to consider the innate ability of collagen to control helix composition and register. Collagen triple helices can be homotrimeric or heterotrimeric, and while some types of natural collagen form only one specific composition of helix, others can form multiple compositions. It is critical to fully understand and, if possible, reproduce the control that native collagen has on helix composition and register. In this Article, we utilize both positive and negative design for the assembly of specific AAB heterotrimers using charged amino acids to form intrahelix electrostatic interactions, which promote heterotrimer formation and simultaneously discourage homotrimers. Homotrimers are further discouraged by reducing hydroxyproline content, which would otherwise lead to nonspecific promotion of triple helix formation. We combine peptides in a 2:1 ratio in which the more abundant peptide has a charge 1/2 and opposite of the less abundant peptide, which can result in the formation of a zwitterionically neutral AAB heterotrimer. Using this approach, we are able to design collagen mimetic systems with full control over the composition of the resulting triple helix. All previous reports on synthetic collagen heterotrimers have shown mixed populations with respect to composition due to varying amounts of residual homotrimers. Our results yield a greater understanding of the self-assembly of collagenous sequences as well as provide a novel design scheme, both positive and negative, for the synthesis of extracellular matrix mimetics.     

Metal-assisted stabilization and probing of collagenous triple helices

Collagen model peptides that contain 2,2'-bipyridyl (bpy) ligands were designed and synthesized. The thermal stability of the collagenous triple helix was increased by forming an Fe(II)(bpy-peptide)(3) complex. The chirality of the metal center was shifted to form right-handed Delta-isomers induced by the supercoiling of the peptide moiety. Moreover, the refolding rate of the triple helix was increased in the presence of Fe(II). This metal-coordinating system possesses potential to be used to stabilize the triple-helical conformation as well as to probe the folding status of collagen model peptides.     

Synthetic collagen heterotrimers: structural mimics of wild-type and mutant collagen type I

Collagen type I is an AAB heterotrimer assembled from two alpha1 chains and one alpha2 chain. Missense mutations in either of these chains that substitute a glycine residue in the ubiquitous X-Y-Gly repeat with a bulky amino acid leads to osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) of varying severity. These mutations have been studied in the past using collagen-like peptide homotrimers as a model system. However, homotrimers, which by definition will contain glycine mutations in all the three chains, do not accurately mimic the mutations in their native form and result in an exaggerated effect on stability and folding. In this article, we report the design of a novel model system based upon collagen-like heterotrimers that can mimic the glycine mutations present in either the alpha1 or alpha2 chains of type I collagen. This design utilizes an electrostatic recognition motif in three chains that can force the interaction of any three peptides, including AAA (all same), AAB (two same and one different), or ABC (all different) triple helices. Therefore, the component peptides can be designed in such a way that glycine mutations are present in zero, one, two, or all three chains of the triple helix. With this design, we for the first time report collagen mutants containing one or two glycine substitutions with structures relevant to native forms of OI. Furthermore, we demonstrate the difference in thermal stability and refolding half-life times between triple helices that vary only in the frequency of glycine mutations at a particular position.     

Rules for the design of aza-glycine stabilized triple-helical collagen peptides

The stability of the triple-helical structure of collagen is modulated by a delicate balance of effects including polypeptide backbone geometry, a buried hydrogen bond network, dispersive interfacial interactions, and subtle stereoelectronic effects. Although the different amino acid propensities for the Xaa and Yaa positions of collagen''s repeating (Glycine–Xaa–Yaa) primary structure have been described, our understanding of the impact of incorporating aza-glycine (azGly) residues adjacent to varied Xaa and Yaa position residues has been limited to specific sequences. Here, we detail the impact of variation in the Xaa position adjacent to an azGly residue and compare these results to our study on the impact of the Yaa position. For the first time, we present a set of design rules for azGly-stabilized triple-helical collagen peptides, accounting for all canonical amino acids in the Xaa and Yaa positions adjacent to an azGly residue, and extend these rules using multiple azGly residues. To gain atomic level insight into these new rules we present two high-resolution crystal structures of collagen triple helices, with the first peptoid-containing collagen peptide structure. In conjunction with biophysical and computational data, we highlight the critical importance of preserving the triple helix geometry and protecting the hydrogen bonding network proximal to the azGly residue from solvent. Our results provide a set of design guidelines for azGly-stabilized triple-helical collagen peptides and fundamental insight into collagen structure and stability.

Guidelines for incorporating aza-glycine residues in collagen peptides are presented, detailing their effects on triple-helical thermal stability.     

Effect of 3-hydroxyproline residues on collagen stability

Collagen is an integral part of many types of connective tissue in animals, especially skin, bones, cartilage, and basement membranes. A fibrous protein, collagen has a triple-helical structure, which is comprised of strands with a repeating Xaa-Yaa-Gly sequence. l-Proline (Pro) and 4(R)-hydroxy-l-proline (4-Hyp) residues occur most often in the Xaa and Yaa positions. The 4-Hyp residue is known to increase markedly the conformational stability of a collagen triple helix. In natural collagen, a 3(S)-hydroxy-l-proline (3-Hyp) residue occurs in the sequence: 3-Hyp-4-Hyp-Gly. Its effect on collagen stability is unknown. Here, two host-guest peptides containing 3-Hyp are synthesized: (Pro-4-Hyp-Gly)(3)-3-Hyp-4-Hyp-Gly-(Pro-4-Hyp-Gly)(3) (peptide 1) and (Pro-4-Hyp-Gly)(3)-Pro-3-Hyp-Gly-(Pro-4-Hyp-Gly)(3) (peptide 2). The 3-Hyp residues in these two peptides diminish triple-helical stability in comparison to Pro. This destabilization is small when 3-Hyp is in the natural Xaa position (peptide 1). There, the inductive effect of its 3-hydroxyl group diminishes slightly the strength of the interstrand 3-HypC=O.H-NGly hydrogen bond. The destabilization is large when 3-Hyp is in the nonnatural Yaa position (peptide 2). There, its pyrrolidine ring pucker leads to inappropriate mainchain dihedral angles and interstrand steric clashes. Thus, the natural regioisomeric residues 3-Hyp and 4-Hyp have distinct effects on the conformational stability of the collagen triple helix.     

Fe(III)-binding collagen mimetics

The synthesis and characterization of hydroxamic acid containing single-chain and TRIS-assembled (where TRIS is tris(carboxyethoxymethyl)aminomethane) collagen mimetics are reported. We have engineered an Fe(III)-binding domain by placing a hydroxamic acid group at the C termini of collagen mimetic chains composed of the Gly-Pro-NLeu sequence. The circular dichroism spectra and thermal denaturation studies show an enhancement in triple-helical thermal stability upon the addition of Fe(III) for the TRIS-assembled structure. No triple-helical structure was detected for the single-chain collagen mimetic. From the absorbance shown in the UV-vis spectra, we believe that the thermal stabilization of the triple helix is the direct result of a coordination complex between Fe(III) and the hydroxamate groups tethered to the C termini of the collagen mimetic peptide chains.     

Self-assembled heterotrimeric collagen triple helices directed through electrostatic interactions

Collagen, a fibrous protein, is an essential structural component of all connective tissues such as cartilage, bones, ligaments, and skin. Type I collagen, the most abundant form, is a heterotrimer assembled from two identical alpha1 chains and one alpha2 chain. However, most synthetic systems have addressed homotrimeric triple helices. In this paper we examine the stability of several heterotrimeric collagen-like triple helices with an emphasis on electrostatic interactions between peptides. We synthesize seven 30 amino acid peptides with net charges ranging from -10 to +10. These peptides were mixed, and their ability to form heterotrimers was assessed. We successfully show the assembly of five different AAB heterotrimers and one ABC heterotrimer. The results from this study indicate that intermolecular electrostatic interactions can be utilized to direct heterotrimer formation. Furthermore, amino acids with poor stability in collagen triple helices can be "rescued" in heterotrimers containing amino acids with known high triple helical stability. This mechanism allows collagen triple helices to have greater chemical diversity than would otherwise be allowed.     

Surprisingly high stability of collagen ABC heterotrimer: evaluation of side chain charge pairs

Type I collagen is a major component of skin, tendon, and ligament and forms more than 90% of bone mass. It is an AAB heterotrimer assembled from two identical alpha1 and one alpha2 chains. However, the majority of studies on the effects of amino acid substitution on triple helix stability have been performed on collagen homotrimeric helices. In a homotrimer, it is impossible to determine whether the contribution to stability is from the polyproline II helix propensity of the amino acids or from interhelix amino acid interactions. The presence of amino acids in all three chains further exaggerates their contribution. In contrast, in a heterotrimer, the individual chains may be tailored in order to have the substitution in one, two, or all three chains. Therefore, a heterotrimer can divulge specific information about any interaction based upon the substitutions in individual chains. In this paper, we evaluate the contribution of electrostatic interactions between side chain charge pairs on the stability of heterotrimers. We synthesize and analyze the stability of four AAB and four ABC heterotrimers including a surprisingly stable ABC heterotrimer composed of (DOG)10, (PKG)10, and (POG)10 chains (O = hydroxyproline). This heterotrimer has a stability comparable to that of a (POG)10 homotrimer even though D and K occur 20 times in the heterotrimeric helix and have been previously shown to significantly destabilize the triple helix compared to the P and O imino acids. These results show that the stability of heterotrimers cannot be directly determined from the analysis of charge pairs in homotrimers. Because collagen heterotrimers can be designed to have substitution in one, two, or three chains, it gives us the ability to decode cross-strand interactions in collagen in a similar fashion to alpha-helical coiled-coil interactions and DNA duplex hydrogen bonding.     

A hyperstable collagen mimic

BACKGROUND: Collagen is the most abundant protein in animals. Each polypeptide chain of collagen is composed of repeats of the sequence: Gly-X-Y, where X and Y are often L-proline (Pro) and 4(R)-hydroxy-L-proline (Hyp) residues, respectively. These chains are wound into tight triple helices of great stability. The hydroxyl group of Hyp residues contributes much to this conformational stability. The existing paradigm is that this stability arises from interstrand hydrogen bonds mediated by bridging water molecules. This model was tested using chemical synthesis to replace Hyp residues with 4(R)-fluoro-L-proline (Flp) residues. The fluorine atom in Flp residues does not form hydrogen bonds but does elicit strong inductive effects. RESULTS: Replacing the Hyp residues in collagen with Flp residues greatly increases triple-helical stability. The free energy contributed by the fluorine atom in Flp residues is twice that of the hydroxyl group in Hyp residues. The stability of the Flp-containing triple helix far exceeds that of any untemplated collagen mimic of similar size. CONCLUSIONS: Bridging water molecules contribute little to collagen stability. Rather, collagen stability relies on previously unappreciated inductive effects. Collagen mimics containing fluorine or other appropriate electron-withdrawing substituents could be the basis of new biomaterials for restorative therapies.     

Influence of decavanadate clusters on the rheological properties of gelatin

The influence of polyoxovanadate clusters ([H(2)V(10)O(28)](4-)) on the thermo-reversible gelation of porcine skin gelatin solution (type A, M w approximately 40 000 g.mol (-1), pH = 3.4 < isoelectric point (IEP) approximately 8) has been investigated as a function of temperature and vanadate concentration by combining rheology and microcalorimetry. This work shows that the rheological properties of the system depend on electrostatic interactions between [H(2)V(10)O(28)](4-) and positively charged gelatin chains. In a first stage, we describe the renaturation of the gelatin triple helices in the presence of decavanadate clusters. We reveal that, when gelatin chains are in coil conformation (30 degrees C < T < 50 degrees C), the inorganic clusters act as physical cross-linkers that govern the visco-elastic properties of the mixture with an exponential dependence of the (G', G') modulus with the vanadate concentration. Below 30 degrees C, we show that gelatin triple helix nucleation is slightly favored by the presence of vanadate, but above a helix concentration of 0.012 g.cm (-3), G' is fully governed by the helix concentration. During the melting process, we reveal the non-fully reversible behavior of the vanadate/gelatin rheological properties and the stabilization of gelatin triple helices due to vanadate species until 50 degrees C. This non-reversible character has also been observed in the same experimental conditions with collagen/vanadate solutions. This is the first time that such a stabilization of triple helices has been reported in the case of gelatin hydrogels chemically cross-linked or not. We propose to analyze these results by considering that triple helix aggregates should persist because of decavanadate bridging, that the nucleation of an extended triple helix network may induce a strong modification of the vanadate cross-linker distribution in the system, or both, thus promoting the formation of thermally stable vanadate/gelatin micro-gels in the dangling end of the triple helices.     

Controlling the morphology of metal-promoted higher ordered assemblies of collagen peptides with varied core lengths

Self-assembling peptides have become an important subclass of next-generation biomaterials. In particular, materials that mimic the properties of collagen have received considerable attention due to the unique properties of natural collagen. Previous peptide-based designs have been successful in generating structures with morphological properties that were primarily determined by the type of self-assembling mechanism. Herein we demonstrate the metal ion-promoted, supramolecular assembly of collagen-based peptide triple helices into distinct morphologies that are controlled by defining the number of Pro-Hyp-Gly repeating units. We synthesized and characterized collagen-based peptides that incorporated either 5, 7, 9, or 11 Pro-Hyp-Gly repeating units. We found that the number of repeating units, and the resulting stability of the collagen triple helix, is intimately linked with the types of assemblies formed. For instance, collagen peptides that did not form a stable triple helix, such as NCoH5, did not participate in supramolecular assembly with added metal ions. Collagen peptides that formed stable triple helices, such as NCoH11, resulted in microsaddle structures with metal-promoted assembly, whereas a highly cross-linked, three-dimensional mesh formed with NCoH7, albeit at a higher metal ion concentration. These data provide evidence that triple helix formation is required for efficient metal-triggered assembly to the observed microstructures.     

How stable is a collagen triple helix? An ab initio study on various collagen and β‐sheet forming sequences

Collagen forms the well characterized triple helical secondary structure, stabilized by interchain H-bonds. Here we have investigated the stability of fully optimized collagen triple helices and beta-pleated sheets by using first principles (ab initio and DFT) calculations so as to determine the secondary structure preference depending on the amino acid composition. Models composed of a total of 18 amino acid residues were studied at six different amino acid compositions: (i) L-alanine only, (ii) glycine only, (iii) L-alanines and glycine, (iv) L-alanines and D-alanine, (v) L-prolines with glycine, (vi) L-proline, L-hydroxyproline, and glycine. The last two, v and vi, were designed to mimic the core part of collagen. Furthermore, ii, iii, and iv model the binding and/or recognition sites of collagen. Finally, i models the G-->A replacement, rare in collagen. All calculated structures show great resemblance to those determined by X-ray crystallography. Calculated triple helix formation affinities correlate well with experimentally determined stabilities derived from melting point (T(m)) data of different collagen models. The stabilization energy of a collagen triple helical structure over that of a beta-pleated sheet is 2.1 kcal mol(-1) per triplet for the [(-Pro-Hyp-Gly-)(2)](3) collagen peptide. This changes to 4.8 kcal mol(-1) per triplet of destabilization energy for the [(-Ala-Ala-Gly-)(2)](3) sequence, known to be disfavored in collagen. The present study proves that by using first principles methods for calculating stabilities of supramolecular complexes, such as collagen and beta-pleated sheets, one can obtain stability data in full agreement with experimental observations, which envisage the applicability of QM in molecular design.     

Selective covalent capture of collagen triple helices with a minimal protecting group strategy

Collagens and their most characteristic structural unit, the triple helix, play many critical roles in living systems which drive interest in preparing mimics of them. However, application of collagen mimetic helices is limited by poor thermal stability, slow rates of folding and poor equilibrium between monomer and trimer. Covalent capture of the self-assembled triple helix can solve these problems while preserving the native three-dimensional structure critical for biological function. Covalent capture takes advantage of strategically placed lysine and glutamate (or aspartate) residues which form stabilizing charge–pair interactions in the supramolecular helix and can subsequently be converted to isopeptide amide bonds under folded, aqueous conditions. While covalent capture is powerful, charge paired residues are frequently found in natural sequences which must be preserved to maintain biological function. Here we describe a minimal protecting group strategy to allow selective covalent capture of specific charge paired residues which leaves other charged residues unaltered. We investigate a series of side chain protecting groups for lysine and glutamate in model peptides for their ability to be deprotected easily and in high yield while maintaining (1) the solubility of the peptides in water, (2) the self-assembly and stability of the triple helix, and (3) the ability to covalently capture unprotected charge pairs. Optimized conditions are then illustrated in peptides derived from Pulmonary Surfactant protein A (SP-A). These covalently captured SP-A triple helices are found to have dramatically improved rates of folding and thermal stability while maintaining unmodified lysine–glutamate pairs in addition to other unmodified chemical functionality. The approach we illustrate allows for the covalent capture of collagen-like triple helices with virtually any sequence, composition or register. This dramatically broadens the utility of the covalent capture approach to the stabilization of biomimetic triple helices and thus also improves the utility of biomimetic collagens generally.

A minimal protecting group strategy is developed to allow selective covalent capture of collagen-like triple helices. This allows stabilization of this critical fold while preserving charge–pair interactions critical for biological applications.     

Computational design of a collagen A:B:C-type heterotrimer

We have successfully designed an A:B:C collagen peptide heterotrimer using an automated computational approach. The algorithm maximizes the energy gap between the target and competing misfolded states while enforcing a minimum target stability. Circular dichroism (CD) measurements confirm that all three peptides are required to form a stable, structured triple helix. This study highlights the power of automated computational design, providing model systems to probe the biophysics of collagen assembly and developing general methods for the design of fibrous proteins.     

Photocontrol of the collagen triple helix: synthesis and conformational characterization of bis-cysteinyl collagenous peptides with an azobenzene clamp

For the photomodulation of the collagen triple helix with an azobenzene clamp, we investigated various collagenous peptides consisting of ideal (Gly-Pro-Hyp) repeats and containing cysteine residues in various positions for a side chain-to-side chain crosslink with a suitable chromophore derivative. Comparative conformational analysis of these cysteine peptides indicated an undecarepeat peptide with two cysteine residues located in the central portion in i and i+7 positions and flanked by (Gly-Pro-Hyp) repeat sequences as the most promising for the cross-bridging experiments. In aqueous alcoholic solution the azobenzene-undecarepeat peptide formed a stable triple helix in equilibrium with the monomeric species as a trans-azobenzene isomer, whereas photoisomerization to the cis isomer leads to unfolding of at least part of the triple helix. Furthermore, the residual supercoiled structure acts like an intermolecular knot, thus making refolding upon cis-to-trans isomerization a concentration-independent fast event. Consequently, these photoswitchable collagenous systems should be well suited for time-resolved studies of folding/unfolding of the collagen triple helix under variable thermodynamic equilibria.     

Design of a triple-helix-specific cleaving reagent

BACKGROUND: Double-helical DNA can be recognized sequence specifically by oligonucleotides that bind in the major groove, forming a local triple helix. Triplex-forming oligonucleotides are new tools in molecular and cellular biology and their development as gene-targeting drugs is under intensive study. Intramolecular triple-helical structures (H-DNA) are expected to play an important role in the control of gene expression. There are currently no good probes available for investigating triple-helical structures. We previously reported that a pentacyclic benzoquinoquinoxaline derivative (BQQ) can strongly stabilize triple helices. RESULTS: We have designed and synthesized the first triple-helix-specific DNA cleaving reagent by covalently attaching BQQ to ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA). The intercalative binding of BQQ should position EDTA in the minor groove of the triple helix. In the presence of Fe(2+) and a reducing agent, the BQQ-EDTA conjugate can selectively cleave an 80 base pair (bp) DNA fragment at the site where an oligonucleotide binds to form a local triple helix. The selectivity of the BQQ-EDTA conjugate for a triplex structure was sufficiently high to induce oligonucleotide-directed DNA cleavage at a single site on a 2718 bp plasmid DNA. CONCLUSIONS: This new class of structure-directed DNA cleaving reagents could be useful for cleaving DNA at specific sequences in the presence of a site-specific, triple-helix-forming oligonucleotide and also for investigating triple-helical structures, such as H-DNA, which could play an important role in the control of gene expression in vivo.     

Peptides that anneal to natural collagen in vitro and ex vivo

Collagen comprises ? of the protein in humans and ? of the dry weight of human skin. Here, we implement recent discoveries about the structure and stability of the collagen triple helix to design new chemical modalities that anchor to natural collagen. The key components are collagen mimetic peptides (CMPs) that are incapable of self-assembly into homotrimeric triple helices, but are able to anneal spontaneously to natural collagen. We show that such CMPs containing 4-fluoroproline residues, in particular, bind tightly to mammalian collagen in vitro and to a mouse wound ex vivo. These synthetic peptides, coupled to dyes or growth factors, could herald a new era in assessing or treating wounds.     

The effect of a trans-locked Gly-Pro alkene isostere on collagen triple helix stability

An alkene isostere of Gly-trans-Pro was synthesized and incorporated into a host Ac-(Gly-Pro-Hyp)8-Gly-Gly-Tyr-NH2 peptide to investigate the effect of locking a proline amide bond. Proline amide bond isomerization is the slow step in collagen folding. By locking the amide, we hypothesized an increase in stability of the collagen triple helix. The substitution instead destabilized the collagen host peptide. The Tm value of the host control peptide was 50.0 degrees C, while the peptide containing the isostere, Ac-(Gly-Pro-Hyp)3-Gly-psi[(E)CH C]-Pro-Hyp-(Gly-Pro-Hyp)4-Gly-Gly-Tyr-NH2, had a Tm value of 28.3 degrees C. There are clearly factors that contribute to collagen stability and folding that we do not yet understand.     

Energetics of Competing Chiral Supramolecular Polymers

Chirality can have unexpected consequences including on properties other than spectroscopic. We show herein that a racemic mixture of bis-urea stereoisomers forms thermodynamically stable supramolecular polymers that result in a more viscous solution than for the pure stereoisomer. The origin of this macroscopic property was probed by characterizing the structure and stability of the assemblies. Both racemic and non-racemic bis-urea stereoisomers form two competing helical supramolecular polymers in solution: a double and a single helical structure at low and high temperature, respectively. The transition temperature between these assemblies, as probed by spectroscopic and calorimetric analyses, is strongly influenced by the composition (by up to 70 °C). A simple model that accounts for the thermodynamics of this system, indicates that the stereochemical defects (chiral mismatches and helix reversals) affect much more the stability of single helices. Therefore, the heterochiral double helical structure predominates over the single helical structure (whilst the opposite holds for the homochiral structures), which explains the aforementioned higher viscosity of the racemic bis-urea solution. This rationale constitutes a new basis to tune the macroscopic properties of the increasing number of supramolecular polymers reported to exhibit competing chiral nanostructures.     

Predicting Collagen Triple Helix Stability through Additive Effects of Terminal Residues and Caps

Collagen model peptides (CMPs) consisting of proline-(2S,4R)-hydroxyproline-glycine (POG) repeats have provided a breadth of knowledge of the triple helical structure of collagen, the most abundant protein in mammals. Predictive tools for triple helix stability have, however, lagged behind since the effect of CMPs with different frames ([POG]_n, [OGP]_n, or [GPO]_n) and capped or uncapped termini have so far been underestimated. Here, we elucidated the impact of the frame, terminal functional group and its charge on the stability of collagen triple helices. Combined experimental and theoretical studies with frame-shifted, capped and uncapped CMPs revealed that electrostatic interactions, strand preorganization, interstrand H-bonding, and steric repulsion at the termini contribute to triple helix stability. We show that these individual contributions are additive and allow for the prediction of the melting temperatures of CMP trimers.