Solid state NMR analysis of the dipolar couplings within and between distant CF3-groups in a membrane-bound peptide

Dipolar couplings contain information on internuclear distances as well as orientational constraints. To characterize the structure of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S when bound to model membranes, two rigid 4-CF3-phenylglycine labels were attached to the cyclic backbone such that they reflect the behavior of the entire peptide. By solid state 19F NMR we measured the homonuclear dipolar couplings of the two trifluoromethyl-groups in oriented membrane samples. Using the CPMG experiment, both the strong couplings within each CF3-group as well as the weak coupling between the two CF3-groups could be detected. An intra-CF3-group dipolar coupling of 86 Hz and a weak inter-group coupling of 20 Hz were obtained by lineshape simulation of the complex dipolar spectrum. It is thus possible to explore the large distance range provided by 19F-labels and to resolve weak dipolar couplings even in the presence of strong intra-CF3 couplings. We applied this approach to distinguish and assign two epimers of the labeled gramicidin S peptide on the basis of their distinct 19F dipolar coupling patterns.     

Orientation of the antimicrobial peptide PGLa in lipid membranes determined from 19F-NMR dipolar couplings of 4-CF3-phenylglycine labels

A highly sensitive solid state (19)F-NMR strategy is described to determine the orientation and dynamics of membrane-associated peptides from specific fluorine labels. Several analogues of the antimicrobial peptide PGLa were synthesized with the non-natural amino acid 4-trifluoromethyl-phenylglycine (CF(3)-Phg) at different positions throughout the alpha-helical peptide chain. A simple 1-pulse (19)F experiment allows the simultaneous measurement of both the anisotropic chemical shift and the homonuclear dipolar coupling within the rotating CF(3)-group in a macroscopically oriented membrane sample. The value and sign of the dipolar splitting determines the tilt of the CF(3)-rotational axis, which is rigidly attached to the peptide backbone, with respect to the external magnetic field direction. Using four CF(3)-labeled peptide analogues (with L-CF(3)-Phg at Ile9, Ala10, Ile13, and Ala14) we confirmed that PGLa is aligned at the surface of lipid membranes with its helix axis perpendicular to the bilayer normal at a peptide:lipid ratio of 1:200. We also determined the azimuthal rotation angle of the helix, which agrees well with the orientation expected from its amphiphilic character. Peptide analogues with a D-CF(3)-Phg label resulting from racemization of the amino acid during synthesis were separately collected by HPLC. Their spectra provide additional information about the PGLa structure and orientation but allow only to discriminate qualitatively between multiple solutions. The structural and functional characterization of the individual CF(3)-labeled peptides by circular dichroism and antimicrobial assays showed only small effects for our four substitutions on the hydrophobic face of the helix, but a significant disturbance was observed in a fifth analogue where Ala8 on the hydrophilic face had been replaced. Even though the hydrophobic CF(3)-Phg side chain cannot be utilized in all positions, it allows highly sensitive NMR measurements over a wide range of experimental conditions and dynamic regimes of the peptide.     

Probing membrane topology by high-resolution 1H-13C heteronuclear dipolar solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Membrane topology changes introduced by the association of biologically pertinent molecules with membranes were analyzed utilizing the (1)H-(13)C heteronuclear dipolar solid-state NMR spectroscopy technique (SAMMY) on magnetically aligned phospholipid bilayers (bicelles). The phospholipids (1)H-(13)C dipolar coupling profiles lipid motions at the headgroup, glycerol backbone, and the acyl chain region. The transmembrane segment of phospholamban, the antimicrobial peptide (KIGAKI)(3) and cholesterol were incorporated into the bicelles, respectively. The lipids (1)H-(13)C dipolar coupling profiles exhibit different shifts in the dipolar coupling contour positions upon the addition of these molecules, demonstrating a variety of interaction mechanisms exist between the biological molecules and the membranes. The membrane topology changes revealed by the SAMMY pulse sequence provide a complete screening method for analyzing how these biologically active molecules interact with the membrane.     

Magic Angle-Oriented Sample Spinning (MAOSS): A New Approach toward Biomembrane Studies

The application of magic angle sample spinning (MAS) NMR to uniformly aligned biomembrane samples is demonstrated as a new general approach toward structural studies of membrane proteins, peptides, and lipids. The spectral linewidth from a multilamellar lipid dispersion is dominated, in the case of protons, by the dipolar coupling. For low-γ or dilute spins, however, the chemical shift anisotropy dominates the spectral linewidth, which is reduced by the two-dimensional order in a uniformly aligned lipid membrane. The remaining line broadening, which is due to orientational defects (“mosaic spread”) can be easily removed at low spinning speeds. This orientational order in the sample also allows the anisotropic intermolecular motions of membrane components (such as rotational diffusion, τ_c= 10⁻¹⁰s) for averaging dipolar interactions to be utilized, e.g., by placing the membrane normal parallel to the rotor axis. The dramatic resolution improvement for protons which are achieved in a lipid sample at only 220 Hz spinning speed in a 9.4 T field is slightly better than any data published to date using ultra-high fields (up to 17.6 T) and high-speed spinning (14 kHz). Additionally, the analysis of spinning sidebands provides valuable orientational information. We present the first¹H,³¹P, and¹³C MAS spectra of uniformly aligned dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) bilayers. Also,¹H resolution enhancement for the aromatic region of the M13 coat protein reconstituted into DMPC bilayers is presented. This new method combines the high resolution usually achieved by MAS with the advantages of orientational constraints obtained by working with macroscopically oriented samples. We describe the general potential and possible perspectives of this technique.     

Low-E probe for (19)F-(1)H NMR of dilute biological solids

Sample heating induced by radio frequency (RF) irradiation presents a significant challenge to solid state NMR experiments in proteins and other biological systems, causing the sample to dehydrate which may result in distorted spectra and a damaged sample. In this work we describe a large volume, low-E (19)F-(1)H solid state NMR probe, which we developed for the 2D (19)F CPMG studies of dilute membrane proteins in a static and electrically lossy environment at 600MHz field. In (19)FCPMG and related multi-pulse (19)F-(1)H experiments the sample is heated by the conservative electric fields E produced in the sample coil at both (19)F and (1)H frequencies. Instead of using a traditional sample solenoid, our low-E (19)F-(1)H probe utilizes two orthogonal loop-gap resonators in order to minimize the conservative electric fields responsible for sample heating. Absence of the wavelength effects in loop-gap resonators results in homogeneous RF fields and enables the study of large sample volumes, an important feature for the dilute protein preparations. The orthogonal resonators also provide intrinsic isolation between the (19)F and (1)H channels, which is another major challenge for the (19)F-(1)H circuits where Larmor frequencies are only 6% apart. We detail steps to reduce (19)F background signals from the probe, which included careful choice of capacitor lubricants and manufacture of custom non-fluorinated coaxial cables. Application of the probe for two-dimensional (19)F CPMG spectroscopy in oriented lipid membranes is demonstrated with Flufenamic acid (FFA), a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug.     

Uniaxial Diffusional Narrowing of NMR Lineshapes for Membrane Proteins Reconstituted in Magnetically Aligned Bicelles and Macrodiscs

Structure and dynamics of membrane proteins can be effectively studied by oriented-sample solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques when the lipid bilayers are macroscopically aligned with respect to the main magnetic field. Magnetic alignment of the protein-containing membrane bilayer results from the negative susceptibility anisotropy of the lipid hydrocarbon interior yielding perpendicular sample alignment. At this orientation, while the uniformity of alignment represents an essential prerequisite for obtaining high-quality NMR spectra, further line narrowing is obtained by uniaxial motional averaging of the azimuthal parts of the chemical shift anisotropies and dipolar couplings. The motional averaging is brought about by uniaxial rotational diffusion of the protein molecules about the normal to the membrane surface, which is perpendicular to the magnetic field. Uniaxial averaging is efficient when the motion about the axis of alignment becomes sufficiently fast (on the timescale of the dipolar couplings and chemical shift anisotropies). Line narrowing under uniaxial rotation can be theoretically modeled using the stochastic Liouville equation. In this mini-review, we illustrate the method of uniaxial averaging for the relatively small Pf1 coat protein which exhibits excellent resolution in magnetically aligned bicelles due to its fast uniaxial diffusion and even superior resolution in large (30 nm) nanodiscs (macrodiscs) stabilized by a belt peptide. Spectra of Pf1 coat protein in polymer-stabilized macrodiscs, an alternative and more robust alignment media, are presented. We also report on preliminary spectra of a much larger protein—uniformly ¹⁵N labeled M1-M4 domain for the human acetylcholine receptor. While some spectral resolution is apparent, significantly broader linewidths emphasize the need for creating fast rotating discoidal membrane mimetics.     

Solid state 19F NMR parameters of fluorine-labeled amino acids. Part II: aliphatic substituents

A representative set of amino acids with aliphatic 19F-labels has been characterized here, following up our previous compilation of NMR parameters for single 19F-substituents on aromatic side chains. Their isotropic chemical shifts, chemical shift tensor parameters, intra-molecular 19F dipole-dipole couplings and temperature-dependent T1 and T2 relaxation times were determined by solid state NMR on twelve polycrystalline amino acid samples, and the corresponding isotropic 19F chemical shifts and scalar couplings were obtained in solution. Of particular interest are amino acids carrying a trifluoromethyl-group, because not only the 19F chemical shift but also the intra-CF3 homonuclear dipolar coupling can be used for structural studies of 19F-labeled peptides and proteins. The CF3-groups are further compared with CH2F-, CD2F-, and CD3-groups, using both 19F and 2H NMR to describe their motional behavior and to examine the respective linebroadening effects of the protonated and deuterated neighbors. We have also characterized two unnatural amino acids in which a CF3-label is rigidly connected to the backbone by a phenyl or bicyclopentyl moiety, and which are particularly well suited for structure analysis of membrane-bound polypeptides. The 19F NMR parameters of the polycrystalline amino acids are compared with data from the correspondingly labeled side chains in synthetic peptides.     

Design and construction of a contactless mobile RF coil for double resonance variable angle spinning NMR

Variable angle spinning (VAS) experiments can be used to measure long-range dipolar couplings and provide structural information about molecules in oriented media. We present a probe design for this type of experiment using a contactless resonator. In this circuit, RF power is transmitted wirelessly via coaxial capacitive coupling where the coupling efficiency is improved by replacing the ordinary sample coil with a double frequency resonator. Our probe constructed out of this design principle has shown favorable properties at variable angle conditions. Moreover, a switched angle spinning correlation experiment is performed to demonstrate the probe's capability to resolve dipolar couplings in strongly aligned molecules.     

An NMR study of the origin of dioxygen-induced spin-lattice relaxation enhancement and chemical shift perturbation

Due to its depth-dependent solubility, oxygen exerts paramagnetic effects which become progressively greater toward the hydrophobic interior of micelles, and lipid bilayer membranes. This paramagnetic gradient, which is manifested as contact shift perturbations (19F and 13C NMR) and spin-lattice relaxation enhancement (19F and 1H NMR), has been shown to be useful for precisely determining immersion depth, membrane protein secondary structure, and overall topology of membrane proteins. We have investigated the influence of oxygen on 19F and 13C NMR spectra and spin-lattice relaxation rates of a semiperfluorinated detergent, (8,8,8)-trifluoro (3,3,4,4,5,5,6,6,7,7)-difluoro octylmaltoside (TFOM) in a model membrane system, to determine the dominant paramagnetic spin-lattice relaxation and shift-perturbation mechanism. Based on the ratio of paramagnetic spin-lattice relaxation rates of 19F and directly bonded 13C nuclei, we conclude that the dominant relaxation mechanism must be dipolar. Furthermore, the temperature dependence of oxygen-induced chemical shift perturbations in 9F NMR spectra suggests a contact interaction is the dominant shift mechanism. The respective hyperfine coupling constants for 19F and 13C nuclei can then be estimated from the contact shifts <(deltav/v0)19F> and <(deltav/v0)13C>, allowing us to estimate the relative contribution of scalar and dipolar relaxation to 19F and 13C nuclei. We conclude that the contribution to spin-lattice relaxation from the oxygen induced paramagnetic scalar mechanism is negligible.     

Three-dimensional solid-state NMR spectroscopy is essential for resolution of resonances from in-plane residues in uniformly (15)N-labeled helical membrane proteins in oriented lipid bilayers

Uniformly (15)N-labeled samples of membrane proteins with helices aligned parallel to the membrane surface give two-dimensional PISEMA spectra that are highly overlapped due to limited dispersions of (1)H-(15)N dipolar coupling and (15)N chemical shift frequencies. However, resolution is greatly improved in three-dimensional (1)H chemical shift/(1)H-(15)N dipolar coupling/(15)N chemical shift correlation spectra. The 23-residue antibiotic peptide magainin and a 54-residue polypeptide corresponding to the cytoplasmic domain of the HIV-1 accessory protein Vpu are used as examples. Both polypeptides consist almost entirely of alpha-helices, with their axes aligned parallel to the membrane surface. The measurement of three orientationally dependent frequencies for Val17 of magainin enabled the three-dimensional orientation of this helical peptide to be determined in the lipid bilayer.     

Atomic refinement with correlated solid-state NMR restraints

The orientation data provided by solid-state NMR can provide a great deal of structural information about membrane proteins. The quality of the information provided is, however, somewhat degraded by sign degeneracies in measurements of the dipolar coupling tensor. This is reflected in the dipolar coupling penalty function used in atomic refinement, which is less capable of properly restraining atoms when dipolar sign degeneracies are present. In this report we generate simulated solid-state NMR data using a variety of procedures, including back-calculation from crystal structures of alpha-helical and beta-sheet membrane proteins. We demonstrate that a large fraction of the dipolar sign degeneracies are resolved if anisotropic dipolar coupling measurements are correlated with anisotropic chemical shift measurements, and that all sign degeneracies can be resolved if three data types are correlated. The advantages of correlating data are demonstrated with atomic refinement of two test membrane proteins. When refinement is performed using correlated dipolar couplings and chemical shifts, perturbed structures converge to conformations with a larger fraction of correct dipolar signs than when data are uncorrelated. In addition, the final structures are closer to the original unperturbed structures when correlated data are used in the refinement. Thus, refinement with correlated data leads to improved atomic structures. The software used to correlate dipolar coupling and chemical shift data and to set up energy functions and their derivatives for refinement, CNS-SS02, is available at our web site.     

High-resolution heteronuclear correlation spectroscopy in solid state NMR of aligned samples

A new two-dimensional scheme is proposed for accurate measurements of high-resolution chemical shifts and heteronuclear dipolar couplings in NMR of aligned samples. Both the (1)H chemical shifts and the (1)H-(15)N dipolar couplings are evolved in the indirect dimension while the (15)N chemical shifts are detected. This heteronuclear correlation (HETCOR) spectroscopy yields high-resolution (1)H chemical shifts split by the (1)H-(15)N dipolar couplings in the indirect dimension and the (15)N chemical shifts in the observed dimension. The advantages of the HETCOR technique are illustrated for a static (15)N-acetyl-valine crystal sample and a (15)N-labeled helical peptide sample aligned in hydrated lipid bilayers.     

13C PGSE NMR experiment with heteronuclear dipolar decoupling to measure diffusion in liquid crystals and solids

A new PGSE NMR experiment, designed to measure molecular diffusion coefficients in systems with nonvanishing static dipolar coupling, is described. The fast static dipolar dephasing of the single-quantum (13)C coherences is removed by multiple-pulse heteronuclear decoupling. The resulting slow dephasing of the (13)C coherences allows for inserting appropriate gradient pulses into the pulse sequence. The presence of the large magnetic field gradient reduces the efficiency of the decoupling sequences which is compensated for by introducing a scheme of sequential slice selection across the sample. The method is demonstrated by (19)F-decoupled (13)C PGSE NMR experiments in a lyotropic nematic and lamellar liquid crystal.     

Two-dimensional NMR correlations of liquid crystals using switched angle spinning

We present the first application of switched angle spinning (SAS) to correlate the first-order dipolar spectrum of a liquid crystalline sample with the isotropic magic angle spinning (MAS) spectrum in a two-dimensional experiment. In this experiment we are able to select the degree of dipolar couplings introduced via mechanical manipulations of the liquid crystal director in a single oriented sample. The (19)F SAS-COSY correlation of iodotrifluoroethylene, an AMX spin system, dissolved in the nematic liquid crystal 4-octylphenyl-2-chloro-4-(4-heptylbenzoyloxy)-benzoate provides assignment of both the J and dipolar couplings in a single experiment. This work demonstrates the use of oriented samples and sample spinning to resolve homonuclear dipolar couplings using isotropic chemical shifts.     

Concentration dependence of F nuclear magnetic resonance decay shapes and second moments in bone mineral

¹⁹F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spin-echoes and free induction decays (FIDs) have been observed from samples of fluoridated trabecular canine bone powder, with fluoride concentrations ([F]) ranging from approximately 10 to 33 mg F/g Ca. Curve fitting of echo envelopes and FIDs was performed using a two-component model function, where one of the components incorporates the effects of one-dimensional dipolar coupling. This function provides a good match for both echo envelopes and FIDs. Estimates of the total second moment and its homonuclear (F–F coupling) component were obtained from the fitting procedure. Based on the second moment measurements, it is argued that ¹⁹F spins in bone mineral typically experience weaker heteronuclear dipolar coupling than those in the mineral hydroxyapatite (HAP), which is often considered to be a prototype for bone mineral.     

Carbon-13 and fluorine-19 NMR spectroscopy of the supramolecular solid p-tert-butylcalix(4)arene.alpha,alpha,alpha-trifluorotoluene

The supramolecular 1:1 host-guest inclusion compound, p-tert-butylcalix[4]arene x alpha,alpha,alpha-trifluorotoluene, 1, is characterized by 19F and 13C solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Whereas the 13C NMR spectra are easily interpreted in the context of earlier work on similar host-guest compounds, the 15F NMR spectra of solid 1 are, initially, more difficult to understand. The 19F[1H] NMR spectrum obtained under cross-polarization and magic-angle spinning conditions shows a single isotropic resonance with a significant spinning sideband manifold. The static 19F[1H] CP NMR spectrum consists of a powder pattern dominated by the contributions of the anisotropic chemical shift and the homonuclear dipolar interactions. The 19F MREV-8 experiment, which minimizes the 19F-19F dipolar contribution, helps to identify the chemical shift contribution as an axial lineshape. The full static 19F[1H] CP NMR spectrum is analysed using subspectral analysis and subsequently simulated as a function of the 19F-19F internuclear distance (D(FF) = 2.25 +/- 0.01 A) of the rapidly rotating CF3 group without including contributions from additional libration motions and the anisotropy in the scalar tensor. The shielding span is found to be 56 ppm. The width of the centerband in the 19F[1H] sample-spinning CP NMR spectrum is very sensitive to the angle between the rotor and the magnetic field. Compound 1 is thus an attractive standard for setting the magic angle for NMR probes containing a fluorine channel with a proton-decoupling facility.     

Internal consistency of NMR data obtained in partially aligned biomacromolecules

A method of testing structure-related NMR data prior to structure calculations is presented. The test is applicable to second rank tensor interactions (dipolar coupling, anisotropic chemical shielding, and quadrupolar interaction) observed in partially aligned samples of biomacromolecules. The method utilizes the fact that only limited number of frequencies corresponding to the mentioned interactions can be measured independently in a rigid fragment of the macromolecule. Additional values can be predicted as linear combinations of the set of independent frequencies. Internal consistency of sufficiently large sets of frequencies measured in individual molecular fragments is tested by comparing the experimental data with their predicted values. The method requires only knowledge of local geometry (i.e., definition of the interaction tensors in the local coordinate frames of the fragments). No information about the alignment or shape of the molecule is required. The test is best suited for planar fragments. Application to peptide bonds and nucleic acid bases is demonstrated.     

Distribution effects on 1H double-quantum MAS NMR spectra

The effect of a distribution in the (1)H-(1)H dipolar coupling on (1)H double-quantum (DQ) magic angle spinning (MAS) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spinning sideband patterns is considered. In disordered or amorphous materials a distribution in the magnitude of the (1)H-(1)H dipolar coupling is a realistic possibility. Simulations of the (1)H DQ MAS NMR spinning sideband spectra were performed with the two-spin approximation. These simulations reveal that a dipolar coupling distribution can greatly affect the DQ spectral shape and behavior of the DQ build-up. The spectral line shapes are quantified by measurement of the relative intensities of the DQ sidebands. These variations in the (1)H DQ NMR spectra are evaluated as a function of the width of the dipolar coupling distribution. As an example, the experimental DQ spinning sideband spectrum for a hydrated polyoxoniobate containing 15 H(2)O molecules per hexaniobate cluster, are better simulated with a distribution of dipolar couplings opposed to a single coupling constant.     

Determination of NMR interaction parameters from double rotation NMR

It is shown that the anisotropic NMR parameters for half-integer quadrupolar nuclei can be determined using double rotation (DOR) NMR at a single magnetic field with comparable accuracy to multi-field static and MAS experiments. The (17)O nuclei in isotopically enriched l-alanine and OPPh(3) are used as illustrations. The anisotropic NMR parameters are obtained from spectral simulation of the DOR spinning sideband intensities using a computer program written with the GAMMA spin-simulation libraries. Contributions due to the quadrupolar interaction, chemical shift anisotropy, dipolar coupling and J coupling are included in the simulations. In l-alanine the oxygen chemical shift span is 455 +/- 20 ppm and 350 +/- 20 ppm for the O1 and O2 sites, respectively, and the Euler angles are determined to an accuracy of +/- 5-10 degrees . For cases where effects due to heteronuclear J and dipolar coupling are observed, it is possible to determine the angle between the internuclear vector and the principal axis of the electric field gradient (EFG). Thus, the orientation of the major components of both the EFG and chemical shift tensors (i.e., V(33) and delta(33)) in the molecular frame may be obtained from the relative intensity of the split DOR peaks. For OPPh(3) the principal axis of the (17)O EFG is found to be close to the O-P bond, and the (17)O-(31)P one-bond J coupling ((1)J(OP)=161 +/- 2 Hz) is determined to a much higher accuracy than previously.