An efficient unnatural base pair for PCR amplification

Expansion of the genetic alphabet by an unnatural base pair system provides a powerful tool for modern biotechnology. As an alternative to previous unnatural base pairs, we have developed a new pair between 7-(2-thienyl)imidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (Ds) and 2-nitropyrrole (Pn), which functions in DNA amplification. Pn more selectively pairs with Ds in replication than another previously reported pairing partner, pyrrole-2-carbaldehyde (Pa). The nitro group of Pn efficiently prevented the mispairing with A. High efficiency and selectivity of the Ds-Pn pair in PCR amplification were achieved by using a substrate mixture of the gamma-amidotriphosphate of Ds and the usual triphosphates of Pn and the natural bases, with Vent DNA polymerase as a 3' to 5' exonuclease-proficient polymerase. After 20 cycles of PCR, the total mutation rate of the Ds-Pn site in an amplified DNA fragment was approximately 1%. PCR amplification of DNA fragments containing the unnatural Ds-Pn pair would be useful for expanded genetic systems in DNA-based biotechnology.     

Monitoring the site-specific incorporation of dual fluorophore-quencher base analogues for target DNA detection by an unnatural base pair system

We developed intramolecular dual fluorophore-quencher base analogues for site-specific incorporation into DNA by an unnatural base pair replication system. An unnatural base pair between 7-(2-thienyl)-imidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (Ds) and 2-nitro-4-propynylpyrrole (Px) exhibits high fidelity in PCR amplification, and the 2-nitropyrrole moiety of Px acts as a quencher. Deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates of Px linked with a fluorophore (Cy3, Cy5 or FAM) were chemically synthesized, and the fluorescent properties and the enzymatic incorporation of the fluorophore-linked dPxTPs into DNA were examined in PCR amplification. The fluorophore-linked dPxTPs were site-specifically incorporated by PCR into DNA, opposite Ds in templates, with high selectivity. Furthermore, we found that the fluorescence of the triphosphates was partially quenched, but increased upon their incorporation into DNA. These dual fluorophore-quencher base analogues would be useful for site-specific DNA labeling and for monitoring the amplification products of target nucleic acid molecules with a specific sequence. We have demonstrated the utility of the fluorophore-linked Px substrates and the Ds-Px pairing in real-time quantitative PCR for target DNA molecule detection.     

Optimization of unnatural base pair packing for polymerase recognition

As part of an effort to expand the genetic alphabet, we have been examining the ability of predominately hydrophobic nucleobase analogues to pair in duplex DNA and during polymerase-mediated replication. We previously reported the synthesis and thermal stability of unnatural base pairs formed between nucleotides bearing simple methyl-substituted phenyl ring nucleobase analogues. Several of these pairs are virtually as stable and selective as natural base pairs in the same sequence context. Here, we report the characterization of polymerase-mediated replication of the same unnatural base pairs. We find that every facet of replication, including correct and incorrect base pair synthesis, as well as continued primer extension beyond the unnatural base pair, is sensitive to the specific methyl substitution pattern of the nucleobase analogue. The results demonstrate that neither hydrogen bonding nor large aromatic surface area is required for polymerase recognition, and that interstrand interactions between small aromatic rings may be optimized for replication. Combined with our previous results, these studies suggest that appropriately derivatized phenyl nucleobase analogues represent a promising approach toward developing a third base pair and expanding the genetic alphabet.     

Stability and selectivity of unnatural DNA with five-membered-ring nucleobase analogues

In an effort to develop an orthogonal third base pair for the storage of genetic information, thiophene and furan heterocycles have been examined as nucleobase analogues. The stability of the unnatural bases was evaluated in duplex DNA paired opposite other unnatural bases as well as opposite the natural bases. Several unnatural base pairs are identified that are both reasonably stable and strongly selective against mispairing with native bases. These results expand the potential nucleobase analogues with which the genetic alphabet may be expanded to include five-membered-ring heterocycles.     

Minor groove hydrogen bonds and the replication of unnatural base pairs

As part of an effort to expand the genetic alphabet, we examined the synthesis of DNA with six different unnatural nucleotides bearing methoxy-derivatized nucleobase analogues. Different nucleobase substitution patterns were used to systematically alter the nucleobase electronics, sterics, and hydrogen-bonding potential. We determined the ability of the Klenow fragment of E. coli DNA polymerase I to synthesize and extend the different unnatural base pairs and mispairs under steady-state conditions. Unlike other hydrogen-bond acceptors examined in the past, the methoxy groups do not facilitate mispairing, implying that they are not recognized by any of the hydrogen-bond donors of the natural nucleobases; however, they do facilitate replication. The more efficient replication results largely from an increase in the rate of extension of primers terminating at the unnatural base pair and, interestingly, requires that the methoxy group be at the ortho position where it is positioned in the developing minor groove and can form a functionally important hydrogen bond with the polymerase. Thus, ortho methoxy groups should be generally useful for the effort to expand the genetic alphabet.     

Discovery, characterization, and optimization of an unnatural base pair for expansion of the genetic alphabet

DNA is inherently limited by its four natural nucleotides. Efforts to expand the genetic alphabet, by addition of an unnatural base pair, promise to expand the biotechnological applications available for DNA as well as to be an essential first step toward expansion of the genetic code. We have conducted two independent screens of hydrophobic unnatural nucleotides to identify novel candidate base pairs that are well recognized by a natural DNA polymerase. From a pool of 3600 candidate base pairs, both screens identified the same base pair, dSICS:dMMO2, which we report here. Using a series of related analogues, we performed a detailed structure-activity relationship analysis, which allowed us to identify the essential functional groups on each nucleobase. From the results of these studies, we designed an optimized base pair, d5SICS:dMMO2, which is efficiently and selectively synthesized by Kf within the context of natural DNA.     

Efforts toward expansion of the genetic alphabet: structure and replication of unnatural base pairs

Expansion of the genetic alphabet has been a long-time goal of chemical biology. A third DNA base pair that is stable and replicable would have a great number of practical applications and would also lay the foundation for a semisynthetic organism. We have reported that DNA base pairs formed between deoxyribonucleotides with large aromatic, predominantly hydrophobic nucleobase analogues, such as propynylisocarbostyril (dPICS), are stable and efficiently synthesized by DNA polymerases. However, once incorporated into the primer, these analogues inhibit continued primer elongation. More recently, we have found that DNA base pairs formed between nucleobase analogues that have minimal aromatic surface area in addition to little or no hydrogen-bonding potential, such as 3-fluorobenzene (d3FB), are synthesized and extended by DNA polymerases with greatly increased efficiency. Here we show that the rate of synthesis and extension of the self-pair formed between two d3FB analogues is sufficient for in vitro DNA replication. To better understand the origins of efficient replication, we examined the structure of DNA duplexes containing either the d3FB or dPICS self-pairs. We find that the large aromatic rings of dPICS pair in an intercalative manner within duplex DNA, while the d3FB nucleobases interact in an edge-on manner, much closer in structure to natural base pairs. We also synthesized duplexes containing the 5-methyl-substituted derivatives of d3FB (d5Me3FB) paired opposite d3FB or the unsubstituted analogue (dBEN). In all, the data suggest that the structure, electrostatics, and dynamics can all contribute to the extension of unnatural primer termini. The results also help explain the replication properties of many previously examined unnatural base pairs and should help design unnatural base pairs that are better replicated.     

The effect of minor-groove hydrogen-bond acceptors and donors on the stability and replication of four unnatural base pairs

The stability and replication of DNA containing self-pairs formed between unnatural nucleotides bearing benzofuran, benzothiophene, indole, and benzotriazole nucleobases are reported. These nucleobase analogues are based on a similar scaffold but have different hydrogen-bond donor/acceptor groups that are expected to be oriented in the duplex minor groove. The unnatural base pairs do not appear to induce major structural distortions and are accommodated within the constraints of a B-form duplex. The differences between these unnatural base pairs are manifest only in the polymerase-mediated extension step, not in base-pair stability or synthesis. The benzotriazole self-pair is extended with an efficiency that is only 200-fold less than a correct natural base pair. The data are discussed in terms of available polymerase crystal structures and imply that further modifications may result in unnatural base pairs that can be both efficiently synthesized and extended, resulting in an expanded genetic alphabet.     

Optimization of interstrand hydrophobic packing interactions within unnatural DNA base pairs

As part of an effort to expand the genetic alphabet, we have evaluated a large number of predominantly hydrophobic unnatural base pairs. We now report the synthesis and stability of unnatural base pairs formed between simple phenyl rings modified at different positions with methyl groups. Surprisingly, several of the unnatural base pairs are virtually as stable as a natural base pair in the same sequence context. The results show that neither hydrogen-bonding nor large aromatic surface area are required for base pair stability within duplex DNA and that interstrand interactions between small aromatic rings may be optimized for both stability and selectivity. These smaller nucleobases are not expected to induce the distortions in duplex DNA or at the primer terminus that seem to limit replication of larger unnatural base pairs, and they therefore represent a promising approach to the expansion of the genetic alphabet.     

Structural Basis for Expansion of the Genetic Alphabet with an Artificial Nucleobase Pair

Hydrophobic artificial nucleobase pairs without the ability to pair through hydrogen bonds are promising candidates to expand the genetic alphabet. The most successful nucleobase surrogates show little similarity to each other and their natural counterparts. It is thus puzzling how these unnatural molecules are processed by DNA polymerases that have evolved to efficiently work with the natural building blocks. Here, we report structural insight into the insertion of one of the most promising hydrophobic unnatural base pairs, the dDs–dPx pair, into a DNA strand by a DNA polymerase. We solved a crystal structure of KlenTaq DNA polymerase with a modified template/primer duplex bound to the unnatural triphosphate. The ternary complex shows that the artificial pair adopts a planar structure just like a natural nucleobase pair, and identifies features that might hint at the mechanisms accounting for the lower incorporation efficiency observed when processing the unnatural substrates.     

Solution Structure,Mechanism of Replication,and Optimization of an Unnatural Base Pair

As part of an ongoing effort to expand the genetic alphabet for in vitro and eventual in vivo applications, we have synthesized a wide variety of predominantly hydrophobic unnatural base pairs and evaluated their replication in DNA. Collectively, the results have led us to propose that these base pairs, which lack stabilizing edge‐on interactions, are replicated by means of a unique intercalative mechanism. Here, we report the synthesis and characterization of three novel derivatives of the nucleotide analogue d MMO2 , which forms an unnatural base pair with the nucleotide analogue d 5SICS . Replacing the para‐methyl substituent of d MMO2 with an annulated furan ring (yielding d FMO ) has a dramatically negative effect on replication, while replacing it with a methoxy (d DMO ) or with a thiomethyl group (d TMO ) improves replication in both steady‐state assays and during PCR amplification. Thus, d TMO –d 5SICS , and especially d DMO –d 5SICS , represent significant progress toward the expansion of the genetic alphabet. To elucidate the structure–activity relationships governing unnatural base pair replication, we determined the solution structure of duplex DNA containing the parental d MMO2 –d 5SICS pair, and also used this structure to generate models of the derivative base pairs. The results strongly support the intercalative mechanism of replication, reveal a surprisingly high level of specificity that may be achieved by optimizing packing interactions, and should prove invaluable for the further optimization of the unnatural base pair.     

Major groove substituents and polymerase recognition of a class of predominantly hydrophobic unnatural base pairs

Expansion of the genetic alphabet with an unnatural base pair is a long‐standing goal of synthetic biology. We have developed a class of unnatural base pairs, formed between d 5SICS and analogues of d MMO2 that are efficiently and selectively replicated by the Klenow fragment (Kf) DNA polymerase. In an effort to further characterize and optimize replication, we report the synthesis of five new d MMO2 analogues bearing different substituents designed to be oriented into the developing major groove and an analysis of their insertion opposite d 5SICS by Kf and Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I (Taq). We also expand the analysis of the previously optimized pair, d NaM –d 5SICS , to include replication by Taq. Finally, the efficiency and fidelity of PCR amplification of the base pairs by Taq or Deep Vent polymerases was examined. The resulting structure–activity relationship data suggest that the major determinants of efficient replication are the minimization of desolvation effects and the introduction of favorable hydrophobic packing, and that Taq is more sensitive than Kf to structural changes. In addition, we identify an analogue (d NMO1 ) that is a better partner for d 5SICS than any of the previously identified d MMO2 analogues with the exception of d NaM . We also found that d NaM –d 5SICS is replicated by both Kf and Taq with rates approaching those of a natural base pair.     

Unnatural substrate repertoire of A, B, and X family DNA polymerases

As part of an effort to develop unnatural base pairs that are stable and replicable in DNA, we examined the ability of five different polymerases to replicate DNA containing four different unnatural nucleotides bearing predominantly hydrophobic nucleobase analogs. The unnatural pairs were developed based on intensive studies using the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase I from E. coli (Kf) and found to be recognized to varying degrees. The five additional polymerases characterized here include family A polymerases from bacteriophage T7 and Thermus aquaticus, family B polymerases from Thermococcus litoralis and Thermococcus 9(o)N-7, and the family X polymerase, human polymerase beta. While we find that some aspects of unnatural base pair recognition are conserved among the polymerases, for example, the pair formed between two d3FB nucleotides is typically well recognized, the detailed recognition of most of the unnatural base pairs is generally polymerase dependent. In contrast, we find that the pair formed between d5SICS and dMMO2 is generally well recognized by all of the polymerases examined, suggesting that the determinants of efficient and general recognition are contained within the geometric and electronic structure of these unnatural nucleobases themselves. The data suggest that while the d3FB:d3FB pair is sufficiently well recognized by several of the polymerases for in vitro applications, the d5SICS:dMMO2 heteropair is likely uniquely promising for in vivo use. T7-mediated replication is especially noteworthy due to strong mispair discrimination.     

An efficiently extended class of unnatural base pairs

A third DNA base pair, which is synthesized efficiently and selectively, would have wide ranging applications from synthetic organisms to nucleic acids biotechnology. Hydrophobic unnatural nucleobases offer a promising route to such a pair, but are often limited by inefficient extension, defined as synthesis immediately following the unnatural pair. Here, we describe a simple screen which enables the characterization of large numbers of previously uncharacterized hetero base pairs. From this screen, we identified a class of unnatural base pairs which are extended more efficiently than any unnatural base pair reported to date. Screening, when complemented by further kinetic analysis, can improve the understanding of the determinants of efficient extension as well as identify viable hetero base pairs.     

Synthesis and properties of oligonucleotides with iodo-substituted aromatic aglycons: investigation of possible halogen bonding base pairs

Ab initio calculations of halogen bond energies of artificial base pairs constructed between iodinated aromatic nucleobase mimics and nitrogen-containing acceptor molecules such as pyridine and imidazole suggest that modified base pairs are converted to optimized planar base pairs with weak Delta E values of -0.19 to -3.93 kcal/mol. To evaluate the contribution of halogen bonding toward duplex stabilization of such modified nucleobase mimics introduced into artificial base pairs, we synthesized three C-nucleoside analogues 1-3 with several iodinated aromatic rings and an imidazole nucleoside derivative 4 and incorporated them into oligodeoxynucleotides. Hybridization studies of modified oligodeoxynucleotides incorporating iodoaromatic bases showed their unique universal base-like ability; however, no indication of halogen bond formation was observed. A more sophisticated design is required for the development of new base pairs stabilized by halogen bonding.