OZONE EXPOSURE DECREASES UVB SENSITIVITY IN A UVB-SENSITIVE FLAVONOID MUTANT OF Arabidopsis

Abstract— The impact of sequential exposure to ozone (O₃) and UVB (290–320 nm) was studied using two genotypes of Arabidopsis thaliana differing in UVB sensitivity. The negative impact of UVB on dry matter production and photosynthetic pigments was absent in the ecotype Landsberg erecta (LER), while the negative impact of UVB was more pronounced when LER plants preexposed to O₃ were irradiated with UVB. However, the growth of tt5 plants (a mutant virtually incapable of synthesizing flavonoids) was significantly affected by the UVB exposures, while the impact of UVB was significantly counteracted when tt5 plants pre-exposed to O₃ were irradiated with UVB. These results suggest that pre-exposure to O₃ decreased sensitivity of tt5 but increased sensitivity of LER to UVB. Concentrations of UV-absorptive compounds were almost the same in plants exposed to UVB alone or sequentially to O₃ and UVB. Exposures of LER and tt5 to UVB enhanced both ascorbic acid and glutathione as well as their redox state compared to control plants. Pre-exposure to O₃ enhanced the total ascorbic acid and glutathione as well as the redox state of ascorbate and glutathione in tt5 but decreased the redox state in LER. Irradiation of plants pre-exposed to O₃ with UVB enhanced the redox state of ascorbate and glutathione slightly in tt5 but decreased it further in LER. The high redox state of ascorbate and glutathione in tt5 pre-exposed to O₃ would have protected plants from UVB and decreased their sensitivity to UVB in spite of their inability to synthesize flavonoids. The decreased redox state in O₃-exposed LER plants would have enhanced their sensitivity to UVB. These results suggest that O₃ influences plant response to UVB in environments enriched with both O₃ and UVB.     

DIFFERENTIAL RESPONSE OF PHOTOSYNTHETIC PIGMENTS, RUBISCO ACTIVITY and RUBISCO PROTEIN OF Arabidopsis thaliana EXPOSED TO UVB and OZONE

Abstract— The effect of UVB (280–320 nm radiation) and ozone (O₃) on growth, photosynthetic pigments, ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rubisco) activity and rubisco protein were investigated in Arabidopsis thaliana genotypes wild type Landsberg erecta (LER) and tt5, a flavonoid-deficient mutant. The UVB exposure for 5 days decreased whole plant dry weight of only tt5 plants, while O₃ exposure decreased the whole plant dry weight of both genotypes. The UVB exposure enhanced chlorophylls and carotenoids in both genotypes while O₃ exposure decreased photosynthetic pigments in both genotypes. Both UVB and 0₃ exposure enhanced UV-absorbing compounds in LER but not in tt5. Ultraviolet-B exposure decreased initial and total rubisco activities only in tt5 plants, which contained smaller amounts of UV-absorbing pigments. The effect of UVB was greater on initial rubisco activity resulting in decreased percent activatible rubisco. Ozone exposure decreased initial and total rubisco activities in both genotypes, and the magnitudes of decrease were greater on total rubisco activity, resulting in enhanced levels of percent activatible rubisco. Immunoblot analysis performed with antibodies raised against rubisco large subunit (LSU) and rubisco small subunit (SSU) showed no major changes in the levels of rubisco protein of either genotype irradiated with UVB. However, both rubisco LSU and SSU decreased in tt5 plants exposed to UVB for 7 days (70% of total leaf area necrotic). In contrast, O₃ exposure of both the genotypes decreased the levels of rubisco LSU and SSU before the appearance of visible symptoms of injury. These results suggested that UVB-induced limitations of growth are independent of changes in rubisco protein while O₃-induced growth limitations appeared to be due to a significant reduction in rubisco protein.     

Ultraviolet Radiation Effects on a Microscopic Green Alga and the Protective Effects of Natural Dissolved Organic Matter

Abstract— The population and photosynthetic responses of a microscopic green alga ( Selenastrum capricornutum ) to realistic levels of UV radiation (UVA and UVB) were assessed in natural lake waters of different dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentration. Specific growth rates and photosynthetic competence (as reflected by F_v/F_m [measure of maximal quantum efficiency of photosystem II] and t_1/2 [estimate of electrons transported to the plastoquinone pool] measured by in vivo variable chlorophyll a fluorescence) were compared between two exposure levels of UVR and two concentrations of DOC (2.5 mg C L⁻¹ 7.7 mg C L⁻¹). Exposure periods of 6–9 days (five to nine generations) were used. Exposure to UVA primarily affected the efficiency of photosystem II, as evidenced by significant decreases of F_v/F_m but not growth rates or t_1/2 Exposure to UVB, in the presence of UVA, did not cause significant additional decreases of F_v/F_m but did diminish growth rates. In the low DOC water, t_1/2 was also diminished, suggesting different proximate sites of action from those for UVA. The high DOC water decreased the effective exposure to both UVA and UVB and diminished the negative impact of UV radiation on the cells, but the apparent protection was not explicable solely by the shading action of the DOC. Control values for F_v/F_m, growth rates and t_1/2 were all lower in the high DOC water, suggesting a negative side effect to the apparent protective action of the DOC against UVB.     

The Influence of Photosynthetically Active Radiation on the Effects of Ultraviolet-B Radiation on Arabidopsis thaliana

Ultraviolet-B (UVB;280–320 nm) radiation is a small but biologically significant portion of the solar spectrum reaching the earth's surface. Research interests have been fostered because UVB has been increasing in recent years due to depletion of stratospheric ozone. Ultraviolet-B that penetrates into plant tissue may damage important cellular macromolecules. Although there has been considerable research on the effects of UVB on plants, the influence of the level of photosynthetically active radiation (PAR;400–700 nm) on effects of UVB requires further definition as a prelude to studies of UVB sensitivity and defense mechanisms. Arabidopsis thaliana wildtype ecotype Landsberg erecta (LER), which is relatively insensitive to UVB, and the relatively sensitive LER-based mutant transparent testa-5 (tt5), were grown under 100 or 250 μmol m^?2 s^?1 PAR and then exposed to O or 7 kJ m^?2 day ^?1 UVB_BE under these PAR levels. Plants exposed to UVB had reduced dry weight and leaf area and higher levels of UV-absorbing compounds in leaf tissue. The level of PAR did influence the effects of UVB, with the higher level of PAR prior to UVB exposure reducing sensitivity of LER to UVB. In contrast to other studies, higher PAR supplied simultaneously with UVB increased rather than decreased sensitivity of both genotypes to UVB. These results demonstrate the importance of controlling and comparing PAR levels when undertaking studies of UVB sensitivity, as effects of UVB on plants are influenced by the PAR levels plants are growing under prior to and during exposure to UVB.     

OXYGEN-DEPENDENT PHOTOSENSITIVITY and MITOTIC RECOMBINATION IN THE SMUT FUNGUS Ustilago violacea

Abstract— The effect of high intensity incandescent radiation on survival and mitotic recombination in the phlph + diploid strain of Ustilago violacea was studied with and without atmospheric O₂. In the presence of atmospheric O₂, strain phlph+ was characterized by photokilling to approximately 50% survival, and induction of mitotic recombination to about 60% by 90 min of light exposure. No photokilling and little induction of mitotic recombination were observed when light exposure was carried out in an 0₂ depleted environment. Photokilling and photo-induced mitotic recombination in U. violacea may be due to DNA damage or repair in response to a photosensitized reaction, involving an endogeneous photosensitizer.     

SEARCH FOR SINGLET OXYGEN LUMINESCENCE IN THE DISPROPORTIONATION OF HO2/O2

Abstract— During the reaction HO₂+ HO₂ (or O₂^-) = H₂O₂+ O₂ in aqueous solution, no luminescence in the region 620–720 nm, expected if the product O₂ were formed in a singlet state, could be detected. If any singlet O₂ is formed, its yield must be less than 10%. Faint luminescence, sometimes found at shorter wavelengths, was shown to arise from reaction of HO₂ with impurities in the reagents present.     

STRATOSPHERIC OZONE DEPLETION BETWEEN 1979 and 1992: IMPLICATIONS FOR BIOLOGICALLY ACTIVE ULTRAVIOLET-B RADIATION and NON-MELANOMA SKIN CANCER INCIDENCE

Abstract— The depletion of stratospheric ozone (0₃) has predictable implications for increases in biologically damaging solar ultraviolet-B radiation (UVB,280–320 nm) reaching the earth's surface. A radiative transfer analysis of satellite-based O₃ measurements between January 1979 and December 1992 shows that surface UVB levels increased substantially at all latitudes except the tropics, if other factors such as cloud cover and local pollutant levels have remained constant over this period. Exposure to UVB radiation is known to induce basal cell and squamous cell skin cancers, and dose-response relationships derived from epidemiological data can be combined with the UVB enhancements to estimate the seasonal and latitudinal distribution of future expected increases in the incidence of these cancers.     

OXYGEN QUENCHING OF CHLOROPHYLL FLUORESCENCE IN CHLOROPLASTS

Abstract— Three phases of chlorophyll a fluorescence quenching by O₂ are observed in green plants. The effects of various inhibitors on photosynthetic partial processes in chloroplasts were investigated in attempts to (1) localize the O₂-quenching sites and (2) assess possible physiological significance of O₂-quenching. Our results localize the most sensitive (and presumably functionally important) phase to a site between plastoquinone and the photosystem I acceptor, chlorophyll (P₇₀₀), possibly plastocyanin. It is suggested that PC may transfer electrons to oxygen in addition to P₇₀₀.     

COOPERATION OF CHARGES IN PHOTOSYNTHETIC O2 EVOLUTION–I. A LINEAR FOUR STEP MECHANISM

Abstract— Using isolated chloroplasts and techniques as described by Joliot and Joliot[6] we studied the evolution of O₂ in weak light and light flashes to analyze the interactions between light induced O₂ precursors and their decay in darkness. The following observations and conclusions are reported: 1. Light flashes always produce the same number of oxidizing equivalents either as precursor or as O₂. 2. The number of unstable precursor equivalents present during steady state photosynthesis is ∼ 1.2 per photochemical trapping center. 3. The cooperation of the four photochemically formed oxidizing equivalents occurs essentially in the individual reaction centers and the final O₂ evolution step is a one quantum process. 4. The data are compatible with a linear four step mechanism in which a trapping center, or an associated catalyst, ( S ) successively accumulates four + charges. The S ⁴⁺ state produces O₂ and returns to the ground state S ₀. 5. Besides S ₀ also the first oxidized state S ⁺ is stable in the dark, the two higher states, S²⁺ and S³⁺ are not. 6. The relaxation times of some of the photooxidation steps were estimated. The fastest reaction, presumably S *₁← S ₂, has a (first) half time ≤ 200 μsec. The S *₂ state and probably also the S *₀ state are processed somewhat more slowly (˜ 300–400 μsec).     

INTERACTIONS OF ASCORBATE AND CHELATED IRON IN A METHYLVIOLOGEN-MEDIATED MEHLER REACTION

Abstract— –In the light, isolated spinach thylakoids consumed O₂ in the presence of methylviologen, and ascorbate was found to interact with this reaction in various ways. Chelating-resin was used to remove metal impurities from the assay medium. Ascorbate diminished the H₂0₂ pool in resin-untreated solutions, while in resin-treated solutions ascorbate had no effect on H₂O₂ concentrations. A Fenton catalyst (Fe-EDTA) increased O₂ uptake in the presence of ascorbate and decreased the amount of O₂ recovered by catalase. Ascorbate tripled the rate of the methylviologen-mediated Mehler reaction, and the O₂ consumed was liberated to 50% of its original concentration by catalase. Superoxide dismutase reversed the effects of ascorbate on the Mehler reaction rates. These results indicate that ascorbate can stimulate Mehler reactions indirectly by promoting a Fenton-type reaction as well as stimulating Mehler reactions directly by reducing 2O₂^- to 2H₂O₂. The promotion of a Fenton-type reaction by ascorbate appears to be the cause of H₂O₂ depletion in resin-untreated solutions.     

Solar UVB Dosimetry by Amplification of Short and Long Segments in Phage LD DNA

Abstract— DNA UVB dosimeters, consisting of minidots of dried bacteriophage DNA placed on a UV-transparent polymer film, were analyzed by polymerase chain reactions (PCR). Ultraviolet-B dosimetry obtained with amplification of phage LD DNA of segments of 1.08 kilobase pairs (kbp) and 2.24 kbp was compared with that obtained with amplification of a 0.5 kbp segment (H. Yoshida and J. D. Regan, 66, 82-88, Photochem. Photobiol 1997). The number of lesions in each segment induced by UV radiation is proportional to the size of the amplified segments; thus, the average lesion frequency per unit dose was greatest in the 2.24 kbp and least in the 0.5 kbp segment. The average lesion frequency per unit dose was 3.5 times 10_-2 and 11.9 times 10_-2 m₂ kJ_-1 for 1.08 kbp and 2.24 kpb, respectively, compared to that for 0.5 kbp of 1.7 times 10_-2 m₂ kJ_-1 at 50 ng DNA. Dependability of DNA dosimeters, containing 50 ng and 100 ng, was tested by placing the DNA dosimeters for a time period of either 1 or 2 days outdoors on 8-12 January at Melbourne, FL. The daily dose was obtained directly with amplification of the 2.24 kbp segment and the 2 day continuous dose was obtained with amplification of the 1.08 kbp segment. Although the average lesion frequencies were different, both 50 ng and 100 ng DNA dosimeters provided about the same UVB dose, equivalent to the dose applied with a solar UVB simulator. The total UVB dose for 4 days obtained by amplification of the 1.08 and 2.24 kbp segments was 19.4-20.8 kJ m_-2, which is within experimental error with the 4 day continuous dose obtained with 0.5 kbp segments. The average daily dose obtained by 0.5 kbp and 1.08 kbp agreed with the average daily dose directly obtained with 2.24 kbp.     

THE EFFECT OF THE ANTIPSORIATIC DRUG METABOLITE ETRETIN (Ro 10-1670) ON UVB IRRADIATION INDUCED CHANGES IN THE METABOLISM OF ARACHIDONIC ACID IN HUMAN KERATINOCYTES IN CULTURE

[¹⁴C]Arachidonic acid was avidly incorporated into human keratinocytes in culture and following exposure to UVB irradiation of 9 mJ/cm² (erythemally effective, EE) substantial amounts of ¹⁴C-radiolabel were released from the cells. The release of radiolabel was accompanied by a decrease in the labelling of phosphatidylethanolamine whereas the labelling of triacylglycerols and cholesteryl esters was increased. Keratinocytes produced significant amounts of prostaglandin E₂ (PGE₂) and following UVB irradiation of 9 mJ/cm² (EE) the formation of prostaglandin E₂ was increased.
Etretin (Ro 10-1670), the active metabolite of the antipsoriatic drug etretinate (Ro 10-9359), affected significantly neither the total release of radiolabel induced by UVB nor the formation of prostaglandin E₂. However, in the presence of etretin the UVB irradiation induced transfer of [^l4C]arachidonic acid into triacylglycerols and cholesteryl esters was not increased as much as in the corresponding experiments without etretin. On the basis of the present study it appears that etretin does not interfere with the release of arachidonic acid in amounts which could be related to the therapeutic effects of the combination of retinoids with UVB irradiation (Re-UVB) in the treatment of psoriasis.     

HO2 ELIMINATION FROM α-HYDROXYALKYLPEROXYL RADICALS IN AQUEOUS SOLUTION

Abstract— In aqueous solutions α-hydroxyalkylperoxyl radicals undergo a spontaneous and a base catalysed HO₂ elimination. From kinetic deuterium isotope effects, temperature dependence, and the influence of solvent polarity it was concluded that the spontaneous reaction occurs via an HO₂ elimination followed by the dissociation of the latter into H⁺ and O₂^-. The rate constant of the spontaneous HO₂ elimination increases with increasing methyl substitution in α-position ( k (CH₂(OH)O₂) < 10s^-1 k (CH₃CH(OH)O₂) = 52s^-1 k ((CH₃)₂C(OH)O₂) = 665 s^-1). The OH^- catalysed reaction is somewhat below diffusion controlled. The mixture of peroxyl radicals derived from polyhydric alcohols eliminate HO₂ at two different rates. Possible reasons for this behaviour are discussed. The mixture of the six peroxyl radicals derived from d -glucose are observed to eliminate HO₂ with at least three different rates. The fastest rate is attributed to the HO₂ elimination from the peroxyl radical at C-l ( k > 7000s^-1). Because of the HO₂ eliminations the peroxyl radicals derived from d -glucose do not undergo a chain reaction in contrast to peroxyl radicals not containing an α-OH group. In competition with the first order elimination reactions the α-hydroxylalkylperoxyl radicals undergo a bimolecular decay. These reactions are briefly discussed.     

THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS FOR SINGLET MOLECULAR OXYGEN, O2(1△g) and O2 (1σ8+)

Abstract— A correction is offered to the approximate values previously given by Mendenhall (1978) for the enthalpy of formation and entropy of O₂(a₁Δ_g) and O₂(b₁₊) between 298 and 1500 K. Accurate values have been calculated for the functions together with the equilibrium constants for the formation of these species from O₂(X₃σ_g-).     

ALTERATIONS OF PROTEOGLYCANS IN ULTRAVIOLET-IRRADIATED SKIN

Abstract— The effect of UVB exposure on the distribution and synthesis of dermal proteoglycans was measured in the skin of hairless mice. Two groups of mice were included: one was irradiated for 10 weeks; the other was kept as control. After intraperitoneal injection of sodium ³⁵S-sulfate, punch biopsies were taken for histology and proteoglycans were extracted from the remaining skin with 4 M guanidinium chloride, containing 3–[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate (0.5%, weight per volume). Following proteolytic digestion, the glycosaminoglycan constituents were isolated and analyzed by quantitative cellulose acetate electrophoresis and enzymatic digestibility.
Under the influence of UVB radiation, newly synthesized proteoglycans measured by ³⁵SO₄ uptake increased as much as 60%. In addition, the irradiated skin had a higher average content of proteoglycan than had control skin (4981 μg vs 4134 μg/g dry weight). This could be ascribed to an increase in heparin (1400 vs 533 μ g/g dry weight) and heparan sulfate (472 vs 367 μg/g dry weight), whereas no change in the concentration of hyaluronic acid (1243 vs 1372 μg/g dry weight) and dermatan sulfate (1866 vs 1863 μg/g dry weight) was observed. The irradiated animals also exhibited a marked increase in the synthesis of heparan sulfate and heparin (62% and 71%, respectively). These results demonstrate that chronic doses of UVB altered proteoglycan metabolism through both quantitative and qualitative changes.     

AFFINITY FOR OXYGEN IN PHOTOREDUCTION OF MOLECULAR OXYGEN AND SCAVENGING OF HYDROGEN PEROXIDE IN SPINACH CHLOROPLASTS

Abstract— The apparent K _m for O₂ in the photoreduction of molecular oxygen by spinach class II chloroplasts and photosystem I subchloroplast fragments was determined. In both cases, a value of 2 ∼ 3 μ M O₂ was obtained. The reaction rate constant between O₂ and P-430, the primary electron acceptor of PS I, is estimated to be ∼ 1.5 × 10⁷ M ^-1 s^-1 and the factors affecting the production of superoxide by the photoreduction of O₂ in chloroplasts are discussed. Preliminary evidence is presented indicating the occurrence of an azide-insensitive scavenging system for H₂O₂ in chloroplast stroma.     

QUENCHING OF THE TRIPLET STATE OF CHLOROPHYLL a BY ASCORBIC ACID AND ASCORBATE IN ETHANOLIC SOLUTION

Abstract— Ascorbic acid and ascorbate in chlorophyll ethanol solution were found to be fairly efficient quenchers of the chlorophyll triplet state; comparable to the efficiency of ascorbic acid as a quencher in aqueous pyridine solution.
It has been well established that ascorbic acid quenches the triplet state of chlorophyll in aqueous pyridine solution.^(1,2) The bimolecular quenching constant, kQ , is very much less than that for O₂ or quinine.^(3,4)
Information regarding the quenching of the triplet state of chlorophyll by ascorbic acid in ethanolic solution is lacking. There has been some question as to whether ascorbic acid reduces photoexcited chloro-phyll-ethanolic solution because of its high oxidation potential, or because like the ascorbate ion, it acts only as a quencher; both ascorbic acid and ascorbate in high concentrations gave low quantum yields.⁽⁵⁾ The quenching of the triplet state by ascorbic acid and ascorbate was determined by the flash-photolytic method.     

THE PRODUCTION OF SINGLET MOLECULAR OXYGEN BY ZINC(II) PHTHALOCYANINE IN ETHANOL AND IN UNILAMELLAR VESICLES. CHEMICAL QUENCHING AND PHOSPHORESCENCE STUDIES

Abstract— Zn(II)phthalocyanine (ZnPc) generates O₂(¹Δ_g) with a quantum yield of ca. 0.4 upon photocxcitation at 354 or 600 nm in ethanolic solution as determined by time-resolved phosphorescence studies at 1270 nm and photooxidation experiments using 1,3-diphenylisobenzofuran (DPBF) as substrate. The quantum yield of photooxidation slightly increases upon incorporation of ZnPc into unilamellar liposomes of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine. Under our irradiation conditions (600 nm, 18^°C, and short light exposure times), DPBF(5–50 μM) undergoes photooxidation by a pure Type II mechanism; the rate constant for the O₂(¹Δ_g) + DPBF reaction is (1.1 ±0.1) x 10⁹ M^-1 s^_1 in ethanol solution and determined to be about two orders of magnitude smaller when both ZnPc and DPBF are embedded into liposomes.     

THE EFFECT OF CHRONIC LOW-DOSE UVB RADIATION ON LANGERHANS CELLS, SUNBURN CELLS, UROCANIC ACID ISOMERS, CONTACT HYPERSENSITIVITY and SERUM IMMUNOGLOBULINS IN MICE

Abstract— C3H mice were irradiated three times a week for up to 6 weeks with either 500 J/m² or 1000 J/m² broadband UVB (270–350 nm) or 3000 J/m² narrowband UVB (311–312 nm; TL01 source). Each dose was suberythemal to the mouse strain used. The number of Langerhans cells (LC) in the epidermis was reduced by over 50% after 2 weeks of irradiation with the UVB source and by 20% following TL01 irradiation. Continued irradiation for up to 6 weeks resulted in no further decrease in LC numbers in the case of the UVB source but a steady decline to 40% in the case of the TL01 source. Sunburn cells were detected following irradiation with both sources but the numbers were very low in comparison with acute exposure. Ultraviolet-B exposure resulted in doubling of the thickness of the epidermis throughout the 6 weeks of irradiation while TL01 exposure did not alter epidermal thickness. Conversion of trans- to ew-urocanic acid (UCA) was observed with both UVB and TL01 sources. The percentage of cis -UCA started to return to normal after 4 weeks of TL01 exposure despite continued irradiation. As observed following a single exposure, the contact hypersensitivity (CH) response was significantly reduced following 6 weeks of UVB irradiation but was unaffected by TL01 exposure, indicating no correlation between cis -UCA levels and CH response. Total serum immunoglobulin levels remained unchanged throughout the 6 weeks of UVB or TL01 irradiation but IgE titers significantly increased in all cases in the first 2 weeks of irradiation, indicating a possible shift to a T_H2 cytokine profile. The IgE levels started to return to normal at later times. Thus chronic broadband UVB exposure induces a number of cutaneous and systemic responses that are likely to be dose dependent, while chronic TL0I exposure induces only some of the these responses.     

REEVALUATION OF THE SPECTRAL AND KINETIC PROPERTIES OF HO2 AND O2- FREE RADICALS

Abstract— The spectra and molar absorbances of the HO₂ and O₂^- free radicals have been redetermined in aqueous formate solutions by pulse and stopped-flow radiolysis as well as by ⁶⁰Co gamma-ray studies. The extinction coefficients at the corresponding maxima and 23°C are ²²⁵= 1400 ± 80 M ^-1 cm^-1 and ²²⁵= 2350 ± 120 M ^-1 cm^-1 respectively. Reevaluation of earlier published rate data in terms of the new extinction coefficients yielded the following rate constants for the spontaneous decay of HO₂ and O₂^-: K _Ho2+HO2= (8.60 ± 0.62) × 10⁵ M ^-1 s^-1; K _Ho2+O2-= (1.02 ± 0.49) × 10⁸ M ^-1 s^-1; K _Ho2+O2- < 0.35 M ^-1 s^-1. For the equilibrium HO₂→ O₂^-+ H⁺ the dissociation constant is K _Ho2= (2.05 ± 0.39) × 10^-5 M or p K _HO2= 4.69 ± 0.08. G (O₂^-) has been evaluated as a function of formate concentration.