Fractionated illumination after topical application of 5-aminolevulinic acid on normal skin of hairless mice: the influence of the dark interval

We have previously shown that light fractionation during topical aminolevulinic acid based photodynamic therapy (ALA-PDT) with a dark interval of 2h leads to a significant increase in efficacy in both pre-clinical and clinical PDT. However this fractionated illumination scheme required an extended overall treatment time. Therefore we investigated the relationship between the dark interval and PDT response with the aim of reducing the overall treatment time without reducing the efficacy. Five groups of mice were treated with ALA-PDT using a single light fraction or the two-fold illumination scheme with a dark interval of 30 min, 1, 1.5 and 2h. Protoporphyrin IX fluorescence kinetics were monitored during illumination. Visual skin response was monitored in the first seven days after PDT and assessed as PDT response. The PDT response decreases with decreasing length of the dark interval. Only the dark interval of 2h showed significantly more damage compared to all the other dark intervals investigated (P<0.05 compared to 1.5h and P<0.01 compared to 1h, 30 min and a single illumination). No relationship could be shown between the utilized PpIX fluorescence during the two-fold illumination and the PDT response. The rate of photobleaching was comparable for the first and the second light fraction and not dependent of the length of dark interval used. We conclude that in the skin of the hairless mouse the dark interval cannot be reduced below 2h without a significant reduction in PDT efficacy.     

Photophysical parameters, photosensitizer retention and tissue optical properties completely account for the higher photodynamic efficacy of meso-tetra-hydroxyphenyl-chlorin vs Photofrin

Meso-tetra-hydroxyphenyl-chlorin (mTHPC) is one of the most potent photosensitizers currently available for clinical photodynamic therapy (PDT). However the reason or reasons for its high photodynamic efficacy remain(s) unresolved. To investigate the PDT efficacy of mTHPC vs Photofrin we use the knowledge of photophysical parameters extracted from the analysis of oxygen electrode measurements in spheroids to compute and compare their respective singlet oxygen (1O2) dose depositions. The electrode measurements indirectly report the bleaching kinetics of mTHPC and indicate that its photobleaching mechanism is consistent with 1O2-mediated reactions. mTHPC's photodegradation via 1O2 reactions is confirmed by a more direct evaluation of the spatially resolved fluorescence in confocal sections of intact spheroids during irradiation. The PDT efficacy comparisons establish that mTHPC's enhanced potency may be accounted for completely on the basis of its ability to sequester tightly in cells and its photophysical properties, in particular its higher extinction coefficient at a redshifted wavelength. We extend the efficacy comparison to include the influence of hemoglobin absorption of PDT treatment light and show that incorporating the influence of wavelength-dependent light attenuation in tissue further contributes to significantly higher efficacy for mTHPC- vs Photofrin-PDT.     

Metal-Organic Layer Delivers 5-Aminolevulinic Acid and Porphyrin for Dual-Organelle-Targeted Photodynamic Therapy

The efficacy of photodynamic therapy (PDT) depends on the subcellular localization of photosensitizers. Herein, we report a dual-organelle-targeted nanoparticle platform for enhanced PDT of cancer. By grafting 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) to a Hf₁₂-based nanoscale metal-organic layer (Hf-MOL) via carboxylate coordination, ALA/Hf-MOL enhanced ALA delivery and protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) synthesis in mitochondria, and trapped the Hf-MOL comprising 5,15-di-p-benzoatoporphyrin (DBP) photosensitizers in lysosomes. Light irradiation at 630 nm simultaneously excited PpIX and DBP to generate singlet oxygen and rapidly damage both mitochondria and lysosomes, leading to synergistic enhancement of the PDT efficacy. The dual-organelle-targeted ALA/Hf-MOL outperformed Hf-MOL in preclinical PDT studies, with a 2.7-fold lower half maximal inhibitory concentration in cytotoxicity assays in vitro and a 3-fold higher cure rate in a colon cancer model in vivo.     

Topical photodynamic therapy at low fluence rates--theory and practice

Photodynamic Therapy (PDT), with topically applied 5-aminolaevulinic acid as the photosensitiser, is an effective treatment for various malignant and pre-malignant skin conditions. Several studies have shown the importance of fluence rate as well as fluence in the efficacy of PDT. We propose a measure of PDT efficacy, Photodynamic Damage Dose (PDD), which uses the product of instantaneous fluence rates, photosensitiser concentrations and oxygen concentrations in its calculation. We derive a qualitative numerical model of PDT and verify it by demonstrating an inverse fluence rate effect, increased efficacy of fractionated PDT, PDT induced hypoxia, and the dependence of photobleaching on fluence rate under certain circumstances. We recommend that fluence, fluence rate and any fractionation regime used should be detailed when reporting a trial as altering any of these has significant effects on PDT efficacy. The model predicts that low fluence rate irradiations should be as effective as high fluence rate irradiations if carried out over the same length of time. To test this we build a light emitting diode-based lamp (fluence rate of 7 mW cm(-2) at 635 nm) and used it to treat 32 superficial basal cell carcinomas on 22 patients (30 min treatment time, fluence 12.6 J cm(-2)). The complete response rate at one year was 84%, which is comparable to that achieved using higher fluence rate sources for similar treatment times. We conclude that this robust, inexpensive light source is effective for topical PDT.     

Miconazole induces fungistasis and increases killing of Candida albicans subjected to photodynamic therapy

Cutaneous and mucocutaneous Candida infections are considered to be important targets for antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (PDT). Clinical application of antimicrobial PDT will require strategies that enhance microbial killing while minimizing damage to host tissue. Increasing the sensitivity of infectious agents to PDT will help achieve this goal. Our previous studies demonstrated that raising the level of oxidative stress in Candida by interfering with fungal respiration increased the efficiency of PDT. Therefore, we sought to identify compounds in clinical use that would augment the oxidative stress caused by PDT by contributing to reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation themselves. Based on the ability of the antifungal miconazole to induce ROS in Candida, we tested several azole antifungals for their ability to augment PDT in vitro. Although miconazole and ketoconazole both stimulated ROS production in Candida albicans, only miconazole enhanced the killing of C. albicans and induced prolonged fungistasis in organisms that survived PDT using the porphyrin TMP-1363 and the phenothiazine methylene blue as photosensitizers. The data suggest that miconazole could be used to increase the efficacy of PDT against C. albicans, and its mechanism of action is likely to be multifactorial.     

Programming DNA Nanoassembly for Enhanced Photodynamic Therapy

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) has extraordinary promise for the treatment of many cancers. However, its clinical progress is impaired by the intrinsic hypoxic tumor microenvironment that limits PDT efficacy and the safety concern associated with biological specificity of photosensitizers or vehicles. Now it is demonstrated that rationally designed DNA nanosponges can load and delivery photosensitizer effectively, target tumor precisely, and relieve hypoxia‐associated resistance remarkably to enhance the efficacy of PDT. Specifically, the approach exhibits a facile assembly process, provides programmable and versatile nanocarriers, and enables robust in vitro and in vivo anti‐cancer efficacy with excellent biosafety. These findings represent a practical and safe approach by designer DNA nanoassemblies to combat cancer effectively and suggest a powerful strategy for broad biomedical application of PDT.     

Tumor microenvironment triggered local oxygen generation and photosensitizer release from manganese dioxide mineralized albumin-ICG nanocomplex to amplify photodynamic immunotherapy efficacy

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) has emerged as a potential clinical strategy for tumor therapy. It can generate reactive oxygen species (ROS) to cause the chemical damage of tumor cells and promote the immune killing effects of T cells on tumor cells in the presence of enough oxygen and PDT drugs. However, most solid tumors are in a state of oxygen deficiency, which seriously limit the efficacy of PDT in generation enough ROS. Besides, few safe PDT drugs with ideal pharmacokinetic behavior are available in the clinic, which severely limits the clinical transformation and application of PDT. Herein, we utilized manganese chloride to mineralize the hydrophilic indocyanine green/albumin polyplexes (ICG@BSA@MnO₂) by using bio-mineralized method to solve these problems of PDT. These ICG@BSA@MnO₂ nanoparticles could circulate in the blood for a long period other than quickly removed from body after 30 min like free ICG. When accumulated at the tumor site, ICG was responsively released in the presence of hydrogen peroxide. Apart this, the tumor hypoxia microenvironment was also reversed owing to enhanced O₂ generation by the reaction of MnO₂ with hydrogen peroxide. Benefits from the rich accumulation of ICG and ameliorated tumor hypoxia in the tumor sites, the enhanced generation of ROS could successfully promote the distribution of CD3⁺ and CD8⁺ T cells inside the tumors, which then lead to the amplified efficacy of PDT in both CT26 and B16F10 tumor models without causing any side effects.     

Enhanced Efficacy of Photodynamic Therapy via a Sequential Targeting Protocol

This study was designed to examine determinants of the discovery that low‐dose lysosomal photodamage (lyso‐PDT) could potentiate the efficacy of subsequent low‐dose mitochondrial photodamage (mito‐PDT). The chlorin NPe6 and the benzoporphyrin derivative (BPD) were used to separately target lysosomes and mitochondria, respectively, in murine hepatoma cells. Lyso‐PDT (LD₅ conditions) followed by mito‐PDT (LD₁₅ conditions) enhanced the loss of the mitochondrial membrane potential, activation of procaspases‐3/7 and photokilling. Reversing the sequence was less effective. The optimal sequence did not enhance reactive oxygen species formation above that obtained with low‐dose mito‐PDT. In contrast, alkalinization of lysosomes with bafilomycin also enhanced low‐dose mito‐PDT photokilling, but via a different pathway. This involves redistribution of iron from lysosomes to mitochondria leading to enhanced hydroxyl radical formation, effects not observed after the sequential procedure. Moreover, Ru360, an inhibitor of mitochondrial calcium and iron uptake, partially suppressed the ability of bafilomycin to enhance mito‐PDT photokilling without affecting the enhanced efficacy of the sequential protocol. We conclude that sequential PDT protocol promotes PDT efficacy by a process not involving iron translocation, but via promotion of the pro‐apoptotic signal that derives from mitochondrial photodamage.     

Light dose fractionation to enhance photodynamic therapy using 5-aminolevulinic acid in the normal rat colon

5-Aminolevulinic acid (ALA) is an attractive photosensitizing agent for photodynamic therapy (PDT) as its photoactive derivative, protoporphyrin IX, is metabolized within 1-2 days, eliminating prolonged skin photosensitivity. However, at the maximum dose patients can tolerate by mouth, 60 mg/kg, only superficial effects are seen. This paper extends earlier studies on enhancing the effect by light fractionation. Experiments in the normal rat colon looked at the area of necrosis around a single light delivery fiber 3 days after PDT with a range of light-dose fractionation regimes. All animals were given 200 mg/kg ALA intravenously 2 h prior to light delivery (100 mW at 635 nm) and each interruption in illumination was for 150 s. The area of PDT necrosis (total dose 25 J) could be increased by a factor of 3 with a single interval after 5 J, compared with continuous illumination. Alternatively, with this single break, the total light dose could be reduced by 60% to achieve the same area of necrosis as with continuous illumination. This simple modification to PDT with ALA could markedly reduce current treatment times as well as increasing clinical efficacy.     

Angiogenesis induced by photodynamic therapy in normal rat brains

Angiogenesis promotes tumor growth and invasiveness in brain. Because brain injury often induces expression of angiogenic-promoting molecules, we hypothesize that oxidative insult induced by photodynamic therapy (PDT) could lead to an endogenous angiogenic response, possibly diminishing the efficacy of PDT treatment of tumors. Therefore, we sought to establish whether PDT induced an angiogenic response within the nontumored brain. PDT using Photofrin as a sensitizer at an optical dose of 140 J/cm2 was performed on normal rat brain (n = 30). Animals were sacrificed at 24 h, and 1, 2, 3 and 6 weeks after PDT treatment. Fluorescein isothiocyanatedextran perfusion was performed, and brains were fixed for immunohistological study. Immunostaining revealed that vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) expression increased within the PDT-treated hemisphere 1 week after treatment and remained elevated for 6 weeks. Three-dimensional morphologic analysis of vasculature within PDT-treated and contralateral brain demonstrated PDT-induced angiogenesis, as indicated by a significant increase in vessel connectivity (P < 0.001) concomitant with decreased (P < 0.05) mean segment length compared with vessels within the contralateral hemisphere. Volumetric measurement of angiogenic regions indicate that neovascular expansion continued for 4 weeks after PDT. These data demonstrate that PDT induces VEGF expression and neovascularization within normal brain. Because angiogenesis promotes growth and invasiveness of tumor, antagonizing this endogenous angiogenic response to PDT may present a practical means to enhance the efficacy of PDT.     

Selective distribution of porphyrins in skin thick basal cell carcinoma after topical application of methyl 5-aminolevulinate

Topical photodynamic therapy (PDT) of superficial basal cell carcinoma (BCC) with 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) has achieved promising clinical results. However, the efficacy of this therapy for thick BCC is dramatically decreased by a limited diffusion of hydrophilic ALA into the tumor. Lipophilic esters of ALA may enhance their penetration into the lesion. In this randomized, open clinical study, microscopic fluorescence photometry incorporating a light-sensitive thermo-electrically cooled charge-coupled device (CCD) camera was employed to investigate the penetration of methyl 5-aminolevulinate-induced porphyrin fluorescence in thick BCC lesions. Both the distribution pattern and the amount of porphyrins in 32 lesions of 16 patients were studied after topical application of 16, 80 or 160 mg/g of methyl 5-aminolevulinate for 3 or 18 h. A highly selective and homogeneous distribution of methyl 5-aminolevulinate-induced porphyrin fluorescence was seen in all lesions studied, with much less fluorescence in the adjacent normal skin tissues. In lesions of up to 2 mm thickness the application of 160 mg/g methyl 5-aminolevulinate for 3 h showed the highest ratio of porphyrin fluorescence depth to tumor depth (0.98+/-0.04), thus providing a biologic rationale for a clinical PDT trial with this regimen.     

The role of photosensitizer molecular charge and structure on the efficacy of photodynamic therapy against Leishmania parasites

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is emerging as a potential therapeutic modality in the clinical management of cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL). In order to establish a rationale for effective PDT of CL, we investigated the impact of the molecular charge and structure of photosensitizers on the parasitic phototoxic response. Two photosensitizers from the benzophenoxazine family that bear an overall cationic charge and two anionic porphyrinoid molecules were evaluated. The photodynamic activity of the photosensitizers decreases in the following order: EtNBSe > EtNBS > BpD > PpIX. The studies suggest that compared to hydrophobic anionic photosensitizers, the hydrophilic cationic benzophenoxazine analogs provide high effectiveness of PDT possibly due to (1) their strong attraction to the negatively charged parasitic membrane, (2) their hydrophilicity, (3) their high singlet oxygen quantum yield, and (4) their efficacy in targeting intracellular organelles.     

Optimization of photodynamic therapy response by survivin gene knockdown in human metastatic breast cancer T47D cells

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) leads to the generation of cytotoxic oxygen species that appears to stimulate several different signaling pathways, some of which lead to cell death, whereas others mediate cell survival. In this context, we observed that PDT mediated by methyl-5-aminolevulinic acid as the photosensitizer resulted in over-expression of survivin, a member of the inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) family that correlates inversely with patient prognosis. The role of survivin in resistance to anti-cancer therapies has become an area of intensive investigation. In this study, we demonstrate a specific role for survivin in modulating PDT-mediated apoptotic response. In our experimental system, we use a DNA vector-based siRNA, which targets exon-1 of the human survivin mRNA (pSil_1) to silence survivin expression. Metastatic T47D cells treated with both pSil_1 and PDT exhibited increased apoptotic indexes and cytotoxicity when compared to single-agent treated cells. The treatment resulted in increased PARP and caspase-3 cleavage, a decrease in the Bcl-2/Bak ratio and no participation of heat shock proteins. In contrast, the overexpression of survivin by a survivin-expressed vector increased cell viability and reduced cell death in breast cancer cells treated with PDT. Therefore, our data suggest that combining PDT with a survivin inhibitor may attribute to a more favorable clinical outcome than the use of single-modality PDT.     

Cell Death Pathways Associated with Photodynamic Therapy: An Update

Photodynamic therapy (PDT ) has the potential to make a significant impact on cancer treatment. PDT can sensitize malignant tissues to light, leading to a highly selective effect if an appropriate light dose can be delivered. Variations in light distribution and drug delivery, along with impaired efficacy in hypoxic regions, can reduce the overall tumor response. There is also evidence that malignant cells surviving PDT may become more aggressive than the initial tumor population. Promotion of more effective direct tumor eradication is therefore an important goal. While a list of properties for the “ideal” photosensitizing agent often includes formulation, pharmacologic and photophysical elements, we propose that subcellular targeting is also an important consideration. Perspectives relating to optimizing PDT efficacy are offered here. These relate to death pathways initiated by photodamage to particular subcellular organelles.     

Engineering of a universal polymeric nanoparticle platform to optimize the PEG density for photodynamic therapy

Nanocarrier-mediated photodynamic therapy(PDT) has attracted extensive attention due to its locoregional therapeutic effect,minimal toxicity to normal tissues, and activation of immune system capability. However, it is still unclear how the physicochemical properties of nanocarriers affect their PDT therapeutic efficacies, which could be very different from those for chemotherapy. Herein, to demonstrate the effect of PEG density on PDT efficacy, we synthesized a series of random polyphosphoesters(PPEs) with different PEG contents by regulating the molar ratios of these monomers, and then these PPEs were used to prepare chlorin e6(Ce6)-loaded polymeric nanoparticles with tunable PEG density. Thereafter, the PDT efficacies of these nanoparticles were carefully and comprehensively evaluated. We demonstrate that the moderate PEG density(3.01 PEG/nm~2) of nanocarrier exhibited the best PDT therapeutic efficacy in a mouse model of pancreatic cancer due to its efficient balance of prolonged circulation and tumor cellular uptake.     

Photodynamic Therapy for Gastrointestinal Cancer

The clinical application of photodynamic therapy (PDT) for gastrointestinal (GI) neoplastic lesions has been developed with appreciation for the great efforts and kind support of Dr. Tom Dougherty and his followers’ contributions. There are several published studies on clinical PDT in the field of GI oncology. Esophageal cancer was one of the first clinical indications for PDT that was approved as an endoscopic procedure in both the United States and Japan. PDT was initially used as a palliative local treatment for patients with obstructive esophageal cancer. PDT is also indicated for eradicative therapy for dysplastic Barret’s esophagus, which is the precursor state of esophageal adenocarcinoma, with the support of level one evidence. In Japan, PDT was approved as a curative treatment for superficial esophageal carcinoma lesions, which are difficult to treat with endoscopic resection. Further, PDT using second-generation photosensitizers is approved for early local failure after radiotherapy, for which treatment with other modalities is difficult. PDT has also been assessed in other GI cancers, including gastric cancer, biliary cancer and pancreatic cancer. In this review, we overview the history and state of PDT for GI cancer.     

Marriage of Scintillator and Semiconductor for Synchronous Radiotherapy and Deep Photodynamic Therapy with Diminished Oxygen Dependence

Strong oxygen dependence and limited penetration depth are the two major challenges facing the clinical application of photodynamic therapy (PDT). In contrast, ionizing radiation is too penetrative and often leads to inefficient radiotherapy (RT) in the clinic because of the lack of effective energy accumulation in the tumor region. Inspired by the complementary advantages of PDT and RT, we present herein the integration of a scintillator and a semiconductor as an ionizing‐radiation‐induced PDT agent, achieving synchronous radiotherapy and depth‐insensitive PDT with diminished oxygen dependence. In the core–shell Ce^III‐doped LiYF₄@SiO₂@ZnO structure, the downconverted ultraviolet fluorescence from the Ce^III‐doped LiYF₄ nanoscintillator under ionizing irradiation enables the generation of electron–hole (e^?–h⁺) pairs in ZnO nanoparticles, giving rise to the formation of biotoxic hydroxyl radicals. This process is analogous to a type I PDT process for enhanced antitumor therapeutic efficacy.     

Lutetium Texaphyrin (PCI-0123): A Near-Infrared, Water-Soluble Photosensitizer

Lutetium texaphyrin, PCI-0123, is a pure, water-soluble photosensitizer with a large broad absorption band centered at 732 nm. The compound was tested for photodynamic therapy (PDT) effectiveness in a murine mammary cancer model. The texaphyrin macrocycle as illustrated by magnetic resonance imaging and ¹⁴C-radiolabeled texaphyrin studies was shown to be tumor selective; a tumor-to-muscle ratio of 10.55 was seen after 5 h. Lutetium texaphyrin, at a drug dose of 20 μmol/kg with irradiation 5 h postinjection at 150 J/cm² and 150 mW/cm², had significant efficacy (P < 0.0001) in treating neoplasms of moderate size (40 ± 14 mm³) and also had significant efficacy ( P < 0.0001) in treating larger neoplasms (147 ± 65 mm³). The PDT efficacy was correlated with the time interval between PCI-0123 administration and light exposure. A 100% cure rate was achieved when photoirradiation took place 3 h postinjection compared to 50% for 5 h using 10 μmol/kg and 150 J/cm² at 150 mW/cm². The PDT efficacy was attributable to the selective uptakehetention of the texaphyrin photosensitizer in addition to the depth of light penetration achievable at the 732 nm laser irradiation.     

Fully Protected Glycosylated Zinc (II) Phthalocyanine Shows High Uptake and Photodynamic Cytotoxicity in MCF‐7 Cancer Cells

Phthalocyanine photosensitizers are effective in anticancer photodynamic therapy (PDT) but suffer from limited solubility, limited cellular uptake and limited selectivity for cancer cells. To improve these characteristics, we synthesized isopropylidene‐protected and partially deprotected tetra β‐glycosylated zinc (II) phthalocyanines and compared their uptake and accumulation kinetics, subcellular localization, in vitro photocytotoxicity and reactive oxygen species generation with those of disulfonated aluminum phthalocyanine. In MCF‐7 cancer cells, one of the compounds, zinc phthalocyanine {4}, demonstrated 10‐fold higher uptake, 5‐fold greater PDT‐induced cellular reactive oxygen species concentration and 2‐fold greater phototoxicity than equimolar (9 μm ) disulfonated aluminum phthalocyanine. Thus, isopropylidene‐protected β‐glycosylation of phthalocyanines provides a simple method of improving the efficacy of PDT.     

Nitric Oxide-Mediated Resistance to Antitumor Photodynamic Therapy

As an antitumor modality based on sensitizer photoexcitation by tumor-directed light, photodynamic therapy (PDT) has the advantage of being site-specific compared with conventional chemotherapy or radiotherapy. Like these other therapies, however, PDT is often limited by pre-existing or acquired resistance. One type of resistance, discovered in the author’s laboratory, involves nitric oxide (NO) generated by inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) in tumor cells. Using human breast, prostate and brain cancer cell lines, we have shown that iNOS is dramatically upregulated after a moderate PDT challenge sensitized by 5-aminolevulinic acid-induced protoporphyrin IX. The elevated NO not only elicited a greater resistance to cell photokilling, but also an increase in the growth and migration/invasion rate of surviving cells. Greater iNOS/NO-based resistance was also demonstrated at the in vivo level using a breast tumor xenograft model. More recent studies have shown that NO from PDT-targeted cells can stimulate a progrowth/promigration response in non-targeted bystander cells. These novel effects of NO, their negative impact on PDT efficacy and possible mitigation thereof by anti-iNOS/NO pharmacologic agents will be discussed.