Initial and Final Backward and Forward Discrete Time Non-homogeneous Semi-Markov Credit Risk Models

In this paper we show how it is possible to construct an efficient Migration models in the study of credit risk problems presented in Jarrow et al. (Rev Financ Stud 10:481–523, 1997) with Markov environment. Recently it was introduced the semi-Markov process in the migration models (D’Amico et al. Decis Econ Finan 28:79–93, 2005a). The introduction of semi-Markov processes permits to overtake some of the Markov constraints given by the dependence of transition probabilities on the duration into a rating category. In this paper, it is shown how it is possible to take into account simultaneously backward and forward processes at beginning and at the end of the time in which the credit risk model is observed. With such a generalization, it is possible to consider what happens inside the time after the first transition and before the last transition where the problem is studied. This paper generalizes other papers presented before. The model is presented in a discrete time environment.     

Kolmogorov–Smirnov‐type testing for the partial homogeneity of Markov processes—with application to credit risk

In banking, the default behaviour of the counterpart is not only of interest for the pricing of transactions under credit risk but also for the assessment of a portfolio credit risk. We develop a test against the hypothesis that default intensities are chronologically constant within a group of similar counterparts, e.g. a rating class. The Kolmogorov–Smirnov‐type test builds up on the asymptotic normality of counting processes in event history analysis. The right censoring accommodates for Markov processes with more than one no‐absorbing state. A simulation study and two examples of rating systems demonstrate that partial homogeneity can be assumed, however occasionally, certain migrations must be modelled and estimated inhomogeneously. Copyright © 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

基于平滑扩充原理的商业银行信用风险评级模型及实证

本文通过银行的资产质量方面、资本充足率方面、管控效能层面、盈利状态层面、流动性层面与社会敏感度层面等构建商业银行信用风险评价体系。根据平滑扩充原理模拟生成大样本数据,对评级得分进行扩充,进而根据扩充后的大样本数据划分银行的信用风险等级。解决了由于样本少、无法对信用等级合理划分的难题。通过实证分析可以了解到,本文得出的银行评级信息和标准普尔提供的评价结论存在共同的序关系状态。因此,可根据本模型对大多数未经过国际权威机构评级的银行进行风险评级。     

Modeling dependencies between rating categories and their effects on prediction in a credit risk portfolio

The internal‐rating‐based Basel II approach increases the need for the development of more realistic default probability models. In this paper, we follow the approach taken in McNeil A and Wendin J 7 (J. Empirical Finance 2007) by constructing generalized linear mixed models for estimating default probabilities from annual data on companies with different credit ratings. The models considered, in contrast to McNeil A and Wendin J 7 (J. Empirical Finance 2007), allow parsimonious parametric models to capture simultaneously dependencies of the default probabilities on time and credit ratings. Macro‐economic variables can also be included. Estimation of all model parameters are facilitated with a Bayesian approach using Markov chain Monte Carlo methods. Special emphasis is given to the investigation of predictive capabilities of the models considered. In particular, predictable model specifications are used. The empirical study using default data from Standard and Poor's gives evidence that the correlation between credit ratings further apart decreases and is higher than the one induced by the autoregressive time dynamics. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

On a multiple credit rating migration model with stochastic interest rate

In this paper, we explore a pricing model for corporate bond accompanied with multiple credit rating migration risk and stochastic interest rate. The bond price volatility strongly depends on potentially multiple credit rating migration and stochastic change of interest rate. A free boundary problem of partial differential equation is presented, which is the equivalent transformation of the pricing model. The existence, uniqueness, and regularity for the free boundary problem are established to guarantee the rationality of the pricing model. Due to the stochastic change of interest rate, the discontinuous coefficient in the free boundary problem depends explicitly on the time variable but is convergent as time tends to infinity. Accordingly, an auxiliary free boundary problem is constructed, whose coefficient is the convergent limit of the coefficient in the original free boundary problem. With some constraint on the risk discount rate satisfied, we prove that a unique traveling wave exists in the auxiliary free boundary problem. The inductive method is adopted to fit the multiplicity of credit rating. Then we show that the solution of the original free boundary problem converges to the traveling wave in the auxiliary free boundary problem. Returning to the pricing model with multiple credit rating migration and stochastic interest rate, we conclude that the bond price profile can be captured by a traveling wave pattern coupling with a guaranteed bond price with face value equal to one at the maturity.     

Credit rating analysis using adaptive fuzzy rule-based systems: an industry-specific approach

This paper presents an analysis of credit rating using fuzzy rule-based systems. The disadvantage of the models used in previous studies is that it is difficult to extract understandable knowledge from them. The root of this problem is the use of natural language that is typical for the credit rating process. This problem can be solved using fuzzy logic, which enables users to model the meaning of natural language words. Therefore, the fuzzy rule-based system adapted by a feed-forward neural network is designed to classify US companies (divided into the finance, manufacturing, mining, retail trade, services, and transportation industries) and municipalities into the credit rating classes obtained from rating agencies. Features are selected using a filter combined with a genetic algorithm as a search method. The resulting subsets of features confirm the assumption that the rating process is industry-specific (i.e. specific determinants are used for each industry). The results show that the credit rating classes assigned to bond issuers can be classified with high classification accuracy using low numbers of features, membership functions, and if-then rules. The comparison of selected fuzzy rule-based classifiers indicates that it is possible to increase classification performance by using different classifiers for individual industries.     

Credit risk optimization using factor models

We study portfolio credit risk management using factor models, with a focus on optimal portfolio selection based on the tradeoff of expected return and credit risk. We begin with a discussion of factor models and their known analytic properties, paying particular attention to the asymptotic limit of a large, finely grained portfolio. We recall prior results on the convergence of risk measures in this “large portfolio approximation” which are important for credit risk optimization. We then show how the results on the large portfolio approximation can be used to reduce significantly the computational effort required for credit risk optimization. For example, when determining the fraction of capital to be assigned to particular ratings classes, it is sufficient to solve the optimization problem for the large portfolio approximation, rather than for the actual portfolio. This dramatically reduces the dimensionality of the problem, and the amount of computation required for its solution. Numerical results illustrating the application of this principle are also presented. JEL Classification G11     

Credit rating prediction using Ant Colony Optimization

The introduction of the Basel II Capital Accord has encouraged financial institutions to build internal rating systems assessing the credit risk of their various credit portfolios. One of the key outputs of an internal rating system is the probability of default (PD), which reflects the likelihood that a counterparty will default on his/her financial obligation. Since the PD modelling problem basically boils down to a discrimination problem (defaulter or not), one may rely on the myriad of classification techniques that have been suggested in the literature. However, since the credit risk models will be subject to supervisory review and evaluation, they must be easy to understand and transparent. Hence, techniques such as neural networks or support vector machines are less suitable due to their black box nature. Building upon previous research, we will use AntMiner+ to build internal rating systems for credit risk. AntMiner+ allows to infer a propositional rule set from a given data set, hereby using the principles from Ant Colony Optimization. Experiments will be conducted using various types of credit data sets (retail, small- and medium-sized enterprises and banks). It will be shown that the extracted rule sets are both powerful in terms of discriminatory power and comprehensibility. Furthermore, a framework will be presented describing how AntMiner+ fits into a global Basel II credit risk management system.     

中小微企业信贷策略研究

利用中小微企业的进销项发票数据,对中小微企业的信贷风险进行评估,并给出最优贷款策略.首先,建立了企业实力-信誉指标体系,并通过优化模型得到有信誉等级和违约记录的123家企业的最优贷款策略;然后,应用WOE-Logistic评分卡模型对无信誉等级的302家企业进行信誉评级,通过上述实力-信誉指标体系和优化模型得到最优贷款...     

Classification of companies using maximal margin ellipsoidal surfaces

We recently proposed a data mining approach for classifying companies into several groups using ellipsoidal surfaces. This problem can be formulated as a semi-definite programming problem, which can be solved within a practical amount of computation time by using a state-of-the-art semi-definite programming software. It turned out that this method performs better for this application than earlier methods based on linear and general quadratic surfaces. In this paper we will improve the performance of ellipsoidal separation by incorporating the idea of maximal margin hyperplane developed in the field of support vector machine. It will be demonstrated that the new method can very well simulate the rating of a leading rating company of Japan by using up to 18 financial attributes of 363 companies. This paper is expected to provide another evidence of the importance of ellipsoidal separation approach in credit risk analysis.     

A dynamic binomial expansion technique for credit risk measurement: a Bayesian filtering approach

Credit risk measurement and management are important and current issues in the modern finance world from both the theoretical and practical perspectives. There are two major schools of thought for credit risk analysis, namely the structural models based on the asset value model originally proposed by Merton and the intensity‐based reduced form models. One of the popular credit risk models used in practice is the Binomial Expansion Technique (BET) introduced by Moody's. However, its one‐period static nature and the independence assumption for credit entities' defaults are two shortcomings for the use of BET in practical situations. Davis and Lo provided elegant ways to ease the two shortcomings of BET with their default infection and dynamic continuous‐time intensity‐based approaches. This paper first proposes a discrete‐time dynamic extension to the BET in order to incorporate the time‐dependent and time‐varying behaviour of default probabilities for measuring the risk of a credit risky portfolio. In reality, the ‘true’ default probabilities are unobservable to credit analysts and traders. Here, the uncertainties of ‘true’ default probabilities are incorporated in the context of a dynamic Bayesian paradigm. Numerical studies of the proposed model are provided.     

Intensity models and transition probabilities for credit card loan delinquencies

We estimate the probability of delinquency and default for a sample of credit card loans using intensity models, via semi-parametric multiplicative hazard models with time-varying covariates. It is the first time these models, previously applied for the estimation of rating transitions, are used on retail loans. Four states are defined in this non-homogenous Markov chain: up-to-date, one month in arrears, two months in arrears, and default; where transitions between states are affected by individual characteristics of the debtor at application and their repayment behaviour since. These intensity estimations allow for insights into the factors that affect movements towards (and recovery from) delinquency, and into default (or not). Results indicate that different types of debtors behave differently while in different states. The probabilities estimated for each type of transition are then used to make out-of-sample predictions over a specified period of time.     

Estimation in the continuous time mover‐stayer model with an application to bond ratings migration

The usual tool for modelling bond ratings migration is a discrete, time‐homogeneous Markov chain. Such model assumes that all bonds are homogeneous with respect to their movement behaviour among rating categories and that the movement behaviour does not change over time. However, among recognized sources of heterogeneity in ratings migration is age of a bond (time elapsed since issuance). It has been observed that young bonds have a lower propensity to change ratings, and thus to default, than more seasoned bonds. The aim of this paper is to introduce a continuous, time‐non‐homogeneous model for bond ratings migration, which also incorporates a simple form of population heterogeneity. The specific form of heterogeneity postulated by the proposed model appears to be suitable for modelling the effect of age of a bond on its propensity to change ratings. This model, called a mover–stayer model, is an extension of a Markov chain. This paper derives the maximum likelihood estimators for the parameters of a continuous time mover–stayer model based on a sample of independent continuously monitored histories of the process, and develops the likelihood ratio statistic for discriminating between the Markov chain and the mover–stayer model. The methods are illustrated using a sample of rating histories of young corporate issuers. For these issuers the default probabilities predicted by the Markov chain and mover–stayer models are different. In particular for 1–4 years old bonds the mover–stayer model estimates substantially lower default probabilities from rating C than a Markov chain. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Modelling credit rating by fuzzy adaptive network

Human judgment plays an important role in the rating of enterprise financial conditions. The recently developed fuzzy adaptive network (FAN), which can handle systems whose behaviour is influenced by human judgment, appears to be ideally suited for the modelling of this credit rating problem. In this paper, FAN is used to model the credit rating of small financial enterprises. To illustrate the approach, the data of the credit rating problem is first represented by the use of fuzzy numbers. Then, the FAN network based on inference rules is constructed. And finally, the network is trained or learned by using the fuzzy number training data. The main advantages of the proposed network are the ability for linguistic representation, linguistic aggregation and the learning ability of the neural network.     

Assessing Markov property in multistate transition models with applications to credit risk modeling

Multistate transition models are increasingly used in credit risk applications as they allow us to quantify the evolution of the process among different states. If the process is Markov, analysis and prediction are substantially simpler, so analysts would like to use these models if they are applicable. In this paper, we develop a procedure for assessing the Markov hypothesis and discuss different ways of implementing the test procedure. One issue when sample size is large is that the statistical test procedures will detect even small deviations from the Markov model when these differences are not of practical interest. To address this problem, we propose an approach to formulate and test the null hypothesis of “weak non‐Markov.” The situation where the transition probabilities are heterogeneous is also examined, and approaches to accommodate this case are indicated. Simulation studies are used extensively to study the properties of the procedures, and two applications are to illustrate the results.     

外资评级机构进入中国能否发挥“鲶鱼效应”?

近年来,中国信用评级行业逐步对外开放。我国监管部门相继批准标普、惠誉等具有国际影响力的外资评级机构进入我国市场。在此背景下,本文采用博弈模型分析了外资评级机构进入中国市场对本土评级机构评级质量的影响。研究发现,高声誉外资评级机构进入中国市场能够起到激励本土评级机构公正评级并促进评级行业形成良性循环的作用。本文研究结论为我国信用评级行业对外开放以及引入更多具有国际影响力的外资评级机构提供了理论支撑。     

Bank-sourced credit transition matrices: Estimation and characteristics

This study proposes and analyses a novel alternative to credit transition matrices (CTMs) developed by credit rating agencies - bank-sourced CTMs. It provides a unique insight into estimation of bank-sourced CTMs by assessing the extent to which the CTMs depend on the characteristics of the underlying credit risk datasets and the aggregation method and outlines that the choice of aggregation approach has a substantial effect on credit risk model results. Further, we show that bank-sourced CTMs are more dynamic than those of credit rating agencies, with higher off-diagonal transition rates and higher propensity to upgrade. Finally, we create a set of industry-specific CTMs, otherwise unobtainable due to the data sparsity faced by credit rating agencies, and highlight the implications of their differences, signalling the existence of industry-specific business cycles. The study uses a unique and large dataset of internal credit risk estimates from 24 global banks covering monthly observations on more than 26,000 large corporates and employs large-scale Monte Carlo simulations. This approach can be replicated by regulators (e.g., data collected by the European Central Bank in the AnaCredit project) and used by organisations aiming to improve their credit risk models.     

Controlled Markov Chains with Weak and Strong Interactions: Asymptotic Optimality and Applications to Manufacturing

This paper deals with the asymptotic optimality of a stochastic dynamic system driven by a singularly perturbed Markov chain with finite state space. The states of the Markov chain belong to several groups such that transitions among the states within each group occur much more frequently than transitions among the states in different groups. Aggregating the states of the Markov chain leads to a limit control problem, which is obtained by replacing the states in each group by the corresponding average distribution. The limit control problem is simpler to solve as compared with the original one. A nearly-optimal solution for the original problem is constructed by using the optimal solution to the limit problem. To demonstrate, the suggested approach of asymptotic optimal control is applied to examples of manufacturing systems of production planning.     

政府促进银行实施绿色信贷的多目标优化策略研究

传统的绿色信贷研究中存在着模型简单、非动态参数以及只能获取纳什均衡点的局限性。为改善这些局限性,研究了一种基于数据驱动多目标优化算法的政府促进银行实施绿色信贷的策略计算方法。首先针对绿色信贷的最优策略求解问题建立数据驱动的多目标优化算法框架,再基于历史数据建立算法框架中的最优策略马可夫状态转移模型,最后使用多目标粒子群优化算法对政府和银行的长远总收益进行最优策略求解。与传统的基于近似模型及博弈论的方法不同,本文提出的方法可以获得历史数据中的经验,从而制定出具有更加长远收益的策略,避免了传统方法中的“短视”现象。分析结果表明,绿色信贷的收益不会在短时间内显现,因此政府在做决策时,必须根据绿色信贷收益的回报周期作出长远的判断。     

An integrated pricing model for defaultable loans and bonds

In recent years, credit risk has played a key role in risk management issues. Practitioners, academics and regulators have been fully involved in the process of developing, studying and analysing credit risk models in order to find the elements which characterize a sound risk management system. In this paper we present an integrated model, based on a reduced pricing approach, for market and credit risk. Its main features are those of being mark to market and that the spread term structure by rating class is contingent on the seniority of debt within an arbitrage-free framework. We introduce issues such as, the integration of market and credit risk, the use of stochastic recovery rates and recovery by seniority. Moreover, we will characterize default risk by estimating migration risk through a “mortality rate”, actuarial-based, approach. The resultant probabilities will be the base for determining multi-period risk-neutral transition probability that allow pricing of risky debt in the trading and banking book.