Metal bioavailability in marine sediments measured by chemical extraction and enzymatic mobilization

In this work we compared metal bioavailable fractions in marine sediments operationally measured by sequential selective extractions (in particular the labile fraction released by acetic acid) and by a biomimetic approach using a commercially available proteolytic enzyme, proteinase K, chosen because of its non-specific behaviour and because it is representative of the enzymes encountered in many deposit-feeding organisms. Different experimental conditions for enzymatic extraction were investigated and the enzyme was employed both untreated and thermally denatured to study metal release mechanisms (i.e. enzymatic hydrolysis and/or complexation). Extractable protein content was also measured to verify possible correlations with some metals.Considering the two sediments used in this work, the available fraction evaluated with a biomimetic approach was often significantly lower than the fraction released by the first step of selective extractions, as expected. Moreover a good correlation was found between the fraction of metal available to the enzyme and enrichment factors in the gut fluids of deposit-feeding organisms, suggesting that enzymatic approach is qualitatively more reliable than chemical extraction in replicating the mechanism of metal mobilization that occurs in the guts of deposit-feeders.     

Different strategies to assess Cu and Pb mobilization in polluted river sediments

Summary For studying the mechanisms of trace metal mobilization in sediments several strategies have been employed, such as single extraction, sequential extractions, ion exchange, or progressive acidification. Several authors assert that sequential extraction is the best option. In this study two procedures are used in order to assess the mobility of copper and lead in heavily polluted river sediments: sequential extraction using a modified Tessier procedure, and progressive acidification, using an automated method. Six heavily polluted sediment samples are studied by applying the two procedures. The amount of metal released at different pH-values (pH 5 and pH 2) is compared with the resulting distribution when the sequential extraction procedure is applied. The information obtained from the two different approaches is discussed. For both metals a different behaviour is observed when applying each of the two procedures. Thus, copper is more easily released than lead when progressive acidification is followed, whereas an inverse situation is observed when sequential extraction is applied.     

Determining PCB desorption behaviour on sediments with SFE and investigating the dependency of selective fractions on sediment characteristics

A method for studying PCB desorption behaviour from sediments using supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) and pressurized liquid extraction (PLE) is presented. Four sediments were investigated and extracted with supercritical carbon dioxide employing increasingly harsher extraction conditions ranging from 40°C and 12?MPa to 100°C and 36.5?MPa. To ensure quantitative extractions, the remaining SFE residues were also extracted with PLE. Resulting profiles identified at least three different PCB fractions within the four sediments. Furthermore, a distinct fraction was obtained with extraction for 2?h at 40°C and 36.5?MPa. This fraction has previously been found to correlate well with bioavailable fractions. The dependency of this fraction on sediment total organic carbon (TOC) was investigated, both for sediments examined in this study as well as for previously reported values using the same extraction conditions. It was found that TOC does not correlate to selective SFE, which indicates that the use of TOC to predict bioavailability is questionable.     

Speciation of heavy metals in sediments of the lagoon of Venice collected in the industrial area

In this study a procedure of sequential extraction of metals from sediments was applied to samples from the lagoon of Venice. Compared to the measurement of total concentrations, the knowledge of metal partitioning among sediment phases can help in estimating the risk posed by metal polluted sediments and give information on contamination sources and on the factors that influence metal enrichment in sediments. The results permitted to estimate for each metal the percentage of the total content that could be potentially remobilized from sediments, owing to changes in environmental conditions. The immediately available fraction represented in general a low proportion of the total content. An important proportion of most metals (except for Zn, Cd and Cu) was associated to residual phases and therefore was not expected to be released under the normal environmental conditions. The large amounts of metals bound to Fe-Mn oxides/hydroxides confirmed the strong scavenging efficiency of this phase. The carbonate phase was the preferential associative form for Pb, Cd and Zn, whereas Cu was bound in prevalence to the organic matter/sulphide phase.     

Evaluation and comparison of two selective extraction procedures for heavy metal speciation in sediments.

Two sequential extraction procedures (the former proposed by the Standard, Measurements and Testing-SM&T-program of European Union and the latter derived from those of Tessier and Forstner with various modifications) have been compared, by analyzing a reference material (CRM 601) certified for the content of heavy metals in the three solutions resulting from the SM&T procedure. Scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray analysis (SEM-EDX) was used to evaluate the composition of the residues after various extractions. Reliable results, both in terms of precision and accuracy, were obtained for the first two steps of the SM&T scheme. As regards the third step, because it was modified during this work, a direct comparison of our results with those certified is not possible. SEM analysis confirmed that the scheme previously used in the laboratory was more aggressive compared to the SM&T procedure, which has also the advantage that the only CRM available for metal partitioning in sediments is certified using this method.     

Comparison of the standard SM&T sequential extraction method with small-scale ultrasound-assisted single extractions for metal partitioning in sediments

A single extraction method based on the reagents employed in the SM&T (standards, measurement and testing programme) sequential extraction scheme for partitioning of Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, and Pb in sediments has been developed. Small-scale extractions adapted to electrothermal atomic absorption spectrometric determinations (i.e. 25 mg mass in 1 mL extractant) have been used for the first time in conjunction with selective reagents using conventional operating conditions (i.e. conductive heating, magnetic stirring) or ultrasound-assisted extraction. Small-scale slurry preparations were implemented for determination of the residual/total metal content. The methodology developed enabled drastic reduction of extraction times, yielding extractable contents in accordance with those obtained by application of the conventional SM&T method, which can be regarded as a standard method. An important saving in the amount of sample and reagents is also achieved with small-scale extractions. Homogeneity of sediments at the mg level proved acceptable - precision was similar for between-batch and within-batch measurements. Method development was performed with CRM BCR 601 lake sediment for which extractable amounts of several metals are known. An application to a "real-world" sediment is also presented.     

Enzyme-assisted extraction of arsenic species from plant material

Investigations regarding the transfer and metabolism of arsenic species in plants require mild extraction conditions to conserve the original composition of arsenic species. Beside the use of water or water/methanol for extraction of arsenic species from plant samples, enzymes can assist this procedure by digestion of cellulose and other constituents of cell walls, resulting in a faster, more efficient extraction technique which preserves the arsenic species. The investigations presented here were focused on the stability of certain arsenic species in enzymatic solutions, optimal conditions for their chromatographic separation and detection namely by means of ion chromatography–inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry and improvements with respect to extraction efficiency. With commercially available enzymes and enzyme mixtures, the digestion rate of soluble starch as model cellulose was determined using high-performance anion exchange chromatography–pulsed amperometric detection analysis of glucose as the major digestion product. The most effective digestion rate (80% within 4?h) was obtained with Viscozyme®. This enzyme mixture was applied to extracted arsenic species from algae and terrestrial plant materials. Qualitative and quantitative differences in the results between enzyme-assisted and water extractions were obtained and discussed. The results show that the application of enzymes in mild extraction protocols should be evaluated as an additional step for the identification of As-metabolics in organisms. Careful selection of suitable enzyme mixtures can overcome the disadvantage that extraction efficiency is very organism-specific.     

海湾河口表层沉积物中重金属形态连续萃取方法的优化研究

采用单一萃取程序对建立的重金属形态连续萃取方法的萃取条件进行优化.分别以Ca和Mg、Fe、有机质(OM)和酸可挥发性硫(AVS)作为萃取剂释放酸溶态、还原态、有机质结合态和硫化物结合态等重金属目标形态的表征参量,考察萃取剂对相应目标形态的萃取能力和选择性.分别根据表征参量和重金属在萃取溶液中的含量变化确定最优萃取时间和萃取样液比.结果表明,优化萃取条件后,萃取剂对目标形态重金属均有很强的释放能力.酸溶态萃取剂对其它非残留态影响很小;还原态萃取剂除对酸溶态有少量提取外,对其它形态影响较小;有机质结合态萃取剂对硫化物结合态有少量萃取,对其它形态影响较小.硫化物结合态在酸溶态、还原态和有机质结合态之后萃取,避免了对这三种形态的影响.优化后的连续萃取方法对重金属形态有较好的选择性,可对海湾和河口表层沉积物中重金属的目标形态进行较为合理地分离和评价.     

Availability of caesium isotopes in vegetation estimated from incubation and extraction experiments.

A rapid and inexpensive incubation and extraction technique for estimating the available low molecular weight and potentially bioavailable fraction of Cs isotopes in vegetation has been developed. Samples of contaminated vegetation (grass, herbage and fungi) and litter were exposed to rumen liquid from sheep, by in vitro incubation or by placing nylon bags in the rumen of sheep (in sacco). The results were compared with laboratory extractions using rumen buffer, NH4OAc, CsCl and de-ionized water. The release of low molecular weight 137Cs species after in vitro incubation with rumen liquid for 4-8 h was 75-85% for grass, herbage and fungi, 30% for lichen and 10% for litter. The reproducibility of the method was 5% for digestible matrices and 10-20% for litter where the fraction of Cs isotopes released was small. Extractions with NH4OAc and CsCl released 75 and 80% of the Cs isotopes in grass, respectively. Significantly lower extraction yields were obtained with de-ionized water and buffer. During in sacco incubation, 90-100% of the Cs isotopes in vegetation was released within 1 h; however, potentially available low molecular weight forms and Cs-bearing colloidal material could not be differentiated. The results obtained by incubation with rumen liquid and by extraction with NH4OAc or CsCl were in good agreement with published data from a 3 week feeding trial. For practical reasons extraction with NH4OAc or CsCl rather than incubation with rumen liquid is recommended for estimating the fraction of available low molecular weight Cs species.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Partition and determination of cadmium, copper, lead and zinc in marine suspended particulate matter

A method for the determination of Cd, Cu, Pb, and Zn in the total and acetic acid (25%) soluble fraction of suspended particulate matter collected on Nuclepore membranes is described. The acetic acid leaching was carried out in a modified Millipore vacuum filtration apparatus. The total sample and the acetic insoluble fraction were decomposed in teflon bombs with HF/aqua regia. Flame or graphite furnace AAS was used for metal determinations. Sequential acetic acid extractions (3) show that on the average 76.4-92.0% of the metals are removed with the first extraction. Cadmium is potentially most easily available to biota with 90.4% of the total metal concentration located in the acetic acid soluble fraction.     

Kinetic approach to heavy metal mobilization assessment in sediments: choose of kinetic equations and models to achieve maximum information

Studies of trace metal mobilization in sediments are generally performed using sequential extraction schemes at equilibrium. In the present work, a kinetic fractionation of trace metals in sediments has been developed to assess that information. The extraction rate data have been obtained using a single extraction scheme with EDTA and following a protocol previously optimized. Two kinetic equations and two kinetic models were used to fit the experimental data. The two constants equation fits well the extraction rate data used in this work but does not present any physico-chemical meaning. The diffusion model and the two first-order reactions model allow determining which parameter (the reaction between the metal M and the EDTA or the diffusion of the complex M/EDTA) is rate limiting in the trace metal extraction by EDTA. It appears that the two first-order reactions model is more efficient than the diffusion model to fit the present extraction rate data so it can be deduced that the diffusion of the complex M/EDTA is not the limiting step of the trace metal extraction by EDTA in estuarine sediments. In a second part, relationships between the fraction of metals determined with the two first-order reactions model and the sediments composition were established.     

Determination of ochratoxin A in foods: state-of-the-art and analytical challenges

The work presented describes the application of different analytical approaches for study of aluminium mobility in rock, soil, and sediment samples affected by mining activity (secondary quartzites with sulfidic deposits). For this purpose we used a combination of the single extractions, the optimized BCR three-step sequential extraction procedure (SEP), and reactive aluminium determination after chelating ion-exchange on Ostsorb (Iontosorb) Salicyl by a batch technique with flame atomic absorption spectrometry quantification. The single extraction agents H₂O, KCl, NH₄Cl, and BaCl₂ were found to be the best for the quantitative estimation of the aluminium mobility in rocks, soils, and sediments caused by acidification of the environment. This fact was confirmed by reactive aluminium determination in the same samples. The vast majority of the aluminium content of samples after application of the optimized BCR three-step SEP is in the residues. The available fraction of aluminium extracted by dilute CH₃COOH in the first step of this procedure correlates with the reactive aluminium content. The amounts of aluminium released in the second and the third steps and the sums from steps 1–3 of this procedure are closely associated with the aluminium content values obtained by the single dilute HCl leach. The accuracy of results obtained was verified with only informative values for individual fractions of the BCR three-step SEP because of the absence of suitable certified or standard reference materials. The amounts of the reactive aluminium determined in samples was in the range 12–82% of total soluble Al in the filtered H₂O extracts. It was confirmed that the acidified polluted samples contain the most of reactive Al content, which is responsible for its toxicity.     

Resolution of uncertainty of a four-stage sequential extraction procedure using analysis of variance

Sequential extraction procedures are mostly applied to soils and sediments. Investigations were made for testing the applicability of a selected extraction scheme on spoil pile material. Therefore, different spoil pile samples from uranium mining were extracted into four steps (exchangeable, reducible, oxidizable, and aqua regia soluble phase) and the contents of the elements Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Ni, and Zn were analyzed. To substitute the sequential extraction by a sequence of single extractions and thus keep uncertainties of extraction on a low level, both procedures were compared regarding conformity of their results. The effects of sample handling as well as those of analysis on the measured metal contents were determined by means of analysis of variance and sources of uncertainties were discussed.     

"Acid extractable" metal concentrations in solid matrices: a comparison and evaluation of operationally defined extraction procedures and leaching tests

Different frequently used methods to determine the influence of acid conditions on heavy metal release from soils, sediments and waste materials, namely pH_stat leaching tests and acid extractions with acetic acid (HOAc) (0.11 M and 0.43 M) and sodium acetate (NaOAc) (1 M) were compared for 30 samples (soils, sediments and waste materials) with different physico-chemical properties and a different degree of contamination. However, no distinct relationship was found between physico-chemical sample characteristics, total element concentrations and acid-extractable metal concentrations in the presented dataset.

pH played an important role in explaining the release of metals from the contaminated soils, sediments and waste materials. The pH-shift after extraction with the different acetic acid solutions (0.11 M and 0.43 M) was both explained by the initial pH of the sample and its acid neutralizing capacity. The pH of the NaOAc extract was well buffered and the release of elements from solid matrices by NaOAc was both the result of the complexation with acetate and pH (pH 5). Generally, a linear correlation was found between the amount of Zn and Cd extracted by 0.11 M HOAc, 0.43 M HOAc and 1 M NaOAc. The amounts of Zn and Cd extracted with HOAc (0.11 M and 0.43 M) were comparable with amounts of respectively Zn and Cd released during pH_stat leaching at pH 4. However, for Cu, Pb and As, it was often not possible to relate the results of a pH_stat leaching test to the results of single extractions with acetic acid solutions.     

Single and Sequential Extraction in Sediments and Soils

Abstract

The determination of extractable trace metal contents in soils and sediments is currently performed in many laboratories to assess the bioavailable metal fraction (and related potential phyto-toxic effects) and the importance and possibility of mobilization of trace metals from polluted soil, sludge and sediment upon landfill application. Single and sequential extraction schemes are used for the assessment of the different “forms” of trace metals (e.g. “mobile/bioavailable”, “carbonate-bound” etc.). The lack of uniformity in the different extraction procedures used throughout the world does not allow the results to be compared or the procedures to be validated which has led to many criticisms in the past few years. Moreover, the lack of suitable reference materials for this type of operationally defined determinations did not enable the quality of the measurements to be controlled. Owing to the need for establishing common schemes for single and sequential extractions as well as for the improvement of the quality of extractable trace metal determinations in soil and sediments, the Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) has organised a project which results along with the state of the art of extractable trace metal determinations, use and applicability of extraction schemes and analytical limitations were decided to be thoroughly discussed in a workshop. This paper presents its main conclusions.     

Evaluation of "labile" metal in sediments by anodic stripping voltammetry

A procedure for determining the "labile" metal content of contaminated sediments (in different chemical environments) has been critically examined. The sediments were extracted overnight with different chemical solutions and the suspensions were analysed by differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry. The extractants used have been recommended for soil/sediment speciation schemes, and by examination of the suspensions directly in the ASV cell, errors due to re-adsorption of released metal ion were minimized. The existence of different chemical forms of metal was signified by changes in peak shape and position or by the appearance of additional peaks. With complexing agents present the peak size was pH-dependent. The limitations of the ASV/suspension analysis technique have been carefully evaluated by using ten different extractants and seventeen sediments. The "lability" results obtained have been compared with the values obtained from a cation-exchanger transfer procedure. For characterizing the lability behaviour of the metal contents of sediments, preliminary extraction into a minimum of four base solutions is advisable, e.g., 0.02M nitric acid (low-pH labile); hydroxylamine in acetic acid (reducing conditions); acetic acid/acetate buffer (weakly sorbed and carbonate-bound) and 0.05M calcium chloride (exchangeable fraction at natural system pH), where the terms in parentheses describe the character of the fraction. The results are critically compared with those obtained by atomic-absorption analysis of the extracts and with those obtained by an earlier ion-exchange fractionation scheme. The advantages and limitations of the ASY systems are discussed.     

Chromium available fractions in arousa sediments using a modified microwave BCR protocol based on microwave assisted extraction

In a research of chromium availability, the three-stage sequential extraction procedure, proposed by European Community Bureau of Reference (BCR), has been applied for the metal fractionation in marine sediment samples. The procedure has been modified, evaluating the effect of microwave energy to perform the sequential method. Results achieved a substantial reduction in time in comparison to the traditional shaking technique. The time of the first and the second extractions were reduced to 30 s in both steps using microwave heating and working at 66 W of power. To the third extraction, higher power was necessary so it was chosen to work at 198 W. In the last step investigated, time was reduced to 1 min, being a great improvement respect to the conventional BCR sequential extraction protocol.Chromium determinations in these extracts were carried out by Electrothermal Atomic Absorption Spectrometry (ETAAS). The developed method was applied for chromium determination in marine sediment samples from Ria de Arousa (Galicia, NW of Spain). The values obtained by our laboratory ranged from 0.10 to 1.02 μg g⁻¹ for soluble and reducible fractions, and from 5.5 to 60.0 μg g⁻¹ for the oxidisable fraction. The higher concentrations obtained were the chromium associated with the organic fraction of the marine sediments.     

Design of a ruthenium(III) immobilized affinity material based on a β‐cyclodextrin‐functionalized poly(glycidyl methacrylate‐ethylene dimethacrylate) monolith for the enrichment of hippuric acid

Immobilized metal affinity chromatography has drawn great attention as a widespread separation and purification approach. In this work, ruthenium was firstly introduced into the preparation of immobilized metal affinity chromatography considering its affinity to N,O‐donor ligands. A β‐cyclodextrin‐functionalized poly(glycidyl methacrylate‐ethylene dimethacrylate) monolith was designed and employed as the supporting material in immobilized metal affinity chromatography. Thiosemicarbazide was introduced into the synthesis process, which not only acted as a bridge between β‐cyclodextrin and glycidyl methacrylate, but also chelated with ruthenium because of its mixed hard‐soft donor characteristics. The developed monolithic ruthenium(III)‐immobilized metal affinity chromatography column was utilized for the adsorption and separation of hippuric acid, a biological indicator of toluene exposure. To achieve high extraction capacity, the parameters affecting the extraction efficiency were investigated with an orthogonal experiment design, L9 (3⁴). Under the optimized conditions, the enrichment factor of hippuric acid was 16.7‐fold. The method reproducibility was investigated in terms of intra‐ and interday precisions with relative standard deviations lower than 8.7 and 9.5%, respectively. In addition, ruthenium(III)‐immobilized metal affinity chromatography material could be used for up to 80 extractions without an apparent change in extraction recovery.     

A rapid fractionation method for heavy metals in soil by continuous-flow sequential extraction assisted by focused microwaves

A microwave-assisted continuous-flow sequential extraction system was developed for rapid fractionation analysis of heavy metals in soil. Insertion of pressure-adjusted air between the extractants provided stable flows of the extractants without mutual mixing and back-pressure influence of a column packed with soil, thereby facilitating reliable continuous-flow extractions. In addition, use of pure water as a pumping solvent removed metal contamination because of direct contact between corrosive extractants and the pump containing metallic materials. Focused microwave irradiation to the soil accelerated the selective extractions of the acid-soluble and reducible fractions of heavy metals in soil in the first and second steps of the sequential extraction conditions, as defined by the Commission of the European Bureau of Reference (BCR). The microwave-assisted continuous-flow extraction provided high correlations in amounts of six heavy metals except Zn in the first step and Cu in the second step extracted from a reference sludge soil, BCR CRM 483, with a conventional batchwise extraction proposed by BCR; continuous-flow extraction assisted by conductive heating provided lower correlations for all the six metals. The proposed method drastically reduced the time required for the sequence extraction to ca. 65 min without losing accuracy and precision of the fractionation analysis of heavy metals in soil, whereas the BCR batchwise method requires ca. 33 h. An erratum to this article can be found at     

Chemical Speciation and Fractionation in Soil and Sediment Heavy Metal Analysis: A Review

Abstract

Today it is generally recognized that the particular behaviour of trace metals in the environment is determined by their specific physicochemical forms rather than by their total concentration. Several chemical speciation and fractionation methods for heavy metal analysis in soils and sediments have been and are still being developed and applied. They primarily are intended to understand the particular environmental behaviour of metals, present in a variety of forms and in a variety of matrices.

Analytical developments, modifications of existing methods, and recent new approaches are reviewed and discussed. Techniques used include chemical extractions, ion-exchange/gel chromatography, filtration, centrifugation and sieving, selective solvent extraction.

Moreover, the application of these various techniques in different research fields over the last years is explored. The value and the limitations of speciation and fractionation techniques applied in specific experimental work is outlined. It is discussed to what extent these methods have, up to now, filled in the expectations or have been satisfactory in particular applications.