Investigation into CO2 laser cleaning of titanium alloys for gas-turbine component manufacture

This paper reports results of the investigation into the feasibility of using a CO₂ laser technology to perform critical cleaning of gas-turbine aero-engine components for manufacture. It reports the results of recent trials and relates these to a thermal model of the cleaning mechanisms, and describes resultant component integrity. The paper defines the experimental conditions for the laser cleaning of various aerospace-grade contaminated titanium alloys, using a continuous wave CO₂ laser. Laser cleaning of Ti64 proved successful for electron beam welding, but not for the more sensitive Ti6246. For diffusion bonding the trials produced a defective standard of joint. Effects of oxide formation is modelled and examined experimentally.     

EU194 in the United Kingdom

This paper describes some of the results obtained in the United Kingdom within the Eureka Eurolaser Project EU194 — Industrial Applications of High-Power CO₂ Lasers. Areas selected include laser welding of aluminium alloys, in particular with respect to the tensile and formability properties of the welds produced; a new technique, involving laser beam spinning, is described for thick section cutting of mild steel using only modest laser power; a comparison of thermal cutting processes is presented in terms of the kerf widths, speed, squareness, roughness and size of heat affected zone produced; a mathematical model for the welding of thin sheet material is described. along with the results of experimental verification of the predictive capabilities of the model; and finally, laser welding of tailored blanks for application in the automotive industry is described, with examples of two particular areas where this technology might be used to advantage.     

Spectroscopic comparison of aluminium welding plasmas produced by high power CO and CO2 lasers

Welding tests on the aluminium alloy AlMgSi1 (6082) by the use of a high power CO laser with good beam quality show higher penetration depths and better weld seam quality compared with the results obtained with a commercial industrial CO₂ laser. Spectroscopy of the laser-induced welding plasma shows a strong decrease of the intensities of Al(II) lines and no appearance of Al(III) lines in CO laser aluminium welding compared with CO₂ laser welding at the same process parameters. This is a consequence of the shorter 5 to 5.6 μm wavelength of the CO laser leading to reduced beam-plasma interaction.     

Interface microstructure and mechanical properties of laser welding copper–steel dissimilar joint

Relatively the high reflectivity of copper to CO₂ laser led to the difficulty in joining copper to steel using laser welding. In this paper, a new method was proposed to complete the copper–steel laser butt welding. The scarf joint geometry was used, i.e., the sides of the copper and steel were in obtuse and acute angles, respectively. During the welding process, the laser beam was fixed on the steel side and the dilution ratio of copper to steel was controlled by properly selecting the deviation of the laser beam. The offset of laser beam depended on the scarf angle between the copper and steel, the thickness of plate and the processing parameters used in the laser welding. The microstructure near the interface between Cu plate and the intermixing zone was investigated. Experimental results showed that for the welded joint with high dilution ratio of copper, there was a transition zone with numerous filler particles near the interface. However, if the dilution ratio of copper is low, the transition zone is only generated near the upper side of the interface. At the lower side of the interface, the turbulent bursting behavior in the welding pool led to the penetration of liquid metal into Cu. The welded joint with lower dilution ratio of copper in the fusion zone exhibited higher tensile strength. On the bases of the microstructural evaluation at the interface of the welded joint, a physical model was proposed to describe the formation mechanism of the dissimilar joint with low dilution ratio of copper.     

Laser welding of low-thickness zinc-coated and uncoated carbon steel sheets

Laser welding is a competitive joining process for low-thickness plates. The speeds achieved with laser welding using a CO₂ laser and the low heat input introduced to the base material are the main advantages of this process. The widespread use of laser welding will increase the productivity and accuracy of welding operations. Nevertheless, there are still important developments to be made.The results of laser welding of thin sheets (below 1.25 mm) of uncoated and zinc-coated carbon steels are presented. A CO₂ laser was used for the welding of sheets of different thicknesses and to make dissimilar welds (carbon steel to zinc-coated steel). The bead dimensions and the distortions of the welded sheets are analysed.     

Spectroscopic, energetic and metallographic investigations of the laser lap welding of AISI 304 using the response surface methodology

Spectroscopic signals originated by the laser-induced plasma optical emission have been simultaneously investigated together with energetic and metallographic analyses of CO₂ laser welded stainless steel lap joint, using the Response Surface Methodology. This statistical approach allowed us to study the influence of the laser beam power and the laser welding speed on the following response parameters: plasma plume electron temperature, joint penetration depth and melted area. A clear correlation has been found between all the investigated response parameters. The results have been shown to be consistent with quantitative considerations on the energy supplied to the workpiece as far as the laser power and travel speed were varied. The regression model obtained in this way could be a valuable starting point to develop a closed loop control of the weld penetration depth and the melted area in the investigated process window.     

Comparison of mechanisms and effects of Nd:YAG and CO2 laser cleaning of titanium alloys

The paper compares laser cleaning trials performed using a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser, λ = 1.064 μm and a continuous wave (CW) CO₂ laser, λ = 10.6 μm, applied to aerospace-grade, contaminated titanium alloys. The mechanisms for cleaning using each laser system are modelled to determine the mode and extent of contaminant removal. The model results are then compared with the surface chemistry and micro-structural results from the cleaning trials performed. The results show the dominant cleaning process for Nd:YAG cleaning to be by evaporation of the contaminant via conduction through surface heating, while for CO₂ laser cleaning the small fraction of the beam coupling directly with the contaminant is sufficient for direct heating and selective evaporation. The results for experimental cleaning, electron beam (EB) welding and diffusion bonding align well with the model, particularly when secondary reactions are taken into account.     

The use of Taguchi method to optimize the laser welding of sealing neuro-stimulator

Titanium has high strength-to-weight ratio, corrosion resistance, excellent weldability and well biocompatibility. It is applied in various fields, such as medical and aerospace industry. Laser welding is major joint technology for titanium sealing in medical field. It is difficult for sealing thin titanium shell of the neuro-stimulator by laser lap welding. The key point for welding quality is the combination of laser welding parameters. In this paper, the effects of the Nd: YAG laser welding parameters is discussed and analyzed at first, and then a novel application of Taguchi's matrix method is proposed to optimize the selection of laser seal welding thin titanium shell, including the main parameters such as laser power, welding speed, defocusing amount and shield gas, finally the manufacture process for sealing neuro-stimulator is confirmed. The results show that Taguchi method has optimized process parameters of the laser welding on sealing thin titanium shell of the neuro-stimulator, and the device is equipped properly in medical treatments.     

Sheet metal welding using a pulsed Nd: YAG laser-robot

This paper presents a pulsed Nd: YAG laser-robot system for spot and seam welding of mild steel sheets. The study evaluates the laser beams behaviour for welding, and then investigates pulsed Nd: YAG laser spot and seam welding processes. High pulse power intensity is needed to initiate the key-hole welding process and a threshold pulse energy to reach full penetration. In seam welding, a weld consists of successive overlapping spots. Both high pulse energy and high average power are needed to keep the key-hole welding going. A 70% overlap is used to define overlapping spot welding as seam welding and to optimize process parameters because a high tensile strength joint compatible with the strength of the base material can be obtained when the overlap is ≥70%; at the same time a smooth seam with full penetration is obtained. In these cases, the joints in pulsed Nd: YAG laser welding are comparable in strength to those obtained with CO₂ laser welding. Robot positioning and motion accuracies can meet the demands of Nd: YAG laser sheet metal welding, but its cornering accuracy affects the welding processes. The purpose of the study is to evaluate the YAG laser-robot system for production in the automotive industry.     

Laser welding of steels for power plant

Many welding applications in CEGB power plant involve components with wall thicknesses in the range 2–10 mm. Therefore, an investigation into the feasibility of laser welding types 316, 310 and DUCOL W30 steels in 6 mm thick plate has been made, the materials being typical of those used in CEGB power plant.The welds were made using the high power, transverse flow, CO₂ laser based at UKAEA Culham Laboratory. The laser welding process used has been compared with TIG (tungsten inert gas), plasma and electron beam using capital cost, power requirement, ease of handling and distortion in workpieces as the criteria for comparison. Possible applications of laser welding to power plant manufacture are discussed.     

Using Taguchi method to optimize welding pool of dissimilar laser-welded components

In the present work, CO₂ continuous laser welding process was successfully applied and optimized for joining a dissimilar AISI 316 stainless-steel and AISI 1009 low carbon steel plates. Laser power, welding speed and defocusing distance combinations were carefully selected with the objective of producing welded joint with complete penetration, minimum fusion zone size and acceptable welding profile. Fusion zone area and shape of dissimilar austenitic stainless-steel with ferritic low carbon steel were evaluated as a function of the selected laser welding parameters. Taguchi approach was used as statistical design of experiment (DOE) technique for optimizing the selected welding parameters in terms of minimizing the fusion zone. Mathematical models were developed to describe the influence of the selected parameters on the fusion zone area and shape, to predict its value within the limits of the variables being studied. The result indicates that the developed models can predict the responses satisfactorily.     

Analysis of hybrid Nd:Yag laser-MAG arc welding processes

In the hybrid laser-arc welding process, a laser beam and an electric arc are coupled in order to combine the advantages of both processes: high welding speed, low thermal load and high depth penetration thanks to the laser; less demanding on joint preparation/fit-up, typical of arc welding. Thus the hybrid laser-MIG/MAG (Metal Inert or Active Gas) arc welding has very interesting properties: the improvement of productivity results in higher welding speeds, thicker welded materials, joint fit-up allowance, better stability of molten pool and improvement of joint metallurgical quality. The understanding of the main relevant involved physical processes are therefore necessary if one wants for example elaborate adequate simulations of this process. Also, for an efficient use of this process, it is necessary to precisely understand the complex physical phenomena that govern this welding technique. This paper investigates the analysis of the effect of the main operating parameters for the laser alone, MAG alone and hybrid Laser/MAG welding processes. The use of a high speed video camera allows us to precisely characterize the melt pool 3D geometry such as the measurements of its depression and its length and the phenomena occurring inside the melt pool through keyhole-melt pool-droplet interaction. These experimental results will form a database that is used for the validation of a three-dimensional thermal model of the hybrid welding process for a rather wide range of operating parameters where the 3-D geometry of the melt pool is taken into account.     

Optimization of laser welding of DP/TRIP steel sheets using statistical approach

Generally, the quality of a weld joint is directly influenced by the welding input parameter settings. Selection of proper process parameters is important to obtain the desired weld bead profile and quality. In this research work, numerical and graphical optimization techniques of the CO₂ laser beam welding of dual phase (DP600)/transformation induced plasticity (TRIP700) steel sheets were carried out using response surface methodology (RSM) based on Box–Behnken design. The procedure was established to improve the weld quality, increase the productivity and minimize the total operation cost by considering the welding parameters range of laser power (2–2.2 kW), welding speed (40–50 mm/s) and focus position (?1 to 0 mm). It was found that, RSM can be considered as a powerful tool in experimental welding optimization, even when the experimenter does not have a model for the process. Strong, efficient and low cost weld joints could be achieved using the optimum welding conditions.     

High-speed laser cutting of superposed thermoplastic films: thermal modeling and process characterization

Common thermoplastic films used in the packaging industry have a thickness lower than 100 μm, and present low absorption to CO₂ laser radiation. This characteristic renders the use of cutting parameters, predicted by models developed for thicker thermoplastics inappropriate. In addition, the usual procedures involve the use of an assisting gas, responsible for removing the melted material, which, when processing thin films, induces changes in position in the material. A new theoretical model describing the temperature distribution on thin thermoplastic material during laser cutting was later developed. The heat conduction was solved analytically by the Green function method and heating and cooling thermal stress evolution was taken into consideration. The laser beam diameter over the samples provides the possibility of obtaining two cut operations: a simple cut, on beam focus, and a cut with welding, defocusing the beam. Engineering parameters predicted by the model were applied to cutting superposed high- and low-density polyethylene and polypropylene samples, transparent and white, with thicknesses between 10 and 100 μm, and experimentally validated.Proper modeling and the introduction of a reflective substrate under the samples allowed the improvement of process efficiency and the achievement of cutting operations up to 20 m s⁻¹, and cut with welding up to 14 m s⁻¹; an order of magnitude of improvement on industrial speeds previously attained for this operation.     

Study of magnesium and aluminum alloys absorption coefficient during Nd:YAG laser interaction

In laser processes, the absorption factor of laser Nd:YAG by metals plays a very important role. In order to model laser welding, we need to know its evolution during the process. The theoretical calculation does not enable the prediction of the absorption factor in the case of a keyhole mode. It is difficult to predict the effect of plasma and recoil pressure on the shape of the keyhole. In this paper, an integrating sphere is used to determine the absorption factor during the laser process, which is carried out on two types of magnesium alloys (WE43 and RZ5) and an aluminum alloy. We obtain the evolution in time of the absorption factor according to different steps of the evolution of the keyhole.     

Experimental study of temperature and clamping force during Nd:YAG laser butt welding

During welding, a high quality clamping device not only holds workpieces firmly together, but should also take the thermal strain of the welding heat without undermining the strength of the weld joint, inducing any excessive distortions, misalignment of workpieces or reducing the weld joint strength. This paper studies the clamping force during laser butt welding of steel workpieces. The clamping force and welding temperature for a butt welded joint during laser welding are measured simultaneously. The preset clamping force is varied during welding for different thicknesses of workpieces and weld joint strengths. The thermal expansion, cooling contraction, and workpiece width reduction during welding induce variations in the preset clamping force and consequently change the weld joint strength. Our study also reveals that there is an optimal preset clamping force that improves the weld joint strength significantly and the welding temperature during steady welding process remains unchanged for any preset clamping force.     

Interaction of CO2 laser radiation with glasses

An illustration of an interaction of pulsed multimode TEA CO₂ laser radiation, through or without a mask, as well as of a laser scanning process of a frequency Q-modulated cw CO₂ laser beam on glass surfaces has been shown. As an object of investigation glass articles with composition as a standard industrial potassium-boron silicate glass, we have used. A complex of investigations shows that the laser treatment leads to qualitative constant changes (well defined peeling structure) depending on the time surface treatment, defocusing and the pulse length of the laser output.     

Research on laser welding of vehicle body

Based on many experiments of CO₂ laser welding of vehicle body, joint microstructure and stress–strain curve of specimen are analyzed. The deep punching performance acquired by adopting Ar as protective gas is better than that of the one acquired by adopting N₂ as protective gas. Meanwhile the percentage of zinc in welding seam can be effectively controlled by means of blowing side protective gas. In this paper, welding penetration and width are shown to vary with laser power and speed of welding. The results indicate that some flaws such as gas hole, crack and softening of HAZ do not appear in laser welding seam in sheet steel of automobile bodies if technology parameters optimizes. The deep punching performance of tailor-welding sheet is fine.     

Effects of temperature-dependent material properties and shielding gas on molten pool formation during continuous laser welding of AZ91 magnesium alloy

Laser welding processes are widely used for fabrications in many engineering applications such as aerospace and automotives. In this paper, a moving distributed heat source model based on Goldak's method [1] has been implemented into finite volume thermal simulations in order to predict temperature distributions during the welding process of a magnesium alloy and to study the effects of variations in thermal properties, absorption coefficient and gas shielding on the computed temperature distributions and weld pool dimensions. The main conclusion is the significant effects of varying the thermal conductivity and absorption coefficient of magnesium. Also, it has been seen that the shielding gas, besides its main role of protection against oxidation, has a significant effect on the width of the weld pool. Finally, the obtained results have been compared to the experimental ones and a satisfactory correlation has been observed, indicating the reliability of the model developed in this study.     

Diode laser welding of ABS: Experiments and process modeling

The laser beam weldability of acrylonitrile/butadiene/styrene (ABS) plates is determined by combining both experimental and theoretical aspects. In modeling the process, an optical model is used to determine how the laser beam is attenuated by the first material and to obtain the laser beam profile at the interface. Using this information as the input data to a thermal model, the evolution of the temperature field within the two components can be estimated. The thermal model is based on the first principles of heat transfer and utilizes the temperature variation laws of material properties. Corroborating the numerical results with the experimental results, some important insights concerning the fundamental phenomena that govern the process could be extracted. This approach proved to be an efficient tool in determining the weldability of polimeric materials and assures a significant reduction of time and costs with the experimental exploration.