Actin-binding marine macrolides: total synthesis and biological importance

Marine organisms produce a fascinating range of structurally diverse secondary metabolites, which often possess unusual and sometimes unexpected biological activities. This structural diversity makes these marine natural products excellent molecular probes for the investigation of biochemical pathways. Recently, a number of novel and stereochemically complex macrolides, having a large macrolactone (22- to 44-membered) ring, that interact with the actin cycloskeleton have been isolated from different marine sources. Actin, like tubulin, is a major component of the cytoskeleton and has important cellular functions. Although the details of these interactions are still under investigation, these marine macrolides are becoming increasingly important as novel molecular probes to help elucidate the cellular functions of actin. Owing to their potent antitumor activities, these compounds, for example the aplyronines, also have potential for preclinical development in cancer chemotherapy. Their appealing molecular structures, with an abundance of stereochemistry, and biological significance, coupled with the extremely limited availability from the marine sources, have stimulated enormous interest in the synthesis of these compounds. This review summarizes the biological properties of these unusual marine natural products and features the recently completed total syntheses of swinholide A, scytophycin C, aplyronine A, mycalolide A--all of these being potent cytotoxic agents that target actin--and a diastereoisomer of ulapualide A. Rather than detailing each individual step of these multistep total syntheses, the different synthetic strategies, key reactions, and methods adopted for controlling the stereochemistry are compared.     

Total synthesis and biological assessment of (-)-exiguolide and analogues

We describe herein an enantioselective total synthesis of (-)-exiguolide, the natural enantiomer. The methylene bis(tetrahydropyran) substructure was efficiently synthesized by exploiting olefin cross-metathesis for the assembly of readily available acyclic segments and intramolecular oxa-conjugate cyclization and reductive etherification for the formation of the tetrahydropyran rings. The 20-membered macrocyclic framework was constructed in an efficient manner by means of Julia-Kocienski coupling and Yamaguchi macrolactonization. Finally, the (E,Z,E)-triene side chain was introduced stereoselectively via Suzuki-Miyaura coupling to complete the total synthesis. Assessment of the growth inhibitory activity of synthetic (-)-exiguolide against a panel of human cancer cell lines elucidated for the first time that this natural product is an effective antiproliferative agent against the NCI-H460 human lung large cell carcinoma and the A549 human lung adenocarcinoma cell lines. Moreover, we have investigated structure-activity relationships of (-)-exiguolide, which elucidated that the C5-methoxycarbonylmethylidene group and the length of the side chain are important for the potent activity.     

A diverted total synthesis of mycolactone analogues: an insight into Buruli ulcer toxins

Mycolactones are complex macrolides responsible for a severe necrotizing skin disease called Buruli ulcer. Deciphering their functional interactions is of fundamental importance for the understanding, and ultimately, the control of this devastating mycobacterial infection. We report herein a diverted total synthesis approach of mycolactones analogues and provide the first insights into their structure-activity relationship based on cytopathic assays on L929 fibroblasts. The lowest concentration inducing a cytopathic effect was determined for selected analogues, allowing a clear picture to emerge by comparison with the natural toxins.     

Probing the biology of natural products: molecular editing by diverted total synthesis

The systematic modification of natural products through diverted total synthesis is a powerful concept for the systematic modification of natural products with the aim of studying mechanistic aspects of their biological activity. This concept offers far-reaching opportunities for discovery at the interface of biology and chemistry. It is underpinned by the power of chemical synthesis, which manifests itself in the ability to modify structure at will. Its implementation, when combined with innovative design, enables the preparation of unique mechanistic probes that can be decisive in differentiating and validating biological hypotheses at the molecular level. This Review assembles a collection of classic and current cases that illustrate and underscore the scientific possibilities for practitioners of chemical synthesis.     

Diverted total synthesis of melodorinol analogues and evaluation of their cytotoxicity

A series of melodorinol analogues were synthesized via a diverted total synthesis approach, leading to structural modifications on several regions of the molecule. Their cytotoxicity was evaluated against five human cancer cell lines (KB, HeLa-S3, MCF-7, HT-29 and A549). Structure-activity relationship studies revealed key parameters that affect the cytotoxicity. In particular, the novel 4-bromo-furanone analogues exhibited greater cytotoxicity compared to the corresponding non-brominated analogues. The stereochemistry at C-6 and the nature of acyl substituents on the C-6 and C-7 hydroxyl groups also play an important role. The most potent analogues exhibit approximately 15-fold higher cytotoxicity towards KB and HeLa-S3 than melodorinol and also show exceptionally high potency against MCF-7, HT-29 and A549 cell lines.     

Diverted total synthesis and biological evaluation of gambierol analogues: elucidation of crucial structural elements for potent toxicity

Gambierol is a polycyclic ether toxin, which has been isolated from the marine dinoflagellate Gambierdiscus toxicus. A series of gambierol analogues have been prepared from an advanced intermediate of our total synthesis of gambierol and investigated for their toxicity against mice, thus providing the first systematic structure-activity relationships (SAR) of this polycyclic ether class of marine toxin. The SAR studies described herein clearly indicate that 1) the C28=C29 double bond within the H ring and the unsaturated side chain are the crucial structural elements required for exerting potent biological activity and 2) the C1 and C6 hydroxy groups, the C30 methyl group, and the C37=C38 double bond have little influence on the degree of neurotoxicity against mice.     

Synthesis and Molecular Editing of Callyspongiolide,Part 1: The Alkyne Metathesis/trans-Reduction Strategy

A path-scouting investigation into the highly cytotoxic marine macrolide callyspongiolide is reported that capitalizes on the selective formation of the C10−C11 alkene site. While the closure of the macrocycle by ring closing alkyne metathesis (RCAM) with the aid of a molybdenum alkylidyne complex was high yielding, the envisaged semi-reduction of the cycloalkyne to the corresponding E-alkene proved challenging. The reasons are likely steric in origin, in that the methyl branches on either side of the alkyne seem to prevent effective coordination of the substrate to the ruthenium catalyst, which must carry a bulky Cp* ligand to ensure high trans-selectivity. This notion is supported by the preparation of a callyspongiolide analogue, in which the two methyl groups in question are excised; its formation by RCAM followed by trans-hydrostannation/proto-destannation was straightforward. In parallel work the formation of the fully functional building block 54 showed that the presence of an unprotected -OH group allows even hindered substrates to be processed: the protic group adjacent to the triple bond engages with a chloride ligand on the ruthenium catalyst in hydrogen bonding and hence assists in substrate binding. Moreover, the preparation of an alkynylogous callyspongiolide analogue is described.     

Total Synthesis,Stereochemical Revision,and Biological Reassessment of Mandelalide A: Chemical Mimicry of Intrafamily Relationships

Mandelalide A and three congeners had recently been isolated as the supposedly highly cytotoxic principles of an ascidian collected off the South African coastline. Since these compounds are hardly available from the natural source, a concise synthesis route was developed, targeting structure 1 as the purported representation of mandelalide A. The sequence involves an iridium‐catalyzed two‐directional Krische allylation and a cobalt‐catalyzed carbonylative epoxide opening as entry points for the preparation of the major building blocks. The final stages feature the first implementation of terminal acetylene metathesis into natural product total synthesis, which is remarkable in that this class of substrates had been beyond the reach of alkyne metathesis for decades. Synthetic 1 , however, proved not to be identical with the natural product. In an attempt to clarify this issue, NMR spectra were simulated for 20 conceivable diastereomers by using DFT followed by DP4 analysis; however, this did not provide a reliable assignment either. The puzzle was ultimately solved by the preparation of three diastereomers, of which compound 6 proved identical with mandelalide A in all analytical and spectroscopic regards. As the entire “northern sector” about the tetrahydrofuran ring in 6 shows the opposite configuration of what had originally been assigned, it is highly likely that the stereostructures of the sister compounds mandelalides B–D must be corrected analogously; we propose that these natural products are accurately represented by structures 68 – 70 . In an attempt to prove this reassignment, an entry into mandelalides C and D was sought by subjecting an advanced intermediate of the synthesis of 6 to a largely unprecedented intramolecular Morita–Baylis–Hillman reaction, which furnished the γ‐lactone derivative 74 as a mixture of diastereomers. Whereas (24R)‐ 74 was amenable to a hydroxyl‐directed dihydroxylation by using OsO₄/TMEDA as the reagent, the sister compound (24S)‐ 74 did not follow a directed path but simply obeyed Kishi’s rule; only this unexpected escape precluded the preparation of mandelalides C and D by this route. A combined spectroscopic and computational (DFT) study showed that the reasons for this strikingly different behavior of the two diastereomers of 74 are rooted in their conformational peculiarities. This aspect apart, our results show that the OsO₄/TMEDA complex reacts preferentially with electron deficient double bonds even if other alkenes are present that are more electron rich and less encumbered. Finally, in a brief biological survey authentic mandelalide A ( 6 ) was found to exhibit appreciable cytotoxicity only against one out of three tested human cancer cell lines and all synthetic congeners were hardly active. No significant fungicidal properties were observed.     

Apoptolidin A: total synthesis and partially glycosylated analogues

The total synthesis of apoptolidin A is described employing an early glycosylation strategy. Strategic disconnections were chosen between C11-C12 (cross-coupling) and C19O-C1 (macrocyclization). The cis-selective glycosylation at C9-OH was achieved with the new SIBA protective group at O2/O3 of the L-glucose residue. Auxiliary substitutents at the 2-position of the 2-deoxy sugars were applied to form selectively the glycosidic linkages of the C27 disaccharide. The cross-coupling of the glycosylated northern half with the glycosylated southern half was achieved with CuI-thiophene carboxylate. The macrocyclization of a trihydroxy carboxylic acid produced the 20-membered macrolide selectively. H2SiF6 was suitable for the final deprotection of the silyl ethers and the conversion of the C21 methylketal into the hemiketal. The synthetic flexibility of the approach was proven by the synthesis of some glycovariants.     

Total synthesis and biological evaluation of (-)apicularen A and analogues thereof

Apicularen A (1) and related benzolactone acylenamines belong to a growing class of novel natural products possessing highly cytotoxic properties. The challenging structure of 1 includes a 10-membered macrolactone ring, a tetrahydropyran system, an o,m-substituted phenol and a doubly unsaturated acyl group attached on the side chain enamine functionality. The total synthesis of apicularen A described herein involves a strategy equivalent to its proposed biosynthesis and entails a reiterative two-step procedure featuring allylation and ozonolytic cleavage to grow the molecule's chain by one acetate unit at a time. The developed synthetic technology was applied to the construction of a series of apicularen A analogues whose biological evaluation established a set of structure-activity relationships in this new area of potential importance in cancer chemotherapy.     

Design, synthesis, and biological properties of highly potent tubulysin D analogues

Ten analogues of tubulysin D were synthesized and assayed against established mammalian cell lines, including cancer cells measuring inhibition of cell growth by an MTT assay. These experiments establish for the first time the essential features for the potent cytotoxicity of tubulysin D. The activities of analogues 2 to 5 demonstrate that numerous modifications may be introduced at the C-terminus of the natural product with only modest loss in activity, while the activities of analogues 6 to 8 suggest that a basic amine must be present at the N-terminus to maintain activity. Most surprisingly, analogue 10 establishes that replacement of the chemically labile O-acyl N,O-acetal with the stable N-methyl group results in almost no loss in activity. In aggregate, these structure-activity relationships enable the design of analogues such as 11 that are smaller and considerably more stable than tubulysin D but that maintain most of its potent cell-growth inhibitory activity.     

Total synthesis and biological evaluation of the protein phosphatase 2A inhibitor cytostatin and analogues

The total synthesis of the natural product cytostatin is described which inhibits protein phosphatase 2A. Cytostatin has anti-metastatic properties and induces apoptosis. On the basis of this synthesis the relative and absolute configuration of cytostatin could be assigned. Key structural elements of cytostatin are an alpha,beta-unsaturated lactone group and a side chain embodying a phosphate and a rather unstable (Z,Z,E)-triene subunit. In addition, the natural product carries six stereocenters. For the construction of the stereocenters reagent-controlled transformations were used in order to ensure maximum stereochemical flexibility. The Evans syn-aldol reaction was chosen to establish the stereochemistry at C-4, C-5, C-9 and C-10; C-6 was introduced by means of the Evans asymmetric alkylation. In all cases the same chiral auxiliary was employed as stereodirecting group. The stereocenter at C-11 was established by an asymmetric reduction using CBS-oxazaborolidine. Temporary protection of the phosphate group was achieved best by using the base-labile 9-fluorenylmethyl group, which could be cleanly cleaved by an excess of triethylamine; this reaction yielded analytically pure phosphates after a simple aqueous work-up. The (Z,Z,E)-triene embodied in cytostatin was synthesized by means of a Stille coupling as key transformation. The synthesis sequence established in this way readily gave access to a series of analogues with simplified structure. Initial biological testing of these analogues proved that the alpha,beta-unsaturated lactone, the C-11-hydroxy group and a fully deprotected phosphate moiety at C-9 are essential for the PP2A-inhibitory activity of cytostatin. The rather unstable triene moiety in the side chain can be replaced by other lipophilic residues with only moderate decrease of biological activity. Other phosphatases, that is, PP1, VHR, PTP1B, CD45, were not inhibited by cytostatin or any of the analogues, demonstrating the high selectivity of this compound. These findings will be useful for the design and synthesis of cytostatin-derived chemical tools for the study of biological processes influenced by PP2A.     

Solid-phase synthesis and biological activity of a combinatorial cross-conjugated dienone library

The solid-phase synthesis of a combinatorial cross-conjugated dienone library based on the structure of clavulones and their biological activity are reported. Clavulones are a family of marine prostanoids, and are composed of a cross-conjugated dienone system bearing two alkyl side-chains. The cross-conjugated dienone system irreversibly reacted with two nucleophiles. Our strategy for the solid-phase synthesis of the cross-conjugated dienones involves the Sonogashira-coupling reaction of a solid-supported cyclopentenone 10 bearing an acetylene group, followed by aldol condensation with aldehydes. The diphenyl derivative 7 aA was prepared from the solid-supported cyclopentenone 10 in 56% total yield. Combinatorial synthesis of a small library using twelve halides and eight aldehydes resulted in the production of 74 desired compounds from 98 candidates, and were detected by their mass spectra. Antiproliferative effects of the crude compounds against HeLaS3 cells showed that eleven samples showed strong antitumor activity (IC50<0.05 microM). Further biological examination of four purified compounds by using five tumor cell lines (A549, HeLaS3, MCF7, TMF1, and P388) revealed strong cytotoxicity comparable to that of adriamycin.