Progress of prompt gamma activation analysis in Korea

Summary The new PGAA facility using diffracted neutron beam was developed in Korea. The basic characteristics of the facility were studied in detail. A general formalism of the k₀ factor as extended to non-1/v absorber and arbitrary neutron spectrum was discussed and the actual data for Cd, Sm, Eu, Gd have been measured and determined successfully owing to the simple nature of the diffracted neutron spectrum. The k₀ factors for B, N, Si, P, S and Cl were also determined and showed consistent results with previously reported ones. At an early stage, feasibility of boron concentration analysis and measurement of thermal neutron capture cross sections has been studied. The PGAA facility is now open to users. A considerable amount of beam time is already dedicated to studies on the elemental analysis.     

Development and applications of <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript> based NAA and prompt gamma-ray NAA methods at BARC

A summary of k ₀-based R&D work on neutron activation analysis (NAA), internal mono standard NAA (IM-NAA) and prompt gamma-ray NAA (PGNAA) is presented. The k ₀-based NAA was standardized by characterizing irradiation sites of research reactors, validated using reference materials and applied to samples of different origin. Recently IM-NAA method was developed, validated for small and large size samples and applied for the analysis of large size as well as non-standard geometry samples. Studies on PGNAA included characterization of neutron beam, determinations of detection efficiency and prompt k ₀-factors, and analytical applications.     

Measurement and evaluation of k0 factors for PGA at JAERI

In order to determine multiple elements by k ₀ standardization-based neutron induced prompt gamma-ray analysis (PGA), measurements and evaluation of k ₀ factors for the elements have been performed. The k ₀ factors using Cl as a comparator for 27 elements, which are effective for the analysis by PGA, were measured with precision almost less than 3% using the cold and thermal guided neutron beams at JRR-3M. The accuracy of the k ₀ factors were better than 10% except for the non-1/v elements of Cd and Sm. Neutron spectrum correction is necessary for common use of k ₀ factors of the non-1/v elements.     

Determination of <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>-values for some elements in neutron capture gamma-ray for prompt gamma activation analysis

Exploration and modification of data for k ₀-PGAA (prompt γ-ray activation analysis) values used as standards for k ₀ standardization are needed. An integrated system has been installed and calibrated in Hot Laboratories Center for PGAA, using ²⁵²Cf isotopic neutron source with neutron flux of 6.16E8 n/cm² s. The prompt k ₀-factors of about 12 elements were determined versus the 1951.1 keV γ-ray of the ³⁵Cl, as well as analyzing crude oil and oil product samples. The concentrations of the elements in crude oil H, B, Mg, Al, Na, Si, P, S, Cl, V and Cd were 1.18E5, 0.084, 5.48E2, 8.45E2 4.88E2, 1.62E2, 3.72E2, 8.2, 144.3, 393 and 209.2 ppm while in oil product samples were 1.32E5, 5.87, 4.56E2, 4.22E2, 7.16E3, 699, 157, 8.74, 492.3, 61 and 198.2 ppm. Validation of the k ₀-PGAA was applied in analyzing standard IAEA reference material (soil-7) which give good agreement with the literature data. The ²⁵²Cf neutron beam in radiation position was characterized by the cadmium-ratio method, and found that the cadmium ratio (f), was 160.     

The recommended k0-factors for neutron-induced prompt gamma-ray analysis and the prompt gamma-ray emission probabilities

Recommended k ₀-factors for gamma-lines of 24 elements useful for neutron-induced prompt gamma-ray analysis (PGA) and which are not influenced by neutron spectrum differences were obtained from the k ₀-factors measured with the cold and thermal neutron guided beams of JRR-3M, by statistical calculation. The prompt gamma-ray emission probabilities were derived from the recommended k ₀-factors using atomic weight, isotopic abundance and thermal neutron capture cross section all related to the k ₀-factors, for which one can obtain accurate data. The derived gamma-ray emission probabilities for the light elements (H to Ca) agreed well within ±10% with those of the ENSDF values, which reflect recent data while the agreement for heavy elements (Ti to Pb) was ±40% with those of the ENSDF, which are still composed of old data. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Prompt-gamma activation analysis using thek 0 approach

Applying thek ₀ standardization method to prompt-gamma activation analysis (PGAA) offers similar benefits as in instrumental neutron activation analysis. It has been demonstrated that under constant flux conditionsk ₀-factors obtained by normalizing to a titanium comparator, measured separately, yield consistent analytical sensitivity ratios. The ratio method has been generalized by using stoichiometric compounds for the determination ofk ₀-factors. Since chlorine forms compounds with essentially everyelement and it also serves as a detector efficiency standard,k ₀ values have been determined relative to chlorine as an internal standard for several analytically important elements in two reactor facilities: the thermal guided beam at the BRR in Budapest and the cold-neutron beams at the NBSR at NIST.     

Correction of k<Subscript>0</Subscript>-factors for non-1/v elements based on neutron spectrum measurements

Neutron spectra were measured by the time of flight method using a rotating disk chopper system in the JRR-3M prompt gamma ray analysis system. Effective g-factors for non-1/v elements such as Cd, Sm and Gd were calculated from the measured neutron spectra and the neutron cross section data, and they was used for correcting the k ₀-factors. The resulting k ₀-factors for the cold and thermal neutron beams agreed within 10%. Furthermore, the prompt gamma ray emission probabilities of Cd, Sm and Gd were derived from the corrected k ₀-factors using other relevant physical constants.     

Prompt k 0-factors and relative gamma-emission intensities for the strong non-1/v absorbers 113Cd, 149Sm, 151Eu and 155,157Gd

Prompt k ₀-factors relative to chlorine and relative g-emission intensities were determined for the strong non-1/v absorbers ¹¹³Cd, ¹⁴⁹Sm, ¹⁵¹Eu,¹⁵⁵Gd and ¹⁵⁷Gd. Measurements were performed using the SNU-KAERI prompt gamma activation analysis (PGAA) facility at the Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI). For proper experimental determination of the prompt k ₀-factors, the effective g-factor and cadmium ratio were taken into account, in consideration of the effects from the non-1/v capture cross section and neutron spectrum in the thermal and epithermal energy region. By using the actual spectrum of the neutron beam in this study, the effective g-factor was obtained by calculation, and the influence of epithermal neutrons on the capture rate was corrected by measuring the cadmium ratio for each non-1/v target isotope. The measured prompt k ₀-factors were used to check the consistency between the existing dataset of the absolute g-emission intensity and the 2200 m/s capture cross section for these isotopes.     

k0 and Comparator NAA: Influences and Interactions

A discussion is held on mutual influences and interactions between k ₀- and (relative) comparator-type NAA. Examples are given concerning: (1) the application of comparator-type NAA in the quality control/quality assurance of the IRMM-530 Al-0.1%Au neutron flux monitor developed for use in k ₀-NAA, (2) the utilization of the k ₀-method of calibration as a tool for the quality assurance of comparator-type NAA, (3) the introduction of corrections for detection efficiency and true-coincidence (of primordial importance in k ₀-NAA) in comparator-type NAA, (4) the development of k ₀-type standardization for use in prompt gamma neutron activation analysis, and (5) the renewal of insights in the traceability of k ₀- and comparator-type NAA.     

k0 Standardization Approach in Neutron-Induced Prompt Gamma-Ray Analysis at JAERI

The k ₀ standardization method has been studied and applied at JAERI for the accurate determination of multielements by neutron-induced prompt gamma-ray analysis (PGA). The k ₀ factors for 26 elements using Cl as a comparator were measured by the cold and thermal neutron guided beams of JRR-3M with an uncertainty less than 3% except for a few elements. The k ₀ factors for most elements obtained with both cold and thermal neutrons agreed within 3%, and agreed also with those measured at other cold and thermal neutron guided beams within 10%, except for a few elements. Multielement determinations in reference materials were performed using the k ₀ factors obtained to evaluate the accuracy and precision of this work.     

Reactor power dependency of the neutron flux parameters fork 0-standardization

Using the facilities of the Triga Mark III reactor at the NNRI, Mexico and the HAV-1 multipurpose monitor, the reactor power dependency for thek ₀-standardization essential neutron flux parameters as: epithermal shape factor (), thermal to epithermal ratio (f) and neutron temperature (T _n ) were experimentally obtained. Evaluation of the obtained dependencies shows that it is unnecessary to analyze the possible introduction of correction factors in thek ₀-INAA experimental results. A single experimental procedure to determine throughf is suggested.     

Standardization of NAA Using the Activation Equation and Isotope-Related Constants

A standardization method for NAA has been developed based on the activation equation and on isotope-related k _i -values that are composite nuclear constants. This approach combines the simplicity of the absolute methods with nearly the same accuracy as that obtained by the relative ones. The k _i -constants are calculated from the well measured k ₀-factors and the neutron flux is determined as with the k ₀-method. A computer program was developed for the determination of the neutron flux parameters and the concentration of the trace element. These calculations start with the measured activity of the radionuclides.     

Comparison of 14 MeV-NAA, k0-NAA and ED-XRF for air pollution bio-monitoring

In this paper the performances and the limitations of three multi-elementary analysis techniques are compared applied to a study of air pollution biomonitoring in Morocco. These techniques are: (1) 14 MeV neutron activation analysis (14 MeV-NAA), (2) thermal neutron activation analysis using the k ₀ quasi-absolute method (k ₀-NAA) and (3) energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence analysis (ED-XRF). The experimental procedures and the control of the analytical results using certified reference materials are described and discussed. The three methods were confronted for the analysis of lichens, mosses and tree-barks. The complementarity of these methods enabled us to determine 43 elements in different samples. The most suitable method for each element was selected according to the sensitivity and selectivity necessitating the minimum corrections of the matrix effects and/or the interfering reactions.     

Performance evaluation of k 0-instrumental neutron activation analysis and flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry in the characterization of various types of alloys

Certified alloys of Ni–Cu based, Fe based and Cu–Sn based were analysed by semi-absolute, standardless k ₀-instrumental neutron activation analysis (k ₀-INAA) and flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry (FAAS) aiming at evaluating their comparative performances. In k ₀-INAA measurements, the irradiations were performed at miniaturized neutron source reactor having thermal neutron flux of about 1 × 10¹² cm^?2 s^?1. The experimentally optimized parameters for INAA suggested a maximum of three irradiations for the quantification of 21 elements within 5 days. The same experiments also produced quantitative results of 13 elements not reported in the certificates of the reference materials. AAS was, however, unable to determine any of those elements. Accuracy of the two techniques was assessed by comparing their average root mean squared errors. The data analysis concluded that k ₀-INAA had better sensitivity and accuracy than FAAS.     

The application and development of k0-standardization method of neutron activation analysis at Dalat research reactor

In recent years the k ₀-NAA method has been applied and developed at the 500 kW Dalat research reactor, which includes (1) the establishment of a PC database of k ₀-NAA-related nuclear parameters, e.g., radionuclide produced, half-lives, k ₀-factors, Q ₀, _r, E _g, etc; the access to the database is able by a k ₀-NAA software or by manual; (2) the detection efficiency calibration of gamma spectrometers used in k ₀-NAA, (3) the determination of reactor neutron spectrum parameters such as a and f factors and neutron fluxes in the irradiation channels, and (4) the validation of the developed k ₀-NAA procedure by analysing some SRMs, namely Coal Fly Ash (NIST-1633b), Bovine Liver (NIST-1577b) and IAEA-Soil7. The analytical results showed the deviations between experimental and certified values were mostly less than 15% with most Z-scores lower than 2. The k ₀-NAA procedure established at the Dalat research reactor has been regarded as a reliable standardization method of NAA and as available for practical applications, in particularly for airborne particulate and crude oil samples.     

Application of prompt gamma-ray analysis and instrumental neutron activation analysis to identify the beef production distinct

We present chemometric study to identify the provenance of agricultural product, beef. Combination of instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) and prompt gamma-ray analysis (k ₀-PGA) were performed to determine 10 elements, C, H, N, S, Sm, Br, Mg, Na, K, Cl, nondestructively. We measured elemental profiles in beef samples produced from different districts in Japan, Australia and USA. In the case of PGA, k ₀-method was employed to determine the elemental concentrations. There was a difference in elemental profiles between Japanese black cattle beef and that produced in USA through principal component analysis (PCA). However, Holstein beef of Japan and that of Australia was not sufficiently grouped by the PCA modeling with the elemental data set. This is the first study to identify the provenance of beef through elemental analysis.     

The use of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis><Subscript>0</Subscript>-IAEA program in NIRR-1 NAA laboratory

The k ₀-IAEA program developed for implementation of the single comparator instrumental neutron activation analysis method (k ₀-INAA) has been used for elemental analysis with NIRR-1 irradiation and counting facilities. The existing experimental protocols for routine analysis based on the relative method were used to test the capability and reliability of the program for the analyses of geological and biological samples. The Synthetic Multi-element Standards (SMELS) types I, II and III recommended by the international k ₀ user community for the validation of k ₀-NAA method in NAA laboratories, furthermore, the following standard reference materials: NIST-1633b (Coal Fly Ash) and IAEA-336 (Lichen) were analyzed. Results obtained with the version 3.12 of the k ₀-IAEA program were found to be in good agreement with the data obtained with the established relative method using WINSPAN-2004 software. Detection limits for elemental analysis of geological and biological samples with NIRR-1 facilities are provided.     

Calibration of the irradiation channel DBVK at BER-II reactor and feasibility of applying the k0-method at this device

This work is about k ₀-INAA using unstable neutron flux for sample irradiation. Due to slow transport, each irradiation in the channel DBVK consists of three phases: stable irradiation at the final position, and two additional irradiations during travelling by exposure to an increasing neutron flux in the delivery course and to a decreasing neutron flux in the fetch course. In this work, the neutron flux distribution along this channel was calibrated and the neutron flux variation with irradiation time was calculated, making it possible to evaluate activity growth during a complete irradiation period. The feasibility of the k ₀-method was checked by analyses of four SRM-materials and three multi-element standards at three DBVK-positions. An accuracy of better than ±10% was found for nearly all determined elements in each determination.     

Direct measurement ofk o for monitor neutron activation analysis

This paper introduces the thermal column or the cold neutron guide beam of the 20 MW NBSR at the National Institute of Standards and Technology as a directk _o measurement facility. Measurement ofk _o at this facility not only produces accurate values, but avoids the additional correction factors needed in other measurement methods. Thek _o of Sb, Ag and Cr with respect to Sc as monitor have been measured and their values are comparable to values based on tabulated nuclear constants and to those measured by other researchers.     

Neutron spectrum correction of k0-factors for k0-based neutron-induced prompt gamma-ray analysis

Neutron spectrum correction has been attempted for the k₀-factors of the non-1/v elements which are affected neutron spectrum difference. Effective g-factors and Westcott g-factors, which are neutron spectrum correction factors obtained from an actual neutron spectrum and the Maxwellian distribution, respectively, for the non-1/v elements were calculated using their neutron cross section data of JENDEL-3.2. The neutron spectrum correction was made for the measured k₀-factors of the non-1/v elements such as Cd, Sm and Gd with the cold and thermal guided neutron beams of JRR-3M using the g-factors. The corrected k₀-factors between the cold and thermal neutron beams using both g-factors for both neutron beams agreed well for Cd. However, 9 to 44% deviations have been found for Sm and Gd, respectively.