The aminolysis of N-aroyl beta-lactams occurs by a concerted mechanism

N-aroyl beta-lactams are imides with exo- and endocyclic acyl centres which react with amines in aqueous solution to give the ring opened beta-lactam aminolysis product. Unlike the strongly base catalysed aminolysis of beta-lactam antiobiotics, such as penicillins and cephaloridines, the rate law for the aminolysis of N-aroyl beta-lactams is dominated by a term with a first-order dependence on amine concentration in its free base form, indicative of an uncatalysed aminolysis reaction. The second-order rate constants for this uncatalysed aminolysis of N-p-methoxybenzoyl beta-lactam with a series of substituted amines generates a Br?nsted betanuc value of +0.90. This is indicative of a large development of positive effective charge on the amine nucleophile in the transition state. Similarly, the rate constants for the reaction of 2-cyanoethylamine with substituted N-aroyl beta-lactams gives a Br?nsted betalg value of -1.03 for different amide leaving groups and is indicative of considerable change in effective charge on the leaving group in the transition state. These observations are compatible with either a late transition state for the formation of the tetrahedral intermediate of a stepwise mechanism or a concerted mechanism with simultaneous bond formation and fission in which the amide leaving group is expelled as an anion. Amide anion expulsion is also indicated by an insignificant solvent kinetic isotope effect, kH2ORNH2/kD2ORNH2, of 1.01 for the aminolysis of N-benzoyl beta-lactam with 2-methoxyethylamine. The Br?nsted betalg value decreases from -1.03 to -0.71 as the amine nucleophile is changed from 2-cyanoethylamine to propylamine. The Br?nsted betanuc value is more invariant although it changes from +0.90 to +0.85 on changing the amide leaving group from p-methoxy to p-chloro substituted. The sensitivity of the Br?nsted betanuc and betalg values to the nucleofugality of the amide leaving group and the nucleophilicity of the amine nucleophiles, respectively, indicate coupled bond formation and bond fission processes.     

Computational study of the aminolysis of esters. The reaction of methylformate with ammonia

The aminolysis of esters is a basic organic reaction considered as a model for the interaction of carbonyl group with nucleophiles. In the present computational study the different possible mechanistic pathways of the reaction are reinvestigated by applying higher level electronic structure theory, examining the general base catalysis by the nucleophile, and a more comprehensive study the solvent effect. Both the ab initio QCISD/6-31(d,p) method and density functional theory at the B3LYP/6-31G(d) level were employed to calculate the reaction pathways for the simplest model aminolysis reaction between methylformate and ammonia. Solvent effects were assessed by the PCM method. The results show that in the case of noncatalyzed aminolysis the addition/elimination stepwise mechanism involving two transition states and the concerted mechanism have very similar activation energies. However, in the case of catalyzed aminolysis by a second ammonia molecule the stepwise mechanism has a distinctly lower activation energy. All transition states in the catalyzed aminolysis are 10-17 kcal/mol lower than those for the uncatalyzed process.     

The effect of inert salts on the structure of the transition state in the SN2 reaction between thiophenoxide ion and butyl chloride

The effect of inert salts on the structure of the transition state has been determined by measuring the secondary alpha deuterium and the chlorine leaving group kinetic isotope effects for the S(N)2 reaction between n-butyl chloride and thiophenoxide ion in both methanol and DMSO. The smaller secondary alpha deuterium isotope effects and very slightly larger chlorine isotope effects found in both solvents when the inert salt is present suggests that the S(N)2 transition state is tighter and more product-like, with a shorter S-C(alpha) and very a slightly longer C(alpha)-Cl bond when the added salt is present. The salt effect on the reaction in methanol where the reacting nucleophile is the solvent-separated ion-pair complex is much greater than the salt effect on the reaction in DMSO where the reacting nucleophile is the free ion. This greater change in transition-state structure found when the inert salt is present in methanol is consistent with the solvation rule for S(N)2 reactions. The greater change in the S-C(alpha) bond is predicted by the bond strength hypothesis. A rationale for the changes found in transition-state structure when the inert salt is present is suggested for both the free-ion and the ion-pair reactions.     

Studies on the mechanism of aldehyde oxidase and xanthine oxidase

DFT calculations support a concerted mechanism for xanthine oxidase and aldehyde oxidase hydride displacement from the sp(2) carbon of 6-substituted 4-quinazolinones. The variations in transition state structure show that C-O bond formation is nearly complete in the transition state and the transition state changes are anti-Hammond with the C-H and C-O bond lengths being more product-like for the faster reactions. The C-O bond length in the transition state is around 90% formed. However, the C-H bond is only about 80% broken. This leads to a very tetrahedral transition state with an O-C-N angle of 109 degrees. Thus, while the mechanism is concerted, the antibonding orbital of the C-H bond that is broken is not directly attacked by the nucleophile and instead hydride displacement occurs after almost complete tetrahedral transition state formation. In support of this the C=N bond is lengthened in the transition state indicating that attack on the electrophilic carbon occurs by addition to the C=N bond with negative charge increasing on the nitrogen. Differences in experimental reaction rates are accurately reproduced by these calculations and tend to support this mechanism.     

The effects of sulfur substitution for the nucleophile and bridging oxygen atoms in reactions of hydroxyalkyl phosphate esters

The effects of sulfur substitution on the reactions of hydroxyalkyl phosphate esters are examined. These compounds are models for the intramolecular phosphoryl transfer reaction involved in the cleavage of the internucleotide bond in RNA. The models studied here lack the ribose ring and their conformational flexibility results in greater stability and the availability of different reaction pathways. Sulfur in the nucleophilic position shows no nucleophilic reaction at phosphorus, instead rapidly attacking at the beta carbon atom, forming thiirane with departure of a phosphomonoester. Sulfur substitution at either of the two bridging positions leads to cleavage of the diester via formation of a cyclic intermediate, but with significant rate acceleration when compared to the oxygen analogues. The bridge-substituted models react substantially slower than the analogous ribose compounds with sulfur substitution at comparable positions. Kinetic isotope effects reveal significant differences in the transition state depending on which bridging position sulfur occupies. When sulfur is in the scissile bridging position, a highly associative transition state is indicated, with a largely formed bond to the nucleophile and the scissile P-S bond is little changed. When sulfur occupies the other bridging position, the isotope effects imply a very early transition state in a concerted reaction.     

Quantum chemical studies of a model for peptide bond formation. 3. Role of magnesium cation in formation of amide and water from ammonia and glycine

The SN2 reaction between glycine and ammonia molecules with magnesium cation Mg2+ as a catalyst has been studied as a model reaction for Mg(2+)-catalyzed peptide bond formation using the ab initio Hartree-Fock molecular orbital method. As in previous studies of the uncatalyzed and amine-catalyzed reactions between glycine and ammonia, two reaction mechanisms have been examined, i.e., a two-step and a concerted reaction. The stationary points of each reaction including intermediate and transition states have been identified and free energies calculated for all geometry-optimized reaction species to determine the thermodynamics and kinetics of each reaction. Substantial decreases in free energies of activation were found for both reaction mechanisms in the Mg(2+)-catalyzed amide bond formation compared with those in the uncatalyzed and amine-catalyzed amide bond formation. The catalytic effect of the Mg2+ cation is to stabilize both the transition states and intermediate, and it is attributed to the neutralization of the developing negative charge on the electrophile and formation of a conformationally flexible nonplanar five-membered chelate ring structure.     

Determining the transition-state structure for different SN2 reactions using experimental nucleophile carbon and secondary alpha-deuterium kinetic isotope effects and theory

Nucleophile (11)C/ (14)C [ k (11)/ k (14)] and secondary alpha-deuterium [( k H/ k D) alpha] kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) were measured for the S N2 reactions between tetrabutylammonium cyanide and ethyl iodide, bromide, chloride, and tosylate in anhydrous DMSO at 20 degrees C to determine whether these isotope effects can be used to determine the structure of S N2 transition states. Interpreting the experimental KIEs in the usual fashion (i.e., that a smaller nucleophile KIE indicates the Nu-C alpha transition state bond is shorter and a smaller ( k H/ k D) alpha is found when the Nu-LG distance in the transition state is shorter) suggests that the transition state is tighter with a slightly shorter NC-C alpha bond and a much shorter C alpha-LG bond when the substrate has a poorer halogen leaving group. Theoretical calculations at the B3LYP/aug-cc-pVDZ level of theory support this conclusion. The results show that the experimental nucleophile (11)C/ (14)C KIEs can be used to determine transition-state structure in different reactions and that the usual method of interpreting these KIEs is correct. The magnitude of the experimental secondary alpha-deuterium KIE is related to the nucleophile-leaving group distance in the S N2 transition state ( R TS) for reactions with a halogen leaving group. Unfortunately, the calculated and experimental ( k H/ k D) alpha's change oppositely with leaving group ability. However, the calculated ( k H/ k D) alpha's duplicate both the trend in the KIE with leaving group ability and the magnitude of the ( k H/ k D) alpha's for the ethyl halide reactions when different scale factors are used for the high and the low energy vibrations. This suggests it is critical that different scaling factors for the low and high energy vibrations be used if one wishes to duplicate experimental ( k H/ k D) alpha's. Finally, neither the experimental nor the theoretical secondary alpha-deuterium KIEs for the ethyl tosylate reaction fit the trend found for the reactions with a halogen leaving group. This presumably is found because of the bulky (sterically hindered) leaving group in the tosylate reaction. From every prospective, the tosylate reaction is too different from the halogen reactions to be compared.     

Nucleophilic substitution reaction of benzyl benzenesulfonates with anilines in MeOH-MeCN mixtures-I : Effects of substituent and solvent on the transition-state structure

Kinetic studies on nucleophilic substitution reaction of benzyl tosylates with anilines are reported. The reaction was found to proceed via a dissociative S_N2 mechanism with less than 50 % bond formation and extensive bond breaking at the transition state. It was found that positive charge development at the benzylic carbon is substantial and para-substituent effect on the substrate is predominantly of resonance type. Bond formation is shown to be favored by a better nucleophile, by an electron withdrawing group on the substrate and by the more polar(higher MeCN content) solvent. The substrate, nucleophile and solvent were found to follow the RSP.     

Ab initio study of catalyzed and uncatalyzed amide bond formation as a model for peptide bond formation: Ammonia-Glycine reactions

As a model reaction for peptide and bond formation, the S_N2 reactions between glycine and ammonia have been studied with and without amine catalysis: using ab initio molecular-orbital methods. For each of the catalyzed and uncatalyzed reactions, two reaction mechanisms have been examined: a two-step and a concerted mechanism. The stationary points of each reaction, including intermediate and transition states, have been identified and free energies calculated for all geometry-optimized reaction species to determine the thermodynamics and kinetics of the reaction. The calculations demonstrate that a second ammonia molecule catalyzes amide bond formation, and that the two-step mechanism is more favorable than the concerted one for the catalyzed reaction, while for the uncatalyzed reaction both mechanisms are competitive.     

The effect of solvent on the structure of the transition state for the S(N)2 reaction between cyanide ion and ethyl chloride in DMSO and THF probed with six different kinetic isotope effects

The secondary alpha- and beta-deuterium, the alpha-carbon, the nucleophile carbon, the nucleophile nitrogen, and the chlorine leaving group kinetic isotope effects for the S(N)2 reaction between cyanide ion and ethyl chloride were determined in the very slightly polar solvent THF at 30 degrees C. A comparison of these KIEs with those reported earlier for the same reaction in the polar solvent DMSO shows that the transition state in THF is only slightly tighter with very slightly shorter NC-C(alpha) and C(alpha)-Cl bonds. This minor change in transition state structure does not account for the different transition structures that were earlier suggested by interpreting the experimental KIEs and the gas-phase calculations, respectively. It therefore seems unlikely that the different transition states suggested by the two methods are due to the lack of appropriate solvent modeling in the theoretical calculations. Previously it was predicted that the transition state of S(N)2 reactions where the nucleophile and the leaving group have the same charge would be unaffected by a change in solvent. The experimental KIEs support this view.     

Factors controlling the mechanism of NAD(+) non-redox reactions

β-Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD(+)) is an indispensable coenzyme or substrate for enzymes involved in catalyzing redox and non-redox reactions. ADP-ribosylating enzymes catalyze cleavage of the nicotinamide-glycosyl bond of NAD(+) and addition of a nucleophilic group from their substrate proteins to the N-ribose anomeric carbon of NAD(+). Although the role of the nicotinamide-ribose fragment in the mechanism of NAD(+) hydrolysis has been examined, the role of the doubly negatively charged, flexible, and chemically reactive NAD(+) diphosphate moiety in the reaction process has largely been neglected. Thus, the participation of the pyrophosphate group in stabilizing intra- and intermolecular interactions in the ground state and transition state has not been explored. Furthermore, the roles of other factors such as the type/nucleophilicity of the attacking nucleophile and the medium in influencing the reaction pathway have not been systematically evaluated. In this study, we endeavor to fill in these gaps and elucidate the role of these factors in controlling the NAD(+) nicotinamide-glycosyl bond cleavage. Using density functional theory combined with continuum dielectric methods, we modeled both S(N)1 and S(N)2 reaction pathways and assessed the role of the diphosphate group in stabilizing the (i) NAD(+) ground state, (ii) oxocarbocation intermediate, (iii) reaction product, and (iv) nucleophile. We also assessed the chemical nature of the attacking nucleophile and the role of the protein matrix in affecting the reaction mechanism. Our results reveal an intricate interplay among various factors in controlling the reaction pathway, which in turn suggests ways in which the enzyme can accelerate the reaction.     

Hydrogen-bonding catalysis and inhibition by simple solvents in the stereoselective kinetic epoxide-opening spirocyclization of glycal epoxides to form spiroketals

Mechanistic investigations of a MeOH-induced kinetic epoxide-opening spirocyclization of glycal epoxides have revealed dramatic, specific roles for simple solvents in hydrogen-bonding catalysis of this reaction to form spiroketal products stereoselectively with inversion of configuration at the anomeric carbon. A series of electronically tuned C1-aryl glycal epoxides was used to study the mechanism of this reaction based on differential reaction rates and inherent preferences for S(N)2 versus S(N)1 reaction manifolds. Hammett analysis of reaction kinetics with these substrates is consistent with an S(N)2 or S(N)2-like mechanism (ρ = -1.3 vs ρ = -5.1 for corresponding S(N)1 reactions of these substrates). Notably, the spirocyclization reaction is second-order dependent on MeOH, and the glycal ring oxygen is required for second-order MeOH catalysis. However, acetone cosolvent is a first-order inhibitor of the reaction. A transition state consistent with the experimental data is proposed in which one equivalent of MeOH activates the epoxide electrophile via a hydrogen bond while a second equivalent of MeOH chelates the side-chain nucleophile and glycal ring oxygen. A paradoxical previous observation that decreased MeOH concentration leads to increased competing intermolecular methyl glycoside formation is resolved by the finding that this side reaction is only first-order dependent on MeOH. This study highlights the unusual abilities of simple solvents to act as hydrogen-bonding catalysts and inhibitors in epoxide-opening reactions, providing both stereoselectivity and discrimination between competing reaction manifolds. This spirocyclization reaction provides efficient, stereocontrolled access to spiroketals that are key structural motifs in natural products.     

Entropic and enthalpic components of catalysis in the mutase and lyase activities of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PchB

The isochorismate-pyruvate lyase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PchB) catalyzes two pericyclic reactions, demonstrating the eponymous activity and also chorismate mutase activity. The thermodynamic parameters for these enzyme-catalyzed activities, as well as the uncatalyzed isochorismate decomposition, are reported from temperature dependence of k(cat) and k(uncat) data. The entropic effects do not contribute to enzyme catalysis as expected from previously reported chorismate mutase data. Indeed, an entropic penalty for the enzyme-catalyzed mutase reaction (ΔS(++) = -12.1 ± 0.6 cal/(mol K)) is comparable to that of the previously reported uncatalyzed reaction, whereas that of the enzyme-catalyzed lyase reaction (ΔS(++) = -24.3 ± 0.2 cal/(mol K)) is larger than that of the uncatalyzed lyase reaction (-15.77 ± 0.02 cal/(mol K)) documented here. With the assumption that chemistry is rate-limiting, we propose that a reactive substrate conformation is formed upon loop closure of the active site and that ordering of the loop contributes to the entropic penalty for converting the enzyme substrate complex to the transition state.     

Phosphodiester cleavage in ribonuclease H occurs via an associative two-metal-aided catalytic mechanism

Ribonuclease H (RNase H) belongs to the nucleotidyl-transferase (NT) superfamily and hydrolyzes the phosphodiester linkages that form the backbone of the RNA strand in RNA x DNA hybrids. This enzyme is implicated in replication initiation and DNA topology restoration and represents a very promising target for anti-HIV drug design. Structural information has been provided by high-resolution crystal structures of the complex RNase H/RNA x DNA from Bacillus halodurans (Bh), which reveals that two metal ions are required for formation of a catalytic active complex. Here, we use classical force field-based and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics calculations for modeling the nucleotidyl transfer reaction in RNase H, clarifying the role of the metal ions and the nature of the nucleophile (water versus hydroxide ion). During the catalysis, the two metal ions act cooperatively, facilitating nucleophile formation and stabilizing both transition state and leaving group. Importantly, the two Mg(2+) metals also support the formation of a meta-stable phosphorane intermediate along the reaction, which resembles the phosphorane intermediate structure obtained only in the debated beta-phosphoglucomutase crystal (Lahiri, S. D.; et al. Science 2003, 299 (5615), 2067-2071). The nucleophile formation (i.e., water deprotonation) can be achieved in situ, after migration of one proton from the water to the scissile phosphate in the transition state. This proton transfer is actually mediated by solvation water molecules. Due to the highly conserved nature of the enzymatic bimetal motif, these results might also be relevant for structurally similar enzymes belonging to the NT superfamily.     

Kinetics and mechanisms of hydrolysis and aminolysis of thioxocephalosporins

The effect of replacing the beta-lactam carbonyl oxygen in cephalosporins by sulfur on their reactivity has been investigated. The second-order rate constant for alkaline hydrolysis of the sulfur analogue is 2-fold less than that for the natural cephalosporin. The thioxo derivative of cephalexin, with an amino group in the C7 side chain, undergoes beta-lactam ring opening with intramolecular aminolysis by a reaction similar to that for cephalexin itself. However, the rate of intramolecular aminolysis for the S-analogue is 3 orders of magnitude greater than that for cephalexin. Furthermore, unlike cephalexin, intramolecular aminolysis in the S-analogue occurs up to pH 14 with no competitive hydrolysis. The rate of intermolecular aminolysis of natural cephalosporins is dominated by a second-order dependence on amine concentration, whereas that for thioxocephalosporins shows only a first-order term in amine. The Bronsted beta(nuc) for the aminolysis of thioxo-cephalosporin is +0.39, indicative of rate-limiting formation of the tetrahedral intermediate with an early transition state with relatively little C-N bond formation.     

Nucleophilic participation in the transition state for human thymidine phosphorylase

Recombinant human thymidine phosphorylase catalyzes the reaction of arsenate with thymidine to form thymine and 2-deoxyribose 1-arsenate, which rapidly decomposes to 2-deoxyribose and inorganic arsenate. The transition-state structure of this reaction was determined using kinetic isotope effect analysis followed by computer modeling. Experimental kinetic isotope effects were determined at physiological pH and 37 degrees C. The extent of forward commitment to catalysis was determined by pulse-chase experiments to be 0.70%. The intrinsic kinetic isotope effects for [1'-(3)H]-, [2'R-(3)H]-, [2'S-(3)H]-, [4'-(3)H]-, [5'-(3)H]-, [1'-(14)C]-, and [1-(15)N]-thymidines were determined to be 0.989 +/- 0.002, 0.974 +/- 0.002, 1.036 +/- 0.002, 1.020 +/- 0.003, 1.061 +/- 0.003, 1.139 +/- 0.005, and 1.022 +/- 0.005, respectively. A computer-generated model, based on density functional electronic structure calculations, was fit to the experimental isotope effect. The structure of the transition state confirms that human thymidine phosphorylase proceeds through an S(N)2-like transition state with bond orders of 0.50 to the thymine leaving group and 0.33 to the attacking oxygen nucleophile. The reaction differs from the dissociative transition states previously reported for N-ribosyl transferases and is the first demonstration of a nucleophilic transition state for an N-ribosyl transferase. The large primary (14)C isotope effect of 1.139 can occur only in nucleophilic displacements and is the largest (14)C primary isotope effect reported for an enzymatic reaction. A transition state structure with substantial bond order to the attacking nucleophile and leaving group is confirmed by the slightly inverse 1'-(3)H isotope effect, demonstrating that the transition state is compressed by the impinging steric bulk of the nucleophile and leaving group.     

HCN→HNC异构化反应过渡态附近的拓扑特性

电荷密度拓扑分析方法(topological analysis of charge distribution)已经被广泛应用于研究化合物的各种静态性质及反应特性.对IRC反应途径上过渡态附近构型的拓扑性质研究报导较少.本工作是用电荷密度分布的拓扑分析方法对HCN→HNC异构化反应IRC过渡态附近的性质进行了研究.对电荷密度分布拓扑分析和IRC途径确定选用相同的基组,得到了一些新的结论。     

Reactions of [aryloxy(phenyl)carbene]pentacarbonylchromium(0) complexes with thiolate ions. Decreasing reactivity with increasing basicity of the nucleophile

A kinetic study of the reactions of thiolate ions with three Fischer-type [aryloxy(phenyl)carbene]pentacarbonyl chromium(0) complexes in 50% MeCN-50% water (v/v) is reported. Br?nsted plots of the second-order rate constants are biphasic with an initial steep rise for weakly basic thiolate ions (beta(nuc) approximately equal to 1.0) followed by a slightly descending leg with a negative slope (beta(nuc) approximately equal to -0.2) for strongly basic thiolate ions. This indicates a change from rate-limiting leaving group departure at low pK(RSH)(a) to rate-limiting nucleophilic attachment at high pK(RSH)(a). The negative beta(nuc) values result from a combination of minimal progress of C-S bond formation at the transition state and the requirement for partial desolvation of the nucleophile before it enters the transition state. Possible factors that may affect the degree of bond formation in reactions of Fischer carbene complexes as well as reactions of other unsaturated electrophiles with thiolate ions are discussed.     

Mechanisms of nucleophilic reactions of carbonyl compounds in the gas phase and in a solution

The effect of substituents on nucleophilic addition at the C=O bond, which occurs by the mechanism of intramolecular proton transfer, has been studied by the quantum-chemical MNDO/H method. The effect of nucleophiles and substituents at the carbonyl C atom in the gas phase is opposite to that in solution. Strengthening of the bond between the nucleophile and the carbonyl compound as the result of the transfer of electron density to the carbonyl C atom results in the stabilization of the tetrahedral bipolar adduct. In the formation of an adduct with a strong nucleophile the geometry of the transition state (TS) is closer to that of the reaction product, whereas in the case of a weak nucleophile it is similar to that of the initial reagents. Attack by a weak nucleophile and electron-donating groups at the carbonyl C atom favor the situation in which the reaction system achieves a TS earlier and proton transfer occurs with a low activation barrier.Translated fromIzvestiya Akademii Nauk. Seriya Khimicheskaya, No. 2, pp. 227–230, February, 1994.     

A new insight into using chlorine leaving group and nucleophile carbon kinetic isotope effects to determine substituent effects on the structure of SN2 transition states

Chlorine leaving group k(35)/k(37), nucleophile carbon k(11)/k(14), and secondary alpha-deuterium [(kH/kD)alpha] kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) have been measured for the SN2 reactions between para-substituted benzyl chlorides and tetrabutylammonium cyanide in tetrahydrofuran at 20 degrees C to determine whether these isotope effects can be used to determine the substituent effect on the structure of the transition state. The secondary alpha-deuterium KIEs indicate that the transition states for these reactions are unsymmetric. The theoretical calculations at the B3LYP/aug-cc-pVDZ level of theory support this conclusion; i.e., they suggest that the transition states for these reactions are unsymmetric with a long NC-C(alpha) and reasonably short C(alpha)-Cl bonds. The chlorine isotope effects suggest that these KIEs can be used to determine the substituent effects on transition state structure with the KIE decreasing when a more electron-withdrawing para-substituent is present. This conclusion is supported by theoretical calculations. The nucleophile carbon k(11)/k(14) KIEs for these reactions, however, do not change significantly with substituent and, therefore, do not appear to be useful for determining how the NC-C(alpha) transition-state bond changes with substituent. The theoretical calculations indicate that the NC-C(alpha) bond also shortens as a more electron-withdrawing substituent is placed on the benzene ring of the substrate but that the changes in the NC-C(alpha) transition-state bond with substituent are very small and may not be measurable. The results also show that using leaving group and nucleophile carbon KIEs to determine the substituent effect on transition-state structure is more complicated than previously thought. The implication of using both chlorine leaving group and nucleophile carbon KIEs to determine the substituent effect on transition-state structure is discussed.