Thin film drainage: hydrodynamic and disjoining pressures determined from experimental measurements of the shape of a fluid drop approaching a solid wall

Accurate measurements of the shape of a mercury drop separated from a smooth flat solid surface by a thin aqueous film reported recently by Connor and Horn (Faraday Discuss. 2003, 123, 193-206) have been analyzed to calculate the excess pressure in the film. The analysis is based on calculating the local curvature of the mercury/aqueous interface, and relating it via the Young-Laplace equation to the pressure drop across the interface, which is the difference between the aqueous film pressure and the known internal pressure of the mercury drop. For drop shapes measured under quiescent conditions, the only contribution to film pressure is the disjoining pressure arising from double-layer forces acting between the mercury and mica surfaces. Under dynamic conditions, hydrodynamic pressure is also present, and this is calculated by subtracting the disjoining pressure from the total film pressure. The data, which were measured to investigate the thin film drainage during approach of a fluid drop to a solid wall, show a classical dimpling of the mercury drop when it approaches the mica surface. Four data sets are available, corresponding to different magnitudes and signs of disjoining pressure, obtained by controlling the surface potential of the mercury. The analysis shows that total film pressure does not vary greatly during the evolution of the dimple formed during the thin film drainage process, nor between the different data sets. The hydrodynamic pressure appears to adjust to the different disjoining pressures in such a way that the total film pressure is maintained approximately constant within the dimpled region.     

Hydrodynamic interaction between spheres coated with deformable thin liquid films

In this article, we considered the hydrodynamic interaction between two unequal spheres coated with thin deformable liquids in the asymptotic lubrication regime. This problem is a prototype model for drop coalescence through the so-called "film drainage" mechanism, in which the hydrodynamic contribution comes dominantly from the lubrication region apart from the van der Waals interaction force. First, a general formulation was derived for two unequal coated spheres that experienced a head-to-head collision at a very close proximity. The resulting set of the evolution equations for the deforming film shapes and stress distributions was solved numerically. The film shapes and hydrodynamic interaction forces were determined as functions of the separation distance, film thickness, viscosity ratios, and capillary numbers. The results show that as the two spheres approach each other, the films begin to flatten and eventually to form negative curvature (or a broad dimple) at their forehead areas in which high lubrication pressure is formed. The dimple formation occurs earlier as the capillary number increases. For large capillary numbers, the film liquids are drained out from their forehead areas and the coated liquid films rupture before the two films "touch" each other. Meanwhile, for small capillary numbers, the gap liquid is drained out first and the two liquid films eventually coalesce.     

Dewetting at soft viscoelastic interfaces

The dewetting transition of thin liquid films (approximately 100 nm) at soft viscoelastic interfaces is analyzed theoretically. It is shown that viscoelastic losses in the soft material can drastically increase the time to complete the dewetting. Thus, the influence of the thinning of the liquid film, due to the hydrodynamic drainage caused by the external applied pressure, has to be considered too. The squeezing pressure coupled with the hydrodynamic drainage may slow down the dewetting to almost zero growth rate of the dry zone; in this case a trapped rim of fluid should be observed.     

Linear stability of a draining film squeezed between two approaching droplets

In the present paper we analyze the effect of infinitesimal non-axisymmetric perturbations in determining the critical gap thickness at which a draining, finite radius thin-film becomes unstable. The film is part of the suspending fluid trapped between two approaching deformable drops under the action of a flow field. We carry out a linear stability analysis in the context of a quasi-static approximation where the rate of growth of the disturbances is assumed to be much faster than the rate of film drainage. An analytical solution is derived for the model in the special case of a uniformly thick film, for two types of perturbation: fixed-end and free-end. It is shown, for this special case, when the hydrodynamic force pushing the drops together from the external flow is constant, that the four most unstable disturbances are of the free-end kind, associated with the lowest frequency modes of azimuthal variation in the film thickness. Higher modes are stabilized by surface tension. Our analysis also shows that adopting the unretarded form of the van der Waals disjoining pressure yields results similar to the analysis when electromagnetic retardation effects are included in the calculation. A second case is analyzed where the film is also of uniform thickness but its lateral extent and the gap thickness are both time-dependent. This case was included to extend the predictions to glancing drop-collisions where the external hydrodynamic force is time-dependent. We find that there is a maximum capillary number below which the film becomes unstable, and that there is range of angles in the trajectory where the film becomes unstable, but that outside this range the film is stable.     

Polymeric stabilized emulsions: steric effects and deformation in soft systems

Polymeric stabilizers are used in a broad range of processes and products, from pharmaceuticals and engine lubricants to formulated foods and shampoos. In rigid particulate systems, the stabilization mechanism is attributed to the repulsive force that arises from the compression of the polymer coating or "steric brush" on the interacting particles. This mechanism has dictated polymer design and selection for more than thirty years. Here we show, through direct measurement of the repulsive interactions between immobilized drops with adsorbed polymers layers in aqueous electrolyte solutions, that the interaction is a result of both steric stabilization and drop deformation. Drops driven together at slow collision speeds, where hydrodynamic drainage effects are negligible, show a strong dependence on drop deformation instead of brush compression. When drops are driven together at higher collision speeds where hydrodynamic drainage affects the interaction force, simple continuum modeling suggests that the film drainage is sensitive to flow through the polymer brush. These data suggest, for drop sizes where drop deformation is appreciable, that the stability of emulsion drops is less sensitive to the molecular weight or size of the adsorbed polymer layer than for rigid particulate systems.     

Measurement and modeling on hydrodynamic forces and deformation of an air bubble approaching a solid sphere in liquids

The interaction between bubbles and solid surfaces is central to a broad range of industrial and biological processes. Various experimental techniques have been developed to measure the interactions of bubbles approaching solids in a liquid. A main challenge is to accurately and reliably control the relative motion over a wide range of hydrodynamic conditions and at the same time to determine the interaction forces, bubble–solid separation and bubble deformation. Existing experimental methods are able to focus only on one of the aspects of this problem, mostly for bubbles and particles with characteristic dimensions either below 100 μm or above 1 cm. As a result, either the interfacial deformations are measured directly with the forces being inferred from a model, or the forces are measured directly with the deformations to be deduced from the theory. The recently developed integrated thin film drainage apparatus (ITFDA) filled the gap of intermediate bubble/particle size ranges that are commonly encountered in mineral and oil recovery applications. Equipped with side-view digital cameras along with a bimorph cantilever as force sensor and speaker diaphragm as the driver for bubble to approach a solid sphere, the ITFDA has the capacity to measure simultaneously and independently the forces and interfacial deformations as a bubble approaches a solid sphere in a liquid. Coupled with the thin liquid film drainage modeling, the ITFDA measurement allows the critical role of surface tension, fluid viscosity and bubble approach speed in determining bubble deformation (profile) and hydrodynamic forces to be elucidated. Here we compare the available methods of studying bubble–solid interactions and demonstrate unique features and advantages of the ITFDA for measuring both forces and bubble deformations in systems of Reynolds numbers as high as 10. The consistency and accuracy of such measurement are tested against the well established Stokes–Reynolds–Young–Laplace model. The potential to use the design principles of the ITFDA for fundamental and developmental research is demonstrated.     

Particle motion near a deformable fluid interface

The present paper reports on one aspect of our recent studies of the hydrodynamic interactions of two deformable particles in a viscous fluid. This general hydrodynamics problem represents an initial step toward a fundamental invertigation of particle/ drop or droplet/droplet interactions in processes such as coalescence and flotation where both hydrodynamic and colloidal effects may be important. Here we consider only the limiting problem of translation of a rigid sphere with constant velocity normal to the plane of an initially flat interface. The Reynolds number is assumed to be vanishingly small; however, no restriction is imposed on the magnitude of the interface deformation.A primary focus of our research has been the qualitative dependence of the mode of interface deformation on the viscosity ratio, and on appropriate non-dimensional measures of interfacial tension and the density difference across the interface. In some instances, the deformation is relatively small and a so called “film drainage” configuration is attained as the particle passes across the plane of the undeformed interface. In other cases. however, the particle passes well into the domain of the second fluid while still surrounded by a layer of the first fluid that is connected to its original domain by a thin column (or “tail”) of fluid behind the sphere. In these latter cases, the rate of thinning of the tail is greate than the rate of thinning of the fluid layer around the particle; thus suggesting a second mode of particle “breakingthrough”, in addition to that associated with the film drainage configuration.     

Effects of bubble size and approach velocity on bubble–particle interaction – a theoretical study

A theoretical analysis of the atomic force microscopy (AFM) approach–retract dynamic interaction between an air bubble and a hydrophilic silica plane was carried out based on the well-established Stokes–Reynolds–Young–Laplace model. An air bubble with different radii attached to the end of a cantilever approached the silica surface with different approach velocities in a 10^?3?M KCl solution. Results showed that with increasing approach velocity (0.1, 1, and 10?µm/s), the repulsive force, flattened area of the film, and hydrodynamic suction force between the 100-µm bubble and the silica plane increased. The film continued thinning at the initial stages of bubble retraction because of the attractive hydrodynamic pressure. When the bubble size decreased, the influence of hydrodynamic pressure was less evident. The final film thickness before bubble retraction was similar to the theoretical equilibrium thickness when the Laplace pressure was equal to the disjoining pressure.     

Dynamic forces between bubbles and surfaces and hydrodynamic boundary conditions

A bubble attached to the end of an atomic force microscope cantilever and driven toward or away from a flat mica surface across an aqueous film is used to characterize the dynamic force that arises from hydrodynamic drainage and electrical double layer interactions across the nanometer thick intervening aqueous film. The hydrodynamic response of the air/water interface can range from a classical fully immobile, no-slip surface in the presence of added surfactants to a partially mobile interface in an electrolyte solution without added surfactants. A model that includes the convection and diffusion of trace surface contaminants can account for the observed behavior presented. This model predicts quantitatively different interfacial dynamics to the Navier slip model that can also be used to fit dynamic force data with a post hoc choice of a slip length.     

Effect of the adsorption component of the disjoining pressure on foam film drainage

The present work is trying to explain a discrepancy between experimental observations of the drainage of foam films from aqueous solutions of sodium dodecylsulfate and the theoretical DLVO-accomplished Reynolds model. It is shown that, due to overlap of the film adsorption layers, an adsorption component of the disjoining pressure is important for the present system. The pre-exponential factor of this adsorption component was obtained by fitting to the experimental drainage curves. It corresponds to a slight repulsion, which reduces not only the thinning velocity as observed experimentally but corrects also the film equilibrium thickness.     

The effect of interfacial viscosity on the droplet dynamics under flow field

The effects of interfacial viscosity on the droplet dynamics in simple shear flow and planar hyperbolic flow are investigated by numerical simulation with diffuse interface model. The change of interfacial viscosity results in an apparent slip of interfacial velocity. Interfacial viscosity has been found to have different influence on droplet deformation and coalescence. Smaller interfacial viscosity can stabilize droplet shape in flow field, while larger interfacial viscosity will increase droplet deformation, or even make droplet breakup faster. Different behavior is found in droplet coalescence, where smaller interfacial viscosity speeds up film drainage and droplet coalescence, but larger interfacial viscosity postpones the film drainage process. This is due to the change of film shape from flat‐like for smaller interfacial viscosity to dimple‐like for larger interfacial viscosity. The film drainage time still scales as Ca⁰ at smaller capillary number (Ca), and Ca^1.5 at higher capillary number when the interfacial viscosity changes. The interfacial viscosity only affects the transition between these limiting scaling relationships. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part B: Polym Phys 46: 1505–1514, 2008     

Dynamic aspects of small bubble and hydrophilic solid encounters

The capture of solid particles suspended in aqueous solution by rising gas bubbles involves hydrodynamic and physicochemical processes that are central to colloid science. Of the collision, attachment and aggregate stability aspects to the bubble-particle interaction, the crucial attachment process is least understood. This is especially true of hydrophilic solids. We review the current literature regarding each component of the bubble-particle attachment process, from the free-rise of a small, clean single bubble, to the collision, film drainage and interactions which dominate the attachment rate. There is a particular focus on recent studies which employ single, very small bubbles as analysis probes, enabling the dynamic bubble-hydrophilic particle interaction to be investigated, avoiding complications which arise from fluid inertia, deformation of the liquid-vapour interface and the possibility of surfactant contamination.     

Different surface corrugations occurring during drainage of axisymmetric thin liquid films

This paper deals with the different surface corrugations observable during the thinning of axisymmetric thin and large aqueous films, stabilized by saponin. The films are observed using a thin film balance under a constant driving pressure. This device allows measurement of the thicknesses of the film surface shapes arising all along the drainage, as well as the following-up of their evolution before equilibrium is attained. Depending on the electrolyte (NaCl) concentration, three different sorts of corrugation were originally observed in such suspended thin liquid films. At the lowest NaCl concentrations, corresponding to repulsive potential between film walls, only the hydrodynamic corrugations deformed the film surfaces. Regarding the higher NaCl concentrations, when van der Waals forces become predominant, and following the thickness of the first-established thin film, the experiments disclose either that the thinner films are broken up by spinodal decomposition, or that the thicker ones are broken by nucleation and growth of black film. In addition, an original aspect of these works appears in the fact that these observations of the spontaneous decomposition of suspended thin films are relatively similar to those usually described for dewetting experiments on solid substrates, and are well fitted by the existing theoretical models.     

Rupture of wetting films caused by nanobubbles

It is now widely accepted that nanometer sized bubbles, attached at a hydrophobic silica surface, can cause rupture of aqueous wetting films due to the so-called nucleation mechanism. But the knowledge of the existence of such nanobubbles does not give an answer to how the subprocesses of this rupture mechanism operate. The aim of this paper is to describe the steps of the rupture process in detail: (1) During drainage of the wetting film, the apex of the largest nanobubble comes to a distance from the wetting film surface, where surface forces are acting. (2) An aqueous "foam film" in nanoscale size is formed between the bubble and the wetting film surface; in this foam film different Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) forces are acting than in the surrounding wetting film. In the investigated system, hydrophobized silica/water/air, all DLVO forces in the wetting film are repulsive, whereas in the foam film the van der Waals force becomes attractive. (3) The surface forces over and around the apex of the nanobubble lead to a deformation of the film surfaces, which causes an additional capillary pressure in the foam film. An analysis of the pressure balance in the system shows that this additional capillary pressure can destabilize the foam film and leads to rupture of the foam film. (4) If the newly formed hole in the wetting film has a sufficient diameter, the whole wetting film is destabilized and the solid becomes dewetted. Experimental data of rupture thickness and lifetime of wetting films of pure electrolyte and surfactant solutions show that the stabilization of the foam film by surfactants has a crucial effect on the stability of the wetting film.     

Film drainage between two surfactant-coated drops colliding at constant approach velocity

The drainage of the intervening continuous phase film between two drops approaching each other at constant velocity under the influence of insoluble surfactant is investigated. The mathematical model to be solved is a coupled pair of fourth-order nonlinear partial differential equations which arise from the relationships governing the evolution of the film thickness and the surfactant interfacial concentration in the lubrication approximation. We adopt a simplified approach which uses lubrication theory to describe the flow within the drop, marking a departure from the conventional framework in which Stokes flow is assumed. When the model is solved numerically together with the relevant initial and boundary conditions, the results obtained are compared with those found in the literature using the "boundary integral" method to solve for the flow in the drop phase. The close agreement between the results inspires confidence in the predictions of the simplified approach adopted. The analysis on the effect of insoluble surfactant indicates that its presence retards the drainage of the film: The fully immobile interface limit is recovered even in the presence of a small amount of surfactant above a critical concentration; film rupture is either prolonged or prevented. The retardation of the film was attributed to gradients of interfacial tension which gave rise to the Marangoni effect. A study of the influence of various system parameters on the drainage dynamics was conducted and three regimes of drainage and possible rupture were identified depending on the relative magnitudes of the drop approach velocity and the van der Waals interaction force: Nose rupture, rim rupture, and film immobilization and flattening. Finally, the possibility of forming secondary droplets by encapsulating the continuous phase film into the coalesced drop at rupture was examined and quantified in light of these regimes.     

Film drainage between two captive drops: PEO-water in silicon oil

An experimental study of the deformation and drainage of a Newtonian liquid film trapped between two drops is performed for the cases of a constant and slightly rising interaction force. Series of polyethylene oxide (PEO) water solutions are used for the dispersed and polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) for the continuous phase. The film evolution is observed by an interferometric technique. Experimental data for the film thinning rate and for the film profile allow quantitative comparison with the available drainage models.     

Film drainage and interfacial instabilities in polymeric systems with diffuse interfaces

We report an experimental investigation on the effect of mutual diffusion in polymeric systems on film drainage between two captive drops. The main objective is to study the influence of diffuse interfaces on film drainage. This is done by using material combinations with different interfacial properties and interferometric visualization of the film between two interacting drops. For highly diffusive systems film drainage is observed to be, in contrast to immiscible systems, non-axisymmetric and unstable immediately after the film formation (at a few micrometers film thickness). Depending on whether the total thickness of the diffusion layers in the film is smaller or larger than the thickness of the film, Marangoni convection is found to enhance or delay film drainage. Enhanced film drainage is determined to be in order of 100 times faster than predicted by the current models, while delayed film drainage is observed after a drainage period where experimental and predicted results (assuming, a partially mobile interface) are in close agreement.