Effects of liquid phase composition on salt cluster formation in positive ion mode electrospray mass spectrometry: implications for clustering mechanism in electrospray

Potassium bromate salt clusters, [KBrO3]nKx(x+), formed by electrospray ionization were studied as a function of solution properties. Clusters with up to 4 positive charges were observed. Their abundance, charge state and distribution were shown to vary with the organic solvent in solution. The effects of 7 solvents, including methanol, ethanol, isopropanol, acetonitrile, acetone, pyridine, and 1,4-dioxane, were thoroughly investigated. Solvents with a low dielectric constant and a high viscosity seem to favor clustering in solution but do not systematically allow high charge state ion formation. On the other hand, cluster charge reduction during desolvation was not correlated with solvent cation affinity over the range of solvents examined. However, ion distribution in mass spectra could be rationalized as a combination of these two competing phenomena. Charge state increases with the cluster size but may be reduced during ion desolvation when high cation affinity solvent molecules are actually involved in the ion solvation shell. This assumption could be envisaged in either Iribarne or Dole mechanisms of ion release in the gas phase. However, intensity profiles of multiply charged clusters could only be understood in terms of the ion evaporation mechanism.     

Effects of solvent and counterion on ion pairing and observed charge states of diquaternary ammonium salts in electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Two diquaternary ammonium chloride salts have been used to examine the roles of solvent and counterion in determination of the degree of ion pairing in solution and the resultant charge state distributions in electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). Three series of solvents, that is, alcohol, polar aprotic, and chlorinated solvents, have been employed to test the influence of solvent polarity and other parameters on the desorption behavior of diquaternary ammonium ions observed in ESI-MS. Solvents of higher polarity were found to yield gas-phase ions of higher charge states, in accordance with their reduced tendency toward ion pairing in solution. Counterion effects were investigated via the following approaches: (1) increase the diquaternary ammonium salt concentration; (2) increase the concentration of an external electrolyte that contained the common counterion Cl^?; (3) replace Cl^? with trifluoroacetate (TFA_c ^?); (4) increase the concentration of an external electrolyte that contained TFAc^?. These experiments indicate that variation of the specific counterion employed alters the degree of influence that the counterion exerts (via ion pairing) on electrospray ionization mass spectra. Increasing amounts of trifluoroacetate ions in a variety of solvent systems invariably led to a progressive shift of the observed ESI-MS charge states of diquaternary ammonium ions toward lower values.     

The relative influences of acidity and polarity on responsiveness of small organic molecules to analysis with negative ion electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS)

The purpose of the work presented here was to evaluate the influence of solution composition and analyte characteristics on responsiveness to analysis with negative ion electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. The responses of a series of structurally diverse acidic molecules were compared in various solvents. Response was generally observed to be higher in methanol than acetonitrile and response for all analytes was poorer when water was mixed with the organic solvent. A positive correlation between negative ion ESI-MS response and log P was observed when either acetonitrile or methanol was used as the electrospray solvent. This result was expected because analytes with significant nonpolar character should be particularly responsive to ESI-MS analysis due to their higher affinity for electrospray droplet surfaces. It was also predicted that highly acidic analytes would be most responsive to analysis with negative ion ESI-MS due to their tendency to form negative ions. However, for the analytes studied here, acidity was found not to have a consistent influence on ESI-MS response. Many of the highly acidic molecules were quite polar and, consequently, were poorly responsive. Furthermore, the deprotonated molecular ion was detected for a number of molecules with very high pKa values, which would not be expected to form negative ions in the bulk solution. Ultimately, these results indicate that acidity is not a conclusive parameter for prediction of the relative magnitudes of negative ion ESI-MS response among a diverse series of analytes. Analyte polarity does; however, appear to be useful for this purpose.     

Disparity between solution-phase equilibria and charge state distributions in positive-ion electrospray mass spectrometry

Two peptides, bradykinin and gramicidin S, were used to investigate the relationship between protonation in the solution phase and charge state distribution observed in electrospray ionization (ES) mass spectra. The degree of protonation in solution was estimated using acid-base equilibrium calculations where possible. Protonation in solution was varied by adjusting pH, solvent composition and peptide concentration. Major disparities were observed between calculated solution-phase peptide protonation and the charge state distributions observed in ES mass spectra. The [(M + 2H)²⁺]/[(M + H)⁺] ratio calculated in solution was larger than the abundance ratio (M + 2H)²⁺ /(M + H)⁺ in the ES mass spectra of all acidic aqueous (pH < 6.5) and non-aqueous solutions; in basic aqueous solutions (pH > 9.5) the opposite was true. At high pH, electrophoretic droplet charging may reduce the activity of OH^? in positively charged droplets. The results at low pH imply the existence of supplementary factors in the ES ionization process which largely attenuate the degree of charging in the gas phase as compared with solution. Factors such as the increasing intra- and intermolecular coulombic repulsion between charge carriers (protons) and increasing attractive forces between protonated sites and counterions at progressively later stages of charged droplet evaporation were hypothesized to be chiefly responsible for this effect. Non-aqueous solvents of high basicity compete with analytes to some extent for available protons, forming protonated solvent molecules while decreasing the sensitivity and the degree of multiple charging of peptides.     

The Charging of Micellar Nanoparticles in Electrospray Ionization

Charging of nanoparticles through electrospray has scarcely been explored. Spherical nanometer‐sized amphiphilic block copolymer nanoparticles with diameters ranging from ～65 to ～150 nm were electrosprayed and analysed by charge detection spectrometry. Herein, we explore the charging of these micellar nano‐objects by conducting a thorough study in different solvents, including pure water, and upon the addition of “supercharging” agents. The charge (z) of micellar nanoparticles electrosprayed from water solution is compared to the Rayleigh’s limiting charge (z_R) of a charged water droplet of the same dimensions. An average ratio (z/z_R) of 0.6–0.65 is observed for the micellar macro‐ions, supporting the charge residue mechanism, where the number of charges available to the micellar macro‐ion is limited by the number of charges on the nanodroplet, which is a function of the surface tension of the solvent. Also we show the possibility of increasing the charging of micellar nanoparticles in the negative mode by adding organic bases (in particular piperidine) to water/methanol solutions.     

Charge as you like! Efficient manipulation of negative ion net charge in electrospray ionization of proteins and nucleic acids

Acidic proteins and nucleic acids such as RNA are most readily ionized in electrospray ionization (ESI) operated in negative-ion mode. The multiply deprotonated protein or RNA ions can be used as precursors in top- down mass spectrometry. Because the performance of the dissociation method used critically depends on precursor ion negative net charge, it is important that the extent of charging in ESI can be manipulated efficiently. We show here that (M - nH)(n-) ion net charge of proteins and RNA can be controlled efficiently by the addition of organic bases to the electrosprayed solution. Our study also highlights the fact that ion formation in ESI in negative mode is only poorly understood.     

Negative ion formation in electrospray mass spectrometry

Analytical and Chemical Sciences, Research Triangle Institute, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA Negative ion electrospray (ES) operating on a single quadrupole mass spectrometer for the detection of low-molecular-weight molecules is discussed. The ES interface was operated at a positive cylindrical electrode potential to produce negative ions, and the results obtained were compared to the positive ion mode. As in the case of operation in the more common positive mode, negative ions with varying degrees of solvation and structurally relevant fragments can be obtained from a variety of solute species, including β-lactam antibiotics, aminoglycosides, aminocyclitols, tetracyclines, sulfonamides, nucleotides, peptides, and explosives. No fragmentation of parent species, except those from some labile explosives, was provided because low potential differences are applied between the capillary and the first skimmer, and electrical discharge is avoided in the gas phase. An increase in the capillary voltage resulted in collision-induced decomposition to produce structurally relevant fragment ions in both operation modes. An evaluation of representative chromatographic solvents indicated that 2-propanol added with oxygen in the ES bath gas is best suited to suppress electrical (corona) discharge phenomena in negative ion operation, whereas it aids in solution nebulization, desolvation, and transfer of ions in solution to the gas phase. For positive ion mode, no such precaution was necessary. Conditions that promote the formation of ions in solution usually improve ES response. Therefore, an increase in the solvent pH can increase the sensitivity in negative ion ES ionization. Negative ion ES offers the advantage of providing complementary structural information to help in the characterization of an unknown compound or to confirm a certain tentatively proposed structure. Nucleotides and explosives were best characterized in negative ion mode owing to the ease with which they form anions in solution, and they could be detected down to the l-pg /gML level.     

Mechanism of charging and supercharging molecules in electrospray ionization

The origin of the extent of charging and the mechanism by which multiply charged ions are formed in electrospray ionization have been hotly debated for over a decade. Many factors can affect the number of charges on an analyte ion. Here, we investigate the extent of charging of poly(propyleneimine) dendrimers (generations 3.0 and 5.0), cytochrome c, poly(ethylene glycol)s, and 1,n-diaminoalkanes formed from solutions of different composition. We demonstrate that in the absence of other factors, the surface tension of the electrospray droplet late in the desolvation process is a significant factor in determining the overall analyte charge. For poly(ethylene glycol)s, 1,n-diaminoalkanes, and poly(propyleneimine) dendrimers electrosprayed from single-component solutions, there is a clear relationship between the analyte charge and the solvent surface tension. Addition of m-nitrobenzyl alcohol (m-NBA) into electrospray solutions increases the charging when the original solution has a lower surface tension than m-NBA, but the degree of charging decreases when this compound is added to water, which has a higher surface tension. Similarly, the charging of cytochrome c ions formed from acidified denaturing solutions generally increases with increasing surface tension of the least volatile solvent. For the dendrimers investigated, there is a strong correlation between the average charge state of the dendrimer and the Rayleigh limiting charge calculated for a droplet of the same size as the analyte molecule and with the surface tension of the electrospray solvent. A bimodal charge distribution is observed for larger dendrimers formed from water/m-NBA solutions, suggesting the presence of more than one conformation in solution. A similar correlation is found between the extent of charging for 1,n-diaminoalkanes and the calculated Rayleigh limiting charge. These results provide strong evidence that multiply charged organic ions are formed by the charged residue mechanism. A significantly smaller extent of charging for both dendrimers and 1,n-diaminoalkanes would be expected if the ion evaporation mechanism played a significant role.     

Relating chromatographic retention and electrophoretic mobility to the ion distribution within electrosprayed droplets

Ions that are observed in a mass spectrum obtained with electrospray mass spectrometry can be assumed to originate preferentially from ions that have a high distribution to the surface of the charged droplets. In this study, a relation between chromatographic retention and electrophoretic mobility to the ion distribution (derived from measured signal intensities in mass spectra and electrospray current) within electrosprayed droplets for a series of tetraalkylammonium ions, ranging from tetramethyl to tetrapentyl, is presented. Chromatographic retention in a reversed-phase system was taken as a measure of the analyte’s surface activity, which was found to have a large influence on the ion distribution within electrosprayed droplets. In addition, different transport mechanisms such as electrophoretic migration and diffusion can influence the surface partitioning coefficient. The viscosity of the solvent system is affected by the methanol content and will influence both diffusion and ion mobility. However, as diffusion and ion mobility are proportional to each other, we have, in this study, chosen to focus on the ion mobility parameter. It was found that the influence of ion mobility relative to surface activity on the droplet surface partitioning of analyte ions decreases with increasing methanol content. This effect is most probably coupled to the decrease in droplet size caused by the decreased surface tension at increasing methanol content. The same observation was made upon increasing the ionic strength of the solvent system, which is also known to give rise to a decreased initial droplet size. The observed effect of ionic strength on the droplet surface partitioning of analyte ions could also be explained by the fact that at higher ionic strength, a larger number of ions are initially closer to the droplet surface and, thus, the contribution of ionic transport from the bulk liquid to the liquid/air surface interface (jet and droplet surface), attributable to migration or diffusion will decrease.     

Effect of solvent and electrospray mass spectrometer parameters on the charge state distribution of peptides--a case study using liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry method development for beta-endorphin assay

Beta-endorphin was used as a model peptide to study the effect of solvent and electrospray mass spectrometer parameters in the optimisation of an assay method for multiply charged compounds using liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS). Unlike with singly charged compounds, the charge state distribution has a significant impact in the method development of multiply charged compounds such as peptides. Using a 50% acetonitrile/water solvent mixture, we found that the ion spray voltage had no influence on the charge state distribution. However, increasing declustering potential led to deprotonation of the higher charge states of the peptide thus causing a shift to lower charge states. The mechanism leading to the deprotonation was examined. It was concluded that the deprotonation is due to endoergic proton transfer from the peptide to solvent molecules clustered to the peptide that occurs in the declustering region. The extent of deprotonation increases with increasing proton affinity of the molecules of the non-aqueous solvent component used. Thus, if desired, deprotonation can be avoided by selecting a low proton affinity solvent such as methanol. The focusing potential was also found to have a great influence on the charge state distribution observed. The results of this study enabled us to select the optimum ion to be used in single ion/reaction monitoring mode. They also provided the most favourable parameter values to be used in the method to obtain the best sensitivity for the ion of choice. The results demonstrate the importance of considering the charge state distribution in the optimisation of electrospray LC/MS methods for multiply charged compounds.     

Separation and characterisation of five polar herbicides using countercurrent chromatography with detection by negative ion electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry.

Five polar herbicides were separated and characterised using high-speed analytical countercurrent chromatography (HSACCC) in conjunction with online electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The countercurrent chromatography used a standard isocratic biphasic solvent system of hexane/ethyl acetate/methanol/water in reverse phase to effect the separation of these five environmentally important compounds. The chromatograph was coupled to a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer via a standard electrospray liquid chromatography interface that was able to give mass spectra in negative ion mode of each compound. Limits of detection are reported for this series of compounds along with representative negative ion ESI-MS data and calibrations for the separation.     

Unfolding of proteins monitored by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry: a comparison of positive and negative ion modes

Electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry (MS) in both the positive and negative ion mode has been used to study protein unfolding transitions of lysozyme, cytochrome c (cyt c), and ubiquitin in solution. As expected, ESI of unfolded lysozyme leads to the formation of substantially higher charge states than the tightly folded protein in both modes of operation. Surprisingly, the acid-induced unfolding of cyt c as well as the acid and the base-induced unfolding of ubiquitin show different behavior: In these three cases protein unfolding only leads to marginal changes in the negative ion charge state distributions, whereas in the positive ion mode pronounced shifts to higher charge states are observed. This shows that ESI MS in the negative ion mode as a method for probing conformational changes of proteins in solution should be treated with caution. The data presented in this work provide further evidence that the conformation of a protein in solution not its charge state is the predominant factor for determining the ESI charge state distribution in the positive ion mode. Furthermore, these data support the hypothesis of a recent study (Konermann and Douglas, Biochemistry 1997, 36, 12296–12302) which suggested that ESI in the positive ion mode is not sensitive to changes in the secondary structure of proteins but only to changes in the tertiary structure.     

Polarization induced electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for the analysis of liquid,viscous and solid samples

In this study, a polarization‐induced electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI‐MS) was developed. A micro‐sized sample droplet was deposited on a naturally available dielectric substrate such as a fruit or a stone, and then placed close to (~2 mm) the orifice of a mass spectrometer applied with a high voltage. Taylor cone was observed from the sample droplet, and a spray emitted from the cone apex was generated. The analyte ion signals derived from the droplet were obtained by the mass spectrometer. The ionization process is similar to that in ESI although no direct electric contact was applied on the sample site. The sample droplet polarized by the high electric field provided by the mass spectrometer initiated the ionization process. The dielectric sample loading substrate facilitated further the polarization process, resulting in the formation of Taylor cone. The mass spectral profiles obtained via this approach resembled those obtained using ESI‐MS. Multiply charged ions dominated the mass spectra of peptides and proteins, whereas singly charged ions dominated the mass spectra of small molecules such as amino acids and small organic molecules. In addition to liquid samples, this approach can be used for the analysis of solid and viscous samples. A small droplet containing suitable solvent (5–10 µl) was directly deposited on the surface of the solid (or viscous) sample, placed close the orifice of mass spectrometer applied with a high voltage. Taylor cone derived from the droplet was immediately formed followed by electrospray processes to generate gas‐phase ions for MS analysis. Analyte ions derived from the main ingredients of pharmaceutical tablets and viscous ointment can be extracted into the solvent droplet in situ and observed using a mass spectrometer. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A laccase study by electrospray ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance MS: copper depletion, glycoforms and stability

The molecular properties and stability of a laccase from the white-rot fungus Trametes hirsuta (ThL) were studied to exploit the unique capability of electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) to monitor conformational and molecular-based heterogeneities and metal ion binding simultaneously. Acid and organic solvents were applied as denaturing agents. In aqueous acidic solution, ThL existed in two major forms, distinguished by their mass difference; in addition to these, two other forms were detected. This molecular heterogeneity was due to the variable glycan content of ThL. Additionally, copper-depleted forms of laccase were observed in mass spectra measured from aqueous acidic solution. A small amount of organic solvent (acetonitrile, CH(3)CN) increased the loss of one Cu atom from folded states and led to unfolding. In the unfolded state, ThL was depleted of all four copper atoms, and the charge state distribution was shifted to lower mass-to-charge region. Thus, denaturation took place in two stages: first, the loss of one Cu resulting in an inactive form; second, complete denaturation with the loss of the three remaining Cu atoms. After all coppers were lost, ThL was unfolded, as was clearly seen in the increased number of charge states in the mass spectra. Different stabilities of the glycoforms were observed in the denaturation triggered in acid and organic solvents.     

Effects of ion solvation on phase equilibrium and interfacial tension of liquid mixtures

We study the bulk thermodynamics and interfacial properties of electrolyte solution mixtures by accounting for electrostatic interaction, ion solvation, and inhomogeneity in the dielectric medium in the mean-field framework. Difference in the solvation energy between the cations and anions is shown to give rise to local charge separation near the interface, and a finite Galvani potential between two coexisting solutions. The ion solvation affects the phase equilibrium of the solvent mixture, depending on the dielectric constants of the solvents, reflecting the competition between the solvation energy and translation entropy of the ions. Miscibility is decreased if both solvents have low dielectric constants and is enhanced if both solvents have high dielectric constant. At the mean-field level, the ion distribution near the interface is determined by two competing effects: accumulation in the electrostatic double layer and depletion in a diffuse interface. The interfacial tension shows a nonmonotonic dependence on the salt concentration: it increases linearly with the salt concentration at higher concentrations and decreases approximately as the square root of the salt concentration for dilute solutions, reaching a minimum near 1 mM. We also find that, for a fixed cation type, the interfacial tension decreases as the size of anion increases. These results offer qualitative explanations within one unified framework for the long-known concentration and ion size effects on the interfacial tension of electrolyte solutions.     

Effects of solvent on the maximum charge state and charge state distribution of protein ions produced by electrospray ionization

The effects of solvent composition on both the maximum charge states and charge state distributions of analyte ions formed by electrospray ionization were investigated using a quadrupole mass spectrometer. The charge state distributions of cytochrome c and myoglobin, formed from 47%/50%/3% water/solvent/acetic acid solutions, shift to lower charge (higher m/z) when the 50% solvent fraction is changed from water to methanol, to acetonitrile, to isopropanol. This is also the order of increasing gas-phase basicities of these solvents, although other physical properties of these solvents may also play a role. The effect is relatively small for these solvents, possibly due to their limited concentration inside the electrospray interface. In contrast, the addition of even small amounts of diethylamine (<0.4%) results in dramatic shifts to lower charge, presumably due to preferential proton transfer from the higher charge state ions to diethylamine. These results clearly show that the maximum charge states and charge state distributions of ions formed by electrospray ionization are influenced by solvents that are more volatile than water. Addition of even small amounts of two solvents that are less volatile than water, ethylene glycol and 2-methoxyethanol, also results in preferential deprotonation of higher charge state ions of small peptides, but these solvents actually produce an enhancement in the higher charge state ions for both cytochrome c and myoglobin. For instruments that have capabilities that improve with lower m/z, this effect could be taken advantage of to improve the performance of an analysis.     

Ion formation from charged droplets: Roles of geometry,energy, and time

The formation of ions from the charged droplets produced in the several spray ionization techniques is viewed as an activated rate process involving field-assisted desorption, in accord with the ideas first set forth by Iribame and Thomson. The novel features of the present treatment are particularly relevant to the unique ability of electrospray ionization to transform large molecules in solution to free ions in the gas phase, with extensive multiple charging. These new features stem mainly from the realization that the spacing of charges on a desorbed ion must relate to the spacing of charges on the surface of the droplet whence it came. The consequences of this “rule” can account for the existence of maxima and minima in the number of charges on the ions of a particular species as well as the nature of the distribution of ions among the intervening charge states. They also explain the dependence of charge state on the configuration in solution of the parent molecule of the desorbed ion. In addition, they provide insight into the sequence in time at which ions in the various charge states leave an evaporating droplet.     

Basic Vapor Exposure for Tuning the Charge State Distribution of Proteins in Negative Electrospray Ionization: Elucidation of Mechanisms by Fluorescence Spectroscopy

Manipulation for simplifying or increasing the observed charge state distributions of proteins can be highly desirable in mass spectrometry experiments. In the present work, we implemented a vapor introduction technique to an Agilent Jet Stream ESI (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) source. An apparatus was designed to allow for the enrichment of the nitrogen sheath gas with basic vapors. An optical setup, using laser-induced fluorescence and a pH-chromic dye, permits the pH profiling of the droplets as they evaporate in the electrospray plume. Mechanisms of pH droplet modification and its effect on the protein charging phenomenon are elucidated. An important finding is that the enrichment with basic vapors of the nitrogen sheath gas, which surrounds the nebulizer spray, leads to an increase in the spray current. This is attributed to an increase in the electrical conductivity of water-amine enriched solvent at the tip exit. Here, the increased current results in a generation of additional electrolytically produced OH(-) ions and a corresponding increase in the pH at the tip exit. Along the electrospray plume, the pH of the droplets increases due to both droplet evaporation and exposure to basic vapors from the seeded sheath gas. The pH evolution in the ESI plume obtained using pure and basic seeded sheath gas was correlated with the evolution of the charge state distribution observed in mass spectra of proteins, in the negative ion mode. Taking advantage of the Agilent Jet Stream source geometry, similar protein charge state distributions and ion intensities obtained with basic initial solutions, can be obtained using native solution conditions by seeding the heated sheath gas with basic vapors.     

Coupling desorption electrospray ionization with ion mobility/mass spectrometry for analysis of protein structure: evidence for desorption of folded and denatured States

A desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) source has been coupled to an ion mobility time-of-flight mass spectrometer for the analysis of proteins. Analysis of solid-phase horse heart cytochrome c and chicken egg white lysozyme proteins with different DESI solvents and conditions shows similar mass spectra and charge state distributions to those formed when using electrospray to analyze these proteins in solution. The ion mobility data show evidence for compact ion structures [when the surface is exposed to a spray that favors retention of "nativelike" structures (50:50 water:methanol)] or elongated structures [when the surface is exposed to a spray that favors "denatured" structures (49:49:2 water:methanol:acetic acid)]. The results suggest that the DESI experiment is somewhat gentler than ESI and under appropriate conditions, it is possible to preserve structural information throughout the DESI process. Mechanisms that are consistent with these results are discussed.     

Morphology control of poly(vinylidene fluoride) thin film made with electrospray

Thin polymer films of poly(vinylidene fluoride) were prepared with electrospray. Effects of solvent, initial spray concentration, temperature, solution conductivity, and polymer size on the film morphology were studied with AFM. The two main factors controlling polymer film morphology are the droplet size of the spray and the viscosity of the solution at deposition. These factors determine the flow of the polymer-solvent mixture over the substrate, the density of the film, and its smoothness. The solvent is a key parameter of the entire process. It affects spray stability, polymer solubility, droplet size of the spray, and viscosity of the solution at deposition. Solvents with a low vapor pressure provide a wider window for optimization of other parameters and are therefore preferred over solvents with high vapor pressure. The viscosity at deposition is mainly controlled with the initial spray concentration, polymer size, temperature, and droplet size. The droplet size is best controlled by the conductivity of the solution and the flow rate of the spray.