Gas-phase ion/ion reactions of multiply protonated polypeptides with metal containing anions

Gas-phase reactions of multiply protonated polypeptides and metal containing anions represent a new methodology for manipulating the cationizing agent composition of polypeptides. This approach affords greater flexibility in forming metal containing ions than commonly used methods, such as electrospray ionization of a metal salt/peptide mixture and matrix-assisted laser desorption. Here, the effects of properties of the polypeptide and anionic reactant on the nature of the reaction products are investigated. For a given metal, the identity of the ligand in the metal containing anion is the dominant factor in determining product distributions. For a given polypeptide ion, the difference between the metal ion affinity and the proton affinity of the negatively charged ligand in the anionic reactant is of predictive value in anticipating the relative contributions of proton transfer and metal ion transfer. Furthermore, the binding strength of the ligand anion to charge sites in the polypeptide correlates with the extent of observed cluster ion formation. Polypeptide composition, sequence, and charge state can also play a notable role in determining the distribution of products. In addition to their usefulness in gas-phase ion synthesis strategies, the reactions of protonated polypeptides and metal containing anions represent an example of a gas-phase ion/ion reaction that is sensitive to polypeptide structure. These observations are noteworthy in that they allude to the possibility of obtaining information, without requiring fragmentation of the peptide backbone, about ion structure as well as the relative ion affinities associated with the reactants.     

Electron transfer versus proton transfer in gas-phase ion/ion reactions of polyprotonated peptides

The ion/ion reactions of several dozen reagent anions with triply protonated cations of the model peptide KGAILKGAILR have been examined to evaluate predictions of a Landau-Zener-based model for the likelihood for electron transfer. Evidence for electron transfer was provided by the appearance of fragment ions unique to electron transfer or electron capture dissociation. Proton transfer and electron transfer are competitive processes for any combination of anionic and cationic reactants. For reagent anions in reactions with protonated peptides, proton transfer is usually significantly more exothermic than electron transfer. If charge transfer occurs at relatively long distances, electron transfer should, therefore, be favored on kinetic grounds because the reactant and product channels cross at greater distances, provided conditions are favorable for electron transfer at the crossing point. The results are consistent with a model based on Landau-Zener theory that indicates both thermodynamic and geometric criteria apply for electron transfer involving polyatomic anions. Both the model and the data suggest that electron affinities associated with the anionic reagents greater than about 60-70 kcal/mol minimize the likelihood that electron transfer will be observed. Provided the electron affinity is not too high, the Franck-Condon factors associated with the anion and its corresponding neutral must not be too low. When one or the other of these criteria is not met, proton transfer tends to occur essentially exclusively. Experiments involving ion/ion attachment products also suggest that a significant barrier exists to the isomerization between chemical complexes that, if formed, lead to either proton transfer or electron transfer.     

Two ion/ion charge inversion steps to form a doubly protonated peptide from a singly protonated peptide in the gas phase

An approach is described to increase the degree of protonation of a polypeptide ion in the gas phase. Sequential charge inversion reactions involving the reactions of oppositely charged ions are used to yield a net increase in ion charge. The approach is illustrated here with the conversion of singly protonated bradykinin to doubly protonated bradykinin. The first step involves conversion of the singly protonated peptide to the singly deprotonated peptide via reactions with multiply charged anions derived from carboxylate-terminated dendrimers. Some of the singly deprotonated peptide was then converted to doubly protonated peptide via reactions with multiply charged cations derived from amino-terminated dendrimers. The overall approach is illustrative of a general strategy for increasing the absolute charge states of large ions in the gas phase.     

An investigation of the energetics of peptide ion dissociation by laser desorption chemical ionization fourier transform mass spectrometry

The energy dependence of competing fragmentation pathways of protonated peptide molecules is studied via laser desorption—chemical ionization in a Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance spectrometer. Neutral peptide molecules are desorbed by the technique of substrate-assisted laser desorption, followed by post-ionization with a proton transfer reagent ion species. The chemical ionization reaction activates the protonated peptide molecules, which then fragment in accordance with the amount of excess energy that is deposited. Chemical ionization forms a protonated molecule with a narrower distribution of activation energy than can be formed by activation methods such as collision activated dissociation. Furthermore, the upper limit of the activation energy is well defined and is approximately given by the enthalpy of the chemical ionization reaction. Control over the fragmentation of peptide ions is demonstrated through reactions between desorbed peptide molecules with different reagent ion species. The fragmentation behavior of peptide ions with different internal energies is established by generation of a breakdown curve for the peptide under investigation. Breakdown curves are reported for the peptides Val-Pro, Val-Pro-Leu, Phe-Phe-Gly-Leu-Met NH₂, and Arg-Lys-Asp-Val-Tyr. The derived breakdown curve of Val-Pro has been fitted by using quasi-equilibrium Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus theory to model the unimolecular dissociation of the protonated peptide to provide a better understanding of the mechanisms for the formation of fragment ions that originate from protonated peptides.     

Targeted biomarker detection via whole protein ion trap tandem mass spectrometry: thymosin beta4 in a human lung cancer cell line

N-Terminally acetylated thymosin beta4, a species implicated for use as a cancer biomarker, was identified in a human lung cancer cell line using ion trap tandem mass spectrometry at the whole protein level. Ion-ion proton transfer reactions were used for parent ion concentration/manipulation and to simplify interpretation of product ion spectra. Dissociation data for the +6 to +3 charge states are reported. As is usually the case, structural information available from the ion trap collisional activation of the protein is sensitive to parent ion charge state. Each parent ion charge state selected, however, provided sufficient information to make a confident identification. Furthermore, each charge state provided relatively rich fragmentation. Therefore, any of the charge states can be used to detect with high specificity thymosin beta(4) in a complex protein mixture. There are advantages associated with the rapid detection of protein biomarkers at the whole protein level, as opposed to the peptide level following protein digestion, particularly for relatively small protein and polypeptide biomarkers. Having identified and characterized the protein, product ion spectra obtained directly, without recourse to ion-ion proton transfer reactions, can be used for library matching. However, ion-ion proton transfer reactions for parent ion concentration and charge state purification are advantageous in addressing relatively complex mixtures.     

Tandem mass spectrometry of half-generation PAMAM dendrimer anions

Ions derived from negative electrospray ionization of polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimer generation 0.5 were subjected to ion trap tandem mass spectrometry. Ion/ion proton transfer reactions were used to manipulate the charge states of PAMAM precursor ions to form lower charge states from those initially formed by electrospray, as well as to facilitate the interpretation of the product ion mass spectra. Most of the products derived from dendrimer precursor ions could be rationalized by retro-Michael decomposition reactions. The dominant fragmentation channels are highly dependent on the composition of the counter-ions, which in this case are restricted to different numbers of sodium ions and protons, and whether the precursor ion is multiply charged or singly charged. An interpretation is given that is consistent with all of the observations made with the various anions associated with this study. The nature of the structural information that can be obtained via ion trap tandem mass spectrometry of the dendrimers is dependent on the types of precursor ions subjected to study. The tandem mass spectrometry data also provided information about the structure of faulty synthesis products present in the PAMAM dendrimer sample.     

Methylating peptides to prevent adduct ion formation also directs cleavage in collision-induced dissociation mass spectrometry

We investigated the effect of N-terminal amino group and carboxyl group methylation on peptide analysis by electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS). Permethylation of the N-terminal amino group and the carboxyl groups can reduce metal ion adducts but does not enhance sensitivity in electrospray as previously observed for matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry. N-terminal trimethylated peptides exhibit collision-induced dissociation (CID) tandem mass spectra that differ from their unmodified analogs; the results support the mobile proton hypothesis of peptide fragmentation. A permanent positive charge at the N-terminus leads to competition between permanent-charge directed processes and loss of the N-terminal trimethyl amino group. Carboxyl methylation has no effect on fragmentation behavior other than to shift the mass of fragments containing methylated carboxyl groups. Comparison of regular and tandem mass spectra of different methylated peptides allowed probing the location of incomplete methylation, the proton displaced by alkali metal ions and the purity of a mass-selected methylated peptide ion.     

Substituent effects on the gas-phase fragmentation reactions of sulfonium ion containing peptides

The multistage mass spectrometric (MS/MS and MS3) gas-phase fragmentation reactions of methionine side-chain sulfonium ion containing peptides formed by reaction with a series of para-substituted phenacyl bromide (XBr where X=CH2COC6H4R, and R=--COOH, --COOCH3, --H, --CH3 and --CH2CH3) alkylating reagents have been examined in a linear quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. MS/MS of the singly (M+) and multiply ([M++nH](n+1)+) charged precursor ions results in exclusive dissociation at the fixed charge containing side chain, independently of the amino acid composition and precursor ion charge state (i.e., proton mobility). However, loss of the methylphenacyl sulfide side-chain fragment as a neutral versus charged (protonated) species was observed to be highly dependent on the proton mobility of the precursor ion, and the identity of the phenacyl group para-substituent. Molecular orbital calculations were performed at the B3LYP/6-31+G** level of theory to calculate the theoretical proton affinities of the neutral side-chain fragments. The log of the ratio of neutral versus protonated side-chain fragment losses from the derivatized side chain were found to exhibit a linear dependence on the proton affinity of the side-chain fragmentation product, as well as the proton affinities of the peptide product ions. Finally, MS3 dissociation of the nominally identical neutral and protonated loss product ions formed by MS/MS of the [M++H]2+ and [M++2H]3+ precursor ions, respectively, from the peptide GAILM(X)GAILK revealed significant differences in the abundances of the resultant product ions. These results suggest that the protonated peptide product ions formed by gas-phase fragmentation of sulfonium ion containing precursors in an ion trap mass spectrometer do not necessarily undergo intramolecular proton 'scrambling' prior to their further dissociation, in contrast to that previously demonstrated for peptide ions introduced by external ionization sources.     

On performing simultaneous electron transfer dissociation and collision-induced dissociation on multiply protonated peptides in a linear ion trap

We propose a tandem mass spectrometry method that combines electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) with simultaneous collision-induced dissociation (CID), termed ETD/CID. This technique can provide more complete sequence coverage of peptide ions, especially those at lower charge states. A selected precursor ion is isolated and subjected to ETD. At the same time, a residual precursor ion is subjected to activation via CID. The specific residual precursor ion selected for activation will depend upon the charge state and m/z of the ETD precursor ion. Residual precursor ions, which include unreacted precursor ions and charge-reduced precursor ions (either by electron-transfer or proton transfer), are often abundant remainders in ETD-only reactions. Preliminary results demonstrate that during an ETD/CID experiment, b, y, c, and z-type ions can be produced in a single experiment and displayed in a single mass spectrum. While some peptides, especially doubly protonated ones, do not fragment well by ETD, ETD/CID alleviates this problem by acting in at least one of three ways: (1) the number of ETD fragment ions are enhanced by CID of residual precursor ions, (2) both ETD and CID-derived fragments are produced, or (3) predominantly CID-derived fragments are produced with little or no improvement in ETD-derived fragment ions. Two interesting scenarios are presented that display the flexibility of the ETD/CID method. For example, smaller peptides that show little response to ETD are fragmented preferentially by CID during the ETD/CID experiment. Conversely, larger peptides with higher charge states are fragmented primarily via ETD. Hence, ETD/CID appears to rely upon the fundamental reactivity of the analyte cations to provide the best fragmentation without implementing any additional logic or MS/MS experiments. In addition to the ETD/CID experiments, we describe a novel dual source interface for providing front-end ETD capabilities on a linear ion trap mass spectrometer.     

Probing the stability and structure of metalloporphyrin complexes with basic peptides by mass spectrometry

The stability and structure of non-covalent complexes of various peptides contatining basic amino acid residues (Arg, Lys) with metalloporphyrins were studied in a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. The complexes of heme and three other metalloporphyrins with a variety of basic peptides and model systems were formed via electrospray ionization (ESI) and their stability was probed by energy-variable collision-induced dissociation (CID). A linear dependence for basic peptides and model compounds/metalloporphyrin complexes was observed in the plots of stability versus degrees of freedom and was used to evaluate relative bond strength. These results were then compared with previous data obtained for complexes of metalloporphyrins with His-containing peptides and peptides containing no basic amino acids. The binding strengths of Lys-containing peptide complexes in the gas phase was found to be almost as strong as that of Arg-containing complexes. Both systems showed stronger binding than His- containing peptides studied previously. To probe the structure of Arg and Lys non-covalent complexes (charge solvation versus salt bridges), two techniques, CID and ionmolecule reactions, were used. CID experiments indicate that the gas-phase complexes are most likely formed by charge solvation of the central metal ion in the metalloporphyrin by basic side chains of Arg or Lys. Results from the ionmolecule reaction studies are consistent with the charge solvation structure as well.     

Occurrence of C-Terminal Residue Exclusion in Peptide Fragmentation by ESI and MALDI Tandem Mass Spectrometry

By screening a data set of 392 synthetic peptides MS/MS spectra, we found that a known C-terminal rearrangement was unexpectedly frequently occurring from monoprotonated molecular ions in both ESI and MALDI tandem mass spectrometry upon low and high energy collision activated dissociations with QqTOF and TOF/TOF mass analyzer configuration, respectively. Any residue localized at the C-terminal carboxylic acid end, even a basic one, was lost, provided that a basic amino acid such arginine and to a lesser extent histidine and lysine was present in the sequence leading to a fragment ion, usually depicted as (b_n-1 + H₂O) ion, corresponding to a shortened non-scrambled peptide chain. Far from being an epiphenomenon, such a residue exclusion from the peptide chain C-terminal extremity gave a fragment ion that was the base peak of the MS/MS spectrum in certain cases. Within the frame of the mobile proton model, the ionizing proton being sequestered onto the basic amino acid side chain, it is known that the charge directed fragmentation mechanism involved the C-terminal carboxylic acid function forming an anhydride intermediate structure. The same mechanism was also demonstrated from cationized peptides. To confirm such assessment, we have prepared some of the peptides that displayed such C-terminal residue exclusion as a C-terminal backbone amide. As expected in this peptide amide series, the production of truncated chains was completely suppressed. Besides, multiply charged molecular ions of all peptides recorded in ESI mass spectrometry did not undergo such fragmentation validating that any mobile ionizing proton will prevent such a competitive C-terminal backbone rearrangement. Among all well-known nondirect sequence fragment ions issued from non specific loss of neutral molecules (mainly H₂O and NH₃) and multiple backbone amide ruptures (b-type internal ions), the described C-terminal residue exclusion is highly identifiable giving raise to a single fragment ion in the high mass range of the MS/MS spectra. The mass difference between this signal and the protonated molecular ion corresponds to the mass of the C-terminal residue. It allowed a straightforward identification of the amino acid positioned at this extremity. It must be emphasized that a neutral residue loss can be misattributed to the formation of a y_m-1 ion, i.e., to the loss of the N-terminal residue following the a₁-y_m–1 fragmentation channel. Extreme caution must be adopted when reading the direct sequence ion on the positive ion MS/MS spectra of singly charged peptides not to mix up the attribution of the N- and C-terminal amino acids. Although such peculiar fragmentation behavior is of obvious interest for de novo peptide sequencing, it can also be exploited in proteomics, especially for studies involving digestion protocols carried out with proteolytic enzymes other than trypsin (Lys-N, Glu-C, and Asp-N) that produce arginine-containing peptides.     

SO<Stack><Subscript>2</Subscript><Superscript>−·</Superscript></Stack> electron transfer ion/ion reactions with disulfide linked polypeptide ions

Multiply-charged peptide cations comprised of two polypeptide chains (designated A and B) bound via a disulfide linkage have been reacted with SO2-* in an electrodynamic ion trap mass spectrometer. These reactions proceed through both proton transfer (without dissociation) and electron transfer (with and without dissociation). Electron transfer reactions are shown to give rise to cleavage along the peptide backbone, loss of neutral molecules, and cleavage of the cystine bond. Disulfide bond cleavage is the preferred dissociation channel and both Chain A (or B)-S* and Chain A (or B)-SH fragment ions are observed, similar to those observed with electron capture dissociation (ECD) of disulfide-bound peptides. Electron transfer without dissociation produces [M + 2H]+* ions, which appear to be less kinetically stable than the proton transfer [M + H]+ product. When subjected to collision-induced dissociation (CID), the [M + 2H]+* ions fragment to give products that were also observed as dissociation products during the electron transfer reaction. However, not all dissociation channels noted in the electron transfer reaction were observed in the CID of the [M + 2H]+* ions. The charge state of the peptide has a significant effect on both the extent of electron transfer dissociation observed and the variety of dissociation products, with higher charge states giving more of each.     

Transmission mode ion/ion proton transfer reactions in a linear ion trap

A new method is described for effecting ion/ion proton transfer reactions that involves storage of analyte ions while oppositely charged ions are transmitted through the stored ion population. In this approach, the products are captured and stored in the linear ion trap for subsequent mass analysis. Charge reduction of multiply charged protein ions is used as an example to illustrate the analytical usefulness of this method. In another variation of the transmission mode ion/ion reaction approach, two charge inversion experiments, implemented by passing analyte ions through a population of multiply charged reagent ions in a LIT, are also demonstrated. A pulsed dual ion source approach coupled with a hybrid triple quadrupole/linear ion trap instrument was used to demonstrate these two methods. The results for ion/ion reactions implemented using these so-called "transmission mode" experiments were comparable to those acquired using the more conventional mutual storage mode, both in terms of efficiency and information content of the spectra. An advantage of transmission mode experiments compared with mutual storage mode experiments is that they do not require any specialized measures to be taken to enable the simultaneous storage of oppositely charged ions.     

Analysis of ketones by selected ion flow tube mass spectrometry

A selected ion flow tube mass spectrometry (SIFT-MS) study of the reactions of H3O+, NO+ and O2+* ions with the ketones (M) 2-heptanone, 2-octanone, 2-nonanone, 2-undecanone and 2-aminoacetophenone has been conducted in preparation for studies of volatile emissions from bacteria. The H3O+ reactions all proceed rapidly via exothermic proton transfer, producing only MH+ ions that form their monohydrates when water vapour is present in the helium carrier gas. The O2+* reactions proceed rapidly via dissociative charge transfer producing parent cations M+* and some fragment ions. The NO+ reactions form the NO+M adduct ions at rates which are dependent on the pressure of the helium carrier gas. Combining the present NO+ kinetic data with those available from previous SIFT studies, the phenomenon of charge transfer complexing is clearly demonstrated. This results in adduct formation in these NO+/ketone reactions at or near the collisional rate. SIFT-MS spectra are presented to illustrate the simplicity of SIFT-MS analysis of ketones using both H3O+ and NO+ precursor ions.     

Beam-type collisional activation of polypeptide cations that survive ion/ion electron transfer

Doubly protonated peptides that undergo an electron transfer reaction without dissociation in a linear ion trap can be subjected to beam-type collisional activation upon transfer from the linear ion trap into an adjacent mass analyzer, as demonstrated here with a hybrid triple quadrupole/linear ion trap system. The activation can be promoted by use of a DC offset difference between the ion trap used for reaction and the ion trap into which the products are injected of 12-16 V, which gives rise to energetic collisions between the transferred ions and the collision/bath gas employed in the linear ion trap used for ion/ion reactions. Such a process can be executed routinely on hybrid linear ion trap/triple quadrupole tandem mass spectrometers and is demonstrated here with several model peptides as well as a few dozen tryptic peptides. Collisional activation of the peptide precursor ions that survive electron transfer frequently provides structural information that is absent from the precursor ions that fragment spontaneously upon electron transfer. The degree to which additional structural information is obtained by collisional activation of the surviving singly charged peptide ions depends upon peptide size. Little or no additional structural information is obtained from small peptides (<8 residues) due to the high electron transfer dissociation (ETD) efficiencies noted for these peptides as well as the extensive sequence information that tends to be forthcoming from ETD of such species. Collisional activation of the surviving electron transfer products provided greatest benefit for peptides of 8-15 residues.     

Charge location directs electron capture dissociation of peptide dications

The effect of peptide dication charge location on electron capture dissociation (ECD) fragmentation pattern is investigated. ECD fragmentation patterns are compared for peptides with amide and free acid C-terminal groups. ECD of free acid compared with C-terminally amidated peptides with basic residues near the N-terminus demonstrates increased formation of a-type ions. Similarly, ECD of free acid compared with C-terminally amidated peptides with basic residues near the C-terminus exhibits increased formation of y-type ions. Alteration of the peptide sequence to inhibit the formation of charged side chains (i.e., amino acid substitution and acetylation) provides further evidence for charge location effect on ECD. We propose that formation of zwitterionic peptide structures increases the likelihood of amide nitrogen protonation (versus basic side chains), which is responsible for the increase in a- and y-type ion formation.     

Strategies for generating peptide radical cations via ion/ion reactions

Several approaches for the generation of peptide radical cations using ion/ion reactions coupled with either collision induced dissociation (CID) or ultraviolet photo dissociation (UVPD) are described here. Ion/ion reactions are used to generate electrostatic or covalent complexes comprised of a peptide and a radical reagent. The radical site of the reagent can be generated multiple ways. Reagents containing a carbon–iodine (C―I) bond are subjected to UVPD with 266‐nm photons, which selectively cleaves the C―I bond homolytically. Alternatively, reagents containing azo functionalities are collisionally activated to yield radical sites on either side of the azo group. Both of these methods generate an initial radical site on the reagent, which then abstracts a hydrogen from the peptide while the peptide and reagent are held together by either electrostatic interactions or a covalent linkage. These methods are demonstrated via ion/ion reactions between the model peptide RARARAA (doubly protonated) and various distonic anionic radical reagents. The radical site abstracts a hydrogen atom from the peptide, while the charge site abstracts a proton. The net result is the conversion of a doubly protonated peptide to a peptide radical cation. The peptide radical cations have been fragmented via CID and the resulting product ion mass spectra are compared to the control CID spectrum of the singly protonated, even‐electron species. This work is then extended to bradykinin, a more broadly studied peptide, for comparison with other radical peptide generation methods. The work presented here provides novel methods for generating peptide radical cations in the gas phase through ion/ion reaction complexes that do not require modification of the peptide in solution or generation of non‐covalent complexes in the electrospray process. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Charge inversion via concurrent cation and anion transfer: application to corticosteroids

A novel charge inversion process that involves the removal of an excess cation from an analyte ion and the transfer of an anion to the neutral analyte in a single ion/ion encounter is described. Polyamidoamine (PAMAM) half-generation dendrimer anions that contain small anions, such as the chloride ion, were used as charge inversion reagents. Several competing processes can occur that include removal of the cation to neutralize the analyte, the removal of the excess cation and an additional proton to yield the deprotonated molecule, or removal of the excess cation and transfer of a small anion to the analyte. For the latter process to dominate, several requirements for both the reagent anion and the analyte cation must be met. The reagent anion must form multiply charged anions and must be able to incorporate one or more small anions for transfer. The analyte must have no strongly acidic sites as well as a relatively high affinity for small anion attachment. The PAMAM dendrimer anions must meet the conditions for the reagent anions and the cations of the corticosteroids meet the conditions for the analyte. The estrogenic steroid estrone, on the other hand, does not meet the requirements and, as a result, is largely neutralized when reacted with the reagent anions. This reaction, therefore, is highly selective and might serve as a useful reaction for the screening of appropriate analytes.     

Gas-phase basicities of histidine and lysine and their selected di- and tripeptides

The gas-phase basicities (GB) of histidine, lysine, and di- and triglycyl peptides containing either one histidine or one lysine residue have been determined. In all, 12 compounds were examined in a Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer. The GBs of the biomolecules were evaluated by proton transfer reactions employing a range of reference compounds with varying gas-phase basicities. In addition, the GBs were determined by using the kinetic method of collision-induced dissociation on a proton-bound dimer containing the peptide and a reference compound. The GBs of histidine and lysine were both found to be 220.8 kcal/mol via proton transfer reactions. The kinetic method experiments, including dissociation of a proton-bound dimer containing both histidine and lysine, also suggest equivalent GBs for these amino acids. However, the small peptides containing lysine are generally more basic than the corresponding histidine-containing peptides. For the peptides, the data suggest that the protonation site is on the basic side chain functional group of the histidine or lysine residues. The GBs of the di- and tripeptides are dependent upon the location of the basic residue. For example, the GBs of the tripeptides glycylglycyl-l-lysine (GlyGlyLys) and l-lysylglycylglycine (LysGlyGly) were both determined to be 230.7 kcal/mol while a GB of kcal/mol was obtained for glycyl-l-lysylglycine (GlyLysGly). A similar GB trend is seen with the histidine-containing tripeptides. Generally, the GBs obtained by using the kinetic method are slightly higher than those obtained by deprotonation reactions; however, the trends in relative GB values are essentially the same with the two techniques.