Discrete element method analysis of single wheel performance for a small lunar rover on sloped terrain

The purpose of this study is to analyze the performance of a lugged wheel for a lunar micro rover on sloped terrain by a 2D discrete element method (DEM), which was initially developed for horizontal terrain. To confirm the applicability of DEM for sloped terrain locomotion, the relationships of slope angle with slip, wheel sinkage and wheel torque obtained by DEM, were compared with experimental results measured using a slope test bed consisting of a soil bin filled with lunar regolith simulant. Among the lug parameters investigated, a lugged wheel with rim diameter of 250 mm, width of 100 mm, lug height of 10 mm, lug thickness of 5 mm, and total lug number of 18 was found, on average, to perform excellently in terms of metrics, such as slope angle for 20% slip, power number for self-propelled point, power number for 15-degree slope and power number for 20% slip. The estimation of wheel performance over sloped lunar terrain showed an increase in wheel slip, and the possibility exists that the selected lugged wheel will not be able to move up a slope steeper than 20°.     

Experimental and DEM analyses on wheel-soil interaction

In this paper, the wheel-soil interaction for a future lunar exploration mission is investigated by physical model tests and numerical simulations. Firstly, a series of physical model tests was conducted using the TJ-1 lunar soil simulant with various driving conditions, wheel configurations and ground void ratios. Then the corresponding numerical simulations were performed in a terrestrial environment using the Distinct Element Method (DEM) with a new contact model for lunar soil, where the rolling resistance and van der Waals force were implemented. In addition, DEM simulations in an extraterrestrial (lunar) environment were performed. The results indicate that tractive efficiency does not depend on wheel rotational velocity, but decreases with increasing extra vertical load on the wheel and ground void ratio. Rover performance improves when wheels are equipped with lugs. The DEM simulations in terrestrial environment can qualitatively reproduce the soil deformation pattern as observed in the physical model tests. The variations of traction efficiency against the driving condition, wheel configuration and ground void ratio attained in the DEM simulations match the experimental observations qualitatively. Moreover, the wheel track is found to be less evident and the tractive efficiency is higher in the extraterrestrial environment compared to the performance on Earth.     

2D FE–DEM analysis of tractive performance of an elastic wheel for planetary rovers

We have been developing a simulation program for use with soil–wheel interaction problems by coupling Finite Element Method (FEM) and Discrete Element Method (DEM) for which a wheel is modeled by FEM and soil is expressed by DEM. Previous two-dimensional FE–DEM was updated to analyze the tractive performance of a flexible elastic wheel by introducing a new algorithm learned from the PID-controller model. In an elastic wheel model, four structural parts were defined using FEM: the wheel rim, intermediate part, surface layer, and wheel lugs. The wheel rigidity was controlled by varying the Young’s Modulus of the intermediate part. The tractive performance of two elastic wheels with lugs for planetary rovers of the European Space Agency was analyzed. Numerical results were compared with experimentally obtained results collected at DLR Bremen, Germany. The FE–DEM result was confirmed to depict similar behaviors of tractive performance such as gross tractive effort, net traction, running resistance, and wheel sinkage, as in the results of experiments. Moreover, the tractive performance of elastic wheels on Mars was predicted using FE–DEM. Results clarified that no significant difference of net traction exists between the two wheels.     

Characteristics of normal and tangential forces acting on a single lug during translational motion in sandy soil

Lugs (i.e., grousers) are routinely attached to the surfaces of wheels/tracks of mobile robots to enhance their ability to traverse loose sandy terrain. Much previous work has focused on how lug shape, e.g., height, affects performance; however, the goal of this study is to experimentally confirm the effects of lug motion on lug–soil forces. We measured normal and tangential forces acting on a single lug as functions of inclination angle, moving direction angle, sinkage length, horizontal displacement, and traveling speed. The experimental results were mathematically fitted by using least square method to facilitate quantitative analyses on effects of changes in these motion parameters. Moreover, we compared the measured tangential forces to values calculated from a conventional tangential force model to evaluate the effects of the lug-tip surface, which is generally ignored in existing terramechanics models. The conclusions from this study would be useful for estimating the traveling performance of locomotive mechanisms equipped with lugs, modeling interaction mechanics between lugged wheels and soil, etc.     

Dynamic behaviour of an open lugged wheel under paddy soil conditions

Many experimental studies of open lugged wheel-soil interaction have been conducted, mainly based on the condition of constant slip and sinkage. As a result the reaction force to lugs seemed to be equal to the soil cutting resistance to a metal surface. However, analyses based on such methods do not appear to represent the actual behaviour of lugged wheel-soil interaction, especially when the lugs are spaced widely. The actual motion the wheel axle. In this study, an experimental device for a model lugged wheel was constructed to investigate the characteristics of the interaction between a lugged wheel and soil. Experiments were conducted under several test conditions of soil including paddy soil with a hard pan. The result of both theoretical and experimental data indicated that slip and sinkage of a lugged wheel showed a fluctuation with rotation angle of which the period is equal to the angular lug spacing. In each test soil condition used, the motion of the lugged wheel and the reaction forces acting on each lug from the soil for a free sinking wheel were different from that of the condition of constant slip and sinkage. It was found that the results obtained from this study could clarify the actual behaviour of lugged wheel-soil interaction.     

Soil-vehicle interaction

Progress in modelling, predicting and measuring soil-vehicle interaction performance is reviewed. Topics include soil properties, track systems, rigid and lugged wheels, pneumatic tyres and soil working systems. Methods range from the highly theoretical to the largely experimental. Substantial progress has been made in computer modelling methods for predicting the tractive performance of track systems and lugged wheels. A generally accepted method for describing the strength/deformation properties of surface soils has yet to evolve.     

Off-road tyre modelling II: effect of camber on tyre performance

The problem of off-road vehicle tyre-terrain interaction is that it is difficult to model accurately. For an off-road vehicle over medium to firm terrain, the tyre load may be entirely supported by the tips of the lugs, or with a minimum carcass contact with the terrain. In this case, the effect of the lugs should be taken into consideration. The forces at the interface between lugged tyre and the soil, including normal and shear stresses, are discussed in this paper. The multi-spoke tyre model was developed to study the effect of tyre lugs on the forces between tyre and terrain and it has been extended to predict the tyre forces and moments in the case of combined lateral and longitudinal slip for a cambered tyre. The influence of slip angle, camber angle and soil hardness on off-road tyre performance has been investigated. A computer program was developed using MATLAB software. The results were derived as tyre forces and moments in the three directions along the tyre contact length. A comparison between the results of the multi-spoke tyre model of a smooth off-road tyre and an off-road tyre with straight lugs, in the cambered case, has been made. The results indicated that slip angle, camber angle and soil characteristics have a strong effect on off-road tyre performance. The modified mathematical model results help the off-road tyre engineering designers to predict accurate values of tyre forces and moments in this complex case.     

Thrust and slip of a low-pressure tire on compressible ground by the compression-sliding approach

Driving wheels with low-pressure lugged tires are standard propulsion components of wheeled off-road vehicles. Such wheels have been mostly treated in theory as shorter tracks or even as “black boxes”. These procedures, however, appear not to be necessary since an updated theory of thrust generation, based on experiments with double-plate meter, was presented at the 2008 ISTVS Turin conference. This theory is based on the compaction-sliding (CS) concept, which claims that the rearward displacement of soil, a reason for slip, starts as horizontal soil compression by lugs (C-stage at lower thrust), followed by the slide of sheared off soil blocks (S-stage at higher thrust). The thrust in terms of ISTVS Standards equals gross tractive effort minus internal rolling resistance of a tire. The resultant thrust of a tire equals the sum of component thrusts of individual soil segments. The respective technique provides thrust-slip curves, which reflect tire size, loading, inflation pressure and tread pattern design, e.g. tread density, lug angle, pitch, height and tire casing lay-out and thus can be useful notably in assessing the traction properties of new tire designs. Concerning the evaluation of tire traction tests or similar applications, the CS approach offers a simplified version of thrust-slip formula (G-function), which complies with the CS concept and is easy to use.     

Traveling and abrasion characteristics of wheels for lunar exploration rover in vacuum

This paper investigates the traveling and abrasion characteristics of rigid wheels for a lunar exploration rover at atmospheric pressure and in a vacuum. For this investigation, a traveling test system that enables the wheel to continuously travel over a long distance was developed. Using this system, tests on traveling performance and abrasion were conducted with the wheel on a lunar regolith simulant surface. In the initial tests, various wheels traveled over different ground conditions and their performances were evaluated based on the relationship between the drawbar pull and slippage. In the later tests, a wheel with grousers traveled a distance of 3 km and the abrasion was analyzed at various intervals. From the traveling performance tests, it was found that for a soft ground condition, the traveling performance of the wheels in vacuum was slightly lower than that in atmosphere. This indicates that ground tests performed in atmosphere overestimate the actual performance on the lunar surface. The abrasion tests suggested that the scratching of wheels occurs more easily in vacuum than in atmosphere. These experiments confirmed that the abrasion of the wheels do not cause any critical problem for a traveling distance of up to 3 km in a simulated lunar environment.     

Experimental analysis of soil reaction on a lug of a movable lug wheel

A movable lug wheel was tested in a soil bin test apparatus to determine its traction performance and to measure the soil reaction forces on its lugs. Similar tests were also conducted using a fixed lug wheel. The effects of the lug motion pattern, lug spacing and horizontal load on pull and lift forces were studied. From the experiments it is confirmed that the movable action of the lug plate could generate superior pull and lift forces in comparison with the fixed lug wheel. Among the test wheels, lug motion pattern-2 generated the highest pull and lift forces. Within the range of the test conditions, there was no significant difference in pull and lift forces of the lug plate between the test lug wheels with 12 lugs and 15 lugs at the same level of horizontal and vertical loads. The increase of horizontal load up to 200 N generally increased the pull force and generated smaller rolling resistance before the lug left the soil, but did not increase the lift force significantly. The patterns of pull force, lift force and drawbar pull generated under a constant slip were slightly different from those under a constant horizontal load. Finally, the results were also elucidated by their actual lug trajectories in soil.     

Tractive performance analysis of a lugged wheel by open-source 3D DEM software

Open-source software (OSS) is free to use and has accessible source codes, thus, it can be modified by various users. By using OSS, it is possible to easily and economically develop a target program for interaction studies in terramechanics. Yet Another Dynamic Engine (YADE) is an OSS for the 3D discrete element method (DEM), but its applicability to various contact interaction problems in terramechanics is not well-known. To investigate the applicability of YADE in terramechanics, the tractive performance of a lugged wheel was analyzed in this study. An idea of a proportional-integral-differential control model was applied to realize the constant rotation of the wheel in YADE. Our previous experiments on the locomotion of a small lugged wheel on a lunar-soil simulant were analyzed by YADE, and the results were found to be qualitatively similar to the obtained experimental results when considering the effects of the lug height, lug thickness, lug number, and wheel diameter. By applying a quasi-2D analysis with the same soil bin width and wheel width, the computational load of 3D DEM by YADE can be reduced up to 36.8% with similar net traction behavior against the wheel slip in a 3D analysis.     

A method for predicting the internal motion resistance of rubber-tracked undercarriages,Pt. 2. A research on the motion resistance of road wheels

In spite of an increasing number of rubber-tracked crawlers, the literature provides few guidelines and calculation models suitable for minimizing their internal motion resistance. This article presents a model where the internal resistance of double-flanged road wheels for rubber-tracked vehicles is calculated as a sum of the losses resulting from the indentation of the wheels into the track surface and friction of the wheels against the track guide lugs. The model allows for vertical and lateral load of the wheels, the non-uniform distribution of the wheel pressure on the track, and the relationship between the friction coefficient and normal reaction force in the interface between the wheel and track guide lugs. The model has been verified by experiments. According to the results of model computations and experiments discussed in the article, the internal losses of a given rubber-tracked undercarriage might be reduced if: the road wheels are covered with a material that exhibits low friction coefficient and mechanical hysteresis, the vehicle suspension system features oscillating bogie wheels, the undercarriage is fitted with the largest possible number of road wheels, and the vehicle weight is evenly distributed to all of the road wheels.     

Systematic design and development of a flexible wheel for low mass lunar rover

Low mass compact rovers provide cost effective means to explore extra-terrestrial terrains. Use of flexible wheels in such applications where the wheel size is restricted, improves traction at reduced slip and sinkage. Design of a flexible wheel for a given mission is a challenging task requiring consideration of stiffness of rim and spokes, stress induced in the wheel, chassis movement during wheel rotation and the operating mode of the wheel. Also, accurate mathematical models are required to save design and development time and reduce the number of prototypes for selection. It is observed that most of the research papers deal with performance testing of flexible wheels and information on analytical formulation is scarce. Therefore, in the present work, a methodology has been formulated to systematically design a flexible wheel for a low mass lunar rover. The prototype performance is tested and compared with analytical estimates and reasons for difference are investigated. Paper contains details of design criteria, mathematical modelling, realisation of wheel prototype, test fixture and analysis test comparison. Authors believe that this work provides a useful aid to the designer to systematically design flexible wheels for low mass lunar rovers.     

Development of a data acquisition system for measuring the characteristics of real time forces by cage wheels

A new data acquisition system was introduced that could be used to monitor the real time wheel forces to solve the limitations of obtaining precise performance characteristics of actual cage wheels. Contrary to previous methods, in which the cage wheel forces were obtained by summing up the individual lug forces. The new method enables measurement of the components of lug force in three orthogonal directions simultaneously. A single unit dynamometer system, with two extended octagonal rings was designed and fabricated using a solid mild steel block, was able to measure force up to 5 kN in each direction. It was used in a soil-bin test rig to determine the characteristics of the forces produced by a cage wheel with opposing circumferential lugs. The characteristics of the pull and lift forces agreed with measured drawbar pull and calculated wheel forces respectively. The force signals fluctuated periodically with rotation angle and the corresponding period approximately equal to the interval of angular lug spacing. The side force fluctuated between positive and negative values and the average was closer to zero due to the balancing effect of opposing lugs. The new system showed better output compared to the previous attempts, confirming its applicability for accurate measurement of real time wheel forces.     

Design of manned lunar rover wheels and improvement in soil mechanics formulas for elastic wheels in consideration of deformation

Most of the current lunar rover vehicle wheels are inconvenient for changing broken wheels and have poor shock absorbing in driving, so they cannot be used to carry people on the moon. To meet the demands for manned lunar transportation, a new wheel possessing a woven metal wire mesh tire and using hub-rim combination slide mechanism is designed in this article. The characteristics of the new wheel is analyzed by comparing with the same-size conventional rover wheels after demonstrating the validity of FEM simulation. The new wheel possesses lighter structure and superior shock absorbing. It also provides stronger traction because the deformation of the designed wheel increases the contact area between the tire and lunar terrain. In order to establish an on-line soil parameter estimation algorithm for low cohesion soil, the stress distribution along a driven deformable wheel on off-road terrain is simplified. The basic mechanics equations of the interaction between the wheel and the lunar soil can be used for analytical analysis. Simulation results show that the soil estimation algorithm can accurately and efficiently identify key soil parameters for loose sand.     

Discrete element method-based studies on dynamic interactions of a lugged wheel with granular media

Terramechanics plays an important role in determining the design and control of autonomous robots and other vehicles that move on granular surfaces. Traction capabilities, slippage, and sinkage of a robot are governed by the interaction of a robot’s appendage with the operating terrain. It is important to understand how the terrain flows under this appendage during such an interaction. In this work, dynamics of soil performance and locomotion performance of a lugged wheel travelling on soft soil are numerically investigated. Studies are conducted with a two-dimensional model by using the discrete element method to analyze the interactions between a lugged wheel and the soil. The soil performance is studied by examining the force distribution and evolution of force networks during the course of the wheel travel. For two different control modes, namely, slip-based wheel control and angular velocity-based wheel control, the performance parameters such as, sinkage, traction, traction efficiency, and power consumption of the wheel are compared for various wheel configurations. The findings of this work are expected to be useful for optimal design and control of the lugged wheel travelling on deformable surfaces.     

Equivalent boundary model of lunar soil drilling simulation by DEM

Aiming to solve the computational cost problem in the discrete element simulation for lunar soil drilling sampling, an equivalent boundary method was proposed. A high-accuracy DEM model of lunar soil was established firstly. As the novel alterable constitutive law, the accuracy of the model was verified to meet the performance of real lunar soil very much both in shear strength indices and elastic–plastic behavior. A common drill bit in the geological exploration field for sampling soil was chosen as the simulation object. In preanalysis, it was known that with the increase of drilling depth, the stress concentration area was always near the drill bit, while the affected area of the lunar soil was a cylindrical area around the drill pipe, which extended towards the drilling direction instead of extending around it. Then a big boundary drilling simulation scene was established to investigate the flow direction of lunar soil particles. The motion law of particles and the velocity field information were obtained, and a U-shape chain was described around the drill bit. Finally an equivalent boundary was set near the U-shaped chain, and the size was determined by comparing the soil stress in the fierce collision zone and around the reference boundary. This method could be a reference for other lunar soil drilling researches with other drills of different sizes.     

Improvement of a power tiller cage wheel for use in swampy peat soils

This study was aimed at investigating traction performance of a cage wheel for use in swampy peat soils in Indonesia. The tests were conducted in a soil bin filled with peat soil taken from the swampy areas. A set up was developed to measure tractive performance of a single cage wheel. Deep sinkage and high wheel slip were identified as the major problems of using the existing cage wheel design in swampy peat soils. The results revealed that increasing the lug angle from 15 to 35° and the length of lug improved the tractive performance of the cage wheel significantly, while increasing the number of lugs from 14 to 18 and width of lug did not improve the tractive performance significantly. A cage wheel with lug size 325×80 mm, 35° lug angle, 14 lugs (26° lug spacing), with 2 circumferential flat rings installed on the inner side of the lugs, out performed the other settings for use with power tillers in swampy peat soils.     

Numerical and experimental studies of gravity effect on the mechanism of lunar excavations

In this paper, the mechanism of soil excavation in partial gravity conditions is investigated by experimental model and numerical study. Experiments were conducted in a parabolic flight, which generated different gravity conditions, focusing on the bearing capacity problem using two soil samples: Toyoura sand and Japanese lunar soil simulant (FJS-1). Corresponding numerical studies were performed by the discrete element method (DEM) for reduced gravity conditions. Herein, the DEM method was modified to include the apparent cohesion that was found in the lunar soil simulant. Two case studies were investigated by the numerical simulations: bearing capacity and soil pushing (as by a bulldozer), and for the former case comparison was made with experiment. Results show that the gravity greatly affects the ultimate bearing capacity of the Toyoura sand; however, such effect becomes insignificant in the lunar soil when the gravity is small or the soil was densely packed. By using the numerical model, this paper suggests that the ultimate bearing capacity observed in the lunar soil simulant was dominated by the apparent cohesive component, rather than gravity or friction. However, gravity causes similar effects on both soil models in the soil pushing problem.     

Experimental study and analysis on driving wheels’ performance for planetary exploration rovers moving in deformable soil

Planetary rovers are different from conventional terrestrial vehicles in many respects, making it necessary to investigate the terramechanics with a particular focus on them, which is a hot research topic at the budding stage. Predicting the wheel-soil interaction performance from the knowledge of terramechanics is of great importance to the mechanical design/evaluation/optimization, dynamics simulation, soil parameter identification, and control of planetary rovers. In this study, experiments were performed using a single-wheel testbed for wheels with different radii (135 and 157.35 mm), widths (110 and 165 mm), lug heights (0, 5, 10, and 15 mm), numbers of lugs (30, 24, 15, and 8), and lug inclination angles (0°, 5°, 10°, and 20°) under different slip ratios (0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.6, etc.). The influences of the vertical load (30 N, 80 N, and 150 N), moving velocity (10, 25, 40, and 55 mm/s), and repetitive passing (four times) were also studied. Experimental results shown with figures and tables and are analyzed to evaluate the wheels’ driving performance in deformable soil and to draw conclusions. The driving performance of wheels is analyzed using absolute performance indices such as drawbar pull, driving torque, and wheel sinkage and also using relative indices such as the drawbar pull coefficient, tractive efficiency, and entrance angle. The experimental results and conclusions are useful for optimal wheel design and improvement/verification of wheel-soil interaction mechanics model. The analysis methods used in this paper, such as those considering the relationships among the relative indices, can be referred to for analyzing the performance of wheels of other vehicles.