Studies of the binding mechanism between aptamers and thrombin by circular dichroism, surface plasmon resonance and isothermal titration calorimetry

Thrombin, a multifunctional serine protease, has both procoagulant and anticoagulant functions in human blood. Thrombin has two electropositive exosites. One is the fibrinogen-binding site and the other is the heparin-binding site. Over the past decade, two thrombin-binding aptamers (15-mer and 29-mer) were reported by SELEX technique. Recently, many studies examined the interactions between the 15-mer aptamer and thrombin extensively, but the data on the difference of these two aptamers binding to thrombin are still lacking and worth investigating for fundamental understanding. In the present study, we combined conformational data from circular dichroism (CD), kinetics and thermodynamics information from surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to compare the binding mechanism between the two aptamers with thrombin. Special attentions were paid to the formation of G-quadruplex and the effects of ions on the aptamer conformation on the binding and the kinetics discrimination between specific and nonspecific interactions of the binding. The results indicated reasonably that the 15-mer aptamer bound to fibrinogen-binding site of thrombin using a G-quadruplex structure and was dominated by electrostatic interactions, while the 29-mer aptamer bound to heparin-binding site thrombin using a duplex structure and was driven mainly by hydrophobic effects.     

Novel application of fluorescence coupled capillary electrophoresis to resolve the interaction between the G‐quadruplex aptamer and thrombin

The dynamic binding status between the thrombin and its G‐quadruplex aptamers and the stability of its interaction partners were probed using our previously established fluorescence‐coupled capillary electrophoresis method. A 29‐nucleic acid thrombin binding aptamer was chosen as a model to study its binding affinity with the thrombin ligand. First, the effects of the cations on the formation of G‐quadruplex from unstructured 29‐nucleic acid thrombin binding aptamer were examined. Second, the rapid binding kinetics between the thrombin and 6‐carboxyfluorescein labeled G‐quadruplex aptamer was measured. Third, the stability of G‐quadruplex aptamer–thrombin complex was also examined in the presence of the interfering species. Remarkably, it was found that the complementary strand of 29‐nucleic acid thrombin binding aptamer could compete with G‐quadruplex aptamer and thus disassociated the G‐quadruplex structure into an unstructured aptamer. These data suggest that our in‐house established fluorescence‐coupled capillary electrophoresis assay could be applied to binding studies of the G‐quadruplex aptamers, thrombin, and their ligands, while overcoming the complicated and costly approaches currently available.     

High-sensitive determination of human alpha-thrombin by its 29-mer aptamer in affinity probe capillary electrophoresis

ACE technique provides an effective tool for the separation and identification of disease-related biomarkers in clinical analysis. In recent years, a couple of synthetic DNA or RNA oligonucleotides, known as aptamers, rival the specificity and affinity for targets to antibodies and are employed as one kind of powerful affinity probe in ACE. In this work, based on high affinity between antithrombin aptamer and thrombin (their dissociation constant is 0.5 nM), a carboxyfluorescein-labeled 29-nucleotide (nt) aptamer (F29-mer) was used and an aptamer-based affinity probe CE (aptamer-based APCE) method was successfully established for high-sensitive detection and quantitative analysis of thrombin. Experimental conditions including incubation temperature and time, buffer composition, and concentration of cations were investigated and optimized. Under the optimized condition, the linear range was from 0 to 400 nM and the LOD was 2 nM (74 ng/mL, S/N = 3), i.e., 40 amol, both in running buffer and in 5% v/v human serum. This LOD is the lowest one than those achieved by the previous APCE methods but based on a 15-mer aptamer. This approach offers a promising method for the rapid, selective, and sensitive detection of thrombin in practical utility. Further binding experiments using one carboxyfluorescein-labeled aptamer and the other nonlabeled aptamer or vice versa were carried out to deduce the formation of ternary complex when these two aptamers coexisted in the free solution with thrombin.     

Chemiluminescent and Colorimetric Aptamer-Based Assays of Human α-Thrombin

Abstract

A microplate-based sandwich assay for the determination of α-human thrombin (HTb) was developed. Fluorescein-modified 29-mer thrombin binding aptamer (FAM-TBA29) and biotinylated 15-mer thrombin binding aptamer (Bio-TBA15) reacting with different exosites of HTb were used as the biorecognition components in the assay. FAM-TBA29 (capture aptamer) was immobilized using its interaction with anti-fluorescein antibody adsorbed on the microplate surface. As a sensitive signaling system, a combination of Bio-TBA15 and streptavidin-polyHRP conjugate was used. Under the optimized conditions, the detection limit for HTb was 1.4?nM; this value was the same in both the colorimetric and the chemiluminescent assays. The replacement of colorimetry for HRP measurement with chemiluminescence increased the assay sensitivity from 0.06 to 1.7?×?10⁶?nM^?1 that clearly demonstrated advantage of the latter approach.     

Aptamer sandwich assays: label-free and fluorescence investigations of heterogeneous binding events

We studied aptamer binding events in a heterogeneous format using label-free and fluorescence measurements for the purpose of developing an aptamer-based sandwich assay on a standard microtiter plate platform. The approach allowed visualization of the underlying aptamer immobilization and target binding events rather than relying on only an endpoint determination for method optimization. This allowed for a better understanding of these multi-step assays and optimal conditions specific to aptamers. α-thrombin was chosen as a prototypical analyte as two well-studied aptamers (15 and 29-mer) binding distinct epitopes are available. The Corning Epic? system, which utilizes a resonance waveguide diffraction grating in a 384-well microtiter plate format, was employed to measure relative immobilization and binding levels for various modified aptamers. Parameters investigated included the effects of aptamer orientation, label orientation, spacer length, spacer type, immobilization concentration, and binding buffer. Most notably, the 15-mer aptamer was preferable for capture over the 29-mer aptamer and aptamers with increasing poly(dT) spacer length between the biotin modification and the aptamer yielded decreased immobilization levels. This decreased immobilization resulted in increased α-thrombin binding ability for 15-mer aptamers with the poly(dT) spacer. Fluorescence measurements of fluorescein-labeled 29-mer aptamers with varying spacers were used to visualize sandwich complex formation. Using both label-free and traditional fluorescence measurements, an in-depth understanding of the overall assay was obtained, thus the inclusion of label-free measurements is recommended for future method development.     

Investigation of the interaction between a bivalent aptamer and thrombin by AFM

Aptamers are a new class of molecular probes for protein recognition, detection, and inhibition. Multivalent aptamer-protein binding through aptamer assembly has been currently developed as an effective way to achieve higher protein affinity and selectivity. In this study, the specific interaction between bivalent aptamer Bi-8S and thrombin has been measured directly and quantitatively by atomic force microscopy to investigate the unbinding dynamics and dissociation energy landscape of the multivalent interaction. Bivalent aptamer Bi-8S contains thrombin's two aptamers, 15apt and 27apt, which are linked by eight spacer phosphoramidites. The results revealed the sequential dissociation of the two aptamers. Moreover, the dynamic force spectroscopy data revealed that the 27apt's binding to the thrombin remains largely unaffected by the eight-spacer phosphoramidites within Bi-8S. In contrast, the eight-spacer phosphoramidites stabilized the 15apt-thrombin binding.     

Time-resolved fluorescence aptamer-based sandwich assay for thrombin detection

In the present study, the authors report a novel sensitive method for the detection of thrombin using time-resolved fluorescence sensing platform based on two different thrombin aptamers. The thrombin 15-mer aptamer as a capture probe was covalently attached to the surface of glass slide, and the thrombin 29-mer aptamer was fluorescently labeled as a detection probe. A bifunctional europium complex was used as the fluorescent label. The introduction of thrombin triggers the two different thrombin aptamers and thrombin to form a sandwich structure. The fluorescence intensity is proportional to the thrombin concentration. The present sensing system could provide both a wide linear dynamic range and a low detection limit. The proposed sensing system also presented satisfactory specificity and selectivity. Results showed that thrombin was retained at the aptamer-modified glass surface while nonspecific proteins were removed by rinsing with buffer solution. This approach successfully showed the suitability of aptamers as low molecular weight receptors on glass slides for sensitive and specific protein detection.     

Single-walled carbon nanotube biosensors using aptamers as molecular recognition elements

We report the real-time detection of protein using SWNT-FET-based biosensors comprising DNA aptamers as molecular recognition elements. Anti-thrombin aptamers that are highly specific to serine protein thrombin were immobilized on the sidewall of a SWNT-FET using CDI-Tween linking molecules. The binding of thrombin aptamers to SWNT-FETs causes a rightward shift of the threshold gate voltages, presumably due to the negatively charged backbone of the DNA aptamers. While the addition of thrombin solution causes an abrupt decrease in the conductance of the thrombin aptamer immobilized SWNT-FET, no noticeable change was observed with elastase.     

Molecularly imprinted aptamers of gold nanoparticles for the enzymatic inhibition and detection of thrombin

We prepared thrombin-binding aptamer-conjugated gold nanoparticles (TBA-Au NPs) through a molecularly imprinted (MP) approach, which provide highly efficient inhibition activity toward the polymerization of fibrinogen. Au NPs (diameter, 13 nm), 15-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA(15)) with different thymidine linkers, and 29-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA(29)) with different thymidine linkers (Tn) in the presence of thrombin (Thr) as a template were used to prepare MP-Thr-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-Tn-Au NPs. Thrombin molecules were then removed from Au NPs surfaces by treating with 100 mM Tris-NaOH (pH ca. 13.0) to form MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-Tn-Au NPs. The length of the thymidine linkers and TBA density on Au NPs surfaces have strong impact on the orientation, flexibility, and stability of MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-Tn-Au NPs, leading to their stronger binding strength with thrombin. MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs (ca. 42 TBA(15) and 42 TBA(29) molecules per Au NP; 15-mer thymidine on aptamer terminal) provided the highest binding affinity toward thrombin with a dissociation constant of 5.2 × 10(-11) M. As a result, they had 8 times higher anticoagulant (inhibitory) potency relative to TBA(15)/TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs (prepared in the absence of thrombin). We further conducted thrombin clotting time (TCT) measurements in plasma samples and found that MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs had greater anticoagulation activity relative to four commercial drugs (heparin, argatroban, hirudin, and warfarin). In addition, we demonstrated that thrombin induced the formation of aggregates from MP-TBA(15)-T(15)-Au NPs and MP-TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs, thereby allowing the colorimetric detection of thrombin at the nanomolar level in serum samples. Our result demonstrates that our simple molecularly imprinted approach can be applied for preparing various functional nanomaterials to control enzyme activity and targeting important proteins.     

Single-Round DNA Aptamer Selection by Combined Use of Capillary Electrophoresis and Next Generation Sequencing: An Aptaomics Approach for Identifying Unique Functional Protein-Binding DNA Aptamers

In DNA aptamer selection, existing methods do not discriminate aptamer sequences based on their binding affinity and function and the reproducibility of the selection is often poor, even for the selection of well-known aptamers like those that bind the commonly used model protein thrombin. In the present study, a novel single-round selection method (SR-CE selection) was developed by combining capillary electrophoresis (CE) with next generation sequencing. Using SR-CE selection, a successful semi-quantitative and semi-comprehensive aptamer selection for thrombin was demonstrated with high reproducibility for the first time. Selection rules based on dissociation equilibria and kinetics were devised to obtain families of analogous sequences. Selected sequences of the same family were shown to bind thrombin with high affinity. Furthermore, data acquired from SR-CE selection was mined by creating sub-libraries that were categorized by the functionality of the aptamers (e. g., pre-organized aptamers versus structure-induced aptamers). Using this approach, a novel fluorescent molecular recognition sensor for thrombin with nanomolar detection limits was discovered. Thus, in this proof-of-concept report, we have demonstrated the potential of a “DNA Aptaomics” approach to systematically design functional aptamers as well as to obtain high affinity aptamers.     

Aptamer-based electrochemical sensors that are not based on the target binding-induced conformational change of aptamers

This study describes a new kind of aptamer-based electrochemical sensor that is not based on the target binding-induced conformational change of the aptamers by using a 15-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (5'-GGTTGGTGTGGTTGG-3') as the model oligonucleotide. The sensors are developed by first self-assembling the aptamer (i.e. a thrombin-binding aptamer) onto an Au electrode and then hybridizing the assembled aptamer with a ferrocene (Fc)-labeled short aptamer-complementary DNA oligonucleotide to form an electroactive double-stranded DNA (ds-DNA) oligonucleotide onto the Au electrode. The binding of the target (i.e. thrombin) towards the aptamer essentially destroys the Watson-Crick helix structure of the ds-DNA oligonucleotide assembled onto the electrode and leads to the dissociation of the Fc-labeled short complementary DNA oligonucleotide from the electrode surface to the solution, resulting in a decrease in the current signal obtained at the electrode, which can be used for the determination of the target. With the thrombin-binding aptamer as the model oligonucleotide, the current decrease obtained with the aptamer-based electrochemical sensors is linear with the concentration of thrombin within the concentration range from 0 to 10 nM (DeltaI/nA = 6.7C(thrombin)/nM + 2.8, gamma = 0.975). Unlike most kinds of existing aptamer-based electrochemical sensor, the electrochemical aptasensors demonstrated here are not based on the conformational change of the aptamers induced by the specific target binding. Moreover, the aptasensors are essentially label-free and are very responsive toward the targets. This study may pave a facile and general way to the development of aptamer-based electrochemical sensors.     

Assessment of aptamer-steroid binding using stacking-enhanced capillary electrophoresis

The binding affinity of 17β-estradiol with an immobilized DNA aptamer was measured using capillary electrophoresis. Estradiol captured by the immobilized DNA was injected into the separation capillary using pH-mediated sample stacking. Stacked 17β-estradiol was then separated using micellar electrokinetic capillary chromatography and detected with UV-visible absorbance. Standard addition was used to quantify the concentration of estradiol bound to the aptamer. Following incubation with immobilized DNA, analysis of free and bound estradiol yielded a dissociation constant of 70 ± 10 μM. The method was also used to screen binding affinity of the aptamer for estrone and testosterone. This study demonstrates the effectiveness of capillary electrophoresis to assess the binding affinity of DNA aptamers.     

Direct Measurement of Through-Bond Effects in Molecular Multivalent Interactions

Multivalent interactions occur throughout biology, and have a number of characteristics that monovalent interactions do not. However, it remains challenging to directly measure the binding force of molecular multivalent interactions and identify the mechanism of interactions. In this study, the specific interaction between bivalent aptamer and thrombin has been measured directly and quantitatively by force-induced remnant magnetization spectroscopy to investigate the binding force and through-bond effects of the multivalent interactions. The measured differential binding forces enable through-bond effects in thrombin–aptamer complexes to be identified, where aptamer binding at exosite II produces visible effects on their binding at exosite I and vice versa. This method might be suitable for practical applications in the design of high-performance ligands.     

Poly(methyl methacrylate) microchip affinity capillary gel electrophoresis of aptamer-protein complexes for the analysis of thrombin in plasma

Thrombin generation in blood serves as an important marker for various hemostasis-related diseases and conditions. Analytical techniques currently utilized for determining the thrombin potential of patients rely primarily on the enzymatic activity of thrombin. Microfluidic-based ACE using fluorescently labeled aptamers as affinity probes could provide a simple and efficient technique for the real-time analysis of thrombin levels in plasma. In this study, aptamers were used for the analysis of thrombin by affinity microchip CGE. The CGE used a poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) microfluidic device for the sorting of the affinity complexes with a linear polyacrylamide (LPA) serving as the sieving matrix. Due to the fact that the assay was run under nonequilibrium electrophoresis conditions, the presence of the sieving gel was found to stabilize the affinity complex, providing improved electrophoretic performance compared to free-solution electrophoresis. Two fluorescently labeled aptamer affinity probes, HD1 and HD22, which bind to exosites I and II, respectively, of thrombin were investigated. With an electric field strength of 300 V/cm, two well-resolved peaks corresponding to free aptamer and the thrombin-aptamer complex were obtained in less than 1 min of separation time with a run-to-run and chip-to-chip reproducibility (RSD) of migration times <10% using both aptamers. HD22 affinity assays of thrombin produced baseline-resolved peaks with favorable efficiency due to its higher binding affinity, whereas HD1 assays showed poorer resolution of the free aptamer and complex peaks. HD22 was used in determining the level of thrombin in human plasma. Assays were performed directly on plasma that was diluted to 10% v/v. Thrombin was successfully analyzed by microchip CGE at a concentration level of 543.5 nM for the human plasma sample.     

Highly efficient control of thrombin activity by multivalent nanoparticles

We have demonstrated that the incorporation of sulfated galactose acid (sulf-Gal) into thrombin-binding-aptamer (TBA)-conjugated gold nanoparticles (TBA-AuNPs) enables highly effective inhibition of thrombin activity toward fibrinogen. AuNP bioconjugates (TBA(15)/TBA(29)/sulf-Gal-AuNPs) were prepared from 13 nm AuNPs, 15-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA(15)), 29-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA(29)), and sulf-Gal. The numbers of TBA and sulf-Gal molecules per AuNP proved to have a strong impact on inhibitory potency. The best results were observed for 15-TBA(15)/TBA(29)/sulf-Gal-AuNPs (with 15 TBA(15) and 15 TBA(29) molecules per AuNP), which, because of their particularly flexible conformation and multivalency, exhibited ultrahigh binding affinity toward thrombin (K(d)=3.4×10(-12) M) and thus extremely high anticoagulant (inhibitory) potency. Compared to the case without inhibitors (the "normal" value), their measured thrombin clotting time (TCT) was 91 times longer, whereas for TBA(15) alone it was only 7.2 times longer. Their anticoagulant activity was suppressed by TBA-complementary-sequence (cTBA)-modified AuNPs (cTBA(15)/cTBA(29)-AuNPs) at a rate that was 20 times faster than that of free cTBA(15)/cTBA(29). Thus, easily prepared, low-cost, multivalent AuNPs show great potential for biomedical control of blood clotting.     

Aptamer binding assays for proteins: The thrombin example—A review

Experimentally selected single-stranded DNA and RNA aptamers are able to bind to specific target molecules with high affinity and specificity. Many analytical methods make use of affinity binding between the specific targets and their aptamers. In the development of these methods, thrombin is the most frequently used target molecule to demonstrate the proof-of-principle. This paper critically reviews more than one hundred assays that are based on aptamer binding to thrombin. This review focuses on homogeneous binding assays, electrochemical aptasensors, and affinity separation techniques. The emphasis of this review is placed on understanding the principles and unique features of the assays. The principles of most assays for thrombin are applicable to the determination of other molecular targets.     

基于铁氰化镍的非标记型核酸适配体电化学传感器检测凝血酶

在玻碳电极（GCE）表面首先用增敏作用的多壁碳纳米管(MWCNTs)夹心于两层电沉积的铁氰化镍（NiHCF）氧化还原电化学探针之间,然后以金纳米粒子为固定核酸适配体的载体,构建了检测凝血酶的非标记型核酸适配体生物传感器。 利用扫描电子显微镜(SEM)对MWCNTs和NiHCF的形貌进行了表征。 利用电化学阻抗谱对传感器的组装过程进行了监测,用循环伏安法（CV）和差分脉冲伏安法（DPV）对传感器的电化学行为进行了研究。 以铁氰化镍为探针的传感器对凝血酶的检测在1.0 ng/L~1.0 mg/L范围内呈良好的线性关系,相关系数为0.998,检测限为0.2 ng/L(S/N=3)。     

Effect of the immobilisation of DNA aptamers on the detection of thrombin by means of surface plasmon resonance

We report a multichannel surface plasmon resonance (SPR) sensor for detection of thrombin via DNA aptamers immobilized on the SPR sensor surface. A detailed investigation of the effect of the immobilisation method on the interaction between thrombin and DNA aptamers is presented. Three basic approaches to the immobilisation of aptamers on the surface of the SPR sensor are examined: (i) immobilisation based on chemisorption of aptamers modified with SH groups, (ii) immobilisation of biotin-tagged aptamers via previously immobilized avidin, neutravidin or streptavidin molecular linkers, and (iii) immobilisation employing dendrimers as a support layer for subsequent immobilisation of aptamers. A level of nonspecific binding of thrombin to immobilized human serum albumin (HSA) for each of the immobilisation methods is determined. Immobilisation of aptamers by means of the streptavidin–biotin system yields the best results both in terms of sensor specificity and sensitivity.     

Screening and preliminary application of a DNA aptamer for rapid detection of Salmonella O8

We report on a rapid method for the detection of Salmonella O8. It does not require an enrichment step but rather uses an aptamer as a probe that was selected by system evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX) assay. Firstly, aptamer against Salmonella O8 was selected from a 78 bp random DNA library that was prepared in-vitro. The binding ability of the aptamers to target bacterium was examined by aptamer-linked immobilized sorbent assay. A high affinity aptamer was successfully selected from the initial random DNA pool, and its secondary structure was also investigated. Next, this high affinity aptamer B10 was used to recognize Salmonella O8 via fluorescence microscopy. The selected aptamer has a high specificity and high affinity against its target. We believe that the resulting fluorescence in-situ labeling assay is a potentially useful alternative in rapid screening and detection of foodborne pathogens.