Dependence of chiral separations on the amount of cyclodextrins as selectors, employing the partial filling technique in capillary zone electrophoresis

Summary The enantioselectivity, resolution factor and migration times for some local anaesthetic drugs were evaluated at different selector concentrations and plug lengths with different cyclodextrins as chiral selectors using the partial filling technique. The resolution remained constant when equal amounts of the chiral selector at a concentration below the optimal concentration were introduced in the capillary. However, the selectivity factor increased with increasing concentration of the chiral selector.     

Principle and applications of the partial filling technique in capillary electrophoresis

Summary The partial filling technique (PFT) in capillary electrophoresis (CE) is an efficient system where, only 50–800 nanolitres of a chiral selector solution needs to be added to each run. PFT is especially applicable when these additives to the background electrolyte (BGE) are expensive or absorb UV light. The selector dissolved in the BGE is applied to the capillary as a plug, shorter than the effective length of the capillary, prior to application of the analyte. During the run both ends of the capillary are connected to the BGE. The applied plug and the analyte may move in opposite directions or in the same direction at different velocities depending on their electrophoretic mobilities. Thus the final plug length is either longer or shorter than the original length. The technique has been successfully applied in a number of studies including enantiomeric separation with a variety of selectors, and for the determination of conditional association constants. Taken from Dr. Pharm. Sc. Thesis, A. Amini, Uppsala, 1998.     

Evaluation of quail egg white riboflavin binding protein as a chiral selector in capillary electrophoresis by applying a modified partial filling technique.

A preliminary evaluation of the enantioselective properties of quail egg yolk riboflavin binding protein (qRfBP) was carried out in capillary electrophoresis by using the complete filling technique. The most promising results obtained by this screening of nineteen chiral drugs were singled out with the aim of optimizing enantiomer separations by applying the partial filling technique, which allows operating at much higher protein concentrations without detection problems. The building of the separation zone in the partial filling technique has been modified in order to enable on-line monitoring, before each run, of the actual protein plug application velocity and, consequently, the building of a plug of the desired length. The electrophoretic conditions chosen gave opposite migration directions for the chiral selector and the analytes, with qRfBP migrating away from the detector. A polyvinyl alcohol-coated capillary was first totally filled with protein and the optimal plug length was obtained by further applying negative pressure together with positive voltage for the time needed. Separations of basic drugs were optimized by using protein concentrations ranging from 200 microM up to 900 microM and different plug lengths, while the running buffer pH (6.0), temperature (25 degrees C) and operating voltage (+20 kV) were kept constant. The enantioresolution of all solutes was affected by both the chiral selector concentration and protein plug length. Baseline separations were obtained for oxprenolol, prilocaine and bupivacaine.     

Fast enantiomeric separation with vancomycin as chiral additive by co-electroosmotic flow capillary electrophoresis: increase of the detection sensitivity by the partial filling technique

A fast and sensitive method is described by using vancomycin as a chiral additive for enantiomeric separation by capillary electrophoresis (CE). In order to overcome disadvantages associated with use of vancomycin as chiral additive in CE, several strategies including the dynamic coating technique, the co-electroosmotic flow technique, and the partial filling technique were employed sequentially in this method. Using the polycationic polymer hexadimethrine bromide (HDB) as a buffer additive, the capillary wall was dynamically coated with a thin film formed by the adsorbed HDB. Consequently, the adsorption of vancomycin onto the capillary wall was minimized via electrostatic repulsion between the coating of the capillary wall and the vancomycin molecule. In addition, the reversed electroosmotic flow (from cathode to anode) produced by the positively charged capillary wall migrates in the same direction of negatively charged analytes (co-electroosmotic flow electrophoresis). Thereby the electrophoretic mobility of negatively charged analytes were drastically accelerated leading to a short separation time of less than 3.4 min. The separation time was further reduced by the use of a short-end-injection technique. For example, the analysis time was achieved by as short as 55 s for a baseline separation of dansyl-alpha-amino-n-butyric acid. Concurrently, the partial filling technique was used to avoid the loss of detection sensitivity caused by the presence of vancomycin in the running buffer. The effect of several parameters, such as HDB concentration, buffer pH, plug length of the chiral selector, concentration of the chiral selector and applied voltage, on enantioselectivity were investigated toward optimization. Besides the advantage of a very short separation time, the method is characterized by high detection sensitivity, high selectivity, and high efficiency.     

Partial filling technique in capillary electrophoresis for the separation of phenolic isomers with sulfonatocalix[4]arene as a selector

p-Sulfonatocalix[4]arene was used as a selector in capillary electrophoresis to separate phenolic positional isomers. To avoid the detection interference caused by the high UV absorption of calixarene, the partial filling technique was applied. The operation variables, including buffer, separation voltage, the concentration of the selector and the plug length of the selector zone, were systematically optimized. The detection limits of mass were in the range of 0.07-0.28 pg. Molecular modeling was used to explain the interaction between calixarene and phenolic isomers.     

Simultaneous separation and enantioresolution of racemic local anesthetic drugs by capillary zone electrophoresis with Tween 20 and methyl-beta-cyclodextrin as selectors, employing a double plug technique

A new approach for simultaneous chiral and achiral separations by capillary zone electrophoresis is described. Two adjacent selector plugs, consisting of Tween 20 as an achiral and methyl-beta-cyclodextrin (CD) as a chiral selector, are employed and four related local anesthetics are used as model compounds. The principles of the partial filling technique, whereby the capillary is filled with the chiral selector solution followed by the micellar solution at different plug lengths and concentrations, prior to application of the solutes, was employed. During the run both capillary ends were dipped in a simple buffer, i.e., one without additives. The two separation media worked independently without any interaction. Separation of the solutes and their enantiomers was regulated by adjusting both the concentration and plug length (PL) of the micellar solution in the capillary, employing methyl beta-CD as chiral selector either at 38 or 76 mM. The solutes were separated on the basis of their affinity towards the micellar phase before they reached the methyl-beta-CD plug for enantioseparation. In the absence of the micellar plug, the enantiomers of prilocaine overlapped those of bupivacaine. The solutes and their enantiomers were completely separated by employing two adjacent plugs consisting of 100 mM Tween 20 solution (PL approximately 10 cm) and methyl-beta-CD solution at either 38 or 76 mM (PL approximately 30 cm).     

Efficient applications of capillary electrophoresis-tandem mass spectrometry to the analysis of adrenoreceptor antagonist enantiomers using a partial filling technique

Throughout the separation of chiral basic drugs by capillary electrophoresis (CE) with neutral hydroxypropyl-beta-cyclodextrin (HP-beta-CD) as chiral selector, the sensitivity of detection can be improved by using tandem mass spectrometric (MS-MS) detection with a partial filling technique rather than with UV spectrometric detection. Prior to sample injection. the capillary was partly filled with HP-beta-CD dissolved in volatile ammonium formate buffer (pH 4, ionic strength 50 mM). The effects of modifying the HP-beta-CD concentration in the selector zone and the length of the separation zone on the enantioresolution and the signal-to-noise ratio of the pseudo-molecular MH+ ion were investigated. For a given selector zone length, as the concentration of the neutral cyclodextrin increases, the resolution between enantiomers becomes higher (the opposite of the behavior of the signal-to-noise ratio) and then reaches an optimum value. The decrease of the selector zone length lowered the resolution between the enantiomers but increased peak efficiencies and signal-to-noise ratio values. Accordingly, partial capillary filling at 80% (v/v) and 10 mM concentration of HP-beta-CD was selected as a suitable compromise between resolution and sensitivity of MS detection. Limits of detection for each adrenoreceptor antagonist enantiomer were 5 ng/ml (0.02 microM) in CE-MS-MS instead of 150 ng/ml (0.60 microM) in CE-UV, which enhances sensitivity by a factor of 30.     

Evaluation of balhimycin as a chiral selector for enantioresolution by capillary electrophoresis

The glycopeptide antibiotic balhimycin and its haloanalogue bromobalhimycin were evaluated as chiral selectors for enantioresolution by capillary electrophoresis. In order (i) to eliminate the adsorption of the glycopeptide antibiotics on the capillary wall, (ii) to shorten the separation time and (iii) to improve the detection sensitivity, a combined approach of the dynamic surface coating technique, the co-electroosmotic flow electrophoresis technique and the partial filling technique was employed for the enantioresolution of 16 acidic racemates. The effect of experimental parameters (plug length of the partial filling solution containing the chiral selector, selector concentration and buffer pH) on enantiorecognition was investigated. Furthermore, the enantiorecognition ability imparted by balhimycin, bromobalhimycin and vancomycin were compared. For most tested compounds, the highest enantiorecognition was obtained with balhimycin as chiral selector. Only in the case of the enantioresolution of tiaprofenic acid, vancomycin showed a superior enantiorecognition.     

Enantioseparation of tartaric acid by ligand‐exchange capillary electrophoresis using contactless conductivity detection

A method for the determination of tartaric acid enantiomers using CE with contactless conductivity detection has been developed. Cu(II) as a central metal ion together with l ‐hydroxyproline were used as a chiral selector, the BGE was composed of 7 mM CuCl_2, 14 mM trans‐4‐hydroxy‐l ‐proline, and 100 mM ε‐aminocaproic acid; the pH was adjusted to 5 by hydrochloric acid. Separation with a resolution of 1.9 was achieved in 9 min in a polyacrylamide‐coated capillary to suppress the EOF. Various counterions of the BGE were studied, and migration order reversal was achieved when switching from ε‐aminocaproic acid to l ‐histidine. With detection limits of about 20 μM, the method was applied to the analysis of wine and grape samples; only l ‐tartaric acid was found.     

Sequence requirements of oligonucleotide chiral selectors for the capillary electrophoresis resolution of low‐affinity DNA binders

We recently reported that a great variety of DNA oligonucleotides (ONs) used as chiral selectors in partial‐filling capillary electrophoresis (CE) exhibited interesting enantioresolution properties toward low‐affinity DNA binders. Herein, the sequence prerequisites of ONs for the CE enantioseparation process were studied. First, the chiral resolution properties of a series of homopolymeric sequences (Poly‐dT) of different lengths (from 5 to 60‐mer) were investigated. It was shown that the size increase‐dependent random coil‐like conformation of Poly‐dT favorably acted on the apparent selectivity and resolution. The base‐unpairing state constituted also an important factor in the chiral resolution ability of ONs as the switch from the single‐stranded to double‐stranded structure was responsible for a significant decrease in the analyte selectivity range. Finally, the chemical diversity enhanced the enantioresolution ability of single‐stranded ONs. The present work could lay the foundation for the design of performant ON chiral selectors for the CE separation of weak DNA binder enantiomers.     

Determination of the enantiomers of α‐hydroxy‐ and α‐amino acids in capillary electrophoresis with contactless conductivity detection

The enantiomers of the anions of five α‐hydroxy acids, namely lactic acid, α‐hydroxybutyric acid, 2‐hydroxycaproic acid, 2‐hydroxyoctanoic acid and 2‐hydroxydecanoic acid, as well as the two α‐amino acids aspartic acid and glutamic acid, were baseline separated and detected by CE with contactless conductivity detection. Vancomycin was employed as chiral selector and could be used with conductivity detection without having to resort to a partial filling protocol as needed when this reagent is used with UV absorbance measurements. The procedure was successfully applied to the determination of the lactic acid enantiomers in samples of milk and yogurt. Linearity was achieved in the concentration range of 10–500 μmol/L with good correlation coefficients (0.9993 and 0.9990 for L ‐ and D ‐lactic acid, respectively). The LODs (3 S/N) for L ‐ and D ‐lactic acid were determined as 2.8 and 2.4 μmol/L, respectively.     

Label‐free aptamer‐based partial filling technique for enantioseparation and determination of dl‐tryptophan with micellar electrokinetic chromatography

In this study, a simple and reproducible method for enantioseparation and determination of dl ‐tryptophan (dl ‐T rp) was developed by using a partial filling technique in combination with MEKC . The corresponding l ‐T rp specific DNA aptamer was used as a chiral selector. Sodium cholate was used to form the chiral micelles and to enhance the enantioseparation of the enantiomers. Effects of aptamer concentration, filling time, buffer composition, and separation voltage on the enantioseparation were evaluated. The M g²⁺ and Na⁺ concentration in separation buffer was found to effectively affect the separation efficiency and reproducibility. Under the optimal conditions, d ‐ and l ‐T rp were completely enantioseparated in less than 9 min. This aptamer‐based partial‐filling approach has the potential to be extended to the separation of other enantiomers after the replacement of corresponding specific aptamers.     

Electrokinetic partial filling technique as a powerful tool for enantiomeric separation of DL-lactic acid by CE with contactless conductivity detection

A modified partial filling method for chiral separation of DL-lactic acid as the model chiral compound with vancomycin chloride as the chiral selector was developed by CE with contactless conductivity detection. Electrokinetic partial filling technique (EK-PFT) was used as an alternative method to the conventional hydrodynamic partial filling method. EK-PFT, in contrast to the hydrodynamic partial filling technique, allowed the removal of the chloride counterions from the chiral selector which otherwise led to poor sensitivity in conductivity detection. The baseline separation of DL-lactic acid as the model analyte was achieved in 5 min in a polyacrylamide-coated capillary. The best resolution was achieved by electrokinetic partial filling of vancomycin cations from the injection solution containing 5 mmol/L oxalate L-histidinium at pH 4.5 with 10 mmol/L vancomycin chloride. Computer simulation was used to explain the observed phenomena in the boundary between the inject vial and the capillary during the EK-PFT of vancomycin cations.     

Affinity capillary electrophoresis coupling with partial filling technique and field‐amplified sample injection for enantioseparation and determination of DL‐tetrahydropalmatine

A novel, simple and sensitive method for the enantioseparation and determination of DL ‐tetrahydropalmatine (DL ‐THP) was developed using ACE in combination with partial filling technique and field‐amplified sample injection. A chiral selector, i.e. BSA, was used for the enantioseparation of DL ‐THP in ACE. Effects of BSA concentration, pH and separation voltage on the effectiveness of the enantiomer separation were evaluated. In an optimal condition, D ‐ and L ‐THP were completely enantio‐separated in less than 9 min by partially filling an electrophoretic capillary with 50 μmol/L BSA (50 mbar, 100 s) and carrying out an electrophoresis with 20 mmol/L phosphate buffer (pH 7.4) at 15 kV. The sensitivity was further improved by making use of field‐amplified sample injection to lower the LOD (defined as S/N=3) down to 6 ng/mL. Real samples were also tested and promising results for the determination of DL ‐THP enantiomers were obtained.     

Cellulases from the fungi Phanerochaete chrysosporium and Trichoderma reesei as chiral selectors in capillary electrophoresis: applications with displacer plugs and sample preconcentration

The cellulases CBH 58 from the fungus Phanerochaete chrysosporium and CBH I from the fungus Trichoderma reesei were compared as chiral selectors in capillary electrophoresis (CE) applying the partial filling technique. Amines, e.g., norephedrine, two bambuterol analogs, as well as acids, e.g., di-p-toluoyl tartaric acid and dibenzoyl tartaric acid, which could not be enantioseparated in the liquid chromatographic use of the selectors, could be separated in the corresponding CE experiments. Due to the very high enantioselectivities, terbutaline, alprenolol and propranolol could be completely enantioresolved with selector plugs shorter than the sample plugs. The affinity of propranolol to CBH 58 was so high at pH 7.0 that neither of the enantiomers reached the detector; therefore, a plug of the displacing disaccharide cellobiose was injected after the sample to elute the propranolol enantiomers. The enantiomers could also be made to leave the capillary at opposite ends, thereby causing an infinite enantioresolution. A new preconcentration technique was introduced, which takes advantage of the very high affinity of propranolol to CBH 58 and the eluting ability of cellobiose. A 12.5 cm long plug of rac-propranolol could be preconcentrated and enantioseparated in a single procedure.     

Simultaneous stereoselective analysis of tramadol and its main phase I metabolites by on-line capillary zone electrophoresis-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

On-line combination of partial filling capillary electrophoresis and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry was demonstrated for the simultaneous enantioseparation of tramadol and its main phase I metabolites. The partial filling technique was efficient at avoiding MS contamination by the chiral selector. Different experimental factors were investigated, including the chiral selector nature and concentration, plug length as well as the separation temperature. The best enantioseparation of the investigated compounds was achieved with a coated polyvinyl alcohol capillary and a 40 mM ammonium acetate buffer, pH 4.0, adding sulfobutyl ether beta-cyclodextrin (2.5 mg/ml) as the chiral selector. The charged cyclodextrin not only allowed enantioseparation of tramadol and its metabolites, but also improved the selectivity of compounds with the same molecular mass. Finally, CE-electrospray ionisation-MS was successfully applied to the stereoselective analysis of tramadol and its main metabolites in plasma after a simple liquid-liquid extraction.     

Development of a CE‐MS2 method for the enantiomeric separation of L/D‐carnitine: Application to the analysis of infant formulas

A new chiral analytical method based on CE‐MS is proposed for the identification and simultaneous quantification of D /L ‐carnitine in infant formulas. Previous derivatization of carnitine with FMOC enabled the optimization of the chiral separation using CE with UV detection. An optimization of electrospray‐MS parameters using a partial filling of the non‐volatile chiral selector (succinyl‐γ‐CD) was performed. A selective fragmentation using MS² experiments with an ion trap analyser was carried out to confirm the identity of D /L ‐carnitine according to the current legislation. Satisfactory results were obtained in terms of linearity, precision, and accuracy. Interestingly, the CE‐MS² method developed allowed a sensitivity enhancement with respect to UV detection of 100‐fold, obtaining an LOD of 100 ng/g for D ‐carnitine. The determination of L ‐carnitine and its enantiomeric purity in 14 infant formulas supplemented with carnitine was successfully achieved, sample preparation only requiring an ultrafiltration with centrifugal filter devices to retain the components with the highest molecular weights.     

Experimental designs to investigate capillary electrophoresis-electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry enantioseparation with the partial-filling technique

An experimental design approach is described to evaluate the main electrophoretic parameters involved in the enantioseparation of pharmaceuticals by capillary electrophoresis (CE) coupled to electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). For all experiments, the partial-filling technique was applied to avoid the chiral selector entering in the mass spectrometer ion source with a negative effect on the electrospray performance. To carry out enantioseparation, a volatile buffer constituted of 20 mM ammonium acetate at pH 4.0, and a polyvinyl alcohol-coated capillary were used. Methadone was employed as the model compound and three different cyclodextrins (CDs), namely sulfobutyl ether-beta-CD, carboxymethylated-beta-CD and hydroxypropyl-beta-CD, were selected in order to study the countercurrent process. Two different experimental designs were chosen: (i) a full-factorial design to examine the effects and significance of the investigated factors, and (ii) a central composite face-centered design to establish the mathematical model of the selected responses in function of experimental factors. The chiral selector concentration, percentage of the capillary filled with the chiral selector, and drying gas nebulization pressure were three relevant factors taken into consideration. For each CD, the methadone enantiomeric resolution, apparent selectivity, and migration time of the second enantiomer were established as responses. The latter were systematically related to experimental parameters with the help of multiple linear regression. It is noteworthy that the behaviour was different in function of the chiral selector charge. Results revealed that the nebulization pressure involved in the electrospray process and the CD concentration had a significant effect on the enantiomeric resolution, while the effect of the separation zone length was less pronounced. Finally, response surfaces were drawn from the mathematical model and experimental conditions were selected to allow a robust determination of methadone enantiomers by CE-MS.     

Synthesis and application of clindamycin succinate as a novel chiral selector for capillary electrophoresis

A novel chiral selector, clindamycin succinate, was synthesized and first used as a chiral selector in capillary electrophoresis (CE). The chiral resolution ability of this kind of clindamycin derivation was studied by CE using some racemic drugs as model analytes. From the experimental results, it was found that both resolution and selectivity of the selector were dependent on the following parameters: concentration of chiral selectors, pH of the running buffer, temperature of the capillary column, applied voltage and organic modifier used. The results show that the chiral selector possesses high resolution toward some racemic drugs, including ofloxacin, chlorphenamine, tryptophan, propranolol, sotalol and metoprolol. Excellent chiral resolution of these tested drugs was achieved under the optimal conditions of 50 mM clindamycin succinate, 10% MeOH v/v, 50 mM Tris buffer, pH 4.0, at 22 kV and 20 °C within 25 min.     

Separation of enantiomers by capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry employing a partial filling technique with a chiral crown ether

Enantiomer separations were performed by capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (CE-MS) with (+)-(18-crown-6)-2,3,11,12-tetracarboxylic acid (18C6H4) as a chiral selector. In order to prevent the introduction of the nonvolatile chiral, selector, 18C6H4, into the nozzle of the CE-MS interface and/or the orifice plate, a partial filling technique was employed in this study. By the partial filling technique, the contamination caused by the nonvolatile chiral selector was avoided not only during the analysis but also during the washing of capillary with the separation solution prior to the run. Several racemic compounds having a primary amino group were successfully separated. Racemic 3-aminopyrrolidine and racemic alpha-amino-epsilon-caprolactam have no strong UV absorption, but such compounds were detected with a high sensitivity by MS detection. In this paper, the effects of the length of separation zone and those of the 18C6H4 concentration were described. As the length of the separation zone was longer or as the concentration of 18C6H4 was higher, the enantiomer resolution was enhanced more and more. However, the optimization of 18C6H4 concentration was practically enough to obtain the baseline separation.