Designs of experiment for proficiency testing with a limited number of participants

Metrological designs of experiment for proficiency testing (PT) with a limited number of participants are discussed. The designs are based on development of in-house reference materials (IHRMs) with traceable assigned values and fit-for-purpose uncertainties, used in a PT scheme as the measurement standards. When adequate certified reference materials (CRMs) are available, a comparative approach for IHRM development, using simultaneous analysis of IHRM and CRM test portions in pairs, is proposed for PT objectives. In the case where adequate CRMs are not available – for example, in the field of analysis of unstable aqueous systems – the function of the measurement standard for PT can be fulfilled by a synthetic IHRM prepared gravimetrically using non-adequate, non-aqueous CRMs or pure substances. The CRM or the pure substance is used as a spike for fortification of a natural water sample, while the natural water sample is used as a working IHRM for the spike determination. In this case the traceability chain is longer, since two IHRMs are added for one quantity determination, but it remains unbroken.Presented at the Second International Conference on Metrology –Trends and Applications in Calibration and Testing Laboratories, 4–6 November 2003, Eilat, Israel     

In-house reference materials of mometasone furoate with traceable assay certified values

Characterization of in-house reference materials (IHRMs) with traceable property values for the mometasone furoate assay is discussed. The traceability of the value carried by the IHRM has been established to the value carried by a higher metrological status United States Pharmacopoeia Reference Standard (USP RS). A comparative approach is used to overcome systematic errors in measurement results, specific to the measurement method and/or to the laboratory developing the IHRM. The traceability chain was realized by the simultaneous analysis of the IHRM and the USP RS test portions under the same conditions.     

Traceable property values of in-house reference materials

The traceability of in-house reference materials (IHRM) is discussed. It is shown that a systematic error in results of a measured value, specific to a measurement method or to a laboratory developing an IHRM, can be overcome if a comparative approach to IHRM characterization is used. A traceability chain of the value carried by the IHRM to the value carried by the reference material with higher metrological status and sufficiently similar matrix (for example, a certified reference material – CRM according to ISO Guide 30) is helpful in such a case. The chain is realized when the IHRM samples are analysed simultaneously with the CRM samples under the same conditions. This and other traceability chains necessary for the IHRM development are examined as the measurement information sources.     

Influence of buffer quality on pH measurement uncertainty: prediction and experimental evaluation

Dependence of the uncertainty of a pH measurement result on the quality of buffers (i.e. the uncertainty of their certified pH values) at different levels of instrumental uncertainty (pH-meter, etc.) was simulated using the Monte Carlo method and regression analysis. The contribution of the instrumental standard uncertainty (in the studied range from 0.1 to 1 mV) to the uncertainty of the pH measurement result is negligible, if the standard uncertainties of the pH buffers exceed 0.04 pH (e. g. for in-house buffers). It is shown how the choice of pH-meter and buffers should be correlated in order to meet the required uncertainty of a pH measurement result in a sample under analysis. The results of the simulation were compared with experimental data obtained from calibrations of a pH/ion-meter with a hydrogen working electrode (Radiometer PHM-240) and with a glass electrode (Metrohm 744). Buffers of different quality (National Institute for Standards and Technology standard reference materials, certified Radiometer buffers and Merck CertiPUR buffers) were used for the calibrations. The uncertainties of the experimental results are close to the predicted ones obtained by the simulation. Received: 16 June 2002 Accepted: 19 July 2002 Presented at the 14^th International Conference of the Israel Society for Quality, 18–21 November 2002, Jerusalem, Israel Correspondence to I. Kuselman     

The need for reference materials when monitoring nitrate intake

Whether dietary exposure to nitrate metabolites is detrimental or beneficial to human health has long been a matter of controversy. In spite of no consistent epidemiological evidence, nitrate metabolites are associated with the formation of carcinogenic-nitrosamines and gastric cancer. Furthermore, recent studies demonstrate that ingested nitrate plays a role in host defence against gastrointestinal pathogenic bacteria. Analytical values of nitrate content in foods are essential for estimating nitrate intake. The analytical process is of paramount importance for assessing human nitrate exposure and for establishing a link between these exposures and the current and future observed health effects. Therefore, the quality assurance of the measurement process is crucial to obtaining reliability, comparability and traceability of results. Certified Reference Materials (CRM) should play a role in the consistency of the measurement process. However, the availability of nitrate CRMs is still poor. When food monitoring is demanded, an approach could be to use In House Reference Materials (IHRM), prepared at a high metrological level, and all preparation steps should be quality driven. IHRMs were prepared, and available CRMs were used to provide traceability of the process. The homogeneity of IHRM was evaluated using an appropriate statistical design. The stability was monitored using an isochronous method. The material shelf life and storage conditions are presented.HPLC was optimised for the determination of nitrates in four vegetable categories. When a suite of IHRMs were used, the response of the HPLC system was linear over the range 1 to 8 mg L^–1. The detection limit for these compounds was 0.2 g L^–1 and the determination limit 1.2 g L^–1.The relationship between measurement uncertainty and critical points of the analytical process is presented. The differences in observed relative uncertainty between food categories could reflect current limitations in the food matrix reference materials.     

Development of a proficiency testing scheme for a limited number of participants in the field of natural water analysis

A proficiency testing (PT) scheme was developed for a limited number of analytical laboratories participating in the analysis of natural water in Israel. Three fit-for-intended-use reference materials (RMs) were prepared for a pilot PT from natural water: RM-blank and two in-house reference materials (IHRMs) with seven analytes fortified to achieve different levels of analyte concentrations. The measurands for the PT participants were the traceable spike values certified in the IHRMs, i.e., added mass concentrations of the analytes. The RM-blank and IHRMs were found to be homogeneous and stable over 11 days, the time necessary for the experimental part of the PT. The RMs were distributed to the PT participants as unknown test items similar to routine samples. The test results were evaluated using their deviations from the IHRM-certified values. Eight Israeli laboratories took part in the interlaboratory comparison. Individual laboratory performance and metrological compatibility of the PT results of the participants, as a local group of laboratories, were evaluated for every analyte.     

Proficiency testing of pH and electrolytic conductivity measurements of groundwater: a case study of the difference between consensus and metrologically traceable values

A proficiency testing (PT) scheme was designed for measurements of pH and electrolytic conductivity (EC) of groundwater in Israel. A groundwater sample was used for preparation of test items fit-for-intended-use. The interlaboratory experiment was organized taking into account changes of the test item properties which occurred after sampling due to presence of CO₂ in the groundwater. A total of 34 PT participants reported pH measurements results, while 29 of them reported results of EC measurements. The pH results were normally distributed. However, a significant bias of the pH consensus value of the PT participants from the metrologically traceable certified value (obtained by the National Physical Laboratory of Israel) was detected. This bias was caused by the drift of the measurement response due to water stirring and CO₂ degassing from the sample during the measurement process. The bias of the EC consensus value from the metrologically traceable one was negligible, in spite of an abnormal distribution of the EC results of the PT participants.     

Development of in-house reference materials for determination of inorganic polysulfides in water

In-house reference materials (IHRMs) for determination of inorganic polysulfides in water have been developed. The determination is based on the polysulfides derivatization with a methylation agent followed by GC/MS or HPLC analysis of the difunctionalized polysulfides. Therefore, the IHRMs are synthesized in the form of dimethylated polysulfides containing from four to eight atoms of sulfur. The composition of the compounds is confirmed by NMR and by the dependence of the HPLC retention time of the dimethyl polysulfides on the number of sulfur atoms in the molecule. Stability of the IHRMs is studied by HPLC with UV detection at 230 nm. Carbon tetrachloride solutions of the dimethyl polysulfides are stable at –20°C for 2 weeks, while their solutions in a mixture of acetonitrile and formic acid, 1:1, are stable even at +5°C for 3 weeks. The total sulfur content is controlled by the IHRMs oxidation with perchloric acid in high-pressure vessels (bombes) followed by determination of the formed sulfate using ICP-AES. Certified values of the dimethyl polysulfide concentrations are in the range of 416–3,327 ppm.Presented at the Second International Conference on Metrology—Trends and Applications in Calibration and Testing Laboratories, 4–6 November, 2003, Eilat, Israel     

Estimation of uncertainty in routine pH measurement

A procedure for estimation of measurement uncertainty of routine pH measurement (pH meter with two-point calibration, with or without automatic temperature compensation, combination glass electrode) based on the ISO method is presented. It is based on a mathematical model of pH measurement that involves nine input parameters. Altogether 14 components of uncertainty are identified and quantified. No single uncertainty estimate can be ascribed to a pH measurement procedure: the uncertainty of pH strongly depends on changes in experimental details and on the pH value itself. The uncertainty is the lowest near the isopotential point and in the center of the calibration line and can increase by a factor of 2 (depending on the details of the measurement procedure) when moving from around pH 7 to around pH 2 or 11. Therefore it is necessary to estimate the uncertainty separately for each measurement. For routine pH measurement the uncertainty cannot be significantly reduced by using more accurate standard solutions than ±0.02 pH units – the uncertainty improvement is small. A major problem in estimating the uncertainty of pH is the residual junction potential, which is almost impossible to take rigorously into account in the framework of a routine pH measurement.¹ Received: 11 August 2001 Accepted: 22 February 2002     

Local comparability of proficiency testing results: determination of concrete slump and compressive strength values

A proficiency testing (PT) scheme is developed for comparability assessment of results of concrete slump and compressive strength determination. The scheme is based on preparing of a test portion/sample of a concrete in-house reference material (IHRM) at a reference laboratory (RL) in the same conditions for every PT participant. Therefore, in this scheme IHRM instability is not relevant as a source of measurement/test uncertainty, while intra- and between-samples inhomogeneity parameters are evaluated using the results of RL testing of the samples taken at the beginning, the middle and the end of the PT experiment. The IHRM assigned slump and compressive strength values are calculated as averaged RL results. Their uncertainties include the measurement/test uncertainty components and the components arising from the material inhomogeneity. The test results of 25 PT participants were compared with the IHRM assigned values taking into account both the uncertainties of the assigned values and the measurement/test uncertainties of the participants. Since traceability of the IHRM assigned values to the international measurement standards and SI units cannot be stated, local comparability of the results is assessed. It is shown, that comparability of the slump and compressive strength determination results is satisfactory, while uncertainty evaluation for slump results requires additional efforts.     

Implementation of proficiency testing schemes for a limited number of participants

A metrological background for the selection and use of proficiency testing (PT) schemes for a limited number N of laboratories-participants (less than 20–30) is discussed. The following basic scenarios are taken into account: (1) adequate matrix certified reference materials (CRM) or in-house reference materials (IHRM) with traceable property values are available for PT use as test items; (2) no appropriate matrix CRM is available, but a CRM or IHRM with traceable property values can be applied as a spike or similar; (3) only an IHRM with limited traceability is available. The discussion also considers the effect of a limited population of PT participants N _p on statistical assessment of the PT results for a given sample of N responses from this population. When N _p is finite and the sample fraction N/N _p is not negligible, a correction to the statistical parameters may be necessary. Scores suitable for laboratory performance assessment in such PT schemes are compared. Presented at the 3rd International Conference on Metrology, November 2006, Tel Aviv, Israel.     

Extended traceability of pH: an evaluation of the role of Pitzer's equations

The 2002 IUPAC recommendation on pH (provisional) has taken its own philosophy to provide a basis for comparable and traceable assignment of a value, from a measurement, to the quantity pH. Whereas the substituted 1983 IUPAC recommendation relied heavily on precisely prescribed experimental techniques and procedures, the current recommendation defines a hierarchical relationship between references for comparison (primary and secondary standards) and objective criteria on the comparison of measurements with these standards. The recommendation aims at a traceability chain from the national metrological institution (NMI) level down to field and laboratory measurements. Currently, however, the traceability chain is developed to the level of certified reference materials (CRM), namely the above mentioned primary and secondary standards. To complete the traceability chain, several theoretical and practical aspects have to be pondered. In part, the methods for comparative assessment of different options have yet to be developed. As an illustrating example of the complexity of issues to be considered in a further extension of the traceability chain is estimation of the doubt associated with Pitzer coefficients. The Pitzer equations for activity coefficient modelling are explicitly mentioned in the 2002 IUPAC recommendation on pH (provisional) as enabling possible improvement in the ionic strength extrapolations to zero ionic strength. An assessment of uncertainty of ternary Pitzer coefficients is given for the first time.     

One of Howard's favorites,null measurements,today

Null measurements formed a considerable fraction of the scientific work of Howard Malmstadt. He worked extensively to automate and perfect titration methods and he applied the titration process to potentiometric and spectrometric methods in a technique he called isomation. Further, a great deal of his work in automation took advantage of devices based on null principles. Null measurement and control systems directly compare the measured quantity with that of a standard which is then adjusted until the difference between the standard and measured quantities is zero. The output number (with units) is obtained from the setting of the standard. Direct measurement systems use conversion devices to convert the information from the measured quantity to a related number. Direct measurements require calibration to obtain the conversion factor and units while null measurements are calibrated inherently. Most modern measurement systems employ null devices, but as conversion devices in direct measurement systems rather than as part of a “full” null system. There are advantages to be gained through a reconsideration of complete null measurement approach advanced so effectively by Howard Malmstadt.     

New developments in the production and use of CRMs in Romania

 A lot of effort is being made in Romania to meet the present main strategic goal – EU integration. Since the confidence in measurements is of considerable importance in almost every field of activity, the National Institute of Metrology (INM) is involved in improving its calibration and measurement capabilities to provide services in accordance with the latest European Regulation. Within this framework the assurance of the required traceability of all measurements plays a most important role. As reliable analytical measurements depend largely upon reference materials and the assurance of the traceability of amount measurements is still developing in Romania, a new approach regarding the function of Certified Reference Materials (CRMs) may be emphasized. The experience of the INM as well as new developments in Romania in preparation and certification of Reference Materials (RMs) are described. A short review of the locally available RMs and CRMs is given. Some aspects regarding the use of RMs and CRMs, especially for calibration, are discussed for their applicability for analytical measurements. Received: 31 October 2002 Accepted: 24 January 2003 Presented at CERMM-3, Central European Reference Materials and Measurements Conference: The function of reference materials in the measurement process, May 30–June 1, 2002, Rogaška Slatina, Slovenia Correspondence to M. Buzoianu     

The impact of ionic strength and background electrolyte on pH measurements in metal ion adsorption experiments

Our understanding of metal ion adsorption to clay minerals has progressed significantly over the past several decades, and theories have been promulgated to describe and predict the impacts of pH, ionic strength, and background solution composition on the extent of adsorption. Studies evaluating the effects of ionic strength on adsorption typically employ a broad range of background electrolyte concentrations. Measurement of pH in these systems can be inaccurate when pH values are measured with liquid junction pH probes calibrated with standard buffers due to changes in the liquid junction potential between standard, low ionic strength (0.05 M) buffers and high ionic strength solutions (>0.1 M). The objective of this research is to determine the extent of the error in pH values measured at high ionic strength, and to develop an approach for accurately measuring pH over a range of ionic strengths using a combined pH electrode. To achieve this objective, the adsorption of cobalt (10(-5) M) onto gibbsite (10 g/L) from various electrolyte solutions (0.01-1 M) was studied. The pH measurements were determined from calibrations with standard buffers and ionic strength corrected buffer calibrations. The results show a significant effect of the aqueous solution background electrolyte anion and ionic strength on pH measurement. The 0.5 and 1 M ionic strength metal ion adsorption edges shifted to lower pH with increasing ionic strength when pH was calibrated with standard buffers whereas no shift in the adsorption edges was observed when calibrated with ionic strength corrected buffers. Therefore, to obtain an accurate pH measurement, pH calibration should contain the same electrolyte and ionic strength as the samples.     

Improved traceability of pH measurements

Traceability is a prerequisite for the comparability and uniformity of measurements. Although pH-measurements are carried out on a large scale in laboratory and industry, the problems involved in the traceability of pH values have not adequately been solved in the past. The comparability of pH measurements is limited, among other parameters, by the accuracy of the pH values of the standard buffer solutions used to calibrate the pH meter-electrode assemblies. The measured pH(X) value must be traceable to primary standard pH(PS) values through an unbroken chain of comparisons, all values having stated uncertainties. A new primary standard measurement device for pH is used to certify primary pH reference materials from which these secondary reference materials can be derived.     

A ratiometric approach for pH optosensing with a single fluorophore indicator

A new fiber-optic prototype of luminometer has been designed in order to perform ratiometric-based measurements for optical sensing purposes. The coupling of a pH-selective sensing phase to the fiber-optic prototype has been evaluated for robust pH optosensing in drinking water. The pH-sensitive material has been synthesized by entrapping a pH-sensitive luminescent indicator (mercurochrome) in a sol-gel inorganic matrix. The pH optosensing is based on the detection of pH-induced reversible changes in the mercurochrome fluorescent emission and in the light reflected by the sensing phase.The instrument has been constructed using low-cost and simple optoelectronic components. The active phase was excited by means of a visible 470 nm high intensity light emitting diode (LED). The radiant power of the LED was modulated using a sinusoidal function so that scattered light due to light sources of different frequency than the modulating signal (e.g. sunlight) can be easily removed by adequate electronic filtering of the emission signal. Both the fluorescence emission from the dye and the sensing phase reflected light were collected in a bifurcated fiber-optic to allow the ratiometric measurement.Two different ratiometric approaches have been evaluated. The analytical performance of the pH optrode using both measurement methods have been compared, between them and with simple fluorescence intensity measurements, in terms of sensitivity, measurement range, response time, repeatability and insensitivity to changes in excitation light intensity.The applicability of the developed pH optrode and methods has been tested for pH analysis in tap and bottled still mineral water samples. The results obtained showed good agreement with the corresponding pH values provided by a commercial glass electrode.In this work, pH was selected as a model analyte to evaluate the performance of the proposed methodology, although other optical sensors for different applications/analytes could benefit of this approach.     

On practical metrology and chemical analysis: etalons and traceability systems

 National measurement systems are infrastructures to ensure, for each nation, a consistent and internationally recognised basis for measurement. Such complex systems have historical, technical, legal, organisational and institutional aspects to connect scientific metrology with practical measurements. Underlying any valid measurement is a chain of comparisons linking the measurement to an accepted standard. The ways the links are forged and the etalons (measurement standards) to which they connect are defining characteristics of all measurement systems. This is often referred to as traceability which aims at basing measurements in common measurement units – a key issue for the integration of quantitative chemical analysis with the evolving physical and engineering measurement systems. Adequate traceability and metrological control make possible new technical capabilities and new levels of quality assurance and confidence by users in the accuracy and integrity of quantitative analytical results. Traceability for chemical measurements is difficult to achieve and harder to demonstrate. The supply of appropriate etalons is critical to the development of metrology systems for chemical analysis. An approach is suggested that involves the development of networks of specialised reference laboratories able to make matrix-independent reference measurements on submitted samples, which may then be used as reference materials by an originating laboratory using its practical measurement procedures. Received: 31 July 1995 Accepted: 19 August 1995     

Improving the quality of potentiometric pH measurements

Like all experimentally determined physical and chemical properties, pH measurements are affected by the limited precision and accuracy of the measurement procedures. Fundamental studies of pH standards, based on measurement of the potential of an electrochemical cell without transference, known as the Harned cell, containing a platinum–hydrogen electrode and a silver–silver chloride reference electrode, indicate that vapour condensation phenomena on potentiometric cell walls not immersed in the thermostatic bath are a major source of error in assessment of pH values. In this work a study was conducted on phthalate buffer, 0.05 mol kg⁻¹ KHPhth, and results are reported for the effect of this phenomenon on the assignment of pH values and on their corresponding uncertainties. Identification and quantification of this effect constitute an original contribution to improvement of the primary method of pH measurement and, therefore, more rigorous pH (PS) values.     

The history and development of a rigorous metrological basis for pH measurements

This paper discusses the basis and historical development of the traceability chain for pH. The quantity pH, first introduced in 1909, is among the most frequently measured analytical quantities. The practical measurement of the pH value of a sample is inexpensive, easy to perform, and yields a rapid result. However, the problems posed by the traceability of pH are not easy to solve. Most pH measurements are performed by potentiometry, using a glass electrode as the pH sensor. Such pH electrodes must be calibrated at regular intervals. Confidence in the reliability of pH measurements requires establishment of a metrological hierarchy including an uncertainty budget for calibration that links the pH measured in the sample to an internationally agreed and stated reference. For pH, this reference is the primary measurement of pH. A traceability chain can be established that links field measurements of pH to primary buffer solutions that are certified using this primary method. This allows the user in the field to estimate the measurement uncertainty of the measured pH data. As the realization of the primary measurement is sophisticated and time-consuming, primary standards are generally realized at national metrology institutes. A number of potentiometric methods are suitable for the determination of the pH of reference buffer solutions by comparison with the primary standard buffers. The choice between the methods should be made according to the uncertainty required for the application. For reference buffer solutions that have the same nominal composition as the primary standard, the differential potentiometric cell, often called the Baucke cell, is recommended.