Photocurrent response after enzymatic treatment of DNA duplexes immobilized on gold electrodes: electrochemical discrimination of 5-methylcytosine modification in DNA

We demonstrate a photoelectrochemical approach to the detection of the methylation status of cytosine bases in DNA. We prepared anthraquinone (AQ) photosensitizer-tethered oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN) duplexes bearing 5-methylcytosine (mC) or the corresponding cytosine (C) at a restriction site of the ODN strand immobilized on gold electrodes, and measured their photocurrent responses arising from hole transport after enzymatic digestion. Treatment with HapII or HhaI of the duplexes bearing normal C led to strand cleavage, and the photosensitizer unit was eliminated from the ODN strand immobilized on the gold electrode, exclusively reducing the photocurrent density. With a similar treatment, the duplexes bearing mC showed higher photocurrent responses arising from hole transport through the duplex. This significant difference in the photocurrent response between mC and normal C residues in DNA on the gold electrodes is potentially applicable to the detection of mC modification in DNA.     

One-electron photooxidation and site-selective strand cleavage at 5-methylcytosine in DNA by sensitization with 2-methyl-1,4-naphthoquinone-tethered oligonucleotides

Photosensitized one-electron oxidation was applied to discriminate a specific base site of 5-methylcytosine (mC) generated in DNA possessing a partial sequence of naturally occurring p53 gene, using a sensitizing 2-methyl-1,4-naphthoquinone (NQ) chromophore tethered to an interior of oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN) strands. Photoirradiation and subsequent hot piperidine treatment of the duplex consisting of mC-containing DNA and NQ-tethered complementary ODN led to oxidative strand cleavage selectively at the mC site, when the NQ chromophore was arranged so as to be in close contact with the target mC. The target mC is most likely to be one-electron oxidized into the radical cation intermediate by the sensitization of NQ. The resulting mC radical cation may undergo rapid deprotonation and subsequent addition of molecular oxygen, thereby leading to its degradation followed by strand cleavage at the target mC site. In contrast to mC-containing ODN, ODN analogs with replacement of normal cytosine, thymine, adenine, or guanine at the mC site underwent less amount of such an oxidative strand cleavage at the target base site, presumably due to occurrence of charge transfer and charge recombination processes between the base radical cation and the NQ radical anion. Furthermore, well designed incorporation of the NQ chromophore into an interior of ODN could suppress a competitive strand cleavage at consecutive guanines, which occurred as a result of positive charge transfer. Thus, photosensitization by an NQ-tethered ODN led to one-electron oxidative strand cleavage exclusively at the target mC site, providing a convenient method of discriminating mC in naturally occurring DNA such as human p53 gene as a positive band on a sequencing gel.     

One-electron oxidation of DNA: the effect of replacement of cytosine with 5-methylcytosine on long-distance radical cation transport and reaction

One-electron oxidation of duplex DNA generates a radical cation that migrates through the nucleobases until it is trapped by an irreversible reaction with water or oxygen. The trapping site is often a GG step, because this site has a relatively low ionization potential and this causes the radical cation to pause there momentarily. Modifications to guanine that lower its ionization potential convert it to a better trap for the radical cation. One such modification is the formation of the Watson-Crick base pair with cytosine, which is reported to very significantly decrease its ionization potential. Methylation of cytosine to form 5-methylcytosine (5-MeC) is a naturally occurring reaction in genomic DNA that may be associated with regions of enhanced oxidative damage. The G.5-MeC base pair is reported to be more rapidly oxidized than normal G.C base pairs. We examined the oxidation of DNA oligomers that were substituted in part with 5-MeC. Irradiation of a covalently linked anthraquinone group injects a radical cation into the DNA and results in strand cleavage after piperidine treatment. For the sequences examined, substitution of 5-MeC for C has no measurable effect on the reactions. Cytosine methylation is not a general cause of enhanced oxidative damage in DNA.     

Anthraquinone-sensitized photooxidation of 5-methylcytosine in DNA leading to piperidine-induced efficient strand cleavage

One-electron photooxidations of 5-methyl-2'-deoxycytidine (d(m)C) and 5-trideuteriomethyl-2'-deoxycytidine ([D(3)]d(m)C) by sensitization with anthraquinone (AQ) derivatives were investigated. Photoirradiation of an aerated aqueous solution containing d(m)C and anthraquinone 2-sulfonate (AQS) afforded 5-formyl-2'-deoxycytidine (d(f)C) and 5-hydroxymethyl-2'-deoxycytidine (d(hm)C) in good yield through an initial one-electron oxidation process. The deuterium isotope effect on the AQS-sensitized photooxidation of d(m)C suggests that the rate-determining step in the photosensitized oxidation of d(m)C involves internal transfer of the C5-hydrogen atom of a d(m)C-tetroxide intermediate to produce d(f)C and d(hm)C. In the case of a 5-methylcytosine ((m)C)-containing duplex DNA with an AQ chromophore that is incorporated into the backbone of the DNA strand so as to be immobilized at a specific position, (m)C underwent efficient direct one-electron oxidation by the photoexcited AQ, which resulted in an exclusive DNA strand cleavage at the target (m)C site upon hot piperidine treatment. In accordance with the suppression of the strand cleavage at 5-trideuterio-methylcytosine observed in a similar AQ photosensitization, it is suggested that deprotonation at the C5-methyl group of an intermediate (m)C radical cation may occur as a key elementary reaction in the photooxidative strand cleavage at the (m)C site. Incorporation of an AQ sensitizer into the interior of a strand of the duplex enhanced the one-electron photooxidation of (m)C, presumably because of an increased intersystem crossing efficiency that may lead to efficient piperidine-induced strand cleavage at an (m)C site in a DNA duplex.     

Selective one-electron oxidation of duplex DNA oligomers: reaction at thymines

The one-electron oxidation of duplex DNA generates a nucleobase radical cation (electron "hole") that migrates long distances by a hopping mechanism. The radical cation reacts irreversibly with H2O or O2 to form oxidation products (damaged bases). In normal DNA (containing the four common DNA bases), reaction occurs most frequently at guanine. However, in DNA duplexes that do not contain guanine (i.e., those comprised exclusively of A/T base pairs), we discovered that reaction occurs primarily at thymine and gives products resulting from oxidation of the T-C5 methyl group and from addition to its C5-C6 double bond. This surprising result shows that it is the relative reactivity, not the stability, of a nucleobase radical cation that determines the nature of the products formed from oxidation of DNA. A mechanism for reaction is proposed whereby a thymine radical cation may either lose a proton from its methyl group or H2O/O2 may add across its double bond. In the latter case, addition may initiate a tandem reaction that converts both thymines of a TT step to oxidation products.     

Excess electron transfer from an internally conjugated aromatic amine to 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine in DNA

DNA duplexes containing an N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-1,5-diaminonaphthalene analogue and 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU) provide a readily accessible system for investigating excess electron transfer in DNA. Photoexcitation of the aromatic amine (lambda > 335 nm) induces reductive electron transfer as observed by strand cleavage adjacent to the BrdU residue. The weak exponential distance dependence (0.3 A-1) of electron transfer determined for this system of mixed dA-T and dG-dC base pairs suggests that thermally activated electron hopping is competitive with proton transfer within the dG.dC radical anion. The UV-dependent transfer of excess electrons and subsequent strand cleavage proceeds equivalently under anaerobic and aerobic conditions and is not sensitive to e-(aq) or hydroxyl radical trapping agents.     

One-electron oxidation of DNA oligomers that lack guanine: reaction and strand cleavage at remote thymines by long-distance radical cation hopping

The anthraquinone (AQ) photosensitized one-electron oxidation of DNA introduces a radical cation (electron "hole") that migrates through the duplex by hopping. The radical cation normally is trapped irreversibly by reaction at guanine. We constructed AQ-linked DNA oligomers composed exclusively of A/T base pairs. Their irradiation led to reaction and strand cleavage primarily at thymines. Long-distance radical cation hopping to distant thymines was demonstrated by the distance dependence of the process and by experiments with DNA oligomers that contain a single remote GG step. The reaction of the radical cation at thymine was shown to involve its 5-methyl group by the replacement of selected thymines with uracils. These findings show that the reactivity of radical cations in DNA cannot be explained simply by exclusive reliance on the relative oxidation potential of the nucleobases. Instead, the site of reaction is determined in accord with the Curtin-Hammett principle for reactive species in rapid equilibrium.     

Base sequence effects in radical cation migration in duplex DNA: support for the polaron-like hopping model

A series of anthraquinone-linked (AQ) duplex DNA oligomers were prepared and investigated. Irradiation of the AQ injects a radical cation into the DNA. The radical cation migrates through the DNA and reacts selectively at GG steps, which leads to strand cleavage after treatment with piperidine. The oligomers investigated in this work were selected to assess the effect on long-distance charge transport of placing a T base (or bases) in a strand of repeating purine bases. With notable exceptions, the amount of strand scission decreases with the distance between the AQ and the GG step. The results are consistent only with models for long-distance transport, such as thermally activated polaron-like hopping, that incorporate radical cation delocalization over two or more adjacent bases.     

Highly oxidizing excited states of one-electron-oxidized guanine in DNA: wavelength and pH dependence

Excited states of one-electron-oxidized guanine in DNA are known to induce hole transfer to the sugar moiety and on deprotonation result in neutral sugar radicals that are precursors of DNA strand breaks. This work carried out in a homogeneous aqueous glass (7.5 M LiCl) at low temperatures (77-175 K) shows the extent of photoconversion of one-electron-oxidized guanine and the associated yields of individual sugar radicals are crucially controlled by the photon energy, protonation state, and strandedness of the oligomer. In addition to sugar radical formation, highly oxidizing excited states of one-electron-oxidized guanine are produced with 405 nm light at pH 5 and below that are able to oxidize chloride ion in the surrounding solution to form Cl(2)(?-) via an excited-state hole transfer process. Among the various DNA model systems studied in this work, the maximum amount of Cl(2)(?-) is produced with ds (double-stranded) DNA, where the one-electron-oxidized guanine exists in its cation radical form (G(?+):C). Thus, via excited-state hole transfer, the dsDNA is apparently able to protect itself from cation radical excited states by transfer of damage to the surrounding environment.     

Charge hopping in DNA.

The efficiency of charge migration through stacked Watson-Crick base pairs is analyzed for coherent hole motion interrupted by localization on guanine (G) bases. Our analysis rests on recent experiments, which demonstrate the competition of hole hopping transitions between nearest neighbor G bases and a chemical reaction of the cation G(+) with water. In addition, it has been assumed that the presence of units with several adjacent stacked G bases on the same strand leads to the additional vibronic relaxation process (G(+)G...G) --> (GG...G)(+). The latter may also compete with the hole transfer from (G(+)G...G) to a single G site, depending on the relative positions of energy levels for G(+) and (G(+)G...G). A hopping model is proposed to take the competition of these three rate steps into account. It is shown that the model includes two important limits. One corresponds to the situation where the charge relaxation inside a multiple guanine unit is faster than hopping. In this case hopping is terminated by several adjacent G bases located on the same strand, as has been observed for the GGG triple. In the opposite, slow relaxation limit the GG...G unit allows a hole to migrate further in accord with experiments on strand cleavage exploiting GG pairs. We demonstrate that for base pair sequences with only the GGG triple, the fast relaxation limit of our model yields practically the same sequence- and distance dependencies as measurements, without invoking adjustable parameters. For sequences with a certain number of repeating adenine:thymine pairs between neighboring G bases, our analysis predicts that the hole transfer efficiency varies in inverse proportion to the sequence length for short sequences, with change to slow exponential decay for longer sequences. Calculations performed within the slow relaxation limit enable us to specify parameters that provide a reasonable fit of our numerical results to the hole migration efficiency deduced from experiments with sequences containing GG pairs. The relation of the results obtained to other theoretical and experimental studies of charge transfer in DNA is discussed. We propose experiments to gain a deeper insight into complicated kinetics of charge-transfer hopping in DNA.     

Selective photocleavage of DNA and RNA by anthraquinone derivatives: targeting the single-strand region of hairpin structures

A tetracationic anthraquinone derivative (27AQS2) binds to hairpin DNA and RNA. Ultraviolet irradiation of the bound quinone causes cleavage in the loop region of both oligonucleotides and at guanines in the stem region of the DNA hairpin. The absence of observable strand cleavage at guanines in the RNA hairpin suggests that either aniline treatment does not cause cleavage at damaged guanines in RNA or that radical cation migration does not occur readily in RNA duplexes. The ability to target the single-stranded regions of DNA and RNA structures is an important property of this photonuclease.     

DNA logic gates

A conceptually new logic gate based on DNA has been devised. Methoxybenzodeazaadenine ((MD)A), an artificial nucleobase which we recently developed for efficient hole transport through DNA, formed stable base pairs with T and C. However, a reasonable hole-transport efficiency was observed in the reaction for the duplex containing an (MD)A/T base pair, whereas the hole transport was strongly suppressed in the reaction using a duplex where the base opposite (MD)A was replaced by C. The influence of complementary pyrimidines on the efficiency of hole transport through (MD)A was quite contrary to the selectivity observed for hole transport through G. The orthogonality of the modulation of these hole-transport properties by complementary pyrimidine bases is promising for the design of a new molecular logic gate. The logic gate system was executed by hole transport through short DNA duplexes, which consisted of the "logic gate strand", containing hole-transporting nucleobases, and the "input strand", containing pyrimidines which modulate the hole-transport efficiency of logic bases. A logic gate strand containing multiple (MD)A bases in series provided the basis for a sharp AND logic action. On the other hand, for OR logic and combinational logic, conversion of Boolean expressions to standard sum-of-product (SOP) expressions was indispensable. Three logic gate strands were designed for OR logic according to each product term in the standard SOP expression of OR logic. The hole-transport efficiency observed for the mixed sample of logic gate strands exhibited an OR logic behavior. This approach is generally applicable to the design of other complicated combinational logic circuits such as the full-adder.     

Molecular modeling study of DNA abasic sites

We use molecular modeling calculations to study the structure and the flexibility of abasic (AP sites) and for the design of anticancer drugs targeted against AP sites. For either adenine or cytosine on the opposing strand within the same sequence context, the results are in line with experimental data which show that the two unpaired bases lead to intrahelical forms, but with differences in induced curvature. Results on flexibility, indicate that the two duplexes have the same bending rigidity for cytosine. In previous work a series of polyfunctional molecules, such as ATAc, were designed to selectively recognize and cleave abasic sites in DNA. The nitrobenzamide group which was added to the ATAc molecule to obtain a new molecule, termed ATAc4, can induce a second lesion under irradiation in close proximity to the abasic site. The different conformations of ATAc4 interacting with a DNA oligomer containing a stable analog of the abasic site were compared to the photoinduced cleavage pattern observed experimentally. Received: 16 September 1999 / Accepted: 3 February 2000 / Published online: 12 May 2000     

Photoinduced reductive repair of thymine glycol: implications for excess electron transfer through DNA containing modified bases

Photoinduced reduction of thymine glycol in oligodeoxynucleotides was investigated using either a reduced form of flavin adenine dinucleotide (FADH(-)) as an intermolecular electron donor or covalently linked phenothiazine (PTZ) as an intramolecular electron donor. Intermolecular electron donation from photoexcited flavin (FADH(-)) to free thymidine glycol generated thymidine in high yield, along with a small amount of 6-hydroxy-5,6-dihydrothymidine. In the case of photoreduction of 4-mer long single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides containing thymine glycol by *FADH(-), the restoration yield of thymine was varied depending on the sequence of oligodeoxynucleotides. Time-resolved spectroscopic study on the photoreduction by laser-excited N,N-dimethylaniline (DMA) suggested elimination of a hydroxyl ion from the radical anion of thymidine glycol with a rate constant of approximately 10(4) s(-1) generates 6-hydroxy-5,6-dihydrothymidine (6-HOT(*)) as a key intermediate, followed by further reduction of 6-HOT(*) to thymidine or 6-hydroxy-5,6-dihydrothymdine (6-HOT). On the other hand, an excess electron injected into double-stranded DNA containing thymine glycol was not trapped at the lesion but was further transported along the duplex. Considering redox properties of the nucleobases and PTZ, competitive excess electron trapping at pyrimidine bases (thymine, T and cytosine, C) which leads to protonation of the radical anion (T(-)(*), C(-)(*)) or rapid back electron transfer to the radical cation of PTZ (PTZ(+)(*)), is presumably faster than elimination of the hydroxyl ion from the radical anion of thymine glycol in DNA.     

Role of the guanine N1 imino proton in the migration and reaction of radical cations in DNA oligomers

Oxidation of a guanine nucleobase to its radical cation in DNA oligomers causes an increase in the acidity of the N1 imino proton that may lead to its spontaneous transfer to N3 of the paired cytosine. This proton transfer is suspected of playing an important role in long-distance radical cation hopping in DNA and the decisive product-determining role in the reaction of the radical cation with H2O or O2. We prepared and investigated DNA oligomers in which certain deoxycytidines are replaced by 5-fluoro-2'-deoxycytidines (F5dC). The pKa of F5C was determined to be 1.7 units below that of dC, which causes proton transfer from the guanine radical cation to be thermodynamically unfavorable. Photoinitiated one-electron oxidation of the DNA by UV irradiation of a covalently attached anthraquinone derivative introduces a radical cation that hops throughout the oligomer and is trapped selectively at GG steps. The introduction of F5dC does not affect the efficiency of charge hopping, but it significantly reduces the amount of reaction at the GG sites, as revealed by subsequent reaction with formamidopyrimidine glycosylase. These findings suggest that transfer of the guanine radical cation N1 proton to cytosine does not play a significant role in long-range charge transfer, but this process does influence the reactions with H2O and/or O2.     

Electron Transfer through DNA in the Course of Radical-Induced Strand Cleavage

No benefit from base stacking is observed for rates of electron transfer in DNA. This conclusion was drawn from experiments with a new DNA assay in which a radical cationic site, generated by strand cleavage, can be reduced by the guanine bases in the same DNA (the electron transfer is indicated by arrows in the diagram). The distance dependence of this electron transfer step is determined by the chemical yield of the reduction product.     

Base sequence effects on transport in DNA

Given the success of the polaron model based on solvation in accounting for the width of a hole polaron on an all-adenine (A) sequence on DNA, we extend the calculations to other sequences. We find excellent agreement with the free energy differences measured by Lewis et al. (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2000, 122, 12037-12038) between a guanine (G) cation and a pair of bases, GG, or a triple of bases, GGG, in all cases surrounded by As, by treating AGGA and AGGGA as solvated polarons. There is additional support for hole polaron formation in DNA from experiments in which oxidative damage due to injected holes is investigated in sequences involving Gs and As. Theory and comparison with transport measurements on repeated sequences involving multiple thymines (Ts) or combinations such as ATs or GCs, where C is cytosine, led to the suggestion that the basic sequences in these cases must be polarons whose wave functions have substantial amplitudes on both chains in a duplex. The size of an electron polaron in DNA is predicted to be similar to that of a hole polaron, approximately 4 or 5 bases. Although experiments have shown that polaron hopping is the dominant mode of charge transport in DNA with repeated sequences such as AGGA, further investigations, particularly of temperature dependence of site energies and transfer integrals, are needed to determine to what extent hole transport takes place by polaron hopping for arbitrary DNA sequences.     

Photosensitized oxidative DNA damage: from hole injection to chemical product formation and strand cleavage

Oxidatively generated damage to DNA induced by a pyrenyl photosensitizer residue (Py) covalently attached to a guanine base in the DNA sequence context 5'-d(CAT[G1Py]CG2TCCTAC) in aerated solutions was monitored from the initial one-electron transfer, or hole injection step, to the formation of chemical end-products monitored by HPLC, mass spectrometry, and high-resolution gel electrophoresis. Hole injection into the DNA was initiated by two-photon excitation of the Py residue with 355 nm laser pulses, thus producing the radical cation Py*+ and hydrated electrons; the latter are trapped by O2, thus forming the superoxide anion O2*-. The decay of the Py*+ radical is correlated with the appearance of the G*+/G(-H)* radical on microsecond time scales, and O2*- combines with guanine radicals at G1 to form alkali-labile 2,5-diamino-4H-imidazolone lesions (Iz1Py). Product formation in the modified strand is smaller by a factor of 2.4 in double-stranded than in single-stranded DNA. In double-stranded DNA, hot piperidine-mediated cleavage at G2 occurs only after G1Py, an efficient hole trap, is oxidized thus generating tandem lesions. An upper limit of hole hopping rates, khh < 5 x 103 s-1 from G1*+-Py to G2 can be estimated from the known rates of the combination reaction of the G(-H)* and O2*- radicals. The formation of Iz products in the unmodified complementary strand compared to the modified strand in the duplex is approximately 10 times smaller. The formation of tandem lesions is observed even at low levels of irradiation corresponding to "single-hit" conditions when less than approximately 10% of the oligonucleotide strands are damaged. A plausible mechanism for this observation is discussed.     

Rapid radical formation by DNA charge transport through sequences lacking intervening guanines

Using the flash-quench technique to probe DNA charge transport in assemblies containing a tethered ruthenium intercalator, the kinetics and yield of methylindole radical formation as a function of DNA sequence were studied by laser spectroscopy and biochemical methods. In these assemblies, the methylindole moiety serves as an artificial base of low oxidation potential. Hole injection and subsequent formation of the methylindole radical cation were observed at a distance of over 30 A at rates >/=107 s-1 in assemblies containing no guanine bases intervening the ruthenium intercalator and GMG oxidation site. Radical yield was, however, strikingly sensitive to an intervening base mismatch; no significant methylindole radical formation was evident with an intervening AA mismatch. Also critical is the sequence at the injection site; this sequence determines initial hole localization and hence the probability of hole propagation. With guanine rather than inosine near the site of hole injection, decreased yields of radicals and long-range oxidative damage are observed. The presence of the low-energy guanine site in this case serves to localize the hole and therefore diminish charge transport through the base pair stack.     

193 NM LIGHT INDUCES SINGLE STRAND BREAKAGE OF DNA PREDOMINANTLY AT GUANINE

Irradiation of DNA with 193 nm light results in monophotonic photoionization, with the formation of a base radical cation and a hydrated electron (φ_P1 = 0.048–0.065). Although >50% of the photoionization events initially occur at guanine in DNA, migration of the “hole” from the other bases to guanine occurs to yield predominantly its radical cation or its deprotonated form. From sequence analysis, the data reveal that 193 nm light induces single strand breaks (ssb) in double-stranded DNA preferential 3’ to a guanine residue. However, it has previously been reported that 193 nm light yields very low yields of ssb (<2% of the yield of eaq). The distribution of these ssb at guanine is nonrandom, showing a dependence on the neighboring base moiety. The efficiency of ssb formation at nonguanine sites is estimated to be at least one order of magnitude lower. The preferred cleavage at guanine is consistent with migration and localization of the electron loss center at guanine. It is argued that singlet oxygen and the photoionized phosphate group of the sugar moiety are not major precursors to ssb. At present, the mechanisms of strand breakage are not known although a guanine radical or one of its products remain potential precursors.