Analysing Policy Effectiveness Using Cone Restricted Data Envelopment Analysis

Reducing weight flexibility has been suggested as a method for ensuring that the solution to data envelopment analyses do not give unreasonably low weightings to certain inputs or outputs. In this paper we extend the use of reducing weight flexibility and use it to model the effects of the decision-making unit's objectives on its efficiency relative to other DMUs with possibly different objectives. We show how such an approach can identify situations in which the weights imputed by a data envelopment analysis can be inconsistent with the decision-making weights used by the firm, and how this approach can be used to provide efficiency measures that are consistent with the DMU's own objectives. The method allows the analyst to distinguish between a decision-making unit's technological inefficiency and its inability to implement its own policies.     

Altering the Bias in Differential School Effectiveness Using Data Envelopment Analysis

There is evidence that many schools are differentially effective in that they promote with different effectiveness the academic attainments of different groups of pupils, divided by such characteristics as prior academic attainments, socio-economic background and so on. Awareness of the extent and direction of a school's differential effectiveness is important. Measures of overall performance of a differentially effective school can be misleading and targets seeking to improve the overall performance of such a school may not address its underlying inadequacies in raising the attainments of specific groups of pupils. This paper develops a data envelopment analysis based method for setting targets for diffentially effective schools to enable them to alter the bias of their differential effectiveness. The method also identifies role model schools which a differentially effective school can emulate in seeking to redress the imbalances in its effectiveness.     

Guiding Schools to Improved Performance Using Data Envelopment Analysis: An Illustration with Data from a Local Education Authority

The educational process is characterized by multiple outcomes such as the achievement of academic results of various standards and non-academic achievements. This paper shows how data envelopment analysis (DEA) can be used to guide secondary schools to improved performance through role-model identification and target setting in a way that recognizes the multi-outcome nature of the education process and reflects the relative desirability of improving individual outcomes. The approach presented in the paper draws from a DEA-based assessment of the schools of a local education authority carried out by the authors. Data from that assessment are used to illustrate the approach presented in the paper.     

Data Envelopment Analysis with Preference Structure

It is important to consider the decision making unit (DMU)'s or decision maker's preference over the potential adjustments of various inputs and outputs when data envelopment analysis (DEA) is employed. On the basis of the so-called Russell measure, this paper develops some weighted non-radial CCR models by specifying a proper set of ‘preference weights’ that reflect the relative degree of desirability of the potential adjustments of current input or output levels. These input or output adjustments can be either less or greater than one; that is, the approach enables certain inputs actually to be increased, or certain outputs actually to be decreased. It is shown that the preference structure prescribes fixed weights (virtual multiplier bounds) or regions that invalidate some virtual multipliers and hence it generates preferred (efficient) input and output targets for each DMU. In addition to providing the preferred target, the approach gives a scalar efficiency score for each DMU to secure comparability. It is also shown how specific cases of our approach handle non-controllable factors in DEA and measure allocative and technical efficiency. Finally, the methodology is applied with the industrial performance of 14 open coastal cities and four special economic zones in 1991 in China. As applied here, the DEA/preference structure model refines the original DEA model's result and eliminates apparently efficient DMUs.     

基于样本评价的广义数据包络分析方法

传统DEA方法是一种依据自评体系评价的方法,而无法自主选择参照系.为了解决DEA方法可以同时依据自评体系和其它参照系进行评价问题,首先给出了广义DEA有效的概念.然后,给出了一类基于样本单元评价的广义数据包络分析模型,包括面向输入的广义DEA模型、面向输出的广义DEA模型以及加性广义DEA模型.最后,分析了上述这些模型与传统DEA模型之间的关系,探讨了广义DEA有效与相应多目标规划Pareto有效之间的关系,并给出了决策单元的投影性质以及决策单元的有效性排序方法.     

基于数据包络分析的企业资本利用有效性研究

数据包络分析(DEA)是一种评价相对有效性的线性规划方法，在多个输入、多个输出情形下的投入产出效率分析中多有应用，并可进行规模效应分析。本采用DEA方法，以沪深股市50家房地产上市公司为样本。采用其2002年度财务数据，对样本公司资本利用的有效性进行了实证分析。研究表明，我国多数房地产上市公司既存在着显的技术非有效，也存在着显的规模非有效；其中，主营业务收入5亿元以上的公司一般运行在规模效益递减区间，这意味着并不是最大的公司具有最好的资本利用有效性。     

引入时间变量的数据包络分析模型

考虑到实际中的生产过程大多数都是多阶段的生产过程,而传统的数据包络分析模型只能对单阶段的生产过程进行评价.传统的数据包络分析模型在应用中的局限性很大.本文是在传统数据包络分析模型的基础上,通过引入离散的时间变量来建立对整个多阶段生产过程进行评价的数据包络分析模型.     

BiLevel programming Data Envelopment Analysis with constrained resource

A new BiLevel programming Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) approach is created to provide valuable managerial insights when assessing the performance of a system with Stackelberg-game relationships. This new approach allows us to evaluate the firm performance in decentralized decisions, which consist of the objective(s) of the leader at its first level and that is of the follower at the second level. This approach can help decentralized companies to optimize their performance using multiple inputs to produce multiples outputs in a cost-effective way, where both the system “black-box” and subsystem performance are exposed in details. We show the algorithms and solutions to our new models. We illustrate and validate the proposed new approach using two case studies: a banking chain and a manufacturing supply chain. The computation shows that subsystem being efficient at all levels results in an overall efficiency achievement in a decentralized BiLevel structure.     

On the Use of Ordinal Data in Data Envelopment Analysis

In many problems involving efficiency analysis using DEA, certain factors may be measurable only on an ordinal scale. Specifically, it may be possible only to rank order the DMUs according to a factor, rather than being able to assign a specific numerical value of that factor to each DMU. To illustrate this, we examine a problem involving the evaluation of new technology installations. The presence of qualitative factors in such an environment motivates the need to investigate how such factors can be incorporated into existing efficiency measurement models. In particular, a procedure is presented for incorporating an ordinal factor into the DEA structure, with the resulting formulation being a particular form of cone ratio model. The model is then applied to the technology installation efficiency problem.     

基于DEA的区域经济可持续发展能力的动态评价

在分析区域经济可持续发展问题的基础上,从区域经济竞争的角度提出区域经济可持续发展能力的评价问题.在此基础上,设计区域经济可持续发展能力的评价指标体系,利用数据包洛分析模型分析与研究不同区域之间的可持续发展能力的强弱变化,同时分析可持续发展能力强弱差异形成的原因,提出相应的解决方法.     

Relative Efficiency Assessments Using Data Envelopment Analysis: An Application to Data on Rates Departments

This paper examines the nature of information obtained from data envelopment analysis (DEA) in comparative studies of the efficiency of decision-making units, and it discusses the interpretation and practical usefulness of such information. The themes developed in the paper are illustrated by an application of DEA to data on the rate-collection function of London Boroughs and Metropolitan District Councils. The paper begins with an overview of DEA, followed by a discussion of some of the practical considerations arising in the application of DEA. It then describes the structuring of the rate-collection function for assessment by DEA, and explores the extent to which units can be classified as relatively efficient or inefficient. In respect of relatively inefficient units, it illustrates the construction of target inputs and outputs so that their relative efficiency may improve. In respect of relatively efficient units, it is argued that their identification is weak in the sense that for some of them their apparent efficiency may be simply a reflection of an uncommon input-output profile. It is shown, nevertheless, that information about relatively efficient units can be used to identify those of them which may prove examples of good operating practice in given aspects of their function. (Readers not familiar with British taxes may wish to note that rates are a tax on property, levied by local authorities.)     

Efficiency bounds in Data Envelopment Analysis

This paper considers a proposal, by Chang and Guh, that the non-archimedean infinitesimal in the CCR data envelopment analysis model be replaced with a data-dependent finite magnitude. Whilst the intention of the proposal is clear: to reduce the CCR efficiency rating of certain problematic DMUs, it is found not to work in practice. An alternative implementation, which puts the CCR model into a mixed-binary linear programming framework, is developed. Chang and Guh's proposal is also related to the earlier modification to the CCR model, Constrained Facet Analysis. Both are seen as providing bounds on the relative efficiency of DMUs which are not properly enveloped in the CCR model.     

模糊数据包络分析方法有效性分析

传统数据包络分析(DEA)模型只能用来评价具有精确投入和产出数据的决策单元.然而在实践中决策单元的投入产出数据可能存在一定模糊性.为了评价具有模糊投入产出数据的决策问题,研究工作者提出了模糊数据包络分析模型,并给出了相应的有效性定义.对于不同研究者提出的有效性定义方式有众多地方需要改进.通过这些改进提出了相关模型及新的有效性定义方式,并给出了相关实例.     

Data Envelopment Analysis of multiple response experiments

Taguchi method is the usual strategy in robust design and involves conducting experiments using orthogonal arrays and estimating the combination of factor levels that optimizes a given performance measure, typically a signal-to-noise ratio. The problem is more complex in the case of multiple responses since the combinations of factor levels that optimize the different responses usually differ. In this paper, an Artificial Neural Network, trained with the experiments results, is used to estimate the responses for all factor level combinations. After that, Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) is used first to select the efficient (i.e. non-dominated) factor level combinations and then for choosing among them the one which leads to a most robust quality loss penalization. Mean Square Deviations of the quality characteristics are used as DEA inputs. Among the advantages of the proposed approach over traditional Taguchi method are the non-parametric, non-linear way of estimating quality loss measures for unobserved factor combinations and the non-parametric character of the performance evaluation of all the factor combinations. The proposed approach is applied to a number of case studies from the literature and compared with existing approaches.     

Fuzzy BCC Model for Data Envelopment Analysis

Fuzzy Data Envelopment Analysis (FDEA) is a tool for comparing the performance of a set of activities or organizations under uncertainty environment. Imprecise data in FDEA models is represented by fuzzy sets and FDEA models take the form of fuzzy linear programming models. Previous research focused on solving the FDEA model of the CCR (named after Charnes, Cooper, and Rhodes) type (FCCR). In this paper, the FDEA model of the BCC (named after Banker, Charnes, and Cooper) type (FBCC) is studied. Possibility and Credibility approaches are provided and compared with an -level based approach for solving the FDEA models. Using the possibility approach, the relationship between the primal and dual models of FBCC models is revealed and fuzzy efficiency can be constructed. Using the credibility approach, an efficiency value for each DMU (Decision Making Unit) is obtained as a representative of its possible range. A numerical example is given to illustrate the proposed approaches and results are compared with those obtained with the -level based approach.     

一类基于属性变量的DEA模型

系统评价不仅应重视系统的经济特征,还必须重视系统的非经济特征.在评价系统的非经济特征时必须考虑属性变量,即不能以货币衡量的反映系统非经济特征的定量变量.在过去关于DEA的研究中并未涉及到这种变量.本文对属性变量进行了明确的定义,并提出一种基于属性变量的DEA效率评价模型,最后通过实例演示了模型的合理性.     

带有随机决策单元的广义数据包络分析方法

广义DEA方法是一种相对效率评价方法,解决了决策单元相对于任意参考系(样本单元集)的效率比较问题.在实际中,有时评价标准是确定的,决策单元的生产具有不确定性,有必要在进行生产之前基于确定性样本单元对随机性决策单元进行相对效率评价.为了解决这个问题,研究样本单元为确定值,决策单元为随机变量的广义DEA模型,分别通过期望值和机会约束将随机模型转化为确定性规划,给出决策单元GEDEA有效和GCDEA有效的概念,GEDEA有效与多目标规划Pareto有效关系,以及利用移动因子对决策单元进行有效性排序方法.     

Reducing Weight Flexibility in Data Envelopment Analysis

This paper explores the consequences of total weight flexibility in data envelopment analysis (DEA) assessments of the efficiency of decision-making units, and it suggests one possible way of limiting such flexibility. It is suggested that total weight flexibility can lead to some decision-making units being assessed, in effect, on only a small subset of their inputs and outputs, while the rest of their inputs and outputs are all but ignored. Constraining the weights in DEA assessments overcomes this problem. The paper suggests one way in which constraints can be placed for the case where the decision-making units to be assessed use only a single input. The method is illustrated using data on local-authority rates departments. Finally, the paper discusses the interpretation and usefulness of the information obtained from DEA assessments involving weights constraints.