Application of the isotope dilution technique for Zr determination in an irradiated cladding material by multiple collector-inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

The determination of ⁹³Zr concentration, a long-lived radionuclide present in spent nuclear fuel and in the structural components of nuclear reactors, is a major issue for nuclear waste disposal purpose and to validate neutronic calculation codes. To measure ⁹³Zr concentration in irradiated cladding material with a high precision, an analytical method based on the use of multiple collector-inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (MC-ICPMS) combined to isotope dilution technique was developed. First a radiochemical separation of zirconium from a zircaloy sample (a zirconium alloy used as a cladding material for nuclear fuel elements), has allowed to obtain a very pure zirconium fraction with no potential isobaric interferences for mass spectrometric measurements. Then as the determination of all zirconium isotope ratios in the sample is necessary for the isotope dilution method, a MC-ICPMS procedure was developed to perform these precise measurements. Finally, the determination of ⁹³Zr concentration in the same sample was performed, after preparation and calibration of a ⁹⁶Zr spike solution. The uncertainties obtained on isotope ratios of zirconium by MC-ICPMS were in the order of 0.1%. The final uncertainty obtained on the ⁹³Zr concentration in the nuclear material used and after chemical purification was lower than 0.6%.     

Determination of zirconium in U−Zr−Al and Pu−Zr−Al alloys by isotope dilution thermal ionization mass spectrometry

An isotope dilution thermal ionization mass-spectrometric (ID-TIMS) method is described for the determination of Zr in U?Zr?Al and Pu?Zr?Al alloy samples. Problems encountered in the chemical exchange between the zirconium isotopes in the spike and sample, particularly Pu?Zr?Al samples, are discussed and a method has been standardized to eliminate it. Separation of Zr from U, Pu and Al was achieved by employing ion exchange procedures. A precision of better than 1% is possible in the determination of Zr with the method reported here.     

Fission yields of molybdenum in the Oklo natural reactor

The isotopic compositions of molybdenum in six uranium-rich samples from the Oklo Zone 9 natural reactor were accurately measured by thermal ionization mass spectrometry. The samples were subjected to an ion exchange separation process that removed the isobaric elements zirconium and ruthenium, with high efficiency and a low blank. Molybdenum possesses seven isotopes of which ^92,94,96Mo are unaffected by the fission process, enabling the raw data to be corrected for isotope fractionation by normalising to ⁹²Mo/⁹⁶Mo, and to use ⁹⁴Mo to correct for the primordial component in each of the fission-produced isotopes. This enables the relative fission yields of Mo to be calculated from the isotopic composition measurements, to give cumulative fission yields of 1:0.941:0.936:1.025 for ^95,97,98,100Mo, respectively. These data demonstrate that the most important nuclear process involved in reactor Zone 9 was the thermal neutron fission of ²³⁵U. The consistency of the relative cumulative fission yields of all six samples from different locations in the reactor, implies that Mo is a mobile element in the uraninite comprising Zone 9, and that a significant fraction of molybdenum was mobilized within the reactor zone and probably escaped from Zone 9, a conclusion in agreement with earlier published work.     

用于锆稳定同位素测定的化学分离技术

本文采用ＨＤＥＨＰ／环己烷体系萃取锆和钼，并将两 发离以便测定锆的稳定同位素，此外，还研究了作为同 素稀释剂的ＺｒＯ２固体粉末的微波溶样法。     

Determination of zirconium traces in polymers by ICP-IDMS – a powerful and fast method for routine testing of zirconium residues in polyolefins

Zirconium trace analyses play an important role for polyolefins produced by modern catalytic processes with zirconium metallocenes. A reliable and fast routine testing method by inductively coupled plasma isotope dilution mass spectrometry (ICP-IDMS) was therefore developed, which allows the determination of zirconium in polymers down to the low ng/g level. With respect to its precision, accuracy, and time-consumption this method is suitable for routine testing of production processes. A spike solution, enriched in the stable isotope ⁹¹Zr, was prepared and used for the isotope dilution procedure, which has the advantage of being an internal “one point” calibration method. The polyolefin samples were dissolved by microwave assisted digestion with a mixture of concentrated HNO₃/HF.     

A selective separation method for <Superscript>93</Superscript>Zr in radiochemical analysis of low and intermediate level wastes from nuclear power plants

The zirconium isotope ⁹³Zr is a long-lived pure β-particle-emitting radionuclide produced from ²³⁵U fission and from neutron activation of the stable isotope ⁹²Zr and thus occurring as one of the radionuclides found in nuclear reactors. Due to its long half life, ⁹³Zr is one of the radionuclides of interest for the performance of assessment studies of waste storage or disposal. Measurement of ⁹³Zr is difficult owing to its trace level concentration and its low activity in nuclear wastes and further because its certified standards are not frequently available. A radiochemical procedure based on liquid–liquid extraction with 1-(2-thenoyl)-3,3,3-trifluoroacetone in xylene, ion exchange with Dowex resin and selective extraction using TRU resin has to be carried out in order to separate zirconium from the matrix and to analyze it by liquid scintillation spectrometry technique (LSC). To set up the radiochemical separation procedure for ⁹³Zr, a tracer solution of ⁹⁵Zr was used in order to follow the behavior of zirconium during the process by γ-ray spectrometry through measurement of the ⁹⁵Zr. Then, the protocol was applied to low level waste (LLW) and intermediate level waste (ILW) from nuclear power plants. The efficiency detection for ⁶³Ni was used to determination of ⁹³Zr activity in the matrices analyzed. The limit of detection of the 0.05 Bq l⁻¹ was obtained for ⁶³Ni standard solutions by using a sample:cocktail ratio of 3:17 mL for OptiPhase HiSafe 3 cocktail.     

Simultaneous Plutonium and Uranium Isotopic Analysis from a Single Resin Bead - A Simplified Chemical Technique for Assaying Spent Reactor Fuels

Abstract

The method uses basic anion resin to adsorb plutonium and uranium from 7–8 M HNO₃ solutions containing dissolved spent reactor fuels. After equilibrating the resin with the solution, a single bead is used to determine the isotopic composition of plutonium and uranium on sample sizes as small as 10^?9 to 10^?10 g of each element per bead. Isotopic measurements are essentially free of isobaric interferences and fission product contamination in the mass spectrometer is eliminated. A very small aliquot of dissolver solution containing 10^?6 g of U and 10^?8 g of Pu is sufficient sample for chemically preparing several resin beads. A single prepared bead is loaded onto a rhenium filament and analyzed in a two-stage mass spectrometer using pulse counting for ion detection to obtain the high sensitivity required. Total quantity of the elements, in addition to isotopic abundances, can be determined by isotope dilution. Other areas where the method may be useful are: in plutonium production, isotope separations, and for trace detection of contamination on reactor parts.     

X-ray fluorescence analysis of titanium alloys

An X-ray solution method is proposed for determining major amounts of Mo, Sn and Zr in Ti alloys. The method utilizes adjacent elements in the periodic table as internal standards and has been successfully applied to levels of 3-10% Sn, 11-40% Mo and 6-20% Zr. The procedure involves three steps: dissolving the sample with a suitable acid mixture; adding the suitable internal standard at the concentration levels experimentally found to give optimum accuracy and precision; analysing the resulting solution mixture by X-ray fluorescence. Antimony was found to be a suitable internal standard for its adjacent element tin at a concentration ratio of 3:1 Sb:Sn. Niobium was successfully used for both its adjacent elements, molybdenum and zirconium, at 2:1 concentration ratios, Nb:Mo and Nb:Zr. A number of elements non-adjacent to tin, molybdenum and zirconium (i.e., copper, bromine, titanium, bismuth and tantalum) were experimentally found unsuitable as internal standards. Concentration factors of the internal standard and the adjacent elements sought were found to affect significantly the precision of analysis.     

Determination of (187)Os in molybdenite by ICP-MS with neutron-induced (186)Os and (188)Os spikes

The article describes a method for the determination of (187)Os in molybdenite by isotope dilution inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ID-ICP-MS) with neutron-induced (186)Os and (188)Os spike. The spike used in the present work was prepared in line with the principle by which artificial nuclides are produced in a nuclear reaction. The concentration and isotopic composition of osmium in the prepared spike were evaluated accurately with the isotope dilution method, using negative thermal ion mass spectrometry (N-TIMS). The advantage of this method is that using (186)Os and (188)Os double spikes can effectively compensate for the mass discrimination effects of ICP-MS. Thus, the common correction practice for mass bias in the isotope dilution method with a single spike is unnecessary. In addition, the method enables one to reduce the determined error arising from instrumental instability. The precision for the (187)Os/((186)Os+(188)Os) ratio was approximately 2% (2sigma, RSD), but in the case of (187)Os/(186)Os, (187)Os/(188)Os and (186)Os/(188)Os, precision ranged from 2.0 to 8% (2sigma, RSD). The results for (187)Os concentration in a molybdenite sample determined with this method showed good agreement with reference values.     

Accuracy of analysis of steels by use of a spark-source mass spectrometer with electrical detection

The precision and accuracy of spark-source mass spectrometry with electrical detection has been studied, with five steel standard reference materials (NBS-SRM 661-665). Two different modes of analysis have been evaluated, magnetic scanning with electrical detection of the individual ions in sequence, using the total ion-current as reference, and magnetic switching between masses, with current integration. Measurements of isotope abundances have been used to evaluate the precision. The relative sensitivity coefficients of Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Co, Ni, Cu, As, Zr, Nb, Mo, Sb, La, Ta and W have been determined vs. iron as an internal standard. The accuracy of analyses based on these experimentally measured relative sensitivity coefficients was confirmed by comparing the results for a pure iron sample with those obtained by neutron-activation analysis.     

Determination of zirconium traces in polymers by ICP-IDMS – a powerful and fast method for routine testing of zirconium residues in polyolefins

Zirconium trace analyses play an important role for polyolefins produced by modern catalytic processes with zirconium metallocenes. A reliable and fast routine testing method by inductively coupled plasma isotope dilution mass spectrometry (ICP-IDMS) was therefore developed, which allows the determination of zirconium in polymers down to the low ng/g level. With respect to its precision, accuracy, and time-consumption this method is suitable for routine testing of production processes. A spike solution, enriched in the stable isotope ⁹¹Zr, was prepared and used for the isotope dilution procedure, which has the advantage of being an internal “one point” calibration method. The polyolefin samples were dissolved by microwave assisted digestion with a mixture of concentrated HNO₃/HF. Received: 16 November 1998 / Revised: 29 January 1999 / Accepted: 18 February 1999     

Isotopenverh?ltnismessung von Mo, V, Ti und Zr sowie deren Konzentrationsbestimmung in W?ssern mit einem Thermionen-Quadrupol-Massenspektrometer

Summary Negative MoO ₃ ^– and positive V⁺, Ti⁺, and Zr⁺ thermal ions are produced in a double-filament ion source to determine the isotope ratios of these elements in a quadrupole mass spectrometer. The average relative standard deviation for all isotope ratio measurements is 0.5%. The ratio Me⁺/MeO⁺ (Me=V, Ti, Zr) is followed dependent on the temperature of the ionization filament. A linear plot is obtained for log (Me⁺/MeO⁺) versus 1/T with increasing Me⁺/MeO⁺ ratios for higher temperatures using a single and a double-filament arrangement. An analytical procedure is developed, which allows the simultaneous measurement of Mo and V, and of Ti and Zr as well from one filament by a stepwise variation of the filament temperatures. Mo, V, Ti, and Zr traces in the ng/g and pg/g level of different water samples could be analysed with isotope dilution mass spectrometry using enriched isotopes of⁹⁷Mo,⁵⁰V,⁴⁷Ti, and⁹¹Zr. The precision lies usually in the range of 1 to 6% and the detection limits are 0.002 ng/g for Mo, 0.02 ng/g for V, 0.05 ng/g for Ti, and 0.01 ng/g for Zr using sample amounts of 250 g.     

Determination of uranium fission interference factors for INAA

Instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) is a very suitable technique for the determination of several elements in different kinds of matrices. However, when the sample contains high uranium concentration this method presents interference problems of uranium fission products. The same radioisotopes used in INAA are formed in uranium fission. Among these radioisotopes are ¹⁴¹Ce, ¹⁴³Ce, ¹⁴⁰La, ⁹⁹Mo, ¹⁴⁷Nd, ¹⁵³Sm and ⁹⁵Zr. The purpose of this study was to evaluate uranium fission interference factors to be used in the INAA of environmental and geological samples containing high levels of U. The obtained interference factors agreed with literature reported values. The results point to the viability of using these experimentally determined interference factors for the correction of uranium fission products.     

Accuracy and long-term reproducibility of lead isotopic measurements by multiple-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry using an external method for correction of mass discrimination

The precision of isotopic measurements of Pb by thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS) is limited by the fact that this element does not possess an invariant isotope ratio that can be used for the correction of mass fractionation by internal normalization. Multiple-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (MC-ICPMS) can overcome this limitation, because with plasma ionization, elements with overlapping mass ranges are thought to display identical mass discrimination. With respect to Pb, this can be exploited by the addition of Tl to the sample solutions; the mass discrimination factor obtained for Tl can then be used for the correction of the measured Pb isotope ratios. In this article we present the results of a detailed study that investigates the accuracy and precision of such an external correction technique for mass discrimination based upon the results of multiple analyses of a mixed standard solution of NIST SRM-981 Pb and SRM-997 Tl. Our data indicate that normalization of the Pb isotope ratios to the certified isotopic composition of SRM-997 Tl produces Pb isotopic results that are significantly lower than recently published reference values by TIMS. This systematic offset can be eliminated by renormalization of the Pb data to a different Tl isotopic composition to obtain an empirically determined mass discrimination factor for Pb that generates accurate results. It is furthermore shown that a linear law is least suited for the correction of mass discrimination, whereas a power or exponential law function provide significantly more accurate and precise results. In detail, it appears that a power law may provide the most appropriate correction procedure, because the corrected Pb isotope ratios display less residual correlations with mass discrimination compared to the exponentially corrected data. Using an exponential or power law correction our results, obtained over a period of over seven months, display a precision (2σ) of better than 60 parts per million (ppm) for ²⁰⁸Pb/²⁰⁶Pb and ²⁰⁷Pb/²⁰⁶Pb and of better than 350 ppm for ²⁰⁶Pb/²⁰⁴Pb, ²⁰⁷Pb/²⁰⁴Pb/²⁰⁴Pb, and ²⁰⁸Pb/²⁰⁴Pb. This represents a significant improvement compared to conventional TIMS techniques and demonstrates the potential of MC-ICPMS for routine, high-precision measurements of Pb isotopic compositions.     

Analysis of low‐concentration gas samples with continuous‐flow isotope ratio mass spectrometry: eliminating sources of contamination to achieve high precision

Developments in continuous‐flow isotope ratio mass spectrometry have made possible the rapid analysis of δ¹³C in CO₂ of small‐volume gas samples with precisions of ≤0.1‰. Prior research has validated the integrity of septum‐capped vials for collection and short‐term storage of gas samples. However, there has been little investigation into the sources of contamination during the preparation and analysis of low‐concentration gas samples. In this study we determined (1) sources of contamination on a Gasbench II, (2) developed an analytical procedure to reduce contamination, and (3) identified an efficient, precise method for introducing sample gas into vials. We investigated three vial‐filling procedures: (1) automated flush‐fill (AFF), (2) vacuum back‐fill (VBF), and (3) hand‐fill (HF). Treatments were evaluated based on the time required for preparation, observed contamination, and multi‐vial precision. The worst‐case observed contamination was 4.5% of sample volume. Our empirical estimate showed that this level of contamination results in an error of 1.7‰ for samples with near‐ambient CO₂ concentrations and isotopic values that followed a high‐concentration carbonate reference with an isotope ratio of ?47‰ (IAEA‐CO‐9). This carry‐over contamination on the Gasbench can be reduced by placing a helium‐filled vial between the standard and the succeeding sample or by ignoring the first two of five sample peaks generated by each analysis. High‐precision (SD ≤0.1‰) results with no detectable room‐air contamination were observed for AFF and VBF treatments. In contrast, the precision of HF treatments was lower (SD ≥0.2‰). VBF was optimal for the preparation of gas samples, as it yielded faster throughput at similar precision to AFF. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Copper and tin isotopic analysis of ancient bronzes for archaeological investigation: development and validation of a suitable analytical methodology

Although in many cases Pb isotopic analysis can be relied on for provenance determination of ancient bronzes, sometimes the use of “non-traditional” isotopic systems, such as those of Cu and Sn, is required. The work reported on in this paper aimed at revising the methodology for Cu and Sn isotope ratio measurements in archaeological bronzes via optimization of the analytical procedures in terms of sample pre-treatment, measurement protocol, precision, and analytical uncertainty. For Cu isotopic analysis, both Zn and Ni were investigated for their merit as internal standard (IS) relied on for mass bias correction. The use of Ni as IS seems to be the most robust approach as Ni is less prone to contamination, has a lower abundance in bronzes and an ionization potential similar to that of Cu, and provides slightly better reproducibility values when applied to NIST SRM 976 Cu isotopic reference material. The possibility of carrying out direct isotopic analysis without prior Cu isolation (with AG-MP-1 anion exchange resin) was investigated by analysis of CRM IARM 91D bronze reference material, synthetic solutions, and archaeological bronzes. Both procedures (Cu isolation/no Cu isolation) provide similar δ ⁶⁵Cu results with similar uncertainty budgets in all cases (±0.02–0.04 per mil in delta units, k?=?2, n?=?4). Direct isotopic analysis of Cu therefore seems feasible, without evidence of spectral interference or matrix-induced effect on the extent of mass bias. For Sn, a separation protocol relying on TRU-Spec anion exchange resin was optimized, providing a recovery close to 100 % without on-column fractionation. Cu was recovered quantitatively together with the bronze matrix with this isolation protocol. Isotopic analysis of this Cu fraction provides δ ⁶⁵Cu results similar to those obtained upon isolation using AG-MP-1 resin. This means that Cu and Sn isotopic analysis of bronze alloys can therefore be carried out after a single chromatographic separation using TRU-Spec resin. Tin isotopic analysis was performed relying on Sb as an internal standard used for mass bias correction. The reproducibility over a period of 1 month (n?=?42) for the mass bias-corrected Sn isotope ratios is in the range of 0.06–0.16 per mil (2 s), for all the ratios monitored.     

Uranium isotope dilution mass spectrometry using NBL certified reference materials as spikes

The isotope dilution mass spectrometry method of analysis is used to determine the elemental uranium contents in a wide variety of uranium bearing materials. The method is based on the mass spectrometric analysis of a mixture prepared by diluting the sample to be analyzed with a spike of distinctly different isotopic composition to that of the sample. In this work, a beginning is made to identify suitable candidates among the multitude of certified reference materials (CRMs) available at the New Brunswick Laboratory to supplant the use of ²³³U which remains now as the preferred spike nuclide. The results of the study presented here identify CRM 112-A (of normal isotopic composition) and CRM 115 (depleted uranium composition) as suitable candidates to replace ²³³U as spike material for determining uranium in high enriched uranium materials, and CRM 116 (²³⁵U mass fraction of >90 %) for determining uranium in materials of low enrichment.     

Correction of instrumentally produced mass fractionation during isotopic analysis of fe by thermal ionization mass spectrometry

High-precision (∼0.015%/mass) isotope ratio measurements of Fe may be obtained by using magnetic-sector thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS), where rigorous correction of instrumentally produced mass fractionation can be made. Such corrections are best done by using a double-spike approach, which was first introduced several decades ago. However, previous derivations do not lend themselves to the high-precision isotope analysis that modern TIMS instruments are capable of because of various assumptions of mass fractionation laws or constant atomic weights. Moreover, some of these previous approaches took iterative approaches to the calculation, and none presented detailed error propagations. Here we present a completely general derivation to the double-spike approach that may be used for any appropriate isotope system and is applicable to the mass fractionation laws that are known to occur in TIMS. In addition, we present an assessment of error propagation as a function of algorithm and spike isotope composition. This approach has produced the highest precision Fe isotope ratio measurements yet reported, on the order of ±0.2 to 0.3 per mil for the ⁵⁴Fe/⁵⁶Fe ratio, that correct for instrumentally produced mass fractionation and yet retain natural, mass-dependent isotopic variations in samples.     

Determination of the fast fission yield of141Pr using neutron activation analysis

A method is described for the determination of the fission yield of¹⁴¹Pr. This method was developed to determine the fast fission yield of¹⁴¹Pr in the Mark III loading (enriched uranium with about 2% zirconium) of the fast fission breeder reactor, EBR-1. The burnup of the fuel sample was determined using the previously reported fission yield of¹³⁷Cs. Praseodymium was separated from uranium, plutonium and other fission products by a combination of precipitation and ion exchange stages. Thereafter,⁵⁵Mn was added to serve as an internal flux monitor and praseodymium determined by neutron activation analysis. A precision of ±2% was obtained. Presented at the 15th Annual Meeting of the American Chemical Society, Miami Beach, Florida (USA), April 1967.     

High-precision Ru isotopic measurements by multi-collector ICP-MS

Ruthenium isotopic data for a pure Aldrich ruthenium nitrate solution obtained using a Nu Plasma multi collector inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometer (MC-ICP-MS) shows excellent agreement (better than 1 epsilon unit = 1 part in 10(4)) with data obtained by other techniques for the mass range between 96 and 101 amu. External precisions are at the 0.5-1.7 epsilon level (2sigma). Higher sensitivity for MC ICP-MS compared to negative thermal ionization mass spectrometry (N-TIMS) is offset by the uncertainties introduced by relatively large mass discrimination and instabilities in the plasma source-ion extraction region that affect the long-term reproducibility. Large mass bias correction in ICP mass spectrometry demands particular attention to be paid to the choice of normalizing isotopes. Because of its position in the mass spectrum and the large mass bias correction, obtaining precise and accurate abundance data for 104Ru by MC-ICP-MS remains difficult. Internal and external mass bias correction schemes in this mass range may show similar shortcomings if the isotope of interest does not lie within the mass range covered by the masses used for normalization. Analyses of meteorite samples show that if isobaric interferences from Mo are sufficiently large (Ru/Mo < 10(4)), uncertainties on the Mo interference correction propagate through the mass bias correction and yield inaccurate results for Ru isotopic compositions. Second-order linear corrections may be used to correct for these inaccuracies, but such results are generally less precise than N-TIMS data.