Emerging methods in proteomics: top-down protein characterization by multistage tandem mass spectrometry

"Top-down" mass spectrometry methods have emerged as an attractive alternative to conventional "bottom-up" approaches for the comprehensive characterization of co- and post-translational protein modifications. Here we present a brief overview of current strategies employed for top-down protein characterization and discuss the key technical challenges and solutions associated with their implementation on a range of mass spectrometry instrument platforms. For more specific details regarding the individual strategies described herein, interested readers are referred to the references cited at the end of this article.     

Hardware-accelerated protein identification for mass spectrometry

An ongoing issue in mass spectrometry is the time it takes to search DNA sequences with MS/MS peptide fragments (see, e.g., Choudary et al., Proteomics 2001; 1: 651-667.) Search times are far longer than spectra acquisition time, and parallelization of search software on clusters requires doubling the size of a conventional computing cluster to cut the search time in half. Field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) are used to create hardware-accelerated algorithms that reduce operating costs and improve search speed compared to large clusters. We present a novel hardware design that takes full spectra and computes 6-frame translation word searches on DNA databases at a rate of approximately 3 billion base pairs per second, with queries of up to 10 amino acids in length and arbitrary wildcard positions. Hardware post-processing identifies in silico tryptic peptides and scores them using a variety of techniques including mass frequency expected values. With faster FPGAs protein identifications from the human genome can be achieved in less than a second, and this makes it an ideal solution for a number of proteome-scale applications.     

Elemental mass spectrometry for quantitative proteomics

In the last decade mass-spectrometry-based proteomics has become an indispensable analytical tool for molecular biology, cellular biology and, lately, for the emerging systems biology. This review summarises the evolution and great potential of analytical methods based on elemental mass-spectrometric detection for quantitative proteomic analysis.     

Inverse 15N-metabolic labeling/mass spectrometry for comparative proteomics and rapid identification of protein markers/targets

The inverse labeling/mass spectrometry strategy has been applied to protein metabolic (15)N labeling for gel-free proteomics to achieve the rapid identification of protein markers/targets. Inverse labeling involves culturing both the perturbed (by disease or by a drug treatment) and control samples each in two separate pools of normal and (15)N-enriched culture media such that four pools are produced as opposed to two in a conventional labeling approach. The inverse labeling is then achieved by combining the normal (14)N-control with the (15)N-perturbed sample, and the (15)N-control with the (14)N-perturbed sample. Both mixtures are then proteolyzed and analyzed by mass spectrometry (coupled with on-line or off-line separation). Inverse labeling overcomes difficulties associated with protein metabolic labeling with regard to isotopic peak correlation and data interpretation in the single-experiment approach (due to the non-predictable/variable mass difference). When two data sets from inverse labeling are compared, proteins of differential expression are readily recognized by a characteristic inverse labeling pattern or apparent qualitative mass shifts between the two inverse labeling analyses. MS/MS fragmentation data provide further confirmation and are subsequently used to search protein databases for protein identification. The methodology has been applied successfully to two model systems in this study. Utilizing the inverse labeling strategy, one can use any mass spectrometer of standard unit resolution, and acquire only the minimum, essential data to achieve the rapid and unambiguous identification of differentially expressed protein markers/targets. The strategy permits quick focus on the signals of differentially expressed proteins. It eliminates the detection ambiguities caused by the dynamic range of detection. Finally, inverse labeling enables the detection of covalent changes of proteins responding to a perturbation that one might fail to distinguish with a conventional labeling experiment.     

Protein identification methods in proteomics

A combination of high-resolution two-dimensional (2-D) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, highly sensitive biological mass spectrometry, and the rapidly growing protein and DNA databases has paved the way for high-throughput proteomics. This review concentrates on protein identification. We first discuss the use of protein electroblotting and Edman sequencing as tools for de novo sequencing and protein identification. In the second part, we highlight matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) as one of the main contemporary analytical methods for linking gel-separated proteins to entries in sequence databases. In this context we describe the two main MALDI-MS-based identification methods: (i) peptide mass fingerprinting, and (ii) post-source decay (PSD) analysis. In the last part, we briefly emphasize the importance of sample preparation for obtaining highly sensitive and high-quality MALDI-MS spectra.     

基于质谱的蛋白质组学技术在神经退行性疾病生物标志物研究中的应用

蛋白质组学是在整体水平上研究细胞、组织或生物体蛋白质组成及变化规律的科学.与传统的生物学研究相比,蛋白质组学具有快速、灵敏、高通量的优点.神经退行性疾病是一类由神经系统内特定神经细胞的进程性病变或丢失而导致神经功能障碍的疾病,严重危害人类健康.近年来,基于质谱的蛋白质组学技术在神经退行性疾病的研究中得到了广泛应用.本文简要介绍了蛋白质组学在样品分离、多肽定量、质谱检测及生物标志物临床验证等方面的技术发展,并结合实例综述了基于质谱的蛋白质组学在神经退行性疾病生物标志物发现与验证中的研究进展.     

Interpretation of mass spectrometry data for high-throughput proteomics

Recent developments in proteomics have revealed a bottleneck in bioinformatics: high-quality interpretation of acquired MS data. The ability to generate thousands of MS spectra per day, and the demand for this, makes manual methods inadequate for analysis and underlines the need to transfer the advanced capabilities of an expert human user into sophisticated MS interpretation algorithms. The identification rate in current high-throughput proteomics studies is not only a matter of instrumentation. We present software for high-throughput PMF identification, which enables robust and confident protein identification at higher rates. This has been achieved by automated calibration, peak rejection, and use of a meta search approach which employs various PMF search engines. The automatic calibration consists of a dynamic, spectral information-dependent algorithm, which combines various known calibration methods and iteratively establishes an optimised calibration. The peak rejection algorithm filters signals that are unrelated to the analysed protein by use of automatically generated and dataset-dependent exclusion lists. In the "meta search" several known PMF search engines are triggered and their results are merged by use of a meta score. The significance of the meta score was assessed by simulation of PMF identification with 10,000 artificial spectra resembling a data situation close to the measured dataset. By means of this simulation the meta score is linked to expectation values as a statistical measure. The presented software is part of the proteome database ProteinScape which links the information derived from MS data to other relevant proteomics data. We demonstrate the performance of the presented system with MS data from 1891 PMF spectra. As a result of automatic calibration and peak rejection the identification rate increased from 6% to 44%.Abbreviations 2-DE Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis - MALDI Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionisation - PMF Peptide mass fingerprinting - MS Mass spectrometry - TOF Time of flight     

Tandem mass spectrometry of deprotonated iodothyronines

In order to assist with the development of more selective and sensitive methods for thyroid hormone analysis the [M-H]- anions of the iodothyronines T4, T3, rT3, (3,5)-T2 and the non-iodinated thyronine (T0) have been generated by negative ion electrospray mass spectrometry. Tandem mass spectra of these ions were recorded on a triple-quadrupole mass spectrometer and show a strong analogy with the fragmentation pathways of the parent compound, tyrosine. All iodothyronines also show significant abundances of the iodide anion in their tandem mass spectra, which represents an attractive target for multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) analysis, given that iodothyronines are the only iodine bearing endogenous molecules. Characteristic fragments are observed at m/z 359.7 and 604.5 for rT3 but are absent in the spectrum of T3, thus differentiating the two positional isomers. The striking difference in the fragmentation patterns of these regioisomeric species is attributed to the increased acidity of the phenol moiety in rT3 compared with T3.     

Microwave-assisted protein staining: mass spectrometry compatible methods for rapid protein visualisation

The effects of microwave irradiation on the staining of electrophoresed and electroblotted proteins have been assessed using currently available detection methods. Although the absorption of microwave radiation was found to be uneven, band intensity following microwave-assisted protein staining (MAPS) was comparable and in some cases exceeded the intensity of the bands visualised by the original staining methods. It was found that microwave treatment drastically reduced the duration of the staining protocols for visualisation of the proteins separated by both one- and two-dimensional electrophoresis. Application of MAPS methods did not affect peptide mass fingerprinting analysis by mass spectrometry and subsequent identification of the protein by database searching. The peptide mass maps corresponding to the proteins visualised using both the conventional and MAPS methods did not show significant difference in signal/noise ratio. Moreover, it appeared that microwave treatment of the gels resulted in the increased recovery of the peptides following in-gel trypsin digestion. Briefly, microwave-assisted protein staining methods were rapid, compatible with mass spectrometry and were equally effective on thin (0.75-mm) and thick (1.5-mm) gels (such as those used in 2D electrophoresis).     

Tandem mass spectrometry of amidated peptides

The behavior of C-terminal amidated and carboxylated peptides upon low-energy collision-induced dissociation (CID) was investigated. Two sets of 76 sequences of variable amino acid compositions and lengths were synthesized as model compounds. In most cases, C-terminal amidated peptides were found to produce, upon CID, an abundant loss of ammonia from the protonated molecules. To validate such MS/MS signatures, the studied peptides contained amino acids that can potentially release ammonia from their side chains, such as asparagine, glutamine, tryptophan, lysine and arginine. Arginine, and to a lesser extent lysine, was shown to induce a competitive fragmentation leading to the loss of ammonia from their side chains, thus interfering with the targeted backbone neutral release. However, when arginine or lysine was located at the C-terminal position mimicking a tryptic digest, losses of ammonia from the arginine side chain and from the peptide backbone were completely suppressed. Such results were discussed in the frame of peptidomic or proteomic studies in an attempt to reveal the presence of C-terminal amidated peptides or proteins.     

Tandem mass spectrometry of synthetic polymers

The detailed characterization of macromolecules plays an important role for synthetic chemists to define and specify the structure and properties of the successfully synthesized polymers. The search for new characterization techniques for polymers is essential for the continuation of the development of improved synthesis methods. The application of tandem mass spectrometry for the detailed characterization of synthetic polymers using the soft ionization techniques matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI‐MS) and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI‐MS), which became the basic tools in proteomics, has greatly been increased in recent years and is summarized in this perspective. Examples of a variety of homopolymers, such as poly(methyl methacrylate), poly(ethylene glycol), as well as copolymers, e.g. copolyesters, are given. The advanced mass spectrometric techniques described in this review will presumably become one of the basic tools in polymer chemistry in the near future. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Combining capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry for applications in proteomics

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics is currently dominated by the analysis of peptides originating either from digestion of proteins separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) or from global digestion; the simple peptide mixtures obtained from digestion of gel-separated proteins do not usually require further separation, while the complex peptide mixtures obtained by global digestion are most frequently separated by chromatographic techniques. Capillary electrophoresis (CE) provides alternatives to 2-DE for protein separation and alternatives to chromatography for peptide separation. This review attempts to elucidate how the most promising CE modes, capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) and capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), might best be applied to MS-based proteomics. CE-MS interfacing, mass analyzer performance, column coating to minimize analyte adsorption, and sample stacking for CZE are considered prior to examining numerous applications. Finally, multidimensional systems that incorporate CE techniques are examined; CZE often finds use as a fast, final dimension before ionization for MS, while CIEF, being an equilibrium technique, is well-suited to being the first dimension in automated fractionation systems.     

Alternative methods for verifying the results of the mass spectrometric identification of peptides in shotgun proteomics

Database search is the most popular approach used for the identification of peptides in contemporary shotgun proteomics; it utilizes only mass spectrometric data. In this work, we introduce three criteria for the verification of peptide identification; these are based on the analysis of data orthogonal to tandem mass spectra. The first one utilizes chromatographic retention times of peptides. The development of such approaches has been hindered by the relatively low accuracy of retention time prediction algorithms. In this work, we suggest the use of two independent models of the liquid chromatography of peptides, which increase the reliability of the results. The second criterion utilizes the mean number of missed tryptic cleavages per peptide. The third one results from the analysis of the difference between theoretical and experimentally measured peptide masses. The proposed criteria were applied to the tandem mass spectra of tryptic peptides from rat kidney tissue, which were processed by the Mascot search engine. All the criteria showed that Mascot significantly overestimated the reliability of an identification. This conclusion was supported by the PeptideProphet algorithm.     

A novel mass spectrometry cluster for high-throughput quantitative proteomics

We have developed and implemented a novel mass spectrometry (MS) platform combining the advantages of high mass accuracy and resolving power of Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) with the economy and speed of multiple ion traps for tandem mass spectrometry. The instruments are integrated using novel algorithms and software and work in concert as one system. Using chromatographic time compression, a single expensive FTICR mass spectrometer can match the throughput of multiple relatively inexpensive ion trap instruments. Liquid chromatography (LC)-mass spectrometry data from the two types of spectrometers are aligned and combined to hybrid datasets, from which peptides are identified using accurate mass from the FTICR data and tandem mass spectra from the ion trap data. In addition, the high resolving power and dynamic range of a 12 tesla FTICR also allows precise label-free quantitation. Using two ion traps in parallel with one LC allows simultaneous MS/MS experiments and optimal application of collision induced dissociation and electrontransfer dissociation throughout the chromatographic separation for increased proteome coverage, characterization of post-translational modifications and/or simultaneous measurement in positive and negative ionization mode. An FTICR-ion trap cluster can achieve similar performance and sample throughput as multiple hybrid ion trap-FTICR instruments, but at a lower cost. We here describe the first such FTICR-ion trap cluster, its performance and the idea of chromatographic compression.     

Tandem mass spectrometry of platinated quadruplex DNA

Quadruplexes are higher-order structures formed by G-rich DNA strands that are involved in various processes of cell cycle regulation, such as control of telomere length and participation in gene regulation. Because of these central biological functions, quadruplex DNA represents a promising target for cancer therapy, e.g. by applying organometallic drugs, such as cisplatin. High-resolution electrospray tandem mass spectrometry is evaluated as a technique for exploring structural features of unplatinated and platinated quadruplexes. Results of experiments on tetramolecular, bimolecular and monomolecular quadruplexes provide information about the extent of platination and the binding sites of the drug. The dissociation behavior of the different types of quadruplexes is compared. Tetramolecular quadruplexes were found to weave out a strand end in order to provide a platination site, and their fragmentation is characterized by the release of an unplatinated strand and the formation of a platinated triplex. Partial opening of the structure in combination with the loss of small fragments leads to truncated quadruplex ions. For the bimolecular quadruplexes studied, strand separation is the predominant dissociation pathway. Depending on the loop sequence, cross-linking of the loops by cisplatin is demonstrated. Distinct differences in the product ion spectra of unannealed and annealed monomolecular sequences provide proof of quadruplex formation and show that platination preferentially occurs at the terminal regions.