Prospects for using proteinase inhibitors to protect transgenic plants against attack by herbivorous insects

Proteinase inhibitors which act on the digestive enzymes of insect herbivores are a basic mechanism of plant defence. Attempts to exploit this defence mechanism in plant genetic engineering have used over-expression of both endogenous and exogenous inhibitors. While significant protection against insect pests has been routinely achieved, the engineered plants do not show levels of resistance considered commercially viable. As a result of selective pressures, insect herbivores have developed multiple mechanisms of adaptation to overcome the defensive effects of plant proteinase inhibitors. Common polyphagous crop pests are well adapted to deal with a range of different inhibitors, which have only limited effects on fitness as a result. A range of strategies have been attempted to improve effectiveness of proteinase inhibitors as antimetabolites towards insects, including selection for inhibitory activity against insect digestive enzymes, mutagenesis for novel inhibitory activity, and engineering inhibitors with multiple functions. However, proteinase inhibitor genes have only been used in transgenic crops in combination with other insecticidal genes. In Chinese genetically engineered cotton varieties which express Bt toxins as an insecticidal protein against lepidopteran larvae, the CpTI (cowpea trypsin inhibitor) gene has been employed as a second transgene to improve protection. This gene combination represents the only commercial deployment of a proteinase inhibitor transgene to date, with Bt/CpTI cotton grown on over 0.5 million hectares in 2005. Future prospects for using proteinase inhibitor genes to enhance insect resistance in transgenic crops will require reassessment of their mechanisms of action, particularly in affecting processes other than digestion, as exemplified by effects on sap-feeding hemipteran pests.     

Duftstoffe: Die Sprache der Pflanzen. Signalrezeption,Biosynthese und Ökologie

Plants respond with coordinated actions to threats from their environment. After being attacked by a herbivorous insect, plants are able to emit a complex blend of volatiles, which attract carnivorous arthropods that reduce the number of herbivores and thus benefit the plant. By modulating the emitted volatile spectrum, plants are able to transmit information on type and intensity of their infestation to their defenders. Using either various elicitors from the saliva secretion of the herbivore or differences in the spatio‐temporal pattern of wounding, the plant is able to discriminate between different herbivore species. Subsequently, a complex signalling network ensures the specific reaction to various stresses. Moreover, also plant roots are able to emit volatiles upon attack to attract the predators of root‐feeding insects. New studies suggest that plants may also be able to communicate with each other: By “eavesdropping” on their damaged neighbour, plants of the same or another species can use the information on a currently increased risk of being attacked by herbivores and, as a precaution, activate its own defences. However, most of these interactions between plants and other organisms have been studied mainly under laboratory conditions and we are only starting to understand the ecology of these mechanisms in nature.     

Indanoyl amino acid conjugates: tunable elicitors of plant secondary metabolism

The unassuming nature of plants belies their viciously effective defensive strategies in the face of herbivore attack. Under the direction of, among others, octadecanoid hormones, plants respond by producing phytoalexins, bitter and toxic alkaloids, protease inhibitors, and even volatile compounds that call predatory insects to the herbivores. A rational design of 4-oxoindanoyl amino acid conjugates based on the phytotoxin, coronatine, as a structural guide resulted in a series of highly active compounds which turn on defensive systems in much the same way as octadecanoid hormones. The developments in the syntheses of indanoyl amino acid conjugates have created easy access to substantial amounts of a variety of such compounds. When these compounds were tested in biological systems, they showed abilities to induce defensive responses that surpassed octadecanoid hormones. In addition, small changes in the structures of these compounds resulted in large differences in the particular defensive systems that were activated. Indanoyl amino acid conjugates are promising tools in photoaffinity approaches towards the macromolecular targets of octadecanoids and their subcellular localization. Owing to the strong activation of plant defense or their efficient induction of fruit abscission which facilitates mechanical harvest, the compounds are promising candidates for future application in agriculture.     

Potato type I and II proteinase inhibitors: modulating plant physiology and host resistance

Serine protease inhibitors (PIs) are a large and complex group of plant proteins. Members of the potato type I (Pin1) and II (Pin2) proteinase inhibitor families are among the first and most extensively characterized plant PIs. Many insects and phytopathogenic microorganisms use intracellular and extracellular serine proteases playing important roles in pathogenesis. Plants, however, are able to fight these pathogens through the activation of an intricate defence system that leads to the accumulation of various PIs, including Pin1 and Pin2. Several transgenic plants over-expressing members of the Pin1 and Pin2 families have been obtained in the last twenty years and their enhanced defensive capabilities demonstrated against insects, fungi and bacteria. Furthermore, Pin1 and Pin2 genetically engineered plants showed altered regulation of different plant physiological processes (e.g., dehydratation response, programmed cell death, plant growth, trichome density and branching), supporting an endogenous role in various plant species in addition to the well established defensive one. This review summarizes the current knowledge about Pin1 and Pin2 structure, the role of these proteins in plant defence and physiology, and their potential exploitation in biotechnology.     

PlantPIs--an interactive web resource on plant protease inhibitors

PlantPIs is a web querying system for a database collection of plant protease inhibitors data. Protease inhibitors in plants are naturally occurring proteins that inhibit the function of endogenous and exogenous proteases. In this paper the design and development of a web framework providing a clear and very flexible way of querying plant protease inhibitors data is reported. The web resource is based on a relational database, containing data of plants protease inhibitors publicly accessible, and a graphical user interface providing all the necessary browsing tools, including a data exporting function. PlantPIs contains information extracted principally from MEROPS database, filtered, annotated and compared with data stored in other protein and gene public databases, using both automated techniques and domain expert evaluations. The data are organized to allow a flexible and easy way to access stored information. The database is accessible at http://www.plantpis.ba.itb.cnr.it/.     

Human rhinovirus 3C protease as a potential target for the development of antiviral agents

As the major cause of the common cold in children and adults, human rhinoviruses (HRVs) are a group of small single-stranded positive-sense RNA viruses. HRVs translate their genetic information into a polyprotein precursor that is mainly processed by a virally encoded 3C protease (3Cpro) to generate functional viral proteins and enzymes. It has been shown that the enzymatic activity of HRV 3Cpro is essential to viral replication. The 3Cpro is distinguished from most other proteases by the fact that it has a cysteine nucleophile but with a chymotrypsin-like serine protease folding. This unique protein structure together with its essential role in viral replication made the 3Cpro an excellent target for antiviral intervention. In recent years, considerable efforts have been made in the development of antiviral compounds targeting this enzyme. To further facilitate the design of potent 3C protease inhibitors for therapeutic use, this review summarizes the biochemical and structural characterization conducted on HRV 3C protease along with the recent progress on the development of 3C protease inhibitors.     

Ultramicrochemistry of insect semiochemicals

Chemical ecology of the Insecta comprises an invisible environment where semiochemicals are the principal factors regulating the mating and host-selection of the one million or more species. Biologically effective concentrations of these semiochemicals range from 10^–10 to 10^–3 g at the insect antennal receptors. These levels are virtually undetectable by conventional microchemistry, and can be measured only by behavioral bioassay and by electrophysiology which are about 10,000 and 100-fold more sensitive than gas chromatography.Despite more than 40 years of study, the sex pheromones have been identified from only about 1300 species of insects (0.1%). The dearth of information about kairomones from host plants for phytophagous insects is even more astonishing, and only about 400 plant species have been studied extensively (ca. 0.2%), and the odorant spectra characterized in only 10 important crop plants. These odorants are chemically complex and their action as semiochemicals for insect herbivores, involves degrees of receptor specificity and synergism that are virtually unstudied.These lacunae in our knowledge of chemical ecology are fundamental to the study of ecology, behavior, and evolution of insects; but also are of vital importance in applied entomology. There is much societal pressure to progress from broadcast application of insecticides, to specific and innovative methods for insect control that are non-hazardous to human health and to environmental quality. Pest management strategies involving the use of semiochemicals are essential to reach this goal. These include monitoring insect populations vis-a-vis the economic threshold, the use of attracticide baits, and strategies for mating confusion and behavioral confusion of insect pest populations in row and orchard crops.The immensity of the semiochemical environments of plant and insect communities, the intellectual challenges for understanding ecology and evolution, and the immediate need for application to applied entomology provide compelling reasons for enhanced study of the microchemistry of semiochemicals.     

Plant proteinases and inhibitors: an overview of biological function and pharmacological activity

Proteinases play a fundamental metabolic role during the life cycle in the plant kingdom. By interacting with endogenous or exogenous inhibitors, the proteolytic activity is modulated to meet metabolic requirements. By probing proteolytic enzymes with their inhibitors, it is possible to identify novel functions unrelated to their proteolytic activity. A group of plant proteolytic enzymes stands as a line of defence against environmental changes as their activation is triggered following various types of stress. On the other hand, plants also contain proteinase inhibitors as countermeasures for their protection against insects and pests. Both proteinases and inhibitors emerge as useful tools to combat human diseases. This review focuses on the biochemical characterization of plant proteinases, their inhibitors, the pharmacological potential of proteinases and inhibitors, and new putative emerging functions of proteolytically inhibited proteinases.     

Plant waste residues as inducers of extracellular proteases for a deuteromycete fungus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Trichoderma atroviride</Emphasis>

The ability of Trichoderma atroviride F-534 to utilize plant waste byproducts derived from processing of vegetables and fruits, as the major source of organic carbon and nitrogen for growth and protease production, was tested. The submerged cultivation of T. atroviride F-534 in the mineral base of the Czapek–Dox medium supplemented with plant waste byproducts resulted into copious biomass formation and was accompanied by secretion of several proteolytic enzymes. Zymography analysis of fungal culture filtrates showed that the high-molecular weight (HMW) protease(s) (from 100 kDa to 230 kDa) represent the major portion of secreted enzymes. Serine-type proteases and metalloproteases were predominant, although all known types of proteolytic enzymes were detected dependent on the type of inducer (substrate). The most conspicuous feature of secreted proteases was that the zymography patterns were unique for each plant material tested. These results confirm our previous finding obtained with purified proteins. Results also suggest that HMW protease(s) may participate in the heterotrophic/saprophytic/mode of life of this fungus. Their identity remains, however, obscure.     

Evaluating the role of a trypsin inhibitor from soap nut <Emphasis Type="Italic">(Sapindus trifoliatus L. Var. Emarginatus)</Emphasis> seeds against larval gut proteases,its purification and characterization

Background

The defensive capacities of plant protease Inhibitors (PI) rely on inhibition of proteases in insect guts or those secreted by microorganisms; and also prevent uncontrolled proteolysis and offer protection against proteolytic enzymes of pathogens.

Methods

An array of chromatographic techniques were employed for purification, homogeneity was assessed by electrophoresis. Specificity, Ki value, nature of inhibition, complex formation was carried out by standard protocols. Action of SNTI on insect gut proteases was computationally evaluated by modeling the proteins by threading and docking studies by piper using Schrodinger tools.

Results

We have isolated and purified Soap Nut Trypsin Inhibitor (SNTI) by acetone fractionation, ammonium sulphate precipitation, ion exchange and gel permeation chromatography. The purified inhibitor was homogeneous by both gel filtration and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). SNTI exhibited a molecular weight of 29 kDa on SDS-PAGE, gel filtration and was negative to Periodic Acid Schiff’s stain. SNTI inhibited trypsin and pronase of serine class. SNTI demonstrated non-competitive inhibition with a Ki value of 0.75?±?0.05×10-10 M. The monoheaded inhibitor formed a stable complex in 1:1 molar ratio. Action of SNTI was computationally evaluated on larval gut proteases from Helicoverpa armigera and Spodoptera frugiperda. SNTI and larval gut proteases were modeled and docked using Schrodinger software. Docking studies revealed strong hydrogen bond interactions between Lys10 and Pro71, Lys299 and Met80 and Van Der Waals interactions between Leu11 and Cys76amino acid residues of SNTI and protease from H. Armigera. Strong hydrogen bonds were observed between SNTI and protease of S. frugiperda at positions Thr79 and Arg80, Asp90 and Gly73, Asp2 and Gly160 respectively.

Conclusion

We conclude that SNTI potentially inhibits larval gut proteases of insects and the kinetics exhibited by the protease inhibitor further substantiates its efficacy against serine proteases.

     

Reverse zymography using fluorogenic substrates for protease inhibitor detection

A novel, sensitive method for detecting protease inhibitors by using fluorescent protease substrates in gels is described. The protease inhibitors were separated on sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gels containing a copolymerized peptide substrate, namely 4-methyl-coumaryl-7-amide (MCA). As the incorporated substrates in the gel, Boc-Phe Ser-Arg-MCA was used for trypsin, Suc-Ala-Ala-Pro-Phe-MCA for alpha-chymotrypsin, and Z-Phe-Arg-MCA for papain. After electrophoresis, washing and incubating the gel with the target protease solutions allowed the substrate to be cleaved by the protease, and the release of the fluorescent 7 amino-4 methyl-coumarin (AMC), which was detected under a UV transilluminator. The uncleaved peptide-MCA substrate remained where the inhibitors were present, and was visualized as dark blue bands on the light-green fluorescent background gel. This new method offers several advantages over other previous methods including: (i) greatly increased sensitivity can be achieved in a shorter period of time, which may be useful for discovering new protease inhibitors in small amounts of crude material; (ii) the procedure is quite simple and quick since the incubation period is very short and no time is needed for staining and destaining steps; (iii) since these probes using substrate specificity/target proteases, they are excellent tools for detection and discrimination of unknown protease inhibitors for various target proteases.     

HIV protease-activated molecular switches based on beta-glucuronidase and alkaline phosphatase

Our long-term goal is to direct the evolution of novel protease variants. To this end we have engineered a new type of protease-activated reporter enzyme. Many protease-activated enzymes evolved in nature, but the introduction of novel regulatory mechanisms into normally unregulated enzymes poses a difficult design challenge. Random Elongation Mutagenesis [1] was used to fuse the p6 peptide, which is recognized and cleaved by HIV protease, and twelve random sequence amino acids to the C-termini of beta-glucuronidase (GUS) and alkaline phosphatase (AP). The resulting GUS-p6-(NNN)12 and AP-p6-(NNN)12 libraries were expressed in E. coli and screened for clones that were inactivated by the C-terminal extension (tail). The inactivated clones were co-expressed with HIV protease, and those that were re-activated were isolated. The AP and GUS activities of the most responsive clones were each >3.5-fold higher when co-expressed with HIV protease, and this activation is correlated with in vivo proteolysis. It should be possible to generalize this strategy to different reporter enzymes, different target proteases, and perhaps to other types of protein-modifying enzymes.     

Cysteine protease inhibitors: from evolutionary relationships to modern chemotherapeutic design for the treatment of infectious diseases

Cysteine proteases are one of the largest groups of proteases and are involved in many important biological functions in all kingdoms of life. They are virulence factors of a range of eukaryotic, bacterial and viral pathogens and are involved in host invasion, pathogen replication and disruption of the host immune response. Their activity is regulated by a range of protease inhibitors. This review discusses the various families of cysteine protease inhibitors, their different modes of inhibition and their evolutionary relationships. These inhibitors as well as the recent discovery of propeptide and propeptide-like inhibitors provide insights into the structures that are important for particular inhibitory mechanisms, thus forming the foundation for the design of future therapeutics.     

Quality control of Photosystem II: where and how does the degradation of the D1 protein by FtsH proteases start under light stress?--Facts and hypotheses

Degradation of the reaction center-binding D1 protein of Photosystem II is central in photoinhibition of Photosystem II. In higher plant chloroplasts, Photosystem II complexes are abundant in the grana. It has been suggested that the Photosystem II complexes containing photodamaged D1 protein migrate for their repair from the grana to the non-appressed stroma thylakoids, where the photodamaged D1 protein is degraded by a specific protease(s) such as filamentation temperature sensitive H (FtsH) protease. There are several possible ways to activate the FtsH proteases. As FtsH is a membrane-bound ATP-dependent metalloprotease, it requires ATP and zinc as essential part of its catalytic mechanism. It is also suggested that a membrane protein(s) associated with FtsH is required for modulation of the FtsH activity. Here, we propose several possible mechanisms for activation of the proteases, which depend on oligomerization of the monomer subunits. In relation to the oligomerization of FtsH subunits, we also suggest unique distribution of active FtsH hexamers on the thylakoids: hexamers of the FtsH proteases are localized near the Photosystem II complexes at the grana. Degradation of the D1 protein probably takes place in the grana rather than in the stroma thylakoids to circumvent long-distance migration of both the Photosystem II complexes containing the photodamaged D1 protein and the proteases.     

Bowman-Birk inhibitors from legumes and human gastrointestinal health: current status and perspectives

Bowman-Birk inhibitors and their variants (BBI) from legumes, such as soybean, pea, lentil and chickpea, are a class of naturally-occurring protease inhibitors which have potential health-promoting properties within the gastrointestinal tract. BBI can resist both acidic conditions and the action of proteolytic enzymes, and transit through the stomach and small intestine without major degradation, permitting significant amounts to reach the large intestine in active form to exert their reported anti-carcinogenic and anti-inflammatory properties. These potential pharmacological benefits have been linked recently to the intrinsic ability of BBI to inhibit serine proteases, and the data suggest that both trypsin- and chymotrypsin-like proteases involved in carcinogenesis should be considered as potential targets of BBI. However, the therapeutic targets and the action mechanisms of BBI remain unknown. Their elucidation will provide insights into the properties of these plant protease inhibitors as colorectal chemopreventive agents, providing a strong base for the development of legume crops and their products as pro-nutritional, health-promoting food. The deployment of modern genomic tools and genome sequence information are underpinning studies of natural and induced polymorphism in BBI. Genetic markers for BBI variants with improved properties can be exploited ultimately in legume breeding programmes to assist the introgression of such variant genes and the development of superior genotypes for human nutrition.     

Combinatorial Chemistry Online - Volume 4, Issue 11, October 2002

Current literature highlights: Inhibitors of human rhinovirus 3C protease - The human rhinoviruses (HRVs) are members of the picornavirus family and are the single most causative agent of the common cold. Over 100 serotypes of the virus exist, so immunisation is an impractical approach to prevent the infection. Rhinoviruses contain a positive-sense strand of RNA that is translated to a large polyprotein in infected cells. This polyprotein is cleaved by viral proteases to yield mature viral enzymes and structural proteins. The 3C protease (3CP) does the majority of the proteolytic processing. Inhibition of this viral protease by a small molecule agent should stop viral replication and thus control the extent of infection. Small molecule inhibitors, such as isatins and homophthalimides, are known in the literature but these all suffer from problems such as cellular toxicity and have only modest antiviral activity. Low molecular weight non-peptidic HRV 3CP inhibitors have been synthesised (Structure-based design of a parallel synthetic array directed toward the discovery of irreversible inhibitors of human rhinovirus 3C protease, [1]).     

Small molecule affinity fingerprinting. A tool for enzyme family subclassification,target identification,and inhibitor design

Classifying proteins into functionally distinct families based only on primary sequence information remains a difficult task. We describe here a method to generate a large data set of small molecule affinity fingerprints for a group of closely related enzymes, the papain family of cysteine proteases. Binding data was generated for a library of inhibitors based on the ability of each compound to block active-site labeling of the target proteases by a covalent activity based probe (ABP). Clustering algorithms were used to automatically classify a reference group of proteases into subfamilies based on their small molecule affinity fingerprints. This approach was also used to identify cysteine protease targets modified by the ABP in complex proteomes by direct comparison of target affinity fingerprints with those of the reference library of proteases. Finally, experimental data were used to guide the development of a computational method that predicts small molecule inhibitors based on reported crystal structures. This method could ultimately be used with large enzyme families to aid in the design of selective inhibitors of targets based on limited structural/function information.     

Investigations of the possible role of proteases in altering surface proteins of virally transformed hamster fibroblasts.

Virally transformed fibroblasts have on their surfaces zero or reduced amounts of a large external transformation-sensitive (LETS) glycoprotein. This protein is extremely sensitive to proteolysis. When prelabeled normal fibroblasts are cocultivated with transformed cells, the LETS glycoprotein of the normal cells shows an increased rate of turnover. Experiments are described which investigate the possibility that this phenomenon and the absence of LETS glycoprotein are due to proteolysis by the transformed cells. In particular, the role of plasminogen activation is examined by the use of protease inhibitors and plasminogen-depleted serum. It is concluded that activation of plasminogen is not required for the disappearance of the LETS glycoprotein although the involvement of other proteases cannot be ruled out. The role of proteases in affecting cell growth and behavior is discussed.     

A comparison of cyclohexanone and tetrahydro-4H-thiopyran-4-one 1,1-dioxide as pharmacophores for the design of peptide-based inhibitors of the serine protease plasmin

The plasminogen system is important in the proteolytic cascade that facilitates angiogenesis, a process that is essential for tumor growth and metastasis. The serine protease plasmin has a central role in the plasminogen system. This protease acts by degrading several components of the basement membrane and by activating other proteases. Therefore, inhibition of plasmin may be an effective method for blocking angiogenesis and, as a result, inhibiting the growth of primary tumors and secondary metastases. Three pairs of plasmin inhibitors were synthesized to compare the relative potency of inhibitors that are based upon a cyclohexanone or a tetrahydro-4H-thiopyran-4-one 1,1-dioxide nucleus. Compounds 1, 3, and 5 were cyclohexanone-based inhibitors, whereas compounds 2, 4, and 6 were tetrahydro-4H-thiopyran-4-one 1,1-dioxide-based inhibitors. Compounds 5 and 6 are reasonable inhibitors with IC50 values of 25 and 5.5 microM, respectively. Comparisons of the IC50 values of the three pairs show that the electron-withdrawing sulfone functional group is a beneficial element for the design of plasmin inhibitors. The presence of the sulfone increases inhibitor potency by a factor of 3-5 when compared to inhibitors that are based upon a simple cyclohexanone core.     

Partial Characterization of the Proteolytic Properties of an Enzymatic Extract From “Aguama” <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bromelia pinguin</Emphasis> L. Fruit Grown in Mexico

Plant proteases are capable of performing several functions in biological systems, and their use is attractive for biotechnological process due to their interesting catalytic properties. Bromelia pinguin (aguama) is a wild abundant natural resource in several regions of Central America and the Caribbean Islands but is underutilized. Their fruits are rich in proteases with properties that are still unknown, but they represent an attractive source of enzymes for biotechnological applications. Thus, the proteolytic activity in enzymatic crude extracts (CEs) from wild B. pinguin fruits was partially characterized. Enzymes in CEs showed high proteolytic activity at acid (pH 2.0–4.0) and neutral alkaline (pH 7.0–9.0) conditions, indicating that different types of active proteases are present. Proteolytic activity inhibition by the use of specific protease inhibitors indicated that aspartic, cysteine, and serine proteases are the main types of proteases present in CEs. Activity at pH 3.0 was stable in a broad range of temperatures (25–50 °C) and retained its activity in the presence of surfactants (SDS, Tween-80), reducing agents (DTT, 2-mercapoethanol), and organic solvents (methanol, ethanol, acetone, 2-propanol), which suggests that B. pinguin proteases are potential candidates for their application in brewing, detergent, and pharmaceutical industries.