Protein A chromatography: Challenges and progress in the purification of monoclonal antibodies

Antibodies for therapeutic use are being continuously approved and their demand has been steadily growing. As known, the golden standard for monoclonal antibody (mAb) purification is Protein A affinity chromatography, a technology that has gained high interest because of its great performance and capabilities. The main concerns are the elevated resins costs and their limited lifetime compared to other resins (e.g. ion exchange chromatography). Great efforts have been carried out to improve purification conditions, such as resin characterization and designing alkali/acid stable resins with a longer lifetime. Modification of Protein A ligands and alternative formats such as monoliths membranes and microshperes have been tested to increase the purification performance. New technology has been proposed to improve the large‐scale separation; in addition, alternative ligands have been suggested to capture mAbs instead of Protein A ligand; however, most of the information is locked by pharmaceutical companies. This mini review summarizes and describes the advances, results, and impact on the Protein A chromatography purification processing.     

Nanoliquid chromatography-mass spectrometry of oligosaccharides employing graphitized carbon chromatography on microchip with a high-accuracy mass analyzer

The nanoLC separations of oligosaccharides using microchip-based columns are described. Mixtures of alditols from mucins and human milk are separated on graphitized carbon. The nanoLC-MS device showed high mass accuracy for the oligosaccharides ranging between 1 and 6 ppm on routine analyses. The high mass accuracy readily allowed identification of oligosaccharide peaks and the determination of their compositions. High retention time reproducibility was exhibited by the microchip LC. Little variation was observed for standard sample either alone or in a complex heterogeneous mixture. The nanoLC-MS exhibits excellent capabilities in profiling mixtures of oligosaccharides.     

Accelerated tryptic digestion for the analysis of biopharmaceutical monoclonal antibodies in plasma by liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometric detection

Accelerated tryptic digestion of a therapeutic protein including microwave irradiation and thermal transfer by convection at 60 °C and 37 °C was investigated. An analytical setup was devised to follow the protein digestion rate using 1D gel electrophoresis and liquid chromatography coupled a triple quadrupole linear ion trap mass spectrometer. The formation kinetic of its tryptic peptides was monitored in the selected monitoring mode (LC-SRM/MS). Different digestion end points (e.g. 2, 5, 10, 15, 30 and 60 min) as well as an overnight digestion were tested using a therapeutic human monoclonal antibody (mAb) with the goal of its LC-SRM/MS quantification in human plasma. The peptides from the human mAb were generated at different rates and were classified into three categories: (1) the fast forming peptides, (2) the slow forming peptides and (3) the peptides degrading over time. For many monitored peptides, a heating temperature of 37 °C with a 750 rpm mixing applied for at least 30 min provided equivalent results to microwave-assisted digestion and generally allowed the achievement of an equivalent peptide concentration as an overnight digestion carried out at 37 °C. The disappearance of the protein of the heavy and light chains can be monitored by 1D gel electrophoresis but was found not to be representative of the final tryptic peptide concentrations. For quantitative purposes a stable isotope labeled version (¹³C₄, ¹⁵N₁) of the therapeutic protein was used. The labeled protein as internal standard was found to be very efficient to compensate for incomplete digestion or losses during sample preparation.     

Analysis of recombinant monoclonal antibodies by capillary zone electrophoresis

Analytical platforms that characterize charge heterogeneity in therapeutic proteins, such as mAbs, are important tools that can be used to define quality attributes. CZE separates protein moieties close to their native state and is a valuable physicochemical analytical method that can be used in parallel with other orthogonal methods for characterization and comparability. In this study, custom conditions for the analysis of charge heterogeneity of two mAbs were developed with regard to critical parameters in the BGE, running conditions, and sample treatment. The method application was tested for up to four mAbs and one mAb fragment. The electropherograms showed specific profiles and contrasting levels of basic and acidic isoforms with respect to the main isoform. Issues that surround this method, such as peak tailing and capillary lifetime, are summarized. Using this method, the identities of rituximab and trastuzumab were confirmed, based on the correspondence between the biosimilars and reference products, noninterference of the sample matrix, and the ability to separate spiked samples of related mAbs. The RSD of the isoform content and migration time for the method repeatability were less than 2 and 1%, respectively.     

High-throughput glycosylation analysis of intact monoclonal antibodies by mass spectrometry coupled with capillary electrophoresis and liquid chromatography

The analysis of monoclonal antibodies glycosylation is a crucial quality control attribute of biopharmaceutical drugs. High throughput screening approaches for antibody glycoform analysis are required in various stages of process optimization. Here, we present high throughput screening suitable mass spectrometry-based workflows for the analysis of intact antibody glycosylation out of cell supernatants. Capillary electrophoresis and liquid chromatography were coupled with quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry or Orbitrap mass spectrometry. Both separation methods offer fast separation (10–15 min) and the capability to prevent the separated cell supernatant matrix to enter the mass spectrometry by post-separation valving. Both mass spectrometry instruments provide comparable results and both are sufficient to determine the glycosylation pattern of the five major glycoforms of the measured antibodies. However, the Orbitrap yields higher sensitivity of 25 μg/mL (CE-nanoCEasy-Orbitrap mass spectrometry) and 5 μg/mL (liquid chromatography-Orbitrap mass spectrometry). Data processing was optimized for a faster processing and easier detection of low abundant glycoforms based on averaged charge-deconvoluted mass spectra. This approach combines a non-target glycoform analysis while yielding the same glycosylation pattern as the traditional approach based on extracted ion traces. The presented methods enable the high throughput screening of the glycosylation pattern of antibodies down to low μg/mL-range out of cell supernatant without any sample preparation.     

The impact of chromatography and mass spectrometry on the analysis of protein phosphorylation sites

Protein phosphorylation analysis is an enormous challenge. This review summarises the currently used techniques, which are based on radiolabelling and mass spectrometry as well as electrophoretic and chromatographic separation. Many methods exist, but there is still no single procedure applicable to all phosphoproteins. MS is able to deliver information about the location of phosphorylation sites, but phosphospecific properties with respect to ionisation present obstacles. Therefore, multidimensional approaches involving several analytical methods are often necessary to conquer phosphorylation site identification.Abbreviations 2D Two-dimensional - CE Capillary electrophoresis - CID Collision-induced dissociation - ECD Electron capture dissociation - ESI Electrospray ionisation - FT-ICR Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance - HPLC High performance liquid chromatography - ICAT Isotope coded affinity tags - ICP Inductively-coupled plasma - IDA Immino-diacetic acid - IMAC Immobilised metal affinity chromatography - IRMPD Infrared multiphoton dissociation - IT Ion trap - MALDI Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation - MRP14 Myeloid-related protein 14 - MS Mass spectrometry - NTA Nitrilo-triacetic acid - PAGE Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis - PDI Protein disulfide isomerase - pS Phosphoserine residue - PSD Post-source decay - pT Phosphothreonine residue - PVDF Polyvinylidene fluoride - pY Phosphotyrosine residue - Q-TOF Quadrupole-time-of-flight - RP Reversed phase - SIM Single-ion monitoring - SDS Sodium dodecyl sulfate - SORI Sustained off-resonance irradiation - TLC Thin-layer chromatography - TOF Time-of-flight An erratum to this article can be found at     

Direct coupling of size exclusion chromatography and mass spectrometry for the characterization of complex monoclonal antibody products

The present study describes the possibilities offered by an innovative bioinert size exclusion chromatography column for size variant characterization of complex monoclonal antibody products. This size exclusion chromatography column includes a novel column hardware surface. The column was prepared from metallic hardware components that were treated to have prototype hydrophilically modified hybrid organic–inorganic silica surfaces called hybrid surface technology. This provides a significant reduction in nondesired hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions that can occur between column and analyte when performing size exclusion chromatography analysis with volatile mobile phase. Compared to a reference stainless-steel column packed with the same batch of packing material, peak tailing, band broadening, and above all recovery of high molecular weight species were distinctly improved for all types of monoclonal antibody products. Based on our observations, we found that 50 mM ammonium acetate in water was a suitable mobile phase offering good compromise in terms of liquid chromatography performance and mass spectrometry sensitivity. In addition, method repeatability (intra- and interday relative standard deviations) on elution times and high molecular weight species peak areas were found to be excellent. By using this innovative size exclusion chromatography material, the low and high molecular weight species contained in various stressed and nonstressed monoclonal antibody products were successfully characterized with mass spectrometry detection.     

Analysis of four therapeutic monoclonal antibodies by online capillary isoelectric focusing directly coupled to quadrupole time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry

Capillary isoelectric focusing (cIEF) was online coupled to a Q‐TOF MS by a flow‐through microvial interface for the analysis of therapeutic mAb. Intact molecular weights obtained from the mass spectrum deconvolution of separated charge variants provided information on the structural heterogeneity of therapeutic mAbs. A sandwich cIEF–MS configuration composed of anolyte, sample, and catholyte segments sequentially injected into a neutrally coated capillary was used for the charge heterogeneity separation of four mAbs. Acetic acid and ammonium hydroxide were used in places of the non‐volatile acids and bases commonly used for IEF but are incompatible with online MS detection. Glycerol was added as the anti‐convective reagent. A chemical modifier was mixed with the cIEF effluent in the flow‐throw microvial to maintain the ESI stability and to mitigate ion suppression from the co‐eluted carrier ampholytes and glycerol. Analysis of mAb samples have shown relative populations of two basic variants originating from C‐terminal lysine process and acidic variant of deamidation. The lysine clippings, deamidation, and sialic acid modification in oligosaccharide chains were revealed in infliximab. Two lysine clipping variants and a deamidated variant were observed in adalimumab. The duplicate analyses of a reference mAb demonstrated five charge variants separated by cIEF due to some unidentified modifications, as their mass spectra shared close similarities. The mAb analyses demonstrated the feasibility of the cIEF–MS method, and they demonstrated how charge and structural variants and minor differences in therapeutic mAbs are observed with this technology. Online cIEF–MS is an information rich technology with high throughput, demonstrated by the initial data presented here.     

Sheathless CE-MS as a tool for monitoring exchange efficiency and stability of bispecific antibodies

Bispecific monoclonal antibodies (BsAbs) are receiving great attention due to their extensive benefits as biopharmaceuticals and their involvement in IgG4 mediated autoimmune diseases. While the production of BsAbs is getting more accessible, their analytical characterization remains challenging. We explored the potential of sheathless CE-MS for monitoring exchange efficiency and stability of in-house produced bispecific antibodies. Two IgG4 bispecific antibodies with different molecular characteristics were prepared using controlled Fragment antigen binding (Fab)-arm exchange. Separation of BsAbs from their parent monospecific antibodies was achieved using a polyethyleniimine (PEI)-coated capillary and acidic background electrolytes permitting reliable assessment of the exchange efficiency. This was especially valuable for a Fab-glycosylated BsAb where the high glycan heterogeneity resulted in an overlap of masses with the monospecific parent antibody, hindering their discrimination by MS only. The method showed also good capabilities to monitor the stability of the generated BsAbs under different storage conditions. The levels of degradation products were different for the studied antibodies indicating pronounced differences in stability. Overall, the proposed method represents a useful analytical tool for exchange efficiency and stability studies of bispecific antibodies.     

甲胺化衍生结合基于硅氢化物固定相的正相色谱用于单克隆抗体药物的N-糖基化表征

采用甲胺化衍生结合基于硅氢化物固定相的正相色谱（SiH-NPC）分析单抗的N-糖基化。样品经酶切、甲胺化衍生、纯化后由液相色谱-质谱进行分析。结果表明,相较于亲水相互作用色谱（HILIC）,SiH-NPC分离机制不同,使用常规的无盐流动相即可实现高分离度,避免污染质谱,色谱柱结构稳定,使用寿命长,更适合快速分析。结合唾液酸衍生方法,SiH-NPC在液相色谱-质谱联用鉴定酸性糖和糖异构体方面呈现显著优势,在生物制药行业中具有重要的应用潜力。     

Profiling of N-linked oligosaccharides using phenylhydrazine derivatization and mass spectrometry

N-linked oligosaccharide standards obtained from commercial sources were derivatized with phenylhydrazine (PHN) and analyzed by on-line reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)/electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). This procedure was then applied to mixtures of N-glycans enzymatically released from hen ovalbumin. Under ESI-MS conditions, phenylhydrazones of asialylated oligosaccharide standards and ovalbumin glycans produced mainly [M + 2H]2+ molecular ions at low cone voltage values, while minimal fragmentation was observed. Reversed-phase HPLC/ESI-MS total and selected ion chromatograms obtained for derivatized N-glycans from ovalbumin showed partial but useful separation. Overall glycan profiles obtained by ESI-MS were compared with results obtained by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI)-MS. Qualitatively, profiles were similar from one technique to the other in terms of relative abundance of glycans versus composition. Post-source decay (PSD) analysis of the [M + Na]+ ions of PHN-glycans showed dominant B, C and internal B/Y, C/Y cleavages. These patterns were helpful in relating fragmentation to proposed structures. Cross-ring cleavage fragment ions (A-type) were also observed in most cases. The PHN derivatization method is fast and simple. It produces abundant parent ions in both MALDI-MS and ESI-MS, while avoiding the presence of salt contaminants during the labeling procedure.     

Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography for the separation,purification, and quantification of raffinose family oligosaccharides from Lycopus lucidus Turcz

A systematic strategy based on hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography was developed for the separation, purification and quantification of raffinose family oligosaccharides from Lycopus lucidus Turcz. Methods with enough hydrophilicity and selectivity were utilized to resolve the problems encountered in the separation of oligosaccharides such as low retention, low resolution and poor solubility. The raffinose family oligosaccharides in L. lucidus Turcz. were isolated using solid‐phase extraction followed by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography at semi‐preparative scale to obtain standards of stachyose, verbascose and ajugose. Utilizing the obtained oligosaccharides as standards, a quantitative determination method was developed, validated and applied for the content determination of raffinose family oligosaccharides both in the aerial and root parts of L. lucidus Turcz. There were no oligosaccharides in the aerial parts, while in the root parts, the total content was 686.5 mg/g with the average distribution: raffinose 66.5 mg/g, stachyose 289.0 mg/g, verbascose 212.4 mg/g, and ajugose 118.6 mg/g. The result provided the potential of roots of L. lucidus Turcz. as new raffinose family oligosaccharides sources for functional food. Moreover, since the present systematic strategy is efficient, sensitive and robust, separation, purification and quantification of oligosaccharides by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography seems to be possible.     

Bacteriophage and impurity carryover and total organic carbon release during extended protein A chromatography

In the biopharmaceutical industry, column chromatography residuals are routinely assessed by the direct measurement of mock eluates. In this study, we evaluated virus and other impurity carryover between protein A cycles and the feasibility of using a total organic carbon (TOC) analyzer to monitor for column impurity leakage as a correlate for actual measured carryover in mock eluates. Commercial process intermediates were used in scaled down studies of two protein A media, ProSep A (Millipore, Bedford, MA, USA) and MabSelect SuRe (GE Healthcare, Uppsala, Sweden). The chromatography system was programmed to run up to 200 normal load/elution cycles with periodic blank cycles to measure protein and phage carryover, and water flush cycles to measure TOC release. Sustained phage carryover was evident in each study. Carryover and TOC release was lowest in the case where cleaning was most stringent (50 mM NaOH/0.5 M Na₂SO₄ with MabSelect SuRe). The TOC analysis at this time does not appear to be a viable practical means of measuring impurity carryover; direct measurements in mock eluates appears to be more predictive of column performance.     

Gas chromatography and gas chromatography/mass spectrometry for the characterization of complex mixtures of large oligosaccharides

High temperature gas chromatography and gas chromatography/mass spectrometry are used in the characterization of complex natural mixtures of permethylated oligosaccharides released from proteins or lipids. The high resolution allows separation of isomeric compounds and the mass range extends to oligosac-charides around molecular mass 2000 daltons or 10 sugar residues for isomalto-oligosaccharides. The mass spectra of permethylated oligosaccharide alditols from mucin glycopeptides are very informative and the approach allows a simple and rapid characterization of these complex components.     

A preliminary study for isolation of catalytic antibodies by histidine ligand affinity chromatography as an alternative to conventional protein A/G methods

Catalytic autoimmune antibodies from the sera of lupus patients were purified using histidyl-aminohexyl-Sepharose gel and compared with the antibodies purified with protein A and protein G affinity chromatography. The IgG preparations from the histidine affinity column had a much higher catalytic activity in hydrolyzing the peptide substrate Pro-Phe-Arg-methyl-coumarinamide compared to the antibodies obtained by the conventional protein A/G method. This preservation of catalytic activity is attributed to the gentle buffer conditions used in the histidine ligand method that allowed the integrity of three-dimensional structure of purified catalytic antibodies. Thus, histidine affinity offer a superior method for isolating autoimmune catalytic antibodies.     

Efficient purification of recombinant proteins fused to maltose-binding protein by mixed-mode chromatography

Two mixed-mode resins were evaluated as an alternative to conventional affinity resins for the purification of recombinant proteins fused to maltose-binding protein (MPB). We purified recombinant MBP, MBP-LacZ and MBP-Leap2 from crude Escherichia coli extracts. Mixed-mode resins allowed the efficient purification of MBP-fused proteins. Indeed, the quantity of purified proteins was significantly higher with mixed-mode resins, and their purity was equivalent to that obtained with affinity resins. By using purified MBP, MBP-LacZ and MBP-Leap2, the dynamic binding capacity of mixed-mode resins was 5-fold higher than that of affinity resins. Moreover, the recovery for the three proteins studied was in the 50–60% range for affinity resins, and in the 80–85% range for mixed-mode resins. Mixed-mode resins thus represent a powerful alternative to the classical amylose or dextrin resins for the purification of recombinant proteins fused to maltose-binding protein.     

Low-molecular weight protein profiling of genetically modified maize using fast liquid chromatography electrospray ionization and time-of-flight mass spectrometry

In this work, the use of liquid chromatography coupled to electrospray time-of-flight mass spectrometry (LC-TOFMS) has been evaluated for the profiling of relatively low-molecular weight protein species in both genetically modified (GM) and non-GM maize. The proposed approach consisted of a straightforward sample fractionation with different water and ethanol-based buffer solutions followed by separation and detection of the protein species using liquid chromatography with a small particle size (1.8 μm) C(18) column and electrospray-time-of-flight mass spectrometry detection in the positive ionization mode. The fractionation of maize reference material containing different content of transgenic material (from 0 to 5% GM) led to five different fractions (albumins, globulins, zeins, zein-like glutelins, and glutelins), all of them containing different protein species (from 2 to 52 different species in each fraction). Some relevant differences in the quantity and types of protein species were observed in the different fractions of the reference material (with different GM contents) tested, thus revealing the potential use of the proposed approach for fast protein profiling and to detect tentative GMO markers in maize.     

单克隆抗体药物糖基化修饰分析研究进展

单克隆抗体药物是一类以免疫球蛋白G的结构为基础的大分子糖蛋白药物,为癌症、自身免疫疾病以及病毒感染等多种疾病的治疗提供了全新的途径。单抗药物的糖基化修饰类型及水平对其稳定性、清除率、免疫原性、抗体依赖细胞毒性及补体依赖细胞毒性等都有一定的影响。单抗药物的迅速发展及其在多种疾病治疗中日益凸显的重要性都对单抗药物的研发及用药安全等方面提出了更高的要求。因此,建立规范可靠的单抗药物糖基化修饰分析方法有着十分重要的意义。该综述将简要介绍单克隆抗体药物糖基化修饰及相关的定性、定量分析方法。     

Probing protein interactions with hydrogen/deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry—A review

Assessing the functional outcome of protein interactions in structural terms is a goal of structural biology, however most techniques have a limited capacity for making structure–function determinations with both high resolution and high throughput. Mass spectrometry can be applied as a reader of protein chemistries in order to fill this void, and enable methodologies whereby protein structure–function determinations may be made on a proteome-wide level. Protein hydrogen/deuterium exchange (H/DX) offers a chemical labeling strategy suitable for tracking changes in “dynamic topography” and thus represents a powerful means of monitoring protein structure–function relationships. This review presents the exchange method in the context of interaction analysis. Applications involving interface detection, quantitation of binding, and conformational responses to ligation are discussed, and commentary on recent analytical developments is provided.     

Harnessing the power of electrophoresis and chromatography: Offline coupling of reverse phase liquid chromatography-capillary zone electrophoresis-tandem mass spectrometry for analysis of host cell proteins in monoclonal antibody producing CHO cell line

Host cell proteins (HCPs) are widely regarded as a critical quality attribute for a biotherapeutic product. Bottom up MS is the present gold standard for HCP analysis but suffers from incomplete protein identification due to complex nature of the HCP mixture and limited separation efficiency of the preceding LC-based systems. In this paper, we present for the first time an application involving use of LC-CE-MS/MS platform for analysis of HCPs. It has been demonstrated that the proposed platform has been able to successfully identify 397 HCPs from the supernatants of recombinant Chinese hamster ovary cells, twice and thrice the number of proteins identified by the state-of-the-art LC-MS/MS (189 HCPs) and CE-MS/MS (128 HCPs) analyses, respectively. Of these, 225 HCPs were unique to the LC-CE-MS/MS approach and were not identified by either LC-MS/MS or CE-MS/MS. It is observed that the LC-CE-MS/MS platform combines the benefits of LC-MS/MS and CE-MS/MS techniques and identifies peptides in a wider range of size, pI, and hydrophobicity. Additionally, LC-CE-MS/MS also identified more HCPs associated with cellular components, molecular functions, biological processes, peptidases, and secretory proteins. The proposed approach would thus be a useful addition in HCP analysis and secretome studies of mAb-producing Chinese hamster ovary cells.