Lipids, a missing link in prion propagation

Prion protein is considered to have an infectious ability by itself. However, in order to explain the main features of prion diseases, additional cofactors would be required. Sanghera et?al. (in this issue of Chemistry and Biology) have found evidence that a ganglioside, GM1, is a ligand for the C-terminal region of prion protein.     

Environmental effects on a prion's helix II domain: copper(II) and membrane interactions with PrP180-193 and its analogues

An abnormal interaction between copper and the prion protein is believed to play a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of prion diseases. Copper binding has been mainly attributed to the N-terminal domain of the prion protein, but this hypothesis has recently been challenged in some papers which suggest that the C-terminal domain might also compete for metal anchoring. In particular, the segment corresponding to the helix II region of the prion protein, namely PrP180-193, has been shown both to bind copper and to exhibit a copper-enhanced cytotoxicity, as well as to interact with artificial membranes. The present work is aimed at extending these results by choosing the most representative model of this domain and by determining its copper affinity. With this aim, the different role played by the electrostatic properties of the C- and N-termini of PrP180-193 (VNITIKQHTVTTTT) in determining its conformational behaviour, copper coordination and ability to perturb model membranes was investigated. Owing to the low solubility of PrP180-193, its copper affinity was evaluated by using the shorter PrPAc184-188NH2 (IKQHT) analogue as a model. ESI-MS, ESR, UV/Vis, and CD measurements were carried out on the copper(II)/PrPAc184-188NH2 and copper(II)/PrP180-193NH2 systems, and showed that PrPAc184-188NH2 is a reliable model for the metal interaction with the helix II domain. The affinity of copper(II) for the helix II fragment is higher than that for the octarepeat and PrP106-126 peptides. Finally, the different ability of PrP180-193 analogues to perturb the DPPC model membrane was assessed by DSC measurements. The possible biological consequences of these findings are also discussed briefly.     

Structural Effects of Multiple Pathogenic Mutations Suggest a Model for the Initiation of Misfolding of the Prion Protein

A molecular understanding of the prion diseases requires delineation of the origin of misfolding of the prion protein (PrP). An understanding of how different disease‐linked mutations affect the structure and dynamics of native monomeric PrP can provide a clue about how misfolding commences. In this study, hydrogen–deuterium exchange mass spectrometry was used to show that several disease‐linked mutant variants, which are thermodynamically destabilized, share a common structural perturbation in their native states: helix 1 is destabilized to an extent that correlates well with the destabilization of the native protein. The mutant variants misfold and form oligomers faster than does the wild‐type protein, at rates that increase exponentially with the extent to which helix 1 is destabilized in the native protein. It appears, therefore, that the loss of helix 1 structure marks the beginning of PrP misfolding and oligomerization.     

Environmental Effects on a Prion's Helix II Domain: Copper(II) and Membrane Interactions with PrP180–193 and Its Analogues

An abnormal interaction between copper and the prion protein is believed to play a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of prion diseases. Copper binding has been mainly attributed to the N‐terminal domain of the prion protein, but this hypothesis has recently been challenged in some papers which suggest that the C‐terminal domain might also compete for metal anchoring. In particular, the segment corresponding to the helix II region of the prion protein, namely PrP180–193, has been shown both to bind copper and to exhibit a copper‐enhanced cytotoxicity, as well as to interact with artificial membranes. The present work is aimed at extending these results by choosing the most representative model of this domain and by determining its copper affinity. With this aim, the different role played by the electrostatic properties of the C‐ and N‐termini of PrP180–193 (VNITIKQHTVTTTT) in determining its conformational behaviour, copper coordination and ability to perturb model membranes was investigated. Owing to the low solubility of PrP180–193, its copper affinity was evaluated by using the shorter PrPAc184–188NH₂ (IKQHT) analogue as a model. ESI‐MS, ESR, UV/Vis, and CD measurements were carried out on the copper(II )/PrPAc184–188NH₂ and copper(II )/PrP180–193NH₂ systems, and showed that PrPAc184–188NH₂ is a reliable model for the metal interaction with the helix II domain. The affinity of copper(II ) for the helix II fragment is higher than that for the octarepeat and PrP106–126 peptides. Finally, the different ability of PrP180–193 analogues to perturb the DPPC model membrane was assessed by DSC measurements. The possible biological consequences of these findings are also discussed briefly.     

Metal-binding ability of human prion protein fragment peptides analyzed by column switch HPLC

The structural conversion of the prion protein (PrP) from the normal cellular isoform (PrP(C)) to the posttranslationally modified form (PrP(Sc)) is thought to relate to Cu2? binding to histidine (H) residues. Traditionally, the binding of metals to PrP has been investigated by monitoring the conformational conversion using circular dichroism (CD). In this study, the metal-binding ability of 21 synthetic peptides representing regions of human PrP(C) was investigated by column switch high-performance liquid chromatography (CS-HPLC). The CS-HPLC system is composed of a metal chelate affinity column and an octadecylsilica (ODS) reversed-phase column that together enable the identification of metal-binding regardless of conformational conversion. Synthetic peptides were designed with respect to the position of H residues as well as the secondary structure of human PrP (hPrP). The ability of the octapeptide (PHGGGWGQ)-repeating region (OP-repeat) to bind metals was analyzed by CS-HPLC and supported by CD analysis, and indicated that CS-HPLC is a reliable and useful method for measuring peptide metal-binding. Peptides from the middle region of hPrP showed a high affinity for Cu2?, but binding to Zn2?, Ni2?, and Co2? was dependent on peptide length. C-Terminal peptides had a lower affinity for Cu2?, Zn2?, Ni2?, and Co2? than OP-repeat region peptides. Interestingly, hPrP193-230, which contained no H residues, also bound to Cu2?, Zn2?, Ni2?, and Co2?, indicating that this region is a novel metal-binding site in the C-terminal region of PrP(C). The CS-HPLC method described in this study is useful and convenient for assessing metal-binding affinity and characterizing metal-binding peptides or proteins.     

Spectroscopic and electronic structure studies of copper(II) binding to His111 in the human prion protein fragment 106-115: evaluating the role of protons and methionine residues

The prion protein (PrP(C)) is implicated in the spongiform encephalopathies in mammals, and it is known to bind Cu(II) at the N-terminal region. The region around His111 has been proposed to be key for the conversion of normal PrP(C) to its infectious isoform PrP(Sc). The principal aim of this study is to understand the role of protons and methionine residues 109 and 112 in the coordination of Cu(II) to the peptide fragment 106-115 of human PrP, using different spectroscopic techniques (UV-vis absorption, circular dichroism, and electron paramagnetic resonance) in combination with detailed electronic structure calculations. Our study has identified a proton equilibrium with a pK(a) of 7.5 associated with the Cu(II)-PrP(106-115) complex, which is ascribed to the deprotonation of the Met109 amide group, and it converts the site from a 3NO to a 4N equatorial coordination mode. These findings have important implications as they imply that the coordination environment of this Cu binding site at physiological pH is a mixture of two species. This study also establishes that Met109 and Met112 do not participate as equatorial ligands for Cu, and that Met112 is not an essential ligand, while Met109 plays a more important role as a weak axial ligand, particularly for the 3NO coordination mode. A role for Met109 as a highly conserved residue that is important to regulate the protonation state and redox activity of this Cu binding site, which in turn would be important for the aggregation and amyloidogenic properties of the protein, is proposed.     

Post-translational modifications in prion proteins

Prions are a novel class of infectious pathogens that cause a group of fatal prion diseases in which the benign cellular form of the prion protein (PrP(C)) is transformed into the disease-related scrapie variant (PrP(SC)). The two PrP isoforms differ in their structure and resistance to degradation. The molecular mechanism by which the PrP(SC) is formed and causes infectivity or neurodegeneration is not known. In a compelling and emerging view, post-translational modifications (or the lack thereof) play roles in the transformation of PrP(C) to PrP(SC). Human PrP contains two consensus sites for N-linked glycosylation, at Asn181 and Asn197. From the functional standpoint, glycosylation can modify either the conformation of PrP(C), or the stability of PrP(SC) and, hence, the rate of PrP(SC) clearance. So far the NMR structures of only recombinant, non-glycosylated prions are known, while the structure of the glycosylated form is estimated by molecular modeling. A number of native amino acid mutations in PrP can be mapped near the glycosylation sites. Normal prion protein has been demonstrated to be a copper binding protein, and increasing evidence has shown correlation between the level of PrP expression and tolerance to oxidative stress. Moreover, histochemistry for nitrotyrosine is used for detection of neuronal labeling, a sign of a peroxynitrite-mediated neuronal degradation and a marker for nitrative stress in scrapie-infected mouse brains. It is an intriguing proposition that the post-translational modifications alone, or in combination with amino acid changes, play dominant roles in the pathogenic transformation of PrP(C) to PrP(SC).     

Palladium complexes affect the aggregation of human prion protein PrP106-126

Many neurodegenerative disorders are induced by protein conformational change. Prion diseases are characterized by protein conformational conversion from a normal cellular form (PrP(C)) to an abnormal scrapie isoform (PrP(Sc)). PrP106-126 is an accepted model for studying the characteristics of PrP(Sc) because they share many biological and physiochemical properties. To understand how metal complexes affect the property of the prion peptide, the present work investigated interactions between Pd complexes and PrP106-126 based on our previous research using Pt and Au complexes to target the peptide. The selected compounds (Pd(phen)Cl(2), Pd(bipy)Cl(2), and Pd(en)Cl(2)) showed strong binding affinity to PrP106-126 and affected the conformation and aggregation of this active peptide in a different binding mode. Our results indicate that it may be the metal ligand-induced spatial effect rather the binding affinity that contributes to better inhibition on peptide aggregation. This finding would prove valuable in helping design and develop novel metallodrugs against prion diseases.     

Heparin Binding by Murine Recombinant Prion Protein Leads to Transient Aggregation and Formation of RNA-Resistant Species

The conversion of cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) into the pathological conformer PrP(Sc) requires contact between both isoforms and probably also requires a cellular factor, such as a nucleic acid or a glycosaminoglycan (GAG). Little is known about the structural features implicit in the GAG-PrP interaction. In the present work, light scattering, fluorescence, circular dichroism, and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy were used to describe the chemical and physical properties of the murine recombinant PrP 23-231 interaction with low molecular weight heparin (LMWHep) at pH 7.4 and 5.5. LMWHep interacts with rPrP 23-231, thereby inducing transient aggregation. The interaction between murine rPrP and heparin at pH 5.5 had a stoichiometry of 2:1 (LMWHep:rPrP 23-231), in contrast to a 1:1 binding ratio at pH 7.4. At binding equilibrium, NMR spectra showed that rPrP complexed with LMWHep had the same general fold as that of the free protein, even though the binding can be indicated by significant changes in few residues of the C-terminal domain, especially at pH 5.5. Notably, the soluble LMWHep:rPrP complex prevented RNA-induced aggregation. We also investigated the interaction between LMWHep and the deletion mutants rPrP Δ51-90 and Δ32-121. Heparin did not bind these constructs at pH 7.4 but was able to interact at pH 5.5, indicating that this glycosaminoglycan binds the octapeptide repeat region at pH 7.4 but can also bind other regions of the protein at pH 5.5. The interaction at pH 5.5 was dependent on histidine residues of the murine rPrP 23-231. Depending on the cellular milieu, the PrP may expose different regions that can bind GAG. These results shed light on the role of GAGs in PrP conversion. The transient aggregation of PrP may explain why some GAGs have been reported to induce the conversion into the misfolded, scrapie conformation, whereas others are thought to protect against conversion. The acquired resistance of the complex against RNA-induced aggregation explains some of the unique properties of the PrP interaction with GAGs.     

A survey of diamagnetic probes for copper2+ binding to the prion protein. 1H NMR solution structure of the palladium2+ bound single octarepeat

The prion protein (PrP(C)) is a copper binding cell surface glycoprotein which when misfolded causes transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. The cooperative binding of Cu2+ to an unstructured octarepeat sequence within PrP(C) causes profound folding of this region. The use of NMR to determine the solution structure of the octarepeat region of PrP with Cu2+ bound has been hampered by the paramagnetic nature of the Cu2+ ions. Using NMR we have investigated the binding of candidate diamagnetic replacement ions, to the octarepeat region of PrP. We show that Pd2+ forms diamagnetic complexes with the peptides HGGG, HGGGW and QPHGGGWGQ with 1:1 stoichiometry. The 1H NMR spectra indicate that these peptides are in slow-exchange between free and bound Pd2+ on the chemical-shift time-scale. We demonstrate that the Pd-peptide complex forms slowly with a time taken to reach half-maximal signal of 3 hours. Other candidate metal ions, Ni2+, Pt2+ and Au3+, were investigated but only the Pd2+ complexes gave resolvable 1H NMR spectra. We have determined the solution structure of the QPHGGGWGQ-Pd 1:1 complex using 71 NOE distance restraints. A backbone RMSD of 0.30 A was observed over residues 3 to 7 in the final ensemble. The co-ordinating ligands consist of the histidine imidazole side chain N epsilon, the amide N of the second and third glycines with possibly H2O as the fourth ligand. The co-ordination geometry differs markedly from that of the HGGGW-Cu crystal structure. This survey of potential replacement metal ions to Cu2+ provides insight into the metal specificity and co-ordination chemistry of the metal bound octarepeats.     

Characterization of the dynamics of an essential helix in the U1A protein by time-resolved fluorescence measurements

The RNA recognition motif (RRM), one of the most common RNA-binding domains, recognizes single-stranded RNA. A C-terminal helix that undergoes conformational changes upon binding is often an important contributor to RNA recognition. The N-terminal RRM of the U1A protein contains a C-terminal helix (helix C) that interacts with the RNA-binding surface of a beta-sheet in the free protein (closed conformation), but is directed away from this beta-sheet in the complex with RNA (open conformation). The dynamics of helix C in the free protein have been proposed to contribute to binding affinity and specificity. We report here a direct investigation of the dynamics of helix C in the free U1A protein on the nanosecond time scale using time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy. The results indicate that helix C is dynamic on a 2-3 ns time scale within a 20 degrees range of motion. Steady-state fluorescence experiments and molecular dynamics simulations suggest that the dynamical motion of helix C occurs within the closed conformation. Mutation of a residue on the beta-sheet that contacts helix C in the closed conformation dramatically destabilizes the complex (Phe56Ala) and alters the steady-state fluorescence, but not the time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy, of a Trp in helix C. Mutation of Asp90 in the hinge region between helix C and the remainder of the protein to Ala or Gly subtly alters the dynamics of the U1A protein and destabilizes the complex. Together these results show that helix C maintains a dynamic closed conformation that is stable to these targeted protein modifications and does not equilibrate with the open conformation on the nanosecond time scale.     

Mapping of possible prion protein self-interaction domains using peptide arrays

Background  

The common event in transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) or prion diseases is the conversion of host-encoded protease sensitive cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into strain dependent isoforms of scrapie associated protease resistant isoform (PrP^Sc) of prion protein (PrP). These processes are determined by similarities as well as strain dependent variations in the PrP structure. Selective self-interaction between PrP molecules is the most probable basis for initiation of these processes, potentially influenced by chaperone molecules, however the mechanisms behind these processes are far from understood. We previously determined that polymorphisms do not affect initial PrP^C to PrP^Sc binding but rather modulate a subsequent step in the conversion process. Determining possible sites of self-interaction could elucidate which amino acid(s) or amino acid sequences contribute to binding and further conversion into other isoforms. To this end, ovine – and bovine PrP peptide-arrays consisting of 15-mer overlapping peptides were probed with recombinant sheep PrP^C fused to maltose binding protein (MBP-PrP).     

Evaluation of a preclinical blood test for scrapie in sheep using immunocapillary electrophoresis

An analytical method is described for detection of endogenous disease-associated prion protein in the buffy coat fraction from the blood of sheep infected with scrapie. The method has been improved and evaluated for its performance in the preclinical diagnosis of ovine transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. The test system uses a protocol for sample preparation that includes extraction and concentration and a test method that uses a liquid-phase competitive immunoassay for prion protein. Antibodies directed to a peptide sequence at the C-terminus of the prion protein (PrP) and a fluorescein-labeled peptide conjugate are used in the assay. Free zone capillary electrophoresis with laser-induced fluorescence for detection is used to separate the antibody-bound fluorescently labeled peptide and free labeled peptide. In this assay, the PrP competes with the fluorescently labeled peptide for limited antibody binding sites, which results in a reduction of the peak representing the immunocomplex of the antibody bound to the fluorescently labeled peptide. When blood samples from scrapie-infected sheep aged 7-12 months and of the scrapie-susceptible PrP genotypes VRQ/VRQ and VRQ/ARQ were analyzed, the abnormal PrP was found in blood samples. These results correlated with the post-mortem diagnosis of scrapie. The sheep were preclinical and appeared normal at the time of testing but later died with clinical disease approximately 12 months after testing. In older animals, and those with clinical signs, a smaller percentage of animals tested positive. This study has demonstrated that this technology can be used as a sensitive, rapid preclinical test to detect the disease-associated PrP in the blood of scrapie-infected sheep. Improvements in the extraction protocol and capillary electrophoresis conditions will enhance the robustness of this test.     

Two-dimensional mapping of three phenotype-associated isoforms of the prion protein in sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE), or prion diseases, are mammalian neurodegenerative disorders characterized by a conformational modification of the host-encoded prion protein (PrP(C)) into an isoform which is detergent-insoluble and partially resistant to protease treatment (PrP(Sc)). Distinct types of PrP(Sc), differing in conformation and variation in the relative amount of their glycoforms, have been associated with different phenotypes of TSE. In sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD), two major types of PrP(Sc), with proteinase K (PK)-resistant fragments of 21 and 19 kDa, have been described. No consensus exists, however, on the molecular classification of PrP(Sc) in sCJD, since further heterogeneity within PrPSc conformers has been reported. We studied 19 subjects with dementia or dementia/ataxia at onset and 12 subjects with ataxia at onset. Following two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, we characterized PrP(C) and PrP(Sc) species in normal and sCJD brains by immunoblotting with antibodies recognizing N-terminal and C-terminal PrP regions. Three types of PrP(Sc) were detected in detergent-insoluble fractions from sCJD brains, mainly consisting of full-length PrP(Sc) in subjects with rapidly progressive dementia, and two different sets of amino-truncated PrP(Sc) glycoforms in subjects with dementia/ataxia and ataxia at onset. Examination of the PrP(Sc) core fragment, following PK treatment and deglycosylation, confirmed the existence of three distinctive patterns. These findings have immediate implications for the molecular classification of sCJD.     

Lipid lateral mobility and membrane phase structure modulation by protein binding

Using a combination of fluorescence correlation and infrared absorption spectroscopies, we characterize lipid lateral diffusion and membrane phase structure as a function of protein binding to the membrane surface. In a supported membrane configuration, cholera toxin binding to the pentasaccharaide headgroup of membrane-incorporated GM1 lipid alters the long-range lateral diffusion of fluorescently labeled probe lipids, which are not involved in the binding interaction. This effect is prominently amplified near the gel-fluid transition temperature, Tm, of the majority lipid component. At temperatures near Tm, large changes in probe lipid diffusion are measured at average protein coverage densities as low as 0.02 area fraction. Spectral shifts of the methylene symmetric and asymmetric stretching modes in the lipid acyl chain confirm that protein binding alters the fraction of lipid in the gel phase.     

Evaluation of the membrane-binding properties of the proximal region of the angiotensin II receptor (AT1A) carboxyl terminus by surface plasmon resonance.

The proximal region of the angiotensin II receptor (AT1A) carboxyl-terminus (known as helix VIII) is important for receptor function. In this study, we used surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to examine the interaction of helix VIII-derived peptides with three model lipid membranes. The membrane-binding properties of these synthetic peptides, as well as a series of peptide analogues with modified amino acid sequences, could be explained by both amino acid sequence and kinetic binding data by SPR. The helix VIII peptides showed a higher affinity for lipid membranes that contained negatively charged phospholipid, rather than zwitterionic phospholipid. The findings of an SPR study may be useful for estimating the cooperative binding of intracellular receptor domains with G proteins and the components of the lipid bilayer.     

Identification of the pathological prion protein allotypes in scrapie-infected heterozygous bank voles (Clethrionomys glareolus) by high-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry

Cerebral formation of the pathological isoform of the prion protein (PrP) is a crucial molecular event in prion diseases. The bank vole (Clethrionomys glareolus) is a rodent species highly susceptible to natural scrapie. The PrP gene of bank vole is polymorphic (Met/Ile) at codon 109. Here we show that homozygous 109Met/Met voles have incubation times shorter than heterozygous 109Met/Ile voles after experimental challenge with three different scrapie isolates. An HPLC-MS/MS method was optimized and applied to investigate whether in heterozygous animals both PrP allotypes are able to undergo pathological conversion. The results demonstrate that both allotypes of the prion protein participate to pathological deposition.     

Detection of prion protein using a capillary electrophoresis-based competitive immunoassay with laser-induced fluorescence detection and cyclodextrin-aided separation

The development of capillary electrophoresis (CE)-based competitive immunoassay for prion protein (PrP) using carboxymethyl beta-cyclodextrin (CM-beta-CD) as a buffer additive is described here. The assay was based on the competitive binding of PrP and a fluorescein-labeled peptide from the prion protein with a limiting amount of specific antibody. The amount of both free and fluorescein-labeled peptide bound to antibody (immunocomplex) were determined by CE with laser-induced fluorescence detection. In the presence of PrP, the peak height ratio of the immunocomplex and the free peptide was altered compared to the control. These changes were directly proportional to the amount of PrP present. The fluorescently labeled peptide spanning amino acid positions 140-158 of the PrP and its corresponding monoclonal antibody is reported here. The reaction times of the antibody with either the peptide or the recombinant PrP was less than 1 min and is a large improvement over the 16-18 h required to achieve equilibrium for polyclonal antibodies. CM-beta-CD was explored as a buffer additive to suppress analyte adsorption and enhance separation selectivity in the CE analysis. A fast (1.1 min), selective (resolution 4.7), and reproducible (relative standard deviations of migration time for free and bound fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)-peptide 0.56% and 0.64%, respectively) separation was obtained with 0.6% CM-beta-CD in 25 mM N-tris(hydroxymethyl)methyl-3-aminopropanesulfonic acid (TAPS) at pH 8.8. The concentration detection limit of the assay for recombinant PrP was determined to be 80 ng/mL (or mass detection limit 1 pg). When blood samples from scrapie-infected sheep and from normal sheep were tested, the results of the blood assay were consistent with scrapie status of the sheep as determined post mortem by Western blot analysis. Development of this assay will lead to a potentially robust, rapid, and specific preclinical diagnosis for transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) in animals and humans.     

Semisynthetic murine prion protein equipped with a GPI anchor mimic incorporates into cellular membranes

Conversion of cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) into the pathological conformer (PrP(Sc)) has been studied extensively by using recombinantly expressed PrP (rPrP). However, due to inherent difficulties of expressing and purifying posttranslationally modified rPrP variants, only a limited amount of data is available for membrane-associated PrP and its behavior in vitro and in vivo. Here, we present an alternative route to access lipidated mouse rPrP (rPrP(Palm)) via two semisynthetic strategies. These rPrP variants studied by a variety of in vitro methods exhibited a high affinity for liposomes and a lower tendency for aggregation than rPrP. In vivo studies demonstrated that double-lipidated rPrP is efficiently taken up into the membranes of mouse neuronal and human epithelial kidney cells. These latter results enable experiments on the cellular level to elucidate the mechanism and site of PrP-PrP(Sc) conversion.